pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 12 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
SMITH. Do you grant the antecedent?
RID. Yes, I grant the antecedent. I am content to let you have so much. Because I know that there be certain ancient fathers of that opinion. I am well content to let you use that proposition as true. And I will frame the argument for you. HE was seen on earth after his ascension.—
SMITH. Nay, nay, I will frame it myself. CHRIST after his ascension was seen really and corporally on earth, albeit he do abide in heaven continually. ERGO, Notwithstanding his ascension and continual abiding at the right hand of the Father, he may be really and corporally on the earth.
RID. Let us first agree about the continual sitting at the right hand of the Father.
SMITH. Doth he so sit at the right hand of his Father, that he doth never forsake the same?
RID. Nay, I do not bind Christ in heaven so straightly. I see you go about to beguile me with your equivocations. Such equivocations are to be distinguished. If you mean by his sitting in heaven, to reign with his Father, he may be both in heaven and also on earth. But if you understand his sitting to be after a corporal manner of sitting, so is he always permanent in heaven. For Christ to be corporal here on earth, when corporally he is resident in heaven, is clean contrary to the holy scriptures, as Austine saith; "The body of Christ is in heaven, but his truth is dispersed in every place." NOW, if continually he abide in heaven after the manner of his corporal presence, then his perpetual abiding there stoppeth or hindereth that the same corporal presence of him cannot be in the sacrament.
SMITH. Acts iii. we read that Christ shall sit perpetually at the right hand of God, until the consummation of the world.
WEST. I perceive you are come here to this issue, whether the body of Christ may be together both on earth and in heaven. I will tell you, that Christ in very deed is both on earth and in heaven together, and at one time, both one and the same natural Christ, after the verity and substance of his very body: Ergo, &c.
RID. I deny the antecedent.
WEST. I prove it by two witnesses. First by Chrysostom: "Do we not offer every day? we do so indeed, but doing it for remembrance of his death. And this offering is one, and not many. And how is it one, and not many, which was offered in the holy place? This sacrifice is a pattern of that: the self same we always offer, not now as offering one lamb to-day, and another to-morrow, but always one and the same lamb. Wherefore here is but one sacrifice; for else by this means, seeing there be many sacrifices in many places, be there many Christs? Not so, but one Christ in all places, both perfect here, and perfect there, one only body." Now thus I argue. WE offer one thing at all times. THERE is one Christ in all places, both here complete and there complete. ERGO, By Chrysostom there is one body both in heaven and earth.
RID. I remember the place well. These things make nothing against me.
WEST. One Christ is in all places, here full and there full.
RID. One Christ is in all places; but not one body in all places.
WEST. One body, saith Chrysostom.
RID. BUT not after the manner of bodily substance he is in all places, nor by circumscription of ⟨p. 339⟩place. For (hic […] illic,) "here and there," in Chrysostom, do assign no place, as Augustine saith; "The Lord is above, but the truth of the Lord is in all places."
RID. BUT not after the manner of bodily substance he is in all places, nor by circumscription of ⟨p. 339⟩place. For (hic 〈…〉 illic,) "here and there," in Chrysostom, do assign no place, as Augustine saith; "The Lord is above, but the truth of the Lord is in all places."
WEST. You cannot so escape. He saith not the verity of Christ is one; but one Christ is in all places, both here and there.
RID. One sacrifice is in all places, becau•• of the unity of him whom the sacrifice doth signify: not that the sacrifices be all one and the same.
WEST. Ergo▪ By your saying it is not Christ, but the sacrifice of Christ. BUT Chrysostom saith▪ "One body and one Christ is there, and not one sacrifice.
RID. I say, that both Christ and the sacrifice of Christ is there: Christ by Spirit, grace, and verity; the sacrifice by signification. THUS much I grant with Chrysostom, that there is one host or sacrifice, and not many: and this our host is called one by reason of the unity of that one, which one only all our hosts do represent. That only host was never any other but that which was once offered on the altar of the cross, of which all our hosts are but sacramental examples. AND where you allege out of Chrysostom, that Christ is offered in many places at once, both here full Christ, and there full Christ; I grant it to be true, that is, that Christ is offered in many places at once, in a mystery and sacramentally, and that he is full Christ in all those places, but not after the corporal substance of our flesh which he took, but after the benediction which giveth life; and he is given to the godly receivers in bread and wine, […] Cyril speaketh, concerning the oblation of Christ, whereof Chrysostom here speaketh, he himself doth clearly show what he meaneth thereby, in saying by the way of correction, "We always do the self same, howbeit by the recorda•ion or remembrance of his sacrifice.
RID. I say, that both Christ and the sacrifice of Christ is there: Christ by Spirit, grace, and verity; the sacrifice by signification. THUS much I grant with Chrysostom, that there is one host or sacrifice, and not many: and this our host is called one by reason of the unity of that one, which one only all our hosts do represent. That only host was never any other but that which was once offered on the altar of the cross, of which all our hosts are but sacramental examples. AND where you alledge out of Chrysostom, that Christ is offered in many places at once, both here full Christ, and there full Christ; I grant it to be true, that is, that Christ is offered in many places at once, in a mystery and sacramentally, and that he is full Christ in all those places, but not after the corporal substance of our flesh which he took, but after the benediction which giveth life; and he is given to the godly receivers in bread and wine, 〈…〉 Cyril speaketh, concerning the oblation of Christ, whereof Chrysostom here speaketh, he himself doth clearly shew what he meaneth thereby, in saying by the way of correction, "We always do the self same, howbeit by the recorda•ion or remembrance of his sacrifice.
