WILLIAM WHITAKERS. The answer to the tenth Reason, which is all manner of Witnesses.WILLIAM WHITAKERS. The answere to the tenth Reason, which is all manner of Witnesses.
pp. 299–32325 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Campian, you are now low drawn and do plainly bewray your want and desperate beggary. Hitherto have you found no place of sure footing, and therefore now you have resolved to wander and run thorough whatsoever is in the world. So one while you fly aloft into heaven, by and by you slip down to hell: after you visit the Jews, Pagans, Turks, Heretics, Lands, Seas Apostolic, Nations and Countries far remote, searching diligently for any monument of your superstition. I am sorry and ashamed on your behalf, whom I see painfully busied about mere trifles. For what a witless kind of reasoning is this; first to reckon up the Saints in Heaven, and say, these are ours? Then to number up the damned, Jews, Gentiles, Turks, Heretics, and affirm those are the enemies of our Church? To rehearse those Countries that have been converted to the faith of Christ, and conclude by and by, these are of our Religion? would you take this man to be well in his wits, compassing Heaven, Earth and Hell so childishly,
ridiculously, and impertinently taking unto himself, what he liketh, and rejecting the rest? A worthy cavil, fit for none but Jesuits, which when
⟨p. 300⟩
a man hath by one negative discharged, can never be proved by their perverse sect and whole society. These dreams of yours (Campian) are unworthy any answer, one word of denial confutes this whole Chapter. I will not bestow much time in answering this Sophism, so unhandsomely framed, and patched together; it shall suffice lightly to pass, and only touch every thing in a word. First therefore you allege the prophecy of Isaiah, of a straight way wherein the simple should not err.
Here the Prophet describes the entrance into Christs Church, viz. that it should be ready, plain and easy. But this way brings us not to your Church: c for of this way the Prophet reports, that no profane man, no Lion or cruel beast shall be found in it; whereas all your ways are compassed with polluted men, raging beasts, Lions, Bears, Leopards, Dragons, Devils; and in conclusion, they lead miserably bewitched men, unto woeful destruction. As for us, we tread that way, which Christ and his Apostles have traced out before us, we avoid your erroneous and strange ways, because
⟨p. 301⟩
it is the way of sinners, that you s•••d in; which way whosoever tread•,
CAmpian, you are now low drawn and doe plainely bewray your want and desperate beggerie. Hitherto haue you found no place of sure footing, and therefore now you haue resolued to wander and runne thorough whatsoeuer is in the world. So one while you flie alost into heauen, by and by you slippe downe to hell: after you visit the Iewes, Pagans, Turkes, Heretikes, Lands, Seas Apostolike, Nations and Countries farre remote, searching diligently for any monument of your superstition. I am sorrie and ashamed on your behalfe, whom I see painefully busied about meere trifles. For what a witles kinde of reasoning is this; first to recken vp the Saints in Heauen, and say, these are ours? Then to number vp the damned, Iewes, Gentiles, Turkes, Heretikes, and affirme those are the enemies of our Church? To rehearse those Countries that haue been conuerted to the faith of Christ, and conclude by and by, these are of our Religion? would you take this man to bee well in his wits, compassing Heauen, Earth and Hell so childishly,a ridiculouslie, and impertinently taking vnto himselfe, what he liketh, and reiecting the rest? A worthie cauil, fit for none but Iesuites, which when ⟨p. 300⟩a man hath by one negatiue discharged, can neuer be proued by their peruerse sect and whole societie. These dreames of yours (Campian) are vnworthie any answere, one word of denial confutes this whole Chapter. I will not bestow much time in answering this Sophisme, so vnhansomely framed, and patched together; it shall suffice lightly to passe, and only touch euery thing in a word. First therefore you alledge the prophecie of Esay, of a straight way wherein the simple should not erre. bHeere the Prophet describes the entrance into Christs Church, viz. that it should be ready, plaine and easie. But this way brings vs not to your Church: c for of this way the Prophet reports, that no prophane man, no Lion or cruell beast shall be found in it; whereas all your waies are compassed with polluted men, raging beasts, Lions, Beares, Leopards, Dragons, Diuels; and in conclusion, they leade miserably bewitched men, vnto wofull destruction. As for vs, we treade that way, which Christ and his Apostles haue traced out before vs, wee auoyde your erroneous and strange waies, because ⟨p. 301⟩it is the way of sinners, that you s•••d in; which way whosoeuer tread•,3 the way of pe•ce they haue not knowne.
aDVR. Jf here he any thing ridiculous, then may you laugh at the Prophet, who a• speedily runs over the whole world. And S. Paul took a testimony for a truth out of the beathen Poet, Act. 17.2•. WHIT. pag. 856. Who knoweth not that God may be known by his creatures, & religion illustrated by nature uncorrupt? but what nature, I pray you, hath taught Camptā thus to judge of the heavenly spirits and the damned souls, and of the whole fr•me of things? can he learn by nature that those who have professed the Popish religion, do now enjoy heavenly happiness, and that they who dislike it are tormented in hell? These weapons of Campian were those that impure Symmachus opposed Christian religion withal, Ambros. Epist. 30. Prudent. contra Symmachum.DVR. Jf heere he any thing ridiculous, then may you laugh at the Prophet, vvho a• speedily runnes ouer the whole world. And S. Paul tooke a testimony for a truth out of the beathen Poet, Act. 17.2•. WHIT. pag. 856. Who knoweth not that God may be knowne by his creatures, & religion illustrated by nature vncorrupt? but what nature, I pray you, hath taught Camptā thus to iudge of the heauenly spirits and the damned soules, and of the whole fr•me of things? can he learne by nature that those who haue professed the Popish religion, doe novv enioy heauenly happines, and that they who dislike it are tormented in hell? These weapons of Campian were those that impure Symmachus opposed Christian religion withall, Ambros. Epist. 30. Prudent. contra Symmachum.
bDVR. You show your ignorance in the Prophet; for he speaketh not of the way to the Church, but of the Church it self, which is the high way to heaven. WHIT. pag. 857. Howsoever you interpret the way, it maketh neither much for me, nor for you. The question is who shall find out that way and walk in it, for it is not discerned of all, because it is a plain way, nor held of all, because it is a right way: but he that hath learned Christ is he that walketh in this way without any error, though he be but silly and unskilful. DVR. Jf this be so, then can it not be the true Church, which containeth sinners and men polluted. And the Fathers by this place exclude only those who are not cleansed by Baptism. WHIT. pag. 858. The Prophet speaketh of the Church of the elect and Saints, because he saith vers. 8. The polluted shall not pass by it: and vers. 20. the redeemed only, whose joy shall be everlasting: but the visible Church containeth those which are impure, whom Christ hath not redeemed, and whose joy shall perish. As for Baptism it purgeth none but such as lay hold of the promise of free justification by Christ, as Tit. 3.5.DVR. You shew your ignorance in the Prophet; for he speaketh not of the way to the Church, but of the Church it selfe, vvhich is the high way to heauen. WHIT. pag. 857. Howsoeuer you interpret the way, it maketh neither much for me, nor for you. The question is who shall find out that way and walke in it, for it is not discerned of all, because it is a plaine way, nor held of all, because it is a right way: but he that hath learned Christ is he that walketh in this way without any error, though he be but sillie and vnskilfull. DVR. Jf this be so, then can it not be the true Church, which conteineth sinners and men polluted. And the Fathers by this place exclude only those who are not clensed by Baptisme. WHIT. pag. 858. The Prophet speaketh of the Church of the elect and Saints, because he saith vers. 8. The polluted shall not passe by it: and vers. 20. the redeemed only, whose ioy shall be euerlasting: but the visible Church conteineth those which are impure, whom Christ hath not redeemed, and whose ioy shall perish. As for Baptisme it purgeth none but such as lay hold of the promise of free iustification by Christ, as Tit. 3.5.
Let us (say you) as•••d into heaven: I fear you Jesuits have no place there, Heaven is for Christians, not Jesuits. But suppose your selves for the time to be in heaven, what followeth? Let us behold (say you) the Martyrs▪ 33. Bishops of Rome slain together, the Universal Pastors, companies of the faithful, all holy Saints. Well, survey (Campian) heaven it self, and all the heavenly host, look well in all the parts, and coasts of it whiles you list, you shall not find there (upon my word) one Jesuit not one Papist; for none shall stand in Mount Zion with the Lamb,1 that have received the mark of the beast, or belong unto Antichrist. But in heaven are 33. Bishops of Rome, and many more, I doubt not; but of all these, name me one, if you can, of your religion, whom you may justly claim as yours. Those were holy and faithful Bishops which shed their blood for the name of Christ. But your Popes for these many hundred years, what else have they done, but persecuted Christ, and murdered his true servants? If those 33. Bishops be in heaven (as doubtless they are) how many late Popes could I reckon up, which possibly cannot be where they are, in all things they are so unlike them? You pick out a few, let us see who these are: Ignatius, say you, was ours; why I pray you? He thought no man equal to the Bishop in causes ecclesiastical, not the King himself, and left in writing certain Apostolic traditions; neither say we that any man is to be compared with the Bishop in such things as belong to his office:d He only ought to oversee ⟨p. 302⟩holy things, viz. instruction of the people, administration of the Sacraments, use of the keys of the kingdom of heaven. These are matters of great weight, and exceed the kingly authority; yet are Kings above Bishops in wealth, honour, government, majesty, and they may lawfully both admonish them of their duty, and restrain them when they offend. If Bishops herein would equal themselves with Kings it were too intolerable. As for the Apostles traditions which Ignatius hath left in writing, we receive them so far as they agree with the Apostolical Scripture: if they dissent from those, we refuse them. The Epistles of Ignatius were most of them counterfeit, as every man may see: here you rehearse many, and still the undersong is, these are ours:
Let vs (say you) as•••d into heauen: I feare you Iesuites haue no place there, Heauen is for Christians, not Iesuites. But suppose your selues for the time to be in heauen, what followeth? Let vs behold (say you) the Martyrs▪ 33. Bishops of Rome slaine together, the Vniuersall Pastors, companies of the faithfull, all holie Saints. Well, suruey (Campian) heauen it selfe, and all the heauenly host, looke well in all the parts, and coasts of it whiles you list, you shall not find there (vpon my word) one Iesuit not one Papist; for none shall stand in Mount Zion with the Lamb,1 that haue receiued the marke of the beast, or belong vnto Antichrist. But in heauen are 33. Bishops of Rome, and many more, I doubt not; but of all these, name me one, if you can, of your religion, whom you may iustly claime as yours. Those were holy and faithfull Bishops which shed their bloud for the name of Christ. But your Popes for these many hundred yeares, what else haue they done, but persecuted Christ, and murthered his true seruants? If those 33. Bishops be in heauen (as doubtlesse they are) how many late Popes could I recken vp, which possibly cannot be where they are, in all things they are so vnlike them? You pick out a few, let vs see who these are: Ignatius, say you, was ours; why I pray you? He thought no man equall to the Bishop in causes ecclesiasticall, not the King himselfe, and left in writing certaine Apostolike traditions; neither say we that any man is to be compared with the Bishop in such things as belong to his office:d He only ought to ouersee ⟨p. 302⟩holy things, viz. instruction of the people, administration of the Sacraments, vse of the keyes of the kingdome of heauen. These are matters of great weight, and exceed the kingly authority; yet are Kings aboue Bishops in wealth, honor, gouernment, maiestie, and they may lawfully both admonish them of their dutie, and restraine them when they offend. If Bishops herein would equall themselues with Kings it were too intolerable. As for the Apostles traditions which Ignatius hath left in writing, we receiue them so farre as they agree with the Apostolicall Scripture: if they dissent from those, we refuse them. The Epistles of Ignatius were most of them counterfet, as euery man may see: heere you rehearse many, and still the vndersong is, these are ours:
dDVR. If these be so proper to Bishops, that they cannot belong to Kings, then, you being judge, the Queen cannot be the head of the English Church. WHIT. pag. 160. We acknowledge no other head of the Church save Christ. And Prince though they may not do any of th•se […], yet they rule overthem, who do and ought to command them, diligently to execute their offices; which if they neglect, they ought to reprove, compel, and punish them, as we read the good Kings of the Church Jewish and Christian have ever done: and the reason hath no force, Princes have no authority to preach, therefore they have no authority to punish those who teach false doctrine to their people.DVR. If these be so proper to Bishops, that they cannot belong to Kings, then, you being iudge, the Queene cannot be the head of the English Church. WHIT. pag. 160. We acknowledge no other head of the Church saue Christ. And Prince though they may not do any of th•se 〈…〉, yet they rule ouerthem, who doe and ought to command them, diligently to execute their offices; which if they neglect, they ought to reproue, compell, and punish them, as we reade the good Kings of the Church Iewish and Christian haue euer done: and the reason hath no force, Princes haue no authoritie to preach, therefore they haue no authority to punish those who teach false doctrine to their people.
