The first, book against the errors of the Avababtistes, divided into dialogues, whereof, the enterloquutors are, Joiada, who representeth the true christen man▪ & Simon, that taketh the Avababtistes part.The fyrste, boke againste the errours of the Auababtistes, diuided into dialogues, wherof, the enterloquutors are, Ioiada, who representeth the true christen man▪ & Symon, that taketh the Auababtistes parte.
306 passagespart 3 of 8
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The .iiii. treatie, or dialoge touchynge simplicitee and erudicion.
Joiada. It is manifest and evident, that ye understand not the words ⟨image 43⟩of Christ. For if by the simple, he should understand them, that lack wisdom and learning (for so ye expound the words of Christ) truly no man should be more apt, than fools and dizzards, which be in deed ignorant in all manner of things. But every man doeth see, that it is against all reason, to think any such thing. Therefore Christ understandeth by simplicity an other thing.
Ioiada. It is manifeste and euident, that ye vnderstonde not the woordes ⟨image 43⟩of Chryst. For if by the symple, he shulde vnderstond them, that lacke wisedome and learnynge (for so ye expounde the wordes of Christ) truely no man shulde be more apt, than fooles and diserdes, whiche be in dede ignoraunt in all maner of thinges. But euery man dooeth see, that it is against al reason, to thinke any such thyng. Therfore Christ vnderstondeth by simplicitee an other thyng.
Joiada. He is called a simple man, not he that is without wit, without reason and wisdom, but he which is plain and sincere, and without fraud, he which is good, and true inwardly in his heart, being without craft and deceit. Else it would come to pass, that every man should defend ⟨image 44⟩his error, by ignorance. Which thing, what could be else, but a carnal malice or liberty, whereby every man would begin and go about, to boast and set forth his ignorance, and therewith to defend his errors? Who did ever see, such temerarious audacity, as these shameful renegades do use? that with their ignorance and rudeness dare defend any thing? By ignorance truly, errors are detected, and not confirmed.
Ioiada. He is called a symple man, not he that is without witte, without reason and wisdome, but he whiche is playne and sincere, and without fraude, he whiche is good, and true inwardly in his herte, beynge without crafte and deceit. Elles it woulde come to passe, that euery man shoulde defende ⟨image 44⟩his errour, by ignorancie. Whiche thyng, what coulde be elles, but a carnall malice or libertee, wherby euery man woulde begynne and goe about, to boaste and sette forthe hs ignorancie, and therewith to defende his errours? Who did euer see, suche temerarious audacitee, as these shamefull rennegates dooe vse? that with theyr ignorancie and rudenesse dare defende any thynge? By ignorauncy truely, errours are detected, and not confyrmed.
Joiada. Truly they were endued with such simplicity, as we have spoken of afore. But they were not unlearned and ignorant. For they ⟨image 44⟩were familiarly conversant with Christ, above three years, with Christ, I say, in whom are, all y• treasures wisdom of & knowledge, yea, which is himself, that eternal wisdom of y• heavenly father. Of this fountain drank they abundantly, by this master, were they instituted and taught, and at length were so endued, and illuminated with the holy ghost that they were •unnynge in all tongues & scriptures. That may be seen, both by their writings and also by their acts. As for that, that thou deniest, y• christ did call none, which were learned, doest thou not repugn here against y• manifest truth? Paul was exceedingly well learned.
Barnabas, Gamaliel, Nicodemus, & Apollo y• Alexandrian were great clerks. That in the ⟨image 45⟩mean season, I should pass over all the other, that is to say, Moses, which was learned in all the sciences of the Egyptians Stephen, Isaiah, Timothy, look better upon the .xiii. chap. of the first epistle, to the Corinthians, and upon the first chap. of the epistle, to Citus, and thou shalt find what erudition and learning an overseer or bishop ought to have. Therefore, these arrogant & presumptuous Anabaptists, can not excuse nor defend, their impudent ignorance, by simpleness, but that it is already manifest unto the world that they are given into a reprobate sense, as they, that be not ashamed, to boast, and to set forth unto all men, their ignorance, in stead of good learning, as though children, do not smell already, ⟨image 45⟩their craft & subtlety. But in y• mean season, no man ought thus, to interpret our sayings as though we should speak here, of them, that are falsely, called learned men. For we speak of such, as have ben taught, by god & to the glory of god. Of whom, there were many, in the primitive church, as Pantonus, Tertullian, Cyprian, Lactantius, Augustine, and many other.
Sy Thou speakest, with good reason. For we ought not to think that Christ did commend such simplicity, whereby the unconnynger that a man is, the bolder he should be. As many, which though they can scarcely read y• vulgar tongue, yet not withstanding, do without shame, ingerate & thrust them selves, in to y• office of preachers, stammering ⟨image 46⟩most foolishly in the common pulpit, But because they should not be found to be ignorant, in some thing: they begin first to excuse their ignorance, with such words. Be not ye offended, O brethren, that I am ignorant and unlearned. For the father, doeth manifest him self to the simple and unlearned. Finally, seeing that Christ, doeth promise, to his disciples such wisdom, and eloquence, that their adversaries, should not be able to withstand it (where as, on the contrary part, these men do reckon their ignorance, to be a glorious thing unto them) I may easily perceive, that these are not such simple persons as Christ doeth speak of, but rather such, as do clothe them selves, in sheep's skins, feigning ⟨image 46⟩them selves, to be sheep, but inwardly, within their hearts, are ravening wolves. But now, I pray thee, to take that away quickly, which offendeth me in the second conclusion.
