AN ANSWER TO THE FORMER CHALLENGE.AN ANSVVER TO THE FORMER CHALLENGE.
pp. 1–527550 passagespart 9 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Yea but pthe word Hades (saith Bellarmine) as we have showed, doth always signify Hell, and never the Grave. But the bo•y of Christ was not in Hell: therefore his soul was there. If he had said, that the word Hades did either rarely or never signify the Grave, although he had not therein spoken truly, yet it might have argued a little more modesty in him, and that he had taken some care also, that his latter conceits should hold some better correspondency with his former. For he might have remembered, how in the place unto which he doth refer us, he had said, that qthe LXXII. Seniors did every where in their translation put Hades in stead of Sheol: which (as he the•e hath told us) is ordinarily taken for the place of souls under the earth, and either rarely or never for the grave. But we have showed not only out of those Dictionaries, unto which the rCardinal doth refer us (having forgotten first to look into them himself) but by allegation of diverse particular instances likewise (unto none of which he hath made any answer) that Hades in the translation of t•e LXXII. Seniors is not rarely, but very usually taken for the place of dead bodies. So for the use of the word Infernus in the Latin translation; Lyranus noteth, that it is staken in the Scripture, not for the place of the damned only, but also for the pit wherein dead •ens carcasses were laid. And among the Jesuits, Gaspar Sanctius yieldeth for the general, that
Bede also is termed Infernus exterior, the exterior Hell. So Alcuinus, moving the question, how that speech of Jacob should be understood, Genes. 37.35. I will go down to my son mourning into Hell. maketh answer: that
these be the words of a troubled and grieving man, amplifying his evils even from hence.
Yea but pthe word Hades (saith Bellarmine) as vvee have shewed, doth alwayes signifie Hell, and never the Grave. But the bo•y of Christ was not in Hell: therefore his soule was there. If he had said, that the word Hades did either rarely or never signifie the Grave, although he had not therein spoken truely, yet it might have argued a little more modestie in him, and that he had taken some care also, that his latter conceits should hold some better correspondencie with his former. For he m•ght have remembred, how in the place unto which hee doth referre us, he had said, that qthe LXXII. Seniors did every where in their translation put Hades in stead of Sheol: which (as he the•e hath told us) is ordinarily taken for the place of soules under the earth, and eyther rarely or never for the grave. But wee have shewed not only out of those Dictionaries, unto which the rCardinall doth referre us (having forgotten first to looke into them himselfe) but by allegation of diverse particular instances likewise (unto none of which he hath made any answere) that Hades in the translation of t•e LXXII. Seniors is not rarely, but verie usu•lly taken for the place of dead bodies. So for the use of the word Infernus in the Latin translation; Lyranus noteth, that it is staken in the Scripture, not for the place of the damned only, but also for the pit wherein dead •ens carkases were layd. And among the Iesuites, Gaspar Sanctius yeeldeth for the generall, that tInfernus or Hell is frequently ⟨p. 309⟩in the Scripture taken for buriall: and in particular, Emmanuel Sà confesseth it to be so taken, in Gen. 42.38. 1. Sam. 2.6. Iob. 7.9. and 21.13. Psalm. 29.4. and 87.4. and 93.17. and 113.17. and 114.3. and 140.7. (according to the Greek division) Prov. 1.12. and 23.14. Ecclesiast. 9.10. Cantic. 8.6. Ecclesiastic. 51.7. Esai. 28.15. and 38.10. Baruch. 2.17. Dan. 3.88. (in the Hymne of the three children) and 2. Maccab. 6.23. in all which places, Hádes being used in the Greek, and Inferi or Infernus in the Latin, it is acknowledged by the uIesuite, that the Grave is meant: which by xBede also is termed Infernus exterior, the exterior Hell. So Alcuinus, moving the question, how that speech of Iacob should be understood, Genes. 37.35. I will goe downe to my sonne mourning into Hell. maketh answer: that ythese be the words of a troubled and grieving man, amplifying his evills even from hence.
pVox [Greek or Hebrew], ut supra ostencimus, significat semper infernū, nunquā sepulch•um. At corpus Christi non fuit in inferno: ergo anima ibi fuit. Bellarm. l•b. 4. de Christo, cap. 12.Vox 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, ut supra ostencimus, significat semper infernū, nunquā sepulch•um. At corpus Christi non fuit in inferno: ergo anima ibi fuit. Bellarm. l•b. 4. de Christo, cap. 12.
qJd. ibid. cap. 10.
rConsulantur omnia dictionaria. I•id. cap. 12.
sAccipitur Infernus in sc•ipturâ dupliciter. uno modo pro fossâ, ubi ponuntur mortuorum cadavera A•io modo pro loco, ubi descendunt animae damnato•um ad purgandū, & generaliter illorū, qui non admittuntur statim ad gloriam. Lyran. in •sai. 5.Accipitur Infernus in sc•ipturâ dupliciter. uno modo pro fossâ, ubi ponuntur mortuorum cadavera A•io modo pro loco, ubi descendunt animae damnato•um ad purgandū, & generaliter illorū, qui non admittuntur statim ad gloriam. Lyran. in •sai. 5.
tEst in Scripturâ frequens infernum pro sepulturâ, atque adeò pro morte sumi. Gosp. S•nct. commentar. in Act. 2. sect. 56.
uEmm. Sà, Notat. in Scripture.Emm. Sà, Notat. in Scriptur.
yPerturbati & dolentis verba sunt, mala sua etiam hinc exaggerantis. vel etiā inferni nomine sepulchrum significavit, quasi diceret: In luctu maneo donec. me terra suscipiat, sicut illū sepulchrum. Alevin. in Gen. Jnterrog. 256.Perturbati & dolentis verba sunt, mala sua etiam hinc exaggerantis. vel etiā inferni nomine sepulchrum significavit, quasi diceret: In luctu maneo donec. me terra suscipiat, sicut illū sepulchrum. Aleuin. in Gen. Jnterrog. 256.
Or else (saith he) by the name of Hell he signified the Grave: as if he should have said. I remain in sorrow, until the earth do receive me, as the grave hath done him.
Or else (saith hee) by the name of Hell he signified the Grave: as if he should have said. I remaine in sorrow, untill the earth doe receive me, as the grave hath done him.
So Primasius, expounding the place, Hebr. 13.20. zGod the father (saith he) brought his son from the dead, that is to say, from Hell; or from the Grave: according to that which the Psalmist had foretold; Thou wilt not suffer thine holy one to see corruption. And Maximus Taurinensis saith, that aMary Magdalene received a reproof, because after the resurrection she sought our Lord in the grave, and not remembering his words, whereby he had said that the third day he would return from hell, she thought him still to be detained by the laws of hell. And ⟨p. 310⟩therefore (saith he) while bshe did seek the Lord in the grave among the rest of the dead, she is reprehended, and it is said umto her: Why seekest thou him that liveth, among the dead? that is to say, Why seekest thou him among them that are in the infernal parts, who is now known to have returned unto the supernall? cFor he that seeketh for him either in the infernal places, or in the graves, to him it is said; Why seekest thou him that liveth among the dead? and to the same purpose he applieth those other words of our Saviour unto Mary; Touch me not, for I am not yet ascended unto my Father as if he had said. dWhy dost thou desire to touch me, who while thou seekest me among the graves, dost not as yet believe that I am ascended to my Father: who while thou searchest for me among the infernalls, dost distrust that I am returned to the celestials; while thou seekest me among the dead, dost not hope that I do live with my father? Where his Inferi and Inferna, do plainly import no more but tumulos and sepulchra.
So Primasius, expounding the place, Hebr. 13.20. zGod the father (saith hee) brought his sonne from the dead, that is to say, from Hell; or from the Grave: according to that which the Psalmiste had foretolde; Thou wilt not suffer thine holy one to see corruption. And Maximus Taurinensis saith, that aMary Magdalene received a reproofe, because after the resurrection she sought our Lord in the grave, and not remembring his words, whereby hee had said that the third day he would returne from hell, shee thought him still to be detayned by the lawes of hell. And ⟨p. 310⟩therefore (saith he) while bshee did seeke the Lord in the grave among the rest of the dead, shee is reprehended, and it is said umto her: Why seekest thou him that liveth, among the dead? that is to say, Why seekest thou him among them that are in the infernall parts, who is now knowne to have returned unto the supernall? cFor he that seeketh for him eyther in the infernall places, or in the graves, to him it is sayd; Why seekest thou him that liveth among the dead? and to the same purpose he applieth those other wordes of our Saviour unto Mary; Touch me not, for I am not yet ascended unto my Father as if hee had sayd. dWhy dost thou desire to touch me, who while thou seekest me among the graves, dost not as yet beleeve that I am ascended to my Father: who while thou searchest for me among the infernalls, dost distrust that I am returned to the celestials; while thou seekest me among the dead, dost not hope that I doe live with my father? Where his Inferi and Inferna, doe plainely import no more but tumulos and sepulchra.
zDeus ergo pater eduxit filium suum de mortuis: hoc est, de inferno, vel de sepulchro, juxta quod Psalmista praedixerat: Non dabis sanctum tuum videre corruptionem. Primaes. in Hebr. 13.
aMaria Magdalene non leviter fuit objurgata, cur post resurrectionem Dominum quaereret in sepulchro; & non reminiscens verborum ejus, quibus se ab inferis tertiâ die rediturum esse dixerat, putaret eum inferni legibus detineri. Maxim. Taurin. de sepultur. Dom. homil. 4.
bUnde & illa Maria Magdalene, quae Dominum inter caeteros defunctos in sepulchro quaerebat, arguitur, & dicitur illi: Quid quaeris viventē cum mortuis? hoc est, Quid quaeris apud inferos, quem redijsse jam constat ad superos? Id. de eâd. homil. 3.Vnde & illa Maria Magdalene, quae Dominum inter caeteros defunctos in sepulchro quaerebat, arguitur, & dicitur illi: Quid quaeris viventē cum mortuis? hoc est, Quid quaeris apud inferos, quem redijsse jam constat ad superos? Id. de eâd. homil. 3.
cNam qui eū aut in infernis requirit, aut tumulis, dicitur ei; Quid quaeris viventē cum mortuis? Ibid.Nam qui eū aut in infernis requirit, aut tumulis, dicitur ei; Quid quaeris viventē cum mortuis? Ibid.
dQuid me cō tingere cupis, quae me dum inter tumulos quaeris, adhuc ad Patrem ascendisse non credis: quae dum me inter inferna scrutaris, ad coelestia redijsse diffidis; dumb inter mortuos quaeris, vivere cū Deo patre meo non speras? Id. de sepul•ur. Dom. hom. 4.Quid me cō tingere cupis, quae me dum inter tumulos quaeris, adhuc ad Patrem ascendisse non credis: quae dum me inter inferna scrutaris, ad coelestia redijsse diffidis; dum inter mortuos quaeris, vivere cū Deo patre meo non speras? Id. de sepul•ur. Dom. hom. 4.
Hereupon Ruffinus in his exposition of the Creed, having given notice, ethat in the Symbol of the Church of Rome there is not added, He descended into hell, nor in the Churches of the East neither; adjoineth presently: Yet the force or meaning of the word seemeth to be the same, in that he is said to have been buried. For the terms of burial and descending into hell in the Scripture phrase tend much to the expressing of the self same thing: but that the bare naming of the one doth lead us only to the consideration of the honour of burial, the addition of the other intimateth unto us that ⟨p. 311⟩which is more dishonourable in it. Thus under the burial of our Saviour may be comprehended his [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew], his funeration and his interring: which are both of them set down in the end of the 19. chapter of the Gospel according to S. John. the latter in the two last verses, where Joseph and Nicodemus are said to have laid him in a new Sepulchre, wherein was never man yet laid: the former in the two verses going before, where it is recorded that they wound his body in linen clothes, with spices, [Greek or Hebrew], as it is the manner of the Jews to bury. for to the [Greek or Hebrew] or funeratiō belongeth the embalming of the dead body, & all other offices that are performed unto it while it remains above ground. So Gen. 50.2. where the Physicians are said to have embalmed Israel; the Greek translators render it: [Greek or Hebrew]. and when Mary poured the precious ointment upon our Saviour; himself interpreteth this to have been done for his ffuneration or burial. gFor it was a custom in times past (saith Eusebius, commonly called Emissenus) that the bodies of noble men being to be buried, should first be anointed with precious ointments, and buried with spices. And hwho knoweth not (saith Stapleton) that a sepulchre is an honour to the dead, and not a disgrace? But the mention of Sheol (which hath special relation, as hath been showed, to the disposing of the dead body unto corruption) and so of Hades, Infernus, or Hell, answering thereunto, carrieth us further to the consideration of that which the Apostle calleth the sowing of the body in corruption and dishonour. (1. Corinth. 15.42, 43.) For which, that place in S. Augustine ⟨p. 312⟩is worth the consideration.
Heereupon Ruffinus in his exposition of the Creed, having given notice, ethat in the Symbol of the Church of Rome there is not added, He descended into hell, nor in the Churches of the East neyther; adjoyneth presently: Yet the force or meaning of the word seemeth to bee the same, in that he is sayd to have bene buried. For the tearmes of buriall and descending into hell in the Scripture phrase tend much to the expressing of the selfe same thing: but that the bare naming of the one doth lead us only to the consideration of the honor of buriall, the addition of the other intimateth unto us that ⟨p. 311⟩which is more dishonourable in it. Thus under the buriall of our Saviour may be comprehended his 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, his funeration and his interring: which are both of them set down in the end of the 19. chapter of the Gospell according to S. Iohn. the latter in the two last verses, where Ioseph and Nicodemus are said to have laid him in a new Sepulchre, vvherein was never man yet laid: the former in the two verses going before, where it is recorded that they wound his body in linnen clothes, with spices, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, as it is the maner of the Iews to bury. for to the 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 or funeratiō belongeth the imbalming of the dead body, & all other offices that are performed unto it while it remaines above ground. So Gen. 50.2. where the Physiciās are said to have imbalmed Israel; the Greek translators render it: 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. and when Mary poured the pretious ointment upon our Saviour; himselfe interpreteth this to have beene done for his ffuneration or buriall. gFor it was a custome in times past (saith Eusebius, commonly called Emissenus) that the bodies of noble men being to be buried, should first be annointed with pretious ointments, and buried with spices. And hwho knoweth not (saith Stapleton) that a sepulchre is an honour to the dead, and not a disgrace? But the mention of Sheol (which hath speciall relation, as hath beene shewed, to the disposing of the dead body unto corruption) and so of Hades, Infernus, or Hell, answering thereunto, carrieth us further to the consideration of that which the Apostle calleth the sowing of the body in corruption and dishonour. (
eSciendum sané est, quòd in Ecclesiae Romanae Symbolo non habetur additum; Descendit ad inferna: sed neque in Orientis ecclesijs habetur hic sermo. vis tamen verbi eadem videtur esse in eo quod sepultus dicitur. Ruffin. in exposit. Symbol.
f[Greek or Hebrew]. Matth. •6.12. [Greek or Hebrew]. Marc 14.8. [Greek or Hebrew]. Joh. 12.7.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Matth. •6.12. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Marc 14.8. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ioh. 12.7.
gMos enim antiquitùs fuit, ut nobiliū corpora sepelienda unguentis pretiosis ungerentur, & cum a•omatibus sepelirentur. Euseb. Emiss. homil. Dominic. in Ramis Palmarum.Mos enim antiquitùs fuit, ut nobiliū corpora sepelienda unguentis pretiosis ungerentur, & cum a•omatibus sepelirentur. Euseb. Emiss. homil. Dominic. in Ramis Palmarum.
hQuis nescit sepulchrum mortuo honori esse, non dedecori; & quorundam sceleribus sepulchra negari? Stapleton. Antidote. in 1. Corinth. 15.55.Quis nescit sepulchrum mortuo honori esse, non dedecori; & quorundam sceleribus sepulchra negari? Stapleton. Antid•t. in 1. Corinth. 15.55.
iDid not the Hells (or, the Grave) give testimony unto Christ, when loosing their power, they reserved Lazarus (whom they had received to dissolve) for four days together; that they might restore him safe again, when they did hear the voice of their Lord commanding it? where you may observe an H•ll appointed for the dissolution of dead mens bodies: the descending into which (according to Ruffinus his note) differeth little or nothing from the descending into the Grave.
iDid not the Hells (or, the Grave) give testimony unto Christ, when loosing their power, they reserved Lazarus (whom they had received to dissolve) for foure dayes together; that they might restore him safe againe, when they did heare the voyce of their Lord commanding it? where you may observe an H•ll appointed for the dissolution of dead mens bodies: the descending into which (according to Ruffinus his note) differeth little or nothing from the descending into the Grave.
iNónne inferna Christo testimonium perhibuerunt, quando jure suo perdito Lazarus, quē dissolvendum acceperant, integrū per quatriduum reservaverunt; ut incolumē redderent, cùm vocem Domini sui jubentis audirent? Oat. c•ntra Judaeos. Pagan. & Arian cap. 17. tom. 6. Oper. Augustin.Nónne inferna Christo testimonium perhibuerunt, quando jure suo perdito Lazaru•, quē dissolvendum acceperant, integrū per quatriduum reservaverunt; ut incolumē redderent, cùm vocem Domini sui jubentis audirent? O•at. c•ntra Iudaeos. Pagan. & Arrian cap. 17. tom. 6. Oper. Augustin.
