A18080:952
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Where have I refused ambrose for an historical witness? pertaineth this to the story / whether an Archbishop be profitable for 1the church / or no? whether he were or no / pertaineth: but whether meet / or unmeet / is without the bounds off story. You had set down that Ambrose allowed of an Archbishop: provoked by me / you can not show off his allowance. And yet because you put me in remembrance off the story witness / when I considered that nether the rest of his writings / nor other writers off the same auncientie / and quarters / as Jerome / and Augustine / mention an Archbishop: it made me suspect greatly / that there was corruption in that place. After seeing how proudly / and swellingly he speaketh off bishops / and how basely off kings / saying the bishops are gold, and kings in comparison off them but lead, and kings must put their necks under the knees of the bishops, and kiss their right hand (which speeches are •a• unlike Ambrose stile of kings): considering also that Erasm. nippeth that book in the head / I assure my self that it is a false Ambrose / and therefore that testimony to be of no force. Wherein I am yet further confirmed by Ambrose own testimony / who saying it is comely, that there ⟨p. CCCCXCII⟩2should be equality in the churches: which taketh away bishops dominion. For seeing that can not be understanded off the whole company of the church: it is manifest that it must be restrained unto the ministers thereof. and saving this advantage / I answer to the next divis. that it shall appear after how strange the name off the Archbishop was at that time.
Where haue I refused ambrose for an historicall witnes? perteineth this to the story / whether an Archbishop be profitable for 1the church / or no? whether he were or no / perteineth: but whether meet / or vnmeet / is vvithowt the boundes off story. Yow had set downe that Ambrose alowed of an Archbishop: prouoked by me / you can not shew off his allowance. And yet becawse yow put me in remembrance off the story vvitnes / whē I considered that nether the reste of his writinges / nor other writers off the same auncientie / and quarters / as Ierome / and Augustine / mention an Archbishop: yt made me suspecte greatly / that there was corruption in that place. After seing howe proudly / and swellingly he speaketh off bishops / and howe basely off kinges / saying the bishops are gold, and kinges in comparison off them but lead, and kinges muste put their nekes vnder the knees of the bishops, and kisse their right hād (which speaches are a vnlike Ambrose stile of kinges): considering also that Erasm. nippeth that booke in the head / I assure my selfe that yt is a false Ambrose / ād therfore that testimonie to be of no force. Wherin I am yet further cōfirmed by Ambrose owne testimonie / who saying it is comely, that there