pp. 41–51144 passagespart 3 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Phil. My lords, it seemeth to your honours that you have great advantage of me by the example I brought in to express my cause, but if it be pondered thoroughly, it maketh wholly with me, and nothing against me, as my lord of London hath pretended. For I will ask of my lord Rich here, whom I know to have good knowledge in the laws and statutes of this realm, although a judge may discern the meaning of a statute agreeable to the words, whether the same may judge a meaning contrary to the express words or no?
Rich. He cannot so do.
Phil. Even so say I, that no man ought to judge the word of God to have a meaning contrary to the express words thereof, as this false church of Rome doth in many things: and with this the lords seemed to be satisfied, and made no further reply herein.
Rich. I marvel then why you do deny the express words of Christ in the sacrament, saying "This is my body:" and yet you will not stick to say it is not his body. Is not God omnipotent? And is not be able as well by his omnipotency to make it his body, as he was to make man flesh of a piece of clay? Did not he say, "This is my body which shall be betrayed for you?" And was not his very body betrayed for us? Therefore it must needs be his body.
Rich. I marvel then why you do deny the express words of Christ in the sac•ament, saying "This is my body:" and yet you will not stick to say it is not his body. Is not God omnipotent? And is not be able as well by his omnipotency to make it his body, as he was to make man flesh of a piece of clay? Did not he say, "This is my body which shall be betrayed for you?" And was not his very body betrayed for us? Therefore it must needs be his body.
Bond. My lord Rich, you have said wonderful well and learnedly. But you might have begun with him before also, in the sixth of John, where Christ promised to give his body in the sacrament of the altar, saying, "The bread which I will give is my flesh." How can you answer to that?
Bon. My lord Rich, you have said wonderful well and learnedly. But you might have begun with him before also, in the sixth of John, where Christ promised to give his body in the sacrament of the altar, saying, "The bread which I will give is my flesh." How can you answer to that?
Phil. If it please you to give me leave to answer first my lord Rich, I will also answer this objection.
Rich. Answer my lord of London first, and after come to me.
Phil. My lord of London may be soon answered: that saying of St. John is, that the humanity of Christ, which he took upon him for the redemption of man, is the bread of life whereby our souls and bodies are sustained to eternal life, of which the sacramental bread is a lively representation, and an effectual coaptation to all such as believe on his passion. And as Christ saith in the same sixth of John, "I am the bread that came down from heaven;" but yet he is not material, neither natural bread: likewise the bread is his flesh, not natural or substantial, but by signification, and by grace in the sacrament▪ AND now my lord Rich's argument. I do not deny the express words of Christ in the sacrament, "This is my body:" but I deny that they are naturally and corporally to be taken; they must be taken sacramentally and spiritually, according to the express declaration of Christ, saying, that the words of the sacrament which the Capernaites took carnally, as the Papists now do, ought to be taken spiritually and not carnally, as they falsely imagine, not weighing what interpretation Christ hath made in this behalf, neither following the institution of Christ, neither the use of the apostles and of the primitive church, who never taught, neither declared any such carnal manner of presence as is now exacted of us violently without any ground of scripture or antiquity, who used to put out of the church all such as did not receive the sacrament with the rest, and also to burn that which was left after the receiving, as by the canon of the apostles, and by the decree of the council of Antioch may appear.
Bond. No, that is not so; they were only Catechumeni, which went out of the church at the celebration of the communion, and none other.
Bon. No, that is not so; they were only Catechumeni, which went out of the church at the celebration of the communion, and none other.
Phil. It was not only of such as were novices in faith, but all others that did not receive.
Bond. What say you to the omnipotency of God? Is not he able to perform that which he spake, as my lord Rich hath very well said? I tell thee, that God by his omnipotency may make himself to be this carpet if he will.
Bon. What say you to the omnipotency of God? Is not he able to perform that which he spake, as my lord Rich hath very well said? I tell thee, that God by his omnipotency may make himself to be this carpet if he will.
Phil. As concerning the omnipotency of God, I say that God is able to do (as the prophet David saith) whatsoever he willeth; but he willeth nothing that is not agreeable to his word; that is blasphemy which my lord of London hath spoken, that God may become a carpet. For, as I have learned of ancient writers, God cannot do that which is contrary to his nature, and it is contrary to the nature of God to be a carpet. A carpet is a creature; and God is the creator; and the creator cannot be the creature: wherefore unless you can declare by the word, that Christ is otherwise present with us than spiritually and sacramentally by grace, as he hath taught us, you pretend the omnipotency of God in vain.
Bond. Why, wilt thou not say that Christ is really present in the sacrament? Or do you deny it?
Bon. Why, wilt thou not say that Christ is really present in the sacrament? Or do you deny it?
Phil. I deny not that Christ is really present in the sacrament to the receiver thereof according to Christ's institution.
Bond. What mean you by really present?
Bon. What mean you by really present?
Phil. I mean by really present, present indeed.
Bond. Is God really present every where?
Bon. Is God really present every where?
Phil. He is so.
Bond. How prove you that?
Bon. How prove you that?
Phil. The prophet Isaiah saith, "That God filleth all places:" and wheresoever there be two or three gathered together in Christ's name, there is he in the midst of them.
