AN ANSWER TO THE FORMER CHALLENGE.AN ANSVVER TO THE FORMER CHALLENGE.
pp. 1–527550 passagespart 3 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
to the end it might be thought, that the Grace which is above all things, did distil the blood thereof into that cup by his Invocation. And even according to this precedent we find it fell our afterwards, that the principal and most powerful means whereby the like gross conceit (of the guttural •ating and drinking of the body and blood of Christ) was at the first fastened upon the multitude, and in process of time more deeply rooted in them, were such delusions and feigned apparitions as these: which yet that great Schoolman himself, Alexander of Hales, confesseth to happen sometimes, either by f•he procurement of man, or by the operation of the devil. Paschasius Radbertus, who was one of the first letters forward of this doctrine in the West, spendeth a large chapter upon this point: wherein he telleth us, gthat Christ in the sacrament did show himself oftentimes in a visible shape, either in the form of a Lamb, or in the colour of flesh and blood, so that while the host was a breaking or an offering, a Lamb in the Priests hands, and blood in the Chalice should be seen as it ⟨p. 69⟩were flowing from the sacrifice, that what lay hid in a mystery, might to them that yet doubted be made manifest in a miracle. And specially in that place he insisteth upon a narration, which he found in gestis Anglorum, (but deserved well to have been put into gesta Romanorum for the goodness of it) of one Ple•gils or Plegilus a Priest; how an Angel showed Christ unto him in the form of a child upon the Altar, whom first he took into his arms and kissed, but eat him up afterwards, when he was returned to his former shape again. Whereof arose that jest which Berengarius was wont to use: hThis was a proper peace of the knave indeed, that whom he had kissed with his mouth, he would devour with his teeth.
to the end it might be thought, that the Grace which is above all things, did distill the blood thereof into that cup by his Invo•ation. And even according to this precedent we finde it fell our afterwards, that the principall and most powerfull meanes whereby the like grosse conceit (of the gutturall ating and drinking of the bodie and blood of Christ) was at the first fastened upon the multitude, and in processe of time more deeply rooted in them, were such delusions and fained apparitions as these: which yet that great Schooleman himselfe, Alexander of Hales, confesseth to happen sometimes, either by
•he procurement of man, or by the operation of the divell. Paschasius Radbertus, who was one of the first letters forward of this doctrine in the West, spendeth a large chapter upon this point: wherein he telleth us,
that Christ in the sacrament did shew himselfe oftentimes in a visible shape, eyther in the forme of a Lamb, or in the colour of flesh and blood, so that while the hoste was a breaking or an offering, a Lamb in the Priests hands, and blood in the Chalice should be seene as it
⟨p. 69⟩
were flowing from the sacrifice, that what lay hid in a mysterie, might to them that yet doubted be made manifest in a miracle. And specially in that place hee insisteth upon a narration, which he found in gestis Anglorum, (but deserved well to have been put into gesta Romanorum for the goodnesse of it) of one Ple•gils or Plegilus a Priest; how an Angell shewed Christ unto him in the forme of a childe upon the Altar, whom first hee tooke into his armes and kissed, but eate him up afterwards, when he was returned to his former shape again. Whereof arose that jeast which Berengarius was wont to use:
gNemo, qui Sanctorum vitas & exempla legerit, potest ignorare, quòd saepè haec mystica corporis & sanguinis sacramenta, aut propter dubios, aut certé propter ardentiùs amantes Christum, visibili spécie in agni formâ, aut in carnis & sanguinis colour monstrata sint: quatenùs de se Christus clementer adhuc non credentibus fidem faceret: ita u• dum oblata frangitur, vel offertur hostia, videretur agnus in manibus & crnor in calice, quasi ex immolatione profluere. ut quod latebat in mysterio, patesceret adhuc dubitantibus in miraculo. Paschas. de corp. & sangu. Dom. cap. 14.Nemo, qui Sanctorum vitas & exempla legerit, potest ignorare, quòd saepè haec mystica corporis & sanguinis sacramenta, aut propter dubios, aut certé propter ardentiùs amantes Christum, visibili spécie in agni formâ, aut in carnis & sanguinis colore monstrata sint: quatenùs de se Christus clementer adhuc non credentibus fidem faceret: ita u• dum oblata frangitur, vel offertur hostia, videretur agnus in manibus & crnor in calice, quasi ex immolatione profluere. ut quod latebat in mysterio, patesceret adhuc dubitantibus in miraculo. Paschas. de corp. & sangu. Dom. cap. 14.
hSpeciosa certé pax nebulonis; ut cui o•is praebuerat basium, dentiū inferret exitiū. Guilielm. Malmesbur. de gestis Reg. Anglor. lib. 3.Speciosa certé pax nebulonis; ut cui o•is praebuerat basium, dentiū inferret exitiū. Guilielm. Malmesbur. de gestis Reg. Anglor. lib. 3.
But there are three other tales of singular note; which though they may justly strive for winning of the Whetstone with any other, yet for their antiquity have gained credit above the rest: being devised, as it seemeth, much about the same time with that other of Plegilus, but having relation unto higher times. The first was had out of the English Legends too, as iJohannes Diaconus reporteth it in the life of Gregory the first: of a Roman Matron, who found a piece of the sacramental bread turned into the fashion of a finger, all bloody, which afterwards, upon the prayers of S. Gregory, was converted to his former shape again. The other two were first coined by the Grecian liars, and from them conveyed unto the Latins, and registered in the book which they called Vitas patrum: which being commonly believed to have been collected by S. kHierome, and accustomed to be read ordinarily in every Monastery; gave occasion of further spread, and made much way for the progress of this mystery of ⟨p. 70⟩iniquity. The former of these is not only related there, lbut also in the Legend of Simeon Metaphrastes, (which is such another author among the Grecians, as Jacobus de Voragine was among the Latins) in the mlife of Arsenius: how that a little child was seen upon the Altar, and an Angel cutting him into small pieces with a knife, and receiving his blood into the Chalice, as long as the Priest was breaking the bread into little parts. The latter, is of a certain Jew, receiving the Sacrament at S. Basils hands, converted visibly into true flesh and blood: which is expressed by Cyrus Theodorus Prodromus, in this Tetrastich.
[Greek or Hebrew]
[Greek or Hebrew].
[Greek or Hebrew],
[Greek or Hebrew].
But the chief author of the fable was a cheating fellow, who, nthat he might lye with authority, took upon him the name of Amphilochius, S. Basils companion, and set out a book of his life ofraught with leasings: as Cardinal Baronius himself acknowledgeth. S. Augustine's conclusion therefore may here well take place. pLet these things be taken away, which are either fictions of lying men, or wonders wrought by evil spirits. For either there is no truth in these reports, or if there be any strange things done by heretics, we ought the more to beware of them:
But there are three other tales of singular note; which though they may justly strive for winning of the Whetstone with anie other, yet for their antiquitie have gained credite above the rest: being devised, as it seemeth, much about the same time with that other of Plegilus, but having relation unto higher times. The first was had out of the English Legends too, as iIohannes Diaconus reporteth it in the life of Gregory the first: of a Romane Matron, who found a piece of the sacramentall bread turned into the fashion of a finger, all bloodie, which afterwards, upon the prayers of S. Gregory, was converted to his former shape againe. The other two were first coyned by the Grecian lyars, and from them conveyed unto the Latines, and registred in the booke which they called Vitas patrum: which being commonly beleeved to have beene collected by S. kHierome, and accustomed to be read ordinarily in everie Monasterie; gave occasion of further spred, and made much way for the progresse of this mysterie of ⟨p. 70⟩iniquitie. The former of these is not onely related there, lbut also in the Legend of Simeon Metaphrastes, (which is such another author among the Grecians, as Iacobus de Voragine was among the Latines) in the mlife of Arsenius: how that a little childe was seene upon the Altar, and an Angell cutting him into small piec•s with a knife, and receiving his blood into the Chalice, as long as the Priest was breaking the bread into little parts. The latter, is of a certaine Iew, receiving the Sacrament at S. Basils hands, converted visibly into true flesh and blood: which is expressed by Cyrus Theodorus Prodromus, in this Tetrastich.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
But the chiefe author of the fable was a cheating fellow, who, nthat hee might lye with authoritie, tooke upon him the name of Amphilochius, S. Basils companion, and set out a booke of his life
kSanctus Hieronymus presbyter, ipsas Sanctorum Patrum Vitas Latino edidit sermone. Paschas. Radbert. in epist. ad Frudegard. Consule libros Carolinos, de Imaginib. lib. 4. cap. 11.
lInter sententias Patrum, áe P••agio Roman•e ecclesiae d•acono Latiné versas, libel. •8. cui •i••lus de Providentiâ vel Proevidentiâ: sive, ut in P•o•ij •iblio•hecâ habetur, •od. 98. [Greek or Hebrew].Inter sententias Patrum, áe P••agio Roman•e ecclesiae d•acono Latiné versas, libell. •8. cui •i••lus de Providentiâ vel Proevidentiâ: sive, ut in P•o•ij •iblio•hecâ habetur, •od. 98. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
mTom. 4. Surij, pag 257. edit. Colon an. 1573.
nNomen Amphilochii ad mentiendum accepit. Baron. tom 4. an. 369. sect. 43.
oScatens men daciis, Id. ibid. an. 363. sect. 55.Scatens mē daciis, Id. ibid. an. 363. sect. 55.
because, when the Lord had said, that certain deceivers should come, who by doing of some wonders should seduce (if it were possible) the very elect, he very ⟨p. 71⟩earnestly commended this unto our consideration, and said; Behold, I have told you before. yea and added a further charge also, that if these impostors should say unto us of him, qBehold he is in secret closets, we should not believe it: which whether it be appliable to them who tell us, that Christ is to be found in a Pyx, and think that they have him in safe custody under Locke and Key; I leave to the consideration of others.
because, when the Lord had said, that certaine deceivers should come, who by doing of some wonders should seduce (if it were possible) the very elect, he verie ⟨p. 71⟩earnestly commended this unto our consideration, and said; Behold, I have told you before. yea and added a further charge also, that if these impostors should say unto us of him, qBehold he is in secret closets, wee should not beleeve it: which whether it be appliable to them who tell us, that Christ is to be found in a Pixe, and thinke that they have him in safe custodie under Locke and Key; I leave to the consideration of others.
The thing which now I would have further observed, is only this; that, as that wretched heretic who first went about to persuade m•n by his lying wonders, that he really delivered wine unto them in the cup of the Eucharist, was censured for being [Greek or Hebrew], an Idol-maker· so in after ages, from the Idol-makers and Image-worshippers of the East it was, that this gross opinion of the oral eating and drinking of Christ in the Sacrament, drew it first breath; rGod having for their idolatry, justly given them up unto a reprobate mind, that they might receive that recompense of their error which was meet. The Popes name in whose days this fell out, was Gregory the second: the mans name who was the principal setter of it abroach, was sJohn Damascene; one that laid the foundation of School-divinity among the Greeks, as Peter Lombard afterwards did among the Latins. On the contrary side, they who opposed the Idolatry of those times, and more especially the CCCXXXVIII. Bishops assembled together at the Council of Constantinople, in the year 754. maintained, that Christ tchose no other shape or type under heaven to represent his incarnation by, but the Sacrament; which uhe delivered to his ministers for a type and a most effectual commemoration thereof; xcommanding the substance of bread to be offered, which did ⟨p. 72⟩not any way resemble the form of a man, that so no occasion might be given of bringing in Idolatry. which bread they affirmed to be the body of Christ, not [Greek or Hebrew] but [Greek or Hebrew], that is, (as they themselves expound it) ya holy and za true image of his natural flesh.
The thing which now I would have further observed, is onely this; that, as that wretched heretick who first went about to perswade m•n by his lying wonders, that he really delivered wine unto them in the cup of the Eucharist, was censured for being 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, an Idol-maker· so in after ages, from the Idol-makers and Image-worshippers of the East it was, that this grosse opinion of the orall eating and drinking of Christ in the Sacrament, drew it first breath; rGod having for their idolatrie, justly given them up unto a reprobate minde, that they might receive that recompence of their errour which was meete. The Popes name in whose dayes this fell out, was Gregory the second: the mans name who was the principall setter of it abroach, was sIohn Damascen; one that laid the foundation of Schoole-divinitie among the Greeks, as Peter Lombard afterwards did among the Latins. On the contrarie side, they who opposed the Idolatrie of those times, and more especially the CCCXXXVIII. Bishops assembled together at the Councell of Constantinople, in the yeare 754. maintayned, that Christ tchose no other shape or type under heaven to represent his incarnation by, but the Sacrament; which uhe delivered to his ministers for a type and a most effectuall commemoration therof; xcommanding the substance of bread to be offered, which did ⟨p. 72⟩not any way resemble the forme of a man, that so no occasion might be given of bringing in Idolatry. which bread they affirmed to be the bodie of Christ, not 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 but 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that is, (as they themselves expound it) ya holy and za true image of his naturall flesh.
z[Greek or Hebrew] &c. So a little after it is called [Greek or Hebrew], and [Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉 &c. So a little after it is called 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
These assertions of theirs are to be found in the athird Tome of the sixth Action of the second Council of Nice, assembled not long after for the reestablishing of Images in the Church. where a pratchant deacon, called Epiphanius, to cross that which those former Bishops had delivered, confidently avoucheth that none of the Apostles, nor of the Fathers, did ever call the Sacrament an image of the body of Christ. He confesseth indeed that some of the Fathers (as Eustathius expounding the Proverbs of Solomon, and S. Basil in his Liturgy) do call the bread and wine [Greek or Hebrew], correspondent types or figures, before they were consecrated: bbut after the consecration (saith he) they are called, and are, and believed to be the body and blood of Christ properly. where the Popes own followers, who of late published the Acts of the general Councils at Rome, were so far ashamed of the ignorance of this blind Bayard; that they correct his boldness with this marginal note. cThe holy gifts are oftentimes found to be called antitypes, or figures correspondent, after they be consecrated: as by Gregory Nazianz. in the funeral Oration upon his sister, and in his Apology; by Cyril of Jerusalem in his fifth Cateches. Mystagogic. and by others. And we have already heard, how the author of the Dialogues against the Marcionites, and after him Eusebius and Gelasius, expressly call the Sacrament an image of Christs body: howsoever this peremptory Clerk denieth, that ever any did so. By all which it may easily ⟨p. 73⟩appear, that, not the oppugners, but the defenders of Images, were the men who first went about herein to alter the language used by their fore-fathers.
These assertions of theirs are to bee found in the athird Tome of the sixth Action of the second Councell of Nice, assembled not long after for the reestablishing of Images in the Church. where a pratchant deacon, called Epiphanius, to crosse that which those former Bishops had delivered, confidently avoucheth that none of the Apostles, nor of the Fathers, did ever call the Sacrament an image of the bodie of Christ. Hee confesseth indeed that some of the Fathers (as Eustathius expounding the Proverbs of Salomon, and S. Basil in his Liturgie) doe call the bread and wine 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, correspondent types or figures, before they were consecrated: bbut after the consecration (saith hee) they are called, and are, and beleeved to be the body and blood of Christ properly. where the Popes owne followers, who of late published the Acts of the generall Councells at Rome, were so farre ashamed of the ignorance of this blind Bayard; that they correct his boldnesse with this marginall note. cThe holy gifts are oftentimes found to be called antitypes, or figures correspondent, after they be consecrated: as by Gregory Nazianz. in the funerall Oration upon his sister, and in his Apologie; by Cyrill of Ierusalem in his fifth Cateches. Mystagogic. and by others. And wee have alreadie heard, how the author of the Dialogues against the Marcionites, and after him Eusebius and Gelasius, expressely call the Sacrament an image of Christs bodie: howsoever this peremptorie Clerke denieth, that ever anie did so. By all which it may easily ⟨p. 73⟩appeare, that, not the oppugners, but the defenders of Images, were the men who first went about herein to alter the language used by their fore-fathers.
aConcil. gener. tom. 3. pag. 599.600. edit Rom.
b[Greek or Hebrew]. Ib. pag. 601.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ib. pag. 601.
c[Greek or Hebrew]. Ibid. in margin.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid. in margine.
Now as in the days of Gregory the third this matter was set afoot by Damascene in the East: so about a hundred years after, in the Papacy of Gregory the fourth, the same began to be propounded in the West, by means of one Amalarius, who was Bishop, not (as he is commonly taken to be) of Triers, but of Metz first, and afterwards of Lyons. This man writing doubtfully of this point; otherwhiles followeth the doctrine of S. Augustine, dthat Sacraments were oftentimes called by the names of the things themselves, and so the Sacrament of Christs body was secundùm quendam modum, after a certain manner the body of Christ: otherwhiles maketh it a part of his ebelief, that the simple nature of the bread and wine mixed, is turned into a reasonable nature, to wit, of the body and blood of Christ. But what should become of this body, after the eating thereof, was a matter that went beyond his little wit: and therefore, said he, fwhen the body of Christ is taken with a good intention, it is not for me to dispute, whether it be invisibly taken up into heaven, or kept in our body until the day of our burial, or exhaled into the air, or whether it go out of the body with the blood, (at the opening of a vein) or be sent out by the mouth; our Lord saying, that every thing which entereth into the mouth goeth into the belly, and is sent forth into the draught. For this, and another like foolerie de gtriformi & tripartito corpore Christi, of the three parts or kinds of Christs body (which ⟨p. 74⟩seem to be those ineptiae de tripartito Christi corpore, that Paschasius in the end of his Epistle entreateth Frudegardus not to follow:) he was censured in a hSynod held at Carisiacum: wherein it was declared by the Bishops of France, that ithe bread and wine are spiritually made the body of Christ; which being a meat of the mind, and not of the belly, is not corrupted, but remaineth unto everlasting life.
Now as in the daies of Gregory the third this matter was set afoot by Damascen in the East: so about a hundred yeares after, in the Papacie of Gregory the fourth, the same began to be propounded in the West, by meanes of one Amalarius, who was Bishop, not (as hee is commonly taken to be) of Triers, but of Mets first, and afterwards of Lyons. This man writing doubtfully of this point; otherwhiles followeth the doctrine of S. Augustine, dthat Sacraments were oftentimes called by the names of the things themselves, and so the Sacrament of Christs bodie was secundùm quendam modum, after a certaine maner the bodie of Christ: otherwhiles maketh it a part of his ebeleefe, that the simple nature of the bread and wine mixed, is turned into a reasonable nature, to wit, of the body and blood of Christ. But what should become of this bodie, after the eating therof, was a matter that went beyond his little witt: and therefore, said he, fwhen the bodie of Christ is taken with a good intention, it is not for me to dispute, whether it be invisibly taken up into heaven, or kept in our body untill the day of our buriall, or exhaled into the ayre, or whether it go out of the body with the blood, (at the opening of a veyne) or be sent out by the mouth; our Lord saying, that every thing which entreth into the mouth goeth into the belly, and is sent forth into the draught. For this, and another like foolerie de gtriformi & tripartito corpore Christi, of the three parts or kindes of Christs body (which ⟨p. 74⟩seeme to be those ineptiae de tripartito Christi corpore, that Paschasius in the end of his Epistle intreateth Frudegardus not to follow:) he was censured in a hSynod held at Carisiacum: wherein it was declared by the Bishops of France, that ithe bread and wine are spiritually made the body of Christ; which being a meat of the mind, and not of the belly, is not corrupted, but remayneth unto everlasting life.
fIta veró sumptum corpus Domini bonâ intentione, non est mihi disputandū utrùm invisibiliter assumatur in coelum, aut reservetur in corpore nostro usque in diem sepulturae, aut exhaletur in auras, aut exeat de corpore cū sanguine, aut per os emittatur; dicente Domino, Omne quod intrat in os in ventrem vadit & in secessum emittitur. Idem, in epistolâ ad Guitardum, MS. in Biblioth. Colleg. S. Benedict. Cantabrig. cod. 55.Ita veró sumptum corpus Domini bonâ intentione, non est mihi disputandū utrùm invisibiliter assumatur in coelum, aut reservetur in corpore nostro usque in diem sepulturae, aut exhaletur in auras, aut exeat de corpore cū sanguine, aut per os emittatur; dicente Domino, Omne quod intrat in os in ventrem vadit & in secessum emittitur. Idem, in epistolâ ad Guitardum, MS. in Biblioth. Colleg. S. Benedict. Cantabrig. cod. 55.
gId. de Ecclesiastic. offic. lib. 3. cap. 35.
hFlorus in Actis Synod. Carisiac. MS. apud N. Ranchinum, in Senatu Tolosan• Regium Consiliarium. Vid. Phil. Morn. de Miss. lib. 4. cap. 8.
iPanis & vinū efficitur spiritualiter corpus Christi. &c. Mentis ergo est cibus iste, non ventris: nec corrumpitur, sed permanet, in vitam aeternam. Ibid.Panis & vinū efficitur spiritualiter corpus Christi. &c. Mentis ergo est cibus iste, non ventris: nec corrumpitur, sed permanet, in vitam aeternam. Ibid.