In the thirteenth of the Acts S. Paul preacheth unto the Jews, that God raised up his Son from the dead, knot to return now any more unto corruption: and yet presently addeth, that therein was verified that prophecy in the Psalm; lThou wilt not suffer thy Holy one to see corruption. implying thereby, that he descended in some sort for a time into corruption, although in that time he did not suffer corruption. And mdo not wonder (saith S. Ambrose) how he should descend into corruption, whose flesh did not see corruption. He did descend indeed into the place of corruption, who pierced the Hells; but being uncorrupted he shut out corruption. For as the word [Greek or Hebrew], which the Prophet useth in the Psalm, doth signify as well the pit or place of corruption, as the corruption it self: so also the word [Greek or Hebrew], whereby S. Luke doth express the same, is used by the Greek Interpreters of the old Testament to signify not the corruption it self alone, but the very place of it likewise. as where we read in Psalm. 7.15. He is fallen into the pit which he made. and, Psalm. 9.16. The heathen are sunk down in the pit that they made. and, Proverb. 26.27. Who so diggeth a pit, shall fall therein. Aquila in the ⟨p. 313⟩first place, the Septuagint in the second, Aquila and Symmachus in the third, retain the Greek word [Greek or Hebrew], So that our Saviour, descending into Sheol, Hades or Hell, may thus be understood to have descended into corruption, that is to say, into the pit or place of corruption, (as S. Ambrose interpreteth it) although he were free in the mean time from the passion of corruption. And because [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew] & [Greek or Hebrew], Hell and Corruption, have reference to the self same thing: therefore doth the Arabic interpreter, *translated by Junius, in Act. 2.31. (or, as the Arabian divideth the book, Act. 4.10.) confound them together, and retain the same word in both the parts of the sentence, after this manner. He was not left in perdition, neither did his flesh see perdition. even as in the 29. Psalm (or the 30. according to the division of the Hebrews) the Arabic readeth,n [Greek or Hebrew] all-gehim, or Hell, where the Greek hath [Greek or Hebrew], the Hebrew [Greek or Hebrew], & the Chaldee paraphrase [Greek or Hebrew], that is, the house of the grave.
In the thirteenth of the Acts S. Paul preacheth unto the Iewes, that God raysed up his Sonne from the dead, knot to returne now any more unto corruption: and yet presently addeth, that therein was verified that prophecie in the Psalme; lThou wilt not suffer thy Holy one to see corruption. implying thereby, that he descended in some sort for a time into corruption, although in that time he did not suffer corruption. And mdoe not wonder (saith S. Ambrose) how he should descend into corruption, whose flesh did not see corruption. He did descend indeed into the place of corruption, who pierced the Hells; but being uncorrupted he shut out corruption. For as the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which the Prophet useth in the Psalm, doth signifie as well the pit or place of corruption, as the corruption it selfe: so also the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, whereby S. Luke doth expresse the same, is used by the Greek Interpreters of the old Testament to signifie not the corruption it selfe alone, but the verie place of it likewise. as where we read in Psalm. 7.15. He is fallen into the pit which he made. and, Psalm. 9.16. The heathen are sunke downe in the pit that they made. and, Proverb. 26.27. Who so diggeth a pit, shall fall therein. Aquila in the ⟨p. 313⟩first place, the Septuagint in the second, Aquila and Symmachus in the third, retaine the Greek word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, So that our Saviour, descending into Sheol, Hades or Hell, may thus be understood to have descended into corruption, that is to say, into the pit or place of corruption, (as S. Ambrose interpreteth it) although hee were free in the meane time from the passion of corruption. And because 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 & 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Hell and Corruption, have reference to the selfe same thing: therfore doth the Arabick interpreter,
l[Greek or Hebrew]. ibid. vers. 35. ex Psal. 16.10.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. ibid. vers. 35. ex Psal. 16.10.
mNe mireris quomodo descenderit in corruptionem; cujus caro non vidit corruptionem. Descendit quidem in locum co•ruptionis, qui penetravit inferna; sed corruptionem incorruptus exclusit. Ambros. de Virginib. lib. 3.
*an. 1578. although in the Arabic Testament, printed by Erpenius an. 1616. the terms be varied: [Greek or Hebrew] all-hawita being put for Hell, and [Greek or Hebrew] phasada for corruption.an. 1578. although in the Arabi•k Testament, printed by Erpenius ann. 1616. the termes be varied: 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 al-hawita being put for Hell, and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 phasada for corruption.
nPsalter. Arabic. edit. Genuae, an. 1516. & Romae, an. 1619. Verúm in duobus meis MSS. exemplarib. habetur hîc [Greek or Hebrew] alhalaci, quod perditionē vel interitū notat.Psalter. Arabic. edit. Genuae, an. 1516. & Romae, an. 1619. Verúm in duobus meis MSS. exemplarib. habetur hîc 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 alhalaci, quod perditionē vel interitū notat.
Athanasius in his book of the Incarnation of the Word, written against the Gentiles, observeth that when God threatened our first parents, that whatsoever day they did eat of the forbidden fruit they should die the death; by odying the death he signified, that they should not only die, but also remain in the corruption of death: & that our Saviour coming to pfree us from this corruption, kept his own body uncorrupted, as a pledge and an evidence of the future resurrection of us all. which hath wrought such a contempt of death in his disciples, that (as he addeth afterwards) we may qsee ⟨p. 314⟩men which are by nature weak, leaping or dancing unto death, being not aghast at the corruption thereof, nor fearing the descents into Hell. So the Grecians sing in their Liturgy at this day: rThe corruption-working palace of Hell was dissolved, when thou didst arise out of the Grave, O Lord ▪ and again. sThe stone is rolled away, the grave is emptied. Behold corruption is trodden under by life. That which was mortal is saved by the flesh of God. Hell mourneth. For God (saith tOrigen) will neither leave our souls in hell, nor suffer us to remain for ever in corruption: but he that recalled him after the third day from hell, will recall us also in fit time; and he who granted unto him, that his flesh should not see corruption, will grant also unto us, that our flesh shall not see corruption, but that in fit time it shall be freed from corruption. Neither is it any whit strange unto them that are conversant in the writings of the ancient Doctors, to hear that our Saviour by his burial descended into Hell, spoiled Hell, and brought away both his own body and the bodies of the Saints from Hell. We find the question moved by Gregory Nyssen, in his sermon upon the Resurrection of Christ; uhow our Lord did dispose himself at the same time three manner of ways? both in the heart of the earth, (Matth. 12.40.) and in Paradise with the thief, (Luk. 23.43.) and in the hands of his Father. (Luk. 23.46.) xFor neither will any man say, (quoth he) that Paradise is in the places under the earth, or the places under the earth in Paradise, that at the same time he might be in ⟨p. 315⟩both; or that those (infernal) places are called the hand of the Father. Now for the last of these, he saith the case is yplain, that being in Paradise he must needs be in his Fathers hands also:
Athanasius in his booke of the Incarnation of the Word, written against the Gentiles, observeth that when God threatned our first parents, that whatsoever day they did eate of the forbidden fruite they should die the death; by odying the death hee signified, that they should not onely die, but also remaine in the corruption of death: & that our Saviour comming to pfree us from this corruption, kept his owne body uncorrupted, as a pledge and an evidence of the future resurrection of us all. which hath wrought such a contempt of death in his disciples, that (as he addeth afterwards) wee may qsee ⟨p. 314⟩men which are by nature weake, leaping or dauncing unto death, being not agaste at the corruption thereof, nor fearing the descents into Hell. So the Grecians sing in their Liturgy at this day: rThe corruption-working pallace of Hell was dissolved, when thou didst arise out of the Grave, O Lord ▪ and againe. sThe stone is rouled away, the grave is emptied. Behold corruption is troaden under by life. That which was mortall is saved by the flesh of God. Hell mourneth. For God (saith tOrigen) will neyther leave our soules in hell, nor suffer us to remaine for ever in corruption: but he that recalled him after the third day from hell, will recall us also in fit time; and he who granted unto him, that his flesh should not see corruption, will grant also unto us, that our flesh shall not see corruption, but that in fit time it shall bee freed from corruption. Neyther is it any whit strange unto them that are conversant in the writings of the ancient Doctors, to heare that our Saviour by his buriall descended into Hell, spoyled Hell, and brought away both his owne body and the bodies of the Saints from Hell. Wee finde the question moved by Gregory Nyssen, in his sermon upon the Resurrection of Christ; uhow our Lord did dispose himselfe at the same time three maner of wayes? both in the heart of the earth, (
o[Greek or Hebrew]; Athanas. de Incarnat. Verbi, tom. 1. Oper. Graecolat. pa. •9.〈non-Latin alphabet〉; Athanas. de Incarnat. Verbi, tom. 1. Oper. Graecolat. pa. •9.
p[Greek or Hebrew]. Ibid. pag. 54.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid. pag. 54.
q[Greek or Hebrew]. etc. Ib. pag. 59.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. etc. Ib. pag. 59.
r[Greek or Hebrew]. Graeci in Octoëcho Anastasimo.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Graeci in Octoëcho Anastasimo.
s[Greek or Hebrew]. etc. [Greek or Hebrew]. Cumûlas, in Graecorum Pentecostario.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. etc. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Cumûlas, in Graecorum Pentecostario.
tNeque nostras animas derelinquet in inferno, nec dabit nos in corruption in perpetuū manere: sed qui illum post diē tertium revocavit ab inferis, & nos revocabit in tempore opportuno; & qui illi donavit, ut nō videat caro ejus corruptionem, nobis donabit, non quidem ut non videat caro nostra corruptionem, sed ut liberetur á corruption tempore opportuno. Origen. tractat. 3•. in Matth. cap. 27.Neque nostras animas derelinquet in inferno, nec dabit nos in corruptione in perpetuū manere: sed qui illum post diē tertium revocavit ab inferis, & nos revocabit in tempore opportuno; & qui illi donavit, ut nō videat caro ejus corruptionem, nobis donabit, non quidem ut non videat caro nostra corruptionem, sed ut liberetur á corruptione tempore opportuno. Origen. tractat. 3•. in
but the greatest doubt he maketh to be, zhow he should at the same time be both in Hades and in Paradise. for with him, the heart of the earth, the places under the earth, and Hades or Hell, are in this question one and the same thing. And his final resolution is, that in this Hell Christ remained with his dead body, when with his soul he brought the thief into the possession of Paradise. aFor by his body (saith he) wherein he sustained not the corruption that followeth upon death, he destroyed him that had the power of death: but by his soul he led the thief into the entrance of Paradise. And these two did work at the self same time, the Godhead accomplishing the good by them both: namely, by the incorruption of the body, the dissolution of death, and by the placing of the soul in his proper seat, the bringing back of men unto Paradise again.
but the greatest doubt hee maketh to be, zhow he should at the same time be both in Hades and in Paradise. for with him, the heart of the earth, the places under the earth, and Hades or Hell, are in this question one and the same thing. And his finall resolution is, that in this Hell Christ remained with his dead body, when with his soule hee brought the thiefe into the possession of Paradise. aFor by his body (saith he) wherein he sustayned not the corruption that followeth upon death, hee destroyed him that had the power of death: but by his soule he ledd the thiefe into the entrance of Paradise. And these two did worke at the selfe same time, the Godhead accomplishing the good by them both: namely, by the incorruption of the body, the dissolution of death, and by the placing of the soule in his proper seat, the bringing backe of men unto Paradise againe.
z[Greek or Hebrew]; Ibid. pag. 824.〈non-Latin alphabet〉; Ibid. pag. 824.
a[Greek or Hebrew]. Ib. pag. 825.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ib. pag. 825.
The like sentence do we meet withal in the same Fathers epistle unto Eustathia, Ambrosia, and Basilissa. bHis body he caused by dispensation to be separated from his soul: but the indivisible deity being once knit with that subject, was neither dis-joined from the body, nor the soul. but was with the soul in Paradise, making way by the thief for an entrance unto mankind thither; and with the body in the heart of the earth, destroying him that had the power of death. Wherewith we may compare that place, which we meet withal in the works of S. ⟨p. 316⟩Gregory Bishop of Neocaesarea: wherein our Saviour is brought in speaking after this manner. cI must descend into the very bottom of Hell, for the dead that are detay-there. I must by the three days death of my flesh overthrow the power of long continuing death. I must light the lamp of my BODY unto them which sit in darkness and in the shadow of death. and that of S. Chrysostom (who is accounted also to be the author of that other sermon attributed unto S. Gregory:) dHow were the brazen gates broken, and the iron bars burst? By his BODY. For then appeared first a body immortal, and dissolving the tyranny of death it self: whereby was showed, that the force of death was taken away, not that the sins of those who dyed before his coming were dissolved. and that which we read in another place of his works: eHe spoiled Hell, descending into Hell: he made it bitter, when it tasted of his flesh. Which Isaiah understanding before hand, cried out, saying: Hell was made bitter, meeting thee below. (so the Septuagint render the words, Isaiah. 14.19.) It was made bitter: for it was destroyed. It was made bitter: for it was mocked. It received a BODY, and light upon God: it received Earth, and met with Heaven: it received that which it saw, and fell from that which it did not see. Thus Caesarius expounding the parable, Luk. 13.21. wherein the kingdom of God is likened unto leaven, which a woman took, and hid in ⟨p. 317⟩three pecks of flour, till all was leavened: saith that fthe three pecks of flour are first the whole nature of mankind, then death, and lastly Hell; wherein the divine BODY being hidden by BURIAL, did leaven all unto resurrection and life. Whereupon he bringeth in our Saviour in another place speaking thus. gI will therefore be buried, for their sakes that be in Hell:
The like sentence doe wee meet withall in the same Fathers epistle unto Eustathia, Ambrosia, and Basilissa. bHis body he caused by dispensation to be separated from his soule: but the indivisible deitie being once knit with that subject, was neyther dis-joyned from the body, nor the soule. but was with the soule in Paradise, making way by the thiefe for an entrance unto mankinde thither; and with the body in the heart of the earth, destroying him that had the power of death. Wherewith wee may compare that place, which we meet withall in the workes of S. ⟨p. 316⟩Gregory Bishop of Neocaesarea: wherein our Saviour is brought in speaking after this maner. cI must descend into the very bottome of Hell, for the dead that are detay-there. I must by the three dayes death of my flesh overthrow the power of long continuing death. I must light the lamp of my BODY unto them vvhich sit in darkenesse and in the shadow of death. and that of S. Chrysostom (who is accounted also to be the author of that other sermon attributed unto S. Gregory:) dHow vvere the brasen gates broken, and the iron barres burst? By his BODY. For then appeared first a body immortall, and dissolving the tyrannie of death it selfe: whereby was shewed, that the force of death was taken away, not that the sinnes of those who dyed before his comming were dissolved. and that which we reade in another place of his workes: eHe spoyled Hell, descending into Hell: hee made it bitter, when it tasted of his flesh. Which Esay understanding before hand, cryed out, saying: Hell was made bitter, meeting thee below. (so the Septuagint render the words, Esai. 14.19.) It was made bitter: for it was destroyed. It was made bitter: for it was mocked. It received a BODY, and light upon God: it received Earth, and met with Heaven: it received that vvhich it saw, and fell from that which it did not see. Thus Caesarius expounding the parable, Luk. 13.21. wherein the kingdome of God is likened unto leaven, vvhich a woman tooke, and hid in ⟨p. 317⟩three pecks of floure, till all was leavened: saith that
b[Greek or Hebrew]. Id. in Epist. ad Eustath. ibid. pag. 1093.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id. in Epist. ad Eustath. ibid. pag. 1093.
c[Greek or Hebrew]. Gregor. Neocaesar. serm. in Theophanta, pag. 111. Oper. edit. Mogunt. & inter Opera Chysostomi, tom. 7. edit. Savilian. pag. 660.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Gregor. Neocaesar. serm. in Theophanta, pag. 111. Oper. edit. Mogunt. & inter Opera Chysostomi, tom. 7. edit. Savilian. pag. 660.
d[Greek or Hebrew]. Chrysost in Matth. cap. 11. homil. 36. edit. Graec. vel 37. Latin.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Chrysost in Matth. cap. 11. homil. 36. edit. Graec. vel 37. Latin.
e[Greek or Hebrew] reponendum, ex MS. Constantinopolitano) [Greek or Hebrew]. Orat. Catechetic. in S. Pascha; tom. 5. oper. Chrysostom. edit. Savilian. pag. 916. & in Graecorum Pentecostario: ubi pro primâ voce [Greek or Hebrew], rectiùs habetur [Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉 reponendum, ex MS. Constantinopolitano) 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Orat. Catechetic. in S. Pascha; tom. 5. oper. Chrysostom. edit. Savilian. pag. 916. & in Graecorum Pentecostario: ubi pro primâ voce 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, rectiùs habetur 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
fFarinae autē sata tria, primū quidem universa mortalium natura, deinde mors, postea orcus; in quo absconditū per sepulturā divinū corpus, fermentavit omnia in resurrectionē & vitam Caesarius, Dialog. 4.Farinae autē sata tria, primū quidem universa mortalium natura, deinde mors, postea orcus; in quo absconditū per sepulturā divinū corpus, fermētavit omnia in resurrectionē & vitam Caesarius, Dialog. 4.
I will therefore as it were a stone strike the gates thereof, bringing forth the prisoners in strength, as my servant David hath said. So S. Basil asketh, hHow we do accomplish the descent into Hell? and answereth, that we do it in imitating the BURIAL of Christ, in Baptism. For the bodies of those that be baptized, are as it were buried in the water: saith he. S. Hilary maketh mention of Christs iflesh quickened out of Hell by himself. and Arator in like maner:
*Infernum Dominus cùm destructurus adiret,
Detulit inde suam spoliato funner carnem.
