pp. 41–51144 passagespart 4 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Phil. My lord, […]. Doctor hath affirmed that these words, "This is my body," spoken by the priest only, do make the sacrament.
Phil. My lord, 〈…〉. Doctor hath affirmed that these words, "This is my body," spoken by the priest only, do make the sacrament.
Bond. Indeed if Mr. Bridges should speak these words over the bread and wine, they would be of none effect: but if a priest speak them after a due manner, they are effectual, and make a real body.
Bon. Indeed if Mr. Bridges should speak these words over the bread and wine, they would be of none effect: but if a priest speak them after a due manner, they are effectual, and make a real body.
Phil. Mr. Doctor hath said otherwise.
Bond. I think you mistake him: for he meaneth •• the words duly pronounced.
Bon. I think you mistake him: for he meaneth •• the words duly pronounced.
Phil. Let him revoke that he hath granted, and then will I begin again with that which before was said; that, "This is my body," hath no place, except Bless, Take, and Eat, duly go before. And therefore because the same words do not go before, "This is my body," but preposterously follow in your sacrament of the mass, it is not the sacrament of Christ, neither hath Christ in it present.
Ched. If "This is my body" only do not make the sacrament, no more do, "Bless, take, and eat."
Phil. I grant that the one without the other cannot make the sacrament. And it can be no sacrament unless the whole action of Christ doth concur together according to the first institution.
Ched. Why, then you would not have it to be the body of Christ, unless it be received?
Phil. No verily, it is not the very body of Christ to any other, but such as condignly receive the same after his institution.
Bond. Is not a loaf a loaf, being set on the table though no body eat thereof?
Bon. Is not a loaf a loaf, being set on the table though no body eat thereof?
Phil. It is not alike, my lord: for a loaf is a loaf before it be set on the table: but so is not the sacrament a perfect sacrament before it be duly administered at the table of the Lord.
Bond. I pray you what is it in the mean while before it is duly received?
Bon. I pray you what is it in the mean while before it is duly received?
Phil. It is, my lord, a sign begun of a holy thing, and yet no perfect sacrament until it be received. For in the sacrament there be two things to be considered, the sign, and the thing itself, which is Christ and his whole passion; and it is that to none but such as worthily receive the holy signs of bread and wine, according to Christ's institution.
Wind. There were never any that denied the words of Christ as you do. Did he not say, "This is my body?"
Phil. My lord, I pray you be not deceived. We do not deny the words of Christ: but we say, these words be of none effect, being spoken otherwise than Christ did institute them in his last supper. For example; Christ biddeth the church to be baptized in the name of the Father, of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. If a priest say these words over the water, and there be no child to be baptized, these words only pronounced do not make baptism. And again, baptism is only baptism to such as be baptized, and to none other standing by.
Lord Chamberlain. I pray you, my lord, let me ask him one question. What kind of presence in the sacrament (duly administered according to Christ's ordinance) do you allow?
Phil. If any come worthily to receive, tha• do I confess the presence of Christ wholly to be with all ⟨p. 51⟩the fruits of his passion, unto the said worthy receiver, by the Spirit of God, and that Christ is thereby joined to him, and he to Christ.
Lord Chamberlain. I am answered.
Bond. My lords, take no heed of him, for he goeth about to deceive you. His similitude that he bringeth in of baptism, is nothing like to the sacrament of the altar. For if I should say to sir John Bridges being with me at supper, and having a fat capon, Take, eat, this is of a capon, although he eat not thereof, is it not a capon still? And likewise of a piece of beef, or of a cup of wine? if I say, Drink, this is a cup of wine, is it not so, because he drinketh not thereof?
Bon. My lords, take no heed of him, for he goeth about to deceive you. His similitude that he bringeth in of baptism, is nothing like to the sacrament of the altar. For if I should say to sir John Bridges being with me at supper, and having a fat capon, Take, eat, this is of a capon, although he eat not thereof, is it not a capon still? And likewise of a piece of beef, or of a cup of wine? if I say, Drink, this is a cup of wine, is it not so, because he drinketh not thereof?
Phil. My lord, your similitudes are too gross for so high mysteries as we have in ha•d, as, if I were your equal, I could more plainly declare; and there is much more dissimilitude between common meats and drinks, than there is between baptism and the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ. Like must be compared to like, and spiritual things with spiritual, and not spiritual things with corporal things. And meats and drinks be of their own natures good or evil, and your words commending or discommending, do but declare what they are. But the sacraments are to be considered according to the word which Christ spake of them, of which, "Take ye, and eat ye," be some of the chief, concurrent to the making of the same, without which there can be no sacraments. And therefore the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ is called Communion: and likewise in the gospel Christ commanded, saying, "Divide it among you."
Phil. My lord, your similitudes are too gross for so high mysteries as we have in ha•d, as, if I were your equal, I could more plainly declare; and there is much more dissimilitude between common meats and drinks, than there is between baptism and the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ. Like must be compared to like, and spiritual things with spiritu•l, and not spiritual things with corporal things. And meats and drinks be of their own natures good or evil, and your words commending or discommending, do but declare what they are. But the sacraments are to be considered according to the word which Christ spake of them, of which, "Take ye, and eat ye," be some of the chief, concurrent to the making of the same, without which there can be no sacraments. And therefore the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ is called Communion: and likewise in the gospel Christ commanded, saying, "Divide it among you."
Ched. St. Paul calleth it a Communication.
Phil. That doth more expressly show that there must be a participation of the sacrament together.
Phil. That doth more expressly shew that there must be a participation of the sacrament together.
Bond. My lords, I am sorry I have troubled you so long with this obstinate man, with whom we can do no good; I will trouble you no longer now. And with that the lords rose up, none of them saying any evil word unto me.
Bon. My lords, I am sorry I have troubled you so long with this obstinate man, with whom we can do no good; I will trouble you no longer now. And with that the lords rose up, none of them saying any evil word unto me.
THUS ended the sixth examination.