These dotages of Amalarius, did not only give occasion to that question propounded by Heribaldus to Rabanus, whereof we have spoken kheretofore; but also to that other of far greater consequence: Whether that which was externally delivered & received in the sacrament, were the very same body which was borne of the Virgin Mary, & suffered upon the Cr•sse, & rose again from the Grave. Paschasius Radbertus (a Deacon of those times, but somewhat of a better and more modest temper then the Greek Deacon showed himself to be of) held that it was the ve•ie same; and to that purpose wrote his book to Placidus, of the Body & Blood of our Lord: wherein (saith a Jesuit) lhe was the first that did so explicate the true sense of the Catholic Church, (his own Roman he meaneth) that he opened the way to those many others, who wrote afterwards of the same argument. Rabanus on the other side, in a writing directed to Abbot Egilo, maintained the contrary doctrine: as hath before been noted. Then one Frudegardus, reading the third book of S. Augustin de doctrinâ Christianâ, and finding there, that the eating of the flesh and drinking of the blood of Christ was a figurative manner of speech, began somewhat to doubt of the truth of that which formerly he had read in that foresaid Treatise of Paschasius: which moved Paschasius to ⟨p. 75⟩write again of the same argument, as of a question wherein he confesseth mmany were then doubtful. But neither by his first nor by his second writing was he able to take these doubts out of mens minds: and therefore Carolus Calvus the Emperor, being desirous to compose these differences, and to have unity settled among his subjects, required Ratrannus (a learned man of that time, who lived in the Monastery of Corbey, whereof Paschasius was Abbot) to deliver his judgement touching these points. nWhether the body and blood of Christ which in the Church is received by the mouth of the faithful, be celebrated in a mystery or in the truth; and whether it be the same body, which was born of Mary, which did suffer, was dead and buried, & which rising again and ascending into heaven sitteth at the right hand of the Father? Whereunto he returneth this answer: that othe bread and the wine are the body and blood of Christ figuratively; that pfor the substance of the creatures, that which they were before consecration, the same are they also afterward;
These dotages of Amalarius, did not only give occasion to that question propounded by Heribaldus to Rabanus, wherof we have spoken kheretofore; but also to that other of far greater consequence: Whether that which was externally delivered & received in the sacrament, were the verie same body which was borne of the Virgin Mary, & suffered upon the Cr•sse, & rose again from the Grave. Paschasius Radbertus (a Deacon of those times, but somewhat of a better and more modest temper then the Greek Deacon shewed himselfe to be of) held that it was the ve•ie same; and to that purpose wrote his book to Placidus, of the Body & Blood of our Lord: wherein (saith a Iesuite) lhe was the first that did so explicate the true sense of the Càtholick Church, (his owne Romane he meaneth) that he opened the way to those manie others, who wrote afterwards of the same argument. Rabanus on the other side, in a writing directed to Abbot Egilo, maintayned the contrarie doctrine: as hath before beene noted. Then one Frudegardus, reading the third book of S. Augustin de doctrinâ Christianâ, and finding there, that the eating of the flesh and drinking of the blood of Christ was a figurative maner of speech, began somewhat to doubt of the truth of that which formerly he had read in that foresaid Treatise of Paschasius: which moved Paschasius to ⟨p. 75⟩write againe of the same argument, as of a question wherein he confesseth mmany were then doubtfull. But neither by his first nor by his second writing was hee able to take these doubts out of mens mindes: and therefore Carolus Calvus the Emperour, being desirous to compose these differences, and to have unitie setled among his subjects, required Ratrannus (a learned man of that time, who lived in the Monasterie of Corbey, whereof Paschasius was Abbat) to deliver his judgement touching these points. nWhether the body and blood of Christ which in the Church is received by the mouth of the faithfull, be celebrated in a mysterie or in the truth; and whether it be the same body, which was born of Mary, which did suffer, was dead and buried, & which rising againe and ascending into heaven sitteth at the right hand of the Father? Whereunto he returneth this answer: that o
kSupr. pag. 16.
lGenuinū Ecclesiae Catholicae sensum ita primus explicuit, ut viam caeteris aperuerit, qui de eodē argumento multi postea scripsere. Jac. Sirmond. in vitâ Radberti.Genuinū Ecclesiae Catholicae sensum ita primus explicuit, ut viam caeteris aperuerit, qui de eodē argumento multi postea scripsere. Iac. Sirmond. in vitâ Radberti.
mQuaeris enim de re ex quâ multi dubitant and again. Quamvis multi ex hoc dubitent, quomodo ille integer manet, & hoc corpus Christi & sanguis •sse possit. Paschas. epist. ad Frudegard.Quaeris enim de re ex quâ multi dubitant and againe. Quamvis multi ex hoc dubitent, quomodo ille integer manet, & hoc corpus Christi & sanguis •sse possit. Paschas. epist. ad Frudegard.
nQuod in Ecclesiâ ore fidelium sumitur corpus & sanguis Christi, quaerit vestrae magnitudinis excellentia, in mysterio fiat, an in veritate, &c. & utrùm ipsum corpus sit, quod de Mariâ natum est, & passum, mortuum & sepultum, quodque resurgens & coelos ascendens, ad dextram Patris consideat? Ratrann. sive Bertram. in lib. de corp. & sangu. Dom. edit. Colon. an. 1551. pag. 180.Quod in Ecclesiâ ore fidelium sumitur corpus & sanguis Christi, quaerit vestrae magnitudinis excellentia, in mysterio fiat, an in veritate, &c. & utrùm ipsum corpus sit, quod de Mariâ natum est, & passum, mortuum & sepultum, quodque resurgens & coelos ascendens, ad dextram Patris consideat? Ratrann. sive Bertram. in lib. de corp. & sangu. Dom. edit. Colon. ann. 1551. pag. 180.
oPanis ille vinumque, figuraté Christi corpus & sanguis existit. Ibid. pag. 183.
pNam secundùm creaturarum substantiam quod fuerunt ante consecrationem, hoc & posteà consistunt. Ib. pag. 105.
that qthey are called the Lords body and the Lords blood, because they take the name of that thing, of which they are a sacrament; & that rthere is a great difference betwixt the mystery of the blood and body of Christ, which is taken now by the faithful in the Church, and that which was borne of the Virgin Mary, which suffered, which was buried, which rose again, which sitteth at the right hand of the Father. All which he ⟨p. 76⟩proveth at large, both sby testimonies of the holy Scriptures, and by the sayings of the ancient Fathers. Whereupon Turrian the Jesuit is driven for pure need, to shift off the matter with this silly interrogation. tTo cite Bertram (so Ratrannus is more usually named) what is it else, but to say, that the heresy of Calvin is not new? As if these things were alleged by us for any other end, then to show, that this way which they call heresy is not new, but hath been trodden in long since, by such as in their times were accounted good and Catholic teachers in the Church. That since they have been esteemed otherwise, is an argument of the alteration of the times, and of the conversion of the state of things: which is the matter that now we are inquiring of, and which our Adversaries (in an evil hour to them) do so earnestly press us to discover.
that qthey are called the Lords bodie and the Lords blood, because they take the name of that thing, of which they are a sacrament; & that rthere is a great difference betwixt the mysterie of the blood and body of Christ, which is taken now by the faithfull in the Church, and that which was borne of the Virgin Mary, which suffered, which was buried, which rose again, which sitteth at the right hand of the Father. All which hee ⟨p. 76⟩proveth at large, both sby testimonies of the holy Scriptures, and by the sayings of the ancient Fathers. Wherupon Turrian the Iesuite is driven for pure need, to shift off the matter with this silly interrogation. tTo cite Bertram (so Ratrannus is more usually named) what is it else, but to say, that the heresie of Calvin is not new? As if these things were alledged by us for anie other end, then to shew, that this way which they call heresie is not new, but hath been troden in long since, by such as in their times were accounted good and Catholick teachers in the Church. That since they have been esteemed otherwise, is an argument of the alteration of the times, and of the conversion of the state of things: which is the matter that now we are inquiring of, and which our Adversaries (in an evill houre to them) doe so earnestly presse us to discover.
qDominicum corpus & sanguis Dominicus appellantur; quoniam ejus sumunt appellationem, cujus existunt sacramentum. Ibid. pag. 200.
rVidemus itaque multâ differentiâ separari mysterium sanguinis & corporis Christi, quod nunc á fide•ibus sumitur in Ecclesiâ, & illud quod natū est de Mariâ virgine, quod passum, quod sepultum, quod resurrexit, quod coelos ascendit, quod ad dextram Patris sedet. Ibid. pag. 222.Videmus itaque multâ differentiâ separari mysterium sanguinis & corporis Christi, quod nunc á fide•ibus sumitur in Ecclesiâ, & illud quod natū est de Mariâ virgine, quod passum, quod sepultum, quod resurrexit, quod coelos ascendit, quod ad dextram Patris sedet. Ibid. pag. 222.
sAnimadvertat (clarissime Princeps) sapientia vestra, quòd positis sanctarū Scripturarum testimoniis, & sanctorum Patrū dictis evidentissimé monstratum est; quòd panis qui corpus Christi, & calix qui sanguis Christi appellatur, figura sit, quia mysterium: & quòd non parva differentia sit inter corpus quod per mysterium existit, & corpus quod passum est, & sepultum, & resurrexit. Ibid. pag. 228.Animadvertat (clarissime Princeps) sapientia vestra, quòd positis sanctarū Scripturarum testimoniis, & sanctorum Patrū dictis evidentissimé monstratum est; quòd panis qui corpus Christi, & calix qui sanguis Christi appellatur, figura sit, quia mysterium: & quòd non parva differentia sit inter corpus quod per mysterium existit, & corpus quod passum est, & sepultum, & resurrexit. Ibid. pag. 228.
tCaeterùm, Bertramum ci•are, quid aliud est, quàm dicere, haeresim Calvini non esse novam? Fr. Turrian. de Eucharist. contra Volanum, lib. 1. cap. 22.
The Emperor Charles, unto whom this answer of Ratrannus was directed, had then in his Court a famous country-man of ours, called Johannes Scotus: who wrote a book of the same argument, and to the same effect that the other had done. This man for his extraordinary learning, was in England (where he lived in great account with King Alfred) surnamed John the wise: and had very lately a room in the uMartyrology of the Church of Rome, though now he be ejected thence. We find him indeed censured by the Church of Lyons and others in that time, for certain opinions which he delivered touching Gods foreknowledge and predestination before the beginning of the world, Mans freewill and the concurrence thereof with Grace in this present world, and the manner of the punishment of reprobate Men & Angels in the world to come: but we find not any where, that his book of the Sacrament ⟨p. 77⟩was condemned, before the days of x Lanfranc; who was the first that leavened that Church of England afterward with this corrupt doctrine of the carnal presence. Till then, this question of the real presence continued still in debate: and it was as free for any man to follow the doctrine of Ratrannus or Johannes Scotus therein, as that of Paschasius Radbertus, which since the time of Satan's loosing, obtained the upper hand. Men have often searched, and do yet often search, how bread that is gathered of corn; and through fires heat baked, may be turned to Christs body; or how wine that is pressed out of many grapes is turned, through one blessing, to the Lords blood: saith yAelfric Abbot of Malmesbury, in his Saxon Homily, written about 650. years ago. His resolution is not only the same with that of Ratrannus, but also in many places directly translated out of him: as may appear by these passages following, compared with his Latin laid down in the margin.
The Emperour Charles, unto whom this answer of Ratrannus was directed, had then in his Court a famous countrey-man of ours, called Iohannes Scotus: who wrote a booke of the same argument, and to the same effect that the other had done. This man for his extraordinarie learning, was in England (where hee lived in great account with King Alfred) surnamed Iohn the wise: and had verie lately a roome in the uMartyrologe of the Church of Rome, though now he be ejected thence. Wee finde him indeed censured by the Church of Lyons and others in that time, for certaine opinions which he delivered touching Gods foreknowledge and predestination before the beginning of the world, Mans freewill and the concurrence thereof with Grace in this present world, and the maner of the punishment of reprobate Men & Angels in the world to come: but we finde not anie where, that his book of the Sacrament ⟨p. 77⟩was condemned, before the dayes of x Lanfranc; who was the first that leavened that Church of England afterward with this corrupt doctrine of the carnall presence. Till then, this question of the reall presence continued still in debate: and it was as free for anie man to follow the doctrine of Ratrannus or Iohannes Scotus therein, as that of Paschasius Radbertus, which since the time of Satans loosing, obtayned the upper hand. Men have often searched, and doe yet often search, how bread that is gathered of corne; and through fires heate baked, may be turned to Christs bodie; or how wine that is pressed out of manie grapes is turned, through one blessing, to the Lords blood: saith yAelfrick Abbat of Malmesburie, in his Saxon Homily, written about 650. yeares agoe. His resolution is not onely the same with that of Ratrannus, but also in manie places directly translated out of him: as may appeare by these passages following, compared with his Latin layd downe in the margent.
uMartyrolog. Rom. IV. ID. Novemb. edit. An•uerp. an. 15•6.Martyrolog. Rom. IV. ID. Novemb. edit. An•uerp. ann. 15•6.
yHomilia Paschalis, Anglo-Saxonicé impressa Londini, per Jo. Daium: & MS. in publicâ Cantabrigiensis Academiae Bibliothecâ.Homilia Paschalis, Anglo-Saxonicé impressa Londini, per Io. Daium: & MS. in publicâ Cantabrigiensis Academiae Bibliothecâ.
zThe bread and the wine which by the Priests ministry is hallowed, show one thing without to mens senses, and another thing they call within to believing minds. Without they be seen bread & wine both in figure and in taste: and they be truly after their hallowing Christs body and his blood by spiritual mystery. aSo the holy font water ⟨p. 78⟩that is called the well-spring of life, is like in shape to other waters, and is subject to corruption: but the holy Ghosts might cometh to the corruptible water through the Priests blessing; and it may after wash the body and soul from all sin, by spiritual virtue. Behold now we see two things in this one creature: in true nature that water is corruptible moisture, and in spiritual mystery hath healing virtue. So also if we behold that holy housel after bodily sense, then see we that it is a creature corruptible and mutable. If we acknowledge therein spiritual virtue, then understand we that life is therein, and that it giveth immortality to them that eat it with belief. bMuch is betwixt the body Christ suffered in, and the body that is hallowed to housel. cThe body truly that Christ suffered in, was borne of the flesh of Mary, with blood and with bone, with skin and with sinews, in humane limbs, with a reasonable soul living: and his spiritual body, which we call the housel, is gathered of many corns, without blood and bone, without lim, without soul; and therefore nothing is to be understood therein bodily, but spiritually. Whatsoever is in that housel, which giveth substance of life, that is spiritual virtue, and invisible doing. dCertainly Christs body which suffered death and rose from death, shall never dye henceforth, but is eternal and unpassible. That housel is temporal, not eternal, corruptible & dealed into sundry parts, chewed between teeth and sent into the belly. ⟨p. 79⟩eThis mystery is a pledge and a figure: Christs body is truth it self. This pledge we do keep mystically, until that we be come to the truth it self; and then is this pledge ended. Christ hallowed bread and wine to housel before his suffering, and said: This is my body & my blood. fYet he had not then suffered: but so notwithstanding he turned through invisible virtue, the bread to his own body, and that wine to his blood:
zThe bread and the wine which by the Priests ministery is hallowed, shew one thing without to mens senses, and another thing they call within to beleeving mindes. Without they be seene bread & wine both in figure and in taste: and they be truely after their hallowing Christs body and his blood by spirituall mysterie. aSo the holy font water ⟨p. 78⟩that is called the well-spring of life, is like in shape to other waters, and is subject to corruption: but the holy Ghosts might commeth to the corruptible water through the Priests blessing; and it may after wash the body and soule from all sinne, by spirituall vertue. Behold now we see two things in this one creature: in true nature that water is corruptible moisture, and in spirituall mysterie hath healing vertue. So also if we behold that holy housel after bodily sense, then see wee that it is a creature corruptible and mutable. If we acknowledge therein spirituall vertue, then understand we that life is therein, and that it giveth immortalitie to them that eate it with beleefe. bMuch is betwixt the bodie Christ suffered in, and the body that is hallowed to housel. cThe body truely that Christ suffered in, was borne of the flesh of Mary, with blood and with bone, with skin and with sinewes, in humane limbs, with a reasonable soule living: and his spirituall body, which we call the housel, is gathered of many cornes, without blood and bone, without lim, without soule; and therefore nothing is to be understood therein bodily, but spiri•ually. Whatsoever is in that housel, which giveth substance of life, that is spirituall vertue, and invisible doing. dCertainly Christs body which suffered death and rose from death, shall never dye henceforth, but is eternall and unpassible. That housel is temporall, not eternall, corruptible & dealed into sundry parts, chewed betweene teeth and sent into the belly. ⟨p. 79⟩eThis mysterie is a pledge and a figure: Christs bodie is truth it selfe. This pledge wee doe keepe mystically, untill that we be come to the truth it selfe; and then is this pledge ended. Christ hallowed bread and wine to housel before his suffering, and said: This is my body & my blood.
zIlle panis qui per Sacerdotis ministeriū Christi corpus efficitur, aliud exteriùs humanis sensibus ostendit, & aliud interiùs fidelium mentibus clamat. Exteriùs quidē panis, quod antè fuerat, forma praetenditur, colour ostenditur, sapor accipitur: ast interiùs Christi corpus ostenditur. Ratrann. sive Bertram. de corp. & sangu. Dom. pag. 182.Ille panis qui per Sacerdotis ministeriū Christi corpus efficitur, aliud exteriùs humanis sensibus ostendit, & aliud interiùs fidelium mentibus clamat. Exteriùs quidē panis, quod antè fuerat, forma praetenditur, color ostenditur, sapor accipitur: ast interiùs Christi corpus ostenditur. Ratrann. sive Bertram. de corp. & sangu. Dom. pag. 182.
aConsideremus fontem sacri baptismatis, qui fons vitae non immerito nuncupatur. &c. In eo si consideretur solummodo quod corporeus aspicit sensus, elementum fluidum conspicitur, corruptioni subjectum, nec nisi corpora lavandi potentiam obtinere. Sed accessit sancti Spiritus per Sacerdotis consecrationem virtus; & efficax facta est non solùm corpora verumetiam animas diluere, & spirituals sordes spiritually potentiâ dimovere. Eccè in uno eodemque elemento, duo videmus inesse sibi resistentia. &c. Igitur in proprietate humour corruptibilis, in mysterio veró virtus sanabilis. Sic itaque Christi corpus & sanguis superficie tenus considerata, creatura est, mutabilitati corruptelaeque subjecta: si mysterii veró perpendis virtutem, vita est, participantibus se tribuens immortalitatem Ibid. pag. 187 188.Consideremus fontem sacri baptismatis, qui fons vitae non immerito nuncupatur. &c. In eo si consideretur solummodo quod corporeus aspicit sensus, elementum fluidum conspicitur, corruptioni subjectum, nec nisi corpora lavandi potentiam obtinere. Sed accessit sancti Spiritus per Sacerdotis consecrationem virtus; & efficax facta est non solùm corpora verumetiam animas diluere, & spirituales sordes spirituali potentiâ dimovere. Eccè in uno eodemque elemento, duo videmus inesse sibi resistentia. &c. Igitur in proprietate humor corruptibilis, in mysterio veró virtus sanabilis. Sic itaque Christi corpus & sanguis superficie tenus considerata, creatura est, mutabilitati corruptelaeque subjecta: si mysterii veró perpendis virtutem, vita est, participantibus se tribuens immortalitatem Ibid. pag. 187 188.
bMultâ differentiâ separantur, corpus in quo passus est Christus, et hoc corpus quod in mysterio passionis Christi qu•tidiè à fid•libus celebratur •bid. pag. 212. & 22•.
as he before did in the wilderness, before that he was borne to men, when he turned that heavenly meat to his flesh, and the flowing water from that stone to his own blood. gMoses and Aaron, and many other of that people which pleased God, did eat that heavenly bread, and they died not the everlasting death, though they dyed the common. They saw that the heavenly meat was visible and corruptible: and they spiritually understood by that visible thing, and spiritually received it.
as he before did in the wildernesse, before that he was borne to men, when he turned that heavenly meate to his flesh, and the flowing water from that stone to his owne blood. gMoses and Aaron, and manie other of that people which pleased God, did eate that heavenly bread, and they died not the everlasting death, though they dyed the common. They saw that the heavenly meate was visible and corruptible: and they spiritually understood by that visible thing, and spiritually received it.
gManducavit & Moses manna, manducavit & Aaron, manducavit & Phinees, manducaverunt ibi multi qui Deo placuerunt; & mortui non sunt. Quare? Quia visibilem cibum spiritualiter intellexerunt, spiritualiter esurierunt, spiritualiter gustaverunt, ut spiritualiter satiarentur. Ibid. pag. 217. ex August. in Evang. Johan. tractat. 26.Manducavit & Moses manna, manducavit & Aaron, manducavit & Phinees, manducaverunt ibi multi qui Deo placuerunt; & mortui non sunt. Quare? Quia visibilem cibum spiritualiter intellexerunt, spiritualiter esurierunt, spiritualiter gustaverunt, ut spiritualiter satiarentur. Ibid. pag. 217. ex August. in Evang. Iohan. tractat. 26.