When the Lord went to Hell to destroy it, He brought from THENCE his own flesh, sp•yling the grave.
I will therefore as it were a stone strike the gates thereof, bringing forth the prisoners in strength, as my servant David hath said. So S. Basil asketh, hHow we do accomplish the descent into Hell? and answereth, that we doe it in imitating the BURIALL of Christ, in Baptisme. For the bodies of those that be baptized, are as it were buried in the water: saith he. S. Hilary maketh mention of Christs iflesh quickened out of Hell by himselfe. and Arator in like maner:
*Infernum Dominus cùm destructurus adiret,
Detulit inde suam spoliato funere carnem.
When the Lord went to Hell to destroy it, He brought from THENCE his owne flesh, sp•yling the grave.
h[Greek or Hebrew]. Basil. de Spiritu sancto. cap. 15.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Basil. de Spiritu sancto. cap. 15.
iEt haec vermis, vel non ex conceptu communiū originū vivens, vel é profundis terrae vivus emergens, ad significationē assumptae & vivificatae per se etiā ex inferno carnis professus est. Hilar. de Trinitat. lib. 11,Et haec vermis, vel non ex cōceptu cōmuniū originū vivens, vel é profundis terrae vivus emergens, ad significationē assumptae & vivificatae per se etiā ex inferno carnis professus est. Hilar. de Trinitat. lib. 11,
kPhilo Carpathius addeth, that in his grave he spoiled Hell. Whereupon the Emperor Leo in his oration upon the burial of our Saviour, wisheth us to lhonour it, by adorning our selves with virtues, and not by putting him in the grave again. For it behoved (saith he) that this should be once done, to the end that Hell might be spoiled: and it was done. And the Grecians retain the commemoration hereof in their Liturgies unto this day: as their Octoëchon Anastasimon and Pentecostarion ⟨p. 318⟩do testify; wherein such hymns and prayers as these are frequent. mThou didst receive death in thy flesh, working thereby immortality for us, O Saviour: and didst dwell in the grave, that thou mightest free us from Hell, raising us up together with thy self. nWhen thou wast put in the tomb as a mortal man, the keepers of Hell gates shook for fear: for, having overthrown the strength of Death, thou diddest exhibit incorruption to all the dead by thy Resurrection. oAlthough thou didst descend into the grave as a mortal man, ô giver of life, yet didst thou dissolve the strength of hell, ô Christ, raising up the dead together with thy self, whom it had also swallowed; and didst exhibit the resurrection, as God, unto all that in faith and desire do magnify thee. pThou who by thy three-days burial didst spoil Death, and by thy life-bringing resurrection didst raise up corrupted man (ô Christ our God) as a lover of mankind: to thee be glory. qThou who by thy three-days burial didst spoil Hell, and by thy resurrection didst save man; have mercy upon me. rBy thy three-days burial the enemy was spoiled, the dead loosed from the bands of Hell, death deadened, the palaces of hell voided. Therefore in hymns do we honour and magnify thee, ô giver of life. sThou wast put in the tomb, being voluntarily made dead; and didst empty all the palaces of hell (ô immortal King) raising up the dead with thy Resurrection. tThou who spoiledst hell by thy burial, be mindful of me.
kPhilo Carpathius addeth, that in his grave he spoyled Hell. Whereupon the Emperour Leo in his oration upon the buriall of our Saviour, wisheth us to lhonour it, by adorning our selves with vertues, and not by putting him in the grave againe. For it behoved (saith he) that this should be once done, to the end that Hell might be spoyled: and it was done. And the Grecians retaine the commemoration hereof in their Liturgies unto this day: as their Octoëchon Anastasimon and Pentecostarion ⟨p. 318⟩do testifie; wherein such hymnes and prayers as these are frequent. mThou didst receive death in thy flesh, working thereby immortalitie for us, O Saviour: and didst dwell in the grave, that thou mightest free us from Hell, raysing us up together with thy selfe. nWhen thou vvast put in the tombe as a mortall man, the keepers of Hell gates shooke for feare: for, having overthrowne the strength of Death, thou diddest exhibite incorruption to all the dead by thy Resurrection. oAlthough thou didst descend into the grave as a mortall man, ô giver of life, yet didst thou dissolve the strength of hell, ô Christ, raysing up the dead together with thy selfe, whom it had also swallowed; and didst exhibit the resurrection, as God, unto all that in faith and desire doe magnifie thee. pThou who by thy three-dayes buriall didst spoyle Death, and by thy life-bringing resurrectiō didst raise up corrupted man (ô Christ our God) as a lover of mankinde: to thee be glory. qThou who by thy three-dayes buriall didst spoyle Hell, and by thy resurrection didst save man; have mercy upon me. rBy thy three-dayes buriall the enemy was spoyled, the dead loosed from the bands of Hell, death deaded, the palaces of hell voyded. Therefore in hymnes doe we honour and magnifie thee, ô giver of life. sThou wast put in the tombe, being voluntarily made dead; and didst emptie all the palaces of hell (ô immortall King) raysing up the dead with thy Resurrectiō.
kPhilo. in Cantic. 5.2. [Greek or Hebrew]. inter fragmenta Eusebij in Cantic. á Men•sio edita pag. 52.Philo. in Cantic. 5.2. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. inter fragmenta Eusebij in Cantic. á Men•sio edita pag. 52.
l[Greek or Hebrew]. Leo Imp. homil. 1.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Leo Imp. homil. 1.
Hitherto also belongeth that of Prudentius, in his Apotheosis:⟨p. 319⟩
—tumuloque inferna refringens
Regna, resurgentes secum jubet ire sepultos.
Coelum habitat, terris intervenit, abdita rumpit
Tartara, vera fides, Deus est, qui totus ubique est.
where, in saying that our Saviour by his grave did break up the infernal kingdoms, and commanded those that were buried to rise up with him; he hath reference unto that part of the history of the Gospel, wherein it is recorded, that The graves were opened, and many bodies of the Saints which slept arose, and came out of the graves after his resurrection, and went into the holy city, and appeared unto many. (Matth. 27.52, 53.) upon which place S. Hilary writeth thus. uEnlightening the darkness of death, and shining in the obscure places of Hell; by the resurrection of the Saints that were seen at the present, he took away the spoils of death it self. To the same effect writeth S. Ambrose also. xNeither did his sepulchre want a miracle. For when he was anointed by Joseph, and buried in his tomb; by a new kind of work, he that was dead himself did open the sepulchres of the dead. His body indeed did lye in the grave; but he himself being free among the dead, did give liberty unto them that were placed in Hell, dissolving the law of death. For his flesh was in the tomb, but his power did work from heaven. which may be a sufficient commentary upon that sentence, which we read in the Exposition of the Creed attributed unto S. Chrysostom. yHe descended into Hell, that there also he might not want a miracle. For ⟨p. 320⟩many bodies of the Saints arose with Christ. namely, zHELL rendering up the BODIES of the Saints alive again: as either the same, or another author that goeth under the like name of Chrysostom, doth elsewhere directly affirm. which is a further confirmation of that which we have heard delivered by Ruffinus, touching the exposition of the article of the Descent into Hell; that the substance thereof seemeth to be the same with that of the Burial. for what other Hell can we imagine it to be but the Grave, that thus receiveth and giveth up the bodies of men departed this life?
Hitherto also belongeth that of Prudentius, in his Apotheosis:⟨p. 319⟩
—tumuloque inferna refringens
Regna, resurgentes secum jubet ire sepultos.
Coelum habitat, terris intervenit, abdita rumpit
Tartara, vera fides, Deus est, qui totus ubique est.
where, in saying that our Saviour by his grave did break up the infernall kingdomes, and commanded those that were buried to rise up with him; he hath reference unto that part of the history of the Gospell, wherein it is recorded, that The graves were opened, and many bodies of the Saints which slept arose, and came out of the graves after his resurrection, and went into the holy citie, and appeared unto many. (Matth. 27.52, 53.) upon which place S. Hilary writeth thus. uInlightning the darkenesse of death, and shining in the obscure places of Hell; by the resurrection of the Saints that were seene at the present, he tooke away the spoyles of death it selfe. To the same effect writeth S. Ambrose also. xNeither did his sepulchre want a miracle. For when he was anoynted by Ioseph, and buried in his tombe; by a new kinde of worke, he that was dead himselfe did open the sepulchres of the dead. His body indeed did lye in the grave; but he himselfe being free among the dead, did give libertie unto them that were placed in Hell, dissolving the law of death. For his flesh was in the tombe, but his power did worke from heaven. which may be a sufficient commentary upon that sentence, which we reade in the Exposition of the Creed attributed unto S. Chrysostom. yHe descended into Hell, that there also he might not want a miracle. For ⟨p. 320⟩many bodies of the Saints arose with Christ. namely, zHELL rendring up the BODIES of the Saints alive againe: as eyther the same, or another author that goeth under the like name of Chrysostom, doth elsewhere directly affirme. which is a further confirmation of that which we have heard delivered by Ruffinus, touching the exposition of the article of the Descent into Hell; that the substance thereof seemeth to be the same with that of the Buriall. for what other Hell can we imagin it to be but the Grave, that thus receiveth and giveth up the bodies of men departed this life?
uIlluminans enim mortis tenebras, & infernorum obscura collustrans; in sanctorum ad praesens conspicatorum resurrectione mortis ipsius spolia detrahebat. Hilar. in Matth. Canon. 33.
xSed nec sepulchrum quidem ejus miraculo caret. Nam cùm esset unctus á Joseph, & •n ejus monumento sepultus; novo opere quodam, ipse defunctus defunctorum sepulchra reserabat. Et corpus quidem ejus jacebat in tumulo, ipse autem inter mortuos liber, remissionem in inferno positis, solutâ mortis lege donabat. Erat enim caro ejus in monumento, sed virtus ejus operabatur é coelo. Ambros •e••ura. not, •ap. 5Sed nec sepulchrum quidem ejus miraculo caret. Nam cùm esset unctus á Ioseph, & •n ejus monumento sepultus; novo opere quodam, ipse defunctus defunctorum sepulchra reserabat. Et corpus quidem ejus jacebat in tumulo, ipse autem inter mortuos liber, remissionem in inferno positis, solutâ mortis lege donabat. Erat enim caro ejus in monumento, sed virtus ejus operabatur é coelo. Ambros •e••ura. nat, •ap. 5
yDescendit ad infernum, ut & ibi á miraculo non vacaret. Nam multa corpora sanctorum resurrexerunt cum Christo. Homil. 2. in Symbol. tom. 5. Latin. Oper. Chrysostom.
And hitherto also may be refer•ed that famous saying, of Christs descending alone & ascending with a multitude: which we meet withal in four several places of antiquity. First, in the heads of the sermon of Thaddaeus, as they are reported by Eusebius out of the Syriac records of the city of Edessa. aHe was crucified, and descended into Hades or Hell, and brake the rampire never broken before since the beginning; and rose again, and raised up with him those dead, that had slept from the beginning: and descended alone, but ascended to his Father with a great multitude. Secondly, in the epistle of Ignatius unto the Trallians. bHe was truly, and not in opinion, crucified, and died; those that were in heaven, and in earth, and under the earth, beholding him. those in heaven, as the incorporeal natures. those in earth, to wit the Jews and the Romans, and such men as were present at that time, when the Lord was crucified. those under the earth, as the multitude that rose up together with the Lord: for many bodies (saith he) of the Saints ⟨p. 321⟩which slept arose, the graves being opened. And he descended into Hades or Hell alone, but returned with a multitude, and brake the rampire that had stood from the beginning, and overthrew the partition thereof. Thirdly, in the disputation of Macarius Bishop of Jerusalem, in the first general Council of Nice. cAfter death we were carried into Hades or Hell. Christ took upon him this also, and descended voluntarily into it; he was not detained as we, but descended only. For he was not subjected unto death, but was the Lord of death. And descending alone, he returned with a multitude. For he was that spiritual grain of wheat, falling for us into the earth, and dying in the flesh; who by the power of his godhead raised up the temple of his body, according to the Scriptures, which brought forth for fruit the Resurrection of all mankind. Fourthly, in the Catechises of Cyril Bishop of Jerusalem: whose words are these. dI believe that Christ was raised from the dead. For of this I have many witnesses, both out of the divine scriptures, & from the witness and operation even unto this day of him that rose again: of him (I say) that descended into Hades or Hell alone, but ascended with many. For he did descend unto death; & many bodies of the Saints that slept were raised by him.
And hitherto also may bee refer•ed that famous saying, of Christs descending alone & ascending with a multitude: which we meet withall in foure severall places of antiquitie. First, in the h•ads of the sermon of Thaddaeus, as they are reported by Eusebius out of the Syriack records of the citie of Edessa. aHe was crucified, and descended into Hades or Hell, and brake the rampiere never broken before since the beginning; and rose againe, and raysed up with him those dead, that had slept from the beginning: and descended alone, but ascended to his Father with a great multitude. Secondly, in the epistle of Ignatius unto the Trallians. bHe was truly, and not in opinion, crucified, and died; those that were in heaven, and in earth, and under the earth, beholding him. those in heaven, as the incorporeall natures. those in earth, to wit the Iewes and the Romanes, and such men as were present at that time, when the Lord was crucified. those under the earth, as the multitude that rose up together with the Lord: for many bodies (saith he) of the Saints ⟨p. 321⟩which slept arose, the graves being opened. And hee descended into Hades or Hell alone, but returned with a multitude, and brake the rampiere that had stood from the beginning, and overthrew the partition thereof. Thirdly, in the disputation of Macarius Bishop of Ierusalem, in the first generall Councell of Nice. cAfter death wee were carried into Hades or Hell. Christ tooke upon him this also, and descended voluntarily into it; he was not detayned as wee, but descended onely. For hee was not subjected unto death, but was the Lord of death. And descending alone, he returned with a multitude. For he was that spirituall graine of wheat, falling for us into the earth, and dying in the flesh; who by the power of his godhead raysed up the temple of his body, according to the Scriptures, which brought forth for fruite the Resurrection of all mankinde. Fourthly, in the Catechises of Cyrill Bishop of Ierusalem: whose wordes are these. dI beleeve that Christ was raysed from the dead. For of this I have many witnesses, both out of the divine scriptures, & from the witnesse and operation even unto this day of him that rose againe: of him (I say) that descended into Hades or Hell alone, but ascēded with many. For he did descend unto death; & many bodies of the Saints that slept were raised by him.
a[Greek or Hebrew]. Thaddaeus, spud Euseb. lib. 1. histor. Ecclesiast. ca. ult〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Thaddaeus, •pud Euseb. lib. 1. histor. Ecclesiast. ca. ult
b[Greek or Hebrew]. Ignat. epist. 2. ad Trallian.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ignat. epist. 2. ad Trallian.
c[Greek or Hebrew]. Macar. Hierosolymit. apud Gelasium Cyzicen. in Act. Concil. Nicaen. lib. 1. ca. 23. all. 24.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Macar. Hierosolymit. apud Gelasium Cyzicen. in Act. Concil. Nicaen. lib. 1. ca. 23. al. 24.
which resurrection he seemeth afterward to make common unto all the Saints that dyed before our Saviour. eAll the righteous men (saith he) were delivered, whom death had devoured. For it became the proclaimed ⟨p. 322⟩King, to be the deliverer of those good proclaimers of him. Then did every one of the righteous say: O death where is thy victory? ô Hell, where is thy sting? for the conqueror hath delivered us. wherewith we may compare that saying of S. Chrysostom. fIf it were a great matter, that Lazarus being four days dead should come forth: much more, that all they who were dead of old should appear together alive. which was a sign of the future resurrection. For many bodies of the Saints which slept arose; saith the text. and these articles of the Confession of the Armenians. gAccording to his body, which was dead, he descended into the grave: but according to his divinity, which did live, he over came Hell in the mean time. The third day he rose again: but withal raised up the souls (or persons) of the faithful together with him; and gave hope thereby, that our bodies also should rise again like unto him at his second coming.
which resurrection he seemeth afterward to make common unto all the Saints that dyed before our Saviour. eAll the righteous men (saith he) were delivered, whom death had devoured. For it became the proclaymed ⟨p. 322⟩King, to be the deliverer of those good proclaymers of him. Then did every one of the righteous say: O death where is thy victory? ô Hell, where is thy sting? for the conqueror hath delivered us. wherewith we may compare that saying of S. Chrysostom. fIf it were a great matter, that Lazarus being foure dayes dead should come forth: much more, that all they who were dead of old should appeare together alive. which was a signe of the future resurrection. For many bodies of the Saints which slept arose; saith the text. and these articles of the Confession of the Armenians. gAccording to his body, which was dead, he descended into the grave: but according to his divinitie, which did live, he over came Hell in the meane time. The third day he rose againe: but withall rays•d up the soules (or persons) of the faithfull together with him; and gave hope thereby, that our bodies also should rise againe like unto him at his second comming.
e[Greek or Hebrew]. Id. ibid.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id. ibid.
f[Greek or Hebrew]. Ch•ysost. in Matth 27. homil. 88. edit. Graec. vel 89. Latin ubi tamen Interpres vertit: Multo majus profectò est multos jam olim mortuos in vitā reduxisse.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ch•ysost. in Matth 27. homil. 88. edit. Graec. vel 89. Latin ubi tamen Interpres vertit: Multo majus profectò est multos jam olim mortuos in vitā reduxisse.
gErgo & in sepulcrum quoad corpus, quod mo•tuū erat, descendit: juxta veró divinitatem, quae vivebat, infernu• intereà devicit. Te•tio die resurrexit: sed & animas fideliū secum unâ suscitavit; & dedit spem corporibus etiā á morte resurgendi sib similiter in secundo adventu Confess. A•men. artic. •22.123.124.Ergo & in sepulcrum quoad corpus, quod mo•tuū erat, descendit: juxta veró divinitatem, quae vivebat, infernu• intereà devicit. Te•tio die resurrexit: sed & animas fideliū secum unâ suscitavit; & dedit spem corporibus etiā á morte resurgendi sib similiter in secundo adventu Con•ess. A•men. artic. •22.123.124.
