And one thing is principally to be noted in your answer to Theodoret §3how you can sophisticate and falsify all mens sayings, be they never so plain. For where between me and the Papists the matter here in contention is this. Whether the bread and wine remain in their proper nature and substance or no. I saying that they remain, and the Papists saying that they remain not, the Issue being in this point whether they remain, or remain not, I bring for me Chrysostom (who saith, the nature of bread remaineth:) I bring Gelasius, (who saith, that there ceaseth not the substance or nature of bread and wine) I bring this Theodoret, whose words be these: The bread and wine after consecration lose not their proper nature, but keep their former substances, form and figure. Now how can any man devise to speak the truth in more plain words than these be? For they say the very same words that I say. And yet because the truth is not liked, here must be devised a crafty Lawyers gloss, of them that never sought other, but to calumniate the truth, and must be said (against all learning, reason and speech) that substance is taken for the visible and palpable qualities or accidents: well yet then you confess that those old ancient Authors agree with me in words, and say as I do, that the bread and wine be not transubstantiated, but remain in their former substance: And then the issue plainly passeth with me by the testimony of these three witnesses, until such time as you can prove that these authors spake one thing, and meant an other, and that qualities and accidents be substances. And if you understood whereunto §4the argument of Theodoret and Gelasius tendeth, you would not say that they spake against the Eutiches, any more then they do against the Nestorians. For if the bread and wine remain not (as you say) but be ⟨p. 323⟩swallowed up of the body and blood of Christ, then likewise in the principal mystery, either the deity must be swallowed up of the humanity, or the humanity of the deity. The contrary whereof is not only against the Eutychians, but also against the Nestorians, Marcionists, and all other that denied any of his two natures to remain perfectly in Christ.
And one thing is principally to be noted in your answere to Theodoret §3how you can sophisticate and falsefy all mens sayinges, be they neuer so playne. For where betweene me and the Papistes the matter here in contention is this. Whether the bread and wine remayne in their proper nature and substauce or no. I saying that they remayne, and the Papistes saying that they remayne not, the Issue being in this poynt whether they remayne, or remayne not, I bring for me Chrisostome (who sayth, the nature of bread remayneth:) I bring Gelasius, (who sayth, that there ceaseth not the substance or nature of bread and wine) I bring this Theodoret, whose wordes be these: The bread and wine after consecration lose not their proper nature, but keepe their former substances, forme and figure. Now how can any man deuise to speake the truth in more playne wordes than these be? For they say the very same wordes that I say. And yet bicause the truth is not liked, here must be deuised a crafty Lawyers glose, of them that neuer sought other, but to calumniate the truth, and must be sayd (agaynst all learning, reason and speach) that substance is taken for the visible and palpable qualities or accidents: well yet then you confesse that those olde auncient Authors agree with me in wordes, and say as I do, that the bread and wine be not transubstantiated, but remayne in their former substance: And then the issue playnly passeth with me by the testimony of these three witnesses, vntill such tyme as you can proue that these authors spake one thing, and ment an other, and that qualities and accidents be substances. And if you vnderstoode whereunto §4the argument of Theodoret and Gelasius tendeth, you would not say that they spake agaynst the Eutiches, any more then they do agaynst the Nestorians. For if the bread and wine remayne not (as you say) but be ⟨p. 323⟩swallowed vp of the body and bloud of Christ, then likewise in the principall mistery, eyther the deity must be swallowed vp of the humanity, or the humanity of the deity. The contrary wherof is not onely agaynst the Eutichians, but also agaynst the Nestorians, Martionistes, and all other that denied any of his two natures to remayne perfectly in Christ.