This Homily was appointed publicly to be read to the people in England, on Easter day, before they did receive the communion. The like matter also was delivered to the Clergy by the Bishops at their Synods; out of two other writings of the same hAelfric: in the one whereof, directed to Wulfsine Bishop of Shyrburne, we read thus. That housel is Christs body, not bodily but spiritually. Not the body which he suffered in, but the body of which he spake, when he blessed bread and wine to housel the night before his suffering; and said by the blessed bread, This is my body: and again by the holy wine, This is my blood which is shed for many in forgiveness of ⟨p. 80⟩sins. In the other, written to Wulfstane Archbishop of York, thus. The Lord which hallowed housel before his suffering, and saith that the bread was his own body, and that the wine was truly his blood; halloweth daily by the hands of the Priest, bread to his body and wine to his blood in spiritual mystery, as we read in books. And yet notwithstanding that lively bread is not bodily so, nor the self same body that Christ suffered in: nor that holy wine is the Saviours blood which was shed for us, in bodily thing, but in spiritual understanding. Both be truly, that bread his body, and that wine also his blood, as was the heavenly bread, which we call Manna, that fed forty years Gods people; and the clear water, which did then run from the stone in the wilderness, was truly his blood: as Paul wrote in one of his Epistles.
This Homily was appointed publikely to be read to the people in England, on Easter day, before they did receive the communion. The like matter also was delivered to the Clergie by the Bishops at their Synods; out of two other writings of the same hAelfrick: in the one wherof, directed to Wulfsine Bishop of Shyrburne, we reade thus. That housel is Christs bodie, not bodily but spiritually. Not the body which he suffered in, but the bodie of which he spake, when he blessed bread and wine to housel the night before his suffering; and said by the blessed bread, This is my body: and againe by the holy wine, This is my blood which is shed for many in forgivenesse of ⟨p. 80⟩sinnes. In the other, written to Wulfstane Archbishop of Yorke, thus. The Lord which hallowed housel before his suffering, and saith that the bread was his owne bodie, and that the wine vvas truely his blood; halloweth daily by the hands of the Priest, bread to his body and wine to his blood in spirituall mysterie, as wee reade in bookes. And yet notwithstanding that lively bread is not bodily so, nor the selfe same body that Christ suffered in: nor that holy vvine is the Saviours blood which was shed for us, in bodily thing, but in spirituall understanding. Both be truely, that bread his body, and that wine also his blood, as was the heavenly bread, which vve call Manna, that fedde fortie yeares Gods people; and the cleare water, which did then runne from the stone in the vvildernesse, vvas truely his blood: as Paul wrote in one of his Epistles.
hIm•ress. Londini cum Homiliâ Paschali: & MS. in publicâ Oxoniensis Academiae Bibliothecâ▪ & Colleg. S. Benedict. Cantabrig.
Thus was Priest and people taught to believe, in the Church of England, toward the end of the tenth, and the beginning of the eleventh age after the Incarnation of our Saviour Christ. And therefore it is not to be wondered, that when Berengarius shortly after stood to maintain this doctrine, imany both by word and writing disputed for him: and not only the English, but also all the French almost & the Italians (as kMatthew of Westminster reporteth) were so ready to entertain that which he delivered. Who though they were so borne down by the power of the Pope (who now was grown to his height) that they durst not make open profession of that which they believed: yet many continued, even there where Satan had his throne, who privately employed both their tongues and their pens in defence of the truth; as out of Zacharias Chrysopolitanus, Rupertus Tuitiensis, and others I have lelsewhere showed. Until at length, in the ⟨p. 81⟩year 1215. Pope Innocent the third, in the Council of Lateran, published it to the Church for an oracle: that mthe body and blood of Jesus Christ are truly contained under the forms •f bread and wine; the bread being transubstantiated into the body, and the wine into the blood, by the power of God. And so are we now come to the end of this controversy: the original and progress whereof I have prosecuted the more at large, because it is of greatest importance, the very life of the Mass and all massing Priests depending thereupon. But this prolixity shall be some ways recompensed by the briefer handling of the points following: the next whereof is that
Thus was Priest and people taught to beleeve, in the Church of England, toward the end of the tenth, and the beginning of the eleventh age after the Incarnation of our Saviour Christ. And therefore it is not to be wondered, that when Berengarius shortly after stood to maintaine this doctrine, imanie both by word and writing disputed for him: and not onely the English, but also all the French almost & the Italians (as kMatthew of Westminster reporteth) were so readie to entertaine that which hee delivered. Who though they were so borne downe by the power of the Pope (who now was growne to his height) that they durst not make open profession of that which they beleeved: yet manie continued, even there where Satan had his throne, who privately employed both their tongues and their penns in defence of the truth; as out of Zacharias Chrysopolitanus, Rupertus Tuitiensis, and others I have lelsewhere shewed. Vntill at length, in the ⟨p. 81⟩yeare 1215. Pope Innocent the third, in the Councell of Lateran, published it to the Church for an oracle: that mthe body and blood of Iesus Christ are truely contayned under the formes •f bread and wine; the bread being transsubstantiated into the bodie, and the wine into the blood, by the power of God. And so are wee now come to the end of this controversie: the originall and progresse whereof I have prosecuted the more at large, because it is of greatest importance, the verie life of the Masse and all massing Priests depending thereupon. But this prolixitie shall be some wayes recompensed by the briefer handling of the points following: the next whereof is that
iSigebert. Gemblac. & Guiliel. Nangiac. in Chron. an. 1051. Conrad. Bruwilerens. in vitâ Wolphelmi, apud Surium, April. 22.
kFlor. histor. an. 1087.Flor. histor. ann. 1087.
lDe Christian. Eccles. success. & stat. edit. ann. 1613. pag. 190.191.192. et 208.
mCujus corpus & sanguis in sacramento altaris sub speciebus panis & vini veraciter continentur; transsubstantiatis pane in corpus, & vino in sanguinem potestate divinâ. Concil. Lateran. cap. 1.Cujus corpus & sanguis in sacramento altaris sub speciebus panis & vini veraciter continentur; trāssubstantiatis pane in corpus, & vino in sanguinem potestate divinâ. Concil. Lateran. cap. 1.
Our Challenger here telleth us, that the Doctors, Pastors and Fathers of the primitive Church, exhorted the people to confess their sins unto their ghostly fathers. And we tell him again, that by the public order prescribed in our Church, before the administration of the holy Communion, the Minister likewise doth exhort the people, that if there be any of them, which cannot quiet his own conscience, but requireth further comfort or counsel; he should come to him, or some other discreet and learned Minister of Gods word, and open his grief: that he may receive such ghostly counsel, advice and comfort, as his conscience may be relieved; and that by the ministry of Gods word he may receive comfort, and the benefit of absolution, to the quieting of his conscience, and avoiding of all scruple and doubtfulness. Whereby it appeareth, that the exhorting of the people to confess their sins unto their ghostly fathers, maketh ⟨p. 82⟩no such wall of separation betwixt the ancient Doctors and us, but we may well for all this be of the same religion that they were of: and consequently, that this doughty Champion hath more will then skill to manage controversies, who could make no wiser choice of points of differences to be insisted upon.
OVr Challenger here telleth us, that the Doctors, Pastors and Fathers of the primitive Church, exhorted the people to confesse their sinnes unto their ghostly fathers. And wee tell him againe, that by the publike order prescribed in our Church, before the administration of the holy Communion, the Minister likewise doth exhort the people, that if there be any of them, which cannot quiet his owne conscience, but requireth further comfort or counsell; he should come to him, or some other discreet and learned Minister of Gods word, and open his griefe: that he may receive such ghostly counsell, advice and comfort, as his conscience may be relieved; and that by the ministery of Gods word hee may receive comfort, and the benefite of absolution, to the quieting of his conscience, and avoyding of all scruple and doubtfulnesse. Whereby it appeareth, that the exhorting of the people to confesse their sinnes unto their ghostly fathers, maketh ⟨p. 82⟩no such wall of separation betwixt the ancient Doctors and us, but we may well for all this be of the same religion that they were of: and consequently, that this doughtie Champion hath more will then skill to manage controversies, who could make no wiser choyce of pointes of differences to bee insisted upon.
Be it therefore known unto him, that no kind of Confession, either public or private, is disallowed by us, that is any way requisite for the due execution of that ancient power of the Keys which Christ bestowed upon his Church: the thing which we reject, is that new pick-lock of Sacramental Confession, obtruded upon mens consciences, as a matter necessary to salvation, by the Canons of the late Conventicle of Trent. where those good Fathers put their curse upon every one, that either shall adeny, that Sacramental confession was ordained by divine right, and is by the same right necessary to salvation: or shall baffirm, that in the Sacrament of Penance it is not by the ordinance of God necessary for the obtaining of the remission of sins, to confess all and every one of those mortal sins, the memory whereof by due and diligent premeditation may be had; even such as are hidden and be against the two last Commandments of the Decalogue, together with the circumstances which change the kind of the sin; but that this confession is only profitable to instruct and comfort the penitent, and was anciently observed only for the imposing of Canonical satisfaction. This doctrine, I say, we cannot but reject: as being repugnant to that which we have ⟨p. 83⟩learned both from the Scriptures and from the Fathers.
Be it therefore knowne unto him, that no kinde of Confession, either publick or private, is disallowed by us, that is anie way requisite for the due execution of that ancient power of the Keyes which Christ bestowed upon his Church: the thing which wee reject, is that new pick-lock of Sacramentall Confession, obtruded upon mens consciences, as a matter necessarie to salvation, by the Canons of the late Conventicle of Trent. where those good Fathers put their curse upon everie one, that either shall adeny, that Sacramentall confession was ordayned by divine right, and is by the same right necessary to salvation: or shall baffirme, that in the Sacrament of Penance it is not by the ordinance of God necessarie for the obtayning of the remission of sinnes, to confesse all and every one of those mortall sinnes, the memory wherof by due and diligent premeditation may be had; even such as are hidden and be against the two last Commandements of the Decalogue, together with the circumstances which change the kinde of the sinne; but that this confession is only profitable to instruct and comfort the penitent, and was anciently observed onely for the imposing of Canonicall satisfaction. This doctrine, I say, wee cannot but reject: as being repugnant to that which wee have ⟨p. 83⟩learned both from the Scriptures and from the Fathers.
aSi quis negaverit Confessionem sacramentalem vel institutam, vel ad salutem necessariam esse jure divino: &c. Anathema sit. Concil. Trident. Sess. 14. Can. 6.
bSi quis dixerit, in sacramē to Poenitentiae ad remissionē peccatorum necessarium non esse jure divino, confiteri omnia & singula peccata mortalia, quorum memoria con debitâ & diligenti praemeditatione habeatur, etiam occulta & quae sunt contra duo ultima Decalogi praecepta, & circumstantias quae peccati speciem mutant: sed eam confessionem tantùm esse utilem ad erudiendum & consolandum poenitentem, & olim observatam fuisse tantùm ad satisfactionem canonicam imponendam; &c Anathema sit. Ibid. can. 7.Si quis dixerit, in sacramē to Poenitentiae ad remissionē peccatorum necessarium non esse jure divino, confiteri omnia & singula peccata mortalia, quorū memoria cū debitâ & diligenti praemeditatione habeatur, etiam occulta & quae sunt contra duo ultima Decalogi praecepta, & circumstantias quae peccati speciem mutant: sed eam confessionem tantùm esse utilem ad erudiendum & consolandum poenitentem, & olim observatam fuisse tantùm ad satisfactionem canonicam imponendam; &c Anathema sit. Ibid. can. 7.
For in the Scriptures we find, that the confession which the penitent sinner maketh to God alone, hath the promise of forgiveness annexed unto it: which no Priest upon earth hath power to make void, upon pretence that himself or some of his fellows were not first particularly acquainted with the business. cI acknowledged my sin unto thee, and mine iniquity have I not hid: I said, I will confess my transgressions unto the Lord; and thou forgavest the iniquity of my sin. And lest we should think that this was some peculiar privilege vouchsafed to dthe man who was raised upon high, the Anointed of the God of Jacob: the same sweet Psalmist of Israel doth presently enlarge his note, and inferreth this general conclusion thereupon. eFor this shall every one that is godly pray unto thee, in a time when thou mayest be found. King Solomon, in his prayer for the people at the dedication of the Temple, treadeth just in his Fathers steps. If they turn (saith fhe) and pray unto thee in the land of their captivity, saying; We have sinned, we have done amiss, and have dealt wickedly: if they return to thee with all their heart, and with all their soul; &c. forgive thy people, which have sinned against thee, all their transgressions wherein they have transgressed against thee. And the poor gPublican putting up his supplication in the Temple accordingly [God be merciful to me a sinner,] went back to his house justified; without making confession to any other ghostly Father, but only hthe Father of Spirits. of whom S. John giveth us this assurance: that iif we confess our sins, he is faithful and just, to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. Which promise, ⟨p. 84⟩that it appertained to such as did confess their sins unto God, the ancient Fathers were so well assured of: that they cast in a manner all upon this Confession, and left little or nothing to that which was made unto man. Nay, they do not only leave it free for men, to confess or not confess their sins unto others (which is the most that we would have:) but some of them also seem, in words at least, to advise men not to do it at all; which is more then we seek for.
For in the Scriptures wee finde, that the confession which the penitent sinner maketh to God alone, hath the promise of forgivenesse annexed unto it: which no Priest upon earth hath power to make voyde, upon pretence that himselfe or some of his fellowes were not first particularly acquainted with the businesse. cI acknowledged my sinne unto thee, and mine iniquity have I not hid: I said, I will confesse my transgressions unto the Lord; and thou forgavest the iniquitie of my sinne. And lest we should thinke that this was some peculiar priviledge vouchsafed to dthe man who was raised upon high, the Anointed of the God of Iacob: the same sweet Psalmist of Israel doth presently enlarge his note, and inferreth this generall conclusion thereupon. eFor this shall every one that is godly pray unto thee, in a time when thou mayest be found. King Salomon, in his prayer for the people at the dedication of the Temple, treadeth just in his Fathers stepps. If they turne (saith fhee) and pray unto thee in the land of their captivity, saying; Wee have sinned, we have done amisse, and have dealt wickedly: if they returne to thee with all their heart, and with all their soule; &c. forgive thy people, which have sinned against thee, all their transgressions wherein they have transgressed against thee. And the poore gPublican putting up his supplication in the Temple accordingly [God bee mercifull to me a sinner,] went back to his house justified; without making confession to anie other ghostly Father, but onely hthe Father of Spirits. of whom S. Iohn giveth us this assurance: that iif wee confesse our sinnes, he is faithfull and just, to forgive us our sinnes, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousnesse. Which promise, ⟨p. 84⟩that it appertained to such as did confesse their sinnes unto God, the ancient Fathers were so well assured of: that they cast in a maner all upon this Confession, and left little or nothing to that which was made unto man. Nay, they doe not onely leave it free for men, to confesse or not confesse their sinnes unto others (which is the most that we would have:) but some of them also seeme, in words at least, to advise men not to doe it at all; which is more then we seeke for.
S. Chrysostom of all others is most copious in this argument: some of whose passages to this purpose, I will here lay down. kIt is not necessary (saith he) that thou shouldest confess in the presence of witnesses: let the inquiry of thy offences be made in thy thought, let this judgement be without a witness; let God only see thee confessing. lTherefore I entreat and beseech and pray you, that you would continually make your confession to God. For I do not bring thee into the theatre of thy fellow servants, neither do I constrain thee to discover thy sins unto men: unclasp thy conscience before God, and show thy wounds unto him, and of him ask a medicine. Show them to him that will not reproach, but heal thee. For although thou hold thy peace, he knoweth all. mLet us not call our selves sinners only, but let us recount our sins, and repeat every one of them in special. I do not say unto thee, Bring thy self upon the stage, nor, Accuse thy self unto others: but I counsel thee to obey the Prophet, saying, ⟨p. 85⟩Reveal thy way unto the Lord. Confess them before God, confess thy sins before the Judge; praying, if not with thy tongue, yet at least with thy memory: and so look to obtain mercy. nBut thou art ashamed to say, that thou hast sinned. Confess thy faults then daily in thy prayer. For do I say; Confess them to thy fellow-servant, who may reproach thee therewith? Confess them to God, who healeth them. For, although thou confess them not at all, God is not ignorant of them. oWherefore then, tell me, art thou ashamed & blushest to confess thy sins? For doest thou discover them to a man, that he may reproach thee? Doest thou confess them to thy fellow servant, that he may bring thee upon the stage? To him who is thy Lord, who hath care of thee, who is kind, who is thy physician, thou showest thy wound. pI constrain thee not, saith he, to go into the middest of the theatre, and to make many witnesses of the matter. Confess thy sin to me alone in private, that I may heal thy sore, and free thee from grief. qAnd this is not only wonderful, that he forgiveth us our sins, but that he neither discovereth them, nor maketh them open and manifest, nor constraineth us to come forth in public and disclose our misdemeanours; but commandeth us to give an account thereof unto him alone, and unto him to make confession of them.
