pp. 3941,982 passagespart 18 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
As for saynt Agustine