The disputation of the fourth day, made between D. William Chadse, wherein he opposed D. Peter Martyr, the first day of June.The disputation of the fourth daie, made betweene D. VVilliam Chadse, wherein he opposed D. Peter Martyr, the first daie of Iune.
pp. 228–250134 passagespart 2 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
D. Martyr. It was his very body and his very flesh, but yet it was given by signification.
D. Martyr. It was his verie bodie and his verie flesh, but yet it was giuen by signification.
D. Chadse. He gave his flesh, which hung upon the cross, and that body which was crucified; but it hung not spiritually upon the cross, neither was natural bread crucified: wherefore that bread in the sixth of John is not understood metaphorically, but must be understood to be the real flesh of Christ.
D. Chadse. He gaue his flesh, which hoong vpon the crosse, and that bodie which was crucified; but it hoong not spirituallie vpon the crosse, neither was naturall bread crucified: wherefore that bread in the sixt of Iohn is not vnderstood metaphoricallie, but must be vnderstood to be the reall flesh of Christ.
D. Martyr. You huddle up many things, which I must unfold, that I may deny the false, and grant those that be true. I have already said, and now I say again, that you use an equivocation; seeing for a metaphorical bread, you always oppose unto me the bread given by Christ in the last supper, the which was true and natural bread, and a sign of this allegorical bread, that is, of the flesh of Christ. Howbeit, 1I never granted you, nor yet will grant, that Christ in John promised a signifying bread, but such a bread, as being taken metaphorically, is even all one with flesh. And in the last supper he gave this allegorical bread; that is, his flesh to be eaten spiritually. And he not only stood to his promises, but he gave more than he promised, by adding of the signs. And that, which you would prove in your argument; to wit, that the body of Christ hung not upon the cross spiritually, and that natural bread was not crucified, or given for us, is of no importance. Insomuch as the words of Christ do sufficiently bear record, that the body of Christ is otherwise eaten of us, and was otherwise crucified; because the Lord would have this to be a spiritual eating, seeing that he called the Capernaites from a carnal eating. Verily to hang upon the cross, and to die, were natural actions. Wherefore you offend in the argument, by going from the substance to the quality, and from the thing it self to the manner. So as we grant, that the body of Christ is eaten of the communicants, but yet not after the same manner that it hung upon the cross. And I marvel that you object this, who would not grant, that Christ was so crucified, as you appoint him to be covered under your forms.