AN ANSWER TO THE FORMER CHALLENGE.AN ANSVVER TO THE FORMER CHALLENGE.
pp. 1–527550 passagespart 10 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
So Leo, in one of his Sermons upon our Lords passion. sHe did undergo the laws of Hell by dying, but did dissolve them by rising again: and so did cut off the perpetuity of death, that of eternal he might make it temporal. So Irenaeus, having said, that our Lord gconversed three days where the dead were, addeth that ⟨p. 347⟩therein he hobserved the law of the dead, that he might be made the first begotten from the dead; staying until the third day in the lower parts of the earth, and afterward rising in his flesh. Then he draweth from thence this general conclusion. iSeeing our Lord went in the midst of the shadow of death, where the souls of the dead were, then afterward rose again corporally, and after his resurrection was assumed: it is manifest that the souls of his disciples also, for whose sake the Lord wrought these things, shall go to an invisible place appointed unto them by God, and there shall abide until the resurrection, waiting for the resurrection; and afterwards receiving their bodies, and rising again perfectly, that is to say corporally, even as our Lord did rise again, they shall so come unto the presence of God. For there is no disciple above his master: but every one shall be perfect, if he be as his master. The like collection doth Tertullian make in his book of the Soul. k
If Christ being God, because he was also man, dying according to the Scriptures, and being buried according to the same, did here also satisfy the law, by performing the course of an humane death in Hell; neither did ascend into the higher parts of the heavens, before he descended into the lower parts of the earth, that he might there make the Patriarchs and Prophets partakers of himself: thou hast, both to believe that there is a region of Hell under the earth, and to push them with the elbow, who proudly enough do not think the souls of the faithful to be fit for Hell; servants above their Lord, and disciples above their Master, scorning perhaps to take the comfort of expecting
⟨p. 348⟩
the resurrection in Abraham's bosom. And in the same book, speaking of the soul:
What is that, saith he, which is translated unto the infernal parts (or Hell) after the separation of the body? which is detained there, which is reserved unto the day of judgement, unto which Christ by dying did descend, to the souls of the Patriarchs, I think.
So Leo, in one of his Sermons upon our Lords passion. sHee did undergoe the lawes of Hell by dying, but did dissolve them by rising againe: and so did cut off the perpetuitie of death, that of eternall hee might make it temporall. So Irenaeus, having said, that our Lord gconversed three dayes where the dead were, addeth that ⟨p. 347⟩therein he hobserved the law of the dead, that hee might be made the first begotten from the dead; staying untill the third day in the lower parts of the earth, and afterward rising in his flesh. Then he draweth from thence this generall conclusion. iSeeing our Lord went in the midst of the shadow of death, vvhere the soules of the dead were, then afterward rose againe corporally, and after his resurrection was assumed: it is manifest that the soules of his disciples also, for whose sake the Lord wrought these things, shall goe to an invisible place appointed unto them by God, and there shall abide untill the resurrection, wayting for the resurrection; and afterwards receaving their bodies, and rising againe perfectly, that is to say corporally, even as our Lord did rise againe, they shall so come unto the presence of God. For there is no disciple above his master: but every one shall be perfect, if he be as his master. The like collection doth Tertullian make in his booke of the Soule. kIf Christ being God, because he was also man, dying according to the Scriptures, and being buried according to the same, did heere also satisfie the law, by performing the course of an humane death in Hell; neyther did ascend into the higher parts of the heavens, before he descended into the lower parts of the earth, that he might there make the Patriarches and Prophets partakers of himselfe: thou hast, both to beleeve that there is a region of Hell under the earth, and to push them with the elbowe, who proudly enough doe not thinke the soules of the faithfull to be fit for Hell; servants above their Lord, and disciples above their Master, scorning perhaps to take the comfort of expecting ⟨p. 348⟩the resurrection in Abrahams bosome. And in the same booke, speaking of the soule: lWhat is that, saith he, which is translated unto the infernall parts (or Hell) after the separation of the body? which is detayned there, which is reserved unto the day of judgement, unto which Christ by dying did descend, to the soules of the Patriarches, I thinke.
sLeges inferni moriendo subijt, sed resurgendo dissolvit: & ita perpetuitatem mortis incîdit, ut eam de aeternâ faceret temporalem. Leo de passion. serm. 8.
gNunc autem tribus diebus conversatus est ubi erant mortui. Irenaeus, lib. 5. cap. ult.
hDominus legem mortuorū servavit, ut fieret primogenitus á mortuis, et commoratus usque ad te•tiā diē in inferioribus terrae, pòst deinde surgens in carne, ut etiā figuras clavorū ostenderet discipulis, sic ascendit ad patrem. Ibid.Dominus legem mortuorū servavit, ut fieret primogenitus á mortuis, et commoratus usque ad te•tiā diē in inferioribus terrae, pòst deinde surgens in carne, ut etiā figuras clavorū ostenderet discipulis, sic ascendit ad patrem. Ibid.
iCùm enim Dominus in medio umbrae mortis abierit, ubi animae mortuorum erant, post deinde corporaliter resurrexit, & post resurrectionē assumptus est: manifestū est quia & discipulorum ejus, propter quos & haec operatus est Dominus, animae abibunt in invisibilem locum, definitū eis á Deo, & ibi usque ad resurrectionem commorabuntur, sustinentes resurrectionem; pòst recipients corpora & perfecté resu•gentes, hoc est corporaliter, quemadmodum & Dominus resurrexit, sic venient ad conspectum Dei. Nemo enim est discipulus super magistrum: perfectus autem omnis erit, sicut magister ejus. Ibid.Cùm enim Dominus in medio umbrae mortis abierit, ubi animae mortuorum erant, post deinde corporaliter resurrexit, & post resurrectionē assumptus est: manifestū est quia & discipulorum ejus, propter quos & haec operatus est Dominus, animae abibunt in invisibilem locum, definitū eis á Deo, & ibi usque ad resurrectionem commorabuntur, sustinentes resurrectionem; pòst recipientes corpora & perfecté resu•gentes, hoc est corporaliter, quemadmodum & Dominus resurrexit, sic venient ad conspectum Dei. Nemo enim est discipulus super magistrum: perfectus autem omnis erit, sicut magister ejus. Ibid.
kTertullian de Animâ, cap. 55. vid. supr. pag. 270. ad liter. b.
lQuid est illud quod ad inferna transfertur post divortium corporis, quod detinetur illic, quod in diem judicij reservatur, ad quod & Christus moriendo descendit, puto ad animas Patriarcharum. Jbid. cap. 7.
Where he maketh the Hell unto which our Saviour did descend, to be the common receptacle not of the souls of the Patriarchs alone, but also of the souls that are now still separated from their bodies: as being the place quò universa humanitas trahitur (as he speaketh melsewhere in that book) unto which all mankind is drawn.
Where he maketh the Hell unto which our Saviour did descend, to be the common receptacle not of the soules of the Patriarches alone, but also of the soules that are now still separated from their bodies: as being the place quò universa humanitas trahitur (as he speaketh melsewhere in that booke) unto which all mankinde is drawne.
So Novatianus after him, affirmeth that the very places nwhich lye under the earth be not void of distinguished and ordered powers. For that is the place (saith he) whither the souls both of the godly and ungodly are led, receiving the fore-judgements of their future d•ome. Lactantius saith that our Saviour orose againe ab inferis, from Hell: but so he saith also that the dead Saints shall be praised up ab inferis at the time of the Resurrection. S. Cyril of Alexandria saith that the Jews qkilled Christ, and cast him into the deep and dark dungeon of death, that is, into Hades: adding afterward, that rHades may rightly be esteemed to be the house and mansion of such as are deprived of life. Nicephorus Gregoras in his funeral Oration upon Theodorus Metochites, putteth in this for one strain of his lamentation. sWho hath brought down that heavenly man unto the ⟨p. 349⟩bottom of Hades? and Andrew archbishop of Crete, touching the descent both of Christ and all Christians after him even unto the dark and comfortless Hades writeth in this manner. tIf he, who was the Lord and master of all, and the light of them that are in darkness, and the life of all men, would taste death, and undergo the descent into Hell, that he might be made like unto us in all things, sin excepted; and for three days went thorough the sad, obscure and dark region of Hell: what strange thing is it, that we who are sinners, and dead in trespasses (according to the great Apostle) who are subject to generation and corruption; should meet with death, and go with our soul into the dark chambers of Hell, where we cannot see light, nor behold the life of mortal men? For are we above our Master, or better then the Saints, who underwent these things of ours after the like manner that we must do?
So Novatianus after him, affirmeth that the very places nwhich lye under the earth be not voyde of distinguished and ordered powers. For that is the place (saith he) whither the soules both of the godly and ungodly are led, receiving the fore-judgements of their future d•ome. Lactantius saith that our Saviour orose againe ab inferis, from Hell: but so he saith also that the dead Saints shall be praised up ab inferis at the time of the Resurrection. S. Cyrill of Alexandria saith that the Iewes qkilled Christ, and cast him into the deepe and darke dungeon of death, that is, into Hades: adding afterward, that rHades may rightly be esteemed to be the house and mansion of such as are deprived of life. Nicephorus Gregoras in his funerall Oration upon Theodorus Metochites, putteth in this for one strayne of his lamentation. sWho hath brought downe that heavenly man unto the ⟨p. 349⟩bottome of Hades? and Andrew archbishop of Crete, touching the descent both of Christ and all Christians after him even unto the darke and comfortlesse Hades writeth in this maner. tIf hee, who was the Lord and master of all, and the light of them that are in darknesse, and the life of all men, would taste death, and undergoe the descent into Hell, that he might be made like unto us in all things, sinne excepted; and for three dayes went thorough the sad, obscure and darke region of Hell: what strange thing is it, that wee who are sinners, and dead in trespasses (according to the great Apostle) who are subject to generation and corruption; should meete with death, and goe with our soule into the darke chambers of Hell, where we cannot see light, nor behold the life of mortall men? For are wee above our Master, or better then the Saints, who underwent these things of ours after the like maner that we must doe?
nQuae infraterram jacent, neque ipsa sunt digestis & ordinatis potestatibus vacua. Locus enim est, quò piorum animae impiorumque ducuntur, futuri judicij pra•judicia sentientes Novatian. de Trinitat. cap 1.
oLactant. Justitut. lib. 4. cap. 19.
pI•. lib. 7. cap. 24. vid. & cap. 22.
q[Greek or Hebrew] Cyril. Glaphyr. in Genes. lib. 6. pag. 154.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Cyrill. Glaphyr. in Genes. lib. 6. pag. 154.
r[Greek or Hebrew]. Ibid. pag 155.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid. pag 155.
t[Greek or Hebrew]; Andre. Hierosolymitan. serm. in vitam humanam, & in Defunctos.〈non-Latin alphabet〉; Andre. Hierosolymitan. serm. in vitam humanam, & in Defunctos.
Juvencus intimateth, that our Saviour giving up the ghost sent his soul unto heaven, in those verses of his:
uTunc clamor Domini magno conamine missus,
Aethereis animam comitem commiscuit auris.
Eusebius Emesenus collecteth so much from the last words which our Lord uttered at the same time; Father, into thine hands I commend my spirit. [Greek or Hebrew], saith xhe, [Greek or Hebrew]. His spirit was above, and his body remained upon the cross for us. In the Greek exposition of the Canticles, collected out of Eusebius, Philo Carpathius and others, that sentence in the beginning of the sixth chapter, My beloved ⟨p. 350⟩is gone down into his garden, is interpreted of Christs ygoing to the souls of the Saints in Hádes. which in the Latin collections that bear the name of Philo Carpathius is thus more largely expressed. zBy this descending of the Bridegroom, we may understand the descending of our Lord Jesus Christ into Hell as I suppose: for that which followeth proveth this, when he sayeth; To the beds of spices. For those ancient holy men are not unfitly signified by the beds of spices; such as were, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, Job, David, Samuel, Elisaeus, Daniel, and very many others before the Law & in the Law: who all of them, like unto beds of spices, gave a most sweet smell of the odours and fruits of holy righteousness. For then as a triumpher did he enter into PARADISE, when he pierced into Hell. God himself is present with us for a witness in this matter, when he answered most graciously to the Thief upon the Cross, commending himself unto him most religiously; To day shalt thou be with me in Paradise. Lastly touching this Paradise, the various opinions of the ancient are thus laid down by Olympiodorus; to seek no farther. aIt is a thing worthy of enquiry, in ⟨p. 351⟩what place under the Sun the righteous are placed which have left this life. Certain it is, that in Paradise: forasmuch as Christ said unto the Thief; This day shalt thou be with me in Paradise. And it is to be known, that the literal Tradition teacheth Paradise to be in earth. But some have said that Paradise also is in Hell, that is, in a place under the earth: unto which opinion of theirs they apply that of the Gospel; where the rich man saw Lazarus, being yet himself sunk down in a lower place, when Lazarus was in a place more eminent, where Abraham was.
Iuvencus intimateth, that our Saviour giving up the ghost sent his soule unto heaven, in those verses of his:
uTunc clamor Domini magno conamine missus,
Aethereis animam comitem commiscuit auris.
