And not of like sort, but of like evilness do you handle (in reprehending of my second untruth as you call it) an other place of S. Augustine in his book de doctrina Christiana, 1where he saith, that the eating and drinking of Christs flesh and blood is a figurative speech: which place you expound so far from S. Augustine's meaning,2 that who soever looketh upon his words, may by and by discern that you do not, or will not understand him. But it is most like (the words of him being so plain and easy) that purposely you will not understand him, nor nothing else that is against your will, rather then you will go from any part of your will and received opinion. For it is plain and clear that S. Augustine in that place speaketh not one word of the separation of the two natures in Christ, and although Christs flesh be never so surely and inseparably united unto his Godhead (without which union it could profit nothing) yet being so joined, it is a very mans flesh, the eating whereof (after the proper speech of eating) is horrible and abominable. Wherefore the eating of Christs flesh must needs be otherwise understanded, then after the proper and common eating of other meats with the mouth, which eating after such sort could avail nothing. And therefore S. Augustine in that place declareth the eating of Christs flesh to be only a figurative speech. And he openeth the figure so, as the eating must be meant with the mind, not with the mouth: that is to say, by chawing and digesting in our minds, to our great consolation and profit, that Christ dyed for us. Thus doth S. Augustine open the figure and meaning of Christ when he spake of the eating of his flesh, and drinking of his blood. And his flesh being thus eaten, it must also be joined unto his divinity, or else it could not give everlasting life, as Cyril and the council Ephesin truly ⟨p. 26⟩decreed. But S. Augustine declared the figurative speech of Christ to be in the eating, not in the union. And where as to shift of the plain words of Christ, spoken in the sixth of John,3 he that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me and I in him: you say that dwelling in Christ is not §4the manducation. You say herein directly against S. Cyprian,4 who saith: quod mansio nostra in ipso, sit manducatio, that our dwelling in him, is the eating. And also against S. Augustine,5 whose words be these:
And not of like sort, but of like euilnes doe you handle (in reprehending of my seconde vntruth as you call it) an other place of S. Augustine in his booke de doctrina Christiana, 1where he sayth, that the eating and drinkinge of Christes flesh and bloud is a figuratiue speach: which place you expound so farre from S. Augustines meaning,2 that who soeuer looketh vpon his wordes, may by and by discern that you do not, or wil not vnderstand him. But it is most like (the words of him being so plain and easy) that purposely you will not vnderstand him, nor nothing els that is against your will, rather then you will goe from any part of your will and receaued opinion. For it is plain and cleare that S. Augustine in that place speaketh not one worde of the separation of the two natures in Christ, and although Christs flesh be neuer so surely and inseparably vnited vnto his Godhead (without which vnion it could profite nothing) yet being so ioyned, it is a very mans flesh, the eating wherof (after the proper speech of eating) is horrible and abominable. Wherfore the eating of Christes flesh must needes be otherwise vnderstanded, then after the proper and common eatinge of other meates with the mouth, which eating after such sort could auayle nothing. And therefore S. Augustine in that place declareth the eating of Christes fleshe to be onely a figuratiue speach. And he openeth the figure so, as the eatinge must be ment with the minde, not with the mouth: that is to say, by chawing and digesting in our mindes, to our great consolation and profite, that Christ dyed for vs. Thus doth S. Augustine open the figure and meaning of Christ when he spake of the eating of his flesh, and drinking of his bloud. And his flesh being thus eaten, it must also be ioyned vnto his diuinitie, or els it could not geue euerlasting life, as Cyrill and the councell Ephesin truly ⟨p. 26⟩decreed. But S. Augustine declared the figuratiue speech of Christ to be in the eating, not in the vnion. And where as to shift of the playn words of Christ, spoken in the sixt of Iohn,3 he that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my bloud, dwelleth in me and I in him: you say that dwelling in Christ is not §4the manducation. You say herein directly against S. Cyprian,4 who saith: quod mansio nostra in ipso, sit manducatio, that our dwelling in him, is the eating. And also against S. Augustine,
- 1August. de doctrina Christiana lib. 3. cap. 13.
- 2How Christs flesh is eaten.How Christes flesh is eaten.
- 3John 6.Iohn 6.
- 4Cyprian. in sermone de caena Domini.
- 5August. in Joan. tra. 26.August. in Ioan. tra. 26.