A42764:59
A late dialogue betwixt a civilian and a divine concerning the present condition of…
A late dialogue betwixt a civilian and a divine concerning the present condition of the Church of England in which, among other particulars, these following are especially spoken of ...
London: printed for Robert Bostock, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Civilian. But tell me now your opinion of another matter, and that is concerning liberty of Conscience, and toleration of Heretics and Sectaries for which there are so many books written of late, and so few against i• ▪ I do not know what you will pronounce of it, from the Principles of your Profession, but I believe, that as in Germany, France, Holland, Poland, yea under the Turkish Tyranny, contrary religions, and opposite professions and practises, have been, and are tolerated upon State-principles, so it shall be Englands unhappiness, though not to chose, yet to be necessitated to grant such a toleration, for avoiding a rupture in the Kingdom, ⟨p. 31⟩and for preserving an Union against the common Enenmy.
Civilian. But tell me now your opinion of another matter, and that is concerning liberty of Conscience, and toleration of Hereticks and Se•taries for which there are so many bookes written of late, and so few against i• ▪ I doe not know what you will pronounce of it, from the Principles of your Profession, but I beleeve, that as in Germany, France, Holland, Poland, yea under the Turkish Tyranny, contrary religions, and opposite professions and practises, have been, and are tolerated upon State-principles, so it shall be Englands unhappinesse, though not to chose, yet to be necessitated to grant such a tolleration, for avoiding a rupture in the Kingdome, ⟨p. 31⟩and for preserving an Union against the common Enenmy.
Divine. This Question about the Toleration of those whose way is different from the common rule which shall be established, must be both stated and resolved, cum •rano salis. We must remember to distinguish person from Corporations or Churches, and both these from errors. Again, to distingu sh persons, whther godly and gracious, or loose and libertine, whether moderate and peaceable, or actious and turbulent; whether such as have deserved well o the public, or such as have done either no service or a disservice. To distinguish Corporation, whether the Question be of such only as have a present existence, or of all who shall join to such a way afterward. To distinguish errrs, whether Practical or Doctrinal only whether fundamental, or circafundamentall, or neither of the two. To distinguish Toleration, whether absolute, or Hypothetical and conditional, whether any where, or in some few certain places only, whether indefinite and general, or limited and bounded, and if bounded, how far and how much: Whether uch Toleration as may stand with the solemn league and Covenant, or such as is inconsistent therewith; whether such as is profitable for the public peace, or such as is apparently destructive thereto. These and the like particulars I do not intend to fall upon at this instant. Only this I say, that to open a wide door, and to grant an unbounded liberty unto all sort of Heretics and Sectaries, (which is the thing that the good Samaritan, and John the Baptist, the blood, Tenet, and others of that kind do plead for as it is inconsistent with the solemn league and Covenant