Sy Thou speakeste, with good reasō. For we ought not to think that Chryste did commend such simplicitee, wherby the vnconnynger that a man is, the bolder he shoulde be. As many, whiche though thei can scarsely reade y• vulgare tonge, yet not withstandyng, doe without shame, ingerate & thrust them selues, in to y• office of preachers, stamering ⟨image 46⟩most foolysshely in the common pulpit, But because thei shulde not be founde to bee ignoraunt, in some thyng: they begyn first to excuse their ignorancie, with such woordes. Be not ye offended, obretherne, that I am ignorant and vnlearned. For the father, doeth manifest hym selfe to the symple and vnlerned. Finally, seyng that Christe, doeth promesse, to his disciples suche wisedome, and eloquence, that their aduersaries, should not be able to withstond it (where as, on the contrary part, these men doe recken their ignorancie, to be a glorious thyng vnto them) I mai easily perceiue, that these are not suche simple persons as Chryste doeth speake of, but rather such, as doe clothe them selues, in sheapes skinnes, faining
Joiada. AS for that, that thou gatherest, by this conclusion, y• so, it should not, be jaufull for every man, to speak and talk of god, thou goest far out of the way, and doest not un derstond my sayings. I speak of common preaching, and not of private communication or talk. For he that taketh upon him to be a common preacher, not being called, doeth raven as he, that maketh him self, by his own authority, a king or governor, making & calling together a particular Senate or ⟨image 47⟩counsel, & beginneth thus, of his own head, to rule and administrate the common wealth, commanding, and forbidding what so ever pleaseth him. Truly, no man, can do this, but that he shall be accused, not only of foolishness & disobedience, but also of tumultee, and high treason. Else, we do not deny, but that every man may talk of god, yea & may sing of him, according to the doctrine of Paul .iiii. Ephesy. And the more, that it is done, the better we allow it. But to separate him self from y• church to seek woods & corners, & there to assemble a company, to institute & ordain sects and to take upon them selves, being uncalled, & unsent, the office of preachers: not only, it hath no example, in y• holy scriptures, but ⟨image 48⟩hath ben judged and condemned always as heretical. But we will now, corroborate and strength these sayings, with holy scripture. In the epist. to the Rom. x. chap. Paul teacheth after this manner: who so ever calleth upon the name of the lord, shall be saved. But how can they call upon him, in whom they have not believed? and how shall they believe in him, of whom they have not hard? And how can they hear without a preacher? And again how shall they prea: the, except they be sent? By these words of Paul, we may perceive, that sending is very necessary, which doeth not equally pertain unto all men. For Paul .i. Corin. xii sayeth, that there be many gifts. And even as the body is one thing, ⟨image 48⟩and hath many limbs, which limbs, though they belong all to one body, yet nevertheless, have not all own office, in the body, so it is in the church, and mystical body of Christ.
God did put and ordain some, in the church, to be apostles, some to be prophets and interpreters of scriptures, some to be teachers, some to be potestates and rulers, sum to have the gifts of healing, sum to minister to the poor, sum to govern, and sum again to have the knowledge of tongues. If so be, that the office of teaching, should equally pertain unto all men: Paul would have said, that god had ordained all, to be prophets, and teachers, but he sayeth: he hath ordained sum to be ⟨image 49⟩apostles. &c. Why dare then the Anabaptists presume so much, as for to set them selves forth, by their own authority, to preach & to teach, against the doctrine of Paul? Hebrews .v. No man (sayeth he) doeth usurp, or presumptuously take that honour unto him self, but he, which is called by god, as Aaron, so christ did not glorify him self to be made bishop, but he that said unto him. Thou art my son and to day have I begotten thee. And in an other place: Thou art a priest for ever, after the order of Melchizedek. After this manner doeth John Baptist, testify of the mission and sending of Christ in the first, and third chapter of John. And of his own sending, doeth he him self speak, ⟨image 49⟩in the .i. cha. of John, saying: There was a man sent by god, whose name was John when he was also asked, by what authority he did teach and baptize, he did bring forth out of Isaiah and Malachi, a testimony and witness of his mission and sending. So the Apostles were both called and sent, as it appeareth, by the x. and .xxviii. of Matthew, by y• last of Mar. and .xx. of Jo. Paul doeth testify in y• beginning of his epistles, and specially in the epistle to y• Galatians, that he was called. In the .xiii. of the Act. he with Barnabas, is segregated by the holy ghost and sent to preach. In Moses also, & in all the prophets their mission and sending is manifested. But against them that do run, being not called, ⟨image 50⟩and without sending do preach, in the .xxiii. of Jeremiah, the lord speaketh thus They did run, but I sent them not.