Telesphorus (say you) Ireneus, Victor, Polycarp, Cornelius, Cyprian, Sixtus, Laurentius, are ours. But I affirm that all these do belong unto us: let us then consider how you will persuade us they are yours.
Telesphorus (say you) Ireneus, Victor, Polycarp, Cornelius, Cyprian, Sixtus, Laurentius, are ours. But I affirme that all these do belong vnto vs: let vs then consider how you will perswade vs they are yours.
Telesphorus enjoined a more strict observation of Lent fast, appointed by the Apostles. eI deny that the ⟨p. 303⟩Apostles ordained any such Lenten fast, or that Telesphorus, commanded a more precise observation thereof. The Apostles were far from ordaining, and Telesph•rus from reviving so great superstition.
Telesphorus enioyned a more strict obseruation of Lent fast, appointed by the Apostles. eI deny that the ⟨p. 303⟩Apostles ordeined any such Len•en fast, or that Telesphorus, commaunded a more precise obseruation thereof. The Apostles were farre from ordeining, and Telesph•rus from reuiuing so great superstition.
eDVR. But J prove it by these witnesses, Augustine, Hierome, Basil, Ambrose, Epiphanius, Clemen•. WHIT. pag. 862. And I prove the contrary by the Fathers. August. Epist. •6. writeth plainly that neither Christ not his Apostles ordained any certain time for fastings. And so not Lent. Tertul. aduer. Psychicos: In times past Christians indifferently fasted, of their own free will, as every mans time and occasions required, and not by any command of new government. Doth not this overthrow the necessary observation of Lent? Chryso. in Mat. hom 47. freely confesseth that Christ did not command us to imitate his fast. But what is Lent but an imitation of it? Further, Montanus was the first who brought up set solemn days of fastings, Euseb. lib. 5. cap. 17. Finally, Ireneus in Eusebius lib. 5. cap. 26. showeth that in the Primitive Church, there was great variety about the keeping of this fast, and that this difference began not in his time only, but was long before. Therefore it is false that Christ and his Apostles appointed the fast of Forty days.DVR. But J proue it by these witnesses, Augustine, Hierome, Basil, Ambrose, Epiphanius, Clemen•. WHIT. pag. 862. And I proue the contrary by the Fathers. August. Epist. •6. writeth plainely that neither Christ not his Apostles ordained any certaine time for fastings. And so not Lent. Tertul. aduer. Psychicos: In times past Christiās indifferently fasted, of their owne free will, as euery mans time and occasions required, and not by any cōmand of new gouernmēt. Doth not this ouerthrow the necessary obseruatiō of Lent? Chryso. in Mat. hom 47. freely confesseth that Christ did not command vs to imitate his fast. But what is Lent but an imitation of it? Further, Montanus was the first who brought vp set solemne daies of fastings, Euseb. lib. 5. cap. 17. Finally, Ireneus in Eusebius lib. 5. cap. 26. sheweth that in the Primitiue Church, there was great variety about the keeping of this fast, and that this difference began not in his time only, but was long before. Therefore it is false that Christ and his Apostles appointed the fast of Fortie daies.
Clemens his Constitutions where this is reported, are not sufficient authority. But if this fast were prescribed by the Apostles, I wonder how afterwards it was discontinued, so as it should be necessary for Telesphorus to enjoin the keeping of it more precisely, especially seeing such strife was in the Church about the celebration of Easter. The epistle of Telesphorus wherein he commands the 7. weeks fast, hath the same authority with the rest of your decretal epistles of your Pope, which were not framed by the most holy Bishops themselves, but coined since by the most impudent Parasites of the church of Rome.1 Ireneus (say you) declared the Apostolic faith from the succession and sea of Rome. So he might well then: for as Ireneus elsewhere saith, They retained with the succession of Bishops, the gracious succession of truth: for succession is nothing worth without truth. Your Chair and Sea hath Bishoply succession; it hath not the succession of truth. Victor (say you) by his edict subdued Asia. He endeavoured it indeed (Campian) but failed of his purpose: for being a man very passionate, he would needs excommunicate all such Churches of Asia as refused to keep Easter according to the Roman custom. When he began thus insolently to abuse his authority,f Ireneus tamed and restrained him. As for the controversy about Easter, Victor was so far from composing and ending it, that it continued unto theg Council ⟨p. 304⟩cell of Nice. You may see how well Victor subduer all Asia.
Clemens his Constitutions where this is reported, are not sufficient authoritie. But if this fast were prescribed by the Apostles, I wonder how afterwards it was discontinued, so as it should bee necessarie for Telesphorus to enioyn the keeping of it more precisely, especially seeing such strife was in the Church about the celebration of Easter. The epistle of Telesphorus wherein he commaunds the 7. weekes fast, hath the same authority with the rest of your decretall epistles of your Pope, which were not framed by the most holy Bishops themselues, but coyned since by the most impudent Parasites of the church of Rome.1 Ireneus (say you) declared the Apostolike faith from the succession and sea of Rome. So he might well then: for as Ireneus elsewhere saith, They retained with the succession of Bishops, the gratious succession of truth: for succession is nothing worth without truth. Your Chaire and Sea hath Bishoply succession; it hath not the succession of truth. Victor (say you) by his edict subdued Asia. He endeuored it indeed (Campian) but failed of his purpose: for being a man very passionate, he would needs excommunicate all such Churches of Asia as refused to keepe Easter according to the Romane custome. When he began thus insolently to abuse his authority,f Ireneus tamed and restrained him. As for the controuersie about Easter, Victor was so farre from composing and ending it, that it cōtinued vnto theg Councell ⟨p. 304⟩cell of Nice. You may see how well Victor subduer all Asia.
1Jren. lib. 4. cap. 43.
fDVR. Neither Ireneus nor any other denied to Pope Victor this power to excommunicate the Churches of Asia. WHIT. pag. 863. But Eusebius writeth lib. 5. cap. 25. that both Ireneus and many other Catholic Bishops sharply reproved him for assuming that power.DVR. Neither Ireneus nor any other denied to Pope Victor this power to excommunicate the Churches of Asia. WHIT. pag. 863. But Eusebius wri•eth lib. 5. cap. 25. that both Ireneus and many other Catholike Bishops sharpely reproued him for assuming that power.
gDVR By the same reason you may say the Councels decree prevailed nothing to endi••• controversy. WHIT. pag. 864. The reason is good, & proveth that when he could prevail neither by examples, reasons, nor threatenings, that those Churches did not account Pope Victor for the head of the Church. And though after that Councell of Nice, some Churches observed the Passover after another manner, yet the most Churches followed the judgement and authority of the Councell. So the Councell prevailed more then the Pope could do.DVR By the same reason you may say the Coūcels decree preuailed nothing to endi••• controuersie. WHIT. pag. 864. The reason is good, & proueth that whē he could preuaile neither by examples, reasons, nor threatnings, that those Churches did not accoūt Pope Victor for the head of the Church. And though after that Councell of Nice, some Churches obserued the Passeouer after another manner, yet the most Churches followed the iudgement and authoritie of the Councell. So the Councell preuailed more then the Pope could doe.
Polycarp in the question about Easter went to Rome, Smyrna gathered his relics. Wonderful reasons. Polycarp went to Rome to consult with Anycetus about Easter, and Smyrna gathered his relics; ergo Polycarp is yours. Doth not the learned Universities make you ashamed of this childish sophistry?h His bones indeed were gathered by the Church of Smyrna, not to worship them, but to bury them, as Eusebius in the same place recordeth. But why are Cornelius and Cyprian yours? forsooth, because Cornelius abolished the i African error, and Cyprian had him in great reverence. Oh wonderful Jesuitical Logic lwho can choose but be much moved with such strong reasons? But let us hear another.
Polycarpe in the question about Easter went to Rome, Smyrna gathered his reliques. Wonderfull reasons. Polycarpe went to Rome to consult with Anycetus about Easter, and Smyrna gathered his reliques; ergo Polycarpe is yours. Doth not the learned Vniuersities make you ashamed of this childish sophistrie?h His bones indeed were gathered by the Church of Smyrna, not to worship them, but to bury them, as Eusebius in the same place recordeth. But why are Cornelius and Cyprian yours? forsooth, because Cornelius abolished the i African error, and Cyprian had him in great reuerence. Oh wonderfull Iesuiticall Logick lwho can chuse but be much moued with such strong reasons? But let vs heare another.
hDVR. Envy maketh you forge an untruth. And while. for eunie you pine away a• the honour which is given of Christians to the relics of Martyrs, you imitate the Jews and the Devil. WHIT. pag. 865. I have spoken neither less nor more then Eusebius hath written who thē lived▪ After we had gathered his banes being more precious then pearles and gold, we buried them where it was thought sit. And as for the relics of Sai•ns, I envy them not, the Saints themselves I ever honourably remember. But that the relics of Saints were worshipped with religious honour, as they are in your Church, you shall never be able to prove.DVR. Enuie maketh you forge an vntruth. And whil. for eunie you pine avvay a• the honor which is giuen of Christians to the reliques of Martyrs, you imitate the Jewes and the Diuell. WHIT. pag. 865. I haue spoken neither lesse nor more then Eusebius hath written who thē liued▪ After we had gathered his banes being more precious then pearles and gold, we buried them where it was thought sit. And as for the reliques of Sai•ns, I enuy them not, the Saints themselues I euer honorablie remember. But that the reliques of Saints were worshipped with religi•us honor, as they are in your Church, you shall neuer be able to proue.
lDVR. His supreme authoritia appeareth in this, because he decreed that controversy, being not the Bishop of Africa, but of Rome. WHIT. pag. 866. Saint Paul confuted many errors of the Churches of Galatia, Corinth, Rome and divers others, yet was he never supreme Bishop. So did Augustine: But what error did he suppress? was it touching Baptism by heretics; that he never could do, but Cyprian and the Bishops of Africa constantly held it: which proved they never acknowledged that he had any such authority.DVR. His supreame authoritia appeareth in this, because hee decreed that controuersie, being not the Bishop of Africke, but of Rome. WHIT. pag. 866. Saint Paul confuted many errors of the Churches of Galatia, Co•inth, Rome and diuers others, yet was hee neuer supreame Bishop. So did Augustine: But what error did he suppresse? was it touching Baptisme by heretikes; that he neuer could doe, but Cyprian and the Bishops of Africke constantly held it: which proued they neuer acknowledged that he had any such authoritie.
Sixtus is ours: and why so? Seven of the Clergy ministered unto him, while he served at the altar. Seven Deacons helped Sixtus to celebrate the Lords supper, ergo Sixtus is yours. If this reason be of force, let him be yours hardly, I will not strive with you about him; but herein is nothing why he may not as well bek ours as yours. Doth it become you (Campian) ⟨p. 305⟩thus to trifle, thus to abuse our patience? What followeth? Laurence is yours: how so I pray you? Our adversaries have cast him out of their Calendar. We remember him with reverence as a saint, and a friend of Christ; though we worship him not as God. But Prudentine prayed unto him a thousand years ago. Give leave (Campian) to a Poet, to use poetical aversions, from whence yet no strong reason can be drawn. But if Prudentius were something too superstitious, what is that to us? Now you reckon up virgins, C•cilia, Agatha, and others: but what have they done why they should not be ours? When the Tyrants examined them of their faith, they professed themselves Christians: if they were Christians, they were ours. But Helen, say you, was ours, who is every way famous for finding the cross of Christ. That which Ambrose reports of Helen, is very suspicious, and Golasius Bishop of Rome calleth these things that were bruited of the invention of the cross,2 new revelations. But grant that Helen found the Cross, for it is not greatly material: Did she adore it? for that is to the purpose. Hear what Ambrose saith: She found the stile, 3she worshipped the King, not the wood certainly: for this is a heathenish error, and a vanity of the wicked. Wherefore though she found the Cross, that is no reason to prove her yours, seeing she worshipped not the cross, as you do: for not finding, but adoring of thel Cross makes a Papist.