Of those who arose with our Saviour from the Grave, or (as anciently they used to speak) from Hell; two there be whom the Fathers nominate in particular: Adam and Job. Of Job, S. Ambrose writeth in this manner. hHaving heard what God had spoken in him, and having understood by the holy Ghost, that the Son of God was not only to come into the earth, but that he was also to descend into Hell to that he might raise up the dead, (which was then done, for a testimony of the present, and an example of the future:) he turned himself unto the ⟨p. 323⟩Lord and said: O that thou wouldest keep me in Hell, that thou wouldest hide me until thy wrath be past, and that thou wouldest appoint me a time in which thou wouldest remember me. (Job. 14.13.) in which words he affirmeth that Job did prophesy, ithat he should be raised up at the passion of our Lord; as in the end of this book, saith he, he doth testify. meaning the apocryphal Appendix, which is annexed to the end of the Greek edition of Job: wherein we read thus. kIt is written, that he should rise again, with those whom the Lord was to raise. which although it be accounted to have proceeded from the Septuagint; yet the thing it self showeth, that it was added by some that lived after the coming of our Saviour Christ. Touching Adam, S. Augustine affirmeth that lthe whole Church almost did consent, that Christ loosed him in Hell. which we are to believe (saith he) that she did not vainly believe, whencesoever this tradition came; although no express authority of the Canonical Scriptures be produced for it. The only place which he could think off that seemed to look this way, was that in the beginning of the tenth Chapter of the book of Wisdom: She kept him who was the first formed father of the world, when he was created alone, and brought him out of his sin. which would be much more pertinent to the purpose, if that were added, which presently followeth in the mLatin text (I mean in the old edition: for the new corrected ones have left it out) Et eduxit illum de limo terrae, and brought him out of the clay of the earth. which being placed after the bringing of him out of his sin, may seem to have reference unto some deliverance (like that of Davids, Psalm. 40 2. He brought me up out of the horrible pit, out of the miry clay) rather then unto ⟨p. 324⟩his first creation out of the dust of the earth.
Of those who arose with our Saviour from the Grave, or (as anciently they used to speake) from Hell; two there be whom the Fathers nominate in particular: Adam and Iob. Of Iob, S. Ambrose writeth in this maner. hHaving heard what God had spoken in him, and having understood by the holy Ghost, that the Sonne of God was not onely to come into the earth, but that he was also to descend into Hell to that he might rayse up the dead, (which was then done, for a testimony of the present, and an example of the future:) he turned himselfe unto the ⟨p. 323⟩Lord and said: O that thou wouldest keepe me in Hell, that thou vvouldest hide me untill thy wrath be past, and that thou wouldest appoint me a time in which thou wouldest remember me. (Iob. 14.13.) in which wordes he affirmeth that Iob did prophecie, ithat he should be raysed up at the passion of our Lord; as in the end of this booke, saith he, he doth testifie. meaning the apocryphall Appendix, which is annexed to the end of the Greeke edition of Iob: wherein we reade thus. kIt is written, that he should rise againe, with those whom the Lord was to raise. which although it be accounted to have proceeded from the Septuagint; yet the thing it selfe sheweth, that it was added by some that lived after the comming of our Saviour Christ. Touching Adam, S. Augustine affirmeth that lthe whole Church almost did consent, that Christ loosed him in Hell. which we are to beleeve (saith he) that shee did not vainely beleeve, whencesoever this tradition came; although no expresse authoritie of the Canonicall Scriptures be produced for it. The onely place which he could thinke off that seemed to look this way, was that in the beginning of the tenth Chapter of the booke of Wisedome: Shee kept him who was the first formed father of the world, when hee was created alone, and brought him out of his sinne. which would be much more pertinent to the purpose, if that were added, which presently followeth in the mLatin text (I meane in the old edition: for the new corrected ones have left it out) Et eduxit illum de limo terrae, and brought him out of the claye of the earth. which being placed after the bringing of him out of his sinne, may seeme to have reference unto some deliverance (like that of Davids,
hAudito igitur quod locutus esset in eo Deus, & cognito per Spiritum sanctum quòd filius Dei non solùm veni•et in terras, sed etiam descensurus esset ad inferos, ut mortuos refuscitaret, (quod tunc quidē factum est ad testimonium praesentium, & exemplum futurorū) conversus ad Dominum ait: Utinam in inferno conservares, absconderes autem me donec desinat ira tua, & statuas mihi tempus in quo memoriam mei facias. Am•ros. de Int•rpellatio••, lib. 1. cap. 8.Audito igitur quod locutus esset in eo Deus, & cognito per Spiritum sanctum quòd filius Dei non solùm veni•et in terras, sed etiam descensurus esset ad inferos, ut mortuos refuscitaret, (quod tunc quidē factum est ad testimonium praesentium, & exemplum futurorū) conversus ad Dominum ait: Vtinam in inferno conservares, absconderes autem me donec desinat ira tua, & statuas mihi tempus in quo memoriam mei facias. Am•ros. de Int•rpellatio••, lib. 1. cap. 8.
iQuòd in passione Domini resuscitandus foret; sicut in fine hujus libri testatur. Ibid.
k[Greek or Hebrew]. Append. ad Job.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Append. ad Iob.
lEt de illo quidem primo homine patre generis humani, quòd eum ibidem solverit, Ecclesia feré tota consentit: quod eam non inaniter credidisse credendum est, undecunque hoc traditum sit, etiamsi canonicarum scripturarum hinc expressa non proferatur authoritas. Aug. epist. 99.
mIn Biblijs Regijs, edit. Antuerp. an. 1572 & magnis Latinis Biblijs edit Venet. an. 1588. ubi in hanc particulam habentur notae Glossae interlinealis & Nic. Lyrani.
So limus terrae may here answer well unto the Arabians [Greek or Hebrew] all-tharai: which properly signifying moist earth or slime or clay, is by the Arabic interpreter of Moses used to express the Hebrew n[Greek or Hebrew] which we translate Hell or Grave. And as this place in the book of Wisdom may be thus applied unto the raising of Adams body out of the earth wherein he lay buried: so may that other tradition also, which was so currant in the Church, be referred unto the self same thing; even to the bringing of Adam out of the Hell of the Grave.
So limus terrae may here answere well unto the Arabians 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 al-tharai: which properly signifying moyst earth or slime or claye, is by the Arabick interpreter of Moses used to expresse the Hebrew n〈non-Latin alphabet〉 which we translate Hell or Grave. And as this place in the booke of Wisedome may be thus applied unto the raysing of Adams body out of the ear•h wh•rein hee lay buried: so may that other tradition also, which was so currant in the Church, be referred unto the selfe same thing; even to the bringing of Adam out of the Hell of the Grave.
nFr. Rapheleng in Lexico Arabico, pag 53. & 55 [Greek or Hebrew] & [Greek or Hebrew] Sepulcrum, infernus, [Greek or Hebrew]. Malé: inquit Erpenius, in observation. ad hunc locum. significat terram humidam. Verúm Raphelengium ab hâc reprehensione vindicat Arabs Pentateuchi interpres ab ipso Erpenio editus: qui Sheol vertit Tharai, Genes. 37.35. & 44.29, 31. item Num. 16.30, 33. & Deut. 32.22.Fr. Rapheleng in Lexico Arabico, pag 53. & 55 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 & 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Sepulcrum, infernus, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Malé: inquit Erpenius, in observation. ad hunc locum. significat terram humidam. Verúm Raphelengium ab hâc reprehensione vindicat Arabs Pentateuchi interpres ab ipso Erpenio editus: qui Sheol vertit Tharai, Genes. 37.35. & 44.29, 31. item Num. 16.30, 33. & Deut. 32.22.
The very Liturgies of the Church do lead us unto this interpretation of the tradition of the Church: beside the testimony of the Fathers, which discover unto us the first ground and foundation of this tradition. In the Liturgy of the Church of Alexandria, ascribed to S. Mark, our Saviour Christ is thus called upon. oO most great King, and coeternal to the Father, who by thy might didst spoil Hell, and tread down death, and bind the strong one, and raise Adam out of the grave by thy divine power and the bright splendour of thine unspeakable Godhead. In the Liturgy of the Church of Constantinople translated into Latin by Leo Thus•us, the like speech is used of him. pHe did voluntarily undergo the Cross for us, by which he raised up the first formed man, and saved our souls from death. And in the Octoëchon Anastasimon and Pentecostarion of the Grecians at this day, such sayings as these are very usual. qThou didst undergo burial, and rise in glory, and raise up ⟨p. 325⟩Adam together with thee, by thy almighty hand. rRising out of thy tomb, thou didst raise up the dead, and break the po•er of death, and raise up Adam. sHaving slept in the flesh as a mortal man, ô King and Lord, the third day thou didst arise again; raising Adam from corruption, and abolishing death. tJesus the deliverer, who raised up Adam of his compassion, &c. Therefore doth Theodorus Prodromus begin his Tetrastich upon our Saviours Resurrection with [Greek or Hebrew]. Rise up, thou first formed old man, rise up from thy grave.
The verie Liturgies of the Church doe lead us unto this interpretation of the tradition of the Church: beside the testimony of the Fathers, which discover unto us the first ground and foundation of this tradition. In the Liturgie of the Church of Alexandria, ascribed to S. Marke, our Saviour Christ is thus called upon. oO most great King, and coëternall to the Father, who by thy might didst spoyle Hell, and tread downe death, and binde the strong one, and raise Adam out of the grave by thy divine power and the bright splendour of thine unspeakeable Godhead. In the Liturgie of the Church of Constantinople translated into Latin by Leo Thus•us, the like speech is used of him. pHe did voluntarily undergoe the Crosse for us, by which he raysed up the first formed man, and saved our soules from death. And in the Octoëchon Anastasimon and Pentecostarion of the Grecians at this day, such sayings as these are very usuall. qThou didst undergoe buriall, and rise in glory, and rayse up ⟨p. 325⟩Adam together with thee, by thy almighty hand. rRising out of thy tombe, thou didst rayse up the dead, and break the po•er of death, and rayse up Adam. sHaving slept in the flesh as a mortall man, ô King and Lord, the third day thou didst arise againe; raysing Adam from corruption, and abolishing death. tIesus the deliverer, who raysed up Adam of his compassion, &c. Therefore doth Theodorus Prodromus begin his Tetrastich upon our Saviors Resurrection with 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Rise up, thou first formed old man, rise up from thy grave.
o[Greek or Hebrew]. Marc. Liturg.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Marc. Liturg.
pCrucem sponte pro nobis subijt, per quam resuscitavit protoplastum, & á morte animas nostras salvavit. Chrysost. Liturg. Latin.
q[Greek or Hebrew]. Nov. Autholog. Graec. edit. Romae, an. 1598. pa. 23. b〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Nov. Autholog. Graec. edit. Romae, an. 1598. pa. 23. b
S. Ambrose pointeth to the ground of the tradition, when he intimateth that Christ suffered in uGolgotha, where Adams sepulchre was, that by his Cross he might raise him that was dead; that where in Adam the death of all men lay, therein Christ might be the resurrection of all. Which he received (as he did many other things besides) from Origen: who writeth thus of the matter. xThere came unto me some such tradition as this, that the body of Adam the first man mas buried there, where Christ was crucified: that as in Adam all do die, so in Christ all might be made alive; that in the place which is called the place of Calvary, that is, the place of the head, the head of mankind might find resurrection with all the rest of the people, by the resurrection of our Lord and Saviour, who suffered there and rose again. For it was unfit, that when many which were borne of him did receive forgiveness ⟨p. 326⟩of their sins and obtain the benefit of Resurrection, he who was the father of all men should not much more obtain the like grace. Athanasius, (or who ever else was author of the Discourse upon the Passion of our Lord, which beareth his name) referreth this tradition of Adams burial place unto the report of the yDoctors of the Hebrews (from whom belike he thought that Origen had received it) and addeth withal, that it was very fit, that where it was said to Adam, Earth thou art and to earth thou shalt return; our Saviour finding him there, should say unto him again. Arise thou that sleepest, and stand up from the dead, and Christ shall give thee light. zEpiphanius goeth a little further, and findeth out a mystery in the water and blood that fell from the Cross upon the relics of our first father lying buried under it: applying thereunto both that in the Gospel, of the arising of many of the Saints, Matth. 27.52. and that other place in S. Paul, Arise thou that sleepest, &c. Ephes. 5.14. which strange speculation, with what great applause it was received by the multitude at the first delivery of it, and for how little reason: he that list may read in the fourth book of S. Hieroms commentaries, upon the 27. of S. Matthew, & in his third upon the fifth to the Ephesians, for upon this first point, of Christs descent into the Hell of the grave, and the bringing of Adam and his children with him from thence, we have dwelt too long already.
S. Ambrose pointeth to the ground of the tradition, when he intimateth that Christ suffered in uGolgotha, where Adams sepulchre was, that by his Crosse he might rayse him that was dead; that where in Adam the death of all men lay, therein Christ might be the resurrection of all. Which he receaved (as he did many other things besides) from Origen: who writeth thus of the matter. xThere came unto me some such tradition as this, that the body of Adam the first man mas buried there, where Christ was crucified: that as in Adam all doe die, so in Christ all might be made alive; that in the place which is called the place of Calvarie, that is, the place of the head, the head of mankinde might finde resurrection with all the rest of the people, by the resurrection of our Lord and Saviour, who suffered there and rose againe. For it was unfit, that when many which were borne of him did receive forgivenesse ⟨p. 326⟩of their sinnes and obtayne the benefit of Resurrection, he who was the father of all men should not much more obtaine the like grace. Athanasius, (or who ever else was author of the Discourse upon the Passion of our Lord, which beareth his name) referreth this tradition of Adams buriall place unto the report of the yDoctors of the Hebrewes (from whom belike hee thought that Origen had received it) and addeth withall, that it was very fit, that where it was said to Adam, Earth thou art and to earth thou shalt returne; our Saviour finding him there, should say unto him again. Arise thou that sleepest, and stand up from the dead, and Christ shall give thee light. zEpiphanius goeth a little furthet, and findeth out a mysterie in the water and bloud that fell from the Crosse upon the relicks of our first father lying buried under it: applying thereunto both that in the Gospell, of the arising of many of the Saints, Matth. 27.52. and that other place in S. Paule, Arise thou that sleepest, &c. Ephes. 5.14. which strange speculation, with what great applause it was received by the multitude at the first delivery of it, and for how little reason: he that list may reade in the fourth book of S. Hieroms cōmentaries, upon the 27. of S. Matthew, & in his third upon the fifth to the Ephesians, for upon this first point, of Christs descent into the Hell of the grave, and the bringing of Adam and his children with him from thence, we have dwelt too long already.
uQuam suscepit in Golgothâ Christus, ubi Adae sepulchrum, ut illū mortuū in suâ cruce resuscitaret. Ubi ergo in Adam mors omnium, ibi i• Christo omniū resurrectio. Ambros. lib. 5. epist. 19.Quam suscepit in Golgothâ Christus, ubi Adae sepulchrum, ut illū mortuū in suâ cruce resuscitaret. Vbi ergo in Adam mors omnium, ibi i• Christo omniū resurrectio. Ambros. lib. 5. epist. 19.
xVenit ad me traditio quaedā talis, quòd corpus Adae primi hominis ibi sepultum est ubi crucifixus est Christus: ut sicut in Adam omnes moriuntur, sic in Christo omnes vivificentur; ut in loco illo qui dicitur Calvariae locus, id est locus capitis, caput humani generis resurrectionem inveniat cum populo universo per resurrectionem Domini Salvatoris, qui ibi passus est, & resurrexit. Inconveniens enim erat, ut cùm multi ex eo nati remissionem acciperent peccatorum, & beneficium resurrectionis consequerentur; non magis ipse pater omnium hominum hujusmodi gratiam consequeretur. Origen. in tractat. 35. in Matth. cap. 27.Venit ad me traditio quaedā talis, quòd corpus Adae primi hominis ibi sepultum est ubi crucifixus est Christus: ut sicut in Adam omnes moriuntur, sic in Christo omnes vivificentur; ut in loco illo qui dicitur Calvariae locus, id est locus capitis, caput humani generis resurrectionem inveniat cum populo universo per resurrectionem Domini Salvatoris, qui ibi passus est, & resurrexit. Inconveniens enim erat, ut cùm multi ex eo nati remissionem acciperent peccatorum, & beneficium resurrectionis consequerentur; non magis ipse pater omnium hominum hujusmodi gratiam consequeretur. Origen. in tractat. 35. in Matth. cap. 27.
y[Greek or Hebrew]. Athanas. in passion. & crucem Domini.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Athanas. in passion. & crucem Domini.
zEpiphan. cont. Tatian. haeres. 46. Vide etiam Paulae & Eusto•hij epist. ad Marcellami, tomo •. oper. Hieronymi, epist. 17.
