1Now where you gather of the words of S. Augustine, De verbis Domini, §6that both the evil and good eat one body of Christ, the selfsame in substance,2 excluding all difference that devise of figure might imagine, to this I answer, that although you express the body of Christ, with what terms you can devise, calling it (as you do in deed) the flesh that was borne of the virgin Mary, the same flesh, the flesh it self, yet I confess that it is eaten in the sacrament. And to express it yet more plainly then peradventure you would have me, I say, that the same visible & palpable flesh that was for us crucified and appeared after his resurrection, and was seen, felt, and groped, and ascended into heaven, and there sitteth at his fathers right hand, and at the last day shall come to judge the quick & the dead, that self same body, having all the parts of a mans body, in good order and proportion, and being visible and tangible, I say is eaten of christen people at his holy supper, what will you now require more of me, concerning the truth of the body? I suppose you be sorry that I grant you so much, and yet what doth this help you? For the diversity is not in the body, but in the eating thereof, no man eating it carnally, but the good eating it both sacramentally and spiritually, and the evil only sacramentally, that is to say, figuratively. And therefore hath S. Augustine these words (Certo quodam modo, after a certain manner) because that the evil eat the sacrament, which after a certain manner, is called the very body of Christ: which manner S. Augustine himself declareth most truly and plainly in a pistle ad Bonifacium, 3saying: If sacraments had not some similitude or likeness of those things whereof they be sacraments, they could in no wise be sacraments. And for their similitude and likeness, they have commonly the name of the things whereof they be sacraments. Therefore after a certain manner the sacrament of Christs body is. Christs body the sacrament of Christs blood is Christs blood. This epistle is set out in my book the 64. leaf, which I pray the reader to look upon for a more full answer unto this place. And after that manner Judas and such like did eat the morsel of the lords bread, but not the bread that is the Lord, but a sacrament thereof which is called the Lord, as S. Augustine saith.
1Now where you gather of the wordes of S. Augustine, De verbis Domini, §6that both the euill and good eat one body of Christ, the selfesame in substance,2 excluding all difference that deuise of fygure might imagine, to this I aunswere, that although you expresse the bodye of Christ, with what tearmes you can deuise, calling it (as you do in deed) the flesh yt was borne of the virgine Mary, the same flesh, the flesh it selfe, yet I confesse that it is eaten in the sacrament. And to expresse it yet more playnely then paraduenture you would haue me, I say, that the same visible & palpable flesh that was for vs crucified and appeared after his resurrection, and was seene, felt, and groped, and ascended into heauen, and there sitteth at his fathers right hand, and at the last day shall come to iudge the quick & the dead, that selfe same body, hauing all the partes of a mans body, in good order and proportion, and being visible and tangible, I say is eaten of christen people at his holy supper, what will you now require more of me, concerning the truth of the body? I suppose you be sory that I graunt you so much, and yet what doth this helpe you? For the diuersitie is not in the body, but in the eating therof, no man eating it carnally, but the good eating it both sacramentally and spiritually, and the euill onely sacramentally, that is to say, figuratiuely. And therfore hath S. Augustine these wordes (Certo quodam modo, after a certayne manner) bicause that the euill eate the sacrament, which after a certayne manner, is called the very body of Christ: which maner S. Augustine himselfe declareth most truely and playnly in a pistle ad Bonifacium, 3saying: If sacramentes had not some similitude or likenes of those thinges wherof they be sacraments, they could in no wise be sacramentes. And for theyr similitude and likenes, they haue commonly the name of the thinges wherof they be sacraments. Therfore after a certayne manner the sacrament of Christes body is. Christes body the sacrament of Christes bloud is Christes bloud. This epistle is set out in my booke the 64. leafe, which I pray the reader to looke vpon for a more full answer vnto this place. And after that maner Iudas and such like did eat ye morsell of the lordes bread, but not the bread that is the Lord, but a sacrament therof which is called the Lord, as S. Augustine sayth.
- 1August. de verbis Domini ser. 11.
- 2The self same flesh yt was crucified & is sensible, is eaten of Christen people.The selfe same flesh yt was crucified & is sensible, is eaten of Christē people.
- 3August. ad Bonifacium episto. 23.