A42764:42
A late dialogue betwixt a civilian and a divine concerning the present condition of…
A late dialogue betwixt a civilian and a divine concerning the present condition of the Church of England in which, among other particulars, these following are especially spoken of ...
London: printed for Robert Bostock, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Civilian. I have heard it asserted by some learned men, that among the Jews, there was no government nor discipline in the Church distinct from the government of the State, yea, that there was no such distinction as Church and State, but that the Jewish Church was the Jewish State, and the Jewish State the Jewish Church; and if it was so among them (whose forms you take in many particulars for patterns) I would fain know why it may not be so among us.
Civilian. I have heard it asserted by some learned men, that among the Jewes, there was no government nor discipline in the Church distinct from the government of the State, yea, that there was no such distinction as Church and State, but that the Jewish Church was the Jewish State, and the Jewish State the Jewish Church; and if it was so among them (whose formes you take in many particulars for patterns) I would fain know why it may not be so among us.
Divine. Though the Jewish Church and Common wealth were for the most part not different materially, the same men being members of both, even as in all Christian Republics, yet they were formally different one from another, in regard of distinct Acts, Laws, Courts, Officers, Censures, and Administrations. For, 1. The Ceremonial law given was given to them as a Church, the Judicial law given to them as a State. 2. They did not worship, do sacrifice, pray, praise, &c. as a State; nor did they kill malefactors with the sword as a Church. 3. As the Lords matters and the Kings matters were distinguished, ⟨p. 19⟩so there were two different Courts for judging of the one and the other, 2. Chron. 19.8.11. Fourthly, when the Romans took away the Jewish State and Civill government, yet their Church did remain. 5. The government of the State and the constitution thereof was not the same under the Judges, under the Kings, and after the captivity: shall we therefore say that the Church was altered and new moulded, as oft as the Civill government was changed.1