pp. 51–5688 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Chan. He will prove his church to be before Christ.
Phil. If I did so, I go not amiss: for there was a church before the coming of Christ, which maketh one catholic church.
Chan. It is so indeed.
Phil. I will desire no better rule than the same which is oftentimes brought in of your side, to prove both my faith and the catholic church; that is, antiquity, universality, and unity.
Bond. Do you not see what a bragging foolish fellow this is? He would seem to be very well versed in the doctors, and he is but a fool. By what doctor art thou able to prove thy church? Name him, and thou shalt have him.
Bon. Do you not see what a bragging foolish fellow this is? He would seem to be very well versed in the doctors, and he is but a fool. By what doctor art thou able to prove thy church? Name him, and thou shalt have him.
Phil. My lord, let me have all your ancient writers, with pen, and ink, and paper, and I will prove both my faith and my church out of every one of them.
Bond. No that thou shalt not have. You shall see how he lieth. St. Cyprian saith, "There must be one high-priest, to which the residue must obey;" and they will allow no head, neither vicar-general.
Bon. No that thou shalt not have. You shall see how he lieth. St. Cyprian saith, "There must be one high-priest, to which the residue must obey;" and they will allow no head, neither vicar-general.
Phil. St. Cyprian saith not, that there should be a vicar-general over all. For in his book De simplicitate Praelatorum, I am sure he saith the contrary: "There is but one bishopric, which is wholly possessed of every bishop in part."
Bond. Fetch hither the book, thou shalt see the manifest place against thee. DR. CH•DSEY brought the book, and turned to the place in an epistle written unto Cornelius then bishop of Rome, and recited these words in sum, "That it went not well with the church, where the high-priest was not obeyed;" and so would have concluded for the confirmation of the bishop's saving.
Bon. Fe•ch hither the book, thou shalt see the manifest place against thee. DR. CH•DSEY brought the book, and turned to the place in an epistle written unto Cornelius then bishop of Rome, and recited these words in sum, "That it went not well with the church, where the high-priest was not obeyed;" and so would have concluded for the confirmation of the bishop's saving.
Phil. Mr. Doctor, you mis-construe the place of St. Cyprian; for he meaneth not there by the high-priest, the bishop of Rome, but every patriarch in his precinct, of whom there were four appointed in his time. And in writing unto Cornelius, he meaneth by the high-priest, himself, who was then bishop of Africa, whose authority the heretics began to despise. Whereof he complaineth to Cornelius, and saith, the church cannot be well ordered, where the chief minister by order after the judgment of the scriptures, after the agreement of the people, and the consent of his fellow-bishops, is not obeyed.
Phil. Mr. Doctor, you mis-construe the place of St. Cyprian; for he meaneth not there by the high-priest, the bishop of Rome, but every patriarch in his precinct, of whom there were four appointed in his time. And in writing unto Cornelius, he meaneth by the high-priest, himself, who was then bishop of Africa, whose authority the heretics began to despise. Whereof he complaineth to Corne•ius, and saith, the church cannot be well ordered, where the chief minister by order after the judgment of the scriptures, after the agreement of the people, and the consent of his fellow-bishops, is not obeyed.
Bond. Hath not the bishop of Rome always been supreme head of the church, and Christ's vicar on earth even from Peter?
Bon. Hath not the bishop of Rome always been supreme head of the church, and Christ's vicar on earth even from Peter?
Phil. No, that he was not. For by the word of God he hath no more authority, than the bishop of London hath.
Bond. Was not Peter head of the church, and hath not the bishop of Rome, who is his successor, the same authority?
Bon. Was not Peter head of the church, and hath not the bishop of Rome, who is his successor, the same authority?
Phil. I grant that the bishop of Rome, as he is the successor of Peter, hath the same authority as Peter had: but Peter had no more authority than every one of the apostles had.
Chan. Yes, that St. Peter had; for Christ said specially unto him, "I will give thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven;" which he spake to none other of his disciples singularly, but to him.
Phil. St. Augustine answereth otherwise to the objection, and saith, "That if in Peter there had not been the figure of the church, the Lord had not said to him, To thee will I give the keys of the kingdom of heaven. Which if Peter received not, the church hath them not▪ if the church hath them, then Peter hath them not."
Bond. What if I can prove and show you out of the civil law, that all christendom ought to follow the holy catholic church of Rome, as there is a special title thereof, De catholica fide & sancta Romana ecclesia?
Bon. What if I can prove and shew you out of the civil law, that all christendom ought to follow the holy catholic church of Rome, as there is a special title thereof, De catholica fide & sancta Romana ecclesia?