Eusebius Emesenus collecteth so much from the last words which our Lord uttered at the same time; Father, into thine hands I commend my spirit. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, saith xhe, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. His spirit was above, and his body remayned upon the crosse for us. In the Greeke exposition of the Canticles, collected out of Eusebius, Philo Carpathius and others, that sentence in the beginning of the sixt chapter, My beloved ⟨p. 350⟩is gone down into his garden, is interpreted of Christs ygoing to the soules of the Saints in Hádes. which in the Latin collections that beare the name of Philo Carpathius is thus more largely expressed. zBy this descending of the Bridegrome, we may understand the descending of our Lord Iesus Christ into Hell as I suppose: for that which followeth proveth this, when he sayeth; To the beds of spices. For those ancient holy men are not unfi•ly signified by the beds of spices; such as were, Noë, Abraham, Isaac, Iacob, Moses, Iob, David, Samuel, Elisaeus, Daniel, and very many others before the Law & in the Law: who all of them, like unto beds of spices, gave a most sweete smell of the odours and fruits of holy righteousnesse. For then as a triumpher did he enter into PARADISE, when he pierced into Hell. God himselfe is present with us for a witnesse in this matter, when he answered most graciously to the Thiefe upon the Crosse, commending himselfe unto him most religiously; To day shalt thou be with me in Paradise. Lastly touching this Paradise, the various opinions of the ancient are thus layd downe by Olympiodorus; to seeke no farther. aIt is a thing worthy of enquirie, in ⟨p. 351⟩what place under the Sunne the righteous are placed which have left this life. Certaine it is, that in Paradise: forasmuch as Christ said unto the Thiefe; This day shalt thou be with me in Paradise. And it is to be knowne, that the literall Tradition teacheth Paradise to be in earth. But some have said that Paradise also is in Hell, that is, in a place under the earth: unto which opinion of theirs they apply that of the Gospell; where the rich man saw Lazarus, being yet himselfe sunke downe in a lower place, when Lazarus was in a place more eminent, where Abraham was.
xEuseb. Em•sen. á Theodore•o citatus in [Greek or Hebrew]. dialog. 3.Euseb. Em•sen. á Theodore•o citatus in 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. dialog. 3.
y[Greek or Hebrew]. Euseb. in Cantic. pag. 68.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Euseb. in Cantic. pag. 68.
zPer descensum Sponsi quem patruelem appellat, Domini nost•i Jesu Christi descensum ad inferos possumus intelligere, ut arbitror: nam & haec sequentia probant, cùm dixit; Ad aromatum phialas sive areolas. Prisci enim illi sanctissimi viri, per phialas aromatum non inepté significantur; quales fuere, Noë, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, Job, David, Samuel, Elisaeus, Daniel, alijque quamplurimi ante Legem & in Lege: qui quidem omnes, veluti aromatum phialae sive areolae, sanctissimae justitiae odours ac fructus suavissimé oluerunt. Tunc enim Paradisum triumphator ingressus est, cùm ad inferos penetravit. Adest nobis ipse Deu• hâc in re testis, cùm in Cruce Latroni (sese illi ipsi religiosissime commendanti) clementissimé respondit; Hodie mecū eris in Paradiso. Philo Carpath in Canti•. 6.Per descensum Sponsi quem patruelem appellat, Domini nost•i Iesu Christi descensum ad inferos possumus intelligere, ut arbitror: nam & haec sequentia probant, cùm dixit; Ad aromatum phialas sive areolas. Prisci enim illi sanctissimi viri, per phialas aromatum non inepté significantur; quales fuere, Noë, Abraham, Isaac, Iacob, Moses, Iob, David, Samuel, Elisaeus, Daniel, alijque quamplurimi ante Legem & in Lege: qui quidem omnes, veluti aromatum phialae sive areolae, sanctissimae justitiae odores ac fructus suavissimé oluerunt. Tunc enim Paradisum triumphator ingressus est, cùm ad inferos penetravit. Adest nobis ipse Deu• hâc in re testis, cùm in Cruce Latroni (sese illi ipsi religiosissime commendanti) clementissimé respondit; Hodie mecū eris in Paradiso. Philo Carpath in Canti. 6.
But howsoever the matter goeth; this without doubt is manifest, aswell out of Ecclesiastes as out of all the sacred Scripture, that the godly shall be in prosperity and peace, and the ungodly in punishments and torments. And others are of the mind, that Paradise is in the Heavens, &c. Hitherto Olympiodorus.
But howsoever the matter goeth; this without doubt is manifest, aswell out of Ecclesiastes as out of all the sacred Scripture, that the godly shall be in prosperity and peace, and the ungodly in punishments and torments. And others are of the minde, that Paradise is in the Heavens, &c. Hitherto Olympiodorus.
That Christs soul went into Paradise, bDoctor Bishop saith, being well understood, is true. For his soul in hell, had the joys of Paradise: but to make that an exposition of Christs descending into hell, is to expound a thing by the flat contrary of it. Yet this ridiculous exposition, he affirmeth to be received of most Protestants. Which is even as true, as that which he avoucheth in the same place; that this article of the descent into Hell is to be found cin the old Roman Creed expounded by Ruffinus: where Ruffinus (as we have heard) expounding that article, delivereth the flat contrary, that it is not found added in the Creed of the Church of Rome. It is true indeed, that more than most Protestants do interpret the words of Christ uttered unto the Thief upon the Cross, Luk. 23.43. of the going of his soul into Paradise: where our Saviour meaning simply and plainly, that he would be that day in dHeaven; M. Bishop ⟨p. 352⟩would have him so to be understood, as if he had meant that that day he would be in Hell. And must it be now held more ridiculous in Protestants, to take Hell for Paradise; then in M. Bishop, to take Paradise for Hell? [Greek or Hebrew], be the words of the Apostles Creed in the Greek: and, [Greek or Hebrew], in the Symbol of eAthanasius. Some learned Protestants do observe, that in these words there is no determinate mention made, either of ascending or descending, either of Heaven or Hell (taking Hell according to the vulgar acception) but of the general only, under which these contraries are indifferently comprehended: and that the words literally interpreted, import no more but this; HE WENT UNTO THE OTHER WORLD. Which is not to expound a thing by the flat contrary of it, as M. Bishop fancieth: who may quickly make himself ridiculous, in taking upon him thus to censure the interpretations of our learned linguists; unless his own skill in the languages were greater, then as yet he hath given proof of.
That Christs soule went into Paradise, bDoctor Bishop saith, being well understood, is true. For his soule in hell, had the joyes of Paradise: but to make that an exposition of Christs descending into hell, is to expound a thing by the flat contrary of it. Yet this ridiculous exposition, he affirmeth to be received of most Protestants. Which is even as true, as that which he avoucheth in the same place; that this article of the descent into Hell is to be found cin the old Roman Creed expounded by Ruffinus: where Ruffinus (as we have heard) expounding that article, delivereth the flat contrarie, that it is not found added in the Creed of the Church of Rome. It is true indeed, that more than most Protestants do interprete the words of Christ uttered unto the Thiefe upon the Crosse, Luk. 23.43. of the going of his soule into Paradise: where our Saviour meaning simply and plainly, that hee would be that day in dHeaven; M. Bishop ⟨p. 352⟩would have him so to be understood, as if he had meant that that day he would be in Hell. And must it be now held more ridiculous in Protestants, to take Hell for Paradise; then in M. Bishop, to take Paradise for Hell? 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, be the wordes of the Apostles Creed in the Greeke: and, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, in the Symbol of eAthanasius. Some learned Protestants do observe, that in these words there is no determinate mention made, eyther of ascending or descending, either of Heaven or Hell (taking Hell according to the vulgar acception) but of the generall only, under which these contraries are indifferently comprehended: and that the words literally interpreted, import no more but this; HEE WENT UNTO THE OTHER WORLD. Which is not to expound a thing by the flat contrary of it, as M. Bishop fancieth: who may quickly make himselfe ridiculous, in taking upon him thus to censure the interpretations of our learned linguistes; unlesse his owne skill in the languages were greater, then as yet he hath given proofe of.
Master Broughton (with whose authority he elsewhere presseth us, as of a man festeemed to be singularly seen in the Hebrew and Greek tongue) hath been but too forward in maintaining that exposition, which by D. Bishop is accounted so ridiculous. In one place, touching the term Hell, as it doth answer the Hebrew Sheol and the Greek Hades, he writeth thus. gHe that thinketh it ever used for Tartaro or Gehenna, otherwise then the term Death may by Synecdoche import so: hath not skill in Hebrew or that Greek, which breathing and live Graecia spake, if God hath lent me any judgement that way. In hanother place he allegeth out of Portus his Dictionary, that the Macedonians call [Greek or Hebrew] Heaven. ⟨p. 353⟩And one of his acquaintance beyond the Sea, reporteth that he should deliver, that in imany most ancient Manuscript copies the Lords prayer is found with this beginning: [Greek or Hebrew], Our Fat•er which art in Hádes. which I for my part will then believe to be true, when I shall see one of those old copies with mine own eyes. But in the mean time for Hades, it hath been sufficiently declared before out of▪ good authors, that it signifieth the place of souls departed in general; and so is of extent large enough to comprehend under it, as well [Greek or Hebrew] (as Damascius speaketh) that part of Hades (or the unseen world) which is in heaven, as that which by kJosephus is called [Greek or Hebrew] the darker Hades, and in the lGospel [Greek or Hebrew] outer darkness. And as for [Greek or Hebrew] the other word; in the Acts of the Apostles it is used ten times: and in none of all those places signifieth any descending from a higher place unto a lower, but a removing simply from one place unto another. Whereupon the Vulgar Latin edition (which none of the Romanists mupon any pretence may presume to reject) doth render it there by the general terms of nabeo, ovenio, pdevenio, qsupervenio. and where it retaineth the word rdescendo, it intendeth nothing less, then to signify thereby the lower situation of the place unto which the removal is noted to be made. If descending therefore in the Acts of the Apostles imply no such kind of thing: what necessity is there; that thus of force it must be interpreted in the Creed of the Apostles? Menelaus declared unto us, [Greek or Hebrew]: saith King Antiochus, in his epistle unto the Jews, 2.
Master Broughton (with whose authoritie hee elsewhere presseth us, as of a man festeemed to be singularly seene in the Hebrew and Greeke tongue) hath beene but too forward in maintayning that exposition, which by D. Bishop is accounted so ridiculous. In one place, touching the terme Hell, as it doth answer the Hebrew Sheol and the Greeke Hádes, he writeth thus. gHe that thinketh it ever used for Tartaro or Gehenna, otherwise then the terme Death may by Synecdoche import so: hath not skill in Ebrew or that Greeke, vvhich breathing and live Graecia spake, if God hath lent me any judgement that way. In hanother place he alledgeth out of Portus his Dictionary, that the Macedonians call 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Heaven. ⟨p. 353⟩And one of his acquaintance beyond the Sea, reporteth that he should deliver, that in imany most ancient Manuscript copies the Lords prayer is found with this beginning: 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Our Fat•er which art in Hádes. which I for my part will then beleeve to be true, when I shall see one of those old copies with mine owne eyes. But in the meane time for Hádes, it hath beene sufficiently declared before out of▪ good authors, that it signifieth the place of soules departed in generall; and so is of extent large enough to comprehend under it, as well 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 (as Damascius speaketh) that part of Hádes (or the unseene vvorld) which is in heaven, as that which by kIosephus is called 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 the darker Hades, and in the lGospell 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 outer darknesse. And as for 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 the other word; in the Acts of the Apostles it is used ten times: and in none of all those places signifieth anie descending from a higher place unto a lower, but a removing simply from one place unto another. Whereupon the Vulgar Latin edition (which none of the Romanists
fBishop. Preface to the second part of his Reformat. of Perkins Catholic pag. 19.Bishop. Preface to the second part of his Reformat. of Perkins Catholick pag. 19.
gBrought. in his epistle to the Nobility of Engl. edit. an. 1597. pag. 38.Brought. in his epistle to the Nobilitie of Engl. edit. an. 1597. pag. 38.
hId. in alio Opusculo, edit. an. 1604.
iInveniri insupe• asserit in multis vetussissimis exemplaribus MS•. orationem Dominicam in hunc modum; [Greek or Hebrew] Pater noster qui es in inferno etc. Veteres quoque Macedones aliter orationem Dominicam nunquam precatos fuisse. Jo. Rodolph. Lavator. de descensu ad inferos, lib. 1. part 1. cap 8.Inveniri insupe• asserit in multis vetussissimis exemplaribus MS•. orationem Dominicam in hunc modum; 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Pater noster qui es in inferno etc. Veteres quoque Macedones aliter orationem Dominicam nunquam precatos fuisse. Io. Rodolph. Lavator. de descensu ad inferos, lib. 1. part 1. cap 8.
kJoseph. de Bello Judaic. lib. 3. cap. 25. pag. 785.Ioseph. de Bello Iudaic. lib. 3. cap. 25. pag. 785.
Maccab. 11.29. Veil vos descendere ad vestros, it is in the Latin edition: whereby ⟨p. 354⟩what else is meant, but that they had a desire to go unto their own?
Maccab. 11.29. Velle vos descendere ad vestros, it is in the Latin edition: whereby ⟨p. 354⟩what else is meant, but that they had a desire to goe unto their owne?
I omit the phrases of descending in praelium, in forum, in campum, in amicitiam, in caussam, &c. which are so usual in good Latin authors: yea and of descending into heaven it self; if that be not a jest which the Poet breaketh upon Claudius.
sIlle senis tremulumque caput descendere jussit
In coelum.
Others add unto this, that the phrase of descending ad inferos, is a popular kind of speech, which sprung from the opinion that was vulgarly conceived of the situation of the receptacle of the souls under the earth: and that according to the rule of Aristotle in his Topics, we must speak as the vulgar, but think as wise men do. Even as we use to say commonly, that the Sun is under a cloud, because it is a vulgar form of speech: and yet it is far enough from our meaning for all that, to imagine the cloud to be indeed higher then the Sun. So Cicero, they say, where ever he hath occasion to mention any thing that concerneth the dead, speaketh still of Inferi according to the vulgar phrase: although he misliked the vulgar opinion, which bred that manner of speaking; and professed it to be his judgement, that tthe souls when they depart out of the body are carried up on high, & not downward unto any habitations under the earth. So Chrysostom and Theophylact think that the Apostle termed the Death and Hell unto which our Saviour did descend, the lower parts of the earth, Ephes. 4.9. u[Greek or Hebrew], xfrom the common opinion of men. So in the translation of the holy Scripture, ⟨p. 355⟩S. Hierome showeth that we use the names of Arcturus and Orion, not approving thereby the ridiculous and monstrous figments of the Poets in this matter, but expressing the Hebrew names of these constellations by the words of heathenish fables; because ywe cannot understand that which is said, but by those words, which we have learned by use, and drunk in by error.
I omitt the phrases of descending in praelium, in forum, in campum, in amicitiam, in caussam, &c. which are so usuall in good Latin authors: yea and of descending into heaven it selfe; if that be not a jeast which the Poet breaketh upon Claudius.
sIlle senis tremulumque caput descendere jussit
In coelum.
Others adde unto this, that the phrase of descending ad inferos, is a popular kinde of speech, which sprung from the opinion that was vulgarly conceived of the situation of the recept•cle of the soules under the earth: and that according to the rule of Aristo•le in his Top•cks, we must speake as the vulgar, but thinke as wise men doe. Even as wee use to say commonly, that the Sunne is under a cloude, because it is a vulgar forme of speech: and yet it is farre enough from our meaning for all that, to imagine the cloude to bee indeede higher then the Sunne. So Cicero, they say, where ever hee hath occasion to mention any thing that concerneth the dead, speaketh still of Inferi according to the vulgar phrase: although hee misliked the vulgar opinion, which bred that maner of speaking; and professed it to bee his judgement, that tthe soules when they depart out of the body are carried up on high, & not downward unto any habitations under the earth. So Chrysostom and Theophylact thinke that the Apostle tearmed the Death and Hell unto which our Saviour did descend, the lower parts of the earth, Ephes. 4.9. u〈non-Latin alphabet〉, xfrom the common opinion of men. So in the translation of the holy Scripture, ⟨p. 355⟩S. Hierome sheweth that wee use the names of Arcturus and Orion, not approving thereby the ridiculous and monstrous figments of the Poets in this matter, but expressing the Hebrew names of these constellations by the vvords of heathenish fables; because ywe cannot understand that which is sayd, but by those words, which we have learned by use, and drunke in by error.
sJuvenal. Satyr. 6.Iuvenal. Satyr. 6.
tAnimos cùm é corpore excesserint, in sublime ferry. Cic lib 1. Tusculan. quaest.Animos cùm é corpore excesserint, in sublime ferri. Cic lib 1. Tusculan. quaest.
yQui non possumus intelligere quod dicitur, nisi per ea vocabula, quae usu didicimus, & error combibimus. Hieronym. lib. 2. in Amos cap. 5.Qui non possumus intelligere quod dicitur, nisi per ea vocabula, quae usu didicimus, & errore combibimus. Hieronym. lib. 2. in Amos cap. 5.
