pp. 32–4012 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Your Majesty having in your first Paper said, that you could not in Conscience consent to Abolish Episcopal Government, because you did conceive it to be of Apostolical Institution, Practised by the Apostles themselves, and by them committed and derived to particular persons as their Successors, and have ever since till these last times bin exercised by Bishops in all the Churches of Christ: We thought it necessary in our Answer, to subjoin to that we had said out of the Scriptures, the Judgment of divers ancient •riters and Fathers, by whom Bishops were not acknowledged as a Divine, but as an Ecclesiastical Institution, as that which might very much conduce both to the easing of your Majesties scruple, to consider that howsoever Episcopal Government was generally currant, yet the superscription was not judged Divine, by some of those that either were themselves Bishops, or lived under that Government, & to the vindication of the opinion which we hold, from the prejudice of Novellisme, or of recess from the Judgement of all Antiquity.
Your Majesty having in your first Paper said, that you could not in Conscience consent to Abolish Episcopall Government, because you did conceive it to be of Apostolicall Institution, Practised by the Apostles themselves, and by them comitted and derived to particular persons as their Successors, and have ever since til these last times bin exercised by Bishops in al the Churchs of Christ: We thought it necessary in our Answer, to subjoyne to that we had said out of the Scriptures, the Iudgment of divers ancient •riters and Fathers, by whom Bishops were not acknowledged as a Divine, but as an Ecclesias•ticall Institution, as that which might very much conduce both to the easing of your Majesties scruple, to consider that howsoever Episcopal Government was generally currant, yet the superscription was not jugded Divine, by some of those that either were themselves Bishops, or lived under that Government, & to the vindication of the opinion which we hold, from the prejudice of Novellisme, or of recesse from the Iudgement of all Antiquity.
We do as firmly believe (as to matter of fact) that Chrysostom and Austin were Bishops, as that Aristotle was a Philosopher, Cicero an Orator; though we should rather call out Faith and belief thereof ••rtaine in matter of fact, upon humane Testimonies uncontrolled, then infallible, in respect of the Testimonies themselves. But where is your Majesty saith, That the darkness of the History of the Church, in the time succeeding the Apostles, is a strong Argument for Episcopacy, which notwithstanding that darkness hath found so full proof by unquestioned Catalogues, as scarce any other matter of fact hath found the like: We humbly conceive, that those fore-mentioned times were dark to the Catalogue-makers, who must derive the series of Succession from, and through those Historical darknesses, and so make up their Catalogues very much from Tradition and Reports, which can give no great Evidence, because they agree not amongst themselves: and that which is the great blemish of their Evidence is, that the nearer they come to the Apostles times (wherein they should be most of all clear, to establish the succession firm and clear at first) the more doubtful, uncertain, and indeed contradictory to one another; are the Testimonies. Some say, that Clemens was first Bishop of Rome, after Peter; some say, the third: and the intricacies about the Order of Succession, in Lin•s, Anacletus, Clemens, and another called Cletus (as some affirm) are inextricable. Some say, that Titus was Bishop of Crate; some say, Arch-bishop; and some, Bishop of Dalmatia. Some say, that Timothy was Bishop of Ephesus; and some say, that John was Bishop of Ephesus at the same time. Some say, that Polycarpus was first Bishop of Smyrna: another saith, that he succeeded one B•colus; and another, that Arist• was first. Some say, that Alexandria had but one Bishop, and other Cities two; and others, that there was but one Bishop of one City at the same time. And how should those Catalogues be unquestionable, ⟨p. 34⟩which must be made up out of Testimonies that fight one with another? We confess, that the Ancient Fathers, Tertullian, Irenaus, &c. made use of Succession, as an Argument against Heretics, or Innovators, to prove that they had the traduces Apostoliei seminis, and that the Godly and Orthodox Fathers were on their side.
