A42764:72
A late dialogue betwixt a civilian and a divine concerning the present condition of…
A late dialogue betwixt a civilian and a divine concerning the present condition of the Church of England in which, among other particulars, these following are especially spoken of ...
London: printed for Robert Bostock, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
but it is a Popish and Prelatical usurpation, as appeareth by the British Ecclesiastical constitutions, collected by Spel••an. So that the Oxfordian missed his mark extremely when he charged it upon Presbyterians, who hold that Ministers are as much subject unto, and as punishable by the Magistrate, as any other of the Subjects. And as Ministers are subject to every ordinance of man, so we suppose the Christian Magistrate will not take it ill to be subject to all the ordinances of Jesus Christ, I shall give you a short but ⟨p. 41⟩clear account of our judgement concerning both these, in the words of the second book of the Discipline of the Church of Scotland, Chap. 1. As Ministers are subject to the judgement and punishment of the Magistrate in external things, if they offend: so ought the Magistrates to submit themselves to the Discipline of the Church, if they transgress in matters of Conscience and Religion. And lest you should think this proper to the Classical and Synodical government: M. Cotton will tell you it is just so in the Congregational government, of the keys of the Kingdom of heaven, pag. 53. As the Church (saith he) is subject to the sword of the Magistrate in things which concern the Civill Peace: so the Magistrate (if Christian) is subject to the keys of the Church, in matters which concern the peace of his conscience, and the Kingdom of heaven. The latter cannot be denied in thesi, no more then the former: and when it comes to the Hypothesis, there is much to be trusted to the prudence and discretion of Pastors and ruling Elders; and when all comes to all, the failing is more like to be in the defect, then in the excess. But to say, that a Magistrate, because a Magistrate, is not bound in conscience to submit himself to the ordinance of Discipline, though he shed innocent blood, commit adultery, blaspheme the name of God, &c. may infer for ought I know, that a Magistrate is not bound to be subject to any of all the ordinances of Jesus Christ. It is condemned as an error in Plato, that he held it lawful for a Magistrate to make an officious lie, for the good of the Common-wealth; but not lawful for a Subject. The error of our Civilians is greater, who will have Magistrates so to rule us, that Christ shall not rule them.
but it is a Popish and Prelaticall usurpation, as appeareth by the Brittish Ecclesiasticall constitutions, collected by Spel••an. So that the Oxfordian missed his mark extreamly when he charged it upon Presbyterians, who hold that Ministers are as much subject unto, and as punishable by the Magistrate, as any other of the Subjects. And as Ministers are subject to every ordinance of man, so we suppose the Christian Magistrate will not take it ill to be subject to all the ordinances of Jesus Christ, I shall give you a short but