And just so standeth the case with this word Hades: which with the G•eeke Poets is the name of Pluto, whom they feigned to be the God of the dead under the earth, & gave a denomination unto [Greek or Hebrew], from riches; zbecause that all things coming to their dissolution, there is nothing which is not at last brought unto him, and made his possession. Thus Homer and Hesiod, with aPlato and others after them, say that Rhea brought forth three sons, to Saturn; Jupiter, Neptune,
b[Greek or Hebrew],
[Greek or Hebrew].
and mighty Hades, who inhabiteth the houses under the earth, having a merciless heart: for that attribute doth Hesiod give unto him, because Death spareth no man. So Homer: — c[Greek or Hebrew]: which is also the description that Hesiod maketh of him in that verse: d[Greek or Hebrew], Hades was afraid, who reigneth over them that lye dead in the earth. Now that [Greek or Hebrew] in the Creed ⟨p. 356⟩is a phrase taken from the heathen, and applied to express a Christian truth; the very Grammatical construction may seem to intimate: where the noun is not put in the accusative case (as otherwise it should) but after the manner of the Greeks in the genitive case, implying the defect of another word necessarily to be understood; as if it had been said, He went unto the place or house of Hades. as the Poets use to express it, sometimes defectively [Greek or Hebrew], and sometimes more fully e[Greek or Hebrew] or f[Greek or Hebrew], into the house or chambers of Hádes. Thus then, they that take Hades for the common receptacle of souls, do interpret the context of the Creed, as Cardinal Cajetan before did the narration of Moses touching Abraham's giving up the ghost, being gathered to his people, and being buried, Genes. 25.8, 9. that the article of the death is to be referred to the whole manhood, and the dissolution of the parts thereof; that of the burial, to the body separated from the soul, and this of the descending into Hades, to the soul separated from the body as if he had said. He suffered death truly, by a real separation of his soul from his body: and after this dissolution, the same did befall him that useth to betide all other dead men;
And just so standeth the case with this word Hades: which with the G•eeke Poets is the name of Pluto, whom they fayned to be the God of the dead under the earth, & gave a denomination unto 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, from riches; zbecause that all things comming to their dissolution, there is nothing which is not at last brought unto him, and made his possession. Thus Homer and Hesiod, with aPlato and others after them, say that Rhea brought forth three sonnes, to Saturne; Iupiter, Neptune,
b〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
and mightie Hades, who inhabiteth the houses under the earth, having a mercilesse heart: for that attribute doth Hesiod give unto him, because Death spareth no man. So Homer: — c〈non-Latin alphabet〉: which is also the description that Hesiod maketh of him in that verse: d〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Hades was afraid, who raigneth over them that lye dead in the earth. Now that 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 in the Creed ⟨p. 356⟩is a phrase taken from the heathen, and applied to expresse a Christian truth; the very Grammatica•l construction may seeme to intimate: where the nowne is not put in the accusative case (as otherwise it should) but after the maner of the Greekes in the genitive case, implying the defect of another word necessarily to be understood; as if it had beene said, He went unto the place or house of Hades. as the Poets use to expresse it, sometimes defectively 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and sometimes more fully e〈non-Latin alphabet〉 or
his lifeless body was sent unto the place which is appointed to receive dead bodies, and his immortal soul went unto the other world, as the souls of other men use to do.
his livelesse bodie was sent unto the place which is appointed to receive dead bodies, and his immortall soule went unto the other world, as the soules of other men use to doe.
Having now declared, how the Greek Hades (and so the Latin Inferi, and our English Hell) is taken for the place of the bodies and of the souls of dead men, severally: it followeth that we show, how the common state of the dead is signified thereby, and the place in general which is answerable unto the parts of the ⟨p. 357⟩whole man thus indefinitely considered in the state of separation. Concerning which, that place of Dionysius, wherein he setteth forth the signification of our being dead and buried with Christ by Baptism, is to be considered. fForasmuch as death is in us, not an utter extinguishment of our being, as others have thought, but a separation of the united parts, bringing them unto that which is to us invisible; the soul as being by the deprivation of the body made unseen, and the body as either being covered in the earth, or by some other of the alterations that are incident unto bodies, being taken away from the sight of man: the whole covering of the man in water is fitly assumed for an image of the death and burial which is not seen. Thus Dionysius, concerning the separation of the united parts by Death, and the bringing of them unto that which is invisible: gaccording whereunto, as his paraphrast Pachymeres noteth, it is called Hades, that is to say, an invisible separation of the soul from the body. And so indeed we find as well in foreign authors, as in the Scriptures & the writings of the Greek and Latin Fathers, that Hades and Inferi are not only taken in as large a sense as Death (and so extended unto all men indifferently, whether good or bad) but are likewise oftentimes indifferently used for it. For proof whereof, out of heathen authors these testimonies following may suffice.
h[Greek or Hebrew]
[Greek or Hebrew]:
saith Pindarus. The man that doeth things befitting him, forgetteth Hades: meaning, that the remembrance of death doth no whit trouble him. and again:
i[Greek or Hebrew]
[Greek or Hebrew]—
[Greek or Hebrew]
[Greek or Hebrew].
⟨p. 358⟩The son of Cleonicus wisheth that with such manners he may meet and receive Hades (that is, death) and hoar old age. So another Poet, cited by kPlutarch:
[Greek or Hebrew].
[Greek or Hebrew].
O Death, the sovereign physician, come: for Hades is in very truth the haven of the earth.
Having now declared, how the Greek Hádes (and so the Latine Inferi, and our English Hell) is taken for the place of the bodies and of the soules of dead men, severally: it followeth that we shew, how the common state of the dead is signified thereby, and the place in generall which is answerable unto the parts of the ⟨p. 357⟩whole man thus indefinitely considered in the state of separation. Concerning which, that place of Dionysius, wherein he setteth forth the signification of our being dead and buried with Christ by Baptisme, is to be considered. fForasmuch as death is in us, not an utter extinguishment of our being, as others have thought, but a separation of the united parts, bringing them unto that which is to us invisible; the soule as being by the deprivation of the body made unseene, and the body as eyther being covered in the earth, or by some other of the alterations that are incident unto bodies, being taken away from the sight of man: the whole covering of the man in water is fitly assumed for an image of the death and buriall which is not seene. Thus Dionysius, concerning the separation of the united parts by Death, and the bringing of them unto that which is invisible: gaccording whereunto, as his paraphrast Pachymeres noteth, it is called Hádes, that is to say, an invisible separation of the soule from the body. And so indeed wee finde as well in forraine authors, as in the Scriptures & the writings of the Greek and Latin Fathers, that Hádes and Inferi are not only taken in as large a sense as Death (and so extended unto all men indifferently, whether good or bad) but are likewise oftentimes indifferently used for it. For proofe whereof, out of heathen authors these testimonies following may suffice.
h〈non-Latin alphabet〉〈non-Latin alphabet〉:
saith Pindarus. The man that doeth things befitting him, forgetteth Hádes: meaning, that the remembrance of death doth no whit trouble him. and againe:
i〈non-Latin alphabet〉〈non-Latin alphabet〉—
〈non-Latin alphabet〉〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
So the saying, that the best thing were, never to have been born, and the next to that, to dye quickly; is thus expressed by Theognis, in his elegies:
[Greek or Hebrew],
[Greek or Hebrew].
[Greek or Hebrew],
[Greek or Hebrew].
So the saying, that the best thing were, never to have been born, and the next to that, to dye quickly; is thus expressed by Theognis, in his elegies:
〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
Sophocles in the beginning of his Trachiniae, bringeth in D•ianira affirming that, howsoever it were an old saying among men, that none could know whether a man, life were happy or unhappy before he were dead; yet she knew her own to be heavy and unfortunate before she went to Hádes.
[Greek or Hebrew],
[Greek or Hebrew].
where [Greek or Hebrew], is the same with [Greek or Hebrew] before death: as both the ancient Scholiast and the matter it self doth show. So in his Ajax: [Greek or Hebrew]. He is better that is hidden in Hades (that is to say, he that is dead, [Greek or Hebrew], as the Scholiast rightly expoundeth it) then he that is sick past recovery. and in his Antigone:
[Greek or Hebrew],
[Greek or Hebrew].
My father and mother being laid in Hades, it is not possible that any brother should spring forth afterward. Wherewith lClemens Alexandrinus doth fitly compare that speech of the wife of Intaphernes in mHerodotus: [Greek or Hebrew] ⟨p. 359⟩[Greek or Hebrew]. My father and mother being now no longer living, another brother by no manner of means can be had. So that [Greek or Hebrew] or [Greek or Hebrew], being in Hades, with the one, is the same with [Greek or Hebrew], not now living, in the other; or as it is alleged by Clemens, [Greek or Hebrew], not now being: which is the Scripture phrase of them that have left this world, Genes. 5.24. and 42.36. Psal. 39.13. Jerem. 31.15. and 49.10. used also by Homer, Iliad. β.
Sophocles in the beginning of his Trachiniae, bringeth in D•ianira affirming that, howsoever it were an old saying among men, that none could know whether a man, life were happy or unhappy before he were dead; yet she knew her own to be heavie and unfortunate before she went to Hádes.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
where 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, is the same with 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 before death: as both the ancient Scholiast and the matter it selfe doth shew. So in his Ajax: 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. He is better that is hidden in Hádes (that is to say, he that is dead, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, as the Scholiast rightly expoundeth it) then he that is sick past recoverie. and in his Antigone:
〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
My father and mother being layd in Hádes, it is not possible that any brother should spring forth afterward. Wherwith lClemens Alexandrinus doth fitly compare that speech of the wife of Intaphernes in mHerodotus: 〈non-Latin alphabet〉⟨p. 359⟩〈non-Latin alphabet〉. My father and mother being now no longer living, another brother by no maner of meanes can be had. So that 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, being in Hádes, with the one, is the same with 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, not now living, in the other; or as it is alledged by Clemens, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, not now being: which is the Scripture phrase of them that have left this world, Genes. 5.24. and 42.36. Psal. 39.13. Ierem. 31.15. and 49.10. used also by Homer, Iliad. β.
Touching the use of the word Hell in the Scriptures, thus writeth Jansenius, expounding those words, Proverb. 15.11. Hell and destruction are before the Lord: how much more then, the hearts of the children of men? nIt is to be known, that by Hell and destruction (which two in the Scriptures are often joined together) the state of the dead is signified; and not of the damned only, as we commonly do conceive when we hear these words, but the state of the deceased in general. So oSanctius the Jesuit, with Sà his fellow, acknowledgeth, that Hell in the Scripture is frequently taken for Death. Therefore are these two joined together, Revel. 1.18. I have the keys of Hell and of Death, or (as other Greek copies read; agreeably to the old Latin and Ethiopian translation) of Death and of Hell. and Isaiah. 28.15. We have made a covenant with Death, and with Hell we are at agreement. where the Septuagint, to show that the same thing is meant by both the words, do place the one in the room of the other, after this manner: We have made a covenant with Hell, and with Death an agreement. The same things likewise are indifferently attributed unto them ⟨p. 360⟩both: as that they are unsatiable, and never full; spoken of Hell, Proverb. 27.20. and of Death, Haback. 2.5. So the gates of Hell, Isaiah. 38:10. are the gates of Death, Psalm. 9.13. and 107.18. and therefore where we read in the book of Wisdom; pThou leadest to the gates of Hell, and bringest back again: the Vulgar Latin translateth it; qThou leadest to the gates of Death, and bringest back again. So the sorrows of Death, Psal. 18.4. are in the verse following termed, the sorrows of Hell: and therefore the LXX. (as hath been showed) translating the self same words of David, do in the Psalm render them the sorrows of Hell, and in the history 2. Sam. 22.6. (where the same Psalm is repeated) the sorrows of Death. Whence also that difference of reading came, Act. 2.24. aswell in the copies of the text as in the citations of the ancient Fathers: which was the less regarded, because that variety in the words bred little or no difference at all in the sense. Therefore Epiphanius in one place, having respect to the beginning of the verse, saith that Christ loosed r[Greek or Hebrew] the sorrows of Death:
Touching the use of the word Hell in the Scriptures, thus writeth Iansenius, expounding those words, Proverb. 15.11. Hell and destruction are before the Lord: how much more then, the hearts of the children of men? nIt is to be knowen, that by Hell and destruction (which two in the Scriptures are often joyned together) the state of the dead is signified; and not of the damned only, as wee commonly doe conceave when we heare these words, but the state of the deceased in generall. So oSanctius the Iesuite, with Sà his fellow, acknowledgeth, that Hell in the Scripture is frequently taken for Death. Therefore are these two joyned together, Revel. 1.18. I have the keyes of Hell and of Death, or (as other Greeke copies read; agreeably to the old Latin and Aethiopian translation) of Death and of Hell. and Esai. 28.15. We have made a covenant with Death, and with Hell we are at agreement. where the Septuagint, to shew that the same thing is meant by both the words, do place the one in the room of the other, after this maner: We have made a covenant with Hell, and with Death an agreement. The same things likewise are indifferently attributed unto them ⟨p. 360⟩both: as that they are unsatiable, and never full; spoken of Hell, Proverb. 27.20. and of Death, Haback. 2.5. So the gates of Hell, Esai. 38:10. are the gates of Death, Psalm. 9.13. and 107.18. and therefore where we reade in the book of Wisedome; pThou leadest to the gates of Hell, and bringest backe againe: the Vulgar Latin translateth it; qThou leadest to the gates of Death, and bringest back againe. So the sorrowes of Death, Psal. 18.4. are in the verse following tearmed, the sorrowes of Hell: and therefore the LXX. (as hath beene shewed) translating the selfe same words of David, doe in the Psalme render them the sorrowes of Hell, and in the historie
nSciendum quòd per Infernum (pro quo dictio Hebraica proprié significat sepulchrum) & perditionem, quae duo in scripturis saepè conjunguntur, significatur status mortuorum; & non solùm damnatorum, ut nos feré ex his vocibus auditis concipimus, sed in genere status defunctorum. Cornellansen. in Proverb 15.
and yet in another, citing the later end of the verse, because it was not possible he should be holden by it, addeth this explication thereunto, s[Greek or Hebrew], that is to say, by Hell. And the author of the Sermon upon Christs passion, among the works of Athanasius, one where saith that he loosed the sorrows of tHell, and otherwhere that he loosed the sorrows of uDeath. unto whom we may adjoin Bede, xwho is in like manner indifferent for either reading.
and yet in another, citing the later end of the verse, because it was not possible he should be holden by it, addeth this explication thereunto, s〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that is to say, by Hell. And the author of the Sermon upon Christs passion, among the workes of Athanasius, one where saith that he loosed the sorrowes of tHell, and otherwhere that he loosed the sorrowes of uDeath. unto whom wee may adjoyne Bede, xwho is in like maner indifferent for eyther reading.
sId. in Anchora•o, pag. 484. Vid. etiam eund. contra Ariomani•. haeres. 69. pag. 337.
tAthana•. Oper. Gra•olat. tom. 1. pag. 801.
uIbid. pag. 805.
xSolutos per Dominū dicit dolores inferni, sive mortis. Bed. Retract. in Act. cap. 2.Solutos per Dominū dicit dolores inferni, sive mortis. Bed. Retract. in Act. cap. 2.