We doe as firmely beleeve (as to matter of fact) that Chrysostome and Austin were Bishops, as that Aristotle was a Philosopher, Cicer• an Orator; though wee should rather call out Faith and beliefe thereof rtaine in matter of fact, upon humane Testimonies uncontrouled, then infallible, in respect of the Testimonies themselves. But where is your Majestie saith, That the darknesse of the Historie of the Church, in the time succeeding the Apostles, is a strong Argument for Episcopacie, which notwithstanding that darknesse hath found so full proofe by unquestioned Catalogues, as scarce any other matter of fact hath found the like: Wee humbly conceive, that those fore-mentioned times were darke to the Catalogue-makers, who must derive the series of Succession from, and through those Historicall darknesses, and so make up their Catalogues very much from Tradition and Reports, which can give no great Evidence, because they agree not amongst themselves: and that which is the great blemish of their Evidence is, that the neerer they come to the Apostles times (wherein they should be most of all clear, to establish the succession firm and cleare at first) the more doubtfull, uncertaine, and indeed contradictorie to one another; are the Testimonies. Some say, that Clemens was first Bishop of Rome, after Peter; some say, the third: and the intricacies about the Order of Succession, in Lins, Anacletus, Clemens, and another called Cletus (as some affirme) are inextricable. Some say, that Titus was Bishop of Crate; some say, Arch-bishop; and some, Bishop of Dalmatia. Some say, that Timothy was Bishop of Ephesus; and some say, that Iohn was Bishop of Ephesus at the same time. Some say, that Polycarpus was first Bishop of Smyrna: another saith, that he succeeded one Bcolus; and another, that Arist was first. Some say, that Alexandria had but one Bishop, and other Cities two; and others, that there was but one Bishop of one Citie at the same time. And how should those Catalogues be unquestionable,
But that which we now have in hand, is Succession in Office; which, according to the Catalogues, resolves it self into some Apostle, or Evangelist, as the first Bishop of such a City, or Place, who (as we conceive) could not be Bishops of those places, being of an higher Office; though, according to the language of after-times, they might by them that drew up the Catalogues, be so called, because they planted and founded, or watered those Churches to which they are entitled, and had their greatest residence in them; or else the Catalogues are drawn from some eminent men that were of great veneration and reverence in the times and places where they lived, and Presidents or Moderators of the Presbyteries, whereof themselves were Members: from whom, to pretend the Succession of after-Bishops, is as if it should be said, that Caesar was Successor to the Roman Consuls. And we humbly conceive, that there are some Rites and Ceremonies used continually in the Church of old, which are asserted to be found in the Apostolical and Primitive times, and yet have no colour of Divine Institution; and, which is Argument above all other, the Fathers, whose Names we exhibited to your Majesty in our Answer, were doubtless acquainted with the Catalogues of Bishops who had been before them, and yet did hold them to be of Ecclesiastical Institution.
But that which we now have in hand, is Succession in Office; which, according to the Catalogues, resolves it selfe into some Apostle, or Evangelist, as the first Bishop of such a Citie, or Place, who (as we conceive) could not be Bishops of those places, being of an higher Office; though, according to the language of after-times, they might by them that drew up the Catalogues, be so called, because they planted and founded, or watered those Churches to which they are entituled, and had their greatest residence in them; or else the Catalogues are drawne from some eminent men that were of great veneration and reverence in the times and places where they lived, and Presidents or Moderators of the Presbyteries, whereof themselves were Members: from whom, to pretend the Succession of after-Bishops, is as if it should be said, that Caesar was Successor to the Roman Consuls. And we humbly conceive, that there are some Rites and Ceremonies used continually in the Church of old, which are asserted to be found in the Apostolicall and Primitive times, and yet have no colour of Divine Institution; and, which is Argument above all other, the Fathers, whose Names wee exhibited to your Majestie in our Answer, were doubtlesse acquainted with the Catalogues of Bishops who had beene before them, and yet did hold them to be of Ecclesiasticall Institution.
And lest your Majesty might reply, That however the Testimonies and Catalogues may vary, or be mistaken, in the order, or times, or names of those persons that succeeded the Apostles, yet all agree, that there was a Succession of some persons; and so, though the credit of the ⟨p. 35⟩Catalogues be infirmed, yet the thing intended is confirmed thereby: We grant, that Succession of men to feed and govern those Churches, while they continued Churches, cannot be denied, and that the Apostles and Evangelists, that planted and watered those Churches (though extraordinary and temporary Officers) were by Ecclesiastical Writers, in compliance with the Language and usage of their own times, called Bishops; and so were other eminent men, of chief note, presiding in the Presbyteries of the Cities or Churches, called by such Writers as wrote after the division or distinction of the names of Presbyters, and Bishops: But that those first and ancientest Presbyters were Bishops in proper sense, according to your Majesties description, invested with power over Presbyters and people, to whom (as distinct from Presbyters) did belong the power of Ordaining, giving Rules and Censures; we humbly conceive can never be proved by authentic or competent Testimonies. And granting, that your Majesty should prove the Succession of Bishops from the Primitive times seriatim; yet if these from whom you draw, and through whom you derive it, be found either more then Bishops, as Apostles, and extraordinary persons, or less then Bishops, as merely first Presbyters, having not one of the three essentials to Episcopal Government (mentioned by your Majesty) in their own hand; it will follow, that all that your Majesty hath proved by this Succession, is the Homonymy and equivocal acceptation of the word Episcopus.
