pp. 32–41141 passagespart 2 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Bond. By what law canst thou refuse me to be thy judge?
Bon. By what law canst thou refuse me to be thy judge?
Phil. By the civil law, De competente judice.
Bond. There is no such title in the law. In what book is it, as cunning a lawyer as you are?
Bon. There is no such title in the law. In what book is it, as cunning a lawyer as you are?
Phil. My lord, I take upon me no great cunning in the law: but you drive me to my shifts for my defence, and I am sure if I had the books of the law, I am able to show what I say.
Phil. My lord, I take upon me no great cunning in the law: but you drive me to my shifts for my defence, and I am sure if I had the books of the law, I am able to shew what I say.
Bon. What De competente judice? I will go bring thee my books. There is a title indeed, De officiis judicis ordinarii.
Phil. Verily, that is the same De competente justice ▪ which I have alleged. With that he ran ⟨p. 35⟩to his study, and brought the whole course of the law between his hands, which (as it might appear) he had well occupied, by the dust they were covered with.
Phil. Verily, that is the same De competente justice ▪ which I have alledged. With that he ran ⟨p. 35⟩to his study, and brought the whole course of the law between his ha•ds, which (as it might appear) he had well occupied, by the dust they were covered with.
Bond. There are the books: find it out if thou canst, and I will promise to release thee out of prison.
Bon. There are the books: find it out if thou canst, and I will promise to release thee out of prison.
Phil. My lord, I stand not here to reason matters of the civil law, although I am not altogether ignorant of the same; for that I have been a student in the law six or seven years; but to answer to the articles of faith with which you may lawfully burden me. And whereas you go about unlawfully to proceed, I challenge, according to my knowledge, the benefit of the law in my defence.
Bond. Why, thou wilt answer directly to nothing thou art charged with: therefore say not hereafter but you might have been satisfied here by learned men, if you would have declared your mind.
Bon. Why, thou wilt answer directly to nothing thou art charged with: therefore say not hereafter but you might have been satisfied here by learned men, if you would have declared your mind.
Phil. My lord, I have declared my mind unto you, and to other of the bishops at my last being with you, desiring you to be satisfied but of one thing, whereunto I have referred all other controversies: which if your lordships now, or other learned men can simply resolve me of, I am as contented to be conformable in all things, as you shall require; which is to prove that the church of Rome (whereof you are) is the catholic church.
Cov. Do you not believe your creed, "I believe the catholic church?"
Phil. Yes, that I do: but I cannot understand Rome (wherewithal you burden us) to be the same, neither like to it.
St. Asaph. It is most evident that St. Peter did build the catholic church at Rome. And Christ said, "Thou art Pe•er, and upon this rock will I build my church." Moreover the succession of bishops in […] of Rome can be proved from time to […] it can be of none other place so we•l, […] probation of the catholic church, as divers doctors do write.
St. Asaph. It is most evident that St. Peter did build the catholic church at Rome. And Christ said, "Thou art Pe•er, and upon this rock will I build my church." Moreover the succession of bishops in 〈…〉 of Rome can be proved from time to 〈…〉 it can be of none other place so we•l, 〈…〉 probation of the catholic church, as divers doctors do write.
Phil. That you would have to be undoubted, is most uncertain, and that by the authority which you allege of Christ, saying unto Peter, "Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church," unless you can prove that rock to signify Rome, as you would make me falsely believe. And although you ca• prove the succession of bishops from Peter, yet this is not sufficient to prove Rome the catholic church, unless you can prove the profession of Peter's faith, whereupon the catholic church is built▪ to have continued in his successors at Rome, and at this present to remain.
Phil. That you would have to be undoubted, is most uncertain, and that by the authority which you alledge of Christ, saying unto Peter, "Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church," unless you can prove that rock to signify Rome, as you would make me falsely believe. And although you ca• prove the succession of bishops from Peter, yet this is not sufficient to prove Rome the catholic church, unless you can prove the profession of Peter's faith, whereupon the catholic church is built▪ to have continued in his successors at Rome, and at this present to remain.
Bond. Are there any more churches than one catholic church? And I pray tell me into what faith were you baptized?
Bon. Are there any more churches than one catholic church? And I pray tell me into what faith were you baptized?
Phil. I acknowledge one holy catholic and apostolic church, whereof I am a member (I praise God), and am of that catholic faith of Christ whereunto I was baptized.
Cov. I pray you, can you tell what this word catholic doth signify? show if you can.
Cov. I pray you, can you tell what this word catholic doth signify? shew if you can.
Phil. Yes, that I can, I thank God. The catholic saith, or the catholic church, is not as now-a-days the people are taught, to be that which is most universal, or by most part of men received, whereby you do infer our faith to hang upon the multitude, which is not so: but I esteem the catholic church to be as St. Austin defineth the same: "We judge, saith he, the catholic faith, of that which hath been, is, and shall be." So that if you can be able to prove, that your faith and church hath been from the beginning taught, and is, and shall be; then you may count yourselves catholic, otherwise not. And catholic is a Greek word compounded of KATA, which signifieth, after, or according, and HOLON, a sum, or principle, or whole. So that catholic church, or catholic faith, is as much as to say, the first, whole, sound, or chief faith.