God dyd putte and ordeyne some, in the churche, to be apostels, some to bee prophetes and interpretours of scriptures, some to bee teachers, some to bee potestates and rulers, summe to haue the giftes of healynge, summe to minister to the poore, summe to gouerne, and summe agayne to haue the knowledge of tonges. If so bee, that the offyce of teachyng, shulde equally perteine vnto al men: Paul would haue sayed, that god hadde ordeyned all, to bee prophettes, and teachers, but he sayeth: he hathe ordeyned summe to bee
Therefore, I do think, that this conclusion is sufficiently proved, and that it is manifest enough, that the Anabaptists do not in this thing, behave them selves well and godly, which, though they be not called, doingerate and thrust them selves, in to the office of preachers Which thing (as we do read) was never done by none of the Saints.
Therfore, I do thynke, that this conclusion is sufficiently proued, and that it is manifeste enough, that the Anababristes dooe not in this thyng, behaue them selues wel and godly, whiche, thowgh thei be not called, doingerate and thrust them selues, in to the office of preachers Which thyng (as we doe reade) was neuer done by none of the Saintes.
Simon. All this that thou hast brought, doeth nothing against the Anabaptists For they say, that they be sent, by the father, and by the holy ghost.
Symon. All this that thou hast brought, dooeth nothyng agaynste the Anababtistes For thei saie, that thei bee sent, by the father, and by the holy ghost.
Joiada. To what thing or for what purpose. Simon. To teach the truth, to preach ⟨image 50⟩of god, and to rebuke sin. Joiada. It is proved before (as thou thy self haste granted) that we do, the same thing, in those places, where the gospel is preached. What need have we then of this mission, and sending of the Anabaptists. To these places where the gospel is preached, god doeth not send men to plant and set errors, to move sedition, and to teach contrary doctrine, to the truth, to separate and make division in the church. But the Anabaptists, do all these things, therefore, they be not sent by god. For god, is not the god of dissension, but of peace, and concord, .i. Corin. xiiii.
Ioiada. To what thing or for what pourpose. Symo•. To teache the truthe, to preache ⟨image 50⟩of god, and to rebuke synne. Ioiada. It is proued before (as thou thy selfe haste graunted) that we dooe, the same thynge, in those places, where the gospell is preached. What neede haue we then of this mission, and sendynge of the Anababtistes. To these places where the gospell is preached, god dooeth not sende men to plante and set errours, to moue sedicion, and to teache contrary doctrine, to the truthe, to separat and make diuision in the churche. But the Anababtistes, dooe all these thynges, therfore, they bee not sente by god. For god, is not the god of dyssencion, but of peace, and concorde, .i. Corin. xiiii.
Joiada. They do say so in deed, ⟨image 51⟩but not truly. For Satan can transform and transfigurate him self into an angel of light ii. Corin .xi. but he is not therefore a good angel.
Ioiada. Thei doe saie so in dede, ⟨image 51⟩but not truely. For Sathan can transforme and transfigurate hym selfe into an angell of light ii. Corin .xi. but he is not therfore a good aungell.
Simon. Is it not written in the .iix. cha. of John, that he, which is of god speaketh the word of god? the Anabaptists do preach the word of god, therefore, they be sent of god.
Symon. Is it not written in the .iix. cha. of Iohn, that he, which is of god speaketh the woorde of god? the Anababtistes dooe preache the worde of god, therfore, they bee sent of god.
Joiada. The Anabaptists do ⟨image 51⟩the same, the refore they be not sent by god, though, they do never so much boast and crake, that they do preach the truth and word of god. Which thing, all the heretics did before, and Satan also doeth usurp the word of god, Matthew .iiii. but it followeth not, that he is sent by god. That saying, which thou hast brought out of the .iii. chapter of John, pertaineth only to Christ, who because y• he was come from god, hath perfect knowledge, of divine and heavenly things. Which thing John Baptist, goeth about to prove to his disciples.
Ioiada. The Anababtistes dooe ⟨image 51⟩the same, the refore they bee not sent by god, though, they dooe neuer so muche boast and crake, that thei doe preache the truthe and worde of god. Which thing, all the heretikes dyd before, and Sathan also dooeth vsurpe the worde of god, Mathew .iiii. but it foloweth not, that he is sent by god. That saiynge, whyche thou hast brought out of the .iii. chapiter of Iohn, perteyneth onely to Chryste, who because y• he was come frome god, hath perfite knowlage, of diuine and heauenly thynges. Which thing Iohn Babtiste, goeth about to proue to his disciples.
Joiada. It skilleth not what they say, which are nothing shamed to lye, as it shall manifestly ⟨image 52⟩appear hereafter. For sith that by this authority taken out of the. iii chapter of John, and applied to Christ alone, they ascribe unto them selves that, which belongeth to Christ only: who doeth not perceive and see, that they be enemies of the truth. We know, what slanderous words they do vomit out, and speak against us, calling us thieves, robbers, Antichrists, false prophets, and seductors. We do impute this to the weakness of the flesh, and forbear for Christs sake. We might clear our selves, if need were, & prove that they do belie us. But so they have need to prove, y• they be sent of god, by other things than by slanderous words and railings.
