5 1Cyprian in his second Book, and 3. Epistle earnestly affirmeth that in this Sacrament of the Eucharist, we must by no means vary from the institution of Christ. And there when he entreateth at large of this matter, he setteth down these special points, namely: That Christ in this matter must be heard: further that we ought not to regard what others have done before us, but what Christ did before all. Moreover, he that doth not as he did, doth in vain worship God with the commandments and doctrines of men. And such precepts of the Sacrament he maketh not light, but saith they be great. And the same Martyr in an Epistle to Pompeius against Stephen Bishop of the City of Rome, writeth: Where any doubt is, we must always resort to the Tradition of the Lord, to the Gospel and the Apostles. The adversaries say, that Cyprian speaketh not of this which we now entreat of. He disputed against the heretics called Aquarij, 2who used not wine unto the cup of the Lord but water. This (say they) he reproved, and not the taking away of a part of the Eucharist from the laity. I grant it, but I say, that these men sin more grievously against the institution of the Lord than did the Aquarij. Because they although they put water in the stead of wine, yet did they not utterly remove the other part of the sacrament. They used the selfsame words, which we speak in delivering of the Cup: only they did change the Element. But these men take away from the people both the whole Cup, and the words thereof. Further I grant the disputation of Cyprian to be particular, whereby he confuteth the Aquarij, but the Argument and reason which he useth is universal: namely that in the ⟨p. 207⟩Sacrament of the Eucharist we must not fly from the institution of the Lord. For this cause also we argue, that we as it were by hands do receive the same from him to the intent we may show, that it was not lawful to take away the cup from the Communion. They have also other subtle shifts, and they say, that Cyprian wrote these things only of them that offer, and that therefore the place serveth nothing unto Communion. But it is a wonder that these so witty men perceived not that they in times past and specially in the time of Cyprian, had no oblation that differed from the Communion. 3There was no place among them for private masses.
5 1Cyprian in his seconde Booke, and 3. Epistle earnestly affirmeth that in this Sacrament of the Eucharist, wee must by no meanes varie from the institution of Christ. And there when hee intreateth at large of this matter, he setteth downe these speciall pointes, namelie: That Christ in this matter must be heard: further that we ought not to regard what others haue doone before vs, but what Christ did before all. Moreouer, he that doth not as he did, doth in vaine worship God with the commaundements and doctrines of men. And such precepts of the Sacrament he maketh not light, but saith they be great. And the same Martyr in an Epistle to Pompeius against Stephen Bishop of the Citie of Rome, writeth: Where any doubt is, we must alwais resort to the Tradition of the Lord, to the Gospell and the Apostles. The aduersaries say, that Cyprian speaketh not of this which we nowe intreate of. He disputed against the heretiks called Aquarij, 2who vsed not wine vnto the cuppe of the Lord but water. This (say they) he reprooued, and not the taking away of a part of the Eucharist from the laitie. I graunt it, but I say, that these men sinne more gréeuously against the institutiō of the Lord than did the Aquarij. Because they although they put water in the stead of wine, yet did they not vtterly remooue the other part of the sacrament. They vsed the selfsame wordes, which we speake in deliuering of the Cup: onely they did change the Element. But these men take awaie from the people both the whole Cup, and the wordes thereof. Further I graunt the disputation of Cyprian to be particular, whereby he confuteth the Aquarij, but the Argument and reason which he vseth is vniuersall: namely that in the ⟨p. 207⟩Sacrament of the Eucharist wee must not flie from the institution of the Lord. For this cause also we argue, that we as it were by handes doe receaue the same from him to the intent we may shewe, that it was not lawfull to take away the cup from the Communion. They haue also other subtill shifts, and they say, that Cyprian wrote these things onelie of them that offer, and that therefore the place serueth nothing vnto Communion. But it is a wonder that these so wittie men perceiued not that they in times past and speciallie in the time of Cyprian, had no oblation that differed from the Cōmunion. 3There was no place among them for priuate masses.
- 1Cyprian.
- 2The Aquarij.
- 3Private Masses.Priuate Masses.