Sixtus is ours: and why so? Seauen of the Clergie ministred vnto him, while hee serued at the altar. Seauen Deacons helped Sixtus to celebrate the Lords supper, ergo Sixtus is yours. If this reason be of force, let him be yours hardly, I will not striue with you about him; but herein is nothing why he may not as well bek ours as yours. Doth it become you (Campian) ⟨p. 305⟩thus to trifle, thus to abuse our patience? What followeth? Laurence is yours: how so I pray you? Our aduersaries haue cast him out of their Calouder. We remember him with reuerence as a saint, and a friend of Christ; though we worship him not as God. But Prudentine prayed vnto him a thousand yeares agoe. Giue leaue (Campian) to a Poet, to vse poeticall auersions, from whence yet no strong reason can be drawne. But if Prudentius were something too superstitious, what is that to vs? Now you recken vp virgins, C•cilia, Agatha, and others: but what haue they done why they should not be ours? When the Tyrants examined them of their faith, they professed themselues Christians: if they were Christians, they were ours. But Helen, say you, was ours, who is euery way famous for finding the crosse of Christ. That which Ambrose reports of Helen, is very suspitious, and Golasius Bishop of Rome calleth these things that were bruted of the inuention of the crosse,2 new reuelations. But graunt that Helen found the Crosse, for it is not greatly materiall: Did she adore it? for that is to the purpose. Heare what Ambrose saith: She found the stile, 3she worshipped the King, not the wood certainly: for this is a heathenish error, and a vanity of the wicked. Wherefore though she found the Crosse, that is no reason to prooue her yours, seeing she worshipped not the crosse, as you do: for not finding, but adoring of thel Crosse makes a Papist.
kDVR. Pope Sixtus a Priest, offered up the body and blood of Christ, Deacons assisting of him could not be a Calvinist, but on our side. WHIT. pag. 868. As if we had no Deacons, who help the Minister when he celebrateth the Lords Supper?DVR. Pope Sixtus a Priest, offred vp the body and blood of Christ, Deacons assisting of him could not bee a Caluinist, but on our side. WHIT. pag. 868. As if we had no Deacons, who helpe the Minister when he celebrateth the Lords Supper?
2Dill. 15. Sanct. Romana.
3Ambros. in Orat. suneb. Theodos.
lDVR. We give not Latria divine worship to the Cross. WHIT pag. 868. The distinction vvill not excuse you, for you reach that the Cross and the Image of Christ, is to be worshipped with Latria or divine worship, Thom. 3. part. 25. q. act. 3. & 4. which is so horrible and pernicious, that it exceedeth all the superstition of old Idolaters.DVR. VVee giue not Latria diuine worship to the Crosse. WHIT pag. 868. The distinction vvill not excuse you, for you reach that the Crosse and the Image of Christ, is to bee worshipped with Latria or diuine worship, Thom. 3. part. 25. q. act. 3. & 4. which is so horrible and pernicious, that it exceedeth all the superstition of old Idolaters.
Monica is ours, who at her death desired they should pray, and offer sacrifice for her at Christs altar. Monica desired not that them sacrifice of the Mass should be offered for her, for the forgiveness and expiation ⟨p. 306⟩of her sins, neither did Augustine either pray or offer for his mother in this manner. The desire of Monica was only this, that at the celebration of the Eucharist there might always be a remembrance of her, insomuch as she assured herself she was one of the heavenly society and community of saints. Augustine indeed prayed for his mother, I deny not; but this his fact proceeded more of affection to his mother then for any necessity. And the custom of prayer for the dead, which prevailed in many places, was not derived from the authority of the scriptures, but only from an excessive kind of love and reverence of them that lived, towards their friends that were dead. But that Augustine never believed his mother to be in Purgatory, that his prayers might relieve her there, it is manifest; for thus he saith, Forgive her Lord, forgive her, I beseech thee, 2enter not into judgement with her ô Lord, yea ô Lord, I believe thou hast already granted that which I desire, but accept ô Lord the freewill offerings of my mouth. But if we should grant that both Augustine and his mother went a little awry, you cannot here infer that either of them are yours, for so much as we are not to give censure of the Fathers (in greatest causes) by one particular judgement, but by their continual and constant opinion. You annex hereunto Paula and Paulus, Hilarian and Anthony. I could reckon ⟨p. 307⟩six hundred Monks like unto these, whereof not one was a Papist, none of them yours. All these were Christians loving solitariness, that they might more quietly intend the meditation of heavenly things. Compare not your Monks with these, which are of an other sort, and sect of Monks. These were holy, painful, faithful, full of good works: yours are impure, idle, idolatrous, devourers, hogs, oxen, asles: how are those like? But how shall it appear unto us that Satyrus the brother of Ambrose was yours? Being in danger, he leaped into the sea and swimming escaped by the strength of his faith. A goodly reason; he was a good swimmer, ergo nyours: other pretence you make none.
Monica is ours, who at her death desired they should pray, and offer sacrifice for her at Christes altar. Monica desired not that them sacrifice of the Masse should be offred for her, for the forgiuenes and expiation ⟨p. 306⟩of her sinnes, neither did Augustine either pray or offer for his mother in this manner. The desire of Monica was only this, that at the celebration of the Eucharist there might alwaies be a remembrance of her, insomuch as she assured herselfe she was one of the heauenly societie and communitie of saints. Augustine indeed prayed for his mother, I denie not; but this his fact proceeded more of affection to his mother then for any necessitie. And the custome of prayer for the dead, which preuailed in many places, was not deriued from the authoritie of the scriptures, but only from an excessiue kind of loue and reuerence of them that liued, towards their friends that were dead. But that Augustine neuer beleeued his mother to be in Purgatory, that his prayers might releeue her there, it is manifest; for thus he saith, Forgeue her Lord, forgiue her, I beseech thee, 2enter not into iudgement with her ô Lord, yea ô Lord, I beleeue thou hast already graunted that which I desire, but accept ô Lord the freewill offrings of my mouth. But if we should graunt that both Augustine and his mother went a little awry, you cannot heere inferre that either of them are yours, for so much as we are not to giue censure of the Fathers (in greatest causes) by one particular iudgement, but by their continuall and constant opinion. You annex hereunto Paula and Paulus, Hilarian and Authony. I could recken ⟨p. 307⟩sixe hundred Monks like vnto these, whereof not one was a Papist, none of them yours. All these were Christians louing solitarines, that they might more quietly intend the meditation of heauenly things. Compare not your Monks with these, which are of an other sort, and sect of Monks. These were holy, painefull, faithfull, full of good works: yours are impure, idle, idolatrous, deuourers, hogges, oxen, asles: how are those like? But how shall it appeare vnto vs that Satyrus the brother of Ambrose was yours? Being in danger, he leaped into the sea and swimming escaped by the strength of his faith. A goodly reason; he was a good smimmer, ergo nyours: other pretence you make none.
mDVR. She desired to be sacrificed for, and what other sacifice is there, but the sacrifice of the Altar, to take away the hand a ritive against us. WHIT. pag. 870. That I have answered in Augustines […] words, Confess. lib. 9. cap. 13. he only desired to be remembered at the Altar. It was a custom in the Church to make honourable mention of the Patriarchs, Prophets, Apostles, the Virgin Mary, the Martyrs, and Confessors, whom they never thought to be tormented in Purgatory; but your Mass is offered for those, whom you think as yet not to be freed from that fire, and to be in heavenly joys. And what a kind of sacrifice it was, Augustine showeth in the same place, saying: Thy hand maiden kuit her soul by the bond of faith, to the Sacrament of that price of our redemption. He calleth then the Eucharist a sacrifice which taketh away the hand-writing against us, because it is the Sacrament of that sacrifice.DVR. Shee desired to be sacrificed for, and what other sacifice is there, but the sacrifice of the Altar, to take away the hand a ritiue against vs. WHIT. pag. 870. That I haue answered in Augustines 〈…〉 words, Confess. lib. 9. cap. 13. hee only desired to bee remembred at the Altar. It was a custome in the Church to make honorable mention of the Patriarkes, Prophets, Apostles, the Virgin Mary, the Martyrs, and Confessors, whom they neuer thought to be tormented in Purgatorie; but your Masse is offered for those, whom you thinke as yet not to be freed from that fire, and to be in heauenly ioyes. And what a kind of sacrifice it was, Augustine sheweth in the same place, saying: Thy hand mayden kuit her soule by the bond of faith, to the Sacrament of that price of our redemption. He calleth then the Eucharist a sacrifice which taketh away the hand-writing against vs, because it is the Sacrament of that sacrifice.
2August. confess. lib. 9. cap. 13.
nDVR But which of you did any such thing armed thing armed with the Calvinist Supper? WHIT. pag. 872. And which of you armed with the Host, durst cast himself into the sea, unless he had learned first to swim? And at that time Satyrus was not only saved, but also others who had not the Host.DVR But which of you did any such thing armed thing armed with the Caluinist Supper? WHIT. pag. 872. And which of you armed with the Host, durst cast himselfe into the sea, vnlesse he had learned first to swimme? And at that time Satyrus was not only saued, but also others who had not the Host.
