pp. 3941,982 passagespart 11 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1But to come directly to the matter, if it be true that you say, that in the sacrament Christs body hath all the forms and quantities of a natural body, why say you then that his body is not there present after the manner of quantity? Declare what difference is between form and quantity, & the manner of quantity? And if Christs body in the Sacrament have the same quantity, that is to say, the same length, breadth, and thickness, and the same form, that is to say, the same due order, and proportion of the men bers and parts of his body, that he had when he was crucified, and hath now in heaven (as he hath by your saying here in this place) then I pray ⟨p. 73⟩you declare further, how the length, breadth, and thickness of a man, should be contained in quantity, within the compass of a piece of bread, no longer nor broader then one or two inches, nor much thicker then one leaf of paper. How an inch may be as long as an ell, and an ell as short as an inch. How length and roundness shall agree in one proportion: and a thick and thin thing be both of one thickness: which you must warrant to be brought to pass, if the form and quantity of Christs body be contained under the form and quantity of such bread and wine as we now use.
1But to come directly to the matter, if it be true that you say, that in the sacrament Christes body hath all the formes and quantities of a naturall body, why say you then that his body is not there present after the manner of quantitie? Declare what difference is betweene forme and quantitie, & the manner of quantitie? And if Christes body in the Sacrament haue the same quantitie, that is to say, the same length, breadth, and thicknes, and the same forme, that is to say, the same due order, and proportion of the mē bers and partes of his body, that he had when he was crucified, and hath now in heauen (as he hath by your saying here in this place) then I pray ⟨p. 73⟩you declare further, how the length, bredth, and thicknes of a man, should be conteined in quantitie, within the compasse of a peece of bread, no lōger nor broader then one or two inches, nor much thicker then one leafe of paper. How an inch may be as long as an elle, and an elle as short as an inch. How length and roundnes shall agree in one proportion: and a thicke and thin thing be both of one thicknes: which you must warrant to be brought to passe, if the forme and quantitie of Christes body be conteined vnder the forme and quantity of such bread and wine as we now vse.
But as Smith in the last comparison did me good service against you,1 so shall you in this comparison do me good service against him. For among the five lies, wherewith he chargeth me in these comparisons, he accounteth this for one, that I report of the Papists, that Christs body in the sacrament hath his proper form and quantity, which you say is a truth. And therefore if I make a lye herein (as Smith saith I do) yet I lie not alone, but have you to bear me company. And yet once again more may the reader here note, how the Papists vary among them selves.
But as Smyth in the last comparison did me good seruice against you,1 so shall you in this comparison do me good seruice against him. For among the fiue lyes, wherewith he chargeth me in these comparisons, he accompteth this for one, that I report of the Papists, that Christes body in the sacrament hath his proper forme and quantity, which you say is a truth. And therefore if I make a lye herein (as Smyth saith I doe) yet I lie not alone, but haue you to beare me company. And yet once again more may the reader here note, how the Papists vary among them selues.
And it is untrue that you say, that good men believe upon the credit of Christ, that there is truly in the Sacrament, the very true body of Christ. For Christ called bread his body and wine his blood (which as the old authors say, must needs be understanded figuratively) but he never said that his true body is truly in the Sacrament, as you here report of him.
And it is vntrue that you say, that good men beleeue vpon the credit of Christ, that there is truely in the Sacrament, the very true body of Christ. For Christ called bread his body and wine his bloud (which as the old authors say, must needs be vnderstanded figuratiuely) but he neuer sayd that his true body is truely in the Sacrament, as you here report of him.
And the manner of his presence you call so high a mystery, that the carnal man can not reach it. And in deed as you feign, the matter it is so high a mystery, that never man could reach it, but your self alone. For you make the manner of Christs being in the Sacrament so spiritual, that you say his flesh, blood and bones be there really and carnally, and yet you confess in your book, that you never red any old author that so said. And this manner of handling of so pure a mystery, is neither godly foolishness nor worldly, but rather a mere frenzy and madness.
And the manner of his presence you call so high a mistery, that the carnall man can not reach it. And in deed as you fayne, the matter it is so high a mistery, that neuer man could reach it, but your selfe alone. For you make the manner of Christes being in the Sacrament so spirituall, that you say his flesh, bloud and bones be there really and carnally, and yet you confesse in your booke, that you neuer red any old author that so said. And this manner of handling of so pure a mistery, is neither godly foolishnes nor worldly, but rather a meere fransy and madnesse.
And although the scripture speak of Christs body to be eaten of us, yet that is understanded of spiritual and not of corporal eating, and of spiritual not of corporal presence. The scripture saith,1 that Christ hath forspoken the world, and is ascended into heaven. Upon which words S. Augustine Uigilius, and other ancient authors do prove, that as concerning the nature §1of his manhood, Christ is gone hence, and is not here, as I declared in my 3. book. the 3.4.5. and 6. chapters.