In the Proverbs, where it is said; There is a way which seemeth right unto a man, but the end thereof are the ways of Death: Proverb. 14.12. and 16.25. the LXX. in both ⟨p. 361⟩places for Death put [Greek or Hebrew] the bottom of Hell. and on the other side, where it is said; Thou shalt beat him with the rod, and shalt deliver his soul from Hell: Proverb. 23.14. they read, [Greek or Hebrew], Thou shalt deliver his soul from Death. So in Hose. 13.14. where the Hebrew and Greek both read: I will deliver them from the hand of Hell: the Vulgar Latin hath; De manu mortis liberabo eos, I will deliver them from the hand of Death. which S. Cyril of Alexandria showeth to be the same in effect. for yhe hath redeemed us (saith he) from the hand of Hell, that is to say, from the power of Death. So out of the text, Matth. 16.18. Eusebius noteth, that the Church doth znot give place to the gates of DEATH, for that one saying which Christ did utter: Upon the rock I will build my Church, and the gates of HELL shall not prevail against it. S. Ambrose also from the same text collecteth thus, that afaith is the foundation of the Church. For it was not said of the flesh of Peter, but of the faith, that the gates of DEATH should not prevail against it: but the confession (of the faith) overcame HELL. So Theodoret noteth, that the bname of Hell is given unto Death, in that place, Cantic. 8.6. Love is strong as death, jealousy is hard or cruel as Hell. which in the writings of the Fathers is a thing very usual. Take the Poems of Theodorus Prodromus for an instance: where delivering an history out of the life of S. Chrysostom, of a woman that had lost four of her sons; he saith that they four were gone unto Hades,
— [Greek or Hebrew]
[Greek or Hebrew].
⟨p. 362⟩and relating how S. Basil had freed the country of Cappadocia from famine, thus he expresseth it:
[Greek or Hebrew]
[Greek or Hebrew]
[Greek or Hebrew].
and showing how Gregory Nazianzen, when he was a child, was recovered from death by being brought to the communion Table; he saith he was brought unto the Sun from Hades: [Greek or Hebrew].
In the Proverbs, where it is said; There is a way which seemeth right unto a man, but the end therof are the waies of Death: Proverb. 14.12. and 16.25. the LXX. in both ⟨p. 361⟩places for Death put 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 the bottome of Hell. and on the other side, where it is said; Thou shalt beate him with the rod, and shalt deliver his soule from Hell: Proverb. 23.14. they reade, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Thou shalt deliver his soule from Death. So in Hose. 13.14. where the Hebrew and Greeke both reade: I will deliver them from the hand of Hell: the Vulgar Latin hath; De manu mortis liberabo eos, I will deliver them from the hand of Death. which S. Cyrill of Alexandria sheweth to be the same in effect. for yhe hath redeemed us (saith he) from the hand of Hell, that is to say, from the power of Death. So out of the text, Matth. 16.18. Eusebius noteth, that the Church doth znot give place to the gates of DEATH, for that one saying which Christ did utter: Vpon the rocke I will build my Church, and the gates of HELL shall not prevaile against it. S. Ambrose also from the same text collecteth thus, that afaith is the foundation of the Church. For it was not said of the flesh of Peter, but of the faith, that the gates of DEATH should not prevaile against it: but the confession (of the faith) overcame HELL. So Theodoret noteth, that the bname of Hell is given unto Death, in that place, Cantic. 8.6. Love is strong as death, jealousie is hard or cruell as Hell. which in the writings of the Fathers is a thing very usuall. Take the Poems of Theodorus Prodromus for an instance: where delivering an historie out of the life of S. Chrysostom, of a woman that had lost foure of her sonnes; he saith that they foure were gone unto Hádes,
— 〈non-Latin alphabet〉〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
y[Greek or Hebrew] Cyril. in Hoseam. pag. 371.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Cyrill. in Hoseam. pag. 371.
aFides ergo est Ecclesiae fundamentū. Non enim de carne Petri, sed de fide dictum est, quia portae mortis ei non praevalebunt; sed confessio vicit infernum. Ambros. de Incarnat. sacrament. cap. 5.Fides ergo est Ecclesiae fundamentū. Non enim de carne Petri, sed de fide dictum est, quia portae mortis ei non praevalebunt; sed confessio vicit infernum. Ambros. de Incarnat. sacrament. cap. 5.
bInfernum autem ex opinione, quae invaluit, usurpavit; hoc etiam morti nomen imponens. Theodoret. in Cantic. 8.
Gregory himself likewise in his Poems, setting out the dangers of a sea-faring life, saith that cthe greater part of them that sail the seas is in Hades. Basil of Seleucia, speaking of the translation of Enoch and Elijah, saith in one place, that dEnoch remained out of Deaths nett, Elijah obeyed not the laws of nature; and in another, that eElijah remained superior to death, Enoch by translation declined Hades: making Death and Hades to be one and the same thing. So he maketh Elijah to pray thus, at the raising of the widows son. fShow, ô Lord, that Death is made gentle towards men, let it learn the evidences of thy humanity; let the documents of thy goodness come even to Hades. And as he there noteth that gDeath received an overthrow from Elijah: so in another place he noteth that hHades received a like overthrow, by Christs raising of the dead. whereupon he bringeth in S. Peter, using this speech unto our Saviour: ⟨p. 363⟩iShall Death make any youthful attempt against thee, whose voice Hades could not endure? The other day thou didst call the widows son that was dead; and Death fled, not being able to accompany him unto the grave whom he had overcome: how shall Death therefore lay hold on him, whom it feareth? and our Saviour himself speaking thus unto his Disciples. kI will arise out of the grave, renewing the Resurrection: I will teach Hades that it must expect the Resurrection to succeed it. For in me both Death ceaseth, and immortality is planted. So saith S. Cyril of Alexandria: lChrist was raised up for us. for he could not be detained by the gates of Hades, nor taken at all by the bonds of Death. And therefore Cyril of Jerusalem having said that our Saviour did mdescend into Hades, doth presently add as an explication thereof. [Greek or Hebrew]. for he did descend into Death. nHe descended into Death as a man: saith Athanasius. oThe divine nature (saith Ruffinus, meaning the divine person) by his flesh descended into Death; not that according to the law of mortal men he should be detained of death, but that rising again by himself he might open the gates of death. pWhen thou didst descend into Death, ô immortal Life, (say the Grecians in their Liturgy) thou didst then mortify Hades or Hell with the brightness of thy divinity.
Gregory himselfe likewise in his Poems, setting out the dangers of a sea-faring life, saith that cthe greater part of them that saile the seas is in Hades. Baesil of Seleucia, speaking of the translation of Enoch and Elias, saith in one place, that dEnoch remayned out of Deaths nett, Elias obeyed not the lawes of nature; and in another, that eElias remayned superior to death, Enoch by translation declined Hades: making Death and Hades to be one and the same thing. So he maketh Elias to pray thus, at the raysing of the widowes sonne. fShew, ô Lord, that Death is made gentle towards men, let it learne the evidences of thy humanity; let the documents of thy goodnesse come even to Hades. And as he there noteth that gDeath received an overthrow from Elias: so in another place he noteth that hHades received a like overthrow, by Christs raysing of the dead. whereupon he bringeth in S. Peter, using this speech unto our Saviour: ⟨p. 363⟩iShall Death make any youthfull attempt against thee, whose voyce Hades could not endure? The other day thou didst call the widowes sonne that was dead; and Death fled, not being able to accompany him unto the grave whom he had overcome: how shall Death therefore lay hold on him, whom it feareth? and our Saviour himselfe speaking thus unto his Disciples. kI will arise out of the grave, renewing the Resurrection: I will teach Hades that it must expect the Resurrection to succeed it. For in me both Death ceaseth, and immortalitie is planted. So saith S. Cyrill of Alexandria: lChrist was raysed up for us. for he could not be detayned by the gates of Hades, nor taken at all by the bonds of Death. And therefore Cyrill of Hierusalem having sayd that our Saviour did mdescend into Hades, doth presently adde as an explication thereof. . for he did descend into Death.
c[Greek or Hebrew]. Nazianz. Carm. 15. de Vitae itinerib. tom. 2. edit. Graecolat. pag. 91.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Nazianz. Carm. 15. de Vitae itinerib. tom. 2. edit. Graecolat. pag. 91.
d[Greek or Hebrew]. Basil. Se•enc. in Jonam orat. 2. pag. 114.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Basil. Se•enc. in Ionam orat. 2. pag. 114.
e[Greek or Hebrew]. Id in illud: Ecce as•endimus Hierosolym. pag. 268.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id in illud: Ecce as•endimus Hierosolym. pag. 268.
f[Greek or Hebrew]. Id. in Eliam. pag. 97.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id. in Eliam. pag. 97.
g[Greek or Hebrew]. Ibid.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid.
h[Greek or Hebrew]. Id. in illud: Ecc• ascendimus Hierosolym. pag. 265.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id. in illud: Ecc• ascendimus Hierosolym. pag. 265.
i[Greek or Hebrew]; •b. pag. 268.〈non-Latin alphabet〉; •b. pag. 268.
And thus, if my memory do not fail me, (for at this present I have not the book lying by me) is the article expressed in the Hebrew Creed, which is printed with Potken's qEthiopian Syllabary. [Greek or Hebrew] He descended ⟨p. 364⟩into the shadow of death. where the Hebrew Interpreter doth render Hades by the shadow of death: as the Greek Interpreters, in that text (which by the rFathers is applied to our Saviours descent into Hell) Job. 38.17. do render the shadow of death by Hades. for where the Hebrew hath [Greek or Hebrew] the gates of the shadow of death, they •eade; [Greek or Hebrew], the keepers of the gates of Hades seeing thee, shrank for fear. sThe resurrection from the dead therefore being the end of our Saviours suffering (as Eusebius notes) and so the beginning of his glorifying: the first degree of his exaltation would thus very aptly answer• unto the last degree of his humiliation that as his Resurrection is an arising from the dead, so his descending unto Hades or ad inferos should be no other thing but a going to the dead. For further confirmation whereof, let it be considered, that S. Hierome in the vulgar Latin translation of the Bible, hath ad inferos deducentur, Ecclesia••is 9.3. where the Hebrew and Greek read, to the dead: and in like manner, Proverb 2.18. he hath ad inferos againe, where [Greek or Hebrew] is in the Hebrew; which being a word that sometimes signifieth the dead, and sometimes Giants, the LXX. do join both together and read, [Greek or Hebrew], in Hades •ith the Giants. So in the Sibylline verses cited by tLactantius, — [Greek or Hebrew], that he may speak unto the dead; is in uProsper translated, Ut inferis l•quatur: and those other verses touching our Saviours Resurrection
x[Greek or Hebrew]
[Greek or Hebrew].
Then coming forth from the Dead, &c. are thus turned ⟨p. 365⟩into Latin in Prosper. yTunc ab inferis regressus, ad lucem veniet primus resurrectionis principio revocatis ostenso. Then returning from Hell, he shall come unto the light first showing the beginning of the Resurrection unto those whom he shall call back from thence. for zChrist returning back a conqueror from Hades unto life (as Basil of Seleucia writeth) the dead were taught the reviving again unto life. His arising from the Dead, was the loosing of us from Hades: saith Gregory Nazianzen. bHe was raised from Hades or from the dead;
And thus, if my memory do not faile me, (for at this present I have not the booke lying by me) is the article expressed in the Hebrew Creed, which is printed with Potkens qAethiopian Syllabarie. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 He descended ⟨p. 364⟩into the shadow of death. where the Hebrew Interpreter doth render Hades by the shadow of death: as the Greeke Interpreters, in that text (which by the rFathers is applied to our Saviours descent into Hell) Iob. 38.17. doe render the shadow of death by Hades. for where the Hebrew hath 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 the gates of the shadow of death, they •eade; 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, the keepers of the gates of Hades seeing thee, shranke for feare. sThe resurrection from the dead therefore being the end of our Saviours s•ffering (as Eusebius notes) and so the beginning of his glorifying: the first degree of his exaltation would thus very aptly answer• unto the last degree of his humiliation that as his Resurrection is an arising from the dead, so his descending unto Hades or ad inferos should be no other thing but a going to the dead. For further confirmation whereof, let it be considered, that S. Hierome in the vulgar Latin translation of the Bible, hath ad inferos deducentur, Ecclesia••is 9.3. where the Hebrew and Greeke reade, to the dead: and in like manner, Proverb 2.18. he hath ad inferos againe, where 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 is in the Hebrew; which being a word that somtimes signifieth the dead, and somtimes Gyants, the LXX. doe joyne both together and reade, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, in Hades •ith the Giants. So in the Sibylline verses cyted by tLactantius, — 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that he may speake unto the dead; is in
qSyllabar. Aethiopic. ad calcem Psalterij, edit. Hebraic. Graec. Latin. & Aethiopic. in fol.
and raised me being dead with him: saith Nectarius, his successor in the See of Constantinople. Therefore is he called cthe first begotten of the dead, because he was the first that rose from Hades; as we also shall rise at his second coming: saith the author of the Treatise of Definitions, among the works of Athanasius.
and raysed me being dead with him: saith Nectarius, his successor in the See of Constantinople. Therefore is he called cthe first begotten of the dead, because he was the first that rose from Hádes; as we also shall rise at his second comming: saith the author of the Treatise of Definitions, among the workes of Athanasius.
c[Greek or Hebrew]. Tract. de Definitionib tom. 2. Oper. Athanas. Graecolat. pag. 59.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Tract. de Definitionib tom. 2. Oper. Athanas. Graecolat. pag. 59.