S. Chrysostome of all others is most copious in this argument: some of whose passages to this purpose, I will here lay downe. kIt is not necessary (saith he) that thou shouldest confesse in the presence of witnesses: let the inquiry of thy offences bee made in thy thought, let this judgement be without a witnesse; let God onely see thee confessing. lTherefore I intreat and beseech and pray you, that you would continually make your confession to God. For I doe not bring thee into the theater of thy fellow servants, neyther doe I constraine thee to discover thy sinnes unto men: unclaspe thy conscience before God, and shew thy wounds unto him, and of him aske a medicine. Shew them to him that will not reproach, but heale thee. For although thou hold thy peace, he knoweth all. mLet us not call our selves sinners onely, but let us recount our sinnes, and repeate every one of them in speciall. I doe not say unto thee, Bring thy selfe upon the stage, nor, Accuse thy selfe unto others: but I counsaile thee to obey the Prophet, saying, ⟨p. 85⟩Reveale thy way unto the Lord. Confesse them before God, confesse thy sinnes before the Iudge; praying, if not with thy tongue, yet at least with thy memory: and so looke to obtayne mercy. nBut thou art ashamed to say, that thou hast sinned. Confesse thy faults then daily in thy prayer. For do I say; Confesse them to thy fellow-servant, who may reproach thee therewith? Confesse them to God, who healeth them. For, although thou confesse them not at all, God is not ignorant of them. oWherefore then, tell me, art thou ashamed & blushest to confesse thy sinnes? For doest thou discover them to a man, that he may reproach thee? Doest thou confesse them to thy fellow servant, that he may bring thee upon the stage? To him who is thy Lord, who hath care of thee, who is kinde, who is thy physitian, thou shewest thy wound. pI constraine thee not, saith he, to go into the middest of the theater, and to make many witnesses of the matter. Confesse thy sin to me alone in privat, that I may heale thy sore, and free thee from griefe. q
kNunc autem neque necessarium praesentibus testibus confiteri: cogitation fiat delictorum exquisitio, absque teste sit hoc judicium. Solus te Deus confitentem videat. Chrysost. homil. de Poenitent. & Confession. tom. 5 edit. Latin. col. 901. edit. Basil. an. 1558.Nunc autem neque necessarium praesentibus testibus confiteri: cogitatione fiat delictorum exquisitio, absque teste sit hoc judicium. Solus te Deus confitentem videat. Chrysost. homil. de Poenitent. & Confession. tom. 5 edit. Latin. col. 901. edit. Basil. an. 1558.
l[Greek or Hebrew]. Id. circa finem homiliae 5. [Greek or Hebrew], de incomprehensib. Dei natur. tom. 6. edit. Graec. D. Hen. Savil. pag. 424. & tom. 5. pag 262.263.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id. circa finem homiliae 5. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, de incomprehensib. Dei natur. tom. 6. edit. Graec. D. Hen. Savil. pag. 424. & tom. 5. pag 262.263.
m[Greek or Hebrew] Id. in epist. ad Hebr. cap 12. homil. 31. tom. 4. Savil. pag. 589.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Id. in epist. ad Hebr. cap 12. homil. 31. tom. 4. Savil. pag. 589.
n[Greek or Hebrew]. Id. in Psalm. 50. hom. 2. tom. 1. Savil. pag. 708.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id. in Psalm. 50. hom. 2. tom. 1. Savil. pag. 708.
o[Greek or Hebrew]. Id. homil. 4. de Lazaro, tom. 5. Savil. pag. 258.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id. homil. 4. de Lazaro, tom. 5. Savil. pag. 258.
p[Greek or Hebrew]. Id ibid.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id ibid.
Neither doth S. Chrysostom here walk alone. That saying of S. Augustine is to the same effect: rWhat have I to do with men, that they should hear my confessions, as though they should heal all my diseases? ⟨p. 86⟩and that collection of S. Hilary upon the two last verses of the 52 Psalm, sthat David there teacheth us to confess to no other but unto the Lord, who hath made the Olive fruitful with the mercy of hope (or, the hope of mercy) for ever and ever. and that advise of Pinuphius the Egyptian Abbot (which I find also inserted amongst the tCanons collected for the use of the Church of England, in the time of the Saxons; under the title, De poenitentiâ soli Deo confitendâ:) uWho is it that cannot humbly say? I made my sin known unto thee, and mine iniquity have I not hid. that by this confession he may confidently adjoin that which followeth: And thou forgavest the impiety of my heart. But if shamefastness do so draw thee back, that thou blushest to reveal them before men: cease not by continual supplication to confess them unto him from whom they cannot be hid, and to say [I know mine iniquity, and my sin is against me always; To thee only have I sinned, and done evil before thee] whose custom is, both to cure without the publishing of any shame, and to forgive sins without upbraiding. S. Augustine, Cassiodor, and Gregory make a further observation upon that place of the 32 Psalm: I said, I will confess my transgressions unto the Lord; and thou forgavest the iniquity of my sin. that God upon the only promise and purpose of making this confession, did forgive the sin. Mark (saith xGregory) how great the swiftness is of this vital ⟨p. 87⟩Indulgence, how great the commendation is of Gods mercy; that pardon should accompany the very desire of him that is about to confess, before that repentance do come to afflict him; and remission should come to the heart, before that confession did break forth by the voice. So S. Basil, upon those other words of the Psalmist, I have roared by reason of the disquietness of my heart; (Psalm. 38.8.) maketh this paraphrase. yI do not confess with my lips, that I may manifest my self unto many. but inwardly in my very heart, shutting mine eyes, to thee alone who seest the things that are in secret, do I show my groans, roaring within my self.
Neyther doth S. Chrysostome here walke alone. That saying of S. Augustine is to the same effect: rWhat have I to doe with men, that they should heare my confessions, as though they should heale all my diseases? ⟨p. 86⟩and that •ollection of S. Hilary upon the two last verses of the 52 Psalme, sthat David there teacheth us to confesse to no other but unto the Lord, vvho hath made the Olive fruitfull with the mercy of hope (or, the hope of mercie) for ever and ever. and that advise of Pinuphius the Aegyptian Abbat (which I finde also inserted amongst the tCanons collected for the use of the Church of England, in the time of the Saxons; under the title, De poenitentiâ soli Deo cōfitendâ:) uWho is it that cannot humbly say? I made my sinne knowne unto thee, and mine iniquity have I not hid. that by this confession he may confidently adjoyne that which followeth: And thou forgavest the impiety of my heart. But if shamefastnesse doe so draw thee backe, that thou blushest to reveale them before men: cease not by continuall supplication to confesse them unto him from whom they cannot be hid, and to say [I know mine iniquitie, and my sinne is against me alwayes; To thee onely have I sinned, and done evill before thee] whose custome is, both to cure without the publishing of any shame, and to forgive sinnes without upbraiding. S. Augustine, Cassiodor, and Gregory make a further observation upon that place of the 32 Psalme: I said, I will confesse my transgressions unto the Lord; and thou forgavest the iniquity of my sinne. that God upon the onely promise and purpose of making this confession, did forgive the sinne. Marke (saith xGregory) how great the swiftnesse is of this vitall ⟨p. 87⟩Indulgence, how great the commendation is of Gods mercy; that pardon should accompany the verie desire of him that is about to confesse, before that repentance doe come to afflict him; and remission should come to the heart, before that confession did break forth by the voice. So S. Basil, upon those other words of the Psalmist, I have roared by reason of the disquietnesse of my heart; (
rQuid mihi ergo est cum hominibus ut audiant confessiones meas, quasi ipsi sanaturi sint omnes languores meos? Aug. Confess. lib. 10. cap. 3.
sConfessionis autem caussam addidit, dicens: Quia fecisti. au•orem scilicèt universitatis hujus Dominum esse cō fessus; nulli alii docens con sitendū, quàm qui fecit Olivā fructife•am spei mise•icordia in seculum seculi. H. lar. in Psal. 51Confessionis autem caussam addidit, dicens: Quia fecisti. au•orem scilicèt universitatis hujus Dominum esse cō fessus; nulli alii docens cō sitendū, quàm qui fecit Olivā fructife•am spei mise•icordia in seculum seculi. H. lar. in Psal. 51
tAntiqu. lib. Canon. 66. titulorum, MS. in Bibliot•ecâ Cottoni•nà.
uQuis est qui non possit suppliciter dicere? Peccatum meū cognitum tibi feci, & in•ustitiam meam non operui ut per hanc con•essionem etiā illud confidenter subjungere mereatur: Et tu remisisti impietatem cordis mei. Quòd si verecundiâ retrahente revelare ea coram hominibus erubescis, illi quem latere non possunt, confiteri ea jugi supplicatione non desinas, ac dicere [Iniquitatem meam ego cognosco, & peccatum meum contra me est semper: tibi soli peccavi, & malum coram te feci:] qui & absque ullius verecundiae publication curare, & sine improperio peccata donare consuevi•. Jo. Cassiar. Collat. 20 cap 8Quis est qui non possit suppliciter dicere? Peccatum meū cognitum tibi feci, & in•ustitiam meam non operui ut per hanc con•essionem etiā illud confidenter subjungere mereatur: Et tu remisisti impietatem cordis mei. Quòd si verecundiâ retrahente revelare ea coram hominibus erubescis, illi quem latere non possunt, confiteri ea jugi supplicatione non desinas, ac dicere [Iniquitatem meam ego cognosco, & peccatum meum contra me est semper: tibi soli peccavi, & malum coram te feci:] qui & absque ullius verecundiae publicatione curare, & sine improperio peccata donare consuevi. Io. Cassiar. Collat. 20 cap 8
And as S. Basil maketh the groans of the heart to be a sufficient confession so doth S. Ambrose the tears of the penitent. Tears (saith zhe) do wash the sin, which the voice is ashamed to confess. Weeping doth provide both for pardon and for shamefastness: tears do speak our fault without horror, tears do confess our crime without offence of our shamefastness from whence, he that glosseth upon Gratian (who hath inserted these words of S. Ambrose into his collection of the Decrees) doth infer; that aif for shame a man will not confess, tears alone do blot out his sin. Maximus Taurinensis followeth S. Ambrose herein almost verbatim. The tear (saith bhe) washeth the sin, which the voice is ashamed to confess. Tears therefore do equally provide both for our shamefastness and for our health: they neither ⟨p. 88⟩blush in asking, and they obtain in requesting. Lastly Prosper, speaking of sins committed by such as are in the ministry, writeth thus cThey shall more easily appease God, who being not convicted by humane judgement, do of their own accord acknowledge their offence: who either do discover it by their own confessions, or others not knowing what they are in secret, do themselves give sentence of voluntary excommunication upon themselves, and being separated (not in mind, but in office). from the Altar to which they did minister, do lament their life as dead; assuring themselves, that God being reconciled unto them by the fruits of effectual repentance, they shall not only receive what they have lost, but also being made citizens of that city which is above, they shall come to everlasting joys. By this it appeareth, that the ancient Fathers did not think, that the remission of sins was so tied unto external confession, that a man might not look for salvation from God, if he concealed his faults from Man: but that inward contrition, and confession made to God alone, was sufficient in this case. Otherwise, neither they nor we do debar men from opening their grievances unto the Physicians of their souls: either for their better information in the true state of their disease, or for the quieting of their troubled consciences, or for receiving further direction from them out of Gods word, both for the recovery of their present sickness and for the prevention of the like danger in time to come.
And as S. Basil maketh the groanes of the heart to be a sufficient confession so doth S. Ambrose the teares of the penitent. Teares (saith zhe) doe wash the sinne, which the voyce is ashamed to confesse. Weeping doth provide both for pardon and for shamefastnesse: teares doe speake our fault without horror, teares doe confesse our crime without offence of our shamefastnesse from whence, he that glosseth upon Gratian (who hath inserted these words of S. Ambrose into his collection of the Decrees) doth inferre; that aif for shame a man will not confesse, teares alone doe blot out his sinne. Maximus Taurinensis followeth S. Ambrose herein almost verbatim. The teare (saith bhe) washeth the sinne, which the voyce is ashamed to confesse. Teares therefore doe equally provide both for our shamefastnesse and for our health: they neyther ⟨p. 88⟩blush in asking, and they obtaine in requesting. Lastly Prosper, speaking of sinnes committed by such as are in the ministery, writeth thus cThey shall more easily appease God, who being not convicted by humane judgement, doe of their owne accord acknowledge their offence: who eyther do discover it by their owne confessions, or others not knowing what they are in secret, doe themselves give sentence of voluntarie excommunication upon themselves, and being separated (not in minde, but in office). from the Altar to which they did minister, doe lament their life as dead; assuring themselves, that God being reconciled unto them by the fruits of effectuall repentance, they shall not onely receive what they have lost, but also being made citizens of that citie which is above, they shall come to everlasting joyes. By this it appeareth, that the ancient Fathers did not thinke, that the remission of sinnes was so tyed unto externall confession, that a man might not looke for salvation from God, if hee concealed his faults from Man: but that inward contrition, and confession made to God alone, was sufficient in this case. Otherwise, neyther they nor wee do debarre men from opening their grievances unto the Physicians of their soules: eyther for their better information in the true state of their disease, or for the quieting of their troubled consciences, or for receiving further direction from them out of Gods word, both for the recoverie of their present sicknesse and for the prevention of the like danger in time to come.
zLavant lachrymae delictum, quod voce pudor est cō fiteri. Et veniae fletus consulunt, & verecundiae: lachrymae sine horror culpā loquuntur; lachrymae crimen sine offensione verecundiae confitentur. Ambros. lib. 10. commentar. in Luc. cap. 22.Lavant lachrymae delictum, quod voce pudor est cō fiteri. Et veniae fletus consulūt, & verecundiae: lachrymae sine horrore culpā loquuntur; lachrymae crimen sine offensione verecundiae confitentur. Ambros. lib. 10. commentar. in Luc. cap. 22.
aUnde etsi propter pudorem nolit quis confiteri; solae lachrymae delent peccata. Gloss. de Poenit. d•stinct 1. cap. 2. LachrymaeVnde etsi propter pudorem nolit quis confiteri; solae lachrymae delent peccata. Gloss. de Poenit. d•stinct 1. cap. 2. Lachrymae
bLavat lachryma delictum, quod voce pudor est confiteri. Lachrymae ergo verecundiae consulunt pariter & saluti; nec erubescunt in petendo, & impetrant in rogando. Maxim. homil. de Poenitent. Petri. Tom. 5. Biblioth. Pat•. part. 1. pag. 21. edit. Colon.
cDeum sibi faciliùs placabunt illi, qui non humano convicti judicio, sed ultrò crimē agnoscunt: qui aut propriis illud confessionibus produnt, aut nescientibus aliis quales occulti sunt, ipsi in se voluntari•e excommunicationis sententiam ferunt, & ab altari cui ministrabant, non animo sed officio separati, vitam tanquā mortuam plangunt; certi, quòd reconciliato sibi efficacis poenitentiae fructibus Deo, non solùm amissa recipiant, sed etiā cives supernae civitatis effecti, ad gaudia sempiterna perveniant. Prosper, de vitâ contemplativâ, lib 2. cap. 7.Deum sibi faciliùs placabunt illi, qui non humano cōvicti judicio, sed ultrò crimē agnoscunt: qui aut propriis illud confessionibus produnt, aut nescientibus aliis quales occulti sunt, ipsi in se voluntari•e excommunicationis sententiam ferūt, & ab altari cui ministrabant, non animo sed officio separati, vitam tanquā mortuam plangunt; certi, quòd reconciliato sibi efficacis poenitentiae fructibus Deo, non solùm amissa recipiant, sed etiā cives supernae civitatis effecti, ad gaudia sempiterna perveniant. Prosper, de vitâ contemplativâ, lib 2. cap. 7.
dIf I shall sin, although it be in any small offence, and ⟨p. 89⟩my thought do consume me, and accuse me, saying; Why hast thou sinned? what shall I do? said a brother once to Abbot Arsenius. The old man answered: Whatsoever hour a man shall fall into a fault, and shall say from his heart, Lord God I have sinned, grant me pardon; that consumption of thought or heaviness shall cease forthwith. And it was as good a remedy as could be prescribed for a green wound: to take it in hand presently, to present it to the view of our heavenly Physician, eto prevent Satan by taking his office (as it were) out of his hand, and faccusing our selves first, that we may be justified. But when it is not taken in time, but suffered to fester and rankle; the cure will not now prove to be so easy: it being found true by often experience, that the wounded conscience will still pinch grievously, notwithstanding the confession made unto God in secret. At such a time as this then, where the sinner can find no ease at home, what should he do but use the best means he can to find it abroad? Is gthere no balm in Gilead? is there no physician there? No doubt but God hath provided both the one and the other, for recovering of the health of the daughter of his people: and S. James hath herein given us this direction. hConfess your faults one to another, and pray one for another, that ye may be healed. According to which prescription, Gregory Nyssen, toward the end of his Sermon of Repentance, useth this exhortation to the sinner. iBe sensible of the disease, wherewith thou art taken, afflict thy self as much as thou canst. Seek also the mourning of ⟨p. 90⟩thy entirely affected brethren, to help thee unto liberty. Show me thy bitter and abundant tears, that I may also mingle mine therewith. Take likewise the Priest for a partner of thine affliction, as thy Father. For who is it that so falsely obtaineth the name of a father, or hath so adamantine a soul, that he will not condole with his sons lamenting? Show unto him without blushing the things that were kept close: discover the secrets of thy soul, as showing thy hidden disease unto thy physician. He will have care both of thy credit and of thy cure.
dIf I shall sinne, although it be in anie small offence, and ⟨p. 89⟩my thought doe consume me, and accuse me, saying; Why hast thou sinned? what shall I doe? said a brother once to Abbat Arsenius. The old man answered: Whatsoever houre a man shall fall into a fault, and shall say from his heart, Lord God I have sinned, grant mee pardon; that consumption of thought or heavinesse shall cease forthwith. And it was as good a remedie as could be prescribed for a greene wound: to take it in hand presently, to present it to the view of our heavenly Physician, eto prevent Satan by taking his office (as it were) out of his hand, and faccusing our selves first, that we may be justified. But when it is not taken in time, but suffered to fester and ranckle; the cure will not now prove to be so easie: it being found true by often experience, that the wounded conscience will still pinch grievously, notwithstanding the confession made unto God in secret. At such a time as this then, where the sinner can finde no ease at home, what should hee doe but use the best means he can to finde it abroad? Is gthere no balme in Gilead? is there no physician there? No doubt but God hath provided both the one and the other, for recovering of the health of the daughter of his people: and S. Iames hath herein given us this direction. hConfesse your faults one to another, and pray one for another, that yee may be healed. According to which prescription, Gregory Nyssen, toward the end of his Sermon of Repentance, useth this exhortation to the sinner. iBe sensible of the disease, vvherewith thou art taken, afflict thy selfe as much as thou canst. Seeke also the mourning of ⟨p. 90⟩thy intirely affected brethren, to helpe thee unto libertie. Shew me thy bitter and aboundant teares, that I may also mingle mine therewith. Take likewise the Priest for a partner of thine affliction, as thy Father. For who is it that so falsely obtayneth the name of a father, or hath so adamantine a soule, that he will not condole with his sonns lamenting? Shew unto him without blushing the things that were kept close: discover the secrets of thy soule, as showing thy hidden disease unto thy physician. Hee will have care both of thy credit and of thy cure.
dSi peccavero, etiam in quocunque minuto peccato, & consumit me cogitatio mea, & arguit me, dicens: Quare peccâsti? quid faciam? Respondit senex: Quacunque horâ ceciderit homo in culpam, & dixerit ex corde, Domine Deus peccavi, indulge mihi; mox cessabit cogitationis vel tristitiae illa consumptio, Respons. Patr. Egypt. á Pas•hasio diacono Latiné vers. cap. 11.Si peccavero, etiam in quocunque minuto peccato, & consumit me cogitatio mea, & arguit me, dicens: Quare peccâsti? quid faciam? Respondit senex: Quacunque horâ ceciderit homo in culpam, & dixerit ex corde, Domine Deus peccavi, indulge mihi; mox cessabit cogitationis vel tristitiae illa consumptio, Respons. Patr. Aegypt. á Pas•hasio diacono Latiné vers. cap. 11.
eNovit omnia Dominus, sed expectat vocē tuam; non ut puniat, sed ut ignoscat: non vult ut insultet tibi Diabolus, & celantē peccata tua arguat. Praeveni accusatorem tuum: si te ipse accusaveris, accusatorem nullum timebis. Ambr. de Poenitent. lib. 2. cap. 17.Novit omnia Dominus, sed expectat vocē tuam; non ut puniat, sed ut ignoscat: non vult ut insultet tibi Diabolus, & celantē peccata tua arguat. Praeveni accusatorem tuum: si te ipse accusaveris, accusatorem nullum timebis. Ambr. de Poenitent. lib. 2. cap. 17.
f[Greek or Hebrew]. LXX. in Esa. 43.26. & Proverb. 18 17.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. LXX. in Esa. 43.26. & P•overb. 18 17.
