Canterbury.Caunterbury.
pp. 274–27921 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Canterbury.
Caunterbury.
AS in your answer to the iii. chapter of my book you have done §1nothing but dallied and trifled, even so do you likewise in the iiii. Chapter, and yet far more unseemly then in the third. For doth it become a christen Bishop, of a matter of religion and a principal article of our faith to make a matter of bread and cheese? And of the holy supper of the Lord to make a resemblance of a dinner of hogs flesh? And yet for persuasion of your purpose, you make (as it were) a play in a dialogue, between a rude man and a learned scholar,1 wherein the matter is so learnedly handled that the simple rude man showeth himself to have more knowledge, then both you and your learned scholar. And why you should bring in this matter I know not, except it be to show your ignorance, to be as great in logic and philosophy,2 as it is in divinity. For what an ignorance is this, to say that a man can know no difference between one substance and an other, and that substances be not judged by any senses? And that all natural things be of these .ii. parts, of substances and accidents: and that their accidents be part of their substances, and be called their substances, their natures, and matters? Was there ever any such learning uttered before this time? May not all men now evidently perceive, unto what a straight your error hath driven you, that you have none other defence, but to fly to such absurdities, as be against the judgement of the whole world? Would you make men believe, that they know not the substance of the bread from drink, nor of chalk from cheese? Would you lead the world into this error, that Christ was never indeed seen, heard nor felt, when he walked here with his apostles? Did he not prove the truth of his very flesh and bones by sight? saying, A spirit hath not flesh and bones as you see me have?3 And although substances be not seen and known to our senses, but by their accidents, yet be they indeed known, and properly known, and truly known by their accidents, and more properly seen then their accidents be. For the accidents be rather the means to know the substance by, then the things that be known. Is not wine known from bear by the taste, and mustard from sugar? Is not one man known by his voice from another? And a shawm from a drum? And is not a man discerned from a beast, and one from an other by sight?