And lest your Majestie might reply, That however the Testimonies and Catalogues may varie, or be mistaken, in the order, or times, or names of those persons that succeeded the Apostles, yet all agree, that there was a Succession of some persons; and so, though the credit of the ⟨p. 35⟩Catalogues be infirmed, yet the thing intended is confirmed thereby: We grant, that Succession of men to feed and governe those Churches, while they continued Churches, cannot be denyed, and that the Apostles and Evangelists, that planted and watered those Churches (though extraordinarie and temporarie Officers) were by Ecclesiasticall Writers, in complyance with the Language and usage of their owne times, called Bishops; and so were other eminent men, of chiefe note, presiding in the Presbyteries of the Cities or Churches, called by such Writers as wrote after the division or distinction of the names of Presbyters, and Bishops: But that those first and ancientest Presbyters were Bishops in proper sence, according to your Majesties description, invested with power over Presbyters and people, to whom (as distinct from Presbyters) did belong the power of Ordaining, giving Rules and Censures; wee humbly conceive can never be proved by authentike or competent Testimonies. And granting, that your Majestie should prove the Succession of Bishops from the Primitive times seriatim; yet if these from whom you draw, and through whom you derive it, be found either more then Bishops, as Apostles, and extraordinarie persons, or lesse then Bishops, as meerly first Presbyters, having not one of the three essentials to Episcopall Government (mentioned by your Majestie) in their owne hand; it will follow, that all that your Majestie hath proved by this Succession, is the Homonymy and equivocall acceptation of the word Episcopus.
For Clemens his Testimony, which your Majesty conceiveth to be made use of, as our old fallacy, from the promiscuous use of the words to infer the indistinction of the things; we refer our selves to himself in his Epistle, now in all mens hands, whose Testimony we think cannot be eluded, but by the old Artifice, of hiding the Bishop under the Presbyters name: for they that have read his whole Epistle, and have considered, that himself is ⟨p. 36⟩called a Bishop, may doubt of Clemens opinion, concerning the distinct offices of Bishops and Presbyters, or rather not doubt of it, if only his one Epistle, may be impanelled upon the Inquest. Concerning Ignatius his Epistles, your Majesty is pleased to use some earnestness of expression, charging some of late, without any regard of ingenuity or truth, out of their partial disaffection to Bishops, to have endeavoured to discredit his writings. One of those cited by us, cannot (as we conceive) be suspected of disaffection to Bishops; and there are great Arguments drawn out of those Epistles themselves, betraying their insincerity, adulterate mixtures, and interpolations; So that Ignatius cannot be distinctly known in Ignatius. And if we take him in gross, we make him the Patron (as Baronious, and the rest of the Popish writers do) of such rites and observations, as the Church in his time cannot be thought to have owned. He doth indeed give testimony to the Prelacy of a Bishop above a Presbyter, that which may justly render him suspected, is that he gives too much. Honour (saith he) the Bishop as Gods high Priest, and after him you must honour the King. He was indeed a holy Martyr, and his writings have suffered Martyrdom, aswell as he; Corruptions could not go currant, but under the credit of worthy Names.
For Clemens his Testimonie, which your Majestie conceiveth to be made use of, as our old fallacie, from the promiscuous use of the words to inferre the indistinction of the things; wee referre our selves to himselfe in his Epistle, now in all mens hands, whose Testimonie wee thinke cannot be eluded, but by the old Artifice, of hiding the Bishop under the Presbyters name: for they that have read his whole Epistle, and have considered, that himselfe is ⟨p. 36⟩called a Bishop, may doubt of Clemens opinion, concerning the distinct offices of Bishops and Presbyters, or rather not doubt of it, if onely his one Epistle, may be impaneld upon the Inquest. Concerning Ignatius his Epistles, your Majesty is pleased to use some earnestnesse of expression, charging some of late, without any regard of ingenuity or truth, out of their partiall disaffection to Bishops, to have endeavoured to discredit his writings. One of those cited by us, cannot (as we conceive) be suspected of disaffection to Bishops; and there are great Arguments drawn out of those Epistles themselves, betraying their insincerity, adulterate mixtures, and interpolations; So that Ignatius cannot be distinctly known in Ignatius. And if we take him in grosse, we make him the Patron (as Baronious, and the rest of the Popish writers do) of such rites and observations, as the Church in his time cannot be thought to have owned. He doth indeed give tetimonie to the Prelacy of a Bishop above a Presbyter, that which may justly render him suspected, is that he gives too much. Honour (saith he) the Bishop as Gods high Priest, and after him you must honour the King. He was indeed a holy Martyr, and his writings have suffered Martyrdom, aswell as he; Corruptions could not go currant, but under the credit of worthy Names.