Bond. What, his humanity?
Bon. What, his humanity?
Phil. No, my lord, I mean the Deity, according to what you demanded.
Rich. My lord of London, I pray you let Dr. Chedsey reason with him, and let us see how he can answer him, for I tell thee he is a learned man indeed, and one that I do credit before a great many of you, whose doctrine the queen's majesty and the whole realm doth well allow, therefore hear him.
Bond. My lords, I pray you, will it please you to drink? You have talked a great while, and much talk is thirsty. I will leave Mr. Doctor and him reasoning together awhile, with your leave, and will come to you by and by again. He went, as I suppose, to make room for more drink, after the lords had drank. MY lord Rich said to the lords, I pray you let the poor man drink, for he is thirsty, and with that he called for a cup of drink, and gave it me, and I drank before them all: God requite him, for I was thirsty indeed. Afterwards Dr. Chedsey began in this wise, making a great process, of which this the effect.
Bon. My lords, I pray you, will it please you to drink? You have talked a great while, and much talk is thirsty. I will leave Mr. Doctor and him reasoning together awhile, with your leave, and will come to you by and by again. He went, as I suppose, to make room for more drink, after the lords had drank. MY lord Rich said to the lords, I pray you let the poor man drink, for he is thirsty, and with that he called for a cup of drink, and gave it me, and I drank before them all: God requite him, for I was thirsty indeed. Afterwards Dr. Chedsey began in this wise, making a great process, of which this the effect.
Ched. Mr. Philpot findeth fault with the convocation-house before your lordships, that he hath lain thus long in prison, and that he had there a dozen arguments, whereof he would not be suffered to prosecute one thoroughly, which is not so; for he had leave to say what he could, and was answered to as much as he was able to bring; and when he had nothing else to say, he sell to weeping. I was there present and can testify thereof; although there is a book abroad of the report of the disputation to the contrary, in which there is never a true word. And whereas you require to be satisfied of the sacrament, I will show you the truth thereof, both by the scriptures and by the doctors.
Ched. Mr. Philpot findeth fault with the convocation-house before your lordships, that he hath lain thus long in prison, and that he had there a dozen arguments, whereof he would not be suffered to prosecute one thoroughly, which is not so; for he had leave to say what he could, and was answered to as much as he was able to bring; and when he had nothing else to say, he sell to weeping. I was there present and can testify thereof; although there is a book abroad of the report of the disputation to the contrary, in which there is never a true word. And whereas you require to be satisfied of the sacrament, I will shew you the truth thereof, both by the scriptures and by the doctors.
Phil. It is a shrewd likelihood that you will not conclude with any truth, since you have began with so many untruths, as to say that I was answered while I had any thing to say; and that I wept for lack of matter to say, and that the book of the report of the disputation is not true. God be praised, there were a good many noblemen, gentlemen, and worshipful men that heard and saw the doings thereof, which can testify that you here have made an unjust report before these honourable lords. And that I wept, was not for lack of matter, as you slander me; for I thank God I have more matter than the best of you all shall ever be able to answer, as little learning as I have: but my weeping was, as Christ was upon Jerusalem, seeing the destruction that should fall upon her: and I foreseeing then the destruction which you (through violence and unrighteousness which you there declared) would work against the true church of Christ and her faithful members, as this day beareth witness, was compelled to weep in remembrance of that which I with many more have felt and shall feel. ALL these words I did then speak out, being interrupted by my lord Rich, saying, that I should suffer him to proceed out in this matter, and afterwards I should have leisure to answer him in every article. But he promised more than he could perform, as the end did well declare; for he had not the consent of the spirituality to his promise, which now rule the roast. God shorten their cruel days, for his elect's sake. And therefore I add this, which I purposed to have spoken, if then I might have been suffered, lest any that perfectly know not the things done in the convocation-house and now laid to my charge, if they should not be answered by me, might reckon Dr. Chedsey's saying to be true. And as concerning the book of the report of the disputations, I wrote the same, and it is true in every argument, as Mr. Dean, of Rochester, and Mr. Cheney; archdeacon of Hereford, (being yet alive, and within the realm) can testify.
Ched. You have of scriptures the four evangelists ⟨p. 49⟩for the probation of Christ's real presence to be in the sacrament after the words of consecration, with St. Paul to the Corinthians; which all say, "This is my body." They say not, as you would have me believe, this is not the body. But especially the 6th of John proveth this most manifestly, where Christ promised to give his body, which he performed in his last supper, as it appeareth by these words, "The bread which I will give is my flesh, which I will give for the life of the world."
Phil. My lord Rich, with your leave I must needs interrupt him a little, because he speaketh open blasphemy against the death of Christ: for if that promise brought in by St. John, was performed by Christ in his last supper, then he needed not to have died after he had given the sacrament.
Rich. Let Mr. Doctor make an end of his arguments, and afterward object to him what you can.
Ched. You must note, that there is twice Dabo in this saying of St. John, and the first is referred to the sacrament of the altar; and the second to the sacrifice upon the cross: and besides these manifest scriptures, there are many ancient doctors proving the same, as Ignatius, Ireneus, St. Cyprian (whose authority he recited at large) which I do omit, because I was not permitted to answer the same.