To lay down all the places of the Fathers, wherein our Lords rising again from the Dead, is termed his rising again from Hades, Inferi or Hell, would be a needless labour: for this we need go no further then to the Canon of the Mass it self; where in the prayer that followeth next after the Consecration, there being a Commemoration made of Christs passion, resurrection, and ascension, the second is set out by the title ab inferis resurrectionis, of the resurrection from Hell. For as the dLiturgies of the Eastern Churches do here make mention [Greek or Hebrew] of the resurrection from the dead: so those of the eWest retain that other title of the resurrection ab inferis, that is [Greek or Hebrew] (as it is in the Liturgy that goeth under the name ⟨p. 348⟩of S. Peter) or [Greek or Hebrew], as it is in the Gregorian Office translated into Greek by Codinus. If then the resurrection from the dead be the same with the resurrection from Hades, Inferi or Hell: why may not the going unto Hades, Inferi or Hell, be interpreted, by the same reason, to be the going unto the dead? whereby no more is understood, than what is intimated in that phrase wch the Latins use of one that hath left this world; Abijt ad plures: or in that of the Hebrews, so frequent in the word of God; He fwent or was gathered unto his people, he went or was gathered unto his fathers. which being applied unto a whole generation, Judg. 2.10. as well as in other places unto particular persons; must of necessity denote the common condition of men departed out of this life.
To lay downe all the places of the Fathers, wherein our Lords rising againe from the Dead, is termed his rising againe from Hádes, Inferi or Hell, would be a needlesse labour: for this we need go no further then to the Canon of the Masse it selfe; where in the prayer that followeth next after the Consecration, there being a Commemoration made of Christs passion, resurrection, and ascension, the second is set out by the title ab inferis resurrectionis, of the resurrection from Hell. For as the dLiturgies of the Easterne Churches doe here make mention 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 of the resurrection from the dead: so those of the eWest retayne that other title of the resurrection ab inferis, that is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 (as it is in the Liturgie that goeth under the name ⟨p. 348⟩of S. Peter) or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, as it is in the Gregorian Office translated into Greek by Codinus. If then the resurrection frō the dead be the same with the resurrection from Hades, Inferi or Hell: why may not the going unto Hades, Inferi or Hell, be interpreted, by the same reason, to be the going unto the dead? whereby no more is understood, than what is intimated in that phrase wch the Latins use of one that hath left this world; Abijt ad plures: or in that of the Hebrewes, so frequent in the word of God; He fwent or was gathered unto his people, he went or was gathered unto his fathers. which being applied unto a whole generation, Iudg. 2.10. as well as in other places unto particular persons; must of necessitie denote the common condition of men departed out of this life.
Now, although Death and Hades, dying and going to the dead, be of near affinity one with the other: yet be they not the same thing properly, but the one a consequent of the other; as it appeareth plainly by the vision, Revelat. 6.8. where Hades is directly brought in as a follower of Death. gDeath it self, as wise men do define it, is nothing else but the separation of the soul from the body; which is done in an instant: but Hades is the continuation of the body and soul in this state of separation, which lasteth all that space of time which is betwixt the day of death and the day of the resurrection. For as the state of hlife is comprehended betwixt two extremes, to wit, the beginning thereof and the ending; and there be itwo motions in nature answerable thereunto, the one whereby the soul concurreth to the body, (which we kcall Generation) the other whereby ⟨p. 349⟩the body is severed from the soul (which we call Death:) so the state of death in like manner is contained betwixt two bounds, the beginning, which is the very same with the ending of the other; and the last end, the motion whereunto is called the Resurrection, whereby the body and soul formerly separated are joined together again. Thus there be three terms here, as it were in a kind of a continued proportion, the middlemost whereof hath relation to either of the extremes: and by the motion to the first a man may be said to be natus, to the second denatus, to the third renatus. The first & the third have a like opposition unto the middle; and therefore are like betwixt themselves: the one being a generation, the other a regeneration. For that our Lord doth call the last Resurrection the Regeneration, Matth. 19.28. lS. Augustine supposeth that no man doubteth. Neither would our Lord himself have been styled m[Greek or Hebrew] the first borne from the dead; unless the Resurrection were accounted to be a kind of a new nativity: whereof he himself was in the first place to be made partaker, nthat among all or in all things he might have the preeminence; the rest of othe sons of God being to be children of the Resurrection also, but in their due time, and in the order of Post-nati.
Now, although Death and Hades, dying and going to the dead, be of neere affinitie one with the other: yet be they not the same thing properly, but the one a consequent of the other; as it appeareth plainely by the vision, Revelat. 6.8. where Hades is directly brought in as a follower of Death. gDeath it selfe, as wise men doe define it, is nothing else but the separation of the soule from the body; which is done in an instant: but Hades is the continuation of the body and soule in this state of separation, which lasteth all that space of time which is betwixt the day of death and the day of the resurrection. For as the state of hlife is comprehended betwixt two extreames, to wit, the beginning thereof and the ending; and there be itwo motions in nature answerable thereunto, the one whereby the soule concurreth to the body, (which we kcall Generation) the other whereby ⟨p. 349⟩the body is severed from the soule (which we call Death:) so the state of death in like maner is contained betwixt two bounds, the beginning, which is the very same with the ending of the other; and the last end, the motion whereunto is called the Resurrection, whereby the body and soule formerly separated are joyned together againe. Thus there be three tearmes here, as it were in a kinde of a continued proportion, the middlemost whereof hath relation to eyther of the extremes: and by the motion to the first a man may be said to be natus, to the second denatus, to the third renatus. The first & the third have a like oppositiō unto the middle; and therefore are like betwixt themselves: the one being a generation, the other a regeneration. For that our Lord doth call the last Resurrection the Regeneration, Matth. 19.28. lS. Augustine supposeth that no man doubteth. Neyther would our Lord himselfe have beene styled m〈non-Latin alphabet〉 the first borne from the dead; unlesse the Resurrection were accounted to be a kinde of a new nativitie: whereof he himselfe was in the first place to be made partaker,
gMortem nihil aliud esse definiunt sapientes, nisi separationem animae á corpore. Origen. tractat. 35. in Matth. cap. 27. Vid. Tertullian. de Animâ, cap. 27. & 51. & August. de Civit. Dei. lib. 13. cap. 6.
The middle distance betwixt the first and second term, that is to say, the space of life which we lead in this world betwixt the time of our birth and the time of our death; is opposite to the distance that is betwixt the second and third term, that is to say, the state of death under which man lieth from the time of his departure out of this life unto the time of his resurrection: and see what difference there is betwixt our ⟨p. 368⟩birth, and the life which we spend here after we are borne; the same difference is there betwixt Death and Hades, in that other state of our dissolution. That which properly we call Death (which is the parting a sunder of the soul and the body) standeth as a middle term betwixt the state of life and the state of death, being nothing else but the ending of the one, and the beginning of the other: and as it were a common mere between lands, or a communis terminus in a Geometrical magnitude, dividing part from part, but being it self a part of neither, and yet belonging equally unto either. Which gave occasion to the question moved by Taurus the philosopher: pWhen a dying man might be said to die; when he was now dead, or while he was yet living? whereunto Gellius returneth an answer out of Plato: qthat his dying was to be attributed neither to the time of his life nor of his death (because repugnances would arise either of those ways) but to the time which was in the confine betwixt both; which Plato calleth r[Greek or Hebrew], a moment or an instant, and denieth to be properly any part of time at all. Therefore Death doth his part in an instant (as hath been said) but Hades continueth that work of his, and holdeth the dead as it were under conquest, until the time of the resurrection; swherein shall be brought to pass the saying that is written. O Death, where is thy sting? O Hades, where is thy victory? For tthese things shall rightly be spoken then (saith Irenaeus) when this mortal and corruptible flesh (about which Death is, and which is holden down by a certain dominion of ⟨p. 369⟩Death) rising up unto life shall put on incorruption and immortality. for then shall death be truly overcome, when the flesh that is holden by it, shall come forth out of the Dominion thereof.
The middle distance betwixt the first and second terme, that is to say, the space of life which we lead in this world betwixt the time of our birth and the time of our death; is opposite to the distance that is betwixt the second and third terme, that is to say, the state of death under which man lyeth from the time of his departure out of this life unto the time of his resurrection: and see what difference there is betwixt our ⟨p. 368⟩birth, and the life which we spend here after wee are borne; the same difference is there betwixt Death and Hades, in that other state of our dissolution. That which properly we call Death (which is the parting a sunder of the soule and the body) standeth as a middle terme betwixt the state of life and the state of death, being nothing else but the ending of the one, and the beginning of the other: and as it were a common meare between lands, or a communis terminus in a Geometricall magnitude, dividing part from part, but being it selfe a part of neyther, and yet belonging equally unto eyther. Which gave occasion to the question moved by Taurus the philosopher: pWhen a dying man might be said to die; when he was now dead, or while hee was yet living? whereunto Gellius returneth an answere out of Plato: qthat his dying was to be attributed neyther to the time of his life nor of his death (because repugnances would arise eyther of those wayes) but to the time which was in the confine betwixt both; which Plato calleth r〈non-Latin alphabet〉, a moment or an instant, and denieth to be properly any part of time at all. Therefore Death doth his part in an instant (as hath beene said) but Hádes continueth that worke of his, and holdeth the dead as it were under conquest, untill the time of the resurrection; swherein shall be brought to passe the saying that is written. O Death, where is thy sting? O Hades, where is thy victorie? For tthese things shall rightly be spoken then (saith Irenaeus) when this mortall and corruptible flesh (about which Death is, and which is holden downe by a certaine dominion of ⟨p. 369⟩Death) rising up unto life shall put on incorruption and immortalitie. for then shall death be truly overcome, when the flesh that is holden by it, shall come forth out of the Dominion thereof.
pQuando moriens moreretur; cùm jam in morte esset, an tum etiam cùm in vitâ foret. Taur.
qPlato neque vitae id tempus, neque morti dedit (vidit quippe utrumque esse pugnans) sed tempori in confinio. A. Gel. N•ct. Attic. lib. 6. cap. 13.Plato neque vitae id tempus, neque morti dedit (vidit quippe utrumque esse pugnans) sed tempori in confinio. A. Gell. N•ct. Attic. lib. 6. cap. 13.
r[Greek or Hebrew]. (all. [Greek or Hebrew].) Plat•. in Parmenide, pag. 67,〈non-Latin alphabet〉. (al. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.) Plat•. in Parmenide, pag. 67,
tHaec justé dicentur tunc, quando mortalis haec & corruptibilis caro (circa quam & mors est, quae & quodam dominio mortis pressa est) in vitam conscendens, induerit incorruptelam & immortalitatē. Tunc enim veré erit victa mors, quando ea quae continetur ab eâ caro, exierit de dominio ejus. Irenae. lib. 5. cap. 13.Haec justé dicentur tunc, quando mortalis haec & corruptibilis caro (circa quam & mors est, quae & quodam dominio mortis pressa est) in vitam conscendens, induerit incorruptelam & immortalitatē. Tunc enim veré erit victa mors, quando ea quae continetur ab eâ caro, exierit de dominio ejus. Irenae. lib. 5. cap. 13.
Death then, as it importeth the separation of the soul from the body (which is the proper acception of it) is a thing distinguishable from Hades, as an antecedent from his consequent: but as it is taken for the whole state of death, and the domination which it hath over the dead ([Greek or Hebrew] Basilius Seleuciensis calleth it, in his oration upon Elijah) it is the self same thing that Hades is; and in that respect (as we have seen) the words are sometimes indifferently put, the one for the other.
Death then, as it importeth the separation of the soule from the body (which is the proper acception of it) is a thing distinguishable from Hades, as an antecedent from his consequent: but as it is taken for the whole state of death, and the domination which it hath over the dead (〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Basilius Seleuciensis calleth it, in his oration upon Elias) it is the selfe same thing that Hades is; and in that respect (as we have seene) the words are sometimes indifferently put, the one for the other.
As therefore our Saviour (that we may apply this now unto him) after he was fastened and lifted up on the Cross, if he had come down from thence (as uthe standers by in mocking wise did wish him to do) might be truly said to have been crucified, but not to have dyed: so when he gave up the ghost, and laid down his life, if he had presently taken it up again, he might truly be said to have dyed, but not to have gone to the dead, or to have been in Hádes. His remaining under the power of Death until the third day, made this good. Whom God did raise up, loosing the sorrows of death, xforasmuch as it was not possible that he should be holden of it: saith S. Peter. and Christ being raised from the dead, dyeth now no more, yDeath hath no more dominion over him: saith S. Paul. implying thereby, that during the space of time that passed betwixt his death and his resurrection, he was holden by death, and death had some kind of domination over him. And therefore Athanasius (or who ever else was author of that writing to Liberius the Roman Bishop) having reference ⟨p. 352⟩unto the former text; affirmeth that zhe raised up that buried body of his, and presented it to his Father, having freed it from Death, of which it was holden. and Maximus (or he that collected the Dialogues against the Marcionites, under the name of Origen, out of him) expounding the other text; aOver whom then had Death dominion? saith he. For the saying that it hath no more dominion, showeth that before it had dominion over him. Not that Death could have any dominion over bthe Lord of Life, further than he himself was pleased to give way unto it: but as, when Death did at the first seize upon him, chis life indeed was taken from the earth, yet dnone could take it from him, but he laid it down of himself; so his continuing to be Deaths prisoner for a time, was a voluntary commitment only, unto which he freely yielded himself for our sakes, not any yoke of miserable necessity that Death was able to impose upon him. For ehe had power to lay down his life, and he had power to take it again: yet would he not take it again, before he had first not laid himself down only upon Deaths bed, but slept also upon it; that arising afterward from thence, he might become fthe first fruits of them that slept. In which respect, the gFathers apply unto him that text of the Psalm;
As therefore our Sauiour (that we may apply this now unto him) after he was fastned and lifted up on the Crosse, if he had come downe from thence (as uthe standers by in mocking wise did wish him to doe) might be truly said to have beene crucified, but not to have dyed: so when he gave up the ghost, and layde downe his life, if he had presently taken it up againe, he might truly be said to have dyed, but not to have gone to the dead, or to have beene in Hádes. His remayning under the power of Death untill the third day, made this good. Whom God did rayse up, loosing the sorrowes of death, xforasmuch as it was not possible that he should be holden of it: saith S. Peter. and Christ being raysed from the dead, dyeth now no more, yDeath hath no more dominion over him: saith S. Paul. implying thereby, that during the space of time that passed betwixt his death and his resurrection, he was holden by death, and death had some kinde of domination over him. And therefore Athanasius (or who ever else was author of that writing to Liberius the Roman Bishop) having reference ⟨p. 352⟩unto the former text; affirmeth that zhe raysed up that buried body of his, and presented it to his Father, having freed it from Death, of which it was holden. and Maximus (or he that collected the Dialogues against the Marcionites, under the name of Origen, out of him) expounding the other text; aOver whom then had Death dominion? saith he. For the saying that it hath no more dominion, sheweth that before it had dominion over him. Not that Death could have any dominion over bthe Lord of Life, further than he himselfe was pleased to give way unto it: but as, when Death did at the first sease upon him, chis life indeed vvas taken from the earth, yet dnone could take it from him, but he layd it downe of himselfe; so his continuing to be Deaths prisoner for a time, was a voluntarie commitment only, unto which he freely yeelded himselfe for our sakes, not anie yoake of miserable necessitie that Death was able to impose upon him. For
I laid me down and slept, I awaked, for the Lord sustained me. (Psalm. 3.5.) and Lactantius that verse of Sibyl,
[Greek or Hebrew],
The term of death he shall finish, when he hath slept unto the third day.
