pp. 69–81226 passagespart 4 of 6
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Phil. Why, Mr. Doctor, do you not know that St. Luke, by making mention of breaking of bread, meaneth •he whole use of the sacrament according to Chri•••s institution, by a figure which you have learned grammar, Synecdoche, where part is mentioned, and the whole understood to be done, as Christ commanded it?
Christo. Nay, that is not so: for I can show you out of Eusebius, in his Ecclesiastical History, that […] a man of God, whom he named, that sent the […] in one kind by a boy, to one that was […].
Christo. Nay, that is not so: for I can shew you out of Eusebius, in his Ecclesiastical History, that 〈…〉 a man of God, whom he named, that sent the 〈…〉 in one kind by a boy, to one that was 〈…〉.
Phil. I have read indeed that they did use to give what was left of the communion-bread to children, to mariners, and to women▪ and so peradventure the boy might carry a piece of what was left to the sick man.
Christo. Nay, as a sacrament it was purposely sent unto him.
Phil. If it were so, y•t you cannot precisely say, that he had not the cup administered unto him also by some sent unto him: but though one man did use it thus, doth it follow that all men may do the like? St. Cyprian noteth many abuses of the sacrament in his time, which rose upon singular men's examples, as using of water instead of wine: therefore he saith, "We must not look what any man hath done before us, but what Christ first of all did and commanded."
Phil. If it were so, y•t you cannot precisely say, that he had not the cup administered unto him also by some sent unto him: but though one man did use it thus, doth it follow that all men may do the lik•? St. Cyprian noteth many abuses of the sacrament in his time, which rose upon singular men's examples, as using of water instead of wine: therefore he saith, "We must not look what any man hath done before us, but what Christ first of all did and commanded."
Christo. Hath not the church taught us so to use the sacrament? And how do we know that Christ is HOMOUSIOS, that is, of one substance with the Father, but by the determination of the church? How can you prove that otherwise by express words of scripture, and where find you HOMOU•IOS in all the scripture?
Phil. Yes, that I do in the first of the Hebrews, where it is written that Christ is the express image of God's own substance, Ejusdem substanti•.
Christo. Nay, that is not so. That is, there is no more but Expressa imago substantiae, The express image of God's substance, and image is accident.
Phil. It is in the text, Of his substance, Substantiae illius, or his own substance, as it may […] well interpreted. Besides this, that which Christ spake of himself in St. John manifesteth the same, saying, I and the Father be one thing, Ego & pater unum sumus. And whereas you say, Imago here is an accident, the ancient fathers use this for a strong argument to prove Christ to be God, because he is the very image of God.
Phil. It is in the text, Of his substance, Substantiae illius, or his own substance, as it may 〈…〉 well interpreted. Besides this, that which Christ spake of himself in St. John manifesteth the same, saying, I and the Father be one thing, Ego & pater unum sumus. And whereas you say, Imago here is an accident, the ancient fathers use this for a strong argument to prove Christ to be God, because he is the very image of God.
Christo. Do they? Is this a good argument, because we are the image of God, Ergo. We are God?
Phil. We are not called the express image of God, as it is written of Christ, and we are but the image of God by participation; and as it is written in Genesis. We are made to the likeness and similitude of God. But you ought to know, Mr. Christopherson, that there is no accident in God, and therefore Christ cannot be the image of God, but he must be of the same substance with God.
Christo. Tush.
Mor. How say you to the presence of the sacrament? Will you stand here to the judgment of your book, or no? Or will you recant?
Phil. I know you go about to catch me in words. If you can prove that book to be my setting forth, lay it to my charge when I come to judgment.
Mor. Speak, are you of the same mind […] this book i• of, or no? Sure I am you were once, unless you are become another manner of man that you were.
Mor. Speak, are you of the same mind 〈…〉 this book i• of, or no? Sure I am you were once, unless you are become another manner of man that you were.
Phil. What I was, you know: what I am, I will not tell you now▪ but this I will say to you by the way, that if you can prove the sacrament of the mass (as you now use it) to be a sacrament, I will then grant you a presence; but first you must prove the same a sacrament, and afterward treat of the presence.
Mor. Ho, do you doubt that it is a sacrament?
Phil. I am past doubting, for I believe you can never be able to prove it a sacrament.
Christo. Yea, do you? Good Lord, doth not St. Augustine call it the sacrament of the altar? How say you to that?