And although the scripture speak of Christes body to be eaten of vs, yet that is vnderstanded of spiritual and not of corporall eating, and of spirituall not of corporall presence. The scripture sayth,1 that Christ hath forspoken the world, and is ascended into heauen. Upon which words S. Augustine Uigilius, and other auncient authors do proue, that as concerning the nature §1of his manhode, Christ is gone hence, and is not here, as I declared in my 3. booke. the 3.4.5. and 6. chapters.
And where you think that this manner of speech was never red, that Christ is present in the Sacrament without form or quantity, I am sure §3that it was never red in any approved author, that Christ hath his proper form and quantity in the sacrament. And Duns saith, that his quantity is in heaven, and not in the Sacrament.
And where you thinke that this manner of speech was neuer red, that Christ is present in the Sacrament without forme or quantity, I am sure §3that it was neuer red in any approued author, that Christ hath his proper forme and quantitie in the sacrament. And Duns saith, that his quantitie is in heauen, and not in the Sacrament.
And when I say that Christ is in the Sacrament Sacramentally and without form and quantity, who would think any man so captious, so ignorant, or so full of sophistry, to draw my words to the form of Christs divinity, which I speak most plainly of the form and quantity of his body and humanity? as I have before declared. And although some other might be so far overseen, yet specially you ought not so to take my words. Forasmuch as you said not past 16. lines before, that my words seem to imply, that I meant of Christs humane body.
And when I say that Christ is in the Sacrament Sacramentally and without forme and quantitie, who would thinke any man so captious, so ignorant, or so full of sophistry, to draw my wordes to the forme of Christs diuinitie, which I speake most plainly of the forme and quantity of his body and humanitie? as I haue before declared. And although some other might be so farre ouerseen, yet specially you ought not so to take my words. Forasmuch as you sayd not past 16. lynes before, that my wordes seeme to implye, that I ment of Christes humayne body.
And because it may appear how truly and faithfully you report my words, you add this word (all) which is more then I speak,1 and marteth all the whole matter. And you gather thereof such absurdities as I never spake, but as you sophistically do gather, to make a great matter• of nothing.
And because it may appeare how truely and faithfully you reporte my words, you adde this word (all) which is more then I speake,1 and marteth all the wholl matter. And you gather therof such absurdities as I neuer spake, but as you sophistically doe gather, to make a great matter• of nothing.
And where of this word (there) you would conclude repugnance in my §7doctrine,1 that where in other places I have written, that Christ is spiritually present in them that receive the sacrament, and not in the sacraments of bread and wine, and now it should seem that I teach contrary; that Christ is spiritually present in the very bread and wine, if you pleased to understand my words rightly, there is no repugnance in my words at all. For by this word (there) I mean not in the Sacraments of bread and wine, but in the ministration of the Sacrament, as the old authors for the most part, when they speak of the presence of Christ in the Sacrament, they mean in the ministration of the Sacrament.
And where of this word (there) you would conclude repugnaunce in my §7doctrine,1 that where in other places I haue written, that Christ is spiritually present in them that receaue the sacrament, and not in the sacramentes of bread and wine, and now it should seeme that I teach contrary; yt Christ is spiritually present in the very bread and wine, if you pleased to vnderstād my wordes rightly, there is no repugnaunce in my words at al. For by this word (there) I meane not in the Sacraments of bread and wine, but in the ministration of the Sacrament, as the olde authors for the most part, when they speake of the presence of Christ in the Sacrament, they meane in the ministration of the Sacrament.
Which my saying varieth from no doctrine that I have taught in any part of my book. Now followeth the tenth comparison.
Which my saying varyeth from no doctrine that I haue taught in any part of my booke. Now followeth the tenth comparyson.
They say, that the fathers, and Prophets of the old Testament did not eat the body, or drink the blood of Christ. We say, that they did eat his body and drink his blood, although he was not yet borne nor incarnated.
They say, that the fathers, and Prophets of the old Testament did not eat the body, or drink the bloud of Christ. We say, that they did eat his body and drink his bloud, although he was not yet borne nor incarnated.
1This comparison of difference is clerkly conveyed, as it were of a riddle, wherein, nay and yea, when they be opened, agree and consent. The fathers did eat Christs body and §1drink his blood in the truth of promise, which was effectual to them of redemption to be wrought, not in trueth of presence, (as we do) for confirmation of redemption already wrought. They had a certain promise, and we a certain present payment: they did eat Christ spiritually, believing in him that was to come, but they did not eat Christs body present in the Sacrament, sacramentally and spiritually, as we do. Their Sacraments were figures of the things, but ours contain the very things. And therefore albeit in a §2sense to the learned men, it may be verified, that the fathers did eat the body of Christ, and drink his blood, yet there is no such form of words in scripture, and it is more agreeable §3to the simplicity of scripture, to say the fathers before Christs nativity, did not eat the body and blood of Christ, which body and blood, Christ himself truly took of the body of the virgin Mary. For although S. Paul in the tenth to the Corinthians, be so understanded of some, as the fathers should eat the same spiritual meat, and drink the same spiritual drink that we do, to which understanding, all do not agree, yet following that understanding, we may not so press the words, as there should be no difference at all, and this one difference S. Augustine noteth how their sacraments contained the promise of that, which in our sacrament is given.2 Thus he saith: And this is evident of it self, how to us in the holy supper (Christ saith) This is my body that shall be betrayed for you, take §4eat) which was never said to the fathers, although their faith in substance agreed with ours, having all one Christ and mediator, which they looked for to come, and we acknowledge §5to be already come (come, and to come,) as S. August. saith, differeth. But Christ is one, by whom all was created, and mans fall repaired, from whom is all feeding corporal & spiritual, & in whom all is restored in heaven & in earth.