His dying, or his burying at the farthest, is that which here is answerable unto his lying down: but his [Greek or Hebrew] or [Greek or Hebrew] (as hDionysius calleth it) his ⟨p. 353⟩his three-days burial, and his continuing for that time in the state of death, is that which answereth unto his sleeping or being in Hádes. And therefore the Fathers of the fourth Council of Toledo, declaring how in Baptism ithe death and resurrection of Christ is signified, do both affirm, that the dipping in the water is as it were a descension into Hell, and the rising out of the water again, a resurrection; and add likewise out of Gregory (with whom many other kDoctors do herein agree) that lthe three-fold dipping is used to signify the three-days burial. which differeth as much from the simple burial or putting into the earth, as [Greek or Hebrew] doth from [Greek or Hebrew], the transportation or leading into captivity from the detaining in bondage, the committing of one to prison from the holding of him there, and the sowing of the seed from the remaining of it in ground.
I layd me down and slept, I awaked, for the Lord sustained mee. (Psalm. 3.5.) and Lactantius that verse of Sibyll,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
The tearme of death he shall finish, when he hath slept unto the third day.
His dying, or his burying at the farthest, is that which here is answerable unto his lying downe: but his 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 (as hDionysius calleth it) his ⟨p. 353⟩his three-dayes buriall, and his continuing for that time in the state of death, is that which answereth unto his sleeping or being in Hádes. And therefore the Fathers of the fourth Councell of Toledo, declaring how in Baptisme ithe death and resurrection of Christ is signified, do both affirme, that the dipping in the water is as it were a descension into Hell, and the rising out of the water againe, a resurrection; and adde likewise out of Gregory (with whom many other kDoctors doe herein agree) that lthe three-fold dipping is used to signifie the three-dayes buriall. which differeth as much from the simple buriall or putting into the earth, as 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 doth from 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, the transportation or leading into captivitie from the detayning in bondage, the committing of one to prison from the holding of him there, and the sowing of the seed from the remayning of it in ground.
hDionys Ecclesiast. Hierarch. cap. 2.
iEt ne fortè cuiquam sit dubium hujus simply mysteriū sacramenti; videat in eo mortem & resurrectionem Christi significari. Nam in aquis mersio, quasi in infernum descensio est; & rursu• ab aquis emersio, resurrectio est. Concil. Toletan. IIII. cap. 5. (all. 6.)Et ne fortè cuiquam sit dubium hujus simpli mysteriū sacramenti; videat in eo mortem & resurrectionem Christi significari. Nam in aquis mersio, quasi in infernum descensio est; & rursu• ab aquis emersio, resurrectio est. Concil. Toletan. IIII. cap. 5. (al. 6.)
kDionys ut sup. Cyrill. vel Johan. Hierosolymitan. Cateches. 2. Mystagogic. Petrus Chrysologus, serm. 113. Leo I. epist 4. cap. 3. Paschasius de Spiritu S. lib. 2. cap. 5. Jo. Damascene. Orthodox. fid. lib. 4. cap. 10. Germanus in rer. Ecclesiast. Theoria. Walafrid, Strab. de reb. Ecclesiastic. cap. 26. Theophylact. in Johan. cap. 3.Dionys ut sup. Cyrill. vel Iohan. Hierosolymitan. Cateches. 2. Mystagogic. Petrus Chrysologus, serm. 113. Leo I. epist 4. cap. 3. Paschasius de Spiritu S. lib. 2. cap. 5. Io. Damascen. Orthodox. fid. lib. 4. cap. 10. Germanus in rer. Ecclesiast. Theoria. Walafrid, Strab. de reb. Ecclesiastic. cap. 26. Theophylact. in Iohan. cap. 3.
lNos autem quòd tertiò mergimus, triduanae sepulturae sacramenta signamus: ut dum tertiò infans ab aquis educitur, resurrectio triduani temporis exprimatur, Concil. Toletan. ex Gregorio, lib. 1. Registri, epist. 41.
And thus have I unfolded at large the general acceptions of the word Hades and Inferi, and so the Ecclesiastical use of the word Hell answering thereunto: which being severally applied to the point of our Saviours descent, make up these three propositions that by the universal consent of Christians are acknowledged to be of undoubted verity. His dead body, though free from corruption, yet did descend into the place of corruption, as other bodies do. His soul, being separated from his body, departed hence into the other world, as all other mens souls in that case use to do. He went unto the dead, and remained for a time in the state of death, as other dead men do. There remaineth now ⟨p. 372⟩the vulgar acception of the word Hell, whereby it is taken for the place of torment prepared for the Devil and his Angels: and touching this also, all Christians do agree thus far, that Christ did descend thither at leastwise in a virtual manner; as God mis said to descend, when he doth any thing upon earth, which being wonderfully done beyond the usual course of nature may in some sort show his presence, or when he otherwise nvouchsafeth to have care of human frailty. Thus when Christs oflesh was in the tomb, his power did work from Heaven: saith S. Ambrose. which agreeth with that which was before cited out of the Armenians Confession: pAccording to his body which was dead, he descended into the grave; but according to his DIVINITY, which did live, he overcame Hell in the mean time. and with that which was cited out of Philo Carpathius, upon Cantic. 5.2. I sleep, but my heart waketh: qin the grave spoiling Hell. for which, in the Latin Collections that go under his name, we read thus. rI sleep, to wit on the Cross, and my heart waketh: when my DIVINITY spoiled Hell, and brought rich spoils from the triumph of everlasting death overcome, and the Devils power overthrown. The author of the imperfect work upon Matthew, attributeth this to the Divinity, not clothed with any part of the Humanity, but naked, as he speaketh. Seeing the Devils sfeared him, (saith he) while he was in the body, saying; What have we to do with thee, Jesus the son of the high God? art thou come to torment us before our ⟨p. 373⟩time? how shall they be able to endure his NAKED DIVINITY descending against them?
And thus have I unfolded at large the generall acceptions of the word Hádes and Inferi, and so the Ecclesiasticall use of the word Hell answering thereunto: which being severally applyed to the point of our Saviours descent, make up these three propositions that by the universall consent of Christians are acknowledged to be of undoubted verity. His dead body, though free from corruption, yet did descend into the place of corruption, as other bodies doe. His soule, being separated from his body, departed hence into the other world, as all other mens soules in that case use to doe. He went unto the dead, and remayned for a time in the state of death, as other dead men doe. There remayneth now ⟨p. 372⟩the vulgar acception of the word Hell, whereby it is taken for the place of torment prepared for the Divell and his Angells: and touching this also, all Christians do agree thus farre, that Christ did descend thither at leastwise in a virtuall maner; as God mis said to descend, when he doth any thing upon earth, which being wonderfully done beyond the usuall course of nature may in some sort shew his presence, or when he otherwise nvouchsafeth to have care of humaine frailtie. Thus when Christs oflesh was in the tombe, his power did worke from Heaven: saith S. Ambrose. which agreeth with that which was before cyted out of the Armenians Confession: pAccording to his body which was dead, he descended into the grave; but according to his DIVINITIE, which did live, he overcame Hell in the meane time. and with that which was cyted out of Philo Carpathius, upon Cantic. 5.2. I sleepe, but my heart waketh: qin the grave spoyling Hell. for which, in the Latin Collections that goe under his name, we reade thus. rI sleepe, to wit on the Crosse, and my heart waketh: vvhen my DIVINITIE spoyled Hell, and brought rich spoyles from the triumph of everlasting death overcome, and the Divells power overthrowne. The author of the imperfect worke upon Matthew, attributeth this to the Divinitie, not cloathed with any part of the Humanitie, but naked, as he speaketh. Seeing the Divels
mDescendere dicitur, cùm aliquid facit in terrâ, quod praeter usitatū naturae cursum mirabiliter sactum praesentiam quodam modo ejus ostendat. August. de Civit. Dei, lib. 16. cap. 5.Descendere dicitur, cùm aliquid facit in terrâ, quod praeter usitatū naturae cursum mirabiliter sactum praesentiam quodam modo ejus ostendat. August. de Civit. Dei, lib. 16. cap. 5.
nDescendere dicitur Deus; quando curam humanae fragi litatis habere dignatur. Aug. serm. 70. de Tempore.
oErat caro ejus in monumento; sed virtus ejus operabaturé coelo. Ambros. de Incarnat. cap. 5.
pSupr. pag. 3 22
qSupr. pag. 317
rEgo dormio, in Cruce scilicèt, & cor meū vigilat: cùm divinitas Tartara spoliavit, & opima spolia retulit de triumpho superatae mortis aeternae, atque dejectae diabolicae potestatis. Philo Carpath. in Cantic. 5.Ego dormio, in Cruce scilicèt, & cor meū vigilat: cùm divinitas Tartara spoliavit, & opima spolia retulit de triumpho superatae mortis aeternae, atque dejectae diabolicae potestatis. Philo Carpath. in Cantic. 5.
sQuem in corpore constitutum timuerunt, dicentes; Quid nobis & tibi, Jesu fili Dei excelsi? venisti ante tempus torquere nos? quomodo nudam ipsam divinitatem contra see descendentem pote•unt sustinere? Ecce post tres dies mortis suae revertetur ab inferis, quasi victor de bello. Op. imperfect. in Matth. homil. 35. tom. 2. Chrysostom.Quem in corpore constitutum timuerunt, dicentes; Quid nobis & tibi, Iesu fili Dei excelsi? venisti ante tempus torquere nos? quomodo nudam ipsam divinitatem contra se descendentem pote•unt sustinere? Ecce post tres dies mortis suae revertetur ab inferis, quasi victor de bello. Op. imperfect. in Matth. homil. 35. tom. 2. Chr•sost•m.
This conquest others do attribute to his Cross, others to his Death, others to his Burial, others to the real descent of his soul into the place of the damned, others to his Resurrection: and extend the effect thereof not only to the delivery of the Fathers of the old Testament, but also to the freeing of our souls from Hell. from whence how men may be said to have been delivered, who never were there, S. Augustin declareth by these similitudes. tThou sayest rightly to the physician, Thou hast freed me from this sickness; not in which thou wast, but in which thou wast like to be. Some body else having a troublesome business, was to be cast into prison: there cometh another, and defendeth him. what saith he, when he giveth thanks? Thou hast delivered me from prison. A debtor was in danger to be hanged: the debt is paid for him; he is said to be freed from hanging. In all these things they were not: but because such were their deserts, that unless they had been holpen, there they would have been; they say rightly that they were freed thence, whither by those that freed them they were not suffered to be brought. That Christ destroyed the power of Hell, uspoiled principalities and powers, and made a show of them openly, triumphing over them: is acknowledged by all Christians. Neither is there any who will refuse to subscribe unto that which Proclus delivered in his Sermon before Nestorius then Bishop of Constantinople (inserted into the Acts of the Council ⟨p. 374⟩of Ephesus.) xHe was shut up in the grave, who stretched out the heavens like a skin: he was reckoned among the dead, and spoiled Hell. and that which S. Cyril and the Synod of Alexandria, wrote unto the same Nestorius, concerning the Confession of their faith: (approved not only by the ythird general Council held at Ephesus, but also by the zfourth at Chalcedon, and the afifth at Constantinople.) bTo the end that by his unspeakable power treading down death in his own as the first and principal flesh, he might become the first borne from the dead and the first fruits of those that slept; and that he might make a way to mans nature for the turning back again unto incorruption: by the grace of God he tasted death for all men; and revived the third day, spoiling Hell. All, I say, do agree, that Christ spoiled or (as they were wont to speak) harrowed Hell:
This conquest others do attribute to his Crosse, others to his Death, others to his Buriall, others to the reall descent of his soule into the place of the damned, others to his Resurrection: and extend the effect therof not only to the deliverie of the Fathers of the old Testament, but also to the freeing of our soules from Hell. from whence how men may be said to have been delivered, who never were there, S. Augustin declareth by these similitudes. tThou sayest rightly to the physician, Thou hast freed me from this sicknesse; not in vvhich thou wast, but in which thou wast like to be. Some bodie else having a troublesome businesse, was to be cast into prison: there commeth another, and defendeth him. vvhat saith he, when he giveth thankes? Thou hast delivered me from prison. A debtor was in danger to be hanged: the debt is payd for him; he is said to be freed from hanging. In all these things they were not: but because such were their deserts, that unlesse they had beene holpen, there they would have beene; they say rightly that they were freed thence, vvhither by those that freed them they vvere not suffered to be brought. That Christ destroyed the power of Hell, uspoyled principalities and powers, and made a shew of them openly, triumphing over them: is acknowledged by all Christians. Neyther is there anie who will refuse to subscribe unto that which Proclus delivered in his Sermon before Nestorius then Bishop of Constantinople (inserted into the Acts of the Councell ⟨p. 374⟩of Ephesus.) xHe was shut up in the grave, who stretched out the heavens like a skinne: he was reckoned among the dead, and spoyled Hell. and that which S. Cyrill and the Synod of Alexandria, wrote unto the same Nestorius, concerning the Confession of their faith: (approved not only by the ythird generall Councell held at Ephesus, but also by the zfourth at Chalcedon, and the afifth at Constantinople.) bTo the end that by his unspeakable power treading down death in his own as the first and principall flesh, he might become the first borne from the dead and the first fruits of those that slept; and that he might make a way to mans nature for the turning back againe unto incorruption: by the grace of God he tasted death for all men; and revived the third day, spoyling Hell. All, I say, do agree, that Christ spoyled or (as they were wont to speake) harrowed Hell:
tRecté dicis medico, Liberâsti me ab aegritudine; non in quâ jam eras, sed in quâ futurus eras. Nescio quis habens caussā molestam, mittendus erat in carcerem: venit alius, defendit eum. gratias agens, quid dicit? Eruisti animam meam de carcere Suspendendus erat debitor: solutum est pro eo; liberatus dicitur de suspendio In his omnibus non erant: sed quia talibus meritis agebantur, ut, nisi subventum esset, ibi essent; inde se recté dicunt liberari, quò per liberatores suos non sunt permissi perduci. Augustin. in Psalm. 85.Recté dicis medico, Liberâsti me ab aegritudine; non in quâ jam eras, sed in quâ futurus eras. Nescio quis habens caussā molestam, mittendus erat in carcerem: venit alius, defendit eum. gratias agens, quid dicit? Eruisti animam meam de carcere Suspendendus erat debitor: solutum est pro eo; liberatus dicitur de suspendio In his omnibus non erant: sed quia talibus meritis agebantur, ut, nisi subventum esset, ibi essent; inde se recté dicunt liberari, quò per liberatores suos non sunt permissi perduci. Augustin. in Psalm. 85.
whether you take Hell for that which keepeth the soul separated from the body, or that which separateth soul and body both from the blessed presence of him who is our true life; the one whereof our Saviour hath conquered by bringing in the Resurrection of the body, the other he hath abolished by procuring for us Life everlasting.
whether you take Hell for that which keepeth the soule separated from the body, or that which separateth soule and body bothe from the blessed presence of him who is our true life; the one whereof our Saviour hath conquered by bringing in the Resurrection of the body, the other he hath abolished by procuring for us Life everlasting.