Why Nicholas and Martinus should be yours, you show no cause, for wearing hair-cloth, fasting and watching, are no marks of your Bishops. Benedict (say you) was the founder and father of the Monkish profession, therefore without doubt he must be yours. I could be content to leave him, as too superstitious, yet can you not prove that he was yours, or favoured your religion in all or the most things. Here you say you pass over thousands, Francis I think you mean, and Dominic, and those huge swarms of white Friars and black Friars: I freely bequeath them unto you, and willingly suffer you to enjoy them, and all such as were like them. They were not of that worth that we should need greatly to strive about them. You pass over the Doctors in silence, which you formerly remembered; wherein I commend your wisdom, seeing to them you can make no claim without doing them too apparent wrong. You demand of all those before recited, whether they were Catholics or Lutherans; to which I will answer, when you have showed how Lutheranism dissenteth from true Catholic religion. Luther taught no new doctrine, he restored and maintained the ancient Catholic ⟨p. 308⟩faith. What though he was unknown unto those ancient Fathers, as being himself of later years, yet the doctrine he brought was Evangelical and Apostolic, which you had wellnigh extinguished, which he restored to his former beauty and perfection. Answer me (Campian) this one thing; of all those you have named, what one was ao Thomist, Scotist, Dominican, Franciscan, or Jesuit? when you have answered me touching those, I will answer as touching Luther. You call the Throne of God to witness, that if there be any heaven at all, it is proper to you. In any case avouch this boldly and confidently; though he that looks into your lines may well think there is no heaven at all. For neither will you enter into heaven your selves, nor suffer those that would; and the lives of those of your side are such, as are far fitter for hell then for heaven. I know not (Campian) what heaven you dream of; if you mean the eternal habitation of God, and his Saints, I take God to witness the maker of this palace, and all the heavenly citizens, that there no place can be for you Papists, false Catholics, Jesuits. As you have devised a new faith whereby you must enter thither, so must you seek a new heaven;
Why Nicholas and Martinus should be yours, you shew no cause, for wearing haire-cloth, fasting and watching, are no marks of your Bishops. Benedict (say you) was the founder and father of the Monkish profession, therefore without doubt he must be yours. I could be content to leaue him, as too superstitious, yet can you not prooue that he was yours, or fauoured your religion in all or the most things. Heere you say you passe ouer thousands, Francis I thinke you meane, and Dominicke, and those huge swarmes of white Friers and blacke Friers: I freely bequeath them vnto you, and willingly suffer you to enioy them, and all such as were like them. They were not of that worth that we should need greatly to striue about them. You passe ouer the Doctors in silence, which you formerly remembred; wherein I commend your wisedome, seeing to them you can make no claime without doing them too apparant wrong. You demaund of all those before recited, whether they were Catholicks or Lutheranes; to which I will answere, when you haue shewed how Lutheranisme dissenteth frō true Catholick religion. Luther taught no new doctrine, he restored and mainteined the auncient Catholicke ⟨p. 308⟩faith. What though he was vnknowne vnto those auncient Fathers, as being himselfe of later yeares, yet the doctrine he brought was Euangelicall and Apostolick, which you had welnigh extinguished, which he restored to his former beautie and perfection. Answere me (Campian) this one thing; of all those you haue named, what one was ao Thomist, Scotist, Dominican, Franciscan, or Iesuite? when you haue answered me touching those, I will answere as touching Luther. You call the Throne of God to witnes, that if there be any heauen at all, it is proper to you. In any case auouch this boldly and confidently; though he that looks into your lines may wel thinke there is no heauen at all. For neither will you enter into heauen your selues, nor suffer those that would; and the liues of those of your side are such, as are far fitter for hell then for heauen. I know not (Campian) what heauen you dreame of; if you meane the eternall habitation of God, and his Saincts, I take God to witnes the maker of this palace, and all the heauenly citizens, that there no place can be for you Papists, false Catholicks, Iesuites. As you haue deuised a new faith whereby you must enter thither, so must you seeke a new heauen;
oDVR. But all these did ever consent in faith and differed only in such things which might be disputed without any hazard of faith. WHIT. pag. 873. Be it granted, they did agree in matter of faith: why then do they not follow all one rule? But S. Paul reproved the Corinthians agreeing in faith, because they attributed to their Ministers more then was meet, whilst one had devoted himself to S. Paul, another to S. Peter, another to Apollo. What then shall be done to the Scotists, Thomists & others? are the names of Scotus, Thomas, Francis more holy and lawful names in their disciples, then the names of S. Peter, S. Paul, and of Apollo? Besides the difference is very great, not in the name, but in things also As thus Let the question be whether the Cross and Image of Christ be to be worshipped with the same kind of worship that Christ is adored withal? Doth not this appertain to faith? But error in this will be plain Idolatry. And yet you know some of the Schoolmen stand for it, some against i•: what of that question, which hath exercised all Churches and Schools so long; Whether the Virgin Mary had original sin, or was ever pure and without spot? And infinite such differences I omit, being matter of faith.DVR. But all these did euer consent in faith and differed only in such things which might be disputed vvithout any hazard of faith. WHIT. pag. 873. Be it granted, they did agree in matter of faith: vvhy then do they not follow all one rule? But S. Paul reproued the Corinthians agreeing in faith, because they attributed to their Ministers more then was meete, vvhilest one had deuoted himselfe to S. Paul, another to S. Peter, another to Apollo. What then shall be done to the Scotistes, Thom•stes & others? are the names of Scotus, Thomas, Francis more holy and lawfull names in their disciples, then the names of S. Peter, S. Paul, and of Apollo? Besides the difference is very great, not in the name, but in things also As thus Let the question be whether the Crosse and Image of Christ bee to bee worshipped with the same kind of worship that Christ is adored withall? Doth not this appertaine to faith? But error in this will be plaine Idolatrie. And yet you know some of the Schoolemen stand for it, some against i•: what of that question, which hath exercised al Churches and Schooles so long; Whether the Virgin Marie had originall sinne, or was euer pure and without spot? And infinite such differences I omit, being matter of faith.
Now being fallen from heaven,1 you look into hell. I wish (Campian) you could seriously view those infernal regions and places of the damned; for though I do willingly think nothing but well of the dead; yet I fear you should find too too many of them that have flourished in your Church, in those places. Certainly (to say nothing of the rest) your later Popes, as those which were called by the names of Boniface, Innocent, Sylvester, Gregory, Calixt, Urbane, Alexander, Adrian, Pius, Leo, Paul, & almost all the rest; were such, as hardly can any man think they could enter into heaven. And further, I call Christ the only teacher of heavenly doctrine to record, that such is your faith and religion, that who so maintains it fully and wholly, cannot reign with Christ, nor be partaker of that heavenly life; and therefore not Jews only, Pagans, Turks, and notorious Heretics are tormented in that fire that never goes out, but Papists also, of all Heretics the most vile and odious. Infinite are the souls of Christian men, which have been thrown headlong into this most woeful destruction these many hundred years by that Antichrist of yours, who alone hath more enlarged that infernal kingdom, then all Jews, Nerves, Mahomets, Arians, Nestorians, Macedonians, Eutychians, and the rest. To you (Campian) I wish that salvation which consisteth in the true knowledge of God, and whom he hath sent Jesus Christ, and desire from my hart that now at length you will renounce that Roman Antichrist, with whom you have conversed, and return unto Christ the only giver of eternal life, from whom too long you have banished your self.
Now being fallen from heauen,1 you looke into hell. I wish (Campian) you could seriously view those infernall regions and places of the damned; for though I do willingly thinke nothing but well of the dead; yet I feare you should find too too many of thē that haue flourished in your Church, in those places. Certainely (to say nothing of the rest) your later Popes, as those which were called by the names of Boniface, Innocent, Siluester, Gregory, Calixt, Vrbane, Alexander, Adrian, Pius, Leo, Paul, & almost all the rest; were such, as hardly can any man thinke they could enter into heauen. And further, I call Christ the only teacher of heauenly doctrine to record, that such is your faith and religion, that who so maintaines it fullie and wholie, cannot raigne with Christ, nor be partaker of that heauenly life; and therefore not Iewes only, Pagans, Turks, and notorious Heretikes are tormented in that fire that neuer goes out, but Papists also, of all Heretikes the most vile and odious. Infinite are the soules of Christian men, which haue been throwne headlong into this most wofull destruction these many hundred yeares by that Antichrist of yours, who alone hath more inlarged that infernall kingdome, then all Iewes, Nerves, Mahomets, Arians, Nestorians, Macedonians, Eutychians, and the rest. To you (Campian) I wish that saluation which cōsisteth in the true knowledge of God, and whom he hath sent Iesus Christ, and desire from my hart that now at length you will renounce that Romane Antichrist, with whom you haue conuersed, and returne vnto Christ the onely giuer of eternall life, from whom too long you haue banished your selfe.
But let us consider what these damned ones will further your cause.1 The Jews you begin with, and here you reckon Jerusalem, holy places, our Saviours Sepulchre, the Manger, Cross, and other […] ⟨p. 310⟩from all which you cannot draw one argument for your purpose. I deny not, but great concourse of people thronged unto the City, partly to hear and see the Apostles whiles they lived, and also to behold those places, where Christ the Son of God had conversed; and at Jerusalem were many things, which might move and persuade men to go thither, that were any thing curiously inclined. And although the Church then was too much addicted to these observations, and as a Spouse exceedingly delighted with any remembrance of her deceased husband, yet was she then far from those superstitiousp pilgrimages, and dotings on Images, which with you Papists is now usual.
But let vs consider what these damned ones will further your cause.1 The Iewes you begin with, and heere you reckon Hierusalem, holy places, our Sauiours Sepulcher, the Manger, Crosse, and other 〈…〉⟨p. 310⟩from all which you cannot draw one argument for your purpose. I denie not, but great concourse of people thronged vnto the Citie, partly to heare and see the Apostles whiles they liued, and also to behold those places, where Christ the Sonne of God had conuersed; and at Ierusalem were many things, which might moue and perswade men to goe thither, that were any thing curiously inclined. And although the Church then was too much addicted to these obseruations, and as a Spouse exceedingly delighted with any remembrāce of her deceassed husband, yet was she then farre from those superstitiousp pilgrimages, and dotings on Images, which with you Papists is now vsuall.
1Jews.Jewes.
pDVR. We do but imitate our fore fathers, who did such things not of curiosity but religiously, Hier. Epist. ad Macel & Pailon. August. Epist. ad Clerum & Pop. Hip. WHIT. pag. 878. But Christ saith, Joh. 4.21.23. If then I may worship God with great fruit in mine own country, I see not why I should go to Jerusalem or any other place on Pilgrimage. And if I have the authority of the Scriptures, object not unto me Hierom, or Augustine, or any other, whom I cannot allow to speak without Scripture against Scripture. And as for Fathers, know you not that Gregory Nyssen hath with pregnant reason confuted all superstitious peregrinations? w•it not Bernard; Monks must search for the heavenly not earthly Jerusalem, which they must go unto not by their feet, but by affections?DVR. VVee doe but imitate our fore fathers, who did such things not of curiosity but religiously, Hier. Epist. ad Macel & Pailon. August. Epist. ad Clerum & Pop. Hipp. WHIT. pag. 878. But Christ saith, Joh. 4.21.23. If then I may worship God with great frui•e in mine owne countrie, I see not why I should go to Hierusalem or any other place on Pilgrimage. And if I haue the authoritie of the Scriptures, obiect not vnto mee Hierom, or Augustine, or any other, whō I cannot allow to speake without Scripture against Scripture. And as for Fathers, know you not that Gregorie Nyssen hath with pregnant reason confuted all superstitious peregrinations? w•it not Bernard; Monkes must search for the heauenly not earthly Hierusalem, vvhich they must goe vnto not by their feete, but by affections?
Neither was this often recourse of Christians into those places the cause of the Jews hatred unto them, as you untruly surmise; but the Gospel was the true cause of difference betwixt them and us.1 They urge Moses; we teach that Moses must give place to Christ;q from hence only proceeds their hatred unto us: but you are odious unto them in many respects;r your manifold idolatries continually hindering ⟨p. 311⟩them from receiving the Gospel of Christ. Remove your idols, that we all that are called Christians, may worship God in spirit and truth. The Jews then will join themselves unto us, and will speedily in great multitudes betake themselves to the sheepfold of Christ. The Jews complain they have been destroyed by your Ancestors; whom mean you, the Romans who raced the City under the conduct of Titus? These were enemies of the faith of Christ: will you be their posterity, or what other Ancestors have you, that have been author of so great calamity unto the Jews? They have, I grant, many things in their religion, which will ever alienate them from you: yet in many respects the Jews are much beholding unto you; so as unless they will incur the suspicion of great unthankfulness, they must love you again deservedly. For you give them leave to use their ancient Ceremonies, and that in Rome, and freely to utter their blasphemies against Christ without blame; so they pay tribute, they have impunity for all their sacrileges and blasphemies. The Lutherans (say you) never opposed themselves against them, neither did they ever receive any damage from the Jesuits.4 You proceed to Heathens, among whom you affirm those were most violent which devised the most grievous torments for Christians. I will easily grant, that those Tyrants that killed and murdered the Christians for the space of 300. years, were violent and outrageous above measure. What of this? These (say you) that were thus drawn unto all kinds of torment that could be devised, These were the fathers and children of our faith. Nothing less (Campian:) this should have bin ⟨p. 312⟩soundly proved, not barely affirmed. No likeness or affinity of faith or works can be found betwixt you and them, so far are they from being your fathers, or you their children. For as our Saviour said to the Jews, If you were the children of Abraham, 5you would do the works of Abraham;
Neither was this often recourse of Christians into those places the cause of the Iewes hatred vnto thē, as you vntruly surmise; but the Gospell was the true cause of difference betwixt them and vs.1 They vrge Moses; wee teach that Moses must giue place to Christ;q from hence only proceeds their hatred vnto vs: but you are odious vnto thē in many respects;r your manifold idolatries continually hindering ⟨p. 311⟩them from receiuing the Gospell of Christ. Remoue your idols, that we all that are called Christians, may worship God in spirit and truth. The Iewes then will ioyne themselues vnto vs, and will speedily in great multitudes betake themselues to the sheepfold of Christ. The Iewes complaine they haue been destroyed by your Auncestors; whom meane you, the Romanes who raced the Citie vnder the conduct of Titus? These were enemies of the faith of Christ: will you be their posteritie, or what other Auncestors haue you, that haue been author of so great calamitie vnto the Iewes? They haue, I graunt, many things in their religion, which will euer alienate them from you: yet in many respects the Iewes are much beholding vnto you; so as vnlesse they will incurre the suspition of great vnthankfulnes, they must loue you againe deseruedly. For you giue them leaue to vse their auncient Ceremonies, and that in Rome, and freely to vtter their blasphemies against Christ without blame; so they pay tribute, they haue impunitie for all their sacriledges and blasphemies. The Lutheranes (say you) neuer opposed themselues against them, neither did they euer receiue any damage from the Iesuites.4 You proceed to Heathens, among whom you affirme those were most violent which deuised the most grieuous torments for Christians. I will easily graunt, that those Tyrants that killed and murthered the Christians for the space of 300. yeares, were violent and outragious aboue measure. What of this? These (say you) that were thus drawne vnto all kinds of torment that could be deuised, These were the fathers and children of our faith. Nothing lesse (Campian:) this should haue bin ⟨p. 312⟩soundly proued, not barely affirmed. No likenes or affinitie of faith or works can be found betwixt you and them, so farre are they from being your fathers, or you their children. For as our Sauiour said to the Iewes, If you were the children of Abraham,
qDVR. They hate us not so much for our faith and profession, as because we have spoiled them of their kingdom and Priest-hood, and have cast them out of their country. WHIT. pag. 877. But what Christian ever spoiled the Jews of their kingdom, or thus expelled them? Did Caligula, Titus, or Adrian destroy the Jews for the religion of Christ? And if they hated you, because you have bereft them of their Priest-hood, why not us for the Gospel, which teacheth that the Priesthood is translated from the posterity of Aaron unto Christ?DVR. They hate vs not so much for our faith and profession, as because wee haue spoiled them of their kingdome and Priest-hood, and haue cast them out of their countrie. WHIT. pag. 877. But what Christian euer spoiled the Iewes of their kingdome, or thus expelled them? Did Caligula, Titus, or Adrian destroy the Iewes for the religion of Christ? And if they hated you, because you haue bereft them of their Priest-hood, why not vs for the Gospell, which teacheth that the Priesthood is translated from the posterity of Aaron vnto Christ?