Ioiada. It skylleth not what they saie, whyche are nothynge shamed to lye, as it shall manyfestly ⟨image 52⟩appere hereafter. For sythe that by this authoritee taken out of the. iii chapiter of Iohn, and applied to Chryste alone, thei adscribe vnto them selues that, which belongeth to Chryste onely: who dooeth not perceiue and see, that thei be enemies of the truthe. We know, what sklanderous wordes thei doe vomite out, and speake agaynste vs, callyng vs theues, robbers, Antichristes, false prophetes, and seductors. We doe impute this to the weakenesse of the flesshe, and forbeare for Chrystes sake. We might cleare our selues, if nede were, & proue that thei doe beelye vs. But so thei haue nede to proue, y• thei be sent of god, by other thinges thē by sklanderous wordes and railinges.
Joiada. No doubt there is, but that they be ignorant, and know not, which way, god doeth call, & what are the tokens and signs of vocation and sending. For they, that are called & sent of god, are manifested by certain tokens and signs which do follow, that it may appear, that they be truly called and sent either by miracles, or by manifest vocation and sending, but specially by dexterity or aptness, integrity of life, constancy and steadfastness, erudition and learning, worthy such sending and vocation.
Ioiada. No doubt there is, but that thei be ignoraunt, and know not, whiche waie, god doeth call, & what are the tokens and signes of vocacion and sendyng. For thei, that are called & sent of god, are manifested by certaine tokens and signes whiche doe folow, that it maie appeare, that thei be truely called and sent either by miracles, or by manifest vocacion and sendynge, but specially by dexteritee or aptenesse, integreted of lyfe, constauncy and stedfastnesse, erudicion and learnynge, woorthy suche sendynge and vocacion.
Joiada. I will prove all, that I have ⟨image 53⟩[…] ⟨image 53⟩[…] ⟨image 54⟩said by the word of god. A little afore, that Christ did depart from his apostles, he did send them, unto the world, to preach the gospel, unto all creatures, but before, that they should take in hand this office, they should tarry a while in Nierusalem till they were endued with grace from above. For he did promise unto them, to send the promised spirit and comfort our of the father upon them. And after, that they had ones received the holy ghost, with it, they did receive, the knowledge of all sciences, speeches, & tongues. Luc. xxiiii. Act. ii. when Moses did draw back, and did bring many excuses, knowledgyng him self, to be without utterance, uneloquent, childish, and unmeet for that office, that god ⟨image 54⟩would have sent him to: the lord, did promise, that he would be in his mouth, as, he did also promise to his apostles, such mouth and wisdom, that no man should be able to resist against it. Matthew .x. Paul writing to Timothy and Titus, concerning the election of bishops, requireth such one, as, is apt to teach, able to exhort with wholesome doctrine, which can reuycte, and confound them, that resist and withsaie the truth .i. Timothy, iii. Titus .i. There Paul doeth forbid, that none of them, which were newly converted, should be admitted to the office of a preacher. Netherto, have I brought places and testimonies out of the scriptures, touching the learning, that ought ⟨image 55⟩to be in an overseer or bishop. Now shall we hear, what the scriptures do testify and witness concerning the miracles of them, that are sent. We do therefore allege here the wonders, that Moses did show, in Egypt and other innumerable signs, and tokens, that be written in the Acts, the manifest imposition of hands, and that they did receive the holy ghost visibly. Moreover that they, which be sent, ought to be lawfully elected and chosen by a common assent, we do dryng the first chapter of the Ats, upon the election of Mathias the vii. and .xiii. of the Acts upon the election of Steven Paul and Barnabas. The .xiii. chap.
also of the Acts doeth manifestly show, that Paul and Barnabas, ⟨image 55⟩when they had created, through all the churches by a general election priests or seniors, laying their hands upon them, and had made their prayers with fasting, did commit them unto the lord, in whom they had believed. Now thou seest, my Simon, that in y• times of the Apostles. every man did not rashly advance nor set for the him self to preach. For if it had ben so, what should have needed any election, and imposition of hands? But election was made after prayers & fasting. The same is also written in the epistle to Titus.
also of the Actes doeth manifestly shewe, that Paule and Barnabas, ⟨image 55⟩when thei had created, thorow all the churches by a generall election priestes or seniours, laiyng their handes vpon them, and had made theyr praiers with fastyng, did committe them vnto the lorde, in whome thei had beleued. Now thou seest, my Symon, that in y• times of the Apostels. euery man dyd not rasshely aduaunce nor sette for the hym selfe to preache. For if it hadde ben so, what shoulde haue neaded any election, and imposicion of handes? But election was made after praiers & fastyng. The same is also written in the epistell to Titus.