That which your Majesty saith in Your fourth Paragraph, That we might have added, (if we had pleased) That James, Timothy, Titus, &c. were constituted and ordained Bishops, of the forementioned places respectively, and that all the Bishops of those times, were reputed successors to the Apostles in their Episcopal office: We could not have added it without prejudice (as we humbly conceive) to the truth; for the Apostles did not ordain any of themselves Bishops, nor could they do it, for even by your Majesties concession, they were Bishops before, viz. as they were Apostles, nor could any Apostle his choice of a certain ⟨p. 37⟩Region or Place to exercise his function in, whilst he pleased, render him a Bishop, any more then Paul was Bishop of the Gentiles, Peter of the Circumcision. Neither did the Apostles ordain the Evangelists Bishops of those Places unto which they sent them; Nor were the Bishops of those times any more then as your Majesty saith, reputed successors to the Apostles in their Episcopal office, they came after the Apostles in the Churches by them planted, so might Presbyters do; but that's not properly succession, at least not succession into office; and this we say with a Salv• to our assertion, that in those times there were no such Bishops distinct from Presbyters: Neither do we understand, whether the words Episcopal office, in this Section, refer to the Bishops or Apostles; for in reference to Apostles, it insinuates a distinction of the Apostles office, into Apostolical and Episcopal, or that the office Apostolical, was wholly Episcopal, unto neither of which we can give our consent for reasons forementioned. To the testimonies by us recited in proof of two only Orders, Your Majesty answers first, that the promiscuous use of the names of Bishops and Presbyters, is imported; That which your Majesty not long ago called our old fallacy, is now Your answer, only with this difference, We under promiscuous names hold the same office: Your Majesty under promiscuous names supposes two, which if as it is often asserted, was but once proved▪ We should take it for a determination of this controversy. Secondly, that they relate to a School-point, or a nicety, utrum Episcopat•• sit ordo vel gradus, both sides of the questionists or disputants in the mean time acknowledging the right of Church-government in the Bishops alone;
That which your Majesty saith in Your fourth Paragraph, That we might have added, (if we had pleased) That Iames, Timothy, Titus, &c. were constituted and ordained Bishops, of the forementioned places respectively, and that all the Bishops of those times, were reputed successors to the Aposles in their Episcopall office: We could not have added it without prejudice (as we humbly conceive) to the truth; for the Apostles did not ordein any of themselves Bishops, nor could they do it, for even by your Majesties concession, they were Bishops before, viz. as they were Apostles, nor could any Apostle his choyce of a certain
It is confessed by us, that that question as it is stated by Popish Authors, is a curious nicety, to which we have no eye or reference; for though the same officers may differ from and excel others of the same order in gifts or qualifications, ⟨p. 38⟩Yet the office it self, is one and the same, without difference or degrees, as one Apostle or Presbyter, is not superior to another in degree of office; they that are of the same order are of the same degree, in respect of office, as having Power and Authority to the same Acts. Nor doth the Scripture warrant or allow, any superiority of one over another of the same order; and therefore the proving of two orders only in the Church, is a demonstration, that Presbyters and Bishops are the same. In which point, the Scripture will counter-balance the testimonies of those that assert three degrees or orders, though ten for one. But for easing of your Majesty of the trouble of producing testimonies against those cited by us, We make this humble motion, that the Regiments on both sides may be discharged out of the field, and the point disputed by Dint of holy Scripture, id verum quod primum. Having passed through the Argumentative parts of your Majesties Reply, wherein we should account it a great happiness, to have given your Majesty any satisfaction, in order whereunto You pleased to honour us with this employment, We shall contract our selves in the remainder, craving your Majesties pardon, if You shall conceive us to have been too much in the former, and too little in that which follows. We honour the Pious intentions and munificence of Your Royal Progenitors, and do acknowledge that ornamental accessions granted to the Person, do not make any substantial change in the office; the real difference between that Episcopal Government, which first obtained in the Church, and the present Hierarchy, consists in ipso regimine & modo regiminis, which cannot be clearly demonstrated in particulars, until it be agreed on both sides, what that Episcopacy was then, and what the Hierarchy is now, and then it would appear, whether these three forementioned essentials of Episcopal Government, were the same in both: For the power ⟨p. 39⟩under Christian Princes, and under Pagan, is one and the same, though the exercise be not.
It is confest by us, that that question as it is stated by Popish Authors, is a curious nicety, to which we have no eye or reference; for though the same officers may differ fromand excell others of the same order in gifts or qualifications,
And we humbly receive your Majesties Pious advertisement, (not unlike that of Constantine's) stirring us up as men unbiased with private interests, to study the nearest accommodation and best resemblance to the Apostolical and Primitive times. But for your Majesties Salve to the Bishops sole Power, of Ordination and Jurisdiction, and that distinction of Ordination, Authoritative in the Bishop, and Concomitant in the Presbytery, which You seem to found upon these two Texts, 2 Tim. 1. 6. 1 Tim. 4. 14. and which is used by D. Bilson, and other defenders of Episcopacy, in explication of that Cannon of the fourth Council of Carthage, which enjoins the joins imposition of the Bishops and Presbyters hands, We shall give your Majesty an account, when we shall be called to the disquisition thereof; Albeit that we do not for the present see, but that this Proviso of your Majesty, renders our accommodation to the Apostolical and Primitive times (where unto You did exhort us) unseasonable. We not withstanding, do fully profess our acknowledgement of subordination of the outward exercise of Jurisdiction, to the Sovereign Power, and our accountableness to the Laws of the Land. As for your Majesties three questions of great importance, Whether there be a certain form of Government left by Christ or his Apostles, to be observed by all Christian Churches; Whether it bind perpetually, or be upon occasion alterable in whole, or in part; Whether that certain form of Government, be the Episcopal, Presbyterian, or some other, differing from them both: The whole volume of Ecclesiastical Policy, is contained in them; and we hope that neither your Majesty expected of us a particular answer to them at this time, nor will take offence at us, if we hold only to that which is the question, in order to the Bill of Abolition; for we humbly profess our readiness ⟨p. 40⟩to serve your Majesty, answering these or any other questions, within our proper Cognizance, according to the proportion of our mean abilities.
And we humbly receive your Majesties Pious advertisement, (not unlike that of Constantines) stirring us up as men unbyassed with private interests, to study the neerest accommodation and best resemblance to the Apostolicall and Primitive times. But for your Majesties Salve to the Bishops sole Power, of Ordination and Iurisdiction, and that distinction of Ordination, Authoritative in the Bishop, and Concomitant in the Presbytery, which You seem to found upon these two Texts,
For your Majesties condescension, in vouchsafing us the liberty and honour of examining Your learned Reply, clothed in such excellency of stile, and for Your exceeding candour, showed to such men as we are; and for the acceptation of our humble duty, we render to your Majesty most humble thanks, and shall pray, That such a pen in the hand of such abilities, may ever be employed in a subject worthy of it.
For your Majesties condescension, in vouchsafing us the liberty and honour of examining Your learned Reply, clothed in such excellency of stile, and for Your exceeding candour, shewed to such men as we are; and for the acceptation of our humble duty, we render to your Majesty most humble thanks, and shall pray, That such a pen in the hand of such abilities, may ever be imployed in a subject worthy of it.
That your Majesty would please to consider, that in this point under debate, succession is not the best clew, and most certain, and ready way to find out the Original; for to go that way, is to go the furthest way about, yea, to go backward; and when You are at the spring, viz. the Scripture it self▪ You go to the rivers end, that You may seek the spring.
That your Majesty would please to consider, that in this point under debate, succession is not the best clew, and most certain, and ready way to finde out the Originall; for to go that way, is to go the furthest way about, yea, to go backward; and when You are at the spring, viz. the Scripture it self▪ You go to the rivers end, that You may seek the spring.
And that the Lord would guide your Majesty, and the two Houses of Parliament, by the right hand of his Council, and show You a happy way of healing our unhappy differences, and of settling the Common-wealth of Jesus Christ, which is the Church; so as all the members thereof, may live under You in all Godliness, Peace, and Honesty.
And that the Lord would guide your Majesty, and the two Houses of Parliament, by the right hand of his Councell, and shew You a happy way of healing our unhappy differences, and of settling the Common-wealth of Jesus Christ, which is the Church; so as all the members thereof, may live under You in all Godlinesse, Peace, and Honesty.