In this faith of Christ, the fathers were fed with heavenly spiritual food, which was the same with ours in respect of the restitution by Christ, and redemption by them hoped, which is achieved by the mystery of the body and blood of Christ, by reason whereof I deny not, but it may be said in a good sense, how they did eat the body and blood of Christ, before he was incarnate, but as I said before, Scripture speaketh not so, and it is no wholesome fashion of speech at this §6time, which furthereth in sound to the ears of the rude, the pestilent heresy wherein Joan of Kent obstinately dyed,1 that is to say, that Christ took nothing of the Virgin, but ⟨p. 75⟩brought his body with him from above, being a thing worthy to be noted, how the old heresy, denying the true taking of the flesh of Christ in the virgins womb, at the same time to revive. When the true deliverance of Christs flesh in the holy supper to be of us eaten, is also denied. For as it is a mere trueth without figure, and yet an high mystery, Gods work in the incarnation of Christ, wherein our flesh was of Christ truly taken of the virgins substance: So is it a mere trueth, without figure in the substance of the celestial thing, & yet an high mystery and Gods work, in the giving of the same true flesh, truly to be in the supper eaten. When I exclude figure in the sacrament, I mean not of the visible part which is called a figure of the celestial invisible part, which is truly there without figure,2 so as by that figure is not impaired the truth of that presence, which I ad to avoid cavillation. And make an end of this comparison, this I say, that this article declareth wantonness to make a difference in words, where none is in the sense rightly taken, with a novelty of speech not necessary to be uttered now.
In this faith of Christ, the fathers were fed with heauenly spirituall food, which was the same with ours in respect of the restitution by Christ, and redemption by them hoped, which is atchieued by the mistery of the body and bloud of Christ, by reason wherof I deny not, but it may be said in a good sense, how they did eat the body and bloud of Christ, before he was incarnat, but as I sayd before, Scripture speaketh not so, and it is no holsome fashion of spéech at this
Note well here reader, how the cuttle cometh in with his dark colours.
NOte well here reader, how the cuttill commeth in with his darke coulours.
Where I speak of the substance of the thing that is eaten, you turn it to the manner and circumstances thereof, to blind the simple reader, and that you may make thereof a riddle of yea and nay, as you be wont to make black white, and white black: or one thing yea and nay, black and white at your pleasure.
Where I speake of the substaunce of the thing that is eaten, you turne it to the manner and circumstaunces thereof, to blynde the simple reader, and that you may make therof a riddle of yea and nay, as you be wont to make blacke white, and white blacke: or one thing yea and nay, black and white at your pleasure.
But to put away your dark colours, and to make the matter plain,1 this I say, that the fathers and prophets did eat Christs body and drink his blood in promise of redemption to be wrought, and we eat and drink the same flesh and blood in confirmation of our faith in the redemption all ready wrought.
But to put away your darke coulours, and to make the matter playne,1 this I say, that the fathers and prophets did eat Christes body and drinke his bloud in promise of redemptiō to be wrought, and we eat and drink the same flesh and bloud in confirmation of our faith in the redemption all ready wrought.
But as the fathers did eat and drink, so did also the Apostles at Christ his supper, in promise of redemption to be wrought, not in confirmation of redemption already wrought. So that if wrought and to be wrought, make the diversity of presence and not presence, then the Apostles did not eat and drink the flesh and blood of Christ really present, because the redemption was not then already wrought, but promised the next day to be wrought.
But as the fathers did eat and drinke, so did also the Apostles at Christ his supper, in promise of redemtion to be wrought, not in confirmation of redēption already wrought. So that if wrought and to be wrought, make the diuersitie of presence and not presence, then the Apostles did not eat and drinke the flesh and bloud of Christ really present, because the redemption was not then already wrought, but promised the next day to be wrought.
And although before the crucifying of his flesh and effusion of his blood our redemption was not actually wrought by Christ, yet was he spiritually and sacramentally present, and spiritually and sacramentally eaten and drunken, not only of the Apostles at his last supper before he suffered his passion, but also of the holy Patriarchs and fathers before his incarnation, aswell as he is now of us after his ascension.
And although before the crucifiyng of his flesh and effusion of his bloud our redemption was not actually wrought by Christ, yet was he spiritually and sacramentally present, and spiritually and sacramentally eaten and drunken, not onely of the Apostles at his last supper before hee suffered his passion, but also of the holy Patriarkes and fathers before his incarnation, aswell as he is now of vs after his ascention.
