Therefore is this matter still most mysteriously intricate that there should be one temper and persuasion agreeing to two so vastly different sorts of persons, while yet we are to seek for a cause (except what is most tremendous to think of) from whence it should proceed, that is common to them both. And here is in short the sum of the wonder, that any, not appearing very grossly unreasonable in other matters, (which cannot be denied even of some of the more sensual and lewder sort of Atheists) should, in so plain and important a case, be so, beyond all expression, absurd. That they, without scruple, are pleased to think like other men, in matters that concern and relate to common practice, and wherein they might more colourably and with less hazard, go out of the common road. And are here only, so dangerously and madly extravagant. Theirs is therefore a particular madness, the Dementia quoad hoc. So much the stranger thing, because they whom it possesses, do only in this one case put off themselves, and are like themselves, and other men in all things else. If they reckoned it a glory to be singular they might (as hath been plainly shown) more plausibly profess it as a principle, that they are not bound to believe the existence of any secular Ruler (and consequently not be subject to any) longer than they see him, and so subvert all Policy and ⟨p. 225⟩Government; or pretend an exemption from all obligation to any act of justice, or to forbear the most injurious violence towards any man, because they are not infallibly certain any one they see is an humane wight, and so abjure all morality as they already have so great a part; than offer with so fearful hazard to assault the Deity (of whose existence if they would but think a while, they might be most infallibly assured, or go about to subvert the foundations of Religion. Or, if they would get themselves glory by great adventures, or show themselves brave men, by expressing a fearless contempt of Divine Power, and Justice. This fortitude is not humane. These are without the compass of its object. As Inundations, 1Earthquakes, &c. are said to be, unto which, that any one should fearlessly expose himself, can bring no profit to others, nor therefore glory to him.
Therefore is this matter still most mysteriously intricate that there should be one temper and perswasion agreeing to two so vastly different sorts of persons, while yet we are to seek for a cause (except what is most tremendous to think of) from whence it should proceed, that is common to them both. And here is in short the sum of the wonder, that any, not appearing very grosly unreasonable in other matters, (which cannot be deny'd even of some of the more sensual and lewder sort of Atheists) should, in so plain and important a case, be so, beyond all expression, absurd. That they, without scruple, are pleased to think like other men, in matters that concern and relate to common practice, and wherein they might more colourably and with less hazard, go out of the common road. And are here only, so dangerously and madly extravagant. Theirs is therefore a particular madness, the Dementia quoad hoc. So much the stranger thing, because they whom it possesses, do only in this one case put off themselves, and are like themselves, and other men in all things else. If they reckon'd it a glory to be singular they might (as hath been plainly shewn) more plausibly profess it as a principle, that they are not bound to believe the existence of any secular Ruler (and consequently not be subject to any) longer than they see him, and so subvert all Policy and ⟨p. 225⟩Government; or pretend an exemption from all obligation to any act of justice, or to forbear the most injurious violence towards any man, because they are not infallibly certain any one they see is an humane wight, and so abjure all morality as they already have so great a part; than offer with so fearful hazard to assault the Deity (of whose existence if they would but think a while, they might be most infallibly assured, or go about to subvert the foundations of Religion. Or, if they would get themselves glory by great adventures, or show themselves brave men, by expressing a fearless contempt of Divine Power, and Justice. This fortitude is not humane. These are without the compass of its object. As Inundations, 1Earthquakes, &c. are said to be, unto which, that any one should fearlesly expose himself, can bring no profit to others, nor therefore glory to him.
- 1Arist. Eth. l. 3.