Touching the manner and the means, whereby Hell was thus spoiled, is all the disagreement. The manner: whether our Lord did deliver his people from Hell by way of prevention, in saving them from coming thither; or by way of subvention, in helping those out whom at the time of his death he found there. The means: whether this were done by his Divinity or his Humanity or both, whether by the virtue of his sufferings, death, burial and resurrection, or by the real descending of his soul into the place wherein mens souls were kept imprisoned. That he descended not ⟨p. 375⟩into the Hell of the damned by the essence of his soul or locally, but virtually only by extending the effect of his power thither: is the common doctrine of cThomas Aquinas and the rest of the School. Cardinal Bellarmine at first held it to be dprobable, that Christs soul did descend thither, not only by his effects, but by his real presence also: but afterwards ehaving considered better of the matter, he resolved that the opinion of Thomas and the other Schoolmen was to be followed. The same is the judgement of fSuarez: who concerning this whole article of Christs descent into Hell, doth thus deliver his mind. gIf by an Article of faith we understand a truth, which all the faithful are bound explicitly to know and believe: so I do not think it necessary to reckon this among the Articles of faith. Because it is not a matter altogether so necessary for all men: and because that for this reason peradventure it is omitted in the Nicene Creed; the knowledge of which Creed seemeth to be sufficient for fulfilling the precept of faith. Lastly for this cause peradventure Augustin and other of the Fathers expounding the Creed, do not unfold this mystery unto the people. And to speak the truth, it is a matter above the reach of the common people to enter into the discussion of the full meaning of this point of the descension into Hell: the determination whereof dependeth upon the knowledge of the learned tongues and other sciences that come not within the compass of their understanding. some experiment whereof they may find in this; that whereas in the other questions here handled, they might find themselves able in some ⟨p. 376⟩reasonable for to follow me; here they leave me, I doubt, and let me walk without their company.
Touching the maner and the meanes, whereby Hell was thus spoyled, is all the disagreement. The maner: whether our Lord did deliver his people from Hell by way of prevention, in saving them from comming thither; or by way of subvention, in helping those out whom at the time of his death he found there. The meanes: whether this were done by his Divinity or his Humanitie or both, whether by the vertue of his sufferings, death, buriall and resurrection, or by the reall descending of his soule into the place wherein mens soules were kept imprisoned. That hee descended not ⟨p. 375⟩into the Hell of the damned by the essence of his soule or locally, but virtually onely by extending the effect of his power thither: is the common doctrine of cThomas Aquinas and the rest of the Schoole. Cardinall Bellarmine at first held it to be dprobable, that Christs soule did descend thither, not only by his effects, but by his reall presence also: but afterwards ehaving considered better of the matter, he resolved that the opinion of Thomas and the other Schoolemen was to be followed. The same is the judgement of fSuarez: who concerning this whole article of Christs descent into Hell, doth thus deliver his minde. gIf by an Article of faith we understand a truth, which all the faithfull are bound explicitly to know and beleeve: so I doe not thinke it necessarie to reckon this among the Articles of faith. Because it is not a matter altogether so necessary for all men: and because that for this reason peradventure it is omitted in the Nicene Creed; the knowledge of which Creed seemeth to be sufficient for fulfilling the precept of faith. Lastly for this cause peradventure Augustin and other of the Fathers expounding the Creed, doe not unfold this mysterie unto the people. And to speake the truth, it is a matter above the reach of the common people to enter into the discussion of the full meaning of this point of the descension into Hell: the determination whereof dependeth upon the knowledge of the learned tongues and other sciences that come not within the compasse of their understanding. some experiment whereof they may finde in this; that whereas in the other questions here handled, they might finde themselves able in some ⟨p. 376⟩
cThom. in Sum. part. 3. quaest 62. art. 2.
dBellarm lib. 4. •e Ch•isto, cap. 16.
eRe meliùs conside•atá, sequendam esse existimo sententiā S. Thoma•, quae estaliorum Scholastico•um in 3. Sent dist. 22. Id. in Recognition Op•rum.Re meliùs conside•atá, sequendam esse existimo sententiā S. Thoma•, quae estaliorum Scholastico•um in 3. Sent dist. 22. Id. in Recognitione Op•rum.
gSi nomine articuli intelligamus veritatem, quam omnes fideles explicité scire ac cedar teneantur: sic non existimo necessarium hunc computare inter articulos fidei. Quia non est res ad modùm necessaria singulis hominibus: & quia ob hanc fortassè caussamin symbolo Niceno omittitur cujus symboli cognitio videtur esse sufficiens ad praeceptum fidei implendum. Denique proptero• fortè Aug. & alij Patres in principio citati exponentes symbolum, non explicant populo hoc mysterium. Id. ibid. sect. 2.Si nomine articuli intelligamus veritatem, quam omnes fideles explicité scire ac c•edere teneantur: sic non existimo necessarium hunc computare inter articulos fidei. Quia non est res ad modùm necessaria singulis hominibus: & quia ob hanc fortassè caussamin symbolo Niceno omittitur cujus symboli cognitio videtur esse sufficiens ad praeceptum fidei implendum. Denique proptero• fortè Aug. & alij Patres in principio citati exponentes symbolum, non explicant populo hoc mysterium. Id. ibid. sect. 2.
It having here likewise been further manifested, what different opinions have been entertained by the ancient Doctors of the Church concerning the determinate place wherein our Saviours soul did remain during the time of the separation of it from his body: I leave it to be considered by the learned, whether any such controverted matter may fitly be brought in to expound the hRule of faith by, which being common both to the great and the small ones in the Church, must contain such verities only as are generally agreed upon by the common consent of all true Christians. and if the words of the article of Christs going to Hades or Hell, may well bear such a general meaning as this; that he went to the dead, and continued in the state of death until the time of his Resurrection: it would be thought upon, whether such a truth as this, which findeth universal acceptance among all Christians may not safely pass for an article of our Creed; and the particular limitation of the place unto which our Saviours soul went (whither to the place of bliss, or to the place of torment, or to both) be left, as a number of other Theological points are, unto further disputation. In the articles of our faith common agreement must be required: which we are sure is more likely to be found in the general, than in the particular. And this is the only reason which moved me to enlarge my self so much in the declaration of the general acceptions of the word Hades, and the application of them to our Saviours descent spoken of in the Creed. wherein if the zeal which I bear to the peace of the Church, and the settlement of unity ⟨p. 377⟩among brethren hath carried me too far, (as it hath made me indeed quite to forget my intended brevity) I entreat the Reader to pardon me; and ceasing to be further troublesome unto him in the prosecution of this intricate argument, I pass to the next question
It having here likewise beene further manifested, what different opinions have beene entertayned by the ancient Doctors of the Church concerning the determinate place wherein our Saviours soule did remaine during the time of the separation of it from his body: I leave it to be considered by the learned, whether any such controverted matter may fitly be brought in to expound the hRule of faith by, which being common both to the great and the small ones in the Church, must contayn such verities only as are generally agreed upon by the common consent of all true Christians. and if the words of the article of Christs going to Hades or Hell, may well beare such a generall meaning as this; that he went to the dead, and continued in the state of death untill the time of his Resurrection: it would be thought upon, whether such a truth as this, which findeth universall acceptance among all Christians may not safely passe for an article of our Creed; and the particular limitation of the place unto which our Saviours soule went (whither to the place of blisse, or to the place of torment, or to both) be left, as a number of other Theologicall points are, unto further disputation. In the articles of our faith common agreement must bee required: which wee are sure is more likely to be found in the generall, than in the particular. And this is the onely reason which moved me to enlarge my selfe so much in the declaration of the generall acceptions of the word Hades, and the application of them to our Saviours descent spoken of in the Creed. wherein if the zeale which I beare to the peace of the Church, and the settlement of unitie ⟨p. 377⟩among brethren hath carried me too farre, (as it hath made me indeede quite to forget my intended brevity) I intreate the Reader to pardon me; and ceasing to be further troublesome unto him in the prosecution of this intricate argument, I passe to the next question
hRegulam fidei pusillis magnisque communem in Ecclesiâ perseveranter tenet. August. epist. 57. ad Dardaenum.Regulam fidei pusillis magnisque communem in Ecclesiâ perseveranter tenent. August. epist. 57. ad Dardaenum.
That one question of S. Paul, Rom. 10.14. How shall they call upon him, in whom they have not believed? among such as lust not to be contentious, will quickly put an end unto this question. For if none can be invocated but such as must be believed in; and none must be believed in but God alone: every one may easily discern, what conclusion will follow thereupon. Again, all Christians have been taught, that no part of divine worship is to be communicated unto any creature. for ait is written: Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve. But prayer is such a principal part of this service, that it is busually put for the whole: and the public place of Gods worship, hath from hence given it the denomination of cthe house of prayer. Furthermore, he that heareth our prayers, must be able to search the secrets of our hearts; and discern the inward disposition of our souls. For the pouring out of good words, and the offering up of external sighs and tears, are but the carcass only of a true prayer: the life thereof consisteth in the dpouring out of the very soul it self, and the sending up of those secret egroans of the spirit which cannot be uttered. But fhe that searcheth the ⟨p. 378⟩hearts, and only he, knoweth what is the mind of the spirit: he gheareth in heaven his dwelling place, and giveth to every man according to his ways, whose heart he knoweth. for he even he ONLY knoweth the hearts of all the children of men: as Solomon teacheth us in the prayer which he made at the dedication of the Temple. whereunto we may add that golden sentence of his father David for a conclusion: hO thou that hearest prayer, unto thee shall all flesh come.
THat one question of S. Paul, Rom. 10.14. How shall they call upon him, in whom they have not beleeved? among such as lust not to be contentious, will quickly put an end unto this question. For if none can be invocated but such as must be beleeved in; and none must be beleeved in but God alone: everie one may easily discerne, what conclusion will follow thereupon. Againe, all Christians have beene taught, that no part of divine worship is to be communicated unto any creature. for ait is written: Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him onely shalt thou serve. But prayer is such a principall part of this service, that it is busually put for the whole: and the publick place of Gods worship, hath from hence given it the denomination of cthe house of prayer. Furthermore, hee that heareth our prayers, must be able to search the secrets of our hearts; and discerne the inward disposition of our soules. For the pouring out of good words, and the offering up of externall sighes and teares, are but the carkase only of a true prayer: the life thereof consisteth in the dpouring out of the very soule it selfe, and the sending up of those secret egroanes of the spirit which cannot be uttered. But fhe that searcheth the ⟨p. 378⟩hearts, and onely he, knoweth vvhat is the minde of the spirit: he gheareth in heaven his dwelling place, and giveth to every man according to his wayes, whose heart he knoweth. for he even he ONELY knoweth the hearts of all the children of men: as Salomon teacheth us in the praier which he made at the dedication of the Temple. wherunto we may add that golden sentence of his father David for a conclusion: hO thou that hearest prayer, unto thee shall all flesh come.