rDVR Many Jews have become Catholics, but not Calvinists, as Jever heard of. WHIT. pag. 878. We desire they might be made Christians not Calvinists, as our Churches hath many of them, I will […] you one, of whom it were strange you should not have heard, Emanuel Tre••lius a Jew borne, being brought to the religion of Christ, whom Calvin loved dearly, and his Catechism he translated into the Hebrew tongue.DVR Many Jevves haue become Catholikes, but not Caluinists, as Jeuer heard of. WHIT. pag. 878. We desire they might be made Christians not Caluinists, as our Churches hath many of them, I will 〈…〉 you one, of whom it were strange you should not haue heard, Emanuell Tre••lius a Iew borne, being brought to the religion of Christ, whom Caluin loued dearely, and his Catechisme he translated into the Hebrew tongue.
so if these had been your fathers (as you say) & you their children, you should have resembled them as your fathers. But beware (Campian) lest that which follows agree more fitly unto you; You are of your father the Devil. 1These holy Fathers if they were now living, would disclaim you from being their of-spring, so little you resemble them in any thing. Be ashamed at length to call your selves their posterity, from whom you have so foully degenerated; or if the name please you, endeavour that it may be proper unto you. But to what purpose make you mention of that Tyrant that broiled Laurence on a Gridiron and why repeat you all these verses out of Prudentius? He speaks indeed of gold and silver and torches; what of all this? Torches were needful in the night season, at which time the Christians then used to meet, because they durst not assemble on the day, but tos light candles (as you do) at noon days, is mere madness. The accusation laid against him by the Tyrant, of gold, silver, plate, and sums of money, wast forged. He had heard that the Christians had a great mass of gold and silver, and concealed treasure, and being exceeding earnest after it, he sends ⟨p. 313⟩for Laurence, and commands him to bring him that money. But where (Campian) was the plate of gold and silver which he brought unto the Tyrant? what Cups, vessels or treasures did he bewray. The Church did not then abound in wealth, neither had they then such plenty of golden basins, silver chalices, costly hangings, or any other great and precious treasure. They had then wooden dishes, but golden Bishops and Priests; but now (as Boniface said truly) we […] golden vessels, 4wooden Priests; neither doth he therein play the Lutheran•, as you play the Papist, Campian. These Nimrods & Church-robbers came not out of Luther's school; those that made greatest spoil of the Church came from you, not us.
so if these had been your fathers (as you say) & you their children, you should haue resembled them as your fathers. But beware (Campian) lest that which followes agree more fitly vnto you; You are of your father the Diu•ll. 1These holy Fathers if they were now liuing, would disclaime you from being their of-spring, so little you resemble them in any thing. Be ashamed at length to call your selues their posteritie, from whom you haue so fouly degenerated; or if the name please you, indeuour that it may be proper vnto you. But to what purpose make you mention of that Tyrant that broyled Laurence on a Gridyroul and why repeate you all these verses out of Prudentius? He speakes indeed of gold and siluer and torches; what of all this? Torches were needfull in the night season, at which time the Christians then vsed to meete, because they durst not assemble on the day, but tos light candles (as you do) at noone dayes, is meere madnes. The accusation laid against him by the Tyrant, of gold, siluer, plate, and summes of money, wast forged. He had heard that the Christians had a great masse of gold and siluer, and concealed treasure, and being exceeding earnest after it, he sends ⟨p. 313⟩for Laurence, and commaunds him to bring him that money. But where (Campian) was the plate of gold and siluer which he brought vnto the Tyrant? what Cups, vessels or treasures did he bewray. The Church did not then abound in wealth, neither had they then such plentie of golden basons, siluer chalices, costly hangings, or any other great and pretious treasure. They had then woodden dishes, but golden Bishops and Priests; but now (as Boniface said truly) we 〈…〉 golden vessels, 4woodden Priests; neither doth he therein play the Lutheran•, as you play the Papist, Campian. These Nimrods & Church-robbers came not out of Luthers schoole; those that made greatest spoile of the Church came from you, not vs.
1Joh. 8.88.
sDVR. Yet was this a most ancient custom: as divers do testify, and they were kindled then to show that the sight of faith ought to be kindled in the mind. WHIT. pag. 879. That which was done in the night, came in time to be done at noon day, I deny not: but I inquire by what Scripture, or what reason: as for your invented mystery, I say this is the way to fill all places with •ignes, figures, and foolish mysteries. But I can easily pardon you, whose ignorance and blindness of mind is so great, that no light is sufficient for you.DVR. Yet was this a most auncient custome: as diuers do testifie, and they vvere kindled then to shevv that the sight of faith ought to bee kindled in the mind. WHIT. pag. 879. That which was done in the night, came in time to be done at noone day, I deny not: but I inquire by what Scripture, or what reason: as for your inuented mysterie, I say this is the way to fill all places with •ignes, figures, and foolish mysteries. But I can easily pardon you, whose ignorance and blindnes of mind is so great, that no light is sufficient for you.
tDVR. Yea your answer is false and feigned for it was true which the Tyrant objected to Laurence. WHIT. pag. 880. Is it like that the Church being under Tyrants could abound with such riches of silver and gold? But at the very same time their poverty appeareth. For Gratian de Co•sp••ra. Dist. 1. c. v•s•. bringeth in Boniface affirming that in time past they had golden Priests, and wooden Chalices. And Xepherinus the sixteenth Bishop of Rome, did ordain that Mass should be celebrated in dishes made of glass. Pope Urb••e was the first who made all the ministering dishes of silver, and so in this as in other things, by success of time the glory of Churches increased.DVR. Yea your answere is false and fained for it was true which the Tyrant obiected to Laurence. WHIT. pag. 880. Is it like that the Church being vnder Tyrants could abound with such riches of siluer and gold? But at the very same time their pouertie appeareth. For Gratian de Co•sp••ra. Dist. 1. c. v•s•. bringeth in Boniface affirming that in time past they had golden Priests, and wooden Chalices. And Xepherinus the sixteenth Bishop of Rome, did ordeine that Masse should bee celebrated in dishes made of glasse. Pope Vrbe was the first who made all the ministring dishes of siluer, and so in this as in other things, by successe of time the glorie of Churches increased.
Against this Tyrant you oppose Constantine, and make a needless digression in his commendation, rather to fill up room, then frame a reason. For to what end rehearse you these things; Constantine quieted the Church, was baptized by Sylvester Bishop of Rome, used the sign of the cross, had Helen to his mother, joined himself to the Fathers of Nice, commended himself to the prayers of Anthony, chose the lowest place in the Synod, ergo, what will you infer? From this loose ware cannot you evince your Church to be the true Church, unless you strain them very violently. Constantin•• indeed brought peace unto the Church in her most troublesome time, and adorned and honoured it with all the preferments and possessions he could, and since his time, as she increased in wealth, so she decreased ⟨p. 314⟩in piety. Whereas you say, that Constantine sent for Sylvester from Soracte, that he might be baptized by him with our baptism, you might better have said, that Sylvester was fetched from heaven to baptize Constantine, for Sylvester died many years before Constantine was baptized, as is manifest out ofu Eusebius, Socrates, Theodorus, Z•zomen, 2who have recorded the baptism of Constantine to have been not whiles he was young, but in his age, not by Sylvester of Rome, but by Eusebius of Nicomedia, an Arian Bishop. Now Sylvester was extreme old when Constantine was a young man. He used the sign of the cross which he had seen in the air as an Ensign, declaring himself thereby the soldier of Christ, and an enemy of Tyrants. But that he worshipped or adored this cross, you shall never approve. As concerning his* place in the Council it skilleth not greatly: for what if he chose the lowest seat amongst the Bishops?4 but you think he did it rather forced by necessary duty then moved by voluntary humility: mark then what Eusebius writes. When he was come to the chief place, he stood up in the middest of the assembly, and there, when a little seat made of gold was brought for him, he sate down. Here you see that Constantine sate in the highest place, a seat of gold, which was the chiefest, and above all the rest, as Z•zomen relates. But these your proofs are passing strange, they strengthen the cause of your Pope excellently well.
Against this Tyrant you oppose Constantine, and make a needlesse digression in his commendation, rather to fill vp roome, then frame a reason. For to what end rehearse you these things; Constantine quieted the Church, was baptized by Siluester Bishop of Rome, vsed the signe of the crosse, had Helen to his mother, ioyned himselfe to the Fathers of Nice, commended himselfe to the prayers of Anthony, chose the lowest place in the Synod, ergo, what will you inferre? From this loose ware cannot you euince your Church to be the true Church, vnlesse you straine them very violently. Constantin•• indeed brought peace vnto the Church in her most troublesome time, and adorned and honored it with all the preferments and possessions he could, and since his time, as she increased in wealth, so she decreased ⟨p. 314⟩in piety. Whereas you say, that Constantine sent for Siluester from Soracte, that he might be baptized by him with our baptisme, you might better haue said, that Siluester was fetcht from heauen to baptize Constantine, for Siluester died many yeares before Constantine was baptized, as is manifest out ofu Eusebius, Socrates, Theodorus, Z•zomen, 2who haue recorded the baptisme of Constantine to haue been not whiles he was yong, but in his age, not by Siluester of Rome, but by Eusebius of Nicomedia, an Arian Bishop. Now Siluester was extreame old when Constantine was a yong man. He vsed the signe of the crosse which he had seene in the ayre as an Ensigne, declaring himselfe thereby the souldier of Christ, and an enemy of Tyrants. But that he worshipped or adored this crosse, you shall neuer approue. As concerning his* place in the Councell it skilleth not greatly: for what if he chose the lowest seate amongst the Bishops?4 but you thinke he did it rather forced by necessary dutie then moued by voluntarie humilitie: marke then what Eusebius writes. When he was come to the chiefe place, he stood vp in the middest of the assemblie, and there, when a little seate made of gold was brought for him, he sate downe. Heere you see that Constantine sate in the highest place, a seate of gold, which was the chiefest, and aboue all the rest, as Z•zomen relates. But these your proofes are passing strange, they strengthen the cause of your Pope excellently well.
uDVR. You know the first of your authors and witnesses was an Arian; and him the rest follow. WHIT. pag. 881. It is incredible to think he would lie in so famous a thing, which might so easily be proved to the contrary. And if he had been baptised at Rome, as you say, it is like the other three would ha•• come to the knowledge of it by some means, & have preferred the credit of the thing, before the lie of Eusebius. As for your witnesses they are not to be compared with these of ours.DVR. You knovv the first of your authors and vvitnesses was an Arian; and him the rest follovv. WHIT. pag. 881. It is incredible to thinke hee would lie in so famous a thing, which might so easily be proued to the contrarie. And if he had been baptised at Rome, as you say, it is like the other three would ha•• come to the knowledge of it by some meanes, & haue preferred the credit of the thing, before the lie of Eusebius. As for your witnesses they are not to be compared with these of ours.
