pp. 69–81226 passagespart 3 of 6
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mor. Will you promise to recant, if I show his saying to be true.
Mor. Will you promise to recant, if I shew his saying to be true.
Phil. My faith shall not hang upon any doctor's saying, further than he shall be able to prove the same by God's word.
Christo. I will go fetch the book, and show it▪ him by and by; and therewithal he went into the bishop's study, and brought Cyprian, and pointed out these words in one of his epistles, Ad Romanos autem, quorum fides Apostolo praedicanto laudata est, non protest accedere perfidia; that is, "But unto the Romans, whose faith by the testimony of the apostle is praised, misbelief can have no access."
Christo. I will go fetch the book, and shew it▪ him by and by; and therewithal he went into the bishop's study, and brought Cyprian, and pointed out these words in one of his epistles, Ad Romanos autem, quorum fides Apostolo praedicanto laudata est, non protest accedere perfidia; that is, "But unto the Romans, whose faith by the testimony of the apostle is praised, misbelief can have no access."
Phil. These words of Cyprian do not prove your pretended assertion, which is, That to the church of Rome there could come no misbelief.
Christo. Good Lord, doth it not not? What can be said more plainly?
Phil. He speaketh not of the church of Rome absolutely.
Christo. By God, a child that can but say his grammar will not deny what you do, the words are so plain.
Phil. Swear not, Mr. Doctor, but weigh Cyprian's words with me, and I shall make you to say as I have said.
Christo. I am no doctor, but I perceive it is but labour lost to reason with you.
AND with that the bishop of London came in blowing again, and said, What, is my lord of Chichester gone away also? (for he even a little before departed also without any other word, than that he must needs be gone.)
What (says Bonner) is the matter you now stand upon?
Mor. Mr. Christopherson hath showed Mr. Philpot a notable place of the authority of the church of Rome, and he maketh nothing of it.
Mor. Mr. Christopherson hath shewed Mr. Philpot a notable place of the authority of the church of Rome, and he maketh nothing of it.
Bond. Where is the place? Let me see▪ By my faith here is a place alone. Come hither, sir, what say you to this? Nay, tarry a while, I will help this place with St. Paul's own testimony, in the first chapter to the Romans, where he saith, That their saith is preached throughout the world▪ how can you be able to answer to this?
Bon. Where is the place? Let me see▪ By my faith here is a place alone. Come hither, sir, what say you to this? Nay, tarry a while, I will help this place with St. Paul's own testimony, in the first chapter to the Romans, where he saith, That their saith is preached throughout the world▪ how can you be able to answer to this?
Phil. Yes, my lord, it is soon answered if you will consider all the words of Cyprian; for he speaketh of such as in his time were faithful at Rome, and followed the doctrine of St. Paul, as he had taught them, and as it was notified throughout the world, by an epistle which he had written in the commendation of their faith. With such as are praised by St. Paul at Rome, for following the true faith, misbelief can have no place. And if you can show, that the faith which the church of Rome holdeth now, is that faith which the apostle praised and allowed in the Romans in his time, then will I say what St. Cyprian then said, and with you, That infidelity can have no place there; but otherwise it maketh not absolutely for the authority of the church of Rome, as you do mistake it.
Phil. Yes, my lord, it is soon answered if you will consider all the words of Cyprian; for he speaketh of such as in his time were faithful at Rome, and followed the doctrine of St. Paul, as he had taught them, and as it was notified throughout the world, by an epistle which he had written in the commendation of their faith. With such as are praised by St. Paul at Rome, for following the true faith, misbelief can have no place. And if you can shew, that the faith which the church of Rome holdeth now, is that faith which the apostle praised and allowed in the Romans in his time, then will I say what St. Cyprian then said, and with you, That infidelity can have no place there; but otherwise it maketh not absolutely for the authority of the church of Rome, as you do mistake it.
Christo. You understand Cyprian well indeed; I think you never read him in your life.
