A14350:4782
The common places of the most famous and renowned divine Doctor Peter Martyr divided into four principal parts: with a large addition of many theological and necessary discourses, some never extant before. Translated and partly gathered by Anthony Marten, one of the sewers of her Majesties most honourable chamber.The common places of the most famous and renowmed diuine Doctor Peter Martyr diuided into foure principall parts: with a large addition of manie theologicall and necessarie discourses, some neuer extant before. Translated and partlie gathered by Anthonie Marten, one of the sewers of hir Maiesties most honourable chamber.
Imprinted at London : In Pater noster Rowe, by Henry Denham and Henry Middleton at the costs and charges of Henry Denham, Thomas Chard, William Broome, and Andrew Maunsell, 1583Imprinted at London : In Pater noster Rovve, by Henry Denham and Henry Middleton at the costs and charges of Henrie Denham, Thomas Chard, VVilliam Broome, and Andrew Maunsell, 1583
No title page in the transcription: set from the catalogue record.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Also if our adversaries opinion should be admitted, it might not be avoided, but that aswell the wicked as the godly should eat and drink the flesh and blood of the Lord. But this doeth Christ the Author of the sacraments manifestly refute in the 6. of John, where he sayeth that his flesh and blood is eaten and drunken by faith. See then (I pray you) that when the wicked are destitute of faith, and be strangers from Christ, what communion have they with the flesh and blood of Christ? Doubtless they have only the signs to be received, and that to their own condemnation: for neither is Christ in them, neither ⟨p. 202⟩do they abide in Christ.
Also if our aduersaries opinion should be admitted, it might not be auoided, but that aswell the wicked as the godly shoulde eate and drinke the flesh and bloud of the Lord. But this doeth Christ the Author of the sacraments manifestly refute in the 6. of Iohn, where he saieth that his flesh and bloud is eaten and drunken by faith. See then (I pray you) that when ye wicked are destitute of faith, and be straungers from Christ, what communion haue they with the flesh and bloud of Christ? Doubtlesse they haue onely the signes to be receiued, and that to their owne condemnation: for neither is Christ in them, neyther ⟨p. 202⟩doe they abide in Christ.
They are to be demanded also which affirm that the blood of the Lord is present in this sacrament, for what cause or under what colour they dare name that their sacrifice an unbloody sacrifice as they term it. Surely if they will have the blood of the Lord flowing from the Lords side to be received in their Cup as Chrysostom said, by an excessive kind of speech, let them endeavour the same as much as they will, as they know and as they can: yet shall they never bring to pass but that they must needs drink bloody drink.
They are to bee demaunded also which affirme that the bloud of the Lord is present in this sacrament, for what cause or vnder what colour they dare name that their sacrifice an vnbloudie sacrifice as they terme it. Surely if they will haue the bloud of the Lorde flowing from the Lordes side to be receiued in their Cuppe as Chrysostome said, by an excessiue kind of speech, let them indeuour the same as much as they will, as they knowe and as they can: yet shall they neuer bring to passe but that they must needes drinke bloudie drinke.
Truly such is the nature of things repugnant as they can never be affirmed both at once, that is, at the self same time of one and the self same sacrament. Wherefore the body of Christ cannot be together and at one time both above and beneath, visible and invisible, one and many, mortal and immortal, broken and whole. This reason have not we feigned to our selves, but we have taken it from Christ, from the Angels, from the Apostles, from the fathers, and from nature it self. For all these do testify that this cannot be all at once. Moreover it were too long to rehearse in how many places and writings of the fathers they have affirmed this absence of the Lord according to the flesh.
Truely such is the nature of things repugnant as they can neuer be affirmed both at once, that is, at the selfe same time of one and the selfe same sacrament. Wherefore the bodie of Christ cannot be together and at one time both aboue and beneath, visible and inuisible, one and many, mortall and immortall, broken and whole. This reason haue not we feined to our selues, but we haue taken it from Christ, from the Angels, from the Apostles, from the fathers, and from nature it selfe. For all these doe testifie that this cannot be all at once. Moreouer it were too long to rehearse in how many places and writinges of the fathers they haue affirmed this absence of the Lord according to the flesh.
As though forsooth this presence of the flesh and blood of the Lord, boasted of and defended by these men in the Eucharist, can, while the same is performed, bring any other profit than we have by a spiritual receiving, which (as we have said) is performed by faith and by the mind.
As though forsooth this presence of the flesh and bloud of the Lord, boasted of and defended by these men in the Eucharist, can, while the same is performed, bring any other profit thā we haue by a spirituall receauing, which (as we haue sayd) is performed by faith and by the minde.
This finally we demand of our adversaries, whether they judge that there is the body of the Lord in the bread without blood, and whether there is blood in the wine without the body? If they say, there is, they divide the humane nature by the two parts of the mystery, which cannot be committed without impiety, since the blood & body and humane nature of Christ are united by a perpetual conjunction. But if they will say that these things be together, and will feign those strange Concomitancies of theirs, this at the leastwise they cannot escape but that they shall double the body of Christ, to wit, wholly under the wine, and wholly under the bread, appointing the same (as they will have it) under their Accidents.
This finally we demaund of our aduersaries, whether they iudge that there is the bodie of the Lord in the bread without bloud, and whether there is bloud in the wine without the bodie? If they say, there is, they diuide the humane nature by the two partes of ye mysterie, which cannot be committed without impietie, since the bloud & bodie and humane nature of Christ are vnited by a perpetuall coniunction. But if they will say yt these thinges bee together, and will feigne those strāge Concomitancies of theirs, this at the leastwise they cannot escape but that they shal double ye bodie of Christ, to wit, wholy vnder the wine, and wholy vnder the bread, appointing the same (as they will haue it) vnder their Accidentes.
Lastly there happeneth unto the words of Christ less than is pronounced by them in the parts of the Sacrament, since they affirm the bread to be the body alone, and the wine to be the blood alone.
Lastly there happeneth vnto the wordes of Christ lesse than is pronounced by them in the partes of the Sacrament, since they affirme the bread to be the bodie alone, and the wine to be the bloud alone.
These be the principal and chief points which are contained in my book of confession against Gardiner, as far as concern the Arguments and confirmations of our part. And now this remaineth, that I lay before the courteous reader some sayings, as it were certain sentences, out of the which not only all our Arguments in a manner are drawn, but whereby also the reasons of our adversaries may easily be confuted. And so all this disputation will become both plain and easy.
These be the principall and chiefe poyntes which are contained in my booke of confession against Gardiner, as farre as concerne the Arguments and confirmations of our part. And now this remaineth, that I lay before the courteous reader some sayinges, as it were certaine sentences, out of the which not onelie all our Argumentes in a manner are drawen, but whereby also the reasons of our aduersaries may easilie be confuted. And so all this disputation will become both plaine and easie.