If it be further here objected by us; that we find neither precept nor example of any of the Fathers of the old Testament, whereby this kind of p•aying to the souls of the Saints departed may be warranted: Cardinal Bellarmine will give us a reason for it. ifor therefore (saith he) the spirits of the Patriarchs and the Prophets before the coming of Christ were neither so worshipped nor invocated, as we do now worship and invocate the Apostles and Martyrs: because that they were detained as yet shut up in the prisons of Hell. But if this reason of his be grounded upon a false foundation (as we have already showed it to be) and the contrary supposition be most true; that the spirits of the Patriarchs and Prophets were not thus shut up in the prisons of Hell: then have we four thousand years prescription left unto us, to oppose against this innovation. We go further yet, and urge against them, that in the New Testament it self we can descry no footsteps of this new kind of Invocation, more then we did in the Scriptures of the old Testament. For this, Salmeron doth tell us, that kthe Scriptures which were made and ⟨p. 379⟩published in the primitive Church ought to found and explain Christ, who by the tacit suggestion of the Spirit did bring the Saints with him: and that it would have been a hard matter to enjoin this to the Jews; and to the Gentiles an occasion would be given thereby to think, that many Gods were put upon them in steed of the multitude of the Gods whom they had forsaken. So this new worship, you see, fetcheth his original neither from the Scriptures of the Old nor of the New Testament: but from I know not what tacit suggestion, which smelt so strongly of Idolatry, that at first it was not safe to acquaint either the Jews or the Gentiles therewith. But if any such sweet tradition as this were at first delivered unto the Church by Christ and his Apostles: we demand further, how it should come to pass, that for the space of 360. years together after the birth of our Saviour, we can find mention no where of any such thing? For howsoever our Challenger giveth it out, that prayer to Saints was of great account, amongst the Fathers of the primitive Church, for the first 400. years after Christ:
If it be further here ob•ected by us; that we finde neyther precept nor example of any of the Fathers of the old Testament, whereby this kinde of p•aying to the soules of the Saints departed may be warranted: Cardinall Bellarmine will give us a reason for it. ifor therefore (saith he) the spirits of the Patriarches and the Prophets before the comming of Christ were neyther so worshipped nor invocated, as we doe now worship and invocate the Apostles and Martyrs: because that they were detayned as yet shut up in the prisons of Hell. But if this reason of his be grounded upon a false foundation (as we have alreadie shewed it to be) and the contrary supposition be most true; that the spirits of the Patriarchs and Prophets were not thus shut up in the prisons of Hell: then have we foure thousand yeares prescription left unto us, to oppose against this innovation. We go further yet, and urge against them, that in the New Testament it selfe we can descry no footsteps of this new kinde of Invocation, more then we did in the Scriptures of the old Testament. For this, Salmeron doth tell us, that kthe Scriptures vvhich were made and ⟨p. 379⟩published in the primitive Church ought to found and explaine Christ, who by the tacite suggestion of the Spirit did bring the Saints with him: and that it would have beene a hard matter to enjoyne this to the Iewes; and to the Gentiles an occasion would be given thereby to thinke, that many Gods were put upon them in steed of the multitude of the Gods whom they had forsaken. So this new worship, you see, fetcheth his originall neyther from the Scriptures of the Old nor of the New Testament: but from I know not what tacite suggestion, which smelt so strongly of Idolatry, that at first it was not safe to acquaint eyther the Iewes or the Gentiles therewith. But if any such sweet tradition as this were at first delivered unto the Church by Christ and his Apostles: we demand further, how it should come to passe, that for the space of 360. yeares together after the birth of our Saviour, we can finde mention no where of any such thing? For howsoever our Challenger giveth it out, that prayer to Saints was of great account, amongst the Fathers of the primitive Church, for the first 400. years after Christ:
iNam id circò ante Christi adventum non ita colebantur, neque invocabantur spiritus Patriarcharū et Prophetarū, quemadmodū nunc Apostolos & Martyres colimus & invocamus: quòd illi adhuc inferni carceribus clausi detinebantur. Bellarmin. fin. Praefat. in Controvers. de Ecclesiá triumphante, in Ord. disputat.Nam id circò ante Christi adventum non ita colebantur, neque invocabantur spiritus Patriarcharū et Prophetarū, quemadmodū nunc Apostolos & Martyres colimus & invocamus: quòd illi adhuc inferni carceribus clausi detinebantur. Bellarmin. fin. Praefat. in Controvers. de Ecclesiá triumphante, in Ord. disputat.
kQuia Scripturas conditas & publicatas in primitivâ Ecclesiâ oportebat Christū fundare, & explicare, qui per tacitam suggestionem Spiritus Sanctos secum adducebat: & durum esset id Judaeis praecipere; & occasio daretur Gentibus put•ndi sibi exhibitos multos Deos pro multitudine Deorum quos relinquebant. Alphons. Salmer. in 1. Timoth. 2. disput. 8.Quia Scripturas conditas & publicatas in primitivâ Ecclesiâ oportebat Christū fundare, & explicare, qui per tacitam suggestionem Spiritus Sanctos secum adducebat: & durum esset id Iudaeis praecipere; & occasio daretur Gentibus put•ndi sibi exhibitos multos Deos pro multitudine Deorum quos relinquebant. Alphons. Salmer. in 1. Timoth. 2. disput. 8.
yet for nine parts of that time, I dare be bold to say, that he is not able to produce as much as one true testimony out of any Father, whereby it may appear, that any account at all was made of it; and for the tithe too, he shall find perhaps before we have done, that he is not like to carry it away so clearly as he weeneth.
yet for nine parts of that time, I dare be bold to say, that he is not able to produce as much as one true testimonie out of any Father, whereby it may appeare, that any account at all was made of it; and for the tithe too, he shall finde perhaps before we have done, that he is not like to carry it away so cleerly as he weeneth.
Whether those blessed spirits pray for us, is not the question here: but whether we are to pray unto them. That God only is to be prayed unto, is the doctrine that was once delivered unto the Saints, for which we so earnestly contend: the Saints praying for us doth no way cross this (for to whom should the Saints pray, ⟨p. 380⟩but to the lKing of Saints?) their being prayed unto, is the only stumbling block that lieth in this way. And therefore in those first times, the former of these was admitted by some, as a matter of probability: but the latter no way yielded unto, as being derogatory to the privilege of the Deity. Origen may be a witness of both: who touching the former writeth in this sort. mI do think thus, that all those fathers who are departed this life before us, do fight with us and assist us with their prayers: for so have I heard one of the elder Masters saying. and in another place. nMoreover if the Saints, that have left the body and be with Christ, do any thing and labour for us, in like manner as the Angels do who are employed in the ministry of our salvation: let this also remain among the hidden things of God, and the mysteries that are not to be committed unto writing. But because he thought that the Angels and Saints prayed for us: did he therefore hold it needful, that we should direct our prayers unto them? Hear, I pray you, his own answer; in his eighth book against Celsus the philosopher. oWe must endeavour to please God alone, who is above all things, and labour to have him propitious unto us, procuring his good will with godliness and all kind of virtue. And if Celsus will yet have us to procure the good will of any others, after him that is God over all: let him consider, that as when the body is moved, the motion of ⟨p. 381⟩the shadow thereof doth follow it; so in like manner, having God favourable unto us who is over all, it followeth that we shall have all his friends, both Angels and souls and spirits, loving unto us. For they have a fellow-feeling with them that are thought worthy to find favour from God. Neither are they only favourable unto such as be thus worthy, but they work with them also that are willing to do service unto him who is God over all, & are friendly to them, and pray with them, and entreat with them.
Whether those blessed spirits pray for us, is not the question here: but whether we are to pray unto them. That God onely is to be prayed unto, is the doctrine that was once delivered unto the Saints, for which we so earnestly contend: the Saints praying for us doth no way crosse this (for to whom should the Saints pray, ⟨p. 380⟩but to the lKing of Saints?) their being prayed unto, is the onely stumbling block that lyeth in this way. And therefore in those first times, the former of these was admitted by some, as a matter of probabilitie: but the latter no way yeelded unto, as being derogatorie to the priviledge of the Deitie. Origen may be a witnesse of both: who touching the former writeth in this sort. mI doe thinke thus, that all those fathers who are departed this life before us, doe fight with us and assist us with their prayers: for so have I heard one of the elder Masters saying. and in another place. nMoreover if the Saints, that have left the body and be with Christ, doe any thing and labour for us, in like maner as the Angels do vvho are imployed in the ministery of our salvation: let this also remaine among the hidden things of God, and the mysteries that are not to be committed unto writing. But because he thought that the Angels and Saints prayed for us: did he therefore hold it needfull, that we should direct our prayers unto them? Heare, I pray you, his owne answer; in his eighth booke against Celsus the philosopher. oWe must endevour to please God alone, who is above all things, and labour to have him propitious unto us, procuring his good will with godlinesse and all kinde of vertue. And if Celsus will yet have us to procure the good will of any others, after him that is God over all: let him consider, that as when the body is moved, the motion of ⟨p. 381⟩the shadow thereof doth follow it; so in like maner, having God favourable unto us who is over all, it followeth that we shall have all his friends, both Angels and soules and spirits, loving unto us. For they have a fellow-feeling with them that are thought worthy to finde favour from God. Neyther are they only favourable unto such as be thus worthy, but they worke with them also that are willing to doe service unto him who is God over all, & are friendly to them, and pray with them, and intreate with them.
mEgo sic arbitror, quòd omnes illi qui dormierunt ante nos patres, pugnent nobiscum & adjuvent nos orationibus suis Ita namque etiā quendam de senioribus magistris audivi dicentē. Origen. in Joshua. homil. 16.Ego sic arbitror, quòd omnes illi qui dormierunt ante nos patres, pugnent nobiscum & adjuvent nos orationibus suis Ita namque etiā quendam de senioribus magistris audivi dicentē. Origen. in Iosue. homil. 16.
nJam veró si etiam extra corpus positi sancti, qui cum Christo sunt, agunt aliquid, & laborant pro nobis ad similitudinem angelorum qui salutis nostrae ministeria procurant. etc. habeatur hoc quoque inter occulta Dei, nec chartis committenda mysteria. Id. lib. 2. in epist. ad Roman. cap. 2.Iam veró si etiam extra corpus positi sancti, qui cum Christo sunt, agunt aliquid, & laborant pro nobis ad similitudinem angelorum qui salutis nostrae ministeria procurant. etc. habeatur hoc quoque inter occulta Dei, nec chartis committenda mysteria. Id. lib. 2. in epist. ad Roman. cap. 2.
o[Greek or Hebrew]. Origen. lib. 8. contra Cels pag. 432.433.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Origen. lib. 8. contra Cels pag. 432.433.
So as we may be bold to say, that when men which with resolution propose unto them selves the best things do pray unto God, many thousands of the sacred powers pray together with them UNSPOKEN to.
So as wee may be bold to say, that when men which with resolution propose unto them selves the best things doe pray unto God, many thousands of the sacred powers pray together vvith them UNSPOKEN to.
•
aDigna fané inquisitu res est, ubinā sub Sole justi vitâ functi collocentur. Constat autem quòd in Paradiso: cùm dixerit Christus Latroni; Hodie mecum eris in Paradiso. Sciendumque est, quòd literalis Traditio Paradisum docet esse in terrâ. Nonnulli veró dixerunt, quòd Paradisus etiam est in inferno, id est, subterraneo loco: ad quam suam opinionem illud accommodant Evangelium. Dives Lazarum vidit, ipse tamen in inferiore demersus, cùm Lazarus eminentiore esset in loco, ubi esset Abraham. Verùm quomodocumque se habeant; illud proculdubio constat, tum ex praesenti Ecclesiastae nostri loco, tum ex omni •acrâ •cripturâ, futuros pios in prosperitate ac pace, in•ustos veró in supplicijs ac tormentis. Alijs autem placuit Paradisum esse in coelis: bonus autem ac ingenuus Ecclesiastes historiae sensum potiùs consectabitur. Olympiodor. in Ecclesiast. cap. 3.Digna fané inquisitu res est, ubinā sub Sole justi vitâ functi collocentur. Constat autem quòd in Paradiso: cùm dixerit Christus Latroni; Hodie mecum eris in Paradiso. Sciendumque est, quòd literalis Traditio Paradisum docet esse in terrâ. Nonnulli veró dixerunt, quòd Paradisus etiam est in inferno, id est, subterraneo loco: ad quam suam opinionem illud accommodant Euangelium. Dives Lazarum vidit, ipse tamen in inferiore demersus, cùm Lazarus eminentiore esset in loco, ubi esset Abraham. Verùm quomodocumque se habeant; illud proculdubio constat, tum ex praesenti Ecclesiastae nostri loco, tum ex omni •acrâ •cripturâ, futuros pios in prosperitate ac pace, in•ustos veró in supplicijs ac tormentis. Alijs autem placuit Paradisum esse in coelis: bonus autem ac ingenuus Ecclesiastes historiae sensum potiùs consectabitur. Olympiodor. in Ecclesiast. cap. 3.
descendo, it intendeth nothing lesse, then to signifie thereby the lower situation of the place unto which the removeall is noted to be made. If descending therfore in the Acts of the Apostles imply no such kind of thing: what necessitie is there; that thus of force it must be interpreted in the Creed of the Apostles? Menelaus declared unto us, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: saith King Antiochus, in his epistle unto the Iewes, 2.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉, into the house or chambers of Hádes. Thus then, they that take Hádes for the common receptacle of soules, doe interpret the context of the Creed, as Cardinall Cajetan before did the narration of Moses touching Abrahams giving up the ghost, being gathered to his people, and being buried, Genes. 25.8, 9. that the article of the death is to be r•ferred to the whole manhood, and the dissolution of the parts thereof; that of the buriall, to the body s•parated from the soule, and this of the descending into Hádes, to the soule separated f•om the body as if he had said. He suffered death truely, by a reall separation of his soule from his bodie: and after this dissolution, the same did befall him that useth to betide all other dead men;
⟨p. 358⟩
The sonne of Cleonicus wisheth that with such manners he may meet and receive Hades (that is, death) and hoare old age. So another Poet, cyted by
. aswell in the copies of the text as in the citations of the ancient Fathers: which was the lesse regarded, because that varietie in the words bredd little or no difference at all in the sense. Therefore Epiphanius in one place, having respect to the beginning of the verse, saith that Christ loosed
and relating how S. Basil had freed the countrey of Cappadocia from famine, thus he expresseth it:
〈non-Latin alphabet〉〈non-Latin alphabet〉〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
and shewing how Gregory Nazianzen, when he was a childe, was recovered from death by being brought to the communion Table; he saith he was brought unto the Sunne from Hádes: 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
The diuine nature (saith Ruffinus, meaning the divine person) by his flesh descended into Death; not that according to the law of mortall men he should be detayned of death, but that rising againe by himselfe he might open the gates of death.
When thou didst descend into Death, ô immortall Life, (say the Grecians in their Liturgie) thou didst then mortifie Hades or Hell with the brightnesse of thy divinitie.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid. pag. 267.
l[Greek or Hebrew]. Cyril. Alexand•. Glaphyr. in Genes. lib. 5. pag 121.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Cyrill. Alexand•. Glaphyr. in Genes. lib. 5. pag 121.
n[Greek or Hebrew]. Athanas. de Incarnat. Verbi, contra Gentes, pag. 77.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Athanas. de Incarnat. Verbi, contra Gentes, pag. 77.
oDivina natura in mortem per carnem descendit; non ut lege mortalium detineretur á morte, sed ut per se resurrecturus januas mortis aperiret. Ruffin. in exposit. Symbol.
p[Greek or Hebrew]. Octoench. Anastas. Graec. & Li•urg. Chr•sost. Latin. á •eone Thus•o edit.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Octoēch. Anastas. Graec. & Li•urg. Chr•sost. Latin. á •eone Thus•o edit.
Tunc ab inferis regressus, ad lucem veniet primus resurrectionis principio revocatis ostenso. Then returning from Hell, he shall come unto the light first shewing the beginning of the Resurrection unto those whō he shall call back from thence. for
he had power to lay downe his life, and he had power to take it again: yet would he not take it againe, before he had first not layd himselfe downe only upon Deaths bed, but slept also upon it; that arising afterward from thence, he might become
feared him, (saith he) while he was in the body, saying; What have we to doe with thee, Iesus the sonne of the high God? art thou come to torment us before our
⟨p. 373⟩
time? how shall they be able to endure his NAKED DIVINITIE descending against them?
reasonable forre to follow me; here they leave me, I doubt, and let me walke without their company.