A18080:911
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Likewise where he saith this word (only) is not to be found in the second proposition: He should have understanded / that it is a part off the principal extremes / and therefore could not enter there. It is his great want / that he can not know one term / from another / onles they stand in their natural order. for because he saw not thes words (only are sufficient) in the natural place off the extreme / as one that had no mark to discern the master from the man / but by going before and behind / he taketh one for another. When S. John saith in the beginning was the word, and by and by after / God was that word, with many such examples both in holy / and profane writ: those that have but a little judgement can tell / that although he changed the natural order / yet those are still the first parts / which are put in the later place: and that it is as much as if he had said / The word was in the beginning, and the vorde was God. This is therefore the argument, which in the Ans. sight hath no manner off form. Those functions which have all gifts needful / ether for the ministering off the word / and Sacraments / or for the government off the church / only are sufficient: the functions reckoned up off Saint Paul in both the places / to the Ephes and Corinth. have all gifts needful / ether for ministering off the word / and Sacraments / or for government of the church: therefore those functions only are sufficient. Let the reader therefore judge / whether this argument be like unto thes sweepings / that he hath matched it with. That an archbishop is a 1new ministry / is declared. Where he saith if no man appoint new offices, but he which can give gifts to discharge them, it should follow, that no man might appoint offices: if he understand as he ought to do ecclesiastical offices / it is that I maintain. if he leap over here (as his custom is) to civill: I have showed that the reason is not like.
Likewise where he saith this worde (onely) is not to be founde in the seconde proposition: He shoulde haue vnderstanded / that it is a parte off the principall extremes / and therfore coulde not enter there. It ys his greate wante / that he can not knowe one terme / from another / onles they stande in their naturall order. for becawse he saw not thes wordes (onely are sufficiente) in the naturall place off the extreme / as one that had no marke to discerne the master from the man / but by going before and behinde / he takethe one for another. When S. Iohn saithe in the beginning vvas the vvorde, and by and by after / God vvas that vvorde, with many such examples both in holie / and prophane writ: those that haue but a litle iudgement can tell / that althowgh he chaunged the naturall order / yet those are still the fyrste partes / which are put in the later place: and that it ys asmuch as if he had said / The vvorde vvas in the beginning, and the vorde vvas God. This is therfore the argumente, which in the Ans. sight hath no manner off forme. Those functions which haue all giftes needefull / ether for the ministring off the worde / and Sacramentes / or for the gouernemente off the churche / onely are sufficient: the functions reckened vp off Saint Paul in bothe the places / to the Ephes and Corinth. haue all giftes needefull / ether for ministring off the word / and Sacramentes / or for gouernement of the churche: therfore those functions onely are sufficient. Let the reader therfore iudge / whether this argument be like vnto thes sweepinges / that he hath matched it with. That an archbishop is a