Phil. That is nothing material, seeing the things of God be not subject to man's laws; and the divine matters must be ordered by the word of God, and not of man.
A Doctor. What will you say, if I can prove that Christ built his church upon Peter, and that out of St. Cyprian? will you then believe that the bishop of Rome ought to be supreme head of the church?
Phil. I know what St. Cyprian writeth in that behalf; but he meaneth nothing as you take it.
A Doctor. St. Cyprian hath these words, That upon Peter was built the church, as upon the first beginning of unity.
Phil. He declareth that in an example, that unity must be in the church; he grounded on Peter his church alone, and not upon men. Which he doth more manifestly declare in the book De simplicitate Praelatorum, saying, in the person of one man God gave the keys to all, that he in signification thereby might declare the unity of all men.
A Doctor. What, will you understand St. Cyprian so? That were good indeed.
Phil. I think you cannot understand St. Cyprian better, than he doth declare himself.
Bond. I will desire you (Mr. Chancellor) to take some pains with Dr. Chedsey, about his examination, for I must go to the parliament-house. And I desire you will dine with me.
Bon. I will desire you (Mr. Chancellor) to take some pains with Dr. Chedsey, about his examination, for I must go to the parliament-house. And I desire you will dine with me.
Phil. Then the doctor again took his former ⟨p. 55⟩authority in hand for want of another, and would have mad a further circumstance, digressing from his purpose. To whom I said he knew not whereabouts he went, and herewith he laughed. And I said his divinity was nothing but scoffing.
A Doctor. Yes, then I have done with you, and so went away.
Phil. You are too young in divinity to teach me in the matters of my faith. Though you may be more learned in other things than I, yet in divinity I have been longer practised than you, for any thing I can hear of you; therefore be not too hasty to judge what you do not perfectly know.
Chan. Peter and his successors from the beginning have been allowed for the supreme head of the church, and that by the scriptures, for Christ said unto him in St. John thrice, "Feed my sheep."
Phil. That is no otherwise to be taken, than, "Go ye and preach," which was spoken to all the apostles as well as unto Peter. And that Christ said thrice, "Feed my sheep," it signifieth nothing else but the earnest study that the ministers of God ought to have in preaching the word. God grant that you of the clergy would weigh your duty in this behalf more than you do. Is this a just interpretation of the scripture, to take "Feed my sheep," for to be lord of the whole world? IN the mean while a bachelor of divinity came in, which is a reader of Greek in Oxford, belonging to the bishop, and he took upon him to help Mr. Chancellor.
Scholar. What will you say if I can show you a Greek author called Theophylact to interpret it so? Will you believe his interpretation?
Scholar. What will you say if I can shew you a Greek author called Theophylact to interpret it so? Will you believe his interpretation?
Phil. Theophylact is a late writer, and one that was a favourer of the bishop of Rome, and therefore not to be credited, since his interpretation is contrary to the determination of many general councils.
Scholar. In what general council was it otherwise, that the bishop of Rome was not supreme head over all?
Phil. In the council of Nice I am sure it was otherwise; for Athanasius was there the chief bishop and president of the council, and not the bishop of Rome.
Scholar. Nay, that is not so.
Phil. Then I perceive you are better seen in words than in knowledge of things: and I will lay with you what you will it is so, as you may see in the Epitome of the councils.
Scholar. I will fetch Eusebius and show the contrary, and the book of General Councils. He went into my lord's closet, and brought Eusebius, but the General Councils he brought not, saying (for saving of his honesty) that he could not come by them, and there he would have defended that it was otherwise in Eusebius, but he was not able to show the same, and so shrunk away confounded.
Scholar. I will fetch Eusebius and shew the contrary, and the book of General Councils. He went into my lord's closet, and brought Eusebius, but the General Councils he brought not, saying (for saving of his honesty) that he could not come by them, and there he would have defended that it was otherwise in Eusebius, but he was not able to shew the same, and so shrunk away confounded.
Chan. The church of Rome hath been always taken for the catholic church; therefore I would advise you to come into the same with us. You see all the men of this realm do condemn you. And why will you be so singular?
Phil. I have said, and still do say, that if you can be able to prove it unto me, that I will be of the same. But I am sure that the church, which you make so much of, is a false church, and a synagogue of Satan. And you with the learned men of the realm do persecute the true church, and condemn such as are more righteous than you.
Chan. Do you hear, Mr. Doctor, what he saith, that the church of Rome is the devil.