A89568:49
The humble answer of the Divines attending the Honourable Commissioners of Parliament, at the…The humble answer of the Divines attending the Honorable Commissioners of Parliament, at the…
The humble answer of the Divines attending the Honourable Commissioners of Parliament, at the treaty at Newport in the Isle of Wight. To the second paper delivered to them by his Majesty, Octob. 6. 1648. about episcopal government. Delivered to his Majesty, October 17. I appoint Abel Roper to print this copy, entitled The humble answer of the Divines, &c. Richard Vines,The humble answer of the Divines attending the Honorable Commissioners of Parliament, at the treaty at Newport in the Isle of Wight. To the second paper delivered to them by his Majesty, Octob. 6. 1648. about episcopall government. Delivered to his Majesty, October 17. I appoint Abel Roper to print this copie, entituled The humble answer of the Divines, &c. Richard Vines,
London: printed for Abel Roper, 1648
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
We do as firmly believe (as to matter of fact) that Chrysostom and Austin were Bishops, as that Aristotle was a Philosopher, Cicero an Orator; though we should rather call out Faith and belief thereof ••rtaine in matter of fact, upon humane Testimonies uncontrolled, then infallible, in respect of the Testimonies themselves. But where is your Majesty saith, That the darkness of the History of the Church, in the time succeeding the Apostles, is a strong Argument for Episcopacy, which notwithstanding that darkness hath found so full proof by unquestioned Catalogues, as scarce any other matter of fact hath found the like: We humbly conceive, that those fore-mentioned times were dark to the Catalogue-makers, who must derive the series of Succession from, and through those Historical darknesses, and so make up their Catalogues very much from Tradition and Reports, which can give no great Evidence, because they agree not amongst themselves: and that which is the great blemish of their Evidence is, that the nearer they come to the Apostles times (wherein they should be most of all clear, to establish the succession firm and clear at first) the more doubtful, uncertain, and indeed contradictory to one another; are the Testimonies. Some say, that Clemens was first Bishop of Rome, after Peter; some say, the third: and the intricacies about the Order of Succession, in Lin•s, Anacletus, Clemens, and another called Cletus (as some affirm) are inextricable. Some say, that Titus was Bishop of Crate; some say, Arch-bishop; and some, Bishop of Dalmatia. Some say, that Timothy was Bishop of Ephesus; and some say, that John was Bishop of Ephesus at the same time. Some say, that Polycarpus was first Bishop of Smyrna: another saith, that he succeeded one B•colus; and another, that Arist• was first. Some say, that Alexandria had but one Bishop, and other Cities two; and others, that there was but one Bishop of one City at the same time. And how should those Catalogues be unquestionable, ⟨p. 34⟩which must be made up out of Testimonies that fight one with another? We confess, that the Ancient Fathers, Tertullian, Irenaus, &c. made use of Succession, as an Argument against Heretics, or Innovators, to prove that they had the traduces Apostoliei seminis, and that the Godly and Orthodox Fathers were on their side.