And although in the manner of signifying there be great difference between their sacraments and ours, yet (as S. Augustine saith) both we and they receive one thing in the diversity of Sacraments.1 And our Sacraments contain presently the very things signified, no more then theirs did. For in their sacraments they were by Christ presently regenerated and fed, as we be in ours, although their sacraments were figures of the death of Christ to come, and ours be figures of his death now past. And as it is all one Christ that was to be borne and to dye for us, and afterward was borne in deed and dyed in deed (whose birth and death be now passed) so was the same Christ, and the same flesh and blood eaten and drunken of the faithful fathers before he was borne or dead, and of his Apostles after he was born ⟨p. 76⟩and before he was dead, and of faithful christen people is now daily eaten and drunken after that both his nativity and death be passed. And all is but one Christ, one flesh & one blood, as concerning the substance, yet that which to the fathers was to come, is to us passed. And nevertheless the eating & drinking is all one, for neither the fathers did, nor we do eat carnally and corporally with our mouths, but both the fathers did and we do eat spiritually by true and lively faith.2 The body of Christ was and is all one to the fathers and to us, but corporally and locally he was yet borne unto them, & from us he is gone: and ascended up into heaven. So that to neither he was nor is carnally, substantially and corporally present, but to them he was & to us he is spiritually present and sacramentally also, and of both sacramē tally, spiritually and effectually eaten and drunken, to eternal salvation & everlasting life.
And although in the manner of signifiyng there be great difference between their sacraments and ours, yet (as S. Augustine saith) both we and they receaue one thing in the diuersitie of Sacraments.1 And our Sacraments contain presently the very things signified, no more then theirs did. For in their sacraments they were by Christ presently regenerated and fed, as we be in ours, although their sacraments were figures of the death of Christ to com, and ours be figurs of his death now past. And as it is al one Christ that was to be borne and to dye for vs, and afterward was borne in deede and dyed in deede (whose byrth and death be now passed) so was the same Christ, and the same flesh and bloud eaten and drunken of the faithfull fathers before he was borne or dead, and of his Apostles after he was born
And this is plainly enough declared in the Scripture, to them that have §3willing minds to understand the truth. For it is written in the old Testament Eccle. 24. in the person of Christ thus: They that eat me, shall yet hunger, and they that drink me shall yet be thirsty.
And this is plainly enough declared in the Scripture, to them that haue §3willing mindes to vnderstand the truth. For it is written in the old Testament Eccle. 24. in the person of Christ thus: They that eat me, shall yet hunger, and they that drinke me shall yet be thirsty.
1And S. Paul writeth to the Corinthians, saying: Our fathers did all eat the same spiritual meat, and did all drink the same spiritual drink, and they drank of that spiritual rock that followed them, which rock was Christ.2 These words S. Augustine expounding saith: What is to eat the same meat: but that they did eat the same which we do. Who so ever in Manna understood Christ, did eat the same spiritual meat that we do, that is to say, that meat which was received with faith and not with bodies. Therefore to them that understood and believed, it was the same meat and the same drink. So that to such as understood not, the meat was only Manna, and the drink, only water, but to such as understood, it was the same that is now. For them was Christ to come, who is now come. To come and is come, be divers words, but it is the same Christ. These be S. Augustine's sayings.
1And S. Paule writeth to the Corinthians, saying: Our fathers did all eat the same spirituall meat, and did all drink the same spirituall drinke, and they drank of that spirituall rock that followed them, which rock was Christ.2 These words S. Augustine expounding sayth: What is to eat the same meat: but that they did eate the same which wee doe. Who so euer in Manna vnderstood Christ, did eat the same spirituall meat that we do, yt is to say, that meat which was receaued with fayth and not with bodyes. Therefore to them that vnderstood and beleued, it was the same meat and the same drinke. So that to such as vnderstoode not, the meate was onely Manna, and the drinke, onely water, but to such as vnderstood, it was the same that is now. For thē was Christ to come, who is now come. To come and is come, be diuers wordes, but it is the same Christ. These be S. Augustines sayings.
And because you say, that it is more agreeable to the scripture, to say, that the fathers before Christs nativity did not eat the body and drink the blood §4of Christ: I pray you show me one scripture that so saith. And show me also one approved author that disallowed S. Augustine's mind by me here alleged, because you say, that all do not agree to his understanding. And in the 77.1 Psalm S. Augustine saith also: The stone was Christ. Therefore the same was the meat & drink of the fathers in the mystery, with is ours, but in signification the same, not in outward form. For it is one Christ him self, that to them was figured in the stone, and to us manifestly appeared in flesh.2 And saint Augustine saith plainly, that both Manna and our Sacrament signifieth Christ, and that although the Sacraments were divers, yet in the thing by them meant and understand, they were both like. And so after the mind of S. Augustine it is clear, that the same things were given to the faithful receivers in the Sacraments of the old Testament, that be given in the new: the same to them was circumcision, that to us is baptism: and to them by Manna was given the same thing, that now is given to us in the sacramental bread.