In the second place therefore we are now to consider, that as Hades and Inferi, (which we call Hell) are applied by rhe Interpreters of the holy Scripture, to denote the place of bodies separated from their souls: so with foreign authors (in whose language, as being that wherewith the common people was acquainted, ⟨p. 327⟩the Church also did use to speak) the same terms do signify ordinarily the common lodge of souls separated from their bodies, whether the particular place assigned unto each of them be conceived to be an habitation of bliss or of misery. For as when the Grave is said to be the common receptacle of dead bodies, it is not meant thereby that all dead carcasses are heaped together promiscuously in one certain pit: so when the Heathen write that all the souls of the dead go to Hades, their meaning is not, that they are all shut up together in one and the self same room: but in general only they understand thereby the translation of them into the other world, the extreme parts whereof the Poets place as far asunder as we do Heaven and Hell. And this opinion of theirs S. Ambrose doth well like off (a wishing that they had not mingled other superfluous and unprofitable conceits therewith) bthat souls departed from their bodies did go to [Greek or Hebrew], that is, to a place which is not seen: which place (saith he) we in Latin call Infernus. So likewise saith S. Chrysostom. cThe Grecians, and Barbarians, and Poets, and Philosophers, and all mankind do herein consent with us, although not all alike; and say that there be certain seats of judgement in Hades: so manifest and so confessed a thing is this. and again. dThe Grecians were foolish in many things; yet did they not resist the truth of this doctrine. If therefore thou wilt follow them, they have granted that there is a certain life after this, & accounts, ⟨p. 328⟩and seats of judgement in Hades, and punishments, and honours, and sentences, judgements. And if thou shalt ask the Jews, or heretics, or any man; he will reverence the truth of this doctrine: & although they differ in other things, yet in this do they all agree and say, that there are accounts to be made there of the things that be done here. Only among the Jews, the Sadducees, wch esay that there is no resurrection, neither Angel, nor Spirit;
In the second place therefore we are now to consider, that as Hádes and Inferi, (which we call Hell) are applied by rhe Interpreters of the holy Scripture, to denote the place of bodies separated from their soules: so with forraine authors (in whose language, as being that wherewith the common people was acquainted, ⟨p. 327⟩the Church also did use to speake) the same tearmes do signifie ordinarily the common lodge of soules separated from their bodies, whether the particular place assigned unto each of them be conceived to be an habitation of blisse or of miserie. For as when the Grave is said to be the common receptacle of dead bodies, it is not meant thereby that all dead carkasses are heaped together promiscuously in one certaine pit: so when the Heathen write that all the soules of the dead goe to Hades, their meaning is not, that they are all shut up together in one and the selfe same roome: but in generall onely they understand thereby the translation of them into the other world, the extreame parts whereof the Poëts place as farre asunder as wee doe Heaven and Hell. And this opinion of theirs S. Ambrose doth well like off (a wishing that they had not mingled other superfluous and unprofitable conceits therewith) bthat soules departed from their bodies did goe to 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that is, to a place which is not seene: which place (saith he) wee in Latin call Infernus. So likewise saith S. Chrysostom. cThe Grecians, and Barbarians, and Poëts, and Philosophers, and all mankinde doe herein consent with us, although not all alike; and say that there be certaine seats of judgement in Hádes: so manifest and so confessed a thing is this. and againe. dThe Grecians were foolish in many things; yet did they not resist the truth of this doctrine. If therefore thou vvilt follow them, they have granted that there is a certaine life after this, & accounts, ⟨p. 328⟩and seats of judgement in Hádes, and punishments, and honors, and sentences, judgements. And if thou shalt aske the Iewes, or heretickes, or any man; he will reverence the truth of this doctrine: & although they differ in other things, yet in this doe they all agree and say, that there are accounts to be made there of the things that be done here. Only amōg the Iwes, the Sadducees, wch
aAtque utinā non superflua his & inutilia miscuissent. Ambros. de bono mortis, cap. 10.Atque utinā non superflua his & inutilia miscuissent. Ambros. de bono mortis, cap. 10.
bSatis fuerat dixisse illis, quòd liberatae animae de corporibus [Greek or Hebrew] peterent, id est, locum qui non videtur. Quem locum Latiné infernum dicimus Jbid.Satis fuerat dixisse illis, quòd liberatae animae de corporibus 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 peterent, id est, locum qui non videtur. Quem locum Latiné infernum dicimus Jbid.
c[Greek or Hebrew]. Chrysost. in 2. Corinth. homil. 9.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Chrysost. in 2. Corinth. homil. 9.
d[Greek or Hebrew]. Chrysostom. de fato & providentiâ, orat. 4. tom. 6. edit. Savil. pa. 874.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Chrysostom. de fato & providentiâ, orat. 4. tom. 6. edit. Savil. pa. 874.
[Greek or Hebrew], take away the punishments, and honours that are in Hades: as is noted by fJosephus. For which wicked doctrine they were condemned by the other sects of the Jews: who generally acknowledged, that there was [Greek or Hebrew] Olam hanneshamoth (for so do they in their language until this day call that,g which Josephus in Greek termeth Hades) that is to say, the world of spirits; into which they held that the souls were translated presently after death, and there received their several judgements.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉, take away the punishments, and honours that are in Hádes: as is noted by fIosephus. For which wicked doctrine they were condemned by the other sectes of the Iewes: who generally acknowledged, that there was 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Olam hanneshamoth (for so doe they in their language untill this day call that,g which Iosephus in Greeke tearmeth Hades) that is to say, the world of spirits; into which they held that the soules were translated presently after death, and there received their seuerall judgements.
fJoseph de Bello Judaic. lib. 2. cap. 12. circa finem.Ioseph de Bello Iudaic. lib. 2. cap. 12. circa finem.
g•lia• Levita in Tis•hbi, verb. [Greek or Hebrew].•lia• Levita in Tis•hbi, verb. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
The same thing doth Theodoret suppose to be signified by that phrase of being gathered to ones people, which is so usual in the word of God. For it being said of Jacob, before he was buried, that he gave up the ghost, and was gathered unto his people, Genes. 49.33. Theodoret observeth, that Moses hby these words did closely intimate the hope of the resurrection. For if men (saith he) had been wholly extinguished, and did not pass unto another life; he would not have said, He was gathered to his people. So likewise where it is distinctly noted of Abraham, Genes. 25.8, 9. first, that he gave up the ghost and died, then, that he was gathered to his people, and lastly, that his sons buried him: Cardinal iCajetan and the Jesuit kLorinus interpret the first de compositi totius dissolution, of the dissolution of the ⟨p. 329⟩parts of the whole-man, consisting of body and soul; the second of the state of the soul separated from the body, and the third of the disposing of the body parted from the soul. Thus the Scriptures speech of being gathered to our people should be answerable in meaning to the phrase used by the heathen of descending into Hell or going to Hades: which, as lSynesius noteth out of Homer, was by them opposed [Greek or Hebrew], to a most absolute extinguishment as well of the soul as of the body. And forasmuch as by that term, the immortality of the soul was commonly signified: therefore doth Plato in his Phaedo disputing of that argument, make this the state of his question; mWhether the souls of men deceased be in Hades or no? and our Ecclesiastical writers also do from thence sometimes fetch a difference betwixt Death and Hades. nYou shall find, saith Theophylact, that there is some difference betwixt Hades and Death: namely that Hades containeth the souls, but Death the bodies. For the souls are immortal. The same we read in oNicetas Serronius his exposition of Gregory Nazianzens second Paschal oration. Andreas Caesareensis doth thus express the difference. pDeath is the separation of the soul and the body. But Hades. is a place to us invisible or unseen and unknown, which receiveth our souls when they depart from hence. The ordinary Gloss, following S. Hierome upon the thirteenth of Hosea, thus. qDeath is that, whereby the soul is separated from the body.
The same thing doth Theodoret suppose to be signified by that phrase of being gathered to ones people, which is so usuall in the word of God. For it being said of Iacob, before he was buried, that he gave up the ghost, and was gathered unto his people, Genes. 49.33. Theodoret observeth, that Moses hby these words did closely intimate the hope of the resurrection. For if men (saith he) had beene wholy extinguished, and did not passe unto another life; he would not have sayd, Hee was gathered to his people. So likewise where it is distinctly noted of Abraham, Genes. 25.8, 9. first, that hee gave up the ghost and died, then, that hee was gathered to his people, and lastly, that his sonnes buried him: Cardinall iCajetan and the Iesuite kLorinus interpret the first de compositi totius dissolutione, of the dissolution of the ⟨p. 329⟩parts of the whole-man, consisting of body and soule; the second of the state of the soule separated from the body, and the third of the disposing of the body parted from the soule. Thus the Scriptures speech of being gathered to our people should be answerable in meaning to the phrase used by the heathen of descending into Hell or going to Hades: which, as lSynesius noteth out of Homer, was by them opposed 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, to a most absolute extinguishment as well of the soule as of the body. And forasmuch as by that tearme, the immortalitie of the soule was commonly signified: therefore doth Plato in his Phaedo disputing of that argument, make this the state of his question; mWhether the soules of men deceased be in Hades or no? and our Ecc•esiasticall writers also doe from thence sometimes fetch a difference betwixt Death and Hades. nYou shall finde, saith Theophylact, that there is some difference betwixt Hades and Death: namely that Hades contayneth the soules, but Death the bodies. For the soules are immotall. The same we reade in
h[Greek or Hebrew]. •heodoret. in Genes. quaest. 109.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. •heodoret. in Genes. quaest. 109.
m[Greek or Hebrew]. Plot. Phaedoa. pag. 81. edit. Graecolatin. an. 1590.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Plat. Phaedoa. pag. 81. edit. Graecolatin. an. 1590.
nComperies aliquod esse inferni & mortis discrimen: videlicèt quòd animas infernus contineat, mors veró corpora. Nam immortales sunt animae. Theophylact. in 1. Corinth. 15.
oHoc differunt mors & infernus: quòd illa corpora, hîc animas detineat. Nicet. in Gregor. Nazianz. orat 42.
p[Greek or Hebrew]. Andr. Caesareens. in Apocalypse. commentar. cap. 64. edit. Graec. 63. Latin.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Andr. Caesareens. in Apocalyps. commentar. cap. 64. edit. Graec. 63. Latin.
qMors est, quâ separatur anima á corpore. Infernus est locus ubi recluduntur animae, vel ad refrigerium, vel ad poenam. Strabus in Gloss. ordinar. •n Hieronym. lib. 3. in Ose. cap. 13.
The rsoul goeth to Hades, saith Nicetas Choniates in the Proem of his History: but the body returneth again into those things, of which it was composed. Caius, (or who ever else was the author of that ancient fragment, which we formerly signified to have been falsely fathered upon Josephus) holdeth that sin Hades, the souls both of the righteous and unrighteous are contained: tbut that the righteous are led to the right hand by the Angels that await them there, and brought unto a lightsome region, wherein the righteous men that have been from the beginning do dwell (and this we call Abraham's b•some: saith he) whereas the wicked are drawn toward the left hand by the punishing Angels, not going willingly, but drawn as prisoners by violence. Where you may observe how he frameth his description of Hades, according to that model wherewith the Poets had before possessed mens mindes.
uDextera, quae Ditis magni sub moenia tendit,
Hâc iter Elysium nobis: at laeva malorum
Exercet poenas, & ad impia tartara mittit.
The right hand path goeth underneath the walls of Pluto deep;
That way we must, if paths to Paradise we think to keep:
The left hand leads to pain, and men to Tartarus doth send.
For xas We do allot unto good men a resting place in Paradise; so the Greeks do assign unto their Heroes the Fortunate Islands, and the Elysian fields: saith Tzetzes. ⟨p. 331⟩And as the Scripture borroweth the term of yTartarus from the Heathen: so is it thought by zTertullian and aGregory Nazianzen that the Heathen took the ground of their Elysian fields from the Scriptures Paradise.
The rsoule goeth to Hádes, saith Nicetas Choniates in the Prooeme of his Historie: but the bodie returneth againe into those things, of which it was composed. Caius, (or whoe ever else was the author of that auncient fragment, which wee formerly signified to have been falsely fathered upon Iosephus) holdeth that sin Hades, the soules both of the righteous and unrighteous are contayned: tbut that the righteous are led to the right hand by the Angels that awayte them there, and brought unto a lightsome region, wherein the righteous men that have beene from the beginning doe dwell (and this wee call Abrahams b•some: saith he) whereas the wicked are drawen toward the left hand by the punishing Angels, not going willingly, but drawen as prisoners by violence. Where you may observe how he frameth his description of Hades, according to that modell wherewith the Poets had before possessed mens mindes.
uDextera, quae Ditis magni sub moenia tendit,
Hâc iter Elysium nobis: at laeva malorum
Exercet poenas, & ad impia tartara mittit.
The right hand path goth underneath the walls of Pluto deepe;
That way we must, if paths to Paradise we thinke to keepe:
The left hand leads to paine, and men to Tartarus doth send.
For xas Wee doe allot unto good men a resting place in Paradise; so the Greekes doe assigne unto their Heroës the Fortunate Ilandes, and the Elysian fields: saith Tzetzes. ⟨p. 331⟩And as the Scripture borroweth the terme of yTartarus from the Heathen: so is it thought by zTertullian and aGregory Nazianzen that the Heathen tooke the ground of their Elysian fields from the Scriptures Paradise.
r[Greek or Hebrew], Nicet init. Historiae.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Nicet init. Historiae.
s[Greek or Hebrew], Caius, in fragmento de Caussâ sive essentiâ Universi: de quo suprà, pag. 222.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Caius, in fragmento de Caussâ sive essentiâ Vniversi: de quo suprà, pag. 222.
t[Greek or Hebrew]. Ibid.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid.
uVirgil A• neid. 6. conferend. cum Platonis narratione lib. 10. de Republ. paulò pòst citandâVirgil A• neid. 6. conferēd. cum Platonis narratione lib. 10. de Republ. paulò pòst citandâ
x[Greek or Hebrew]. Jo. Tzetz. in Hesiodi [Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Io. Tzetz. in Hesiodi 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
To heap up many testimonies out of the Heathen authors, to prove that in their understanding all souls went to Hades, and received there either punishment or reward according to the life that they led in this world; would be but a needless work: seeing none that hath read any thing in their writings can be ignorant thereof. If any man desire to inform himself herein, he may repair to Plutarch's consolatory discourse written to Apollonius: where he shall find the testimonies of Pindarus and many others alleged, [Greek or Hebrew], touching the state of the godly in Hades. Their common opinion is sufficiently expressed in that sentence of Diphilus, the old Comical Poet. bIn Hades we resolve there are two paths: the one whereof is the way of the righteous, the other of the wicked. But as in this general they agreed together both among themselves and with the truth: so touching the particular situation of this Hades, and the special places whereunto these two sorts of souls were disposed, and the state of things there, a number of ridiculous fictions and fond conceits are to be found among them; wherein they dissented as much from one another, as they did from the truth it self. So we see, for example, *that the best souls are placed by some of them in the company of their Gods in heaven, by others in the Galaxias or milky circle, by others beyond the Ocean, and by others under the earth: ⟨p. 332⟩c[Greek or Hebrew], yet one Hades notwithstanding was commonly thought to have received them all.
To heape up many testimonies out of the Heathen authors, to prove that in their understanding all soules went to Hades, and received there eyther punishment or reward according to the life that they led in this world; would be but a needlesse worke: seeing none that hath reade any thing in their writings can be ignorant therof. If any man desire to informe himselfe herein, he may repayre to Plutarches consolatory discourse written to Apollonius: where he shall finde the testimonies of Pindarus and many others alledged, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, touching the state of the godly in Hades. Their common opinion is sufficiently expressed in that sentence of Diphilus, the old Comicall Poet. bIn Hades we resolve there are two pathes: the one whereof is the way of the righteous, the other of the wicked. But as in this generall they agreed together both among themselves and with the truth: so touching the particular situation of this Hádes, and the speciall places whereunto these two sorts of soules were disposed, and the state of things there, a number of ridiculous fictions and fond conceits are to be found among them; wherein they dissented as much from one another, as they did from the truth it selfe. So we see, for example, *that the best soules are placed by some of them in the companie of their Gods in heaven, by others in the Galaxias or milky circle, by others beyond the Ocean, and by others under the earth: ⟨p. 332⟩c〈non-Latin alphabet〉, yet one Hádes notwithstanding was cōmonly thought to have received them all.
b[Greek or Hebrew]. [Greek or Hebrew]. D•phil. apud Clement. Alexandr. lib. 5. Stromat, ind• que apud Euseb. Praeparat. Evangelic. lib. 13. pag. 400. edit Grace. & Theodoret. in Therapeutic. ad Graec. lib. 8. pag. 88.89. who commendeth this for true, philosophy indeed.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. D•phil. apud Clement. Alexandr. lib. 5. Stromat, ind• que apud Euseb. Praeparat. Euangeli•. lib. 13. pag. 400. edit Grae•. & Theodoret. in Therapeutic. ad Graec. lib. 8. pag. 88.89. who commendeth this for true, philosophy indeed.
*Vid. Tertullian. de Animâ cap. 54.55. & Macrob. in Somn. Scipionis. lib. 1. cap. 9.10.11.12.
