A19563:1588
An answerAn aunsvvere
An answer by the Reverend Father in God Thomas Archbishop of Canterbury, primate of all England and metropolitan, unto a crafty and sophistical cavillation, devised by Stephen Gardiner Doctor of Law, late Bishop of Winchester against the true and godly doctrine of the most holy sacrament, of the body and blood of our saviour Jesus Christ Wherein is also, as occasion serveth, answered such places of the book of Doct. Richard Smith, as may seem any thing worthy the answering. Here is also the true copy of the book written, and in open court delivered, by D. Stephen Gardiner ...An aunsvvere by the Reuerend Father in God Thomas Archbyshop of Canterbury, primate of all England and metropolitane, vnto a craftie and sophisticall cauillation, deuised by Stephen Gardiner Doctour of Law, late Byshop of Winchester agaynst the true and godly doctrine of the most holy sacrament, of the body and bloud of our sauiour Iesu Christ Wherein is also, as occasion serueth, aunswered such places of the booke of Doct. Richard Smith, as may seeme any thyng worthy the aunsweryng. Here is also the true copy of the booke written, and in open court deliuered, by D. Stephen Gardiner ...
London: printed by John Daye, 1580London: printed by Iohn Daye, 1580
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But other shift have you none to defend your Transubstantiation, but to devise such monstrous kinds of speeches, as never was heard of before. ⟨p. 277⟩For you say, that the nature, matter and substance of bread and wine remain not, but be changed into the body and blood of Christ: the old writers say directly contrary, that the nature, matter and substance remain. Christ (saith Theodoret) called bread and wine his body and blood,1 and yet changed not their natures. And again he saith, The bread and wine after the consecration lose not their proper nature, but keep their former substance, form and figure which they had before. And Origene saith that the matter of bread availeth nothing,2 but as concerning the material part thereof, it goeth down into the belly, and is avoided downward. And Gelasius saith,3 that the nature and substance of bread and wine cease not to be. Now seeing that your doctrine (who teach that the nature matter and substance of bread and wine be changed and remain not) is as clean contrary to these old writers, with many other, as black is contrary to white, and light to darkness, You have no remedy to defend your error and wilful opinion, but to imagine such portentous and wonderful kinds of speeches to be spoken by these authors, as never were uttered before by no man, that is to say, that the outward appearance and accidences of any thing, should be called the nature, matter and substance thereof. But such monsters had you rather bring forth, then you would in one jot relent in your error once by you uttered, and undertaken by you defended. And yet bring you nothing for the proof of your saying, but that if the authors words should be understand as they be spoken, this should follow thereof, that bread and wine should be seen and felt, which as no man doubteth of, but all men take it for a most certain truth, so you take it for a great inconvenience and absurdity. So far be you forced in this matter to vary in speech and judgement from the sentence and opinion of all men.
But other shift haue you none to defend your Transubstantiation, but to deuise such monstrous kindes of speaches, as neuer was heard of before.