But here again will some one of you steppe forth like a tall fellow, and say, when the Lord spake those words of his body, he uttered no syllable or term of signifying. Neither did he speak thus, This doth signify my body, but did profess simply without all figure, this is my body. But this trymmetra••ne so nicely conned out, Augustine will easily unlose unto us.1 Who writing against Adimantus, doth amongest other rules recited in the nature of a sign reckon up this same very speech in the Gospel.2 The Lord, sayeth Augustine, do•ted nothing to say, This is my body, when he gave a sign of his body. Verily, if he gave a sign of his body, he could not choose but give somewhat wherein he might signify his body, although there be no word significant expressed. In like manner neither was any word significant uttered by the Apostle when he spake of the Rock,3 as the same Augustine witnesseth: for the Apostle said not, the rock did signify Christ, but the rock was Christ, when as nevertheless no man ought to doubt of the Apostles meaning herein, not that Christ was a very rock or stone in deed, but that the rock did signify Christ. Or if these jolly fellows will not be satisfied with this answer of Augustine, then let Ambrose answer for Augustine: Who setting down the matter plainly by the word of signifying: Because, saith he, we be delivered by the death of the Lord, being mindful hereof we do in eating and drinking signify ⟨image 103⟩the flesh and blood, which was crucified for us.
But here againe will some one of you steppe foorth like a tall felowe, and saye, when the Lorde spake those wordes of his body, he vttered no sillable or terme of signifying. Neither did he speake thus, This doth signifie my body, but did professe simply without all figure, this is my body. But this trymmetra••ne so nicely conned out, Augustine will easely vnlose vnto vs.1 Who writing against Adimantus, doth amongest other rules recited in the nature of a signe reckō vp this same very speech in the Gospell.2 The Lorde, saieth Augustine, do•ted nothing to saye, This is my body, when hee gaue a signe of his bodye. Uerily, if he gaue a signe of his body, he could not choose but giue somewhat wherein hee might signifie his body, although there bee no woorde significant expressed. In like maner neither was any woorde significant vttered by the Apostle when hee spake of the Rocke,3 as the same Augustine witnesseth: for the Apostle sayed not, the rocke did signifie Christ, but the rock was Christ, when as neuerthelesse no man ought to doute of the Apostles meaning herein, not that Christe was a very rocke or stone in deede, but that the rocke did signifie Christ. Or if these iolly fellowes will not bee satisfied with this aunswere of Augustine, then let Ambrose aunswere for Augustine: Who setting downe the matter playnely by the woorde of signifying: Bicause, saith he, we be deliuered by the death of the Lorde, beeing myndefull hereof we doe in eating and drinking signifie ⟨image 103⟩the flesh and blood, which was crucified for vs.
- 1Aug. contra Adimantum cap. 12.
- 2An objection. Christ said not, this doth signify my body, but this is my body. Ergo, simply it is Christs body. August. doth answer, Paul said not the rock doth signify Christ, but the rock was Christ. Ergo The rock was Christ naturally.An obiection. Christ sayed not, this doth signifie my body, but this is my body. Ergo, simply it is Christes body. August. doth answere, Paul sayed not the rock doth signifie Christ, but the rock was Christe. Ergo The rock was Christe naturally.
- 3August. de Civitate Dei. lib. 18. Cap. 48. Because after a certain manner all things significant do bear the names of the things signified. As this speech of the Apostle, the rock was Christ, when as notwithstanding it did signify Christ.August. de Ciuitate Dei. lib. 18. Cap. 48. Bicause after a certen maner all thinges significant doe beare the names of the thinges signified. As this speech of the Apostle, the rocke was Christe, when as notwithstanding it did signifie Christe.