It was no part of his meaning to advise us, that we should open our selves in this manner unto every hedge-priest; as if there were a virtue generally annexed to the order, that upon confession made and absolution received from any of that rank, all should be straight made up: but he would have us communicate our case both to such Christian brethren, and to such a ghostly father, as had skill in physic of this kind, and out of a fellow-feeling of our grief, would apply themselves to our recovery. Therefore, saith Origen, klook about thee diligently, unto whom thou oughtest to confess thy sin. Try first the physician, unto whom thou oughtest to declare the cause of thy malady, who knoweth to be weak with him that is weak, to weep with him that weepeth, who understandeth the discipline of condoling and compassionating: that so at length, if he shall say any thing, who hath first showed himself to be both a skilful physician and a merciful, or if he shall give any counsel, thou mayest do and follow it. For, as S. Basil well noteth, lthe very same course is to be held in the ⟨p. 91⟩confession of sins, which is in the opening of the diseases of the body. As men therefore do not discover the diseases of their body to all, nor to every sort of people, but to those that are skilful in the cure thereof: even so ought the confession of our sins be made, unto such as are able to cure them; according to that which is written. Ye that are strong, bear the infirmities of the weak, that is, take them away by your diligence. He requireth care and diligence in performance of the cure: being ignorant (good man) of that new compendious method of healing, invented by our Roman Paracelsians, whereby a man min confession of attrite is made contrite by virtue of the keys; that the sinner need put his ghostly father to no further trouble then this. Speak the word only, and I shall be healed. And this is that Sacramental confession, devised of late by the Priests of Rome: which they notwithstanding would fain father upon S. Peter, from whom the Church of Rome (as they would have us believe) received this instruction. nthat if envy, or infidelity, or any other evil did secretly creep into any mans heart, he who had care of his own soul should not be ashamed to confess those things unto him who had the oversight over him;
It was no part of his meaning to advise us, that wee should open our selves in this maner unto everie hedge-priest; as if there were a vertue generally annexed to the order, that upon confession made and absolution received from anie of that ranke, all should be straight made up: but he would have us communicate our case both to such Christian brethren, and to such a ghostly father, as had skill in physick of this kinde, and out of a fellow-feeling of our griefe, would apply themselves to our recoverie. Therefore, saith Origen, klooke about thee diligently, unto whom thou oughtest to confesse thy sinne. Try first the physician, unto whom thou oughtest to declare the cause of thy maladie, vvho knoweth to be weake with him that is weake, to weepe with him that weepeth, who understandeth the discipline of condoling and compassionating: that so at length, if hee shall say anie thing, who hath first shewed himselfe to be both a skilfull physician and a mercifull, or if he shall give anie counsaile, thou mayest doe and follow it. For, as S. Basil well noteth, lthe verie same course is to be held in the ⟨p. 91⟩confession of sinnes, which is in the opening of the diseases of the bodie. As men therefore do not discover the diseases of their bodie to all, nor to everie sort of people, but to those that are skilfull in the cure thereof: even so ought the confession of our sinnes be made, unto such as are able to cure them; according to that which is written. Yee that are strong, beare the infirmities of the weake, that is, take them away by your diligence. He requireth care and diligence in performance of the cure: being ignorant (good man) of that new compendious method of healing, invented by our Romane Paracelsians, whereby a man min confession of attrite is made contrite by vertue of the keyes; that the sinner need put his ghostly father to no further trouble then this. Speake the word onely, and I shall be healed. And this is that Sacramentall confession, devised of late by the Priests of Rome: which they notwithstanding would faine father upon S. Peter, from whom the Church of Rome (as they would have us beleeve) received this instruction. nthat if envie, or infidelitie, or anie other evill did secretly creepe into anie mans heart, hee who had care of his owne soule should not be ashamed to confesse those things unto him who had the oversight over him;
kTantummodò circumspice diligentiùs, cui debeas confiteri peccatum tuum Proba priùs medicum, cui debeas caussam languoris expone•e, qui sciat infirmari cum infirmante, fle•e cum flente, qui condolendi & compatiendi noverit disciplinam: ut ita demùm si quid ille dixerit, qui se priùs & eruditum medicū ostenderit & mise•icordem, si quid consilii dederit, facias, & sequaris Origen. in Psal. 37. homil. 2.Tantummodò circumspice diligentiùs, cui debeas confiteri peccatum tuum Proba priùs medicum, cui debeas caussam languoris expone•e, qui sciat infirmari cum infirmante, fle•e cum flente, qui condolendi & compatiendi noverit disciplinam: ut ita demùm si quid ille dixerit, qui se priùs & eruditum medicū ostenderit & mise•icordem, si quid consilii dederit, facias, & sequaris Origen. in Psal. 37. homil. 2.
l[Greek or Hebrew]. Basil. in Regul. breviorib. resp. 229.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Basil. in Regul. breviorib. resp. 229.
mSecundùm Archiepisc. imò sanctum Thomam, & alios Theologos, in confessione fit quis de attrito contritus, virtute clavium. Summa Sylvestrina: de Confess Sacramental. ca. 1. sect. 1.
nQuòd si fortè alicujus cor vel livor, vel infidelitas, vel aliquod malum latenter irrepserit; non erubescat, qui animae suae curam gerit, confiteri haec huic qui prae est, ut ab ipso per verbū Dei & consilium salubre curetur. Clem. epist. 1.Quòd si fortè alicujus cor vel livor, vel infidelitas, vel aliquod malum latenter irrepserit; non erubescat, qui animae suae curam gerit, confiteri haec huic qui prae est, ut ab ipso per verbū Dei & consilium salubre curetur. Clem. epist. 1.
that by Gods word and wholesome counsel, he might be cured by him. And so indeed we read in the apocryphal epistle of Clement, pretended to be written unto S. James the brother of our Lord: where in the several editions of Crab, Sichardus, Venradius, Surius, Nicolinus, and Binius, we find this note also laid down in the margent; Nota de confessione sacramentali, Mark this of sacramental confession. But their own oMaldonat would have ⟨p. 92⟩taught them, that this note was not worth the marking: forasmuch as the proper end of sacramental confession, is the obtaining of remission of sins, by virtue of the keys of the Church; whereas the end of the confession here said to be commended by S. Peter, was the obtaining of counsel out of Gods word for the remedy of sins. which kind of medicinal confession we well approve of, and acknowledge to have been ordinarily prescribed by the ancient Fathers for the cure of secret sins.
that by Gods word and wholsome counsaile, he might be cured by him. And so indeed we reade in the apocryphall epistle of Clement, pretended to be written unto S. Iames the brother of our Lord: where in the severall editions of Crab, Sichardus, Venradius, Surius, Nicolinus, and Binius, wee finde this note also laid downe in the margent; Nota de confessione sacramentali, Marke this of sacramentall confession. But their owne oMaldonat would have ⟨p. 92⟩taught them, that this note was not worth the marking: forasmuch as the proper end of sacramentall confession, is the obtayning of remission of sinnes, by vertue of the keyes of the Church; whereas the end of the confession here said to be commended by S. Peter, was the obtayning of counsaile out of Gods word for the remedie of sinnes. which kinde of medicinall confession wee well approve of, and acknowledge to have beene ordinarily prescribed by the ancient Fathers for the cure of secret sinnes.
oMaldonat. Disputat. de Sacrament, tom. 2. de Confessionis origine cap. 2.
For as for notorious offences, which bred open scandal, private confession was not thought sufficient: but there was further required public acknowledgement of the fault, & the solemn use of the keys for the reconciliation of the penitent. pIf his sin do not only redound to his own evil, but also unto much scandal of others, and the Bishop thinketh it to be expedient for the profit of the Church, let him not refuse to perform his penance in the knowledge of many or of the whole people also, let him not resist, let him not by his shamefastness add swelling to his deadly and mortal wound: saith S. Augustine. and more largely in another place; where he meeteth with the objection, of the sufficiency of internal repentance, in this manner. qLet no man say ⟨p. 93⟩unto himself: I do it secretly, I do it before God; God who pardoneth me doth know, that I do it in my heart. Is it therefore said without cause; Whatsoever you shall loose on earth, shall be loosed in heaven? Are the keys therefore without cause given unto the Church of God? Do we frustrate the Gospel of God? do we frustrate the words of Christ? Do we promise that to you which he denieth you? Do we not deceive you? Job saith: If I was abashed to confess my sins in the sight of the people. So just a man of Gods rich treasure, who was tried in such a furnace, saith thus: and doth the child of pestilence withstand me, and is ashamed to bow his knee under th• blessing of God? That which the Emperor was not ashamed to do, is he ashamed of, who is not as much as a Senator, but only a simple Courtier? O proud neck, ó crooked mind! perhaps, nay it is not to be doubted, it was for this reason God would that Theodosius the Emperor should do public penance in the sight of the people, especially because his sin could not be concealed: and is a Senator ashamed of that, whereof the Emperor was not ashamed? is he ashamed of that who is no Senator, but a Courtier only, whereof the Emperor was not ashamed? Is one of the vulgar sort, or a trader ashamed of that, whereof the Emperor was not ashamed? What pride is this? Were not this alone sufficient to bring them to hell, although no adultery had been committed? Thus far S. Augustine, concerning the necessity of public Repentance for known offences:
For as for notorious offences, which bred open scandall, private confession was not thought sufficient: but there was further required publick acknowledgement of the fault, & the solemne use of the keyes for the reconciliation of the penitent. pIf his sin do not only redound to his own evill, but also unto much scandall of others, and the Bishop thinketh it to be expedient for the profit of the Church, let him not refuse to performe his penance in the knowledge of manie or of the whole people also, let him not resist, let him not by his shamefastnesse add swelling to his deadly and mortall wound: saith S. Augustine. and more largely in another place; where he meeteth with the objection, of the sufficiencie of internall repentance, in this maner. qLet no man say ⟨p. 93⟩unto himselfe: I doe it secretly, I doe it before God; God vvho pardoneth me doth know, that I doe it in my heart. Is it therefore said without cause; Whatsoever you shall loose on earth, shall be loosed in heaven? Are the keyes therfore without cause given unto the Church of God? Doe we frustrate the Gospell of God? doe we frustrate the words of Christ? Doe we promise that to you which hee denieth you? Do wee not deceive you? Iob saith: If I was abashed to confesse my sinnes in the sight of the people. So just a man of Gods rich threasure, who was tried in such a furnace, saith thus: and doth the childe of pestilence vvithstand me, and is ashamed to bow his knee under th• blessing of God? That which the Emperor was not ashamed to doe, is he ashamed of, who is not as much as a Senator, but only a simple Courtier? O proud neck, ó crooked minde! perhaps, nay it is not to be doubted, it was for this reason God would that Theodosius the Emperour should doe publick penance in the sight of the people, especially because his sinne could not be concealed: and is a Senator ashamed of that, whereof the Emperour was not ashamed? is he ashamed of that who is no Senator, but a Courtier onely, whereof the Emperour was not ashamed? Is one of the vulgar sort, or a trader ashamed of that, whereof the Emperour was not ashamed? What pride is this? Were not this alone sufficient to bring them to hell, although no adultery had beene committed? Thus farre S. Augustine, concerning the necessitie of publike Repentance for knowne offences:
pSi peccatum ejus non solùm in gravi ejus malo, sed etiā in tanto scandalo est aliorū, atque hoc expedire utilitati Ecclesiae videtur Antistiti, in notitiâ multorum, vel etiā totius plebis agere poenitentiam non recuset, non resistat, non lethali & mortiferae plagae per pudorē addat tumorē. August. in lib. de Poenitentiâ: quae postrema est homilia ex 50. in 10. Tom.Si peccatum ejus non solùm in gravi ejus malo, sed etiā in tanto scandalo est aliorū, atque hoc expedire utilitati Ecclesiae videtur Antistiti, in notitiâ multorum, vel etiā totius plebis agere poenitentiam non recuset, non resistat, non lethali & mortiferae plagae per pudorē addat tumorē. August. in lib. de Poenitentiâ: quae postrema est homilia ex 50. in 10. Tom.
qNemo sibi dicat, Occulté ago, apud Deū ago; novit Deus qui mihi ignoscit, quia in corde ago. Ergo sine caussâ dictum est: Quae solveritis in terrâ, soluta erunt in coelo? Ergo sine caussâ sunt claves datae Ecclesiae Dei? Frustramus Evangelium Dei: frustramus verba Christi? Promittimus vobis quod ille negat? Nónne vos decipimus? Job dicit: Si erubui in conspectu populi confiteri peccata mea. Talis justus thesauri divini obryzi, tali camino probatus, ista dicit: & resistit mihi filius pestilentiae, & erubescit genu figere sub benedictione Dei? Quod non erubuit Imperator, erubescit nec senator, sed tantùm curialis? Superba cervix, mens tortuosa. fortassis, imò quod non dubitatur, proptereà Deus v•luit ut Theodosius Imperator ageret poenitentiam publicam in conspectu populi, maximé quia peccatum ejus celari non potuit: & erubescit Senator, quod non erubuit Imperator? erubescit nec Senator, sed tantùm curialis, quod nō erubuit Imperator? Erubescit plebeius sive negotiator, quod nō erubuit Imperator? Quae ista superbia est? Nónne sola sufficeret gehennae, etiamsi adulteriū nullū esset. Id. hom. 49. ex 50. ca. 3.Nemo sibi dicat, Occulté ago, apud Deū ago; novit Deus qui mihi ignoscit, quia in corde ago. Ergo sine caussâ dictum est: Quae solveritis in terrâ, soluta erunt in coelo? Ergo sine caussâ sunt claves datae Ecclesiae Dei? Frustramus Evangelium Dei: frustramus verba Christi? Promittimus vobis quod ille negat? Nónne vos decipimus? Iob dicit: Si erubui in conspectu populi confiteri peccata mea. Talis justus thesauri divini obryzi, tali camino probatus, ista dicit: & resistit mihi filius pestilentiae, & erubescit genu figere sub benedictione Dei? Quod non erubuit Imperator, erubescit nec senator, sed tantùm curialis? Superba cervix, mens tortuosa. fortassis, imò quod non dubitatur, proptereà Deus v•luit ut Theodosius Imperator ageret poenitentiam publicam in conspectu populi, maximé quia peccatum ejus celari non potuit: & erubescit Senator, quod non erubuit Imperator? erubescit nec Senator, sed tantùm curialis, quod nō erubuit Imperator? Erubescit plebeius sive negotiator, quod nō erubuit Imperator? Quae ista superbia est? Nónne sola sufficeret gehēnae, etiamsi adulteriū nullū esset. Id. hom. 49. ex 50. ca. 3.
which being in tract of time disused in some places, long after this, the rBishops of France, by the assistance of Charles the great, caused it to be brought in use again, according to the order of the old Canons.
which being in tract of time disused in some places, long after this, the rBishops of France, by the assistance of Charles the great, caused it to be brought in use againe, according to the order of the olde Canons.
rConcil. Arelat. IV cap 26 & Cabilonens. II. cap. 25.
Neither is it here to be omitted, that in the time of ⟨p. 94⟩the more ancient Fathers this strict discipline was not so restrained to the censure of public crimes; but that private transgressions also were sometimes drawn within the compass of it. For whereas at first, public confession was enjoined only for public offences: men afterwards, discerning what great benefit redounded to the penitents thereby, (aswell for the subduing of the stubbornness of their hard hearts, and the furthering of their deeper humiliation; as for their raising up again by those sensible comforts which they received by the public prayers of the Congregation, and the use of the keys) some men, I say, discerning this, and finding their own consciences burdened with the like sins, which being carried in secrecy, were not subject to the censures of the Church; to the end they might obtain the like consolation and quiet of mind, did voluntarily submit themselves to the Churches discipline herein, and undergo the burden of public Confession and Penance. This appeareth by Origen in his second Homily upon the 37 Psalm, Tertullian in his book de Poenitentiâ, chap. 9. S. Cyprian in his Treatise de Lapsis, sect. 23. (or 11. according to Pamelius his distinction) S. Ambrose in his first book de Poenitentiâ, chap. 16. and others. And to the end that this publication of secret faults might be performed in the best manner: some prudent Minister was first of all made acquainted therewith; by whose direction the delinquent might understand what sins were fit to be brought to the public notice of the Church, and in what manner the penance was to be performed for them. Therefore did Origen advise (as we heard) that one should use great care in making choice of a good and skilful physician, to whom he ⟨p. 95⟩should disclose his grief in this kind. and sif he understand (saith he) and foresee that thy disease is such as ought to be declared in the assembly of the whole Church, and cured there, whereby peradventure both others may be edified, and thou thy self more easily healed; with much deliberation, and by the very skilful counsel of that physician, must this be done.
Neyther is it here to be omitted, that in the time of ⟨p. 94⟩the more ancient Fathers this strict discipline was not so restrayned to the censure of publicke crimes; but that private transgressions also were sometimes drawn within the compasse of it. For whereas at first, publike confession was enjoyned onely for publike offences: men afterwards, discerning what great benefit redounded to the penitents thereby, (aswell for the subduing of the stubburnesse of their hard hearts, and the furthering of their deeper humiliation; as for their raysing up againe by those sensible comforts which they received by the publike prayers of the Congregation, and the use of the keyes) some men, I say, discerning this, and finding their owne consciences burdened with the like sinnes, which being carried in secrecie, were not subject to the censures of the Church; to the end they might obtaine the like consolation and quiet of minde, did voluntarily submit themselves to the Churches discipline herein, and undergoe the burden of publick Confession and Penance. This appeareth by Origen in his second Homily upon the 37 Psalme, Tertullian in his booke de Poenitentiâ, chap. 9. S. Cyprian in his Treatise de Lapsis, sect. 23. (or 11. according to Pamelius his distinction) S. Ambrose in his first booke de Poenitentiâ, chap. 16. and others. And to the end that this publication of secret faults might be performed in the best maner: some prudent Minister was first of all made acquainted therewith; by whose direction the delinquent might understand what sinnes were fit to be brought to the publick notice of the Church, and in what maner the penance was to bee performed for them. Therefore did Origen advise (as wee heard) that one should use great care in making choyce of a good and skilfull physician, to whom hee ⟨p. 95⟩should disclose his griefe in this kinde. and sif hee understand (saith he) and foresee that thy disease is such as ought to be declared in the assembly of the whole Church, and cured there, whereby peradventure both others may be edified, and thou thy selfe more easily healed; with much deliberation, and by the very skilfull counsaile of that physician, must this be done.
sSi intellexerit, & praeviderit talem esse languorem tuū qui in conventu totius Ecclesiae exponi debeat, & curari, ex quo for•assis & caeteri aedificari poterunt, & tu ipse facilè sanari: multâ hoc deliberatione, & satis perito medici illius consilio procurandū est. Origen. in Psal. 37. h•mil. 2.Si intellexerit, & praeviderit talem esse languorem tuū qui in conventu totius Ecclesiae exponi debeat, & curari, ex quo for•assis & caeteri aedificari poterunt, & tu ipse facilè sanari: multâ hoc deliberatione, & satis perito medici illius consilio procurandū est. Origen. in Psal. 37. h•mil. 2.
But within a while (shortly after the persecution raised in the days of Decius the Emperor) it was no longer left free to the Penitent to make choice of his ghostly father: but by the general consent of the Bishops it was ordained, that in every Church one certain discreet Minister should be appointed to receive the confessions of such as relapsed into sin after Baptism. This is that addition, which tSocrates in his Ecclesiastical history noteth to have been then made unto the Penitential Canon; and to have been observed by the governors of the Church for a long time: until at length in the time of Nectarius Bishop of Constantinople (which was about CXL. years after the persecution of Decius) upon occasion of an infamy drawn upon the Clergy by the confession of a Gentlewoman, defiled by a Deacon in that city, it was thought fit it should be abolished, and that uliberty should be given unto every one, upon the private examination of his own conscience, to resort to the holy Communion. Which was agreeable both to the rule of the Apostle, 1. Cor. 11.28. (Let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of that bread and drink of that cup:) and to the judgement of the more ancient Fathers, as appeareth by Clemens Alexandrinus, who accounteth a mans own conscience to be his xbest directer in this case. howsoever our new Masters of ⟨p. 96⟩yTrent have not only determined that sacramental confession must necessarily be premised before the receiving of the Eucharist; but also have pronounced them to be excommunicate ipso facto, that shall presume to teach the contrary.