Jo. Not y• less jot, of all y• above rehearsed things, ergo they are not sent by god, but sensuality ⟨image 56⟩and impudent boldness, did impel & move them. For, what miracles do they? except, these are, to be called miracles, that they, with their pernicious doctrine, do bring men, out of their right, and godly mind, in to stark madness, or, that they, make the gammons, and legs of bacon, hanging in the larders, of the simple and poor people, invisible? What learning, should we look for, where rudeness, and (as they do speak themselves) simplicity, is taken for high rudicion? I do pass over here, many of them, which can scarcely read, yea and what will ye say of them, y• can read no manner of thing Are not these, y• neophytes (by y• neophytes, I mean not only them, that are newly converted, ⟨image 56⟩but such as do lack learning) that Paul do reject? But they promote them, that by all their lives time, did never read the Bibles, having only in readiness, certain sentences, not understood, which being, either plucked out, of all parts of scripture, or stolen, or else borrowed, of their guides & leaders, they do writhe, wrest & turn to contention, with all maledicence, & reviling. And so, standing among the simple people, have always in their tongues ends, y• father of heaven and the spirit. What name, my Simon, may conveniently, be given unto them? I may not call them apostles, for they are not sent, by god. Again, they do not preach where nothing hath ben yet preached of god but where y• people, hath ben a long ⟨image 57⟩[…] ⟨image 57⟩[…] ⟨image 58⟩season, & with the great labour of the true and faithful ministers, taught the way of truth there do they break in, destroying, perverting, &, as a storm or tempest, stirring up, all things, making the commons so perplexed, and doubtful, that they know neither end nor beginning. If any man, should call them prophets and expositors of the scriptures, it were none other thing, but to call a filthy swine, an excellent & cunning Musician. For they are ignorant in all manner of tongues, in so much, that they do contemn them, being content with y vulgar tongue only, If thou callest them doctors, they know nothing less, than the right way and trade of teaching, Besides, that they want the truth,
Why do y• lack then all such excellent gifts, as Paul requireth in a teacher or bishop In so much that they be unlearned, strivers, contentious and rude neophytes? Briefly they have nothing, that pertain to y• office of a teacher. Whereby any man may perceive, that the Anabaptists, are such, as do send them selves, being perplexed, seditious debateful, & ambitious heretics.
Why do y• lacke then al suche excellent giftes, as Paule requireth in a teacher or bishop In so much that thei be vnlearned, striuers, contencious and rude neophites? Briefly they haue nothyng, that perteine to y• office of a teacher. Wherby any man maie perceiue, that the Anababtistes, are suche, as doe send them selues, beyng perplexed, sedicious debatefull, & ambitious heretykes.
Jo. This sending, & election, maketh me, to remember y• bishop of ⟨image 59⟩Rome, for after, that the bishop of Rome, did ones get & purchase unto him self, through disobedience, tyranny and pernicious craft, such great power: by and by, did he promote to bishoprics, every mule keeper, bawds and bloody soldiers▪ But, who did teach them, to sever and divide the church, being united, and glued with faith, and charity? seeing that there is but one God, one faith one baptism, and one church? Who hath sent the authors of this sect, to make and congregate a new church? Truly, emulation, envy, strife, contention, avarice, ambition, and stiff pertinacy. I could well and sufficiently prove all these things. except, I should here wittingly, spare some people. ⟨image 59⟩Their Church therefore, is not the Church of God, but a certain sect, and congregation of styffenecked and disobedient people, among whom, there is no more just election, then is in the company of rebels & traitors, which forsaking their own prince or governor, do retchely, & without advisement choose, this man or that man, to be their Captain. But let us grant, that it is a Church, yet not withstanding, they err in election, which is not used among them, according to the precepts of the apostle, Donatus, did gather a particular Church. Nonatus likewise, & both in Africa. And yet not withstanding, none of them both, was called or sent by god. And their Church also, were ⟨image 60⟩no Churches, but conventicles or assembles of Heretics.
Io. This sendyng, & election, maketh me, to remēbre y• bishop of ⟨image 59⟩Rome, for after, that the bisshop of Rome, dyd ones get & pourchasse vnto hym selfe, thorowgh disobedience, tirannie and pernicious crafte, suche great power: by and by, dyd he promote to bisshoprykes, euery mule keper, bawdes and blody souldyours▪ But, who did teache them, to seuer and diuide the churche, beynge vnited, and glued with faithe, and charitee? seynge that there is but one God, one faythe one babtyme, and one churche? Who hathe sent the authours of this secte, to make and congregate a new churche? Truely, amulacion, enuy, strife, contencion, auaryce, ambicion, and stiffe pertinacy. I could wel and sufficiently proue all these thynges. except, I shoulde here wittyngly, spare some people.
Simon. What thinkest thou by the saying of s, Paul .i. Corin. xiiii. where he doth give free liberty, unto all men to preach, or interpret the Scriptures.
Symon. What thynkest thou by the saiyng of s, Paule .i. Corin. xiiii. where he doth geue free libertie, vnto all men to preache, or interprete the Scriptures.
Joiada. I am of the same self opinion, that Paul is: Two or three (saith he) may speak in the church: Let the other hear and judge. Finally, if it be revelated to an other sitting by, let the other hold his peace.
And by and by it followeth: For ye may all prophecy, one after another, that all may learn and have consolation.
