The disputation of the second day, which was the 29. day of May, between D. Peter Martyr, and D. William Chadse.The disputation of the second day, which was the 29. daie of Maie, betweene D. Peter Martyr, and D. William Chadse.
pp. 193–209132 passagespart 3 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
D. Martyr. So do you interpret & expound him; and in the mean time you answer nothing for the liberty and the licence that you take, in the turning of these relatives to your own purpose. But I return to the chief point of the argument, wherein I said, that one and the same body of Christ doth not sustain at one and the self-same time, so contrary qualities as is passible and impassible: and you fled unto divers respects. But how much that availeth in this question of the body of Christ, hear what Vigilius saith in his fourth book against Eutyches; Because that one nature alone receiveth not in it self any thing that is contrary or diverse. But diverse it is, and far unlike, to be bounded within a place, and to be every-where: for the word is every-where, but the flesh thereof is not every-where: Thus you see that this most learned father denieth, that it can agree with one only nature to be limited within a place, and not to be limited. Wherefore the one of these things he will have to be attributed unto the Godhead, and the other to the manhood, because the nature of man is not capable of both. But if we should give you place for your divers respects, it was unprofitably spoken of him. For some man would object unto him; The humane nature of Christ is in one respect limited, as you do say; namely, as it is in it self; but as it is in the Eucharist, it is without limitation. Howbeit, because to be within limit & without limitation, even as to be passible and impassible, be absolute qualities, therefore in what respect soever you speak, one and the self-same body cannot bear both conditions together at one time.
D. Martyr. So doo you interpret & expound him; and in the meane time you answer nothing for the libertie and the licence that you take, in the turning of these relatiues to your owne purpose. But I returne to the chéefe point of the argument, wherein I said, that one and the same bodie of Christ dooth not susteine at one and the selfe-same time, so contrarie qualities as is passible and impassible: and you fled vnto diuers respects. But how much that auaileth in this question of the bodie of Christ, heare what Vigilius saith in his fourth booke against Eutyches; Bicause that one nature alone receiueth not in it selfe anie thing that is contrarie or diuerse. But diuerse it is, and farre vnlike, to be bounded within a place, and to be euery-where: for the word is euerie-where, but the flesh therof is not euerie-where: Thus you sée that this most learned father denieth, that it can agrée with one onelie nature to be limited within a place, and not to be limited. Wherefore the one of these things he will haue to be attributed vnto the Godhead, and the other to the manhood, bicause the nature of man is not capeable of both. But if we should giue you place for your diuers respects, it was vnprofitablie spoken of him. For some man would obiect vnto him; The humane nature of Christ is in one respect limited, as you doo saie; namelie, as it is in it selfe; but as it is in the Eucharist, it is without limitation. Howbeit, bicause to be within limit & without limitation, euen as to be passible and impassible, be absolute qualities, therefore in what respect soeuer you speake, one and the selfe-same bodie cannot beare both conditions togither at one time.