Plato relateth this, as a sentence delivered by them who were the first ordainers of the Grecian Mysteries: dWhosoever goeth to Hades not initiated and not cleansed, shall lye in the mire; but he that cometh thither, purged and initiated, shall dwell with the Gods. So Zoroaster the great father of the Magi in the East, is said to have used this entrance into his discourse touching the things of the other world. eThese things wrote Zoroaster, the son of Armenius, by race a Pamphylian, having been dead in the war, which I learned of the Gods, being in Hades. as Clemens Alexandrinus relateth in the fifth book of his Stromata: where he also noteth, that this Zoroaster is that Er the son of Armenius, a Pamphylian, of whom Plato writeth in the tenth book of his Common-wealth; that being slain in the war he revived the twelfth day after, and was sent back as a messenger to report unto men here the things which he had heard and seen in the other world one part of whose relation was this: that he saw certain fgulfs beneath in the earth, and above in the heaven, opposite one to the other; and that the just were commanded by the Judges that sate betwixt those gulfs, to go to the right hand up toward Heaven, but the wicked to the left hand and downward. which testimony gEusebius bringeth in, among many others, to show the consent that is betwixt Plato and the Hebrews in matters that concern the state of the world to come. Next to Zoroaster cometh Pythagoras: whose golden verses are concluded with this distich.⟨p. 333⟩h[Greek or Hebrew],
[Greek or Hebrew]·
When thou shalt leave the body, and come unto a free heaven; thou shalt be an immortal God, incorruptible, and not subject to mortality any more. So Epicharmus the scholar of Pythagoras: iIf thou be godly in mind, thou shalt suffer no evil when thou art dead; thy spirit shall remain above in heaven. and Pindarus: kThe souls of the ungodly fly under the heaven (or under the earth) in cruel torments, under the unavoidable yokes of evils. but the souls of the godly, dwelling in heaven, do praise that great blessed one with songs and hymns.
Plato relateth this, as a sentence delivered by them who were the first ordayners of the Grecian Mysteries: dWhosoever goeth to Hádes not initiated and not cleansed, shal lye in the mire; but he that commeth thither, purged and initiated, shall dwell with the Gods. So Zoroaster the great father of the Magi in the East, is said to have used this entrance into his discourse touching the things of the other world. eThese things wrote Zoroaster, the sonne of Armenius, by race a Pamphylian, having beene dead in the warre, which I learned of the Gods, being in Hades. as Clemens Alexandrinus relateth in the fifth booke of his Stromata: where he also noteth, that this Zoroaster is that Er the sonne of Armenius, a Pamphylian, of whom Plato writeth in the tenth booke of his Common-wealth; that being slain in the warre he revived the twelfth day after, and was sent backe as a messenger to report unto men here the things which he had heard and seene in the other world one part of whose relation was this: that he saw certaine fgulfes beneath in the earth, and above in the heaven, opposite one to the other; and that the just were commanded by the Iudges that sate betwixt those gulfs, to go to the right hand up toward Heaven, but the wicked to the left hand and downeward. which testimonie gEusebius bringeth in, among many others, to shew the consent that is betwixt Plato and the Hebrewes in matters that concerne the state of the world to come. Next to Zoroaster commeth Pythagoras: whose golden verses are concluded with this distich.⟨p. 333⟩h〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉·
When thou shalt leave the body, and come unto a free heaven; thou shalt be an immortall God, incorruptible, and not subject to mortalitie any more. So Epicharmus the scholler of Pythagoras: iIf thou be godly in minde, thou shalt suffer no evill when thou art dead; thy spirit shall remaine above in heaven. and Pindarus: k
d[Greek or Hebrew]. Plot. Phaedon. pag. 380. f. & 386. a.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Plat. Phaedon. pag. 380. f. & 386. a.
hPhytag•r•aur. Ca•m. cum commentar. H•er• cli•▪ pag 310.
i[Greek or Hebrew]. Epicharm. apud Clement. Alexandr. lib. 4. stro••.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Epicharm. apud Clement. Alexandr. lib. 4. stro••.
k[Greek or Hebrew]. Pindar. ibid. & apud Theodore•. in Therapeutic. ad Grae•os, lib. 8.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Pindar. ibid. & apud Theodore•. in Therapeutic. ad Grae•os, lib. 8.
Cicero in his Tusculan questions allegeth the testimony of lEnnius, approving the common fame, that Romulus did lead his life in heaven with the Gods. and in the sixth book of his Common-wealth, he bringeth in Scipio teaching that munto all them which preserve, assist, and enlarge their country, there is a certain place appointed in heaven, where they shall live blessed world without end. nSuch a life (saith he) is the way to heaven, and into the company of these, who having lived and are now loosed from their body, do inhabit that place which thou seest, p•inting to the Galaxiaes or milky circle. whereof we read thus also in oManilius:
An fortes animae, dignatque nomina coelo
Corporibus resoluta suis, terraeque remissa;
⟨p. 334⟩Huc migrant ex orbe, suumque habitantia coelum,
Aethereos vivunt annos, mundoque fruuntur?
With Damascius the philosopher of Damascus, this circle pis the way of the souls that go to the Hades in heaven. Against whom Johannes Philoponus doth reason thus, from the etymology of the word. qIf they pass through the Galaxias or milky circle; then this should be that [Greek or Hebrew] or Hades that is in heaven: and how can that be Hades, which is so lightsome? To which, they that maintained the other opinion, would peradventure oppose that other common derivation of the word from the Doric [Greek or Hebrew], which signifieth to please or to delight; or that which rPlato doth deliver in the name of Socrates, [Greek or Hebrew] from seeing or knowing all good things. For, there did Socrates look to find such things: as appeareth by that speech which Plato in his Dialogue of the Soul maketh him to use the same day that he was to depart out of this life. sThe soul, being an invisible thing, goeth hence into such another noble and pure and invisible place; to Hades, in truth, unto the good and wise God: whither, if God will, my soul must presently go. which place is alleged by tEusebius, to prove that uin the things which concern the immortality of the soul, Plato doth differ in opinion nothing from Moses. The tale also which Socrates there telleth of the xpure land seated above in the pure heaven, though it have a number of toys added to it (as tales use to have) yet the foundation thereof both Eusebius and Origen do judge to have been taken from ⟨p. 335⟩the speeches of the Prophets touching the land of promise and the heavenly Canaan:
Ci•ero in his Tusculan questions alledgeth the testimony of lEnnius, approving the common fame, that Romulus did lead his life in heaven with the Gods. and in the sixth booke of his Common-wealth, he bringeth in Scipio teaching that munto all them which preserve, assist, and enlarge their countrey, there is a certaine place appointed in heav•n, where they shall live blessed world without end. nSuch a life (saith he) is the way to heaven, and into the company of these, who having lived and are now loosed from their body, doe inhabite that place which thou seest, p•inting to the Galaxiaes or milky circle. whereof we reade thus also in oManilius:
An fortes animae, dignatque nomina coelo
Corporibus resoluta suis, terraeque remissa;
⟨p. 334⟩Huc migrant ex orbe, suumque habitantia coelum,
Aethereos vivunt annos, mundoque fruuntur?
With Damascius the philosopher of Damascus, this circle pis the way of the soules that goe to the Hades in heaven. Against whom Iohannes Philoponus doth reason thus, from the etymologie of the word. qIf they passe through the Galaxias or milky circle; then this should be that 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 or Hades that is in heaven: and how can that be Hades, which is so lightsome? To which, they that maintayned the other opinion, would peradventure oppose that other common derivation of the word from the Dorick 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which signifieth to please or to delight; or that which rPlato doth deliver in the name of Socrates, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 from seeing or knowing all good things. For, there did Socrates looke to finde such things: as appeareth by that speech which Plato in his Dialogue of the Soule maketh him to use the same day that he was to depart out of this life.
lRomulus in co•lo cum dijs agit aevum: ut famae assentiens dixit Ennius. Cic Tus•ul. quaest. lib. 1.
mOmnibus, qui patriam conservârint, adjuverint, auxerint, certum esse in coelo ac definitum locum, ubi beati aevo sempiterno fruantur. Id. in Som•o Scipionis.
nEa vita, via est in coelum, & in hunc coetum eorum, qui jam vixerunt, & corpore laxati, illum incolunt locum quem vides (erat autem is splendidissimo candour inter flammas elucens circulus) quem vos, ut á Graijs accepistis, orbem lacteum nuncupatis Ibid.Ea vita, via est in coelum, & in hunc coetum eorum, qui jam vixerunt, & corpore laxati, illum incolunt locum quem vides (erat autem is splendidissimo candore inter flammas elucens circulus) quem vos, ut á Graijs accepistis, orbem lacteum nuncupatis Ibid.
oManil. lib. 1. Astronom.
p[Greek or Hebrew] Damasc.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Damasc.
q[Greek or Hebrew]; Philopon in 1. Mettor. fol. 104. b.〈non-Latin alphabet〉; Philopon in 1. Mettor. fol. 104. b.
r[Greek or Hebrew]. Socrat. apud Platonem in Cra•ylo. pag 265.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Socrat. apud Platonem in Cra•ylo. pag 265.
s[Greek or Hebrew]. Id. apud. eund. in Phaedone. pag. 385. g.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id. apud. eund. in Phaedone. pag. 385. g.
and for the rest, Origen referreth us to Plato's interpreters, affirming that ythey who handle his writings more gravely, do expound this tale of his by way of allegory.
and for the rest, Origen referreth us to Platoes interpreters, affirming that ythey who handle his writings more gravely, doe expound this tale of his by way of allegory.
y[Greek or Hebrew] Origen lib 7. contra Celsum, pag. 362.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Origen lib 7. contra Celsum, pag. 362.
Such another tale doth the same philosopher relate in the Dialogue which he intituleth Gorgias: showing, that zamong men he that leadeth his life righteously and holily, shall when he is dead go unto the Fortunate Islands, and dwell in all happiness, free from evils. but he that leadeth it unrighteously and impiously, shall go unto the prison of punishment and just revenge, which they call Tartarus. which Theodoret bringeth in, to prove that aPlato did exactly believe that there were judgements to pass upon men in Hades. For being conversant with the Hebrews (saith he) in Egypt, he heard without doubt the oracles of the Prophets: and btaking some things from thence, and mingling other things therewith out of the fables of the Greeks, made up his discourses of these things. Among which mixtures, that which he hath of the Fortunate Islands, is reckoned by cTheodoret for one: whereof you may read in dHesiod, ePindarus, fDiodorus Siculus, gPlutarch, and hJosephus also; who treating of the diverse sects that were among the Jews, showeth that the Essenes borrowed this opinion (of the placing of good mens souls in a certain pleasant habitation beyond the Ocean) from the Grecians. But the Pharisees (as he noteth ielsewhere) held ⟨p. 336⟩that the place, wherein both rewards were given to the good and punishments to the wicked, was under the earth: which as kOrigen doth declare to have been the common opinion of the Jews, so doth Lucian show that it was the more vulgar opinion among the Grecians. For among them lthe common multitude, whom wise men (saith he) call simple people, being persuaded of these things by Homer and Hesiod and such other fabulous authors, and receiving their Poems for a law; took HADES to be a certain deep place under the earth. The first original of which conceit is by Cicero derived from hence. mThe bodies falling into the ground, and being covered with earth, (whence they are said to be interred) men thought that the rest of the life of the dead was led under the earth, upon which opinion of theirs (saith he) great errors did ensue: which were increased by the Poës. Others do imagine, that the Poets herein had some relation to the nspherical situation of the world: for the better understanding whereof, these particulars following would be considered by them that have some knowledge in this kind of learning.
Such another tale doth the same philosoper relate in the Dialogue which he intituleth Gorgias: shewing, that zamong men he that leadeth his life righteously and holily, shall when he is dead goe unto the Fortunate Ilands, and dwell in all happinesse, free from evills. but he that leadeth it unrighteously and impiously, shall goe unto the prison of punishment and just revenge, which they call Tartarus. which Theodoret bringeth in, to prove that aPlato did exactly beleeve that there were judgements to passe upon men in Hades. For being conversant with the Hebrewes (saith he) in Aegypt, he heard without doubt the oracles of the Prophets: and btaking some things from thence, and mingling other things therewith out of the fables of the Greekes, made up his discourses of these things. Among which mixtures, that which he hath of the Fortunate Ilands, is reckoned by cTheodoret for one: whereof you may reade in dHesiod, ePindarus, fDiodorus Siculus, gPlutarch, and hIosephus also; who treating of the diverse sectes that were among the Iewes, sheweth that the Essenes borrowed this opinion (of the placing of good mens soules in a certaine pleasant habitation beyond the Ocean) from the Grecians. But the Pharisees (as hee noteth ielsewhere) held ⟨p. 336⟩that the place, wherein both rewards were given to the good and punishments to the wicked, was under the earth: which as kOrigen doth declare to have been the common opinion of the Iewes, so doth Lucian shew that it was the more vulgar opinion among the Grecians. For among them
z[Greek or Hebrew]. Plato, in Gorg. pag. 312. c.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Plato, in Gorg. pag. 312. c.
a[Greek or Hebrew]. Theodoret. Therapeutic. ad Graec. lib. 11. pag. 155.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Theodoret. Therapeutic. ad Graec. lib. 11. pag. 155.
b[Greek or Hebrew]. Ibid. pag. 166.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid. pag. 166.
cIbid. pag. 157.
dHesiod. in [Greek or Hebrew].Hesiod. in 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
ePindar. Olymp. Od. 2.
fDiodor. Bibliothec. lib. 3.
gPlutarch. in vitâ Serlorij.
hJoseph. de bello Judaico, lib. 2. cap. 12. pag. 730. edit. Graec.Ioseph. de bello Iudaico, lib. 2. cap. 12. pag. 730. edit. Graec.
First, the material Spheres in ancient time were not made moveable in their sockets, as they are now, that they might be set to any elevation of the Pole: but were osixth to the elevation of XXXVI. degrees; which was the height of the Rhodian climate. Secondly, the Horizon which divided this Sphere through the middle, and separated the visible part of the world from the invisible, was commonly esteemed the utmost ⟨p. 337⟩bound of the earth: so that whatsoever was under that horizon, was accounted to be under the earth. for neither the common people, nor yet some of the learned Doctors of the Church (as pLactantius, qS. Augustine, rProcopius, and others) could be induced to believe that which our daily navigations find now to be most certain; that there should be another southern hemisphere of the earth, inhabited by any Antipodes, that did walk with their feet just opposite unto ours. Thirdly, the great Ocean was supposed to be the thing in nature which was answerable to this horizon in the Sphere. Therefore it is observed by sStrabo that Homer, and by tTheon, uAchilles Statius, and others that Aratus and the rest of the Poets do put the Ocean for the Horizon: and thereupon where the astronomers say that the Sun or the stars at their setting, go under the horizon the common phrase of the Poets is, that they do tingere see Oceano, dive themselves into the Ocean. for as they took the Earth to be but half a globe, and not a whole one: so they imagined that demye globe to be as it were a great mountain or Island seated in, and environed round about with the Ocean. Thus the author of the book de Mundo, affirmeth that xthe whole world is one Island, compassed about with the Atlantic sea: and Dionysius Alexandrinus, in the beginning of his Geography,
[Greek or Hebrew]
[Greek or Hebrew].
⟨p. 338⟩wherein he followed Eratosthenes, as his expositor Eustathius there noteth: who compareth also with this, that place of Orpheus [Greek or Hebrew],
— [Greek or Hebrew],
[Greek or Hebrew].
whereunto answereth that of yEuphorion, or (as zAchilles Statius citeth it) of Neoptolemus Parianus in his [Greek or Hebrew].
First, the materiall Spheres in ancient time were not made moveable in their sockets, as they are now, that they might bee set to any elevation of the Pole: but were ofixt to the elevation of XXXVI. degrees; which was the height of the Rhodian climat. Secondly, the Horizon which devided this Sphere through the middle, and separated the visible part of the world from the invisible, was commonly esteemed the utmost ⟨p. 337⟩bound of the earth: so that whatsoever was under that horizon, was accounted to be under the earth. for neyther the common people, nor yet some of the learned Doctros uf the Church (as pLactantius, qS. Augustine, rProcopius, and others) could be induced to beleeve that which our daily navigations finde now to bee most certaine; that there should bee another southerne hemisphere of the earth, inhabited by any Antipodes, that did walke with their feete just opposite unto ours. Thirdly, the great Ocean was supposed to be the thing in nature which was answerable to this horizon in the Sphere. Therefore it is observed by sStrabo that Homer, and by tTheon, uAchilles Statius, and others that Aratus and the rest of the Poets doe put the Ocean for the Horizon: and thereupon where the astronomers say that the Sunne or the starres at their setting, goe under the horizon the common phrase of the Poets is, that they doe tingere se Oceano, dive themselves into the Ocean. for as they tooke the Earth to be but halfe a globe, and not a whole one: so they imagined that demye globe to be as it were a great mountaine or Iland seated in, and invironed round about with the Ocean. Thus the author of the booke de Mundo, affirmeth that xthe whole world is one Iland, compassed about with the Atlanticke sea: and Dionysius Alexandrinus, in the beginning of his Geography,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
o[Greek or Hebrew]. G•minus, in Phaenomen. cap. 13.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. G•minus, in Phaenomen. cap. 13.
sStrabo, Geograph. lib. 1. ad quem doctiss. Casauhonus hane ex Grammaticis Oceani definitionem producit. [Greek or Hebrew].Strabo, Geograph. lib. 1. ad quem doctiss. Casauhonus hane ex Grammaticis Oceani definitionem producit. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
t[Greek or Hebrew]. Theon in Arat. pag. 6. [Greek or Hebrew]. Ibid. pag. 59. edit. Paris.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Theon in Arat. pag. 6. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid. pag. 59. edit. Paris.
u[Greek or Hebrew]. Ach•l. Stat. in Ar••. pag. 93 •dit. Florentin. ubi etiam alius scholiastes, pag. 115. de horizonte similiter notat. [Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ach•l. Stat. in Ar••. pag. 93 •dit. Florentin. ubi etiam alius scholiastes, pag. 115. de horizonte similiter notat. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
And this opinion of theirs the Fathers of the Church did the more readily entertain: because they thought it had ground from *Psalm. 24.2. and 136.6. and such other testimonies of holy Scripture. aThat the whole earth (saith Procopius Gazaeus) doth subsist in the waters, and that there is no part of it which is situated under us void and cleared of waters; I suppose it be known unto all. For so doth the Scripture teach: Who stretcheth out the earth upon the waters. and again: He hath founded it upon the seas, and prepared it upon the floods. Neither is it fit we should believe, that any earth under us is inhabited, opposite unto our part of the world. The same collection is made by S. bHilary, cChrysostom, dCaesarius, and others. Fourthly, it was thought by the ancient heathen, that the Ocean (supplying the place of the Horizon) did eseparate the visible world from the kingdom of Hades: and therefore that such as went to Hades (or the world invisible to us) must first ⟨p. 339⟩pass the Ocean. and that the pole Antarctic was seen by them there, as the Arctic or North pole is by us here: according to that of Virgil in his Georgics,
Hic vertex nobis semper sublimis: at illum
Sub pedibus Styx atra videt, manesque profundi.