Ioiada. I am of the same selfe opinion, that Paule is: Two or three (sayth he) may speake in the church: Let the other heare and iudge. Finally, if it be reuelated to an other syttyng by, let the other holde his peace.
And by and by it followeth: For ye may al prophecy, one after another, that all may learne and haue cousolacion.
Simon. By these words, it appeareth. that Paul doth not give liberty to every man, to preach what he listeth, when he nameth ii. or .iii. and biddeth the other ⟨image 60⟩to hear, & to give attendance to that that the Prophets (in the new Testament, such, as do expound the scriptures are called Prophets) do expound and set forth out of the scriptures. Nor he doth not give licence to the hearers, to interrupt the sermons of the Prophets, except it be, when any thing is left or perversely expounded by the Prophet, or interpreter. By this, it followeth, that it is not seemly ne comely, that any man should interrupt, if the truth be sufficiently enucleated & showed, much less, that any man should, under such pretence and colour sew in, or bring in his errors. I do see & perceive, that the effect of the matter doeth consist, in this thing: If it be necessary, if any ⟨image 61⟩thing be omitted and left, by them that are Prophets, that ought not to be omitted, or which being left, may do harm: and again, which being showed, may edify the church, that then it may be showed unto them, by any man, but that, with all soberness and charity. If nothing be wanting or lacking, all the audience to hold their peace.
Symon. By these wordes, it appeareth. that Paule dothe not geue libertie to euery man, to preache what he listeth, whē he nameth ii. or .iii. and byddeth the other ⟨image 60⟩to heare, & to geue attendance to that that the Prophetes (in the newe Testament, suche, as do expounde the scriptures are called Prophetes) do expounde and set furthe out of the scriptures. Nor he doth not gyue lysence to the hearers, to interrupte the sermons of the Prophetes, excepte it be, when any thyng is lefte or peruersly expounded by the Prophet, or interpretor. By this, it foloweth, that it is not semely ne comely, that any mā shuld interrupt, if the truthe be sufficiētly enucleated & shewed, muche lesse, that any man shoulde, vnder suche pretence and colour sewe in, or bring in his errors. I doo see & perceiue, that the effecte of the matter doeth consist, in thys thyng: If it be necessary, if any ⟨image 61⟩thyng be omitted and lefte, by them that are Prophetes, that oughte not to bee omitted, or whiche beynge lefte, maye dooe harme: and agayne, which being shewed, may edifi the churche, that then it may be shewed vnto them, by any mā, but that, with al sobrenesse and charitie. If nothing be wanting or lackynge, all the audience to holde their ptace.
Joiada. Thou takest the right sense of it. For it followeth by and by: The spirit of the Prophets, is subject to the Prophets. For God is not the author of confusion, but of peace. The Holy ghost doth not break forth rashly, & with affection and strife, but is treatable: nor he doeth not stiffly contend for every light matter, but suffereth him self to be instructed, ⟨image 61⟩and taught: & so giveth easily place, to him that hath better understanding. But the Anabaptists are far from all such things, boasting nevertheless a spirit, but as Judas did boast his Apostleship: saint James, did not without a cause, warn us, saying: Let not many masters be among you, knowing that we shall receive greater damnation or judgement, that is to say: we that are teachers.
Ioiada. Thou takest the ryght sense of it. For it foloweth by and by: The spirite of the Prophetes, is subiect to the Prophetes. For God is not the auctor of confusiō, but of peace. The Holy ghost doth not breake furth rashely, & with affection and stryfe, but is treatable: nor he dooeth not styffely contende for euery lyght matter, but suffereth him self to be instructed, ⟨image 61⟩and taughte: & so geueth easely place, to him that hathe better vnderstandyng. But the Anababtistes are farre from al such thinges, boastyng neuerthelesse a spirit, but as Iudas did boast his Apostleship: sayut Iames, dyd not without a cause, warne vs, saiyng: Let not many masters be among you, knowynge that we shall receyue greatter dampnaciō or iudgement, that is to say: we that are teachers.
Ioiada. Truely thei were endued with such simplicitee, as we haue spoken of afore. But they were not vnlerned and ignoraunt. For they ⟨image 44⟩were familiarly cōuersant with Chryste, aboue three yeares, wt Christ, I say, in whom are, all y• treasures wisdō of & knowlage, yea, which is hymself, yt eternal wisedome of y• heauenly father. Of this fountaine drāke they abundantly, by this maister, wer thei instituted and tawght, and at lengthe were so endued, and illuminated with the holy ghost that they were •unnynge in all tonges & scriptures. That may be sene, bothe by their writyngs and also by theyr actes. As for that, that thou denaiest, y• christ did call none, whiche were learned, doest thou not repugne here agaīst y• manifest truthe? Paull was excedyngly well lerned.
