D. Martyr. Your answer standeth upon many chief points; I will reply to every one by it self. First, whereas you say; It sufficeth that it is bread and wine before consecration, by which substances we be nourished, it proveth not, but that in the sacrament it self the conveniency is by you taken away. For we speak not of the sacrament, when it is now a sacrament, where also we affirm, that the analogy must be kept. You appoint the same to be before the sacrament; and when ye come to the sacrament, you take it away, and so ye sin against the sacrament. 1Doubtless in baptism it fareth not after that manner: for by the water, wherewith we be commonly washed, is signified the purging of the soul; neither is the water taken away. No; but it remaineth, and we are washed therewith: and if it were taken away, it should be no full sacrament. And therefore it is not enough to say, that before consecration, there was a due matter extant. Again, the saying, which you allege out of Augustine; The word cometh to the element, 2and is made a sacrament, doth make most of all against you: for he saith not; It thrusteth out the element, but it cometh to the element; and the meaning is, that the element it self is made a sacrament. The very same mercy, which you say is given us by reason of the accidents, that in them may be hidden the body of Christ, least while it is seen, it should cause a loathing thereof; even the same, I say, we have by the remaining of bread and wine. For accustomed natures are not loathsome to us. And whereas you affirm, that the accidents or shows do lead us unto that similitude, it doth not satisfy. First, because that, which you speak of accidents is a feigned thing. Secondly, because that must remain, which nourisheth us naturally: which accidents do not perform. For a sacrament must signify the matter of the sacrament, but not a substance that had been, which ye say it hath cast away. Lastly, you allege no cause, why ye extrude the bread. Oftentimes yesterday did I ask, why? But could hear nothing: perhaps you will assign a cause.
D. Martyr. Your answer standeth vpon manie chéefe points; I will replie to euerie one by it selfe. First, whereas you saie; It sufficeth that it is bread and wine before consecration, by which substances we be nourished, it prooueth not, but that in the sacrament it selfe the conueniencie is by you taken awaie. For we speake not of the sacrament, when it is now a sacrament, where also we affirme, that the analogie must be kept. You appoint the same to be before the sacrament; and when ye come to the sacrament, you take it awaie, and so ye sinne against the sacrament. 1Doubtlesse in baptisme it fareth not after that maner: for by the water, wherewith we be commonlie washed, is signified the purging of the soule; neither is the water taken awaie. No; but it remaineth, and we are washed therewith: and if it were taken awaie, it should be no full sacrament. And therefore it is not enough to saie, that before consecration, there was a due matter extant. Againe, the saieng, which you alledge out of Augustine; The word commeth to the element, 2and is made a sacrament, dooth make most of all against you: for he saith not; It thrusteth out the element, but it commeth to the element; and the meaning is, that the element it selfe is made a sacrament. The verie same mercie, which you saie is giuen vs by reason of the accidents, that in them may be hidden the bodie of Christ, least while it is séene, it should cause a lothing thereof; euen the same, I saie, we haue by the remaining of bread and wine. For accustomed natures are not loathsome to vs. And whereas you affirme, that the accidents or shewes doo lead vs vnto that similitude, it dooth not satisfie. First, bicause that, which you speake of accidents is a feigned thing. Secondlie, bicause that must remaine, which nourisheth vs naturallie: which accidents doo not performe. For a sacrament must signifie the matter of the sacrament, but not a substance that had béene, which ye saie it hath cast awaie. Lastlie, you alledge no cause, why ye extrude the bread. Oftentimes yesterdaie did I aske, why? But could heare nothing: perhaps you will assigne a cause.
- 1In baptism is kept an analogy, because water remaineth.In baptism is kept an analogie, bicause water remaineth.
- 2If the word come unto the element it doth not thrust it out.If the word come vnto the element it dooth not thrust it out.