D. Martyr. Whereas you affirm that the body of Christ is received with the mouth, that is repugnant unto that which you hold; for you say, that the body of Christ in the Eucharist is not of quantity; and the action or receiving of our mouth, seeing it is natural, is not extended unto spiritual substance: and you shall never be able to show any other thing to be received with the mouth, but the signs. As touching the truth of the sacrament and faith of God, I know it is a true sacrament, although we do not believe. And yet that proveth not, but that he, which is void of faith, hath some other thing than the sacrament, that is, the sign or the elements. And what is to eat Christ, 1Cyprian declared in his sermon De coena Domini, when he saith; That we might know that our eating is our dwelling in Christ, & our drinking is a kind of incorporating [into him.] Again; Wherefore the eating of this flesh, is a certain greediness, and as it were a certain desire of dwelling in him. And again; Look what food is to the flesh, that same is faith unto the soul: what meat is to the body, that same is the word to the spirit. And yet again; These things so often as we do, we sharpen not our teeth unto biting, but with a sincere faith, we break and divide the holy bread. Also Augustine, in his 21. book De civitate Dei, the 25. chapter, saith; And therefore, these must neither be said to eat the body of ⟨p. 209⟩Christ, because also they must not be accounted among the members of Christ, and (to forbear the rest) They cannot be together the members of Christ, 2and the members of an harlot. Finally, insomuch as he saith; He that eateth my flesh, 3and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me, and I in him, it showeth what is To eat, not sacramentally, but verily the body of Christ, and to drink his blood, that is he to dwell in Christ, and that Christ should dwell in him. For he so spake this, as if he should have said; He that dwelleth not in me, and he in whom I dwell not, let him not say or esteem of himself, that he eateth my body, or drinketh my blood. And in another place he saith; that To drink signifieth as much, as to live. Again; Why preparest thou thy belly, and thy teeth? Believe, and thou hast eaten. Which matters sith they agree not to the wicked, they cannot be said to eat the body of Christ.
D. Martyr. Whereas you affirme that the bodie of Christ is receiued with the mouth, that is repugnant vnto that which you hold; for you saie, that the bodie of Christ in the Eucharist is not of quantitie; and the action or receiuing of our mouth, séeing it is naturall, is not extended vnto spirituall substance: and you shall neuer be able to shew anie other thing to be receiued with the mouth, but the signes. As touching the truth of the sacrament and faith of God, I knowe it is a true sacrament, although we doo not beléeue. And yet that prooueth not, but that he, which is void of faith, hath some other thing than the sacrament, that is, the signe or the elements. And what is to eate Christ, 1Cyprian declared in his sermon De coena Domini, when he saith; That we might knowe that our eating is our dwelling in Christ, & our drinking is a kind of incorporating [into him.] Againe; Wherefore the eating of this flesh, is a certeine gréedinesse, and as it were a certeine desire of dwelling in him. And againe; Looke what food is to the flesh, that same is faith vnto the soule: what meate is to the bodie, that same is the word to the spirit. And yet againe; These things so often as we doo, we sharpen not our téeth vnto biting, but with a sincere faith, we breake and diuide the holie bread. Also Augustine, in his 21. booke De ciuitate Dei, the 25. chapter, saith; And therefore, these must neither be said to eate the bodie of ⟨p. 209⟩Christ, bicause also they must not be accounted among the members of Christ, and (to forbeare the rest) They cannot be togither the members of Christ, 2and the members of an harlot. Finallie, insomuch as he saith; He that eateth my flesh, 3and drinketh my bloud, dwelleth in me, and I in him, it sheweth what is To eate, not sacramentallie, but verelie the bodie of Christ, and to drinke his bloud, that is he to dwell in Christ, and that Christ should dwell in him. For he so spake this, as if he should haue said; He that dwelleth not in me, and he in whom I dwell not, let him not saie or estéeme of himselfe, that he eateth my bodie, or drinketh my bloud. And in another place he saith; that To drinke signifieth as much, as to liue. Againe; Whie preparest thou thy bellie, and thy téeth? Beléeue, and thou hast eaten. Which matters sith they agree not to the wicked, they cannot be said to eate the bodie of Christ.
- 1What is to eat Christ.What is to eate Christ.
- 21. Cor. 6.
- 3John 6, 56.Iohn 6, 56.