Barnabas, Gamaliell, Nicodedemus, & Apollo y• Alexandrian were great clerkes. That in the ⟨image 45⟩meane season, I shulde passe ouer all the other, that is to saie, Moises, whiche was learned in al the sciences of the Egipcians Steauen, Esaie, Timothe, loke better vpon the .xiii. chap. of the first epistel, to the Corinthians, and vpon the first chap. of the epistell, to Citus, and thou shalt fynde what erudicion and learnynge an ouerseer or bisshoppe ought to haue. Therfore, these arrogant & presumptuous Anababtistes, can not excuse nor defende, their impudent ignorancie, by simplenes, but that it is alredy manifest vnto the world yt they are geuen into a reprobate sence, as thei, that be not ashamed, to boast, and to set forth vnto all men, their ignorancie, in stede of good learnynge, as though children, do not smel alredy, ⟨image 45⟩their craft & subtiltee. But in y• meane seasō, no man ought thus, to interprete our saiynges as though we shuld speake here, of them, that are falsely, called learned men. For we speake of such, as haue ben taught, by god & to the glory of god. Of whom, there were many, in the primitiue churche, as Pātonus, Tertulian, Cyprian, Lactantius, Augustine, and many other.
⟨image 46⟩
them selues, to be sheapes, but inwardely, within theyr hertes, are rauenyng wolues. But now, I praye the, to take that awaye quickely, whyche offendeth me in the seconde conclusion.
Ioiada. AS for that, that thou gatherest, by this cō clusion, y• so, it shulde not, be iaufull for euery man, to speake and talke of god, thou goest far out of the waie, and doest not vn derstond my saiynges. I speake of common preachyng, and not of priuate communicacion or talke. For he that taketh vpon hym to be a common preacher, not being called, doeth rauen as he, that maketh hym selfe, by his owne authoritee, a kyng or gouernour, makyng & callyng together a particuler Senate or ⟨image 47⟩counseill, & beginneth thus, of his owne heade, to rule and administrate the common welthe, commaunding, and forbiddyng what so euer pleaseth him. Truly, no man, can dooe this, but yt he shalbe accused, not onely of folishenesse & disobedience, but also of tumultee, and high treason. Elles, we do not denaie, but yt euery man maie talke of god, yea & maie synge of him, accordyng to ye doctrine of Paule .iiii. Ephesy. And the more, yt it is done, the better we alow it. But to separate him self frō y• church to seke woods & corners, & there to assemble a company, to institute & ordein sectes and to take vpon them selues, beyng vncalled, & vnsent, the office of preachers: not onely, it hath no example, in y• holy scriptures, but ⟨image 48⟩hath ben iudged and condemned alwais as heretikall. But we will now, corroborate and strength these saiynges, with holy scripture. In the epist. to the Rom. x. chap. Paule teacheth after this maner: who so euer calleth vpon the name of the lorde, shalbe saued. But how can thei call vpon hym, in whome they haue not belued? and how shal thei beleue in hym, of whom thei haue not harde? And how can they heare without a preacher? And agayne how shal thei prea: the, except thei be sent? By these wordes of Paule, we maie perceiue, that sendyng is veary necessary, whiche doeth not equally pertaine vnto all men. For Paule .i. Corin. xii saieth, that there be many giftes. And eauen as the body is one thynge, ⟨image 48⟩and hath many lymmes, which lymmes, though thei belong all to one body, yet neuerthelesse, haue not all owne offyce, in the body, so it is in the churche, and misticall body of Chryste.
⟨image 49⟩
apostels. &c. Why dare then the Anababtistes presume so much, as for to set them selues forthe, by their own autoritee, to preache & to teach, againste the doctrine of Paule? Hebrues .v. No man (saieth he) doeth vsurpe, or presumptuousli take that honor vnto hym selfe, but he, which is called by god, as Aarō, so christ did not glorifie hym selfe to bee made bisshoppe, but he that saied vnto hym. Thou art my sonne and to daye haue I begotten the. And in an other place: Thou arte a priest for euer, after the order of Melchysedecke. After this maner dooeth Iohn Babtiste, testifye of the mission and sendynge of Chryste in the fyrste, and thyrde chapiter of Iohn. And of his owne sendyng, doeth he hym selfe speake,
⟨image 49⟩
in the .i. cha. of Iohn, saiynge: There was a man sente by god, whose name was Iohn when he was also asked, by what authoritee he did teache and babtize, he did bryng forthe out of Esaie and Malachie, a testimony and witnesse of his mission and sendyng. So the Apostelles were bothe called and sent, as it appeareth, by the x. and .xxviii. of Mathew, by y• last of Mar. and .xx. of Io. Paule doeth testifie in y• begynnyng of his epistels, and specially in the epistell to y• Galathiās, that he was called. In the .xiii. of the Act. he with Barnabas, is segregated by the holy ghost and sent to preache. In Moises also, & in all the prophetes their mission and sendyng is manifested. But agaynst them that dooe renne, beyng not called,
⟨image 50⟩
and without sendyng doe preache, in the .xxiii. of Hieremy, the lorde speaketh thus Thei did renne, but I sent them not.
