First I allege against Smiths negation, your affirmation, which, as it is more true in this point then his negation, so for your estimation it is able to countervail his saying, if there were nothing else: & yet if Smith had well pondered what I have written in the second chap. of my second book, and in the 7. and 8. chapters of my third book, he should have found this matter so fully proved, that he neither is, nor never shall be able to answer thereto. For I have alleged the scripture, I have alleged the consent of the old writers, holy fathers, and martyrs, to prove that Christ called bread his body, and wine his blood. For the Evangelists speaking of the Lords supper,1 say, that he took bread, blessed it, brake it, & gave it to his disciples, saying: This is my body: and of the wine he said: Take this, divide it among you, & drink it: this is my blood. I have alleged Irene,2 saying that Christ confessed bread to be his body, and the cup to be his blood I have cited Tertullian who saith in many places,3 that Christ called bread his body. I have brought in for the same purpose Cyprian,4 who saith that Christ called such bread as is made of many corns joined together, his body: and such wine he named his blood, as is pressed out of many grapes. I have written the words of Epiphanius,5 which be these, that Christ speaking of a loaf which is round in fashion, and can neither see, hear, nor feel, said of it: This is my body. And S. Hierom writing ad Hedibiam, 6sayth that Christ called the bread which he brake, his body. And S. Augustine saith,7 that Jesus called meat, his body, and drink his blood. And Cyril saith more plainly,8 that Christ called the pieces of bread his body. And last of all I brought forth Theodorete,9 whose saying is this, that when Christ gave the holy mysteries, he called bread his body, and the cup mixed with wine and water, ⟨p. 29⟩he called his blood. All these Authors I alleged, to prove that Christ called bread his body, and wine his blood.
First I alleadge against Smithes negation, your affirmation, which, as it is more true in this point then his negation, so for your estimation it is able to counteruail his saying, if there were nothing els: & yet if Smith had well pondered what I haue written in the second chap. of my second booke, and in the 7. and 8. chapters of my third book, he should haue foūd this matter so fully prooued, that he neither is, nor neuer shalbe able to answere thereto. For I haue alleadged the scripture, I haue alleadged the consent of the old writers, holy fathers, and martirs, to prooue that Christ called bread his body, and wine his bloud. For the Euangelistes speaking of the Lords supper,1 say, yt he took bread, blessed it, brake it, & gaue it to his disciples, saying: This is my body: and of the wine he sayd: Take this, deuide it among you, & drinke it: this is my bloud. I haue alleadged Irene,2 saying that Christ confessed bread to be his body, and the cup to be his bloud I haue cyted Tertulliā who sayth in many places,3 that Christ called bread his body. I haue brought in for the same purpose Cyprian,4 who sayth that Christ called such bread as is made of many cornes ioyned together, his body: and such wine he named his bloud, as is pressed out of many grapes. I haue written the wordes of Epiphanius,5 which be these, that Christ speakinge of a loafe which is round in fashion, and can neither see, heare, nor feele, said of it: This is my body. And S. Hierom writing ad Hedibiam, 6sayth that Christ called the bread which he brake, his body. And S. Augustine sayth,7 that Iesus called meate, his body, and drinke his bloud. And Cyrill sayth more plainly,8 that Christ called the peeces of bread his body. And last of all I brought forth Theodorete,9 whose saying is this, that when Christe gaue the holy mysteries, he called bread his body, and the cuppe mixt with wine and water, ⟨p. 29⟩
- 1Mat. 26. Mark. 14. Luke. 22.
- 2Ireneus.
- 3Tertullianus.
- 4Cyprianus.
- 5Epiphanius.
- 6Heironymus.
- 7Augustinus.
- 8Cyrillus.
- 9Theodorus.