pp. 81–8782 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Worc. What, a real presence?
Phil. Yea, a real presence by the Spirit of God in the right administration.
Wor. That is well said: and do you agree with the catholic church also?
Phil. I do agree with the true catholic church.
Wor. My lord of London, this man speaketh reasonably now.
Bond. You do agree in generals, but when it shall come to particulars, you will far disagree.
Bon. You do agree in generals, but when it shall come to particulars, you will far disagree.
Wor. Well, keep yourself here, and you shall have other learned bishops to commune further with you, as my lord of Durham, and my lord of Chichester, whom I hear say you do like well.
Phil. I do like them as I do all others that speak the truth. I have once already spoken with them, and they found no fault with me.
Wor. In the mean season pray to God for grace.
Phil. Prayer is the most comfortable exercise I feel in my trouble, and my conscience is quiet, and I have the peace of mind, which cannot be the fruits of heresy.
Wor. We bid you farewell for this time.
AFTER dinner they called for me again, and demanded of me whether I meant as I spake before dinner, and would not go from it. To them I answered, that I would not go from what I had said.
Wor. You said at my departing from you before dinner, that if we did burn you, we should burn a catholic man: will you be a catholic man, and stand to the catholic church?
Phil. I will stand to the true catholic church.
Wor. Will you stand to the catholic church of Rome?
Phil. If you can prove the same to be the catholic church, I will be one thereof.
Wor. Did not Christ say unto Peter, and to all his successors of Rome, "Feed my sheep, feed ⟨p. 84⟩my lambs?" Which doth signify that he gave him more authority than the rest.
Phil. That saying pertaineth nothing to the authority of Peter, above others, but declareth what Christ requireth of his beloved apostles, that they should with all diligence preach to the flock of Christ the way of salvation, and that doth the iteration of feeding, spoken to Peter, only signify. But the bishop of Rome little regardeth the spiritual feeding, and therefore he hath imagined an easier way to make himself lord of the whole world, yea, and of God's word too, and doth not feed Christ's flock as Peter did.
Wor. How can you tell that?
Phil. Yes, I have been there, and I could not learn of all his countrymen that ever he preacheth.
Wor. Though he preacheth not one way, he preacheth another, by procuring good order for the church to be kept in.
Phil. I am sure that it will be his damnation before God, that he leaveth what he is commanded by Christ, and setteth forth his own decrees to deface the gospel.
Wor. It is the evil living that you have seen at Rome, that causeth you to have this ill judgment of the church of Rome. I cannot now tarry with you to reason further of the matter. HOW say you to the real presence of the sacrament, will you stand to that?
Phil. I do acknowledge (as I have said) a real presence of the sacrament, in the due administration thereof, to the worthy receivers by the Spirit of God.
Wor. You add now a great many more words than you did before; and yet you say more of the sacrament than a great many will do. THUS they departed, and after them came unto me, Dr. Chedsey, and Dr. Wright, archdeacon of Oxford, with a great many more.
Wor. You add now a great many more words than you did before; and yet you say more of the sacrament than a great many will do. THUS they departed, and after them came unto me, Dr. Chedsey, and Dr. Wright, a•chdeacon of Oxford, with a great many more.
Ched. Mr. Philpot, here is Mr. Archdeacon of Oxford come to give you good counsel, I pray hear him.
Phil. I will refuse to hea• none that will counsel me any good; and if any can bring me better matter than I have, I will stick thereunto.
Wright. I would wi•• you, Mr. Philpot, to agree with the catholic church, and not to stand in your own conceit: you see a great many learned men against you.
Phil. I am, Mr. Doctor, of the unfeigned catholic church, and will live and die therein: and if you can prove your church to be the true catholic church, I will be one of the same.
Wright. I came not to dispute with you, but to exhort you. Here are better learned than I, who can inform you better.
Ched. What proof would you have? I will prove unto you our church to have it's being and foundation by the scriptures, by the apostles, and by the primitive church, confirmed with the blood of martyrs, and with the testimony of all confessors.
Phil. Give me your hand, Mr. Doctor, prove that, and have with you.
Ched. If I had my books here, I could soon prove it, I will go fetch some; and with that he went and brought his book of annotations, saying, I cannot well bring my books, therefore I have brought my book of annotations, and turned there to a common place of the sacrament, asking me whether the catholic church did allow the presence of Christ's body in the sacrament, or no? I hear say you do confess a real presence: but I'll be hanged if you will abide by it: you will deny it by and by.
Phil. What I have said I cannot deny, neither intend, whatsoever you say.
Ched. If there be a real presence in the sacrament, ⟨p. 87⟩then evil men receive Christ, which thing you will not grant, I am sure.
Phil. I deny the argument, for I do not grant in the sacrament, by transubstantiation, any real presence, as you falsely imagine, but in the due administration to the worthy receivers.
Ched. I will prove that the evil and wicked men eat the body of Christ, as well as the good men, by St. Augustine here.
Phil. And in the beginning of his text St. Augustine seemeth to approve his assertion; but I bad him read out to the end, and there St. Augustin declareth most evidently that it was Quodammodo, after a certain manner the evil men received the body of Christ, which is sacramentally, only in the outward sign, and not really, or indeed as the good doth. And thus all the doctors that you seem to bring in for your purpose, be quite against you if you did rightly weigh them.
Ched. By God you are a subtle fellow. See how he would writhe St. Augustine's words.
Phil. See which of us do writhe St. Augustine most, you or I, who take his meaning by his own express words. And seeing you charge me with subtlety, what subtlety is this of you, to say, that you will prove your matter of the church, even from the beginning, promising to show your books therein, and when it cometh to the proof, you are able to show none, and for want thereof slip into a by-matter, and you faint in the proof thereof? Before God you are ridiculous and without shame in your religion.
Phil. See which of us do writhe St. Augustine most, you or I, who take his meaning by his own express words. And seeing you charge me with subtlety, what subtlety is this of you, to say, that you will prove your matter of the church, even from the beginning, promising to shew your books therein, and when it cometh to the proof, you are able to shew none, and for want thereof slip into a by-matter, and you faint in the proof thereof? Before God you are ridiculous and without shame in your religion.