*DVR. What can be spoken more foolishly? WHIT. pag. 881. And yet what is my folly, which was not the folly of Eusebius and Sozomen: for Eusebius who was present at the same Synod, writeth that Constantine in the first rank sate down in a golden chair. And Sozomen saith there was a throne prepared for him, and that a great one, and above all the other.DVR. VVhat can bee spoken more foolishlie? WHIT. pag. 881. And yet what is my follie, which was not the follie of Eusebius and Sozomen: for Eusebius who was present at the same Synod, writeth that Constantine in the first rancke sate downe in a golden chaire. And Sozomen saith there was a throne prepared for him, and that a great one, and aboue all the other.
4Euseb. lib. 3. de vita Constant. Sozom. lib. 2. cap. 19.
Now you pass forward unto the Turks,1 wherein you do too manifestly bewray your ignorance in ⟨p. 315⟩history. For the Turkish government never less prevailed, then since Luther began to publish the Gospel: Before he did over-run, and like a troublous sea break into all Countries, with a furious and unresisted violence. But since Luther like a good husbandman began to sow the seed of the Gospel, this raging sea hath as it were retired or stood still, and contained it self within his own bounds. Vienna was kept by the Lutherans, and assaulted by Solyman, but he returned with loss and with shame; and prove if you can, that ever the Christians became weak, or the Turks stronger by their default. The Letters which you pretend, as written from Solyman to Luther, might with better reason have bin sent to the Pope: for the Turks are beholding to none more then your Pope, as they well know; and unless they will be unthankful, they will ever acknowledge it. For if as our Saviour Christ saith, a kingdom divided against it self cannot stand, then the breaking of the strength of the Empire, and weakening the power of Christians, and consequently strengthening the Turks, all must be imputed to him which rent and divided the Roman and Christian Empires, and of one kingdom made two: As long as the provinces and dominions of the Empire were united, we were strong enough against the Turks; but after Pope Leo the 3. divided the Empire, the Emperor of Constantinople which before had much ado to resist the Turk, was now no longer able to sustain the burden, wanting the greatest part of his Empire. There is then no reason why the Turk should thank Luther, but the Pope rather, as he hath good cause. It were too long to rehearse all the intercourse which hath passed betwixt the Pope and the Turk: let us now hear the conclusion. They are (say you) only professed enemies to us. Certainly they have infested them of the Greek church more ⟨p. 316⟩then the Latin. So that if they be the best Christians that are most persecuted by the Turks, the Grecians must go before you. Whereas you add something of Altars and Images, know you that the Idolatry of your Church is so great, that the Turks themselves are ashamed, and therefore they break, and evil entreat your Images and Idols wheresoever they find them.
Now you passe forward vnto the Turks,1 wherein you do too manifestly bewray your ignorance in ⟨p. 315⟩historie. For the Turkish gouernement neuer lesse preuailed, then since Luther began to publish the Gospell: Before he did ouer-run, and like a troublous sea breake into all Countries, with a furious and vnresisted violence. But since Luther like a good husbandman began to sow the seed of the Gospell, this raging sea hath as it were retired or stood still, and conteined it selfe within his owne bounds. Vicuna was kept by the Lutheranes, and assaulted by Solyman, but he returned with losse and with shame; and prooue if you can, that euer the Christians became weake, or the Turks stronger by their default. The Letters which you pretend, as written from Solyman to Luther, might with better reason haue bin sent to the Pope: for the Turks are beholding to none more then your Pope, as they well know; and vnlesse they will be vnthankfull, they will euer acknowledge it. For if as our Sauiour Christ saith, a kingdome diuided against it selfe cannot stand, then the breaking of the strength of the Empire, and weakning the power of Christians, and consequently strengthning the Turks, all must be imputed to him which rent and diuided the Romane and Christian Empires, and of one kingdome made two: As long as the prouinces and dominions of the Empire were vnited, we were strong ynough against the Turks; but after Pope Leo the 3. diuided the Empire, the Emperour of Constantinople which before had much ado to resist the Turke, was now no longer able to sustaine the burthen, wanting the greatest part of his Empire. There is then no reason why the Turke should thanke Luther, but the Pope rather, as he hath good cause. It were too long to rehearse all the intercourse which hath passed betwixt the Pope and the Turke: let vs now heare the conclusion. They are (say you) onely professed enemies to vs. Certainely they haue infested them of the Greeke church more ⟨p. 316⟩then the Latine. So that if they be the best Christians that are most persecuted by the Turks, the Grecians must goe before you. Whereas you adde something of Altars and Images, know you that the Idolatry of your Church is so great, that the Turks themselues are ashamed, and therefore they breake, and euill intreate your Images and Idols wheresoeuer they find them.
Now you come to Heretics, the lees, bellows, 1and fuel of hell fire. As long as there wants no Papists this fire will want no fuel. The first you meet with is Simon Magus. Indeed your Church is something more indebted to this Simon then the other: but what of him? He denied freewill unto man, and bragged of faith alone. Where find you that? tell us Campian, for this is not affirmed by Ireneus or Clemens in the places alleged; he thought that all things came to pass by destiny, and an inevitable necessity, whereby he utterly abolished mans freewill:x We hold no such opinion. Neither did he boast of sole faith (as you say:) but this was his opinion, that from the doctrine of Justification by grace and faith, he let loose the reins to all impiety & dishonesty: where do we defend any such things? Novatianus would himself be Bishop of Rome, and opposed himself to Cornelius the lawful Bishop, hoping by force to get the Bishopric. What is this to us? But he was an enemy to the two Sacraments of penance and extreme unction. yHe denied pardon and repentance to them ⟨p. 317⟩that fell in persecution. Herein he was an enemy of repentance. Our case in far different, which exclude no true penitent from hope of pardon. Manes wholly rejected baptism, as unprofitable and not necessary. Do we affirm any such thing? Wez deny (indeed) that baptism confers grace to the unbeliever by the work wrought: he denied it to be profitable at all: are we like him? Austen and Epiphanius account Aerius for an Heretic, so did few of the ancient Fathers besides these. And if to condemn prayers for the dead, 5and make equal a Priest with a Bishop be heretical, what shall be Catholic? Hierome was altogether of Aerius his mind, about equality of Priests; for he determines them to be equal with Bishops by Gods law. This was not that Aerius, 6whom they usually called Atheist, but an other, Aetius; the likeness of the names deceived you. To that you objected concerning Vigilantius and Jovinian, an answer is formerly given;a for my part, I neither mean to defend them, nor can I greatly accuse them. If they were heretics, convince them of some error they held against the scriptures: Hieromes passions can make no man an heretic. Now you bring in the swarm of heretics, Macedonians, Pelagians, Nestorians, Eutychians, the M••otholites, and Iconomachs.
Now you come to Hereticks, the lees, bellowes, 1and fewell of hell fire. As long as there wants no Papists this fire will want no fewell. The first you meete with is Simon Magus. Indeed your Church is something more indebted to this Simon then the other: but what of him? He denied freewill vnto man, and bragged of faith alone. Where finde you that? tell vs Campian, for this is not affirmed by Ireneus or Clemens in the places alleaged; he thought that all things came to passe by destinie, and an ineuitable necessitie, whereby he vtterly abolished mans freewill:x We hold no such opinion. Neither did he boast of sole faith (as you say:) but this was his opinion, that from the doctrine of Iustification by grace and faith, he let loose the raines to all impietie & dishonestie: where do we defend any such things? Nouatianus would himselfe be Bishop of Rome, and opposed himselfe to Cornelius the lawfull Bishop, hoping by force to get the Bishoprick. What is this to vs? But he was an enemie to the two Sacraments of penance and extreme vnction. yHe denied pardon and repentance to them ⟨p. 317⟩that fell in persecution. Herein he was an enemie of repentance. Our case in farre different, which exclude no true penitent from hope of pardon. Manos wholie reiected baptisme, as vnprofi•able and not necessarie. Do we affirme any such thing? Wez denie (indeed) that baptisme confers grace to the vnbeleeuer by the worke wrought: he denied it to be profitable at all: are we like him? Austen and Epiphanius accompt Aerius for an Heretick, so did few of the auncient Fathers besides these. And if to condemne praiers for the dead, 5and make equall a Priest with a Bishop be hereticall, what shall be Catholick? Hierome was altogether of Aerius his mind, about equalitie of Priests; for he determines them to be equall with Bishops by Gods law. This was not that Aerius, 6whom they vsually called Atheist, but an other, Aetius; the likenes of the names deceiued you. To that you obiected concerning Vigilantius and Iouinian, an answere is formerly giuen;a
1Heretics.Heretikes.
xDVR. If you be a Calvinist, then this must needs be your doctrine, when as Calvin had so taken away all freedom, that he hath brought a necessity greater then Stoics fate. WHIT. pag. 882. I am a Christian, you a Jesuit; Calvin, as you well know, never took away the freedom of will, unless you reason thus: the will of man is not free in good things, before it be regenerate by the spirit of God, therefore there is no freedom of the will at all; which verily hath no strength of consequent in it.DVR. If you be a Caluinist, then this must needs be your doctrine, when as Caluin had so taken avvay all freedome, that he hath brought a necessitie greater then Stoickes fate. WHIT. pag. 882. I am a Christian, you a Iesuite; Caluin, as you wel know, neuer tooke away the freedome of will, vnlesse you reason thus: the will of man is not free in good things, before it be regenerate by the spirit of God, therfore there is no freedome of the will at all; which verily hath no strength of consequent in it.
yDVR. It was not for this, but because he took away the Sacrament of Penance, in which Priests do pardon sin. WHIT. pag. 882. Whether Penance was a Sacrament or no, was not the thing in question betwixt Novatus and the Catholics, but whether there was any place for repentance left unto those that did sin, that the Minister might assure thē of remission of sins, if they repented: we grant that this power is given to the Ministers of the Gospel; therefore we are far from the error of Novatus.DVR. It was not for this, but because he tooke away the Sacrament of Penance, in vvhich Priests do pardon sinne. WHIT. pag. 882. Whether Penance was a Sacrament or no, was not the thing in question betwixt Nouatus and the Catholikes, but whether there was any place for repentance left vnto those that did sinne, that the Minister might assure thē of remission of sins, if they repēted: we grant that this power is giuē to the Ministers of the Gospell; therefore we are far from the error of Nouatus.
zDVR. You take from Baptism all power to remit sins and confirre grace as the Manic•es do. And ye Calvinists deny that the deed done doth confirre grace to them who believe. WHIT. pag. 883. We believe and teach that in Baptism sins are forgiven, which the Manichees usually deny. Therefore we differ much from them. And as for the invention of the deed done we reject it, even in those who are endued with faith, for what need have we of any such invention, that grace is conferred and give by the deed done, if faith be not wanting?
