A18080:898
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Here all shifts / and colours failing him / and not being once 1able to lift at this reason: he hath changed my argument. For ⟨p. CCCCLV⟩where I had said it forth in a plain hypothetical Syllogism: he hath altered it. But I will offer it him again, if under Saint Pauls Pastor the archbishop be comprehended, then he is necessary, and commanded by the word off God: but you say he is comprehended: therefore he is commanded and necessary. Which if it be true: then you are fallen from your distinction / of things necessary to salvation / and not necessary / off things arbitrary / and commanded by the word off God. But let us see now you have prepared the argument after your own fashion / and as you thought you could weld it / how you deal with it. You say first this proposition (Pastors are necessary at all times) is particular. verily the masters / by whom this should be judged / never taught that an indefinite proposition in a necessary matter / is particular. But because you like not the form which I used / you shall have it after your own in this sort. All S. Pauls Pastors are necessary: the Archbishop (as you say) is one off S. Pauls Pastors: therefore he is necessary. Here if you deny the first proposition: you have the whole council / and Senate almost of learned men against you: affirming that those two / Pastor / and Doctor / are amongest the rest perpetual offices. And if to be a perpetual office be verified off the Pastor / which S Paul speaketh of: then it must be verified off all contained underneath / amongest whom you say the Archbishop is. Secondly the Archbishop being made one off the gifts / which our Saviour ascending sent unto his church: if it were in the power off the church ether to establish / or not to establish him: it should be in her power to refuse the gifts off Christ. which if it be absurd: that also must be whereof this followeth. Thirdly if the Archbishop be necessary at any time (which must needs be if he be comprehended under S. Pauls Pastor): then goeth to the ground his con men refuge / that his office may be instituted / or not / at the churches vvill.
Here all shiftes / and coulors failing him / and not being once 1able to lift at this reason: he hath chaunged my argument. For ⟨p. CCCCLV⟩