Fifthly, as they held that Hades was for situation placed from the centre of the earth downward; so betwixt the beginning and the lowest part thereof they imagined as great a space to be interjected, as there is betwixt Heaven and Earth. So saith Apollodorus of Tartarus, the dungeon of torment. fThis is a dark place in Hades, having as great a distance from the earth, as the earth from the heaven. and Hesiod in his Theogonia (agreeably to that which before we heard from Homer)
[Greek or Hebrew],
[Greek or Hebrew].
It is as far beneath the earth, as heaven is from the earth: for thus equal is the distance from the earth unto dark Tartarus. whereunto that of Virgil may be added, in the •ixt of the Aeneids:
— tum Tartarus ipse
Bis patet in praeceps tantum tenditque sub umbras,
Quantus ad aethereum coeli suspectus Olympum.
—then Tartarus it self, that sink-hole steep
Two times as low descends, two times as headlong downright deep
As heaven upright •s hie.
that, see how high the heaven is over us, when we look upward to it; the downright distance from thence to Tartarus, should be twice as deep again.
And this opinion of theirs the Fathers of the Church did the more readily entertayne: because they thought it had ground from *Psalm. 24.2. and 136.6. and such other testimonies of holy Scripture. aThat the whole earth (saith Procopius Gazaeus) doth subsist in the waters, and that there is no part of it which is situated under us voyde and clear'd of waters; I suppose it be knowne unto all. For so doth the Scripture teach: Who stretcheth out the earth upon the waters. and againe: Hee hath founded it upon the seas, and prepared it upon the floods. Neyther is it fit we should beleeve, that any earth under us is inhabited, opposite unto our part of the world. The same collection is made by S. bHilary, cChrysostom, dCaesarius, and others. Fourthly, it was thought by the ancient heathen, that the Ocean (supplying the place of the Horizon) did eseparate the visible world from the kingdome of Hades: and therefore that such as went to Hádes (or the world invisible to us) must first ⟨p. 339⟩passe the Ocean. and that the pole Antarctick was seene by them there, as the Arctick or North pole is by us here: according to that of Virgil in his Georgicks,
Hic vertex nobis semper sublimis: at illum
Sub pedibus Styx atra videt, manesque profundi.
Fiftly, as they held that Hades was for situation placed from the center of the earth downeward; so betwixt the beginning and the lowest part thereof they imagined as great a space to be interjected, as there is betwixt Heaven and Earth. So saith Apollodorus of Tartarus, the dungeon of torment. fThis is a darke place in Hades, having as great a distance from the earth, as the earth from the heaven. and Hesiod in his Theogonia (agreably to that which before we heard from Homer)
〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
It is as farre beneath the earth, as heaven is from the earth: for thus equall is the distance from the earth unto darke Tartarus. whereunto that of Virgil may be added, in the ixt of the Aeneids:
— tum Tartarus ipse
Bis patet in praeceps tantum tenditque sub umbras,
Quantus ad aethereum coeli suspectus Olympum.
—then Tartarus it selfe, that sinke-hole steep
Two times as low descends, two times as headlong downright deep
As heaven upright s hie.
that, see how hye the heaven is over us, when we looke upward to it; the downright distance from thence to Tartarus, should be twice as deepe againe.
*Vid. Augustin. Quaest. 132. in Genesim.
aQuòd autē universa terra in aquis subsistat, nec ulla sit pars ejus, quae infra nos sita est, aquis vacua & denudata, omnibus notum reor. Nam sic docet Scriptura: Qui expandit terram super aquas. Et iterùm: Quia ipse super maria fundavit eam, & super flumina praeparavit eam. &c. Nec decet ut credamus aliquam terram infra nos coli nostro orbi oppositam. Procop. in Genes. cap. 1.Quòd autē universa terra in aquis subsistat, nec ulla sit pars ejus, quae infra nos sita est, aquis vacua & denudata, omnibus notum reor. Nam sic docet Scriptura: Qui expandit terram super aquas. Et iterùm: Quia ipse super maria fundavit eam, & super flumina praeparavit eam. &c. Nec decet ut credamus aliquam terram infra nos coli nostro orbi oppositam. Procop. in Genes. cap. 1.
These observations, I doubt not, will be censured by many to savour of a needless and fruitless curiosity: but the intelligent reader for all that will easily discern, how hereby he may be led to understand, in what sense the ancient both heathen and Christian writers did hold Hades to be under the earth; and upon what ground. For they did not mean thereby (as the Schoolmen generally do, and as gTertullian sometime seemeth to imagine) that it was contained within the bowels of the earth: but that it lay under the whole bulk thereof, and occupied that whole space, which we now find to be taken up with the earth, air and firmament of the southern hemisphere. hthe inhabitants of which infernal region and vast depth are thereupon affirmed by S. Hilary to be non intra terram sed infra terram, not within the earth but beneath the earth. And this proceeded from no other ground, but the vulgar opinion, that the southern hemisphere of the earth was not inhabited by living men, as our northern is insomuch that some of the heathen atheists, finding the contrary to be true by the discourse of right reason; endeavoured to persuade themselves from thence, that there was no such place as Hades at all. iLucretius for the greater part, (saith Servius) and others fully teach, tha• the kingdoms of Hell cannot as much as have a being. For what place can we say they have; when under the earth our Antipodes are said to be? and that they should be in the midst of the earth, neither will the solidity permit, nor the centre of the earth. which earth if it be in the middle of the world, the profundity thereof can ⟨p. 341⟩not be so great, that it may have those Inferos within it, in which is Tartarus: whereof we read,
Bis patet in praeceps tantum, tenditque sub umbras
Quantus ad aethereum coeli suspectus Olympum.
But Christian men, being better instructed out of the word of God, were taught to answer otherwise. kIf thou dost ask me (saith S. Chrysostom) of the situation and place of Gehenna: I will answer and say, that it is seated somewhere out of this world; and that it is not to be inquired in what place it is situated, but by what means rather it may be avoided.
These observations, I doubt not, will be censured by many to savour of a needlesse and fruitelesse curiositie: but the intelligent reader for all that will easily disc•rne, how hereby he may be led to understand, in what sense the ancient both heathen and Christian writers did hold Hades to be under the earth; and upon what ground. For they did not meane thereby (as the Schoolemen generally doe, and as gTertullian sometime seemeth to imagine) that it was contayned within the bowels of the earth: but that it lay under the whole bulke thereof, and occupied that whole space, which we now finde to be taken up with the earth, ayre and firmament of the southerne hemisphere. hthe inhabitants of which infernall region and vast depth are thereupon affirmed by S. Hilary to be non intra terram sed infra terram, not within the earth but beneath the earth. And this proceeded from no other ground, but the vulgar opinion, that the southerne hemisphere of the earth was not inhabited by living men, as our north•rne is insomuch that some of the heathen atheists, finding the contrary to be true by the discourse of right reason; endevoured to perswade themselves from thence, that there was no such place as Hades at all. iLucretius for the greater part, (saith Servius) and others fully teach, tha• the kingdomes of Hell cannot as much as have a being. For what place can we say they have; when under the earth our Antipodes are sayd to be? and that they should be in the midst of the earth, neyther will the solidity permit, nor the center of the earth. which earth if it be in the middle of the world, the profundity thereof can ⟨p. 341⟩not be so great, that it may have those Inferos within it, in which is Tartarus: whereof we reade,
Bis patet in praeceps tantum, tenditque sub umbras
Quantus ad aethereum coeli suspectus Olympum.
But Chrstiian men, being better instructed out of the word of God, were taught to answere otherwise. kIf thou dost aske me (saith S. Chrysostom) of the situation and place of Gehenna: I will answere and say, that it is seated somewhere out of this world; and that it is not to be inquired in what place it is situated, but by what meanes rather it may be avoyded.
gNobis inferi, non nuda cavositas, nec subdivalis aliqua mundi sentina credū tur: sed in fossâ terrae & in alto vastitas, & in ipsis visceribus ejus abstrusa profunditas. Tertull. de anima, cap. 55.Nobis inferi, non nuda cavositas, nec subdivalis aliqua mundi sentina credū tur: sed in fossâ terrae & in alto vastitas, & in ipsis visceribus ejus abstrusa profunditas. Tertull. de anima, cap. 55.
hEsse autem hujus infernae regionis vas•aeque abyssi incolas pl•res, beati Joannis Apocalypsi docemur. e•c. Hila••. •n P•alm. 2.Esse autem hujus infernae regionis vas•aeque abyssi incolas pl•res, beati Ioannis Apocalypsi docemur. e•c. Hila••. •n P•alm. 2.
iLucretius ex majore part•, & alij integré docent, inferorum regna ne esse quidem posse. Nam locum ipso•um quem possumus dicere; cùm sub •erris d••a••ur esse Antipodes? in mediâ veró terrâ eos esse, nec soliditas patitur, nec centrum terrae, quae terra si in ••edio mundi est; tanta ejus esse profunditas non potest, ut in medio sui habeat inferos, in quibus est Tartarus: de quo legitur, Bis patet in praeceps tantum, etc. Servius, in Aen•i•. 6.
kSi de situ & loco quaesieris, respondebo, dicamque extra terra•ū orbē hunc aliquo esse positam. Non ergo erit, quo fuerit haec loco sita, quin magis quo pacto evitari possit, quaerendū Chrysostom de paemij. sanctor. tom. 3. Oper. Laein.
In the Dialogue betwixt Gregory Nyssen and that admirable woman Macrina, S. Basils sister, touching the Soul and the Resurrection, this point is stood upon at large: the question being first proposed by Gregory in this manner. lWhere is that name of Hades so much spoken of? which is so much treated of in our common conversation, so much in the writings both of the heathen and our own. into which all men think that the souls are translated from hence as into a certain receptacle. For you will not say that the elements ar• this Hades. whereunto Macrina thus replieth. mIt appeareth that thou didst not give much heed to my speech. for when I spake of the translation of the soul from that which is seen unto that which is invisible; I thought I had left nothing behind to be inquired of Hades. Neither doth that name, wherein souls are said to be, seem to me to signify any other thing either in profane writers or in the holy scripture, save only a removing unto that which is invisible and unseen. Thereupon ⟨p. 342⟩it being further demanded: nhow then do some think that a certain subterraneall place should be so called, and that the souls do lodge therein? for answer thereunto it is said, that there is no manner of difference betwixt the lower hemisphere of the earth, and that wherein we live: that as long as the principal doctrine of the immortality of the soul is yielded unto, no controversy should be moved touching the place thereof; that local position is proper to bodies, and the soul being incorporeal hath no need to be detained in certain places. then the place objected from Philip. 2.10. of those under the earth that should bow at the name of Jesus, being largely scanned: this in the end is laid down for the conclusion. oThese things being thus, no man can constrain us by the name of things under the earth to understand any subterraneall place: forasmuch as the air doth so equally compass the earth round about, that there is no part thereof found naked from the covering of the air. Both these opinions are thus propounded by pTheophylact, and by qHugo Etherianus after him. What is Hades or Hell? Some say that it is a dark place under the earth. Others say, that it is the translation of the soul from that which is visible unto that which is unseen and invisible. For while the soul is in the body, it is seen by the proper operations thereof:
In the Dialogue betwixt Gregory Nyssen and that admirable woman Macrina, S. Basils sister, touching the Soule and the Resurrection, this point is stood upon at large: the question being first proposed by Gregory in this maner. lWhere is that name of Hádes somuch spoken of? which is so much treated of in our common conversation, so much in the writings both of the heathen and our owne. into which all men thinke that the soules are translated from hence as into a certaine receptacle. For you will not say that the elements ar• this Hades. whereunto Macrina thus replyeth. mIt appeareth that thou didst not give much heed to my speech. for when I spake of the translation of the soule from that which is seen unto that which is invisible; I thought I had left nothing behinde to be inquired of Had•s. Neyther doth that name, wherein soules are said to be, seeme to me to signifie any other thing eyther in profane writers or in the holy scripture, save onely a removing unto that which is invisible and unseene. Thereupon ⟨p. 342⟩it being further demanded: nhow then doe some thinke that a certaine subterraneall place should be so called, and that the soules doe lodge therein? for answere thereunto it is said, that there is no maner of difference betwixt the lower hemisphere of the earth, and that wherein we live: that as long as the principall doctrine of the immortalitie of the soule is yeelded unto, no controversie should be moved touching the place therof; that locall position is proper to bodies, and the soule being incorporeall hath no need to be detained in certaine places. then the place objected from Philip. 2.10. of those under the earth that should bow at the name of Iesus, being largely skanned: this in the end is laid downe for the conclusion. oThese things being thus, no man can constraine us by the name of things under the earth to understand any subterraneall place: forasmuch as the ayre do•h so equally compasse the earth round about, that there is no part thereof found naked from the covering of the ayre. Both these opinions are thus propounded by p
l[Greek or Hebrew]. Gregor. N•ssen. in Macrin•s, tom. 2 Oper. pag 641.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Gregor. N•ssen. in Macrin•s, tom. 2 Oper. pag 641.
m[Greek or Hebrew]. (fort. [Greek or Hebrew].) Ibid. pag. 641.642.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. (fort. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.) Ibid. pag. 641.642.
n[Greek or Hebrew]; etc. Ibid. pag. 642.〈non-Latin alphabet〉; etc. Ibid. pag. 642.
o[Greek or Hebrew] Ibid, pag. 644.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Ibid, pag. 644.
p[Greek or Hebrew]. Theophylact. in Luc. cap. 16.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Theophylact. in Luc. cap. 16.
qInfernum autem hi quidem putant regionem sub terrâ caliginis & tenebrarum. &c. Alij veró Infernum ex apparitione ad disparitionem animae nominaverunt. Quandiu anima est in corpore, per proprias videtur actiones: sed ubi á corpore discessum est, omnibus modis incognita nobis existit. Hugo. Etherian. de animar. regress. ab Inferis, cap. 11.
So where the author of the Ecclesiastical Hierarchy ⟨p. 343⟩defineth death to be a separation of the united parts, and the bringing to them [Greek or Hebrew], unto that which is invisible to us: his scholiast Maximus noteth thereupon, that rthis invisible thing some do affirm to be Hades; that is to say, an unseen and invisible departure of the soul unto places not to be seen by the sense of man. Hitherto also may be referred the place cited sbefore out of Origen in his fourth book [Greek or Hebrew]: which by S. Hierome is thus delivered. tThey who dye in this world by the separation of the flesh and the soul, according to the difference of their works obtain diverse places in Hell. Where by Hades, Inferi, or Hell he meaneth indefinitely the other world: in which how the souls of the godly were disposed, he thus declareth in another place. uThe soul leaveth the darkness of this world, and the blindness of this bodily nature, and is translated unto another world: which is either the bosom of Abraham, as it is showed in Lazarus, or Paradise, as in the thief that believed upon the cross; or yet if God know that there be any other places, or other mansions, by which the soul that believeth in God passing, and coming unto that river which maketh glad the city of God, may receive within it the lot of the inheritance promised unto the Fathers. For touching the determinate state of the faithful souls departed this life, the ancient Doctors (as we have showed) were not so thoroughly resolved.