Ioiada. I wyll proue all, that I haue ⟨image 53⟩〈…〉⟨image 53⟩〈…〉⟨image 54⟩saied by the worde of god. A littell afore, that Chryste did departe from his apostels, he did sende them, vnto the worlde, to preache the gospel, vnto all cretures, but before, yt thei shoulde take in honde this offyce, they shulde tary a while in Nierusalem till they were endued with grace frome aboue. For he dyd promise vnto them, to sende the promised spirit and comfort our of the father vpon them. And after, that thei had ones receiued the holy ghost, with it, thei did receiue, the knowlage of all sciences, speches, & tongues. Luc. xxiiii. Act. ii. whan Moises dyd draw backe, and did bryng many excuses, knowledgyng hym selfe, to bee without vtterance, vneloquent, chyldisshe, and vnmete for that offyce, that god ⟨image 54⟩woulde haue sent hym to: the lord, did promise, that he would be in his mouth, as, he dyd also promise to his apostelles, suche mouth and wisedome, that no man shoulde bee able to resyste agaynste it. Mathew .x. Paule writynge to Tymothe and Titus, concernyng the election of bysshoppes, requireth such one, as, is apte to teache, able to exhorte with wholsome doctrine, whyche can reuycte, and confounde them, that resyste and withsaie the truthe .i. Timothe, iii. Titus .i. There Paule doeth forbydde, that none of them, whyche were newly conuerted, shoulde be admitted to the office of a preacher. Netherto, haue I brought places and testimonies out of the scriptures, touchyng the learnyng, that ought ⟨image 55⟩to be in an ouerseer or bysshop. Now shall we heare, what the scriptures doe testifie and witnesse concernyng the miracles of them, that are sent. We dooe therfore alleage here the wonders, that Moyses did shewe, in Egypte and other innnmerable signes, and tokens, that bee written in the Actes, the manifeste imposicion of handes, and that thei dyd receiue the holy ghost visebly. Moreouer that thei, whiche be sent, ought to be laufully elected and chosen by a common assent, we dooe dryng the first chapiter of the Attes, vpon the election of Mathias the vii. and .xiii. of the Actes vpon the election of Steuen Paule and Barnabas. The .xiii. chap.
•
⟨image 58⟩
which is chiefly required in a teacher. But peradventure, they will be called bishops and shepherds.
Io. Not y• lesse iote, of al y• aboue rehersed thīges, ergo thei are not sēt by god, but sēsualitee ⟨image 56⟩and ipmpudent boldenesse, dyd impell & moue them. For, what myracles doe thei? except, these are, to be called miracles, that they, with their pernicious doctrine, dooe brynge men, out of their right, and godly minde, in to starke madnesse, or, that thei, make the gammons, and legges of bakon, hangynge in the larders, of the symple and poore people, inuisible? What learnynge, should we loke for, where rudenes, and (as thei do speake themselues) simplicitee, is taken for hyghe rudicion? I dooe passe ouer here, many of them, whiche can scarcely reade, yea and what wyll ye saie of them, y• can reade no maner of thyng Are not these, y• neophites (by y• neophites, I meane not onely them, that are newly conuerted, ⟨image 56⟩but such as doe lacke learnyng) that Paule do reiecte? But thei promote them, that by all their lyues tyme, did neuer reade the Bybles, hauyng onely in readinesse, certaine sentences, not vnderstonded, which beyng, either plucked out, of al partes of scripture, or stolen, or els borowed, of their gydes & leaders, thei dooe wrethe, wrast & turne to contencion, wt all maledicence, & reuilyng. And so, stondyng among the simple people, haue alwais in their tonges endes, y• father of heauen and the spirite. What name, my Symon, maie conueniently, be geuen vnto them? I maie not call them apostels, for thei are not sent, by god. Again, thei do not preache wher nothīn hath ben yet preached of god but where y• people, hath ben a long ⟨image 57⟩〈…〉⟨image 57⟩〈…〉⟨image 58⟩season, & with the great labour of the true and faithfull ministers, taught the waie of truthe there doe thei breake in, destroiyng, peruertyng, &, as a storme or tempest, stirryng vp, all thinges, makyng the commons so perplexed, and doubtfull, that thei know neither ende nor begynnyng. If any man, shoulde call them prophetes and expositours of the scriptures, it were none other thyng, but to call a filthy swine, an excellent & cunning Musician. For thei are ignorant in al maner of tongues, in so muche, that thei doe contemne them, being content with y• vulgare tongue onely, If thou callest thē doctours, they know nothynge lesse, than the right waie and trade of teachyng, Besides, that thei want the truthe, ⟨image 58⟩whiche is chiefly required in a teacher. But paraduenture, thei will be called bishops and sheapherdes.
⟨image 59⟩
Their Churche therfore, is not the Churche of God, but a certayne secte, and congregacion of styffenecked and disobedient people, among whom, there is no more iust election, then is in the company of rebelles & traytours, whiche forsakyng their owne prince or gouernour, doo retchely, & without aduisement chuse, thys man or that man, to be their Capitayne. But let vs graunt, that it is a Church, yet not withstandyng, they erre in election, whiche is not vsed among them, accordyng to the preceptes of the apostle, Donatus, dyd gather a particuler Church. Nonatus lykewyse, & bothe in Affrica. And yet not withstandynge, none of theim both, was called or sent by god. And their Churche also, were
⟨image 60⟩
no Churches, but conuenticles or assembles of Heretikes.