These first we hate as hell it self; those last have committed nothing deserving the name of heretics. To set up and worship Images is heretical, but not to overthrow them. What you judge touching Luther and Caluin• is nothing material: whiles they lived they nothing regarded you, now they are dead they despise you, what will you conclude ⟨p. 318⟩at length from this heretical company? A•• these (you say) forsook the government of your Church, and were overthrown by them. Nay Campian, these were your forefathers, and you their progeny and successors: for your monster of Popery hath been hatched by the impure commixtion of all heresies.
These first we hate as hell it selfe; those last haue committed nothing deseruing the name of hereticks. To set vp and worship Images is hereticall, but not to ouerthrow them. What you iudge touching Luther and Caluin• is nothing materiall: whiles they liued they nothing regarded you, now they are dead they despise you, what will you conclude ⟨p. 318⟩at length from this hereticall companie? A•• these (you say) forsooke the gouerment of your Church, and were ouerthrowne by them. Nay Campian, these were your forefathers, and you their progenie and successors: for your monster of Poperie hath been hatched by the impure commixtion of all heresies.
But you now appear out of hell,1 and are come to land, and wheresoever you cast your eyes or thoughts, All is your own (as you say) all subject themselves, and subscribe to your religion. Me thinks I see that brainsick Merchant, who standing by the sea, and beholding the ships, cried out, all he saw was his own; otherwise such senseless dreams could not proceed, but from a wit and judgement exceedingly weakened.2 For (say you) the Roman succession witnesseth, in which Church (as Austen speaketh) the Primacy of the Apostolic chair hath always had the preeminence. Many causes there were, why special account in times past should be made of the church of Rome, especially for that Rome was the seat of the Empire, as approved in the Council held at Constantinople. 3bI grant therefore tha••his Church was accounted the supreme, chief, greatest, and the principal, preferred before other Churches. Trow you hence to conclude, the Bishop of Rome is the chief and principal Bishop or head of the Church?5 Austen himself forbid it in the Council of Carthage, viz. that the Bishop of the chief Sea should not be called Prince of Priests, or any like title. Although then the holy Fathers for divers respects gave the preeminence to the church of Rome, yet ⟨p. 319⟩••d they never acknowledgec that infinite p•••••••ll authority which he now challengeth, neither ••d other Apostolic Churches, whether they were founded by the Apostles themselves, or by some of their scholars, yield any testimony of truth to the church of Rome. Here you stick in a quagmire, and ••e fain by entreaty to beg that which by strong reason you should prove and cannot.
But you now appeare out of hell,1 and are come to land, and wheresoeuer you cast your eyes or thoughts, All is your own (as you say) all subiect themselues, and subscribe to your religion. Me thinks I see that brainsick Merchant, who standing by the sea, and beholding the ships, cried out, all he saw was his owne; otherwise such senselesse dreames could not proceed, but from a wit and iudgement exceedingly weakned.2 For (say you) the Romane succession witnesseth, in which Church (as Austen speaketh) the Primacie of the Apostolike chaire hath alwaies had the preeminence. Many causes there were, why speciall accompt in times past should be made of the church of Rome, especially for that Rome was the seate of the Empire, as approued in the Councell held at Constantinople. 3bI graunt therefore tha••his Church was accompted the supreme, chiefe, greatest, and the principall, preferred before other Churches. Trow you hence to conclude, the Bishop of Rome is the chiefe and principall Bishop or head of the Church?5 Austen himselfe forbid it in the Councell of Carthage, viz. that the Bishop of the chiefe Sea should not be called Prince of Priests, or any like title. Although then the holy Fathers for diuers respects gaue the preheminence to the church of Rome, yet ⟨p. 319⟩••d they neuer acknowledgec that infinite p•••••••ll authority which he now challengeth, neither ••d other Apostolike Churches, whether they were founded by the Apostles themselues, or by some of their schollers, yeeld any testimonie of truth to the church of Rome. Heere you stick in a quagmire, and ••e faine by intreatie to beg that which by strong reason you should prooue and cannot.
1Lands.
2Sedes Apostolica.
3Concil. Constantinop. 1. cap. 5.
bDVR. Why then may not he that is Bishop of this Church be over all other Bishops, and so the Prince of Priests, the chief Priest, and supreme head of the rest? WHIT. pag. 885. Because authority and dominion is not proper to them who are more excellent then others; which may be showed by infinite examples. Who can be ignorant that the tribe of Judah was the chief, the first and the Prince of the other tribes? will it therefore follow that the head of the principal family in this tribe had authority over all other tribes? Aristotle was accounted the prince of Philosophers, Homer of Poets, Hippocrates of Physicians, Apelles of Painters: did they therefore exercise authority over all the rest of the same profession? So though for a long time together the church of Rome for many respects was excellent among the rest, yet it never had domination and rule over the rest of the Churches of Christ.DVR. VVhy then may not he that is Bishop of this Church be ouer all other Bishops, and so the Prince of Priests, the chiefe Priest, and supreame head of the rest? WHIT. pag. 885. Because authoritie and dominion is not proper to them who are more excellēt then others; which may bee shewed by infinite examples. Who can be ignorant that the tribe of Iudah was the chiefe, the first and the Prince of the other tribes? will it therefore follow that the head of the principall family in this tribe had authoritie ouer all other tribes? Aristotle was accounted the prince of Philosophers, Homer of Poets, Hippocrates of Physitians, Apelles of Painters: did they therefore exercise authoritie ouer all the rest of the same profession? So though for a long time together the church of Rome for many respects was excellent among the rest, yet it neuer had domination and rule ouer the rest of the Churches of Christ.
5Concil. Carthag. 3. cap. 26. Dist. 99 prima sedis.
cDVR. This prohibition was given by the Fathers, because they knew that a• the sovereignty of the Apostolic Chair did ever flourish in the Roman Church, so they did not doubt but the manner of the chief Priest did appertain• only to the Bishop of Rome. WHIT. pag. 885. Nay, the prohibition of the Councell did as well concern the Bishop of Rome, whom all acknowledge to be the Bishop of the chief seat, as the Bishops of other Seas. Therefore for the time he obeyed the decree of the Councell, and was content with his names and refused to be called the sovereign chief Priest.
But you urge further, and recount the Pastors of several countries, to wha• end I pray you. The remainder•, say you, of the labours of all those that have published the Gospel in all nations far and wide, all, present unto us this same religion which Catholics at this day profess. What could be affirmed more weakly? for the Grecians are opposite unto you, which unto this time have their succession of Bishops not interrupted. And further, the spye• which you send in your new found lands, have found in the furthest coasts thereof many monuments of that faith which we maintain,1 neither may you prefer us before them, at least afore all, you ought to prefer the truth,2 as the Philosopher saith. But if you think your Popes and other glorious titles more ancient then the Gospel, what can you allege why Christ should not deny you to belong to him, seeing you value any thing more then him. Here you tell us of Princes, 3Kings, Caesars, Emperors, and make a goodly show of names, as your manner is. At length you mention our noble Queen• Elizabeth, and will needs teach her, her duty. But she, Campian, needs no such Masters, 4or instructors. She knoweth her self to be the nursing mother of the Church, and that by divine dispensation, and accordingly doth she with all watchfulness and care procure the good thereof, and labours by all possible diligence to prevent all dangers intended by you and your adherents. You say of Calvin and these Princes, ⟨image 179⟩[…] you have spoken, th•• […] heaven can no• contain them. But it passeth your skill to pronounce certainly hereof, nay your Pope himself cannot with all his might pull Calui•• out of heaven, not any of them whom Christ hath made witnesses of his truth. As for you and your fellows, we wish you not the gallows, but salvation. I desire to hope the best of you; and I doubt not but you might attain to the knowledge of the truth in controversy betwixt us, if for the time you could lay aside all prejudicate opinions, and consult with the word of God, and the holy Fathers of the Church. As for the society of Jesus, whereunto you are admitted, it braggeth that it is wholly at the Popes dispensation, and loves Gregory the 13. too well, to love Queen Elizabeth any thing at all, who is so far differing from him.5 You proceed, and produce the utmost coasts and countries of the world to testify for you:
But you vrge further, and recompt the Pastors of seuerall countries, to wha• end I pray you. The remainder•, say you, of the labours of all those that haue published the Gospell in all nations farrs and wide, all, present vnto vs this same religion which Cathol•kes at this day professe. What could be affirmed more weakely? for the Greeians are opposite vnto you, which vnto this time haue their succession of Bishops not interrupted. And further, the spye• which you send in your new found lands, haue found in the furthest coasts thereof many monuments of that faith which we mainteine,1 neither may you preferre vs before them, at least afore all, you ought to preferre the truth,2 as the Philosopher saith. But if you thinke your Popes and other glorious titles more auncient then the Gospell, what can you alleage why Christ should not denie you to belong to him, seeing you value any thing more then him. Heere you tell vs of Princes, 3Kings, C•sars, Emperours, and make a goodly shew of names, as your manner is. At length you mētion our noble Queen• Elizabeth, and will needs teach her, her dutie. But she, Campian, needs no such Masters, 4or instructiors. She knoweth her selfe to be the nursing mother of the Church, and that by diuine dispensation, and accordingly doth she with all watchfulnes and care procure the good thereof, and labours by all possible diligence to preuent all dangers intended by you and your adherents. You say of Caluine and these Princes, ⟨image 179⟩〈…〉 you haue spoken, th••〈…〉 heauen can no• containe thē. But it passe•h your skill to pronounce certainely hereof, nay your Pope himselfe cannot with all his might pull Calui•• out of heauen, not any of them whom Christ hath made witnesses of his truth. As for you and your fellowes, we wish you not the gallowes, but saluation. I desire to hope the best of you; and I doubt not but you might attaine to the knowledge of the truth in controuersie betwixt vs, if for the time you could lay aside all preiudicate opinions, and consult with the word of God, and the holy Fathers of the Church. As for the societie of Iesus, whereunto you are admitted, it braggeth that it is wholie at the Popes dispensation, and loues Gregory the 13. too well, to loue Queene Elizabeth any thing at all, who is so farre differing from him.
1Os•rius.
2Aristot.
3Princes.
4•say 48.
5Nations converted to Christ.Nations conuerted to Christ.
you should distinguish ancient and later times. For grant that the whole world had conspired with the Pope against Christ (which it hath not) that is no advantage to you, nor prejudice to us:d whosoever forsakes the Gospel, he is necessarily divided from the Church. To put to silence the oracles of the heathen Idols, and carry the name of Christ unto the Gentiles, was no doubt a great work, and a divine work: but that is none of your work, for you have filled the world with Idols, and as much as in you lay, overturned ⟨p. 321⟩the kingdom of Christ. The Idols of the he•••en have been o•e•••owne, and the kingdom of God enlarged by the Apostles and Apostolic men; •••e ••e o•e Papist, or one Jesuit amongst these. For the Jesuits, which assay to make new kingdoms amongst the Indians, serve not Christ, but the Pope: not do they enlarge the kingdom of Christ, but they prepare for the Pope a kingdom far from the Lutherans, where he may reign after he shall be banished from these countries.c You ask, is Christ divided? I answer, you Jesuits have divided him, else why have you separated Jesus from Christ, and leaving the ancient ordinary names of Christians, which you scorn as too common, you desire rather to be called Jesuits, a new name of your own framing, then Christians? As though there were some society of Jesus appropriated to one kind of men separated from other Christians; If there be, then is Christ divided, if not, then you Jesuits are too impudent to devise a new society.
you should distinguish auncient and later times. For graunt that the whole world had conspired with the Pope against Christ (which it hath not) that is no aduantage to you, nor preiudice to vs:d whosoeuer forsakes the Gospell, he is necessarily diuided from the Church. To put to silence the oracles of the heathen Idols, and carry the name of Christ vnto the Gentiles, was no doubt a great worke, and a diuine worke: but that is none of your worke, for you haue filled the world with Idols, and as much as in you lay, ouerturned ⟨p. 321⟩the kingdome of Christ. The Idols of the he•••en haue been o•e•••owne, and the kingdome of God enlarged by the Apostles and Apostolike men; •••e ••e o•e Papist, or one Ies•ite amongst these. For the Iesuites, which assay to make new kingdomes amongst the Indians, serue not Christ, but the Pope: not do they enlarge the kingdome of Christ, but they prepare for the Pope a kingdome farre from the Lutheranes, where he may raigne after he shall be banished from these countries.c You aske, is Christ diuided? I answere, you Iesuites haue diuided him, els why haue you separated Iesus from Christ, and leauing the auncient ordinary names of Christians, which you scorne as too common, you desire rather to be called Iesuites, a new name of your owne framing, then Christians? As though there were some societie of Iesus appropriated to one kind of men separated from other Christians; If there be, then is Christ deuided, if not, then you Iesuites are too impudent to deuise a new societie.
