A18081:545
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Where he taketh for granted by me, that some of the Apostles used a several apparel: he is to light handed, in taking that, which I never gave. For, when as in speaking of the Prophets, Apostles, and our Saviour Christ, I confess that some of them had a peculiar garment: it is manifest, upon my discourse, that I meant the Prophets only, which were extraordinarily raised. And so far I will grant, his conclusion: otherwise, if some only of the Apostles had a special garment, how could that be a mark of his ministry, when the rest of the Apostles, which were fellows in the same ministry, had not? And therefore, I marvel, how you dare press S. Johns thin plate upon his head: seeing that Eusebius, noteth that of him as a singular attire, from other the Apostles: whereas, if it had been a mark, of the ministry of his Apostleship, other Apostles, should have had the like. If it had been a mark of his Archbishopric (whereunto, from the hall to the kitchen, you use sometime to promote him) then all the other supposed Archbishops, did wear the same: which is, as far from Eusebius mind, as the other. So, your conclusion, that if some of the Apostles had a several apparel, therefore all the ministers may have such a note of their ministry, is to bad: it rather argueth, the clean contrary: that, for so much as the Apostles leaving nothing undone, which might make for the furtherance of their ministry, differed amongest them selves in the form of apparel, one wearing a leaf of his head, the rest wearing no such thing: that therefore, it pertaineth not ⟨p. 247⟩to the furtherance of the ministry, that all should be enjoined, to wear one form of apparel.
Vuhere he taketh for graunted by me, that some of the Apostles vsed a seueral apparel: he is to light handed, in taking that, which I neuer gaue. For, when as in speaking of the Prophetes, Apostles, and our Sauiour Christ, I confes that some of them had a peculiar garment: yt is manifest, vpon my discours, that I meant the Prophetes onely, which were extraordinarily raysed. And so far I wil graunt, his conclusion: otherwise, yf some onely of the Apostles had a special garment, how could that be a mark of his ministery, when the rest of the Apostles, which were fellowes in the same ministery, had not? And therefore, I meruail, how yow dare pres S. Iohns thin plate vpon his head: seing that Eusebius, noteth that of hym as a singuler attire, from other the Apostles: whereas, if yt had bene a mark, of the ministery of his Apostleship, other Apostles, should haue had the like. Yf yt had bene a mark of his Archbishoprik (whereunto, from the hal to the kytchin, yow vse sometyme to promote hym) then al the other supposed Archbishopes, did wear the same: which is, as far from Eusebius minde, as the other. So, your conclusion, that if some of the Apostles had a seueral apparel, therefore al the ministers may haue such a note of their ministery, is to bad: yt rather argueth, the clean contrary: that, for so much as the Apostles leauing nothing vndoen, which might make for the furtherance of their ministery, differed amongest them selues in the form of apparel, one wearing a leaf of his head, the rest wearing no such thing: that therefore, yt pertayneth not