But within a while (shortly after the persecution raysed in the dayes of Decius the Emperour) it was no longer left free to the Penitent to make choyce of his ghostly father: but by the generall consent of the Bishops it was ordayned, that in every Church one certaine discreet Minister should be appointed to receive the confessions of such as relapsed into sinne after Baptisme. This is that addition, which tSocrates in his Ecclesiasticall historie noteth to have beene then made unto the Penitentiall Canon; and to have beene observed by the governours of the Church for a long time: untill at length in the time of Nectarius Bishop of Constantinople (which was about CXL. yeares after the persecution of Decius) upon occasion of an infamy drawne upon the Clergie by the confession of a Gentlewoman, defiled by a Deacon in that citie, it was thought fit it should be abolished, and that ulibertie should be given unto everie one, upon the private examination of his owne conscience, to resort to the holy Communion. Which was agreeable both to the rule of the Apostle, 1. Cor. 11.28. (Let a man examine himselfe, and so let him eate of that bread and drinke of that cup:) and to the judgement of the more ancient Fathers, as appeareth by Clemens Alexandrinus, who accounteth a mans owne conscience to be his xbest directer in this case. howsoever our new Masters of ⟨p. 96⟩yTrent have not onely determined that sacramentall confession must necessarily be premised before the receyving of the Eucharist; but also have pronounced them to be excommunicate ipso facto, that shall presume to teach the contrarie.
The case then (if these mens censures were ought worth) would go hard with Nectarius, and all the Bishops that followed him; but especially with S. John Chrysostom, who was his immediate successor in the See of Constantinople. for thus doth he expound that place of the Apostle: zLet every one examine himself, and then let him come. He doth not bid one man to examine another, but every one himself; making the judgement private, and the trial without witnesses. and in the end of his second homily of Fasting (which in others is the eighth de Poenitentiâ) frameth his exhortation accordingly. aWithin thy conscience, none being present but God who seeth all things, enter thou into judgement and into a search of thy sins, and recounting thy whole life, bring thy sins unto judgement in thy mind: reform thy excesses, and so with a pure conscience draw near to that sacred Table, and partake of that holy sacrifice. Yet in another place he deeply chargeth Ministers, not to admit known offenders unto the Communion. But bif one (saith he) be ignorant that he is an evil person, after that he hath used much diligence therein, he is not to be blamed. for these things are spoken by me of such as are known. And we find both in him, and in the practise of the times following, that the order of public Penance was not wholly taken away; but according to the ancient discipline established by the Apostles in the Church, open offenders were openly censured and pressed to make public confession of ⟨p. 97⟩their faults. Whereby it is manifest, that the liberty brought in by Nectarius, of not resorting to any Penitentiary, respected the disclosing of secret sins only; such as that foul one was, from whence the public scandal arose, which gave occasion to the repeal of the former Constitution. For to suffer open and notorious crimes, committed in the Church, to pass without control, was not a mean to prevent but to augment scandals; nay the ready way, to make the house of God become a den of thieves.
The case then (if these mens censures were ought worth) would goe hard with Nectarius, and all the Bishops that followed him; but especially with S. Iohn Chrysostom, who was his immediat successor in the See of Constantinople. for thus doth hee expound that place of the Apostle: zLet every one examine himselfe, and then let him come. He doth not bid one man to examine another, but every one himselfe; making the judgement private, and the tryall without witnesses. and in the end of his second homily of Fasting (which in others is the eighth de Poenitentiâ) frameth his exhortation accordingly. aWithin thy conscience, none being present but God who seeth all things, enter thou into judgement and into a search of thy sinnes, and recounting thy whole life, bring thy sinnes unto judgement in thy minde: reforme thy excesses, and so vvith a pure conscience draw neare to that sacred Table, and partake of that holy sacrifice. Yet in another place hee deepely chargeth Ministers, not to admit knowne offendors unto the Communion. But bif one (saith hee) be ignorant that hee is an evill person, after that hee hath used much diligence ther•in, he is not to be blamed. for these things are spoken by me of such as are knowne. And we finde both in him, and in the practise of the times following, that the order of publick Penance was not wholly taken away; but according to the ancient discipline established by the Apostles in the Church, open offendors were openly censured and pressed to make publick confession of ⟨p. 97⟩their faults. Whereby it is manifest, that the libertie brought in by Nectarius, of not resorting to any Penitentiarie, respected the disclosing of secret sinnes only; such as that foule one was, from whence the publick scandall arose, which gave occasion to the repeale of the former Constitution. For to suffer open and notorious crimes, committed in the Church, to passe without controule, was not a meane to prevent but to augment scandalls; nay the readie way, to make the house of God become a denne of theeves.
z[Greek or Hebrew]. Chrysost. in 1. Cor. 11. homil. 28.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Chrysost. in 1. Cor. 11. homil. 28.
Two observations more I will add upon this part of the history. The one: that the abrogation of this Canon showeth, that the form of Confession used by the ancient, was Canonical, that is, appertaining to that external discipline of the Church which upon just occasion might be altered; and not Sacramental, and of perpetual right, which is that our Jesuits stand for. The other: that the course taken herein by Nectarius, was not only approved by S. Chrysostom, who succeeded him at Constantinople; but cgenerally in a manner by the Catholic Bishops of other places. howsoever the Arians, and the rest of the sectaries (the Novatians only excepted, who from the beginning would not admit the discipline used in the Church for the reconciliation of Penitents) retained still the former usage. as by the relation of Socrates and Sozomen more fully may appear. And therefore when within some XXI. years after the time wherein they finished their histories, and about LXX. after that the publication of secret offences began to be abolished by Nectarius, certain in Italy did so do their penance, that they caused a writing to be publicly read, containing a profession of their several sins: Leo, who at that time was Bishop ⟨p. 98⟩of Rome, gave order, that by all means dthat course should be broken off; forasmuch as it was sufficient, that the guilt of mens consciences should be declared in secret confession to the Priests alone. For although (saith he) the fullness of faith may seem to be laudable, which for the fear of God doth not fear to blush before men: yet because all mens sins are not of that kind, that they may not fear to publish such of them as require repentance, let so inconvenient a custom be removed; lest many be driven away from the remedies of repentance, while either they are ashamed, or afraid to disclose their deeds unto their enemies, whereby they may be drawn within the peril of the laws. For that confession is sufficient, which is offered first unto God, and then unto the Priest, who cometh as an intercessor for the sins of the penitent. For then at length more may be provoked to repentance, if that the conscience of him who confesseth be not published to the ears of the people.
Two observations more I will adde upon this part of the historie. The one: that the abrogation of this Canon sheweth, that the forme of Confession used by the ancient, was Canonical, that is, appertayning to that externall discipline of the Church which upon just occasion might be altered; and not Sacramentall, and of perpetuall right, which is that our Iesuites stand for. The other: that the course taken herein by Nectarius, was not onely approved by S. Chrysostome, who succeeded him at Constantinople; but cgenerally in a maner by the Catholick Bishops of other places. howsoever the Arrians, and the rest of the sectaries (the Novatians onely excepted, who from the beginning would not admit the discipline used in the Church for the reconciliation of Penitents) retained still the former usage. as by the relation of Socrates and Sozomen more fully may appeare. And therefore when within some XXI. yeares after the time wherein they finished their histories, and about LXX. after that the publication of secret offences began to be abolished by Nectarius, certaine in Italy did so doe their penance, that they caused a writing to be publickly read, containing a profession of their severall sinnes: Leo, who at that time was Bishop ⟨p. 98⟩of Rome, gave order, that by all meanes dthat course should be broken off; forasmuch as it was sufficient, that the guilt of mens consciences should be declared in secret confession to the Priests alone. For although (saith he) the fulnesse of faith may seeme to be laudable, vvhich for the feare of God doth not feare to blush before men: yet because all mens sinnes are not of that kinde, that they may not feare to publish such of them as require repentance, let so inconvenient a custome be removed; lest many be driven away from the remedies of repentance, vvhile eyther they are ashamed, or afraid to disclose their deedes unto their enemies, whereby they may be drawne within the perill of the lawes. For that confession is sufficient, which is offered first unto God, and then unto the Priest, who commeth as an intercessor for the sinnes of the penitent. For then at length more may be provoked to repentance, if that the conscience of him who confesseth be not published to the eares of the people.
dNe de singulorum peccatorum genere libellis scripta professio publicé recitetur: cùm reatus con scientiarum sufficiat solis sacerdotibus indicari confessione secretâ. Quamvis enim plenitudo fidei videatur esse laudabilis, quae propter Dei timorem apud homines erubescere non veretur: tamen quia non omnium hujusmodi sunt peccata, ut ea, quae poenitentiam poscunt, non timeant publicare, removeatur tam impro babilis consuetudo; ne multi á poenitentiae remediis arceantur, dumb aut crubescunt, aut metuunt inimicis suis sua facta referare, quibus possint legum constitution percelli. Sufficit enim illa confess•o, quae primùm Deo offertur, tum etiam Sacerdoti, qui pro delictis poenitentium precator accedit. Tunc enim demùm plures ad poenitentiā poterunt provocari si populi aur•bus non publicetur conscientia confitentis. Leo, epist. 80. ad Epis•opos Campaniae, Samnij & Pi••ni.Ne de singulorum peccatorum genere libellis scripta professio publicé recitetur: cùm reatus cō scientiarum sufficiat solis sacerdotibus indicari confessione secretâ. Quamvis enim plenitudo fidei videatur esse laudabilis, quae propter Dei timorem apud homines erubescere non veretur: tamen quia non omnium hujusmodi sunt peccata, ut ea, quae poenitentiam poscunt, non timeant publicare, removeatur tam impro babilis consuetudo; ne multi á poenitentiae remediis arceantur, dum aut crubescunt, aut metuunt inimicis suis sua facta referare, quibus possint legum constitutione percelli. Sufficit enim illa confess•o, quae primùm Deo offertur, tum etiam Sacerdoti, qui pro delictis poenitentium precator accedit. Tunc enim demùm plures ad poenitentiā poterunt provocari si populi aur•bus non publicetur conscientia confitentis. Leo, epist. 80. ad Epis•opos Campaniae, Samnij & Pi••ni.
By this place of Leo we may easily understand, how upon the removal of public Confession of secret faults (together with the private made unto the Penitentiary, which was adjoined as a preparative thereunto) Auricular confession began to be substituted in the room thereof: to the end, that by this means more might be drawn on to this exercise of repentance; the impediments of shame and fear, which accompanied the former practise, being taken out of the way. for indeed the shame of this public Penance was such, that in the time of Tertullian (when this discipline was thought most needful for the Church) it was ⟨p. 99⟩strongly epresumed, that many did either shun this work as a publication of themselves, or deferred it from day to day, being more mindful (as he saith) of their shame than of their salvation. Nay S. Ambrose observed that fsome, who for fear of the punishment in the other world, being conscious to themselves of their sins, did here desire their penance, were yet for shame of their public supplication drawn back, after they had received it. Therefore the conjecture of gRhenanus is not to be contemned, that from this public confession, the private took his original: which by Stapleton, (in his Fortress, part. 2. chap. 4.) is positively delivered in this manner. Afterward this open and sharp penance was brought to the private and particular confession now used; principally for the lewdness of the common lay Christians, which in this open confession began at length to mock and insult at their brethren's simplicity and devotion. although it may seem by that which is written by hOrigen, that the seeds of this lewdness began to sprout long before; howsoever iTertullian imagined, that no member of the Church would be so ungracious as to commit such folly.
By this place of Leo we may easily understand, how upon the removeall of publick Confession of secret faults (together with the private made unto the Penitentiarie, which was adjoyned as a preparative thereunto) Auricular confession began to be substituted in the roome thereof: to the end, that by this meanes more might be drawne on to this exercise of repentance; the impediments of shame and feare, which accompanied the former practise, being taken out of the way. for indeed the shame of this publick Penance was such, that in the time of Tertullian (when this discipline was thought most needefull for the Church) it was ⟨p. 99⟩strongly epresumed, that many did eyther shunne this worke as a publication of themselves, or deferred it from day to day, being more mindefull (as hee saith) of their shame than of their salvation. Nay S. Ambrose observed that fsome, who for feare of the punishment in the other world, being conscious to themselves of their sinnes, did here desire their penance, vvere yet for shame of their publick supplication drawne back, after they had received it. Therfore the conjecture of gRhenanus is not to be contemned, that from this publick confession, the private tooke his originall: which by Stapleton, (in his Fortresse, part. 2. chap. 4.) is positively delivered in this maner. Afterward this open and sharpe penance vvas brought to the private and particular confession now used; principally for the lewdnesse of the common lay Christians, which in this open confession began at length to mocke and insult at their brethrens simplicity and devotion. although it may seeme by that which is written by hOrigen, that the seeds of this lewdnesse began to sprout long before; howsoever iTertullian imagined, that no member of the Church would be so ungracious as to commit such folly.
ePlerosque tamen hoc opus ut publicationē sui aut suffugere, aut de die in diem differ, praesumo; pudoris magis memores quàm salutis. Tertull. de Poenit cap. 9.Plerosque tamen hoc opus ut publicationē sui aut suffugere, aut de die in diem differre, praesumo; pudoris magis memores quàm salutis. Tertull. de Poenit cap. 9.
fNam plerique futuri supplicii metu, peccatorū suorum conscii, poenitentiam petunt: & cùm acceperint, publicae supplicationis r•vocantur pudore. Hi videntur malorū petisse poenitentiam, agere bonorū, Ambr. de poenitent. lib. 2. cap 9.Nam plerique futuri supplicii metu, peccatorū suorum conscii, poenitentiam petunt: & cùm acceperint, publicae supplicationis r•vocantur pudore. Hi videntur malorū petisse poenitentiam, agere bonorū, Ambr. de poenitent. lib. 2. cap 9.
gPorrò non aliam ob caussam compluriū hîc testimoniis usi sumus, quàm ne quis admiretur Tertullianum de clanculariâ istâ admissorum confessione nihil locutum: quae, quantum conjicimus, nata est ex istâ Exomologesi per ultroneam hominum pietatem, ut occultorum peccatorum esset & Exomologesis occulta. Nec enim usquàm praeceptam olim legimus. B. Rhenan. argument. in lib. Tertullian. de Poenitent.Porrò non aliam ob caussam compluriū hîc testimoniis usi sumus, quàm ne quis admiretur Tertullianum de clanculariâ istâ admissorum confessione nihil locutum: quae, quantum conjicimus, nata est ex istâ Exomologesi per ultroneam hominum pietatem, ut occultorum peccatorum esset & Exomologesis occulta. Nec enim usquàm praeceptam olim legimus. B. Rhenan. argument. in lib. Tertullian. de Poenitent.
hSi ergo hujusmodi homo memor delicti sui, confitea tur quae commisit, & humanâ▪ confusione parvi pendat eos qui exprobrant eum confitentem, & notant vel irrident: &c. Origen. in Psalm. 37. homil. 2.
iCerté periculum ejus tunc si fortè onerosum est, cùm penes insultaturos in risiloquio consistit, ubi de alterius ruinâ alter attollitur, ubi prostrato superscenditur. Caeterùm inter fratres atque cons•rvos, ubi communis spes, metus, gaudium, dolor, passio: quid tuos aliud quàm te opinaris? Quid consortes casuum tuorum, ut plausores fugis? Non potest corpus de unius membri vexation laetum agere: Tertullian. de Poenitent. cap 9.
The public confession therefore of secret sins being thus abolished, by Nectarius first (for the scandal that came thereby unto others) and by the rest of the ⟨p. 100⟩Catholic Bishops after him (for the reproach and danger, whereunto the penitents by this means were laid open:) private Confession was so brought in to supply the defect thereof, that it was accounted no more sacramental, nor esteemed (at least generally) to be of more necessity for the obtaining of remission of sins, then that other. So that whatsoever order afterward was taken herein, may well be judged to have had the nature of a temporal law, which, according to the definition of S. Augustine, kalthough it be just, yet in time may be justly also changed. Nay we find that Laurence Bishop of Novaria, in his homily de Poenitentiâ, doth resolutely determine, that for obtaining remission of sins, a man needeth not to resort unto any Priest, but that his own internal repentance is sufficient for that matter: God (saith lhe) after Baptism hath appointed thy remedy within thy self, he hath put remission in thine own power, that thou needest not seek a Priest when thy necessity requireth; but thou thy self now, as a skilful and plain master, mayest amend thine error within thy self, & wash away thy sin by repentance. mHe hath given unto thee (saith another, somewhat to the same purpose) the power of binding and loosing. Thou hast bound thy self with the chain of the love of wealth; loose thy self with the injunction of the love of poverty. Thou hast bound thy self with the furious desire of pleasures; loose thy self with temperance. Thou hast bound thy self with the misbelief of Eunomius; loose thy self with the religious embracing of the right faith.
The publick confession therefore of secret sinnes being thus abolished, by Nectarius first (for the scandall that came thereby unto others) and by the rest of the ⟨p. 100⟩Catholick Bishops after him (for the reproach and danger, whereunto the penitents by this meanes were layd open:) private Confession was so brought in to supply the defect thereof, that it was accounted no more sacramentall, nor esteemed (at least generally) to be of more necessitie for the obtayning of remission of sinnes, then that other. So that whatsoever order afterward was taken herein, may well be judged to have had the nature of a temporall law, which, according to the definition of S. Augustine, kalthough it be just, yet in time may be justly also changed. Nay we finde that Laurence Bishop of Novaria, in his homily de Poenitentiâ, doth resolutely determine, that for obtayning remission of sinnes, a man needeth not to resort unto anie Priest, but that his owne internall repentance is sufficient for that matter: God (saith lhee) after Baptisme hath appoynted thy remedy within thy selfe, hee hath put remission in thine owne power, that thou needest not seeke a Priest when thy necessity requireth; but thou thy selfe now, as a skilfull and plaine master, mayest amend thine error within thy selfe, & wash away thy sin by repentance. mHe hath given unto thee (saith another, somewhat to the same purpose) the power of binding and loosing. Thou hast bound thy selfe with the chayn of the love of wealth; loose thy selfe with the injunction of the love of povertie. Thou hast bound thy selfe with the furious desire of pleasures; loose thy selfe with temperance. Thou hast bound thy selfe with the misbeleefe of Eunomius; loose thy selfe with the religious embracing of the right faith.
kAppellemus istam legem, si placet, temporalem, quae quamvis justa sit, commutari tamen per tempora justé potest. August. de lib. arbitr. lib. 1. cap. 6.
lPost Baptisma, remedium tuum in teipso statuit, remissionem in arbitrio tuo posuit, ut non quaeras Sacerdotē cùm necessitas flagitaverit: sed ipse jam acsi scitus perspicuusque magister, errorem tuum intra te emends, & peccatum tuū poenitudine abluas Lair. Novar •om. 6. Biblioth. Patr. part. 1. pag. 337. a edit. Colon.Post Baptisma, remedium tuum in teipso statuit, remissionem in arbitrio tuo posuit, ut non quaeras Sacerdotē cùm necessitas flagitaverit: sed ipse jam acsi scitus perspicuusque magister, errorem tuum intra te emendes, & peccatum tuū poenitudine abluas La•r. Nouar •om. 6. Biblioth. Patr. part. 1. pag. 337. a edit. Colon.
m[Greek or Hebrew] Author homiliae in illud; Quaecunque ligaveritis &c. inter opera Chrysostomi, tom. 7. edit. Savil. pag. 268.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Author homiliae in illud; Quaecunque ligaveritis &c. inter opera Chrysostomi, tom. 7. edit. Savil. pag. 268.
