pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 5 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
CHED. This is because of the union; so that God is said to be touched, when Christ, who is both God and Man, is touched. TERTULLIAN, speaking of the resurrection of the body, saith, "Let us consider as concerning the proper form of the Christian man, what great prerogative this vain and foul substance of our's hath with God. Although it were sufficient to it, that no soul could ever get salvation, unless it believe while it is in the flesh: so much the flesh availeth to salvation; by the which flesh it cometh, that whereas the soul so is linked unto God, it is the said flesh that causeth the soul to be linked: yet the flesh moreover is washed, that the soul may be cleansed; the flesh is anointed, that the soul may be consecrated; the flesh is signed, that the soul may be defended; the flesh is shadowed by the imposition of hands, that the soul may be illuminated with the Spirit; the flesh doth eat the body and blood of Christ, that the soul may be fed of God." Whereupon I gather this argument. THE flesh eateth the body of Christ. ERGO, The body of Christ is eaten with the mouth. PHOCEUS also, 1 Cor. chapter xi. upon these words, "Is guilty of the body and blood," declareth, "That like as Judas betrayed him, and the Jews were fierce and spiteful against him; so do they dishonour him, who receive his holy body with their impure hands, and as the Jews did hold him then, do now receive him with impure mouths. And whereas he often maketh mention of the body and blood of the Lord, he declareth, that it is not simply man that is sacrificed, but even the Lord himself, being the maker of all things, hereby (as it were) making them afraid." THEREFORE, the body of Christ is touched with the hands.
CRAN. You vouch two authors against me upon sundry things. First, I must answer Tertullian, and then the other.
CHED. They tend both to one meaning.
CRAN. Unto Tertullian I answer, (because our disputation is wandering and uncertain) that he calleth that the flesh which is the sacrament. For although God works all things in us invisibly beyond men's reach, yet they are so manifest, that they ⟨p. 321⟩may be seen, and perceived of every sense. Therefore he setteth forth baptism, unction, and last of all the supper of the Lord unto us, which he gave to signify his operation in us. The flesh liveth by the bread, but the soul is inwardly fed by Christ.
WEST. Stick to those words of Tertullian, "The body eateth, that the soul may be fed.
CHED. The flesh eateth the body of Christ, that the soul may be fed therewith.
WEST. Here you see two kinds of food, of the soul and of the body.
CHED. He saith, that not only the soul, but the flesh also is fed.
CRAN. The soul is fed with the body of Christ, the body with the sacrament.
CHED. Is the soul fed with the body of Christ, and not with the sacrament?
CRAN. Read that which followeth, and you shall perceive, that by things external, an operation internal is understood. Inwardly we eat Christ's body, and outwardly we eat the sacrament. So one thing is done outwardly, another inwardly. Like as in baptism the external element, where the body is washed, is one; the internal thing, whereby the soul is cleansed, is another.
CHED. The soul is fed by that which the body eateth. BUT the soul is fed by the flesh of Christ. ERGO, The body eateth the flesh of Christ.
CRAN. We eat not one thing outwardly and inwardly. Inwardly we eat Christ's body: outwardly we eat the sacrament.
CHED. I will repeat the argument. THE flesh eateth Christ's body, that the soul may be fed therewith. THE soul is not fed with the sacrament, but with Christ's body. ERGO, The flesh eateth the body of Christ.
CRAN. The sacrament is one thing, the matter of the sacrament is another. Outwardly we receive the sacrament; inwardly we eat the body of Christ.
YONG. This disputation is taken in hand, that the truth might appear. I perceive that I must go another way to work than I had thought. It is a common saying, against those who deny principles, we must not dispute; therefore, that we may agree of the principles, I demand, whether there be any other body of Christ, than his instrumental body?
CRAN. There is no natural body of Christ, but his organical body.
YONG. Again, I demand, whether sense and reason ought to give place to faith?
CRAN. They ought.
YONG. Thirdly, whether Christ be true in all his words?
CRAN. Yes, he is truth itself.
YONG. Fourthly, whether Christ, at his supper, minded to do that which he spake, or no?
CRAN. In saying he spake, but in saying he made not, but made the sacrament to his disciples.
YONG. Answer according to the truth, whether did Christ that as God and man which he spake, when he said, "This is my body?"
CRAN. This is sophistical cavilling. There is some deceit in these questions.
YONG. I demand, whether Christ by these words wrought any thing, or no?
CRAN. He did institute the sacrament.
YONG. But answer, whether he did work any thing?
CRAN. He did work in instituting the sacrament.
YONG. Now I have you; for before you said, it was a figurative speech. BUT a figure worketh nothing. THEREFORE, it is not a figurative speech. A liar ought to have a good memory.
YONG. Now I have you; for before you said, it was a figurative speech. BUT a figure worketh nothing. THEREFORE, it is not a figurative speech. A lyar ought to have a good memory.
CRAN. I understood your sophistry before. You by working understand converting into the body of Christ: but Christ wrought the sacrament, not in converting, but in instituting.
YONG. Woe be to them, who made Christ a deceiver. Did he work any other thing than he spake, or the self-same thing?
CRAN. He wrought the sacrament, and by these words he signified the effect.
YONG. A figurative speech is no working thing. BUT the speech of Christ is working. THEREFORE, it is not figurative.
CRAN. It worketh by instituting, not by converting.
YONG. The thing signified in the sacrament, is it not that sacrament?
CRAN. It is. For the thing is ministered in a sign. He followeth the letter that taketh the thing for a sign. Augustine separateth the sacrament from the thing. The sacrament (saith he) is one, and the thing of the sacrament another.
WEST. Stick to this argument. IT is a figurative speech. ERGO, It worketh nothing.
YONG. But the speech of Christ is a working thing. ERGO, It is not figurative.
CRAN. Oh how many crafts are in this argument! they are mere fallacies; I said not, that the words of Christ do work, but Christ himself; and he worketh by a figurative speech.