Bond. Doth St. Austin say so as he allegeth it? or doth he mean as he taketh the same? How say you, Mr. Curtop?
Bon. Doth St. Austin say so as he alledgeth it? or doth he mean as he taketh the same? How say you, Mr. Curtop?
Cur. Indeed, my lord, St. Austin hath such a ⟨p. 36⟩saying, speaking against the Donatists, that the catholic faith ought to be esteemed of things in times past, and as they are practised according to the same and ought to be through all ages, and not after a new manner, as the Donatists began to profess.
Phil. You have said well, Mr. Curtop, and after the meaning of St. Austin, and to confirm that which I have said for the signification of catholic.
Cov. Let the book be seen, my lord.
Bond. I pray you, my lord, be content, or in good faith I will break even off, and let all alone. Do you think that the catholic church (until within these few years, in which a few upon singularity have swerved from the same) hath erred?
Bon. I pray you, my lord, be content, or in good faith I will break even off, and let all alone. Do you think that the catholic church (until within these few years, in which a few upon singularity have swerved from the same) hath erred?
Phil. I do not think that the catholic church can err in doctrine: but I require you to prove this church of Rome to be the catholic church.
Cur. I can prove that Ireneus (which was within an hundred years after Christ) came to Victor, then bishop of Rome, to ask his advice about the excommunication of certain heretics, which (by all likelihood) he would not have done, if he had not taken him to be supreme head.
Cov. Mark well this argument. How are you able to answer the same? Answer if you can.
Phil. It is soon answered, my lord, for that is of no force; neither doth this fact of Ireneus make any more for the supremacy of the bishop of Rome, than mine hath done, who have been at Rome as well as he, and might have spoken with the pope if I had list; and yet I would none in England did favour his supremacy more than I.
St. Asaph. You are more to blame (by the faith of my body) for that you favour the same no better, since all the catholic church (until these few years) have taken him to be the supreme head of the church, besides this good man Ireneus.
Phil. That is not likely, that Ireneus so took him, or the primitive church: for I am able to show seven general councils after Ireneus's time, wherein he never took him for supreme head.
Phil. That is not likely, that Ireneus so took him, or the primitive church: for I am able to shew seven general councils after Ireneus's time, wherein he never took him for supreme head.
The other bishop. This man will never be satisfied, say what we can. It is but folly to reason any more with him.
Phil. O, my lords, would you have me satisfied with nothing? Judge, I pray you, who hath better authority, he which bringeth the example of one man going to Rome, or I that by these many general councils am able to prove, that he was never so taken in many hundred years after Christ, as by Nicene, Ephesine, the first and second Chalcedon, Constantinopolitan, Carthaginese, Aquilense.
Cov. Why will you not admit the church of Rome to be the catholic church?
Phil. Because it followeth not the primitive catholic church, neither agreeth with the same, no more than an apple is like a nut.
Cov. Wherein doth it dissent?
Phil. It were too long to recite all, but two things I will name, the supremacy and transubstantiation.
Cur. As for transubstantiation, albeit it was set forth and decreed for an article of faith not much above three hundred years ago, yet it was always believed in the church.
Bond. Yes, that it was. Very well said of you, Mr. Curtop.
Bon. Yes, that it was. Very well said of you, Mr. Curtop.
Phil. You have said right, that transubstantiation is but a late plantation of the bishop of Rome, and you are not able to show any ancient writer, that believed any such thing; and with this Curtop shrank away. And immediately after the ambassador of Spain came in, to whom my lord of London went, leaving the others with me. To whom I said, My lords, if you can show me that this church of Rome (whereof you are members) is the catholic church, I shall be con••nt to be one thereof, and as conformable to the same ⟨p. 37⟩as you can require me in all things; for I know there is no salvation but within the church.
Phil. You have said right, that transubstantiation is but a late plantation of the bishop of Rome, and you are not able to shew any ancient writer, that believed any such thing; and with this Curtop shrank away. And immediately after the ambassador of Spain came in, to whom my lord of London went, leaving the others with me. To whom I said, My lords, if you can shew me that this church of Rome (whereof you are members) is the catholic church, I shall be con••nt to be one thereof, and as conformable to the same ⟨p. 37⟩as you can require me in all things; for I know there is no salvation but within the church.
Cov. Can you disprove that the church of Rome is the catholic church?
Phil. Yes, that I am able, but I desire rather to hear of you the proof thereof. And seeing I cannot have my request at your hands, neither be satisfied with any probable authority, I will show you good proof why it is not. For if the primitive church were catholic, as it was indeed, and ought to be the form and school-mistress unto the world's end; then is not the church of Rome now the catholic church, which dissenteth so far from the same both in doctrine and use of the sacraments.
Phil. Yes, that I am able, but I desire rather to hear of you the proof thereof. And seeing I cannot have my request at your hands, neither be satisfied with any probable authority, I will shew you good proof why it is not. For if the primitive church were catholic, as it was indeed, and ought to be the form and school-mistress unto the world's end; then is not the church of Rome now the catholic church, which dissenteth so far from the same both in doctrine and use of the sacraments.