Divine. I answer, First there is no ground at all in Scripture for such a distinction, for the Scripture holds not out one form of Church-government, for times of persecution, another for times of peace. But rather one form to be perpetual and continued, till the second coming of Jesus Christ. Rev. 2.24, 25. That which ye• have already, hold fast till I come. So 1. Tim. 6.14. before cited, and the like. 2. Chrysostom Hom. 12. in 1. Cor. doth show diverse sins for which the best Law-givers had appointed no punishment. And where there are Christian Magistrates, yet there are no Laws nor civill punishments for somethings which must needs fall within the compass of Church-discipline, such as ignorance of God, neglect of family worship, living in malice, or envy, &c. 3. And though the civill or municipal Laws should reach to all offences which are supposed to fall under the verge of Church-discipline, yet there is still a necessary use of both. For instance, a Traitor, or a Murderer being excommunicated by the Church, is by the blessing of God gained to true repentance, humiliation, and confession, whereupon he is loosed and remitted, and again received into the bosom of the Church: nevertheless the civill sword falleth upon him; were he never so penitent, shall such a one either escape the civill sword because reconciled to the Church, or shall he after God hath given him mercy, and a great measure of repentance, die under the dreadful sentence of excommunication, because Justice must be done by the Magistrate. There is no way of avoiding great inconveniences on both sides, but by holding the necessary ⟨p. 18⟩distinct uses both of the sword of the Magistrate, and censures of the Church. 4. And when they are most coincident, it is but materially or objectively, not formally: one and the same man must be civilly punished, because justice and the law of the land so requireth, and that the Common wealth may be kept in Peace and Order; he must also be Ecclesiastically censured, that his soul may be humbled, that he may be filled with godly sorrow, and with shame and confusion of face, and drawn to repentance, (if possible) which the Church, not the Magistrate, driveth at.
Divine. I answer, First there is no ground at all in Scripture for such a distinction, for the Scripture holds not out one form of Church-government, for times of persecution, another for times of peace. But rather one form to bee perpetuall and continued, till the second coming of Jesus Christ. Rev. 2.24, 25. That which ye• have already, hold fast till I come. So 1. Tim. 6.14. before cited, and the like. 2. Chrysostome Hom. 12. in 1. Cor. doth shew diverse sinnes for which the best Law-givers had appointed no punishment. And where there are Christian Magistrates, yet there are no Lawes nor civill punishments for somethings which must needs fall within the compasse of Church-discipline, such as ignorance of God, neglect of family worship, living in malice, or envy, &c. 3. And though the civill or municipall Lawes should reach to all offences which are supposed to fall under the verge of Church-discipline, yet there is still a necessary use of both. For instance, a Traitor, or a Murtherer being excommunicated by the Church, is by the blessing of God gained to true repentance, humiliation, and confession, whereupon hee is loosed and remitted, and again received into the bosome of the Church: neverthelesse the civill sword falleth upon him; were hee never so penitent, shall such a one either escape the civill sword because reconciled to the Church, or shall he after God hath given him mercy, and a great measure of repentance, die under the dreadfull sentence of excommunication, because Justice must bee done by the Magistrate. There is no way of avo•ding great inconveniences on both sides, but by holding the necessary ⟨p. 18⟩distinct uses both of the sword of the Magistrate, and censures of the Church. 4. And when they are most coincident, it is but materially or objectively, not formally: one and the same man must bee civilly punished, because justice and the law of the land so requireth, and that the Common wealth may bee kept in Peace and Order; he must also bee Ecclesiastically censured, that his soule may be humbled, that hee may bee filled with godly sorrow, and with shame and confusion of face, and drawn to repentance, (if possible) which the Church, not the Magistrate, driveth at.