Rich. Now answer, and object to him what you can, and you shall be heard.
Phil. My lord, the chief ground whereon he with the rest of his side do ground themselves against us, are these words, "This is my body," with a false pretence of the omnipotency of God. And before I will come to the particular answers of all that he hath alleged, for that your lordships may the better understand me, what I mean, and whereupon I stand, I will first require Mr. Doctor to answer me one question. But first of all I do protest to your honours that I think as reverently of the sacrament, as a christian man ought to do, and that I acknowledge the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ, ministered after Christ's institution, •o be one of the greatest treasures and comforts that he left us on the earth; contrariwise, it is most sinful and abominable, not being ministered as it ought to be, as it is used now a-days.
Phil. My lord, the chief ground whereon he with the rest of his side do ground themselves against us, are these words, "This is my body," with a false pretence of the omnipotency of God. And before I will come to the particular answers of all that he hath alledged, for that your lordships may the better understand me, what I mean, and whereupon I stand, I will first require Mr. Doctor to answer me one question. But first of all I do protest to your honours that I think as reverently of the sacrament, as a christian man ought to do, and that I acknowledge the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ, ministered after Christ's institution, •o be one of the great•st treasures and comforts that he left us on the earth; contrarywise, it is most sinful and abominable, not being ministered as it ought to be, as it is used now a-days.
AND now to my question, which is this: whether these words only, "This is my body," spoken by a priest over the bread and wine, may make the body and blood of Christ, as you suppose, or no?
CHEDSEY studying what he might say, at last answered, That these words alone, pronounced by the priest, are sufficient to make the bread and wine the very body and blood of Christ really.
Phil. That is blasphemy to say, and against all the scriptures and doctors, who affirm that the form and substance in consecration must be observed which Christ used and did institute, as St. Cyprian saith, "In the sacrifice which is C•••st, only Christ is to be followed." And by the law it is forbidden to add or take away from God's word. And St. Peter saith, "If any man speak, let him speak as the word of God." Wherefore whosoever saith that these words only, "This is my body," do make a presence of Christ, without "Bless, Take, and Eat," which be three as substantial points of the sacrament, as, "This is my body," he is highly deceived. THEREFORE St. Augustine saith, "Let the word be joined to the element, and it becometh a sacrament:" So that if the entire words of Christ's institutions be not observed in the ministration of a sacrament, it is no sacrament; as the sacrifices which the ten tribes did offer at Bethel to God, were not acceptable, because they were not in all points done according to God's word. Wherefore except blessing be made after the word, (which is a due thanksgiving for our redemption in Christ) and also a showing forth of the Lord's death in such wise as the congregation may be edified; and moreover a taking and eating after Christ's commandment; except, I say, these three parts be first performed, (which is not done in the mass) these words, "This is my body," which are last placed in the institution of the Lord's supper, cannot be verified. For Christ commanded as well, "Take ye, Eat ye," as "This is my body."
Phil. That is blasphemy to say, and against all the scriptures and doctors, who affirm that the form and substance in consecration must be observed which Christ used and did institute, as St. Cyprian saith, "In the sacrifice which is C•••st, only Christ is to be followed." And by the law it is forbidden to add or take away from God's word. And St. Peter saith, "If any man speak, let him speak as the word of God." Wherefore whosoever saith that these words only, "This is my body," do make a presence of Christ, without "Bless, Take, and Eat," which be three as substantial points of the sacrament, as, "This is my body," he is highly deceived. THEREFORE St. Augustine saith, "Let the word be joined to the element, and it becometh a sacrament:" So that if the intire words of Christ's institutions be not observed in the ministration of a sacrament, it is no sacrament; as the sacrifices which the ten tribes did offer at Bethel to God, were not acceptable, because they were not in all points done according to God's word. Wherefore except blessing be made after the word, (which is a due thanksgiving for our redemption in Christ) and also a shewing forth of the Lord's death in such wise as the congregation may be edified; and moreover a taking and eating after Christ's commandment; except, I say, these three parts be first performed, (which is not done in the mass) these words, "This is my body," which are last placed in the institution of the Lord's supper, cannot be verified. For Christ commanded as well, "Take ye, Eat ye," as "This is my body."
Ched. Christ said, "Take, Eat, this is my body," and not, Take ye, Eat ye.
Phil. Did he not, Mr. Doctor? be not these the words of Christ, Accipite, Manducate? and do not these words in the plural number signify, "Take ye, Eat ye," and not Take thou, Eat thou, as you would suppose?
Ched. I grant it is as you say.
Phil. Likewise of consequence, you (Mr. Doctor) must needs deny what you have said, that these words, "This is my body," being only spoken, be sufficient to make the body and blood of Christ in the sacrament, as you have untruly said.
Phil. Likewise of consequence, you (Mr. Doctor) must n•eds deny what you have said, that these words, "This is my body," being only spoken, be sufficient to make the body and blood of Christ in the sacrament, as you have untruly said.
THEN the bishop came in again and said, What is it that you would have Mr. Doctor deny?