And because you say, that it is more agreable to the scripture, to say, that the fathers before Christs natiuity did not eat the body and drink the bloud §4of Christ: I pray you shew me one scripture that so saith. And shew me also one approued author that disalowed S. Augustines mind by me here alleaged, because you say, that all doe not agree to his vnderstanding. And in the 77.1 Psalme S. Augustine saith also: The stone was Christ. Therefore the same was the meat & drinke of the fathers in the mistery, wich is ours, but in significatiō the same, not in outward forme. For it is one Christ him selfe, that to them was figured in the stone, and to vs manyfestly appeared in flesh.2 And saint Augustine sayth playnely, that both Manna and our Sacrament signifieth Christ, and that although the Sacraments were dyuers, yet in the thing by them ment and vnderstand, they were both like. And so after the mynd of S. Augustine it is cleare, that the same thinges were geuen to the faithfull receiuers in the Sacraments of the old Testament, that be geuen in the new: the same to them was circumcisiō, that to vs is baptisme: and to them by Manna was geuen the same thing, that now is geuen to vs in the sacramentall bread.
And if I would grant for your pleasure, that in their sacraments Christ was promised, and that in ours, he is really given, doth it not then follow ⟨p. 77⟩§5aswell that Christ is given in the sacrament of Baptism, as that he is given in the Sacrament of his flesh and blood? And S. Augustin contra Faustum, 1esteemeth them mad, that think diversity between the things signified in the old and new testament, because the signs be divers. And expressing the matter plainly, saith, that the flesh and blood of our sacrifice before Christs coming, was promised • y sacrifices of similitudes, in his passion was given indeed, & after his ascension is solemnly put in our memory by the Sacrament.
And if I would graunt for your pleasure, that in theyr sacramēts Christ was promised, and that in ours, he is really geuen, doth it not then followe ⟨p. 77⟩§5aswell that Christ is geuen in the sacrament of Baptisme, as that he is geuen in the Sacrament of his flesh and bloud? And S. Augustin contra Faustum, 1esteemeth them madde, that think diuersity betweene the things signified in the old and new testament, because the signes be diuers. And expressing the matter playnely, sayth, that the flesh and bloud of our sacryfice before Christs comming, was promised • y sacryfices of similitudes, in his passion was geuen indeed, & after his as••ntion is solemnly put in our memory by the Sacrament.
And the thing which you say S. Augustine noteth to be given in the sacraments of the new testament,1 and to be promised in the sacraments of the old, S. Augustine expresseth the thing which he meant, that is to say, salvation and eternal life by Christ. And yet in this mortal life we have not eternal life in possession, but in promise, as the prophets had. But S. Augustine saith, that we have the promise, because we have Christ all ready come, which by the Prophets was promised before that he should come, & therefore S. John the Baptist was called more then a Prophet, because he said:2 Here is the lamb of God already preset, which the Prophets taught us to look for, until he came.
And the thing which you say S. Augustine noteth to be geuen in the sacraments of the new testament,1 and to be promised in the sacramentes of the olde, S. Augustine expresseth the thing which he ment, that is to say, saluation and eternall lyfe by Christ. And yet in thys mortall lyfe we haue not eternall lyfe in possession, but in promise, as the prophets had. But S. Augustine sayth, that we haue the promise, because we haue Christ all ready come, which by ye Prophets was promised before that he should come, & therefore S. Iohn the Baptist was called more then a Prophet, because he said:2 Here is the lamb of God already preset, which the Prophets taught vs to looke for, vntill he came.
The effect therefore of S. Augustins words plainly to be expressed, was this, that the prophets in the old testament Promised a saviour to come, & redeem the world, (which the sacraments of that time testified until his coming): but now he is already come, and hath by his death performed that was promised, which our sacraments testify unto us, as S. Augustine declareth more plainly in his book De fide ad Petrum, the xix. chapter. So that S. Augustine speaketh of the giving of Christ to death,1 (which the sacraments of the old testament, testified to come, and ours testify to be done) and not of the giving of him in the sacraments.
The effect therfore of S. Augustins words plainly to be expressed, was this, that the prophets in the old testament Promised a sauiour to come, & redeem the world, (which the sacraments of that tyme testified vntill hys comming): but now he is already come, and hath by his death performed that was promised, which our sacramentes testifie vnto vs, as S. Augustine declareth more playnely in his booke De fide ad Petrum, the xix. chapter. So that S. Augustine speaketh of the geuing of Christ to death,1 (which the sacraments of the old testament, testified to come, and ours testify to be done) and not of the geuing of him in the sacraments.
And forasmuch as S. Augustine spake generally of all the sacraments, therefore if you will by his words prove, that Christ is corporally in the sacrament of the holy communion, you may aswell prove, that he is corporally in baptism. For saint Augustine speaketh no more of the one then of the other. But where saint Augustin speaketh generally of all the sacraments, you restrain the matter particularly to the sacrament of the Lords supper only, that the ignorant reader should think, that saint Augustine spake of the corporal presence of Christ in the sacraments, and that only in the sacraments of bread and wine, where as saint Augustine himself speaketh only of our salvation by Christ, and of the sacraments in general.