dDVR. You had spoken better, if you had said that he forsakes the Gospel, who affirmeth that the whole world conspire• against Christ. O miserable Calvinists, who cannot defend their saith otherwise, than by bereaving Christ of his kingdom, and the whole christian world of faith! WHIT. pag. 886. This is very true you say: but Duraeus, did we ever speak after this manner? Will you keep your custom of railing and slandering▪ even to the last act? Nay rather, O miserable Duraeus, who blinded with malice and ignorance, doth not feel your own misery? Not the whole world, but your Synagogue which is but a small part of the whole world, hath conspired against Christ. And is it to be feared, least Christ should loose his kingdom, and the world faith, if your shaveling with his whole rabble fall from the Gospel? Though you be perfidious and wicked, yet God will remain always faithful and true.DVR. You had spoken better, if you had said that he forsakes the Gospell, who affirmeth that the whole world conspire• against Christ. O miserable Caluinists, who cannot defend their saith otherwise, than by bereauing Christ of his kingdome, and the whole christian world of faith! WHIT. pag. 886. This is very true you say: but Duraeus, did we euer speak after this manner? Will you keepe your custome of rayling and slaundering▪ euen to the last act? Nay rather, O miserable Duraeus, who blinded with malice and ignorance, doth not feele your owne miserie? Not the whole world, but your Synagogue which is but a small part of the whole world, hath conspired against Christ. And is it to be feared, least Christ should loose his kingdome, and the world faith, if your shaueling with his whole rabble fall frō the Gospell? Though you be perfidious and wicked, yet God will remaine alwaies faithfull and true.
cDVR. You set upon our society, and say we have divided Christ. Because certain men have chosen unto them this name above all others, to be accounted of the society of Jesus; because they have consecrated themselves wholly to advance this name, must they therefore of necessity divide Christ? have not you Christ College in Oxford? WHIT. pag. 8•6. I will not strive much with you about your society, of which I •••e very small account. If you have for some special consideration dedicated your selves unto Christ, what is that consideration? why do you not tell us what Jesus requireth of you, which all other Christians are not bound to do? If the order of your profession require that you propagate honour, and magnify the name Jesus, if for this all Christians ought not to labour, at least Bishops, and specially your Pope: and if they be Jesuits who do this, why re not all your Divines, Bishops, Cardinals, and Popes Jesuits? It may be this care is arre from them. Whereas then name are for distinguishing of things, they be needless and vain, when there i no difference in the thing. Either show us what is the proper & peculiar duties of Jesuits, or confess that without any cause you have appropriated such a me unto them. In Cambridge aswell s in Oxford we have both Christ and Jesus College: but they that lie in those Colleges are called only Christians. Think you that because there are many Colleges different in names, there are many different Orders & professions of men? In places distinctions of names are necessary and without danger, unless some schism may happen betwixt y wls. Have you no other thing to say for your sect & society?
You say either we or he preach a wrong Christ. This ⟨p. 322⟩of necessity must be so. But Luther preached the true Christ, storm the Pope never so much: look then what Jesus, what Christ you have amongst you? the true Christ it is not. I beseech you, Campian, for Christs sake consider well whom you have forsaken, to whom you have betaken you, into what danger you have cast your self. But you will tell us who is the true Christ, I listen to hear it: let him b• true Christ, and on their side, by whose bringing in Dagon's neck was broken. With a good will. Christ by us preached, hath within these few years thrown down an infinite sort of your Dagons: for so soon as Christ accompanied with his Gospel got footing in any place, your Dagons out of hand fell down, and had not only their arms and legs broken, but necks also. Patrick in Ireland, and Palladius in Scotland, what they were I mean not to search. We Englishmen, I grant, received much good by Austen the Monk, and much evil also and superstition which he brought in with him. It is plain that we had received the Christian faith in Brittany many ages before his coming hither. How it was by him increased or hindered, I will not say. But he lived six hundred years after Christ; which as I judge was not the purest time of the Church, but as others affirm, the age was most corrupt.
You say either we or he preach a wrong Christ. This ⟨p. 322⟩of necessitie must be so. But Luther preached the true Christ, storme the Pope neuer so much: looke then what Iesus, what Christ you haue amongst you? the true Christ it is not. I beseech you, Campian, for Christes sake consider well whom you haue forsaken, to whome you haue betaken you, into what danger you haue cast your selfe. But you will tell vs who is the true Christ, I listen to heare it: let him b• true Christ, and on their side, by whose bringing in Dagons neck was broken. With a good will. Christ by vs preached, hath within these few yeares throwne downe an infinite sort of your Dagons: for so soone as Christ accompanied with his Gospell got footing in any place, your Dagons out of hand fell downe, and had not only their armes and legs broken, but necks also. Patrick in Ireland, and Palladius in Scotland, what they were I meane not to search. We Englishmen, I graunt, receiued much good by Austen the Monke, and much euill also and superstition which he brought in with him. It is plaine that we had receiued the Christian faith in Brittany many ages before his comming hither. How it was by him increased or hindred, I will not say. But he liued sixe hundred yeares after Christ; which as I iudge was not the purest time of the Church, but as others affirme, the age was most corrupt.
Now to conclude, because to prosecute all were infinite, you gather a heap of witnesses together, the Universities, written laws, the common fashions of all people, choice of Emperors, kingly rites, orders of Knighthood, habits, church windows, coins, gates, houses, all things great and small, unto all which I answer in a word, if an Angel from heaven should preach unto us an other Gospel then that which Christ hath taught, the Apostles published, our Churches now profess, we would reject and detest it, much less do we stand upon these toys of yours, ⟨p. 323⟩and ma••ers of •o•om•nt. The flourishing Universities, ancient law•, and i• all kinds, monuments of great antiquity, all these afford unto us an open testimony of the truth we profess. Thus have we heard your ten-fold Apology, wherein I perceive you have bestowed no small diligence; how you have therein prevailed, I leave the judgement to others. If you have satisfied none more therein then our University men, I can assure you, you have lost your labour, and are disappointed of your hope. For my own part though in this case I profess my self your adversary, yet your person (Campian) I love as far as a Christian may love a Jesuit. And I pray God the Father of Jesus Christ, that he would open the eyes of your mind, and direct you in his ways, least you cast away that silly soul so dearly bought which you desire to save. Therefore leave off to resist the truth, and wittingly to •ick against the prick, you cannot by force stop the waves of the sea, you cannot darken the beams of the sun, nor restrain the arm of God. Falsehood driven back shall give place, and truth at the length (resist while you will) shall have the victory.
Now to conclude, because to prosecute all were infinite, you gather a heape of witnesses together, the Vniuersities, written lawes, the common fashions of all people, choyce of Emperours, kingly rites, orders of Knighthood, habites, church windowes, coines, gates, houses, all things great and small, vnto all which I answere in a word, if an Angell from heauen should preach vnto vs an other Gospell then that which Christ hath taught, the Apostles published, our Churches now professe, we would reiect and detest it, much lesse do we stand vpon these toyes of yours, ⟨p. 323⟩and ma••ers of •o•om•nt. The florishing Vniuersitie•, auncient law•, and i• all kinds, monuments of great antiquitie, all these afford vnto vs an open testimonie of the truth we professe. Thus haue we heard your ten-fold Apollogy, wherein I perceiue you haue bestowed no small diligence; how you haue therein preuailed, I leaue the iudgement to others. If you haue satisfied none more therein then our Vniuersitie men, I can assure you, you haue lost your labour, and are disappointed of your hope. For my owne part though in this case I professe my selfe your aduersary, yet your person (Campian) I loue as farre as a Christian may loue a Iesuite. And I pray God the Father of Iesus Christ, that he would open the eyes of your mind, and direct you in his waies, least you cast away that silly soule so deerely bought which you desire to saue. Therefore leaue off to resist the truth, and wittingly to •ick against the prick, you cannot by force stop the waues of the sea, you cannot darken the beames of the sunne, nor restraine the arme of God. Falshood driuen back shall giue place, and truth at the length (resist while you will) shall haue the victorie.
for my part, I neither meane to defend them, nor can I greatly accuse th•m. If they were hereticks, conuince them of some error they held against the scriptures: Hieromes passions can make no man an heretick. Now you bring in the swarme of hereticks, Macedonians, Pelagiās, Nestorians, Eutychians, the M••otholites, and Iconomachs.
•
DVR. You take from Baptisme all power to remit sinnes and confirre grace as the Manic•es doe. And yee Caluinists deny that the deed done doth confirre grace to them vvho beleeue. WHIT. pag. 883. We beleeue and teach that in Baptisme sins are forgiuen, which the Manichies vsually deny. Therefore we differ much from them. And as for the inuention of the deed done we reiect it, euen in those who are indued with faith, for what neede haue wee of any such inuention, that grace is conferred and giue• by the deed done, if faith be not wanting?
5Hierou. ad Evag. & in 1. Tit.Hierou. ad Euag. & in 1. Tit.
6Socrat. lib. 2. cap. 35.
aDVR. You speak wittily, but you must of necessity do the one. WHIT. pag. 884. If they have defended any thing against the Scriptures, they are heretics; but if not, they cannot be condemned by the judgement of any Church.DVR. You speake vvit•ilie, but you must of necessity do the one. WHIT. pag. 884. If they haue defended any thing against the Scriptures, they are heretikes; but if not, they cannot bee condemned by the iudgement of any Church.
DVR. This prohibition was giuen by the Fathers, because they knew that a• the soueraignty of the Apostolike Chaire did euer flourish in the Romane Church, so they did not doubt but the manner of the chiefe Priest did appertain• onely to the Bishop of Rome. WHIT. pag. 885. Nay, the proh•bition of the Councell did as well concerne the Bishop of Rome, whom all acknowledge to be the Bishop of the chiefe seate, as the Bishops of other Seas. Therefore for the time he obeyed the decree of the Councell, and was content with his names and refused to be called the soueraigne chiefe Priest.
You proceed, and produce the vtmost coasts and countries of the world to testifie for you:
•
•
•
•
••
•
•
•
•
DVR. You set vpon our societie, and say vve haue diuided Christ. Because certeine men haue chosen vnto them this name aboue all others, to be accounted of the societie of Iesus; because they haue consecrated thēselues wholy to aduance this name, must they therefore of necessitie diuide Christ? haue not you Christ Colledge in Oxford? WHIT. pag. 8•6. I will not striue much with you about your societie, of which I •••e very small account. If you haue for some speciall consideration dedicated your selues vnto Christ, what is that consideration? why doe you not tell vs what Iesus requireth of you, which all other Christians are not bound to doe? If the order of your profession require that you propagate honour, and magnifie the name Iesus, if for this all Christians ought not to labour, at least Bishops, and specially your Pope: and if they be Ies•ites who doe this, why •re not all your Diuines, Bishops, Cardinals, and Popes Iesuites? It may bee this care is •arre from them. Whereas then name• are for distinguishing of things, they be needlesse and vaine, when there i• no difference in the thing. Either shew vs what is the proper & peculier duties of Iesuits, or confesse that without any cause you haue app•opriated such a ••me vnto thē. In Cambridge aswell •s in Oxford we haue both Christ and Iesus Colledge: but they that li•e in those Colledges are called onely Christians. Thinke you that because there are many Colledge• different in names, there are many differēt Orders & professions of men? In places distinctions of names are necessarie and without danger, vnlesse some schisme may happē betwixt y• w•ls. Haue you no other thing to say for your sect & societie?