Phil. Yes, Mr. Doctor, that I have, I can show you a book noted with mine own hand: though I have not read so much as you, yet I have read somewhat. It is a shame for you to wrest and wreath the doctors as you do, to maintain a false religion, which be altogether against you, if you take them aright; and indeed your false packing of doctors together hath given me and others occasion to look upon them, whereby we find you shameful liars, and mis reporters of the ancient doctors.
Phil. Yes, Mr. Doctor, that I have, I can shew you a book noted with mine own hand: though I have not read so much as you, yet I have read somewhat. It is a shame for you to wrest and wreath the doctors as you do, to maintain a false religion, which be altogether against you, if you take them aright; and indeed your false packing of doctors together hath given me and others occasion to look upon them, whereby we find you shameful liars, and mis reporters of the ancient doctors.
Mor. What, will you be in hand to allow doctors now? They of your sect do not so. I marvel therefore that you will allow them.
Phil. I do allow them inasmuch as they do agree ⟨p. 75⟩with the scriptures, and so do all they which are of the truth, howsoever you term us, and I praise God for that good understanding I have received by them.
Christo. What? you understand not the doctors, you may be ashamed to say it.
Phil. I thank God, I understand them better than you: for you have Exc••cationem cordis, The blindness of heart; so that you understand not truly what you read, no more than the wall here, as your taking of Cyprian doth declare. And, before God, you are but deceivers of the people, for all the brag you make of learning; neither have you scripture or ancient doctor on your side, being truly taken.
Mor. Why, all the doctors are on our side, and against you altogether.
Phil. Yea, so you say when you are in your pulpits alone, and none to answer you. But if you will come to cast accounts with me thereof, I will venture with you a recantation, that I (as little fight as I have in the doctors) will bring more authorities of ancient doctors on my side than you shall be able for your's, and he that can bring most, to him let the other side yield. Are you willing so to do?
Christo. It is but folly to reason with you, you will believe no man but yourself.
Phil. I will believe you or any other learned man, if you can bring any thing worthy to be believed. You cannot win me with vain words from my faith. Before God there is no truth in you.
Mor. What, no truth? No truth? ha, ha, ha!
Phil. Except the articles of the Trinity, you are corrupt in all other things, and sound in nothing.
Mor. What say you; do we not believe well on the sacrament?
Phil. It is the thing which (among all others) you do most abuse.
Mor. Wherein I pray you? tell us.
Phil. I have told you before, Mr. Doctor, in the convocation•house.
Mor. Yes marry: indeed you told us there very well. For there you fell down upon your knees, and fell to weeping, ha, ha, ha!
Phil. I did weep indeed, and so did Christ upon Jerusalem, and am not to be blamed for it, if you consider the cause of my weeping.
Mor. What, make you yourself Christ? ha, ha, ha!
Phil. No, sir, I make not myself Christ▪ but I am not ashamed to do as my Master and Saviour did, to bewail and lament your infidelity and idolatry, which I there foresaw through tyranny you would bring again to this realm, as this day doth declare.
Phil. No, sir, I make not myself Christ▪ but I am not ashamed to do as my Master and Saviour did, to bewail and lament your infidelity and idolatry, which I there foresaw through tyranny you would bring again to this r•alm, as this day doth declare.
Mor. That is your argument.
Christo. Wherein do we abuse the sacrament? tell us.
Phil. As I may touch but one of the least abuses, you administer it not in both kinds as you ought to do, but keep the one half from the people, contrary to Christ's institution.
Christo. Why, is there not as much contained in one kind as in both? And what need is it then to minister in both kinds?
Phil. I believe not so: for if it had, Christ would have given but one kind only; for he instituted nothing superfluous: and therefore you cannot say that the whole effect of the sacrament is as well in one kind as in both, since the scripture teacheth otherwise.
Christo. What if I can prove it by scripture, th•• we may administer it in one kind? The apostle• did so, as it may appear in the Acts of the Apostles in one or two places, where it is written, that the apostles continued "in prayers and in breaking of bread," which is meant of the sacrament.