And, that we may see how variable mens judgements were touching the matter of Confession in the ages following: Bede would have us nconfess our daily & light sins one unto another, but open the uncleanness of the greater leprosy to the Priest. Alcuinus, not long after him, would have us oconfess all the sins that we can remember. Others were of another mind. For some (as it appeareth by the writings of the same pAlcuinus and of qHaymo) would not confess their sins to the Priest; but rsaid, it was sufficient for them that they did confess their sins to God alone, provided always that they ceased from those sins for the time to come. Others confessed their sins unto the Priests, but not fullys: as may be seen in the Council of Cavailon, held in the days of Charles the great where, though the Fathers think that this had need to be amended: yet they freely acknowledge, that it remained still a question, whether men should only confess to God, or to the Priests also; and they themselves put this difference betwixt both those confessions, that the one did properly serve for the cure, the other for direction in what sort the repentance (and so the cure) should be performed. Their words are these. tSome ⟨p. 102⟩say, that they ought to confess their sins only unto God, and some think that they are to be confessed unto the Priests: both of which, not without great fruit, is practised within the holy Church. namely thus, that we both confess our sins unto God, who is the forgiver of sins (saying with David: I acknowledged my sin unto thee, and mine iniquity have I not hid. I said, I will confess against my self my transgressions unto the Lord: and thou forgavest the iniquity of my sin.) and according to the institution of the Apostle, confess our sins one unto another, and pray one for another, that we may be healed. The Confession therefore which is made unto God, purgeth sins: but that which is made unto the Priest, teacheth in what sort those sins should be purged. For God the author and bestower of salvation and health, giveth the same sometime by the invisible administration of his power, sometime by the operation of Physicians.
And, that wee may see how variable mens judgements were touching the matter of Confession in the ages following: Bede would have us nconfesse our daily & light sinnes one unto another, but open the uncleanenesse of the greater leprosie to the Priest. Alcuinus, not long after him, would have us oconfesse all the sinnes that we can remember. Others were of another minde. For some (as it appeareth by the writings of the same pAlcuinus and of qHaymo) would not confesse their sinnes to the Priest; but rsaid, it was sufficient for them that they did confesse their sinnes to God alone, provided alwayes that they ceased from those sinnes for the time to come. Others confessed their sinnes unto the Priests, but not fullys: as may be seene in the Councell of Cauailon, held in the dayes of Charles the great where, though the Fathers thinke that this had need to be amended: yet they freely acknowledge, that it remained still a question, whether men should only confesse to God, or to the Priests also; and they themselves put this difference betwixt both those confessions, that the one did properly serve for the cure, the other for direction in what sort the repentance (and so the cure) should be performed. Their words are these. tSome ⟨p. 102⟩say, that they ought to confesse their sinnes onely unto God, and some thinke that they are to be confessed unto the Priests: both of which, not without great fruit, is practised within the holy Church. namely thus, that wee both confesse our sinnes unto God, who is the forgiver of sinnes (saying with David: I acknowledged my sinne unto thee, and mine iniquity have I not hid. I said, I will confesse against my selfe my transgressions vnto the Lord: and thou forgavest the iniquity of my sinne.) and according to the institution of the Apostle, confesse our sinnes one unto another, and pray one for another, that we may be healed. The Confession therfore which is made unto God, purgeth sins: but that which is made unto the Priest, teacheth in what sort those sinnes should be purged. For God the author and bestower of salvation and health, giveth the same sometime by the invisible administration of his power, sometime by the operation of Physicians.
nIn hâc sententiâ illa debet esse discretio; ut quotidiana leviá que pecca•a alteru•um coaequalibus confiteamur, corumque quotidianâ credamus oratione salvari. Porrò gravioris leprae immunditiā juxta legem sacerdoti pandamus, atque ad ejus arbitrium qualiter & quanto tempore jusserit, purificari curemus. Bed. in Jacob. 5.In hâc sententiâ illa debet esse discretio; ut quotidiana leviá que pecca•a alteru•um coaequalibus confiteamur, corumque quotidianâ credamus oratione salvari. Porrò gravioris leprae immūditiā juxta legem sacerdoti pandamus, atque ad ejus arbitrium qualiter & quanto tempore jusserit, purificari curemus. Bed. in Iacob. 5.
oVolens dimittere omnia his qui in se peccaverunt, confiteatur omnia peccata sua, quae recordari potest. Alcuin. de divin. offi•. cap 13 in capite Jejunii.Volens dimittere omnia his qui in se peccaverunt, confiteatur omnia peccata sua, quae recordari potest. Alcuin. de divin. offi•. cap 13 in capite Iejunii.
pId. epist. 26.
qHaymo in Evangel. Dominic. 15. post Pentecost. Ite ostendite vos Sacerdotib.Haymo in Evangel. Dominic. 15. post Pentecost. Ite ostēdite vos Sacerdotib.
rDicentes, sibi sussicere, ut soli Deo peccata sua confiteantur; si tantùm ab ipsis peccatis in reliquo cessent. Haymo, ut supra.Dicentes, sibi sussicere, ut soli Deo peccata sua confiteātur; si tantùm ab ipsis peccatis in reliquo cessent. Haymo, ut supra.
sSed & hoc emendatione egere perspeximus, quòd quidā dun confitentur peccata sua sacerdotibus, non plené id faciunt. Concil. C. bilo•. II. cap. 32.Sed & hoc emendatione egere perspeximus, quòd quidā dū cōfitentur peccata sua sacerdotibus, non plené id faciūt. Concil. C. bilo•. II. cap. 32.
This Canon is cited by uGratian out of the Penitential of Theodorus Archbishop of Canterbury: but clogged with some unnecessary additions. as when in the beginning thereof it is made the xopinion of the Grecians, that sins should be confessed only unto God; and of the rest of the Church, that they should be confessed to Priests. where those words, ut Graeci, in Gratian seem unto Cardinal Bellarmine, yto have crept out of the margin into the text; and to have been a marginal annotation of some unskilful man, who gathered by the fact of Nectarius, that Sacramental Confession was wholly taken away among the Grecians. For otherwise ⟨p. 103⟩(saith he) in the Capitular it self of Theodorus, whence that Canon was transcribed, those two words [ut Graeci] are not to be had; nor are they also to be had in the second Council of Cavaillon, c. 33. whence Theodorus seemeth to have taken that chapter: neither yet doth the Master of the Sentences, in his 4. book and 17. distinction bringing in the same sentence, add those words [ut Graeci.] But the Cardinals conjecture of the translating of these words out of the margin into the text of Gratian, is of little worth: seeing we find them expressly laid down in the elder collections of the Decrees, made by zBurchardus and aIvo; from whence it is evident that Gratian borrowed this whole chapter, as he hath done many a one beside. For as for the Capitular it self of Theodorus, whence the Cardinal too too boldly affirmeth that Canon was transcribed; as if he had looked into the book himself: we are to know, that no such Capitular of Theodorus is to be found: only Burchardus and Ivo, (in whom, as we said, those controverted words are extant) setteth down this whole chapter as taken out of Theodore's Penitential, & so misguided Gratian. for indeed in Theodorus his Penitential (which I did lately transcribe out of a most ancient copy kept in Sir Robert Cottons Treasury) no part of that chapter can be seen: nor yet any thing else tending to the matter now in hand, this short sentence only excepted. Confessionem suam Deo soli, si necesse est, licebit agere. It is lawful, that Confession be made unto God alone, if need require. And to suppose as the Cardinal doth that Theodorus should take this chapter out of the second Council of Cavaillon:
This Canon is cyted by uGratian out of the Penitentiall of Theodorus Archbishop of Canterbury: but clogged with some unnecessarie additions. as when in the beginning thereof it is made the xopinion of the Grecians, that sinnes should be confessed onely unto God; and of the rest of the Church, that they should be confessed to Priests. where those words, ut Graeci, in Gratian seeme unto Cardinall Bellarmine, yto have crept out of the margent into the text; and to have beene a marginall annotation of some unskilfull man, who gathered by the fact of Nectarius, that Sacramentall Confession was wholly taken away among the Grecians. For otherwise ⟨p. 103⟩(saith hee) in the Capitular it selfe of Theodorus, whence that Canon was transcribed, those two words [ut Graeci] are not to be had; nor are they also to be had in the second Councell of Cauaillon, c. 33. whence Theodorus seemeth to have taken that chapter: neyther yet doth the Master of the Sentences, in his 4. booke and 17. distinction bringing in the same sentence, adde those words [ut Graeci.] But the Cardinalls conjecture of the translating of these words out of the margent into the text of Gratian, is of little worth: seeing wee finde them expressely laid downe in the elder collections of the Decrees, made by zBurchardus and aIvo; from whence it is evident that Gratian borrowed this whole chapter, as he hath done manie a one beside. For as for the Capitular it selfe of Theodorus, whence the Cardinall too too boldly affirmeth that Canon was transcribed; as if hee had looked into the booke himselfe: we are to know, that no such Capitular of Theodorus is to be found: onely Burchardus and Ivo, (in whom, as we said, those controverted words are extant) setteth downe this whole chapter as taken out of Theodors Penitentiall, & so misguided Gratian. for indeed in Theodorus his Penitentiall (which I did lately transcribe out of a most ancient copie kept in Sir Robert Cottons Threasurie) no part of that chapter can be seene: nor yet any thing else tending to the matter now in hand, this short sentence onely excepted. Confessionem suam Deo soli, si necesse est, licebit agere. It is lawfull, that Confession be made unto God alone, if need require. And to suppose as the Cardinall doth that Theodorus should take this chapter out of the second Councell of Cauaillon:
uGrat. de Poenit. distinct. 1. cap. ult. Quidā Deo.Grat. de Poenit. distinct. 1. cap. ult. Quidā Deo.
xQuidā Deo solummodò confiteri debere peccata dicunt, ut Graeci: qui dam veró Sacerdotibus cō fitenda esse percensent, ut tota feré sancta Ecclesia. Ibid.Quidā Deo solummodò cōfiteri debere peccata dicūt, ut Graeci: qui dam veró Sacerdotibus cō fitenda esse percensent, ut tota feré sancta Ecclesia. Ibid.
yVidetur irrepsisse in textum ex margine: & marginalem annotationem imperiti alicujus fuisse, qui ex facto Nectarii collegit sublatam omnino Confessionem Sacramentalem apud Graecos. Nam alioqui in ipso capitulari Theodori, unde canon ille descriptus est, non habentur duae illae voces [ut Graeci,] neque etiam habentur in Concilio II. Cabilonensi, c. 33. unde Theodorus Capitulum illud accepisse videtur: sed nec Magister Sentent. in 4. lib. dist. 17. eandem sententiam adducens, addidit illud, [ut Graeci.] Bellarmin. de Poenitent. lib. 3. cap. 5.
were an idle imagination▪ seeing it is well known that Theodore died Archbishop of Canterbury in the year of ⟨p. 104⟩our Lord 690: and the Council of Cavaillon was held in the year 813. that is, 123. years after the others death. The truth is; he who made the additions to the Capitularia of Charles the great and Ludovicus Pius, (gathered by Ansegisus and Benedict) translated this Canon out of that Council into his bCollection: which Bellarmine, as it seemeth, having someway heard of, knew not to distinguish between those Capitularia, and Theodore's Penitential. being herein as negligent, as in his allegation of the fourth book of the Sentences: where the Master doth not bring in this sentence at all, but having among other questions propounded this also for one, cWhether it be sufficient that a man confess his sins to God alone, or whether he must confess to a Priest; doth thereupon set down the diversity of mens opinions touching that matter, and saith, that unto some it seemed to suffice, if confession were made to God only without the judgement of the Priest or the confession of the Church. because David said; I said, I will confess unto the Lord: he saith not, Unto the Priest; and yet he showeth that his sin was forgiven him. For in these points, as the same author had before noted,d even the learned were found to hold diversly: because the Doctors seemed to deliver diverse and almost contrary judgement• therein.
were an idle imagination▪ seeing it is well knowne that Theodore died Archbishop of Canterbury in the yeare of ⟨p. 104⟩our Lord 690: and the Councell of Cauaillon was held in the yeare 813. that is, 123. yeares after the others death. The truth is; hee who made the additions to the Capitularia of Charles the great and Ludovicus Pius, (gathered by Ansegisus and Benedict) translated this Canon out of that Councell into his bCollection: which Bellarmine, as it seemeth, having someway heard of, knew not to distinguish between those Capitularia, and Theodors Penitentiall. being herein as negligent, as in his allegation of the fourth book of the Sentences: where the Master doth not bring in this sentence at all, but having among other questions propounded this also for one, cWhether it be sufficient that a man confesse his sinnes to God alone, or whether hee must confesse to a Priest; doth thereupon set down the diversitie of mens opinions touching that matter, and saith, that unto some it seemed to suffice, if confession vvere made to God onely without the judgement of the Priest or the confession of the Church. because David said; I said, I will confesse unto the Lord: he saith not, Vnto the Priest; and yet he sheweth that his sinne was forgiven him. For in these points, as the same author had before noted,d even the learned were found to hold diversly: because the Doctors seemed to deliver diverse and almost contrarie judgement• therein.
cUtrum sufficiat peccata confiteri soli Deo, an op•rteat confiteri Sacerdoti Quibusdam visum est sufficere, si soli Deo fiat confessio sine judicio Sacerdotali & confessione ecclesiae. quia David dixit; Dixi Confitebor Domino, &c. non ait, Sacerdoti: & tamen remissum sibi peccatum dicit. Petr. Lombard. lib. 4. Senten• dist. 17.Vtrum sufficiat peccata confiteri soli Deo, an op•rteat confiteri Sacerdoti Quibusdam visum est sufficere, si soli Deo fiat confessio sine judicio Sacerdotali & confessione ecclesiae. quia David dixit; Dixi Confitebor Domino, &c. non ait, Sacerdoti: & tamen remissum sibi peccatum dicit. Petr. Lombard. lib. 4. Senten• dist. 17.
dIn his enim etiam docti diversa s•ntire inveniuntur: quia super his varia ac pené adversa tradidisse videntur doctores. Ibid.
The diverse sentences of the Doctors touching this question, whether external confession were necessary or not, are at large laid down by Gratian: who in the end, leaveth the matter in suspense, and concludeth in this manner. eUpon what authorities, or upon what ⟨p. 105⟩strength of reasons both these opinions are grounded, I have briefly laid open. But to whether of them we should rather cleave to, is reserved to the judgement of the reader. For both of them have for their favourers both wise and religious men. And so the matter rested undetermined 1150. years after Christ: howsoever the Roman Correctors of Gratian do tell us, that now the case is altered, and that fit is most certain, and must be held for most certain, that the sacramental confession of mortal sins is necessary, used in that manner, and at such time, as in the Council of Trent after other Councils it is appointed. But the first Council, wherein we find any thing determined touching this necessity, is that of Lateran under Innocent the III. wherein we heard that Transubstantiation was established▪ for there it was ordayned, that gOmnis utriusque sexus sidelis, every faithful one of either sex, being come to years of discretion, should by himself alone, once in the year at least, faithfully confess his sins unto his own Priest; and endeavour according to his strength to fulfil the penance enjoined unto him, receiving reverently at least at Easter the sacrament of the Eucharist: otherwise, that both being alive he should be kept from entering into the Church, and being dead should want Christian burial. Since which determination, Thomas Aquinas (in his exposition of the text of the fourth book of the Sentences, distinct. 17.) holdeth hthe denial of the necessity of Confession unto salvation to be heresy: which before that time (saith Bonaventure, in his disputations upon the same fourth book) was not heretical, forasmuch as many ⟨p. 106⟩Catholic Doctors did hold contrary opinions therein, as appeareth by Gratian.
The diverse sentences of the Doctors touching this question, whether externall confession were necessarie or not, are at large layd downe by Gratian: who in the end, leaveth the matter in suspense, and concludeth in this maner. eVpon what authorities, or upon what ⟨p. 105⟩strength of reasons both these opinions are grounded, I have briefly layd open. But to whether of them wee should rather cleave to, is reserved to the judgement of the reader. For both of them have for their favourers both wise and religious men. And so the matter rested undetermined 1150. yeares after Christ: howsoever the Romane Correctors of Gratian doe tell us, that now the case is altered, and that fit is most certaine, and must be held for most certaine, that the sacramentall confession of mortall sinnes is necessary, used in that maner, and at such time, as in the Councell of Trent after other Councels it is appointed. But the first Councell, wherein we finde any thing determined touching this necessitie, is that of Lateran under Innocent the III. wherein wee heard that Transsubstantiation was established▪ for there it was ordayned, that gOmnis utriusque sexus sidelis, every faithfull one of eyther sex, being come to yeares of discretion, should by himselfe alone, once in the yeare at least, faithfully confesse his sinnes unto his owne Priest; and indevour according to his strength to fulfill the penance injoyned unto him, receiving reverently at least at Easter the sacrament of the Eucharist: otherwise, that both being alive hee should be kept from entring into the Church, and being dead should want Christian buriall. Since which determination, Thomas Aquinas (in his exposition of the text of the fourth booke of the Sentences, distinct. 17.) holdeth hthe deniall of the necessitie of Confession unto salvation to be heresie: which before that time (saith Bonaventure, in his disputations upon the same fourth booke) was not hereticall, forasmuch as manie ⟨p. 106⟩Catholick Doctors did hold contrarie opinions therein, as appeareth by Gratian.
eQuibus auctoritatibus, vel quibus rationū firmamentis utraque sententia innitatur, in medium breviter exposuimus. Cui autem harum potiùs adhaerendum sit, lectoris judicio reservatur. Utraque enim fautores habet sapientes, & religiosos viros, De P••ie. dist. 1. cap. 29▪ Quamvis.Quibus auctoritatibus, vel quibus rationū firmamentis utraque sententia innitatur, in medium breviter exposuimus. Cui autem harum potiùs adhaerendum sit, lectoris judicio reservatur. Vtraque enim fautores habet sapientes, & religiosos viros, De P••ie. dist. 1. cap. 29▪ Quamvis.
fCertissimum est. & pro certissimo habendum peccati mortalis necessariam esse cō fessionem sacramentalem eo modo, ac ten pore adhibitā, quo in Concilio Tridentino post alia Concilia est constitutum. Rom. Correct. ibid.Certissimum est. & pro certissimo habendum peccati mortalis necessariam esse cō fessionem sacramentalem eo modo, ac tē pore adhibitā, quo in Concilio Tridentino post alia Concilia est constitutum. Rom. C•rrect. ibid.
gOmnis utriusque sexus fidelis, postquàm ad annos discretionis pervenerit, omnia sua solus peccata confiteatur fideliter saltem semel in anno proprio sacerdoti; & injunctam sibi poenitentiam studeat pro viribus adimplere, suscipiens reverenter ad minùs in Pascha Eucharistiae sacramentum: &c. alioquin & vivens ab ingressu Ecclesiae arceatur, & moriens Christianâ careat sepulturâ. Concil. Lateran. cap 21.
hMagister & Gratianus hoc pro opinione ponunt Sed nunc post determinationem Ecclesiae sub Inn. 111. factam, haeresis reputanda est. Thom.
But Medina will not admit by any means, ithat it should be accounted strictly heresy: but would have it said, that it savours of heresy. and for this decree of Confession to be made once in the year, he saith kthat it doth not declare nor interpret any divine right of the thing, but rather appointeth the time of confessing. Durand thinketh that it may be said, that this statute containeth lan holy and wholesome exhortation of making confession, and then adjoineth a precept of the receiving of the Eucharist backed with a penalty: or if both of them be precepts, that mthe penalty respecteth only the precept of communicating (of the transgression whereof knowledge may be taken) and not the precept of confession, of the transgression whereof the Church can take no certain notice, and therefore can appoint no certain penalty for it. But howsoever; this we are sure of, that the Canonists afterward held no absolute necessity of obedience to be required therein, as unto a Sacramental institution ordained by Christ for obtaining remission of sins; but a Canonical obedience only, as unto an useful constitution of the Church. And therefore where Gratian in his first distinction de Poenitentiâ, had in the 34. chapter and the three next following, propounded the allegations which made for them who held, nthat men might obtain pardon for their sins without any oral confession of them; and then proceeded to the authorities which might ⟨p. 107⟩seem to make for the contrary opinion: Johannes Semeca at the beginning of that part, upon those words of Gratian, Alij é contrario tes•antur, putteth too this Gloss. oFrom this place until the section His auctoritatib. he allegeth for the other part, that sin is not forgiven unto such as are of years, without confession of the mouth which yet is false: saith he. But this free dealing of his did so displease Friar Manrique, who by the command of Pius Quintus, set out a censure upon the Glosses of the Canon law; that he gave direction these words, which yet is false, should be clean blotted out. which direction of his notwithstanding, the Roman Correctors under Gregory the XIII. did not follow: but letting the words still stand, give them a check only with this marginal annotation. pNay it is most true, that without confession, in desire at least, the sin is not forgiven.