And forasmuch as S. Augustine spake generally of all the sacraments, therefore if you will by his words proue, that Christ is corporally in the sacrament of the holy communion, you may aswell proue, that he is corporally in baptisme. For saint Augustine speaketh no more of the one then of the other. But where saint Augustin speaketh generally of al the sacraments, you restrayne the matter particularly to the sacrament of the Lords supper onely, that the ignoraunt reader should thinke, that saynt Augustine spake of the corporall presence of Christ in the sacramentes, and that onely in the sacraments of bread and wine, where as saynt Augustine himself speaketh onely of our saluation by Christ, and of the sacraments in generall.
And nevertheless as the fathers had the same Christ and mediator that we have (as you here confess) so did they spiritually eat his f•esh and drink his blood (as we do) and spiritually feed of him, and by faith he was present with them (as he is with us) although carnally and corporally he was yet to come unto them, and from us is gone up to his father into heaven.
And neuerthelesse as the fathers had the same Christ and mediator that we haue (as you here confesse) so did they spiritually eat his f•esh and drinke his bloud (as we doe) and spiritually feed of him, and by faith he was present with thē (as he is with vs) although carnally and corporally he was yet to come vnto thē, and from vs is gon vp to his father into heauen.
This besides saint Augustine is plainly set out by Bertram above 6. hundred years passed,1 whose judgement in this matter of the sacrament, although you allow not (because it utterly condemneth your doctrine therein) yet forasmuch as hitherto his teaching was never reproved by none, but by you alone, and that he is commended of other, as an excellent learned man in holy scripture, and a notable famous man, aswell in living as learning, and that among his excellent works this one is specially praised, which ⟨p. 78⟩he wrote of the matter of the Sacrament of the body and blood of our Lord, therefore I shall rehearse his teaching in this point, how the holy fathers and Prophets before the coming of Christ did eat Christs flesh and drink his blood: So that although Bertram's saying be not esteemed with you, yet the indifferent reader may see what was written in this matter, before your doctrine was invented. And although his authority be not received of you, yet his words may serve against Smith,2 who herein more learnedly, and with more judgement then you, approveth this author. This is Bertram's doctrine S. Paul saith, that all the old fathers did eat the same spiritual meat, and drink the same spiritual drink. But peradventure thou wilt ask, Which the same? Even the very same that christen people do daily eat and drink in the church. For we may not understand divers things, when it is one and the self same Christ, which in times past did feed with his flesh, and made to drink of his blood, the people that were baptised in the cloud and sea, in the wilderness, and which doth now in the church feed christen people with the bread of his body, and giveth them to drink the flood of his blood. When he had not yet taken mans nature upon him, when he had not yet tasted death for the salvation of the world, not redeemed us with his blood, nevertheless even then our forefathers by spiritual meat and invisible drink did eat his body in the wilderness and drink his blood, as the Apostle beareth witness, saying: The same spiritual meat, the same spiritual drink. For he that now in the church by his omnipotent power doth spiritually convert bread & wine into the flesh of his body, and into the flood of his own blood, he did then invisibly so work, that Manna which came from heaven was his body, and the water his blood.
Now by the things here by me alleged, it evidently appeareth, that this is no novelty of speech to say, that the holy fathers and Prophets did eat Christs flesh and drink his blood. For both the scripture and old authors use so to speak, how much soever the speech mislike them, that like no fashion but their own.
Now by the thinges here by me alledged, it euidently appereth, that this is no nouelty of speech to say, that the holy fathers and Prophets did eat Christes flesh and drink his bloud. For both the scripture and old authors vse so to speake, how much soeuer ye spech mislike them, that like no fashion but their own.
1And what doth this further the pestilent heresy of Joan of Kent? Is this §6a good argument? The fathers did eat Christs flesh and drink his blood spiritually before he was borne, ergo after he was not corporally borne of his mother? Or because he was corporally borne, is he not therefore daily eaten spiritually of his faithful people? Because he dwelt in the world corporally from his incarnation unto his ascension, did he not therefore spiritually dwell in his holy members before that time, and hath so done ever sithens, and will do to the worlds end? Or if he be eaten in a figure, can you induce thereof that he was not borne without a figure? Do not such kind of arguments favour the error of Joan of Kent? Yea do they not manifestly approve her pestiferous heresy, if they were to be allowed? What man that meaneth the trueth, would bring in such manner of reasoning to deface the truth? And yet it is not to be denied, but that Christ is truly eaten, as he was truly born, but the one corporally and without figure, and the other spiritually, and with a figure. Now followeth my 11, comparison.2
1And what doth this further ye pestilent heresy of Ione of Kent? Is this §6a good argument? The fathers did eat Christes flesh and drinke his bloud spiritually before he was borne, ergo after he was not corporally borne of his mother? Or because he was corporally borne, is he not therefore dayly eaten spiritually of his faithfull people? Because he dwelt in the world corporally from his incarnation vnto his ascention, did he not therfore spiritually dwell in his holy members before that tyme, and hath so done euer sithens, and will do to the worldes end? Or if he be eaten in a figure, can you induce thereof that he was not borne without a figure? Do not such kynde of argumentes fauour the errour of Ione of Kent? Yea do they not manifestly approue her pestiferous heresy, if they were to be alowed? What man that meaneth the trueth, would bring in such manner of resoning to deface the truth? And yet it is not to be denied, but that Christ is truely eaten, as he was truly born, but the one corporally and without figure, and the other spiritually, and with a figure. Now followeth my 11, comparison.2
They say, that the body of Christ is every day many times made, as often as there be Masses said, and that then and there he is made of bread and wine. We say, that Christs body was never but once made, and then not of the nature & substance of bread and wine, but of the substance of his blessed mother.