WEST. The second witness is Bernard, who saith, in a sermon on the supper of our Lord, "How cometh this to us, most gentle Jesus, that we silly worms creeping on the face of the earth, that we, I say, who are but dust and ashes, may deserve to have thee present in our hands, and before our eyes, who both together, full and whole, dost •it at the right hand of the Father, and who also in the moment of one hour, from the rising of the sun to the going down of the same, ••t present one and the self-same in many and divers places▪"
RID. These words of Bernard make for you nothing at all. But I know that Bernard was in such a time, that in this matter he may worthily be suspected. He hath many good and faithful sayings; as also in the same place by you alleged. But yet he followed in such an age, as when the doctrine of the holy supper was perverted. Notwithstanding I will so expound him, rather than reject him, that he shall make nothing for you. That we have Christ in a mystery, in a sacrament, under a veil or cover. In the mean time, here now he saith, That the verity of Christ is every-where. The verity of Christ is both here and there, and in all places.
RID. These words of Bernard make for you nothing at all. But I know that Bernard was in such a time, that in this matter he may worthily be suspected. He hath many good and faithful sayings; as also in the same place by you alledged. But yet he followed in such an age, as when the doctrine of the holy supper was perverted. Notwithstanding I will so expound him, rather than reject him, that he shall make nothing for you. That we have Christ in a mystery, in a sacrament, under a veil or cover. In the mean time, here now he saith, That the verity of Christ is every-where. The verity of Christ is both here and there, and in all places.
WEST. What do you call verity? He saith not the verity of Christ, but the verity of the body of Christ.
RID. The verity of the body of Christ is the true faith of the body of Christ: after that verity he is with them which truly believe upon him.
WEST. Christ is one and the •ame in divers places. I urge these words, [in divers places,] and yet I am not satisfied.
SMITH. Christ was seen really and corporally on the earth after his ascension, and continually sitting at the right hand of the Father. ERGO, The ascension and perpetual sitting in heaven hinder nothing, but that he may be really and corporally in the sacrament.
RID. If by perpetual sitting you mean the residence of his body in heaven, your reason containeth manifest contradiction.
SMITH. Th•se two have no contradiction in them at all, both to sit continually at his Father's ⟨p. 340⟩right hand, and also to be seen here really on earth after his ascension. First, You will allow, that Christ sitteth in heaven at the right hand of his Father. For so it is written, Acts v. "Heaven must needs receive him until the time of the restoring of all, &c." Secondly, He was also seen of Paul here corporally on earth. WHEREFORE these two do import, as ye see, no contradiction.
RID. What hindereth, but that Christ, if it please him, and when it pleaseth him, may be in heaven and on earth, and appear to whom he will? And yet notwithstanding you have not yet proved that he will so do. And though Christ continually shall be resident in heaven until the judgment, yet there may be some intermission, notwithstanding. But this controversy, as I said, is amongst all the ancient doctors and writers. And that Christ hath been seen, that they grant all: but whether he was then on earth or in heaven, that is doubtful.
SMITH. I will prove that he would appear on earth HE so would, and also did appear here on earth after his ascension: Ergo, &c.
RID. He appeared I grant; but how he appeared, whether then being in heaven or in earth, that is uncertain. So he appeared to Stephen, being then corporally sitting in heaven. For, speaking after the true manner of man's body, when he is in heaven, he is not at the same time on earth; and when he is on earth, he is not the same time corporally in heaven.
SMITH. Christ hath been both in heaven and on earth all at one time. ERGO, You are deceived in denying that.
RID. I do not utterly deny Christ here to have been seen on earth. Of uncertain things I speak uncertainly.
SMITH. He was seen of Paul, as being born before his time, after his ascending up to heaven, 1 Cor. xv. BUT his vision was a corporal vision. ERGO, He was seen corporally upon the earth after his ascending into heaven.
RID. He was seen really and corporally indeed: but whether being in heaven or earth, is a doubt. And of doubtful things we must judge doubtfully. Howbeit, you must prove that he was in heaven at the same time, when he was corporally on earth.
SMITH. I would know of you, whether this vision may enforce the resurrection of Christ?
SMITH. I would know of you, whether this vision may inforce the resurrection of Christ?
RID. I account this a sound and firm argument to prove the resurrection. But whether they saw him in heaven or on earth, I am in doubt: and to say the truth, it maketh no great matter. Both ways the argument is of like strength. For whether he were seen in heaven, or whether he were seen on earth, either of both maketh sufficiently for the matter. Certain it is, he rose again; for he could not have been seen, unless he had risen again.
SMITH. Paul saw him as he was here conversant on earth, and not out of heaven, as you affirm.
RID. You run to the beginning again: that you take for granted, which you should have proved.
SMITH. You make delays for the purpose.
RID. say not so, I pray you. Those that hear us are learned: they can tell both what you oppose, and what I answer well enough, I warrant you.