But Medina will not admit by anie meanes, ithat it should be accounted strictly heresie: but would have it said, that it savours of heresie. and for this decree of Confession to be made once in the yeare, hee saith kthat it doth not declare nor interpret any divine right of the thing, but rather appointeth the time of confessing. Durand thinketh that it may be said, that this statute contayneth lan holy and wholsome exhortation of making confession, and then adjoyneth a precept of the receiving of the Eucharist backed with a penaltie: or if both of them be precepts, that mthe penaltie respecteth onely the precept of communicating (of the transgression whereof knowledge may be taken) and not the precept of confession, of the transgression whereof the Church can take no certaine notice, and therefore can appoint no certaine penaltie for it. But howsoever; this wee are sure of, that the Canonists afterward held no absolute necessitie of obedience to be required therein, as unto a Sacramentall institution ordayned by Christ for obtayning remission of sinnes; but a Canonicall obedience onely, as unto an usefull constitution of the Church. And therefore where Gratian in his first distinction de Poenitentiâ, had in the 34. chapter and the three next following, propounded the allegations which made for them who held, nthat men might obtaine pardon for their sinnes without anie orall confession of them; and then proceeded to the authorities which might ⟨p. 107⟩seeme to make for the contrarie opinion: Iohannes Semeca at the beginning of that part, upon those words of Gratian, Alij é contrario tes•antur, putteth too this Glosse. oFrom this place untill the section His auctoritatib. he alledgeth for the other part, that sinne is not forgiven unto such as are of yeares, without confession of the mouth which yet is false: saith he. But this free dealing of his did so displease Friar Manrique, who by the command of Pius Quintus, set out a censure upon the Glosses of the Canon law; that hee gave direction these words, which yet is false, should be cleane blotted out. which direction of his notwithstanding, the Romane Correctors under Gregory the XIII. did not follow: but letting the words still stand, give them a check only with this marginall annotation.
iIdeò dicendum, quòd praesata assertio non est stricté haeresis, sed sapit haeresim. Jo. Medina. tractat. 2. de Confessione, quaest. 4.Ideò dicendum, quòd praesata assertio non est stricté haeresis, sed sapit haeresim. Io. Medina. tractat. 2. de Confessione, quaest. 4.
kNam illud, quod illic dicitur de confessione semel in anno, non procedit declarando, nec divinū jus interpretā do, sed potiùs tempus confitendi instituendo. Id. ibid. quaest· 2.Nam illud, quod illic dicitur de confessione semel in anno, non procedit declarando, nec divinū jus interpretā do, sed potiùs tempus confitendi instituendo. Id. ibid. quaest· 2.
lIn quo praemittitur exhortatio sancta & salubris de cō fessione faciendâ, & subjungitur praeceptū de perceptione Eucharistiae vallatum poenâ. Durand. in lib. 4. Sentent. distinct. 17. quaest. 14.In quo praemittitur exhortatio sancta & salubris de cō fessione faciendâ, & subjungitur praeceptū de perceptione Eucharistiae vallatum poenâ. Durand. in lib. 4. Sentent. distinct. 17. quaest. 14.
mEt ob hoc posset rationabiliter videri alicui, quòd praedicta poena illius statuti respicit solum praeceptum de communione de cujus transgressione constare potest, & non praeceptum de confessione. Id. ibid.
nUnde datur intelligi, quòd etiam ore tacente, veniam consequi possumus. De Poenit. dist. 1. cap. 34. Convertimini. Vid. initium eiusd. distinct. & Glossam. ibid. verb. Sunt enim.Vnde datur intelligi, quòd etiam ore tacente, veniam consequi possumus. De Poenit. dist. 1. cap. 34. Convertimini. Vid. initium eiusd. distinct. & Glossam. ibid. verb. Sunt enim.
oAb hoc loco usque ad sect. His auctoritatib. pro aliâ part allegat, quòd scilicèt adulto peccati• non dimittitur sine oris confessione. quod tamen falsum est G•oss.Ab hoc loco usque ad sect. His auctoritatib. pro aliâ parte allegat, quòd scilicèt adulto peccati• non dimittitur sine oris confessione. quod tamen falsum est G•oss.
In like manner, where the same Semeca holdeth it to be the better opinion, that Confession was qordained by a certain tradition of the universal Church, rather then by the authority of the new or old Testament, and inferreth thereupon, that it is rnecessary among the Latins, but not among the Greeks, because that tradition did not spread to them: Friar Manrique commandeth all that passage to be blotted out, but the Roman Correctors clap this note upon the margin for an antidote. sNay confession was ordained by our Lord, and by Gods Law is necessary to all that fall into mortal sin after Baptism, as well Greeks as Latins. and for this they quote only the 14. Session of the Council of Trent: ⟨p. 108⟩where that opinion is accursed in us, which was held two or three hundred years ago by the men of their own religion. among whom, tMichael of Bononia (who was Prior general of the order of the Carmelites in the days of Pope Urban the sixth) doth conclude strongly out of their own received grounds; that confession is not necessary for the obtaining of the pardon of our sin: and Panormitan the great Canonist, uprofesseth that the opinion of Semeca doth much please him, which referreth the original of Confession to a general tradition of the Church: because (saith he) there is not any clear authority, which showeth that God or Christ did clearly ordain that Confession should be made unto a Priest. Yea, xall the Canonists, following their first Interpreter, say that Confession was brought in only by the law of the Church, and not by any divine precept: if we will believe Maldonat. who addeth notwithstanding, that ythis opinion is either already sufficiently declared by the Church to be heresy, or that the Church should do well if it did declare it to be heresy.
In like maner, where the same Semeca holdeth it to be the better opinion, that Confession was qordayned by a certaine tradition of the universall Church, rather then by the authoritie of the new or old Testament, and inferreth thereupon, that it is rnecessarie among the Latins, but not among the Greekes, because that tradition did not spread to them: Friar Manrique commandeth all that passage to be blotted out, but the Romane Correctors clap this note upon the margent for an antidote. sNay confession was ordayned by our Lord, and by Gods Law is necessary to all that fall into mortall sinne after Baptisme, as well Greekes as Latins. and for this they quote onely the 14. Session of the Councell of Trent: ⟨p. 108⟩where that opinion is accursed in us, which was held two or three hundred yeares ago by the men of their owne religion. among whom, tMichael of Bononia (who was Prior general of the order of the Carmelites in the dayes of Pope Vrban the sixth) doth conclude strongly out of their owne received grounds; that confession is not necessary for the obtayning of the pardon of our sinne: and Panormitan the great Canonist, uprofesseth that the opinion of Semeca doth much please him, which referreth the originall of Confession to a generall tradition of the Church: because (saith he) there is not anie cleare authority, which sheweth that God or Christ did clearely ordayne that Confession should be made unto a Priest. Yea, xall the Canonists, following their first Interpreter, say that Confession was brought in onely by the law of the Church, and not by anie divine precept: if we will beleeve Maldonat. who addeth notwithstanding, that ythis opinion is eyther alreadie sufficiently declared by the Church to be heresie, or that the Church should doe well if it did declare it to be heresie.
qMeliùs dicitur ea• institutam fuisse à quadam universalis Ecclesiae tradition, potiùs quàm ex novi v•l veteris Testamē ti auctoritate, Gloss. de Poenitent. init. distinct. 5. In poenitentia.Meliùs dicitur ea• institutam fuisse à quadam universalis Ecclesiae traditione, potiùs quàm ex novi v•l veteris Testamē ti auctoritate, Gloss. de Poenitēt. init. distinct. 5. In poenitentia.
rErgo necessaria est confessio in mortalibus apud nos, apud Graecos non: quia non emanavit apud illos traditio talis Ibid.
sImò confessio est instituta à Domino, & est omnibus post Baptismum lapsis in mortale peccatū, tam Graecis quàm Latinis, jure divino necessaria. Rom. Correct. ibid. in marg.Imò confessio est instituta à Domino, & est omnibus post Baptismum lapsis in mortale peccatū, tam Graecis quàm Latinis, jure divino necessaria. Rom. Correct. ibid. in marg.
uMultùm mihi placet illa opinio: quia nō est aliqua authoritas aperta, quae innuat Deū seu Christum aperté instituisse confessionem fiendā Sacerdoti. Panorm. in 5. Decretal. de Poenit. & remiss. cap. 12. Omnis utriusque. sect. 18.Multùm mihi placet illa opinio: quia nō est aliqua authoritas aperta, quae innuat Deū seu Christum aperté instituisse confessionem fiendā Sacerdoti. Panorm. in 5. Decretal. de Poenit. & remiss. cap. 12. Omnis utriusque. sect. 18.
xOmnes juris Pontificii periti, secuti primū suum Interpretem, dicunt Confessionem tantùm esse introductam jure Ecclesiastico. Maldonat. Disp. de Sacrament. Tom. 2. de Confess. orig. cap. 2.Omnes juris Pontificii periti, secuti primū suum Interpretem, dicunt Confessionem tantùm esse introductam jure Ecclesiastico. Maldonat. Disp. de Sacrament. Tom. 2. de Confess. orig. cap. 2.
ySed tamen haec opinio, aut jam declarata est satis tanquā haeresis ab Ecclesiâ; aut faceret Ecclesia operae pretium, si declararet esse haeresim. Id. ibid. de praecepto Confess. cap 3.
And we find indeed, that in the year of our Lord 1479. (which was 34. years after the death of Panormitan) by a special commission directed from Pope Sixtus the fourth unto Alfonsus Carillus Archbishop of Toledo, one Petrus Oxomensis, professor of Divinity in the University of Salamanca, was driven to abjure zthis conclusion, which he had before delivered as agreeable to the common opinion of the Doctors; that confession of sins in particular was grounded upon some statute of the universal Church, and not upon ⟨p. 109⟩divine right. and when learned men for all this would not take warning, but would needs be meddling again with that which the Popish Clergy could not endure should be touched, (as Johannes de Selva, among others, in the end of his treatise de Jurejurando; Erasmus in diverse of his works, and Beatus Rhenanus in his argument upon Tertullians book de Poenitentiâ:) the fathers of Trent within 72. years after that, conspired together to stop all mens mouths with *an anathema, that should deny sacramental confession to be of divine institution or to be necessary unto salvation. And so we are come to an end of that point.
And we finde indeed, that in the yeare of our Lord 1479. (which was 34. yeares after the death of Panormitan) by a speciall commission directed from Pope Sixtus the fourth unto Alfonsus Carillus Archbishop of Toledo, one Petrus Oxomensis, professor of Divinitie in the Vniversitie of Salamanca, was driven to abjure zthis conclusion, which hee had before delivered as agreeable to the common opinion of the Doctors; that confession of sinnes in particular vvas grounded upon some statute of the universall Church, and not upon ⟨p. 109⟩divine right. and when learned men for all this would not take warning, but would needs be medling againe with that which the Popish Clergie could not indure should be touched, (as Iohannes de Selva, among others, in the end of his treatise de Iurejurando; Erasmus in diverse of his workes, and Beatus Rhenanus in his argument upon Tertullians booke de Poenitentiâ:) the fathers of Trent within 72. yeares after that, conspired together to stop all mens mouthes with *an anathema, that should denie sacramentall confession to be of divine institution or to be necessarie unto salvation. And so we are come to an end of that point.
zQuòd confessio de peccatis in specie suerit ex aliquo statuto universalis Ecclesiae, non de jure divino. Congregat. Complutens. sub Alfonso Carillo: apud Ca•ranzam in Summâ Concil. sub Sixto IV.
Let these things be taken away, which are eyther fictions of lying men, or wonders wrought by evill spirits. For eyther there is no truth in these reports, or if there be any strange things done by hereticks, we ought the more to beware of them:
p
Removean•ur ista vel figmenta mendacium hominū, vel portenta fallacium spirituū. Aut enim non sunt vera quae dicuntur, aut si haereticorum aliqua mira facta sunt, magis cavere debemus: quòd cùm dixisset Dominus quosdā futuros esse fallaces, qui nonnulla signa faciendo etiam electos si fieri posset fallerent; adjecit vehementer commendans, & ait, Ecce praedixi vobis. August. de unitat. Eccles. cap. 16.Removean•ur ista vel figmenta mendacium hominū, vel portenta fallacium spirituū. Aut enim non sunt vera quae dicuntur, aut si haereticorum aliqua mira facta sunt, magis cavere debemus: quòd cùm dixisset Dominus quosdā futuros esse fallaces, qui nonnulla signa faciendo etiam electos si fieri posset fallerent; adjecit vehementer commendans, & ait, Ecce praedixi vobis. August. de unitat. Eccles. cap. 16.
the bread and the wine are the body and blood of Christ figuratively; that
Yet he had not then suffered: but so notwithstanding hee turned through invisible vertue, the bread to his owne body, and that wine to his blood:
c
Illa namque caro quae c•ucifixa est, de Virginis carne facta est, ossibus & nervis compacta, & humanorum membrorum lineamentis distincta, rationalis animae spiritu vivificata in propriam vitam & congruentes motus. At veró caro spiritualis, quae populum credentem spiritualiter pascit, secundùm speciem quam gerit exteriùs, frumenti granis manu artificis consistit, nullis nervis ossibusque compacta, nullâ membrorum varietate distincta, nullâ rationally substantiâ vegetata, nullos proprios potens motus exercere. Quicquid enim in eâ vitae praebet substantiam, spiritualis est potentiae, & invisibilis efficientiae, divinaeque vi•tutis. Ibid. pag. 214.Illa namque caro quae c•ucifixa est, de Virginis carne facta est, ossibus & nervis compacta, & humanorum membrorum lineamentis distincta, rationalis animae spiritu vivificata in propriam vitam & congruentes motus. At veró caro spiritualis, quae populum credentem spiritualiter pascit, secundùm speciem quam gerit exteriùs, frumenti granis manu artificis consistit, nullis nervis ossibusque compacta, nullâ membrorum varietate distincta, nullâ rationali substantiâ vegetata, nullos proprios potens motus exercere. Quicquid enim in eâ vitae praebet substantiam, spiritualis est potentiae, & invisibilis efficientiae, divinaeque vi•tutis. Ibid. pag. 214.
dCorpus Christi quod mortuum est & resurrexit, & immortale factum, jam non moritur, & mors illi ultrà non dominabitur, aeternum est, nec jam passibile. Hoc autem quod in Ecclesiâ celebratur, temporale est, non aeternum; corruptibile est, non incorruptum, &c. dispartitur ad sumendum, & dentibus commolitum, in corpus trajicitur. Ibid. pag. 216.217.
eEt hoc corpus, pignus est & species: illud veró ipsa veritas. Hoc enim geritur, donec ad illud perveniatur: ubi veró ad illud perventum fuerit, hoc removebitur. Ib. pag. 222.
fVidemus nondū passum esse Christum, &c. Sicut ergo paulò antequàm pateretur, panis substantiam & vini creaturam converter potuit in propriū corpus quod passurum erat, & in suum sanguinē qui pòst fundendus extabat: sic etiā in deserto manna & aquam de petrâ in suam carnē & sanguinem converter praevaluit &c. Ibid. pag. 193.Videmus nondū passum esse Christum, &c. Sicut ergo paulò antequàm pateretur, panis substantiam & vini creaturam convertere potuit in propriū corpus quod passurum erat, & in suum sanguinē qui pòst fundendus extabat: sic etiā in deserto manna & aquam de petrâ in suam carnē & sanguinem convertere praevaluit &c. Ibid. pag. 193.
And this is not only wonderfull, that he forgiveth us our sinnes, but that he neither discovereth them, nor maketh them open and manifest, nor constraineth us to come forth in publike and disclose our misdemeanours; but commandeth us to give an account thereof unto him alone, and unto him to make confession of them.
q[Greek or Hebrew]. Id. in [Greek or Hebrew] ad pop. Antiochen. homil 2•. •om. 6. Savil. pag. 608.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Id. in 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 ad pop. Antiochen. homil 2•. •om. 6. Savil. pag. 608.
I do not confesse with my lips, that I may manifest my selfe unto many. but inwardly in my very heart, shutting mine eyes, to thee alone who seest the things that are in secret, doe I shew my groanes, roaring within my selfe.
•
xAttend quanta sit indulgentiae vitalis velocitas, quan•a misericordiae Dei commendatio: ut confitentis desiderium comitetur venia, antequàm ad cruciatum perveniat poenitentia; antè remissio ad cor perveniat, quàm confessio in vocem •rumpat. Gregor. exposit. 2. Psal. Poenit•ntia all.Attende quanta sit indulgentiae vitalis velocitas, quan•a misericordiae Dei commendatio: ut confitentis desiderium comitetur venia, antequàm ad cruciatum perveniat poenitentia; antè remissio ad cor perveniat, quàm confessio in vocem •rumpat. Gregor. exposit. 2. Psal. Poenit•ntia al.
y[Greek or Hebrew]. Basil. in Psalm. 37.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Basil. in Psalm. 37.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉, &c. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Greg. Nyssen. de Poenitent. in Operū Appendice, edit. Paris. an. 1618. pag. 175.176.
Certé periculum ejus tunc si fortè onerosum est, cùm penes insultaturos in risiloquio consistit, ubi de alterius ruinâ alter attollitur, ubi prostrato superscenditur. Caeterùm inter fratres atque cons•rvos, ubi communis spes, metus, gaudium, dolor, passio: quid tuos aliud quàm te opinaris? Quid consortes casuum tuorum, ut plausores fugis? Non potest corpus de unius membri vexatione laetum agere: Tertullian. de Poenitent. cap 9.
Quidā solummodò Deo confiteri debere dicunt peccata, quidā veró Sacerdotibus confitenda esse percensent: quod utrunque non sine magno fructu intra sanctam fit Ecclesiā ita duntaxat, ut & Deo, qui remissor est peccatorū, confiteamur peccata nostra, (& cum David dicamus: Delictū meū cognitū tibi feci, & injustitiā meam non abscondi, Dixi, Confitebor adversùm me injustitias meas Domino, & tu remisisti impietatē peccati mei.) et secundùm institutionē Apostoli, confiteamur alterutrū peccata nostra, & oremus pro invicem ut salvemur. Confessio itaque quae Deo fit, purgat peccata: ea veró quae Sacerdoti fit, docet qualiter ipsa purgentur peccata. Deus namque salutis & sanitatis author & largitor, plerunque hanc praebet suae potentiae invisibili administration, plerunque Medicorū operation. Ibid. cap. 33
Quidā solūmodò Deo cōfiteri debere dicūt peccata, quidā veró Sacerdotibus confitēda esse percensent: quod utrūque non sine magno fructu intra sanctam fit Ecclesiā ita duntaxat, ut & Deo, qui remissor est peccatorū, confiteamur peccata nostra, (& cum David dicamus: Delictū meū cognitū tibi feci, & injustitiā meam non abscōdi, Dixi, Cōfitebor adversùm me injustitias meas Domino, & tu remisisti impietatē peccati mei.) et secundùm institutionē Apostoli, cōfiteamur alterutrū peccata nostra, & oremus pro invicem ut salvemur. Confessio itaque quae Deo fit, purgat peccata: ea veró quae Sacerdoti fit, docet qualiter ipsa purgētur peccata. Deus namque salutis & sanitatis author & largitor, plerūque hāc praebet suae potētiae invisibili administratione, plerūque Medicorū operatione. Ibid. cap. 33
Nay it is most true, that without confession, in desire at least, the sinne is not forgiven.
Imó verissimum sine confessione in voto non dimitti peccatum. Rom. Correct. ibid. in marg.
Sed tamen haec opinio, aut jam declarata est satis tanquā haeresis ab Ecclesiâ; aut faceret Ecclesia operae pretium, si declararet esse haeresim. Id. ibid. de praecepto Confess. cap 3.