They say, that the body of Christ is euery day many tymes made, as often as there be Masses sayd, and that then and there he is made of bread and wine. We say, that Christes body was neuer but once made, and then not of the nature & substance of bread and wine, but of the substance of his blessed mother.
The body of Christ, is by Gods omnipotency, who so worketh in his word, made present unto us at such time, as the church pray, it may please him so to do, which prayer is ordered to be made in the book of common prayer now set forth.1 Wherein we require of §2God, the creatures of bread and wine to be sanctified, and to be to us the body and blood of Christ, which they can not be, unless God worketh it, and make them so to be: In which §1mystery it was never taught, as this author willingly misreporteth,2 that Christs most §3precious body is made of the matter of bread, but in that order, exhibited and made preset unto us, by conversion of the substance of bread into his precious body, not a new body made of a new matter of bread and wine, but a new presence of the body, that is never old made present there, where the substance of bread and wine was before. So as this comparison of difference is mere wrangling and so evident, as it needeth no further answer, but a note: Lo how they be not ashamed to trifle in so great a matter, and without cause by wrong terms, to bring the truth in slander (if it were possible.) May not this be accounted, §4as a part of Gods punishment, for men of knowledge to write to the people such matter seriously, as were not tolerable to be by a scoffer devised in a play, to supply when his fellow had forgotten his part.
The body of Christ, is by Gods omnipotency, who so worketh in his word, made present vnto vs at such tyme, as the church praye, it may please him so to doe, which prayer is ordred to be made in the booke of common prayer now set foorth.1 Wherin we require of §2God, the creatures of bread and wine to be sanctified, and to be to vs the body and bloud of Christ, which they can not be, vnlesse God worketh it, and make them so to be: In which §1mistery it was neuer taught, as this author willingly misreporteth,
Christ is present when so ever the church prayeth unto him, and is gathered together in his name. And the bread and wine be made unto us the §1body and blood of Christ,1 (as it is in the book of common prayer) but not by changing the substance of bread and wine into the substance of Christs natural body and blood, but that, in the godly using of them, they be unto the receivers Christs body and blood. As of some the Scripture saith, that their riches is their redemption, and to some it is their damnation:2 And as Gods word to some is life, to some it is death and a snare (as the prophet saith.) And Christ himself to some is a stone to stumble at, to some is a raising from death, not by conversion of substances, but by good or evil use: that thing which to the godly is salvation; to the ungodly is damnation. So is the water in baptism, and the bread and wine in the Lords supper, to the worthy receivers, Christ himself and eternal life, and to the unworthy receivers everlasting death and damnation, not by conversion of one substance into an other, but by godly or ungodly use thereof. And therefore in the book of the holy communion we do not pray absolutely, that the bread and wine may be made the body and blood of Christ, but that unto us in that holy mystery they may be so, that is to say,3 that we may so worthily receive the same, that we may be partakers of Christs body and blood, and that therewith in spirit and in truth we may be spiritually nourished. And a like prayer of old time were all the people wont to make at the communion, of all such offerings, as at that time all the people used to offer, praying that their offerings might be unto them the body and blood of Christ.
Christ is present when so euer the church praieth vnto him, and is gathered togither in his name. And the bread and wine be made vnto vs ye §1body and bloud of Christ,1 (as it is in the book of common praier) but not by chaunging the substaunce of bread and wine into the substance of Christes naturall body and bloud, but that, in the godly vsing of thē, they be vnto the receauers Christes body and bloud. As of some the Scripture saith, yt their riches is their redemption, and to some it is their damnatiō:
And where you say, it was never taught as I say,1 that Christs body is §2made of the matter of bread, you knowingly and willingly misreport me. For I say not, of the matter of bread, but of bread, which when you deny that the Papists so say, it seemeth you be now ashamed of the doctrine; which the Papists have taught this 4. or 5. hundred years. For is it not plainly written of all the Papists, both lawyers and school authors, that the body of Christ in the sacrament is made of bread, and his blood of wine? And they say not that his body is made present of bread & wine, but is made of bread and wine. Be not their books in print ready to be showed? Do they not say, ⟨p. 80⟩that the substance of the bread neither remaineth still nor is turned into nothing, but into the body of Christ? And do not your self also say here in this place, that the substance of bread is converted into Christs precious body? And what is that else, but the body of Christ to be made of bread, and to be made of a new matter? For if the bread do not vanish away into nothing, but be turned into Christs body, then is Christs body made of it, and then §3it must needs follow that Christs body is made of new, and of an other substance then it was made of in his mothers womb. For there it was made of her flesh and blood, and here it is made of bread and wine. And the Papists say not (as you now would shift of the matter) that Christs body is made present of bread, but they say plainly without addition, that it is made of bread. Can you deny that this is the plain doctrine of the Papists Ex pane fit Corpus Christi, of bread is made the body of Christ, and that the substance of bread is turned into the substance thereof And what reason, sentence, or english, could be in this saying, Christs body is made present of bread? Marry to be present in bread might be some sentence, but the speech will you in no wise admit.