So where the author of the Ecclesiasticall Hierarchy ⟨p. 343⟩defineth death to be a separation of the united parts, and the bringing to them 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, unto that which is invisible to us: his scholiast Maximus noteth thereupon, that rthis invisible thing some doe affirme to be Hádes; that is to say, an unseene and invisible departure of the soule unto places not to be seene by the sense of man. Hitherto also may be referred the place cited sbefore out of Origen in his fourth book 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: which by S. Hierome is thus delivered. tThey who dye in this world by the separation of the flesh and the soule, according to the difference of their workes obtaine diverse places in Hell. Where by Hádes, Inferi, or Hell he meaneth indefinitely the other world: in which how the soules of the godly were disposed, hee thus declareth in another place. uThe soule leaveth the darkenesse of this world, and the blindnesse of this bodily nature, and is translated unto another world: which is eyther the bosome of Abraham, as it is shewed in Lazarus, or Paradise, as in the thiefe that beleeved upon the crosse; or yet if God know that there be any other places, or other mansions, by which the soule that beleeveth in God passing, and comming unto that river which maketh glad the citie of God, may receive within it the lott of the inheritance promised unto the Fathers. For touching the determinate state of the faithfull soules departed this life, the ancient Doctors (as we have shewed) were not so thoroughly resolved.
r[Greek or Hebrew] Maxim. in Dionys. Ecclesiast. Hi• rarch. cap. 2.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Maxim. in Dionys. Ecclesiast. Hi• rarch. cap. 2.
sSuprá, pag. 217.
tIn isto mundo qui moriuntur separatione carnis & animae, juxta operum differentiā diversa apud Inferos obtinent loca. Origen. de Prin•ipijs, lib. 4. apud Hieronym. epist. 59. ad Avitum.In isto mundo qui moriuntur separatione carnis & animae, juxta operum differentiā diversa apud Inferos obtinēt loca. Origen. de Prin•ipijs, lib. 4. apud Hieronym. epist. 59. ad Avitum.
uRelinquit anima mundi hujus tenebras, ac naturae corporeae caecitatem, & transfertur ad aliud seculum: quod vel sinus Abrahae, ut in Lazaro, vel Paradisus, ut in latrone qui de cruce credidit, indicatur; vel etiam si qua novit Deus esse alia loca, vel alias mansiones, per quae transiens anima Deo creden•, & perveniens usque ad flumen illud quod laetificat civitatem Dei, intra ipsum sortem promissae patribus haereditatis accipiat. Origen. in Numer. 31. homil. 2•.
Now, all the question betwixt us and the Romanists is, whether the faithful be received into their everlasting tabernacles presently upon their removal out of the body, or after they have been first purified ⟨p. 344⟩to the point (as Allen speaketh) in the furnace of Purgatory: but in the time of the Fathers, as S. Augustin noteth, the xgreat question was, whether the receiving of them into those everlasting tabernacles were performed presently after this life; or in the end of the world, at the resurrection of the dead, and the last retribution of judgement. And so concerning Hell the question was as great among them, whether all, good and bad, went thither or no? whereof the same S. Augustin is a witness also; who upon that speech of Jacob, Gen. 37.35. I will go down to my son mourning into Hell, writeth thus. yIt useth to be a great question, in what manner Hell should be understood: whether evil men only, or good men also when they are dead do use to go down thither. And if evil men only do; how doth he say that he would go down unto his son mourning? for he did not believe that he was in the pains of Hell. Or be these the words of a troubled & grieving man, amplifying his evils from hence? and upon that other speech of his, Genes. 42.38. You shall bring down mine old age with sorrow unto Hell. zWhether therefore unto Hell, because with sorrow? Or although sorrow were away, speaketh he these things as if he were t• go down into hell by dying? For of Hell there is a great question: and what the Scripture delivereth thereof, in all the places where it hath occasion to make mention of it, is to be observed. Hitherto S. Augustin: who had reference to this great question, when he said as hath been abefore alleged. Of Hell neither have I had any experience ⟨p. 345⟩as yet, nor you: and peradventure there shall be another way, and by Hell it shall not be. For these things are uncertain. Neither is there greater question among the Doctors of the Church concerning the Hell of the Fathers of the Old Testament, then there is of the Hell of the faithful now in the time of the New:
Now, all the question betwixt us and the Romanistes is, whether the faithfull be received into their everlasting tabernacles presently upon their removeall out of the body, or after they have beene first purified ⟨p. 344⟩to the point (as Allen speaketh) in the furnace of Purgatorie: but in the time of the Fathers, as S. Augustin noteth, the xgreat question was, vvhether the receiving of them into those everlasting tabernacles were performed presently after this life; or in the end of the world, at the resurrection of the dead, and the last retribution of judgement. And so concerning Hell the question was as great among them, whether all, good and bad, went thither or no? whereof the same S. Augustin is a witnesse also; who upon that speech of Iacob, Gen. 37.35. I will goe downe to my sonne mourning into Hell, writeth thus. yIt useth to be a great question, in what maner Hell should be understood: vvhether evill men onely, or good men also when they are dead doe use to goe downe thither. And if evill men only doe; how doth he say that he would goe downe unto his sonne mourning? for he did not beleeve that he was in the paines of Hell. Or be these the words of a troubled & grieving man, amplifying his evils frō hence? and upon that other speech of his, Genes. 42.38. You shal bring down mine old age with sorrow unto Hell. zWhether therefore unto Hell, because with sorrow? Or although sorrow were away, speaketh he these things as if he were t• goe down into hell by dying? For of Hell there is a great question: and what the Scripture delivereth thereof, in all the places where it hath occasion to make mention of it, is to be observed. Hitherto S. Augustin: who had reference to this great question, when he said as hath beene abefore alledged. Of Hell neyther have I had any experience ⟨p. 345⟩as yet, nor you: and peradventure there shal be another way, and by Hell it shall not be. For these things are uncertaine. Neyther is there greater question among the Doctors of the Church concerning the Hell of the Fathers of the Old Testament, then there is of the Hell of the faithfull now in the time of the New:
xIlla receptio utrùm statim post istam vitam flat, an in fine suculi in resurrectione mortuorum, atque ultimâ retributione judicij; non minima quaestio est. August. Quaestion Evangel lib. 2. cap. 38.Illa receptio utrùm statim post istam vitam flat, an in fine suculi in resurrectione mortuorum, atque ultimâ retributione judicij; non minima quaestio est. August. Quaestion Euange• lib. 2. cap. 38.
ySolet esse magna quaestio, quo modo intelligatur infernus: u•rùm illuc mali tantùm, an etiam boni mortui descendere soleant. Si ergo tantùm mali: quo modo iste ad filium suum see dicit lugentem descendere? Non enim in poenis inferni eum esse credidit. An per turbati & dolentis v•rba sunt, mala sua etiam hinc exagggerantis? Id. Quaestio. 126, in Genesim. & Eucher. in Genes. l•b. 3. cap. 18.Solet esse magna quaestio, quo modo intelligatur infernus: u•rùm illuc mali tantùm, an etiam boni mortui descendere soleant. Si ergo tantùm mali: quo modo iste ad filium suum se dicit lugentem descendere? Non enim in poenis inferni eum esse credidit. An per turbati & dolentis v•rba sunt, mala sua etiam hinc exagggerantis? Id. Quaestio. 126, in Genesim. & Eucher. in Genes. l•b. 3. cap. 18.
zUtrùm ideò ad infernum, quia cum tristitiâ? An etiam si abesset tristitia, tanquam ad in•ernum moriendo descensurus haec loquitur? De inferno enim magna quaestio est: & quid inde Scriptura sentiat, locis omnibus ubi fortè hoc commemoratum fuerit, observandum est. Augustin. Quaest. 142. in Genes•m. & Eucher. in Genes. lib. 3. cap. 27.Vtrùm ideò ad infernum, quia cum tristitiâ? An etiam si abesset tristitia, tanquam ad in•ernum moriendo descensurus haec loquitur? De inferno enim magna quaestio est: & quid inde Scriptura sentiat, locis omnibus ubi fortè hoc commemoratum fuerit, observandum est. Augustin. Quaest. 142. in Genes•m. & Eucher. in Genes. lib. 3. cap. 27.
neither are there greater differences betwixt them touching the Hell into which our Saviour went (whether it were under the earth or above, whether a darksome place or a lightsome, whether a prison or a paradise) then there are of the mansions wherein the souls of the blessed do now continue.
neyther are there greater differences betwixt them touching the Hell into which our Saviour went (whether it were under the earth or above, whether a darkesome place or a lightsome, whether a prison or a paradise) then there are of the mansions wherein the soules of the blessed do now continue.
S. Hierome, interpreting those words of King Hezekiah, Isaiah. 38.10. I shall go to the gates of Hell: saith that this is meant, beither of the common law of nature, or else of those gates, from which that he was delivered, the Psalmist singeth; Thou that liftest me up from the gates of death, that I may show forth all thy praises in the gates of the daughter of Zion. (Psalm. 9.13, 14.) Now as some of the Fathers do expound our Saviours going to Hell, of his descending into Gehenna: so others expound it of his going to Hell according to the common law of nature; the common law of nature (I say) which extendeth it self indifferently unto all the dead, whether they belong to the state of the New Testament or of the Old. For as Christs soul was in all points made like unto ours (sin only excepted) while it was joined with his body here in the land of the living: so when he had humbled himself unto the death, it became him in all things to be made like unto his brethren, even in that state of dissolution. cAnd so indeed the soul of Jesus had experience of both. For ⟨p. 346⟩it was in the place of human souls, and being out of the flesh did live and subsist. It was a reasonable soul therefore and of the same substance with the souls of men; even as his flesh is of the same substance with the flesh of men, proceeding from Mary: saith Eustathius the Patriarch of Antioch in his exposition of that text of the Psalm; Thou wilt not leave my soul in Hell, Where by [Greek or Hebrew] or Hell, you see, he understandeth [Greek or Hebrew], the place of human souls (which is the Hebrews [Greek or Hebrew] or world of spirits) and by the disposing of Christs soul there after the manner of other souls, concludeth it to be of the same nature with other mens souls. So S Hilary in his exposition of the 138. Psalm. dThis is the law of human necessity, saith he, that the bodies being buried, the souls should go to Hell. Which descent the Lord did not refuse for the accomplishment of a true man. and a little after he repeateth it, that de supernis ad inferos mortis lege descendit, he descended from the supernall to the infernal parts by the law of death. and upon the 53. Psalm more fully. eTo fulfil the nature of man he subjected himself to death, that is, to a departure as it were of the soul and body;
S. Hierome, interpreting those words of King Ezechias, Esai. 38.10. I shall goe to the gates of Hell: saith that this is meant, beyther of the common law of nature, or else of those gates, from which that he was delivered, the Psalmist singeth; Thou that liftest me up from the gates of death, that I may shew forth all thy prayses in the gates of the daughter of Sion. (Psalm. 9.13, 14.) Now as some of the Fathers doe expound our Saviours going to Hell, of his descending into Gehenna: so others expound it of his going to Hell according to the common law of nature; the common law of nature (I say) which extendeth it selfe indifferently unto all the dead, whether they belong to the state of the New Testament or of the Old. For as Christs soule was in all points made like unto ours (sinne onely excepted) while it was joyned with his body here in the land of the living: so when he had humbled himselfe unto the death, it became him in all things to be made like unto his brethren, even in that state of dissolution. cAnd so indeed the soule of Iesus had experience of both. For ⟨p. 346⟩it was in the place of humaine soules, and being out of the flesh did live and subsist. It was a reasonable soule therefore and of the same substance with the soules of men; even as his flesh is of the same substance with the flesh of men, proceeding from Mary: saith Eustathius the Patriarch of Antioch in his exposition of that text of the Psalme; Thou wilt not leave my soule in Hell, Where by 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 or Hell, you see, he understandeth 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, the place of humaine soules (which is the Hebrewes 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 or world of spirits) and by the disposing of Christs soule there after the maner of other soules, concludeth it to be of the same nature with other mens soules. So S Hilary in his exposition of the 138. Psalme. dThis is the law of humaine necessitie, saith he, that the bodies being buried, the soules should goe to Hell. Which descent the Lord did not refuse for the accomplishment of a true man. and a little after he repeateth it, that de supernis ad inferos mortis lege descendit, he descended from the supernall to the infernall parts by the law of death. and upon the 53. Psalme more fully.
bVel communi lege naturae, vel•illas portas, de qu•bus quòd liberatus sit, Psalmista decantat: Qui exaltas me de portis mortis, ut annunciem omnes laudationes tuas in portis filiae Zion Hi•ronym. lib. 11. in Isaiah. cap. 38.Vel communi lege naturae, vel•illas portas, de qu•bus quòd liberatus sit, Psalmista decantat: Qui exaltas me de portis mortis, ut annunciem omnes laudationes tuas in portis filiae Sion Hi•ronym. lib. 11. in Esai. cap. 38.
c[Greek or Hebrew]. Eustathius Antiochen. in Psal. 15. citatus á •heodoreto in [Greek or Hebrew]. dialog. 1.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Eustathius Antiochen. in Psal. 15. citatus á •heodoreto in 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. dialog. 1.
dHumanae ista lex necessitatis est, ut consepultis corporibus ad inferos animae descendant. Quam descensionem Dominus ad consummationem veri hominis non recusavit. Hilari. in Psal. 138.
eAd explendam quidem hominis naturam etiā morti se, id est, discenssioni se tanquam animae corporisque subjecit; & ad infernas sedes, id quod homini debitum videtur esse, penetravit. Id. in Psalm. 53.Ad explendam quidem hominis naturam etiā morti se, id est, discenssioni se tanquam animae corporisque subjecit; & ad infernas sedes, id quod homini debitum videtur esse, penetravit. Id. in
translated by Iunius, in Act. 2.31. (or, as the Arabian divideth the book, Act. 4.10.) confound them together, and retaine the same word in both the parts of the sentence, after this maner. Hee was not left in perdition, neyther did his flesh see perdition. even as in the 29. Psalme (or the 30. according to the division of the Hebrewes) the Arabick readeth,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉 al-gehim, or Hell, where the Greek hath 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, the Hebrew 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, & the Chaldee paraphrase 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that is, the house of the grave.
For neither will any man say, (quoth he) that Paradise is in the places under the earth, or the places under the earth in Paradise, that at the same time he might be in
⟨p. 315⟩
both; or that those (infernall) places are called the hand of the Father. Now for the last of these, hee saith the case is
the three pecks of floure are first the whole nature of mankind, then death, and lastly Hell; wherein the divine BODY being hidden by BURIALL, did leaven all unto resurrection and life. Whereupon he bringeth in our Saviour in another place speaking thus.
I will therefore be buried, for their sakes that be in Hell:
g
Idcirco sepeliar, propter eos qui in Orco sunt: idcirco veluti saxum aliquod percutiā illius portas, educens vinctos in fortitudine, quemadmodū inquit Davids servus meus. Id. Dialog 3.Idcirco sepeliar, propter eos qui in Orco sunt: idcirco veluti saxum aliquod percutiā illius portas, educens vinctos in fortitudine, quemadmodū inquit Davides servus meus. Id. Dialog 3.
Death is the separation of the soule and the body. But Hades. is a place to us invisible or vnseene and unknowne, which receiveth our soules when they departe from hence. The ordinary Glosse, following S. Hierome upon the thirteenth of Hosea, thus.
Death is that, whereby the soule is separated from the body.
The soules of the ungodly flie under the heaven (or under the earth) in cruell torments, under the unavoydable yoakes of evills. but the soules of the godly, dwelling in heaven, doe prayse that great blessed one with songs and hymnes.
The soule, being an invisible thing, goeth hence into such another noble and pure and invisible place; to Hades, in truth, unto the good and wise God: whither, if God will, my soule must presently goe. which place is alledged by
in the things which concerne the immortalitie of the soule, Plato doth differ in opinion nothing from Moses. The tale also which Socrates there telleth of the
pure land seated above in the pure heaven, though it have a number of toyes added to it (as tales use to have) yet the foundation thereof both Eusebius and Origen doe judge to have beene taken from
⟨p. 335⟩
the speeches of the Prophets touching the land of promise and the heavenly Canaan:
Euseb. Praepar. Euangel. lib. 11. pag. 325.
u[Greek or Hebrew]. Ibid. pag. 323.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid. pag. 323.
the common multitude, whom wise men (saith he) call simple people, being perswaded of these things by Homer and Hesiod and such other fabulous authors, and receiving their Poëms for a law; tooke HADES to be a certaine deepe place under the earth. The first originall of which conceite is by Cicero derived from hence.
The bodies falling into the ground, and being covered with earth, (whence they are said to be interred) men thought that the rest of the life of the dead was led under the earth, upon which opinion of theirs (saith he) great errors did ensue: which were increased by the Poës. Others do imagine, that the Poets herein had some relation to the
sphericall situation of the world: for the better understanding whereof, these particulars following would be considered by them that have some knowledge in this kinde of learning.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Lucian. de luctu.
mIn terram enim cadentibus corporibus, hisque humo tectis, ex quo dictum est humari; sub terrâ censebant reliquam vitam agi mortuorum. quam •orum opinionem magni errores consecuti sunt: quos auxerunt Poëtae. Cic. Tuscul. quaest. lib. 1.
nHera•lid Pontic de Allegor. Homer. Servius, in Virgil. Ae•e•d. lib. 6.
⟨p. 338⟩
wherein he followed Eratosthenes, as his expositor Eustathius there noteth: who compareth also with this, that place of Orpheus 〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
— 〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
whereunto answereth that of
Achilles Statius citeth it) of Neoptolemus Parianus in his 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
[Greek or Hebrew]. Aristot. de Mundo, cap. 3.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Aristot. de Mundo, cap. 3.
yCitat ab Arati scholiaste, edit. cum Hipparcho, Florent. an. 1567. pag. 115.
zAchil. Stat. in Arateis, ibid. pag 93.
•
•
•
•
•
Si de situ & loco quaesieris, respondebo, dicamque extra terra•ū orbē hunc aliquo esse positam. Non ergo erit, quo fuerit haec loco sita, quin magis quo pacto evitari possit, quaerendū • Chrysostom de p•aemij. sanctor. tom. 3. Oper. Lae•in.
Hugò Etherianus after him. What is Hades or Hell? Some say that it is a darke place under the earth. Others say, that it is the translation of the soule from that which is visible unto that which is unseene and invisible. For while the soule is in the body, it is seene by the proper operations thereof: