The kLicentiate followeth him in the same steppes, reproving a speech of mine, touching Cyprian. Whose praise of the Romans, that unfaithfulness cannot have access to them, being stretched by Sanders to prove that the Church of Rome cannot err: lI, having showed the contrary by scripture, did add, What? and was Cyprian of an other mind? Pardon me ô Cyprian: I would believe thee gladly, but that believing thee I should not believe the word of God. Hereon, M. Martin, to advantage his cause, first abuseth mCyprian, saying, that he affirmeth that the Church of Rome cannot err in faith. Which he affirmeth not. But whereas the Novatian heretics at Carthage had made themselves there a Bishop in schism, and to get him credit with the Church of Rome had written thither falsely, that he was allowed by five & twē tie Bishops: Cyprian, to meet with their falsehood and treachery, saith that it could not find credit with the Romans, who being faithful men would not give ear to faithless liars. Neither spake he this as though the Romans could not in deed be deceived by false reports of wicked imps; (for even there he noteth they might be 4a while, as he did try both then and 5after:) but to stir them up to beware of heretics, by praising them as wary. Wherefore he affirmeth not that the Church of Rome cannot err in faith: as M. Martin threapeth on him. Yet because he might be supposed ⟨p. 749⟩to have thought it, at least by a consequent; for if they could not err *in that, much less in faith: therefore I, contenting my self with a peremptory exception against it, said, that if he thought it, he must pardon me for not believing him, the word of God gainsaying it. And this doth M. Martin reprove, both for that whereupon I spake it, and for my kind of speech. That, whereupon I spake it, is (he saith) that every youth among us, upon confidence of his spirit, will control not only one but all the Fathers consenting together, if it be against that which we imagine to be the truth. In which words, by mentioning so all the Fathers consenting together, he bewrayeth the canker that consumed him. For I touched the credit of no more of them, then nthe Papists grant themselves may be touched. Nor controlled I ought upon confidence of my spirit, but of othe spirit of God: because it was against, not that which I imagined, but knew to be the truth.
The kLicentiate foloweth him in the same steppes, reprouing a speech of mine, touching Cyprian. Whose praise of the Romans, that vnfaithfulnesse cannot haue accesse to thē, being stretched by Sanders to proue that the Church of Rome cannot erre: lI, hauing shewed the contrarie by scripture, did adde, What? and was Cyprian of an other minde? Pardon me ô Cyprian: I would beleeue thee gladly, but that beleeuing thee I should not beleeue the word of God. Hereon, M. Martin, to aduauntage his cause, first abuseth mCyprian, saying, that he affirmeth that the Church of Rome cannot erre in faith. Which he affirmeth not. But whereas the Nouatian heretikes at Carthage had made themselues there a Bishop in schisme, and to get him credite with the Church of Rome had writen thither falsly, that he was allowed by fiue & twē tie Bishops: Cyprian, to meete with their falshood and treacherie, saith that it could not finde credit with the Romans, who being faithfull men would not giue eare to faithlesse lyers. Neither spake he this as though the Romans could not in deede be deceiued by false reportes of wicked ympes; (for euen there he noteth they might be 4a while, as hee did trie both then and 5after:) but to stirre them vp to beware of heretikes, by praising them as wary. Wherfore he affirmeth not that the Church of Rome cannot erre in faith: as M. Martin threapeth on him. Yet because he might be supposed ⟨p. 749⟩to haue thought it, at least by a consequent; for if they could not erre *in that, much lesse in faith: therefore I, contenting my selfe with a peremptorie exception against it, sayd, that if he thought it, he must pardon me for not beleeuing him, the word of God gainsaying it. And this doth M. Martin reproue, both for that wherevpon I spake it, and for my kind of speeche. That, wherevpon I spake it, is (he sayth) that euery youth among vs, vpon confidence of his spirit, will controll not onely one but all the Fathers consenting together, if it be against that which we imagine to be the truth. In which wordes, by mentioning so all the Fathers consenting together, he bewrayeth the canker that consumed him. For I touched the credite of no more of them, then
- kGreg. Martin. in the preface of his discovery.Greg. Martin. in the preface of his discouery.
- lIn my preface to the Conclusions.
- mEpist. 55. ad Co••elium.
- 4Mendacia non diu fa••unt.
- 5Basilides fesellit Stephanum. Cyprian. ••ist. 68.
- *Wherein all men grant that the Pope may •rie: even they who stay him most from erring in faith. A•n. Sil•ius Card. in ep. de mo•ibus Ger•. •urreciemata, Sanders, •ellarmin, Torrensis, and the whole nation of the Jesuits.Wherein all men graunt that the Pope may •rie: euen they who stay him most from erring in faith. A•n. Sil•ius Card. in ep. de mo•ibus Ger•. •urreciemata, Sanders, •ellarmin, Torrensis, and the whole nation of the Iesuites.
- nJo. Picus Mirand. in Apol. Alfonsus a Castr. aduer. haer. l. 1. c. 7. Canus locor. Theolog. l. 7. c. 3. Andrad. defe ns. •id. T••d. l. 2. Sixtus Sen. biblioth. sanct. lib. 5. & 6. & cae• passim.Io. Picus Mirand. in Apol. Alfonsus a Castr. aduer. haer. l. 1. c. 7. Canus locor. Theolog. l. 7. c. 3. Andrad. defe ns. •id. Td. l. 2. Sixtus Sen. biblioth. sanct. lib. 5. & 6. & cae passim.