And where you say, it was neuer taught as I say,1 that Christs body is §2made of the matter of bread, you knowingly and willingly misreport me. For I say not, of the matter of bread, but of bread, which when you deny that the Papists so say, it semeth you be now ashamed of the doctrin; which the Papistes haue taught thys 4. or 5. hundred yeres. For is it not playnely written of all the Papists, both lawyers and scholl authors, that the body of Christ in the sacramēt is made of bread, and his bloud of wine? And they say not that his body is made present of bread & wine, but is made of bread and wine. Be not their books in print ready to be shewed? Do they not say,
And this your saying here (if the reader mark it well) turneth over quite and clean all the whole Papistical doctrine in this matter of the Sacrament,1 as well touching transubstantiation, as also the carnal presence. For their doctrine with one whole consent and agreement is this. That the substance of bread remaineth not, but is turned into the substance of Christs §4body, and so the body of Christ is made of it. But this is false (say you) and not tolerable to be by a scoffer devised in a place, to supply when his fellow had forgotten his part. And so the whole doctrine of the papists, which they have taught these 4. or 5. hundred years, do you condemn with condigne reproaches, as a teaching intolerable, not to be devised by a scoffer in a play. Why do you then take upon you to defend the Papistical doctrine, if it be so intolerable? Why do you not forsake those scoffers and players, which have juggled with the world so long, and embrace the most certain truth, that Christs body is not made of bread? And seeing that you embrace it here in this one place, why stand you not constantly therein but go from it again in all the rest of your book, defending the Papistical doctrine clean contrary to yours in this point, in that they teach that Christs body is made of bread.
And this your saying here (if the reader mark it wel) turneth ouer quite and cleane all the wholl Papisticall doctrine in this matter of the Sacrament,1 as well touching transubstantiation, as also the carnall presence. For their doctrine with one whol consent and agreement is this. That the substance of bread remaineth not, but is turned into the substance of Christes §4body, and so the body of Christ is made of it. But this is false (say you) and not tollerable to be by a scoffer deuised in a place, to supply when his fellow had forgotten his part. And so the wholl doctrine of the papists, which they haue taught these 4. or 5. hundreth yeares, doe you condemne with condigne reproches, as a teaching intollerable, not to be deuised by a scoffer in a play. Why doe you then take vpon you to defend the Papistical doctrine, if it be so intollerable? Why doe you not forsake those scoffers and players, which haue iugled with the world so long, and embrace the most certayne truth, that Christs body is not made of bread? And seeing that you embrace it here in this one place, why stand you not constantly therin but goe from it againe in all the rest of your booke, defending the Papisticall doctrine cleane contrary to yours in this pointe, in that they teach that Christes body is made of bread.
And you vary so much from your self herein, that although you deny the Papists sayings in words, that Christs body is made of bread, yet in effect you grant and maintain the same, which you say is intolerable, and not to be devised by a scoffer in a play. For you say, that Christ calleth bread his body, and that his calling is making. And then if he make bread his body, it must needs follow that he maketh his body of the bread: moreover you say,1 that Christs body is made present by conversion, or turning of the substance of bread, into the substance of his precious body, where of must follow, that his body is made of bread. For when so ever one substance is turned into another, then the second is made of the first. As, because earth was turned into the body of Adam,2 we say that Adam was made of earth and that Eve was made of Adams rib: And the wine in Galilee made of water,3 because the water was turned into wine, and the rib of Adams side into the body of Eve. If the water had been put out of the pots, and ⟨p. 81⟩wine put in for the water, we might have said that the wine had been made present there, where the water was before: But then we might not have said that the wine had been made of the water, because the water was emptied out, and not turned into wine. But when Christ turned the water into the wine, then by reason of that turning, we say that the wine was made of the water. So likewise if the bread be turned into the substance of Christ his body, we must not only say that the body of Christ is present, where the bread was before, but also that it is made of the bread, because that the substance of the bread is converted and turned into the substance of his body. Which thing the papists saw must needs follow, and therefore they plainly confessed, that the body of Christ was made of bread, which doctrine (as you truly say in this place) is intolerable, and not to be devised by a scoffer in a play, when his fellow had forgotten his part. And yet you so far forget your self in this book, that throughout the same (what so ever you say here) you defend the same intolerable doctrine, not to be devised by a scoffer.
And you varry so much from your selfe herein, that although you deny the Papistes sayinges in wordes, that Christes body is made of bread, yet in effect you graunt and maintayn the same, which you say is intollerable, and not to be deuised by a scoffer in a play. For you say, that Christ calleth bread his body, and that his calling is making. And then if he make bread his body, it must needes follow that he maketh his body of the bread: moreouer you say,