Phil. That maketh nothing for the probation of your sacrament. For so he with other ancient writers do call the holy communion or supper of the Lord, in respect that it is the sacrament of the sacrifice which Christ offered upon the altar of the cross, which sacrifice all the altars and sacrifices done upon the altars in the old law did prefigure and shadow, which pertaineth nothing to your sacrament hanging upon your altars of lime and stone.
Christo. Doth it not? I pray you, what signifieth Altar.
Phil. Not as you falsely take it, materially, but for the sacrifice of the altar of the cross.
Christo. Where find you it ever so taken.
Phil. Yes, that I do in St. Paul to the Hebrews, the 13th chap. where he saith, "We have an alter, of which it is not lawful for them to eat which serve the tabernacle." Is not altar in this place taken for the sacrifice of the altar, and not for the altar of lime and stone?
Phil. Yes, that I do in St. Paul to the Hebrews, the 13th chap. where he saith, "We have an alter, of which it is not lawful for them to eat which serve the t•bernacle." Is not altar in this place taken for the sacrifice of the altar, and not for the altar of lime and stone?
Christo. Well, God bless me out of your company. You are such an obstinate heretic, as I have not heard the like.
Phil. I pray God keep me from such blind doctors, who when they are not able to prove what they say, then fall to reviling (as you do now) for lack of better proof. In the mean while the bishop of London was talking with some other hard by, and at length came in to supply his part, and said:
•on. I pray you, masters, hearken to what I shall say to this man. Come hither, Mr. Green: and now, sir, (pointing to me) you cannot think it sufficient to be wicked yourself, but must go about to procure this young gentleman to do the like.
Phil. My lord, he cannot say that I ever hitherto wrote unto him concerning any such matter, as he here can testify.
Green. No, you never wrote unto me.
Bond. Why, is not this your letter which you did write concerning him.
Bon. Why, is not this your letter which you did write concerning him.
Phil. I have showed your lordship my mind concerning that letter already: it was not written to Mr. Green, neither was he privy to the writing thereof.
Phil. I have shewed your lordship my mind concerning that letter already: it was not written to Mr. Green, neither was he privy to the writing thereof.
Bond. How say you then, if a man be in an error, and you know thereof, what are you bound to do in such a case?
Bon. How say you then, if a man be in an error, and you know thereof, what are you bound to do in such a case?
Phil. I am bound to do the best I can to bring him out of it.
Bond. If Mr. Green here be in the like, are you not bound to reform him thereof if you can?
Bon. If Mr. Green here be in the like, are you not bound to reform him thereof if you can?
Phil. Yes, that I am, and will do the uttermost of my power therein. BUT the bishop remembering himself, thinking that he would but shrewdly after his expectation be holpen at my mouth, but rather consumed in that which he called an error, ceased to go any further in his demand, and called Mr. Green aside, and before his register read him a letter, I know not the contents thereof: and therewithal he gave Mr. Green the book of my disputation in the convocation-house, and afterwards went aside, communing with Mr. Christopherson, leaving Mr. Morgan▪ Mr. Harpsfield, and Mr. Cousins, to reason with me in the hearing of Mr. Green.
Phil. Yes, that I am, and will do the uttermost of my power therein. BUT the bishop remembering himself, thinking that he would but shrewdly after his expectation be holpen at my mouth, but rather consumed in that which he called an error, ceased to go any further in his demand, and called Mr. Green aside, and before his register read him a letter, I know not the contents thereof: and therewithal he gave Mr. Green the book of my disputation in the convocation-house, and afterwards went aside, communing with Mr. Christopherson, leaving Mr. Morgan▪ Mr. Harpsfield, and Mr. Cosins, to reason with me in the hearing of Mr. Green.
Morgan. Mr. Philpot, I would ask you how old your religion is?
Phil. It is older than your's by a thousand years and more.
Mor. I pray you, where was it fifty years ago?
Phil. It was in Germany apparent by the testimony of Huss, Jerome of Prague, and Wycliffe, whom your generation an hundred years ago and ⟨p. 78⟩more, did burn for preaching the truth unto you; and before their time and since hath been, although under persecution it hath been put to silence.
Phil. It was in Germany apparent by the testimony of Huss, Jerome of Prague, and Wickliffe, whom your generation an hundred years ago and ⟨p. 78⟩more, did burn for preaching the truth unto you; and before their time and since hath been, although under persecution it hath been put to silence.
Mor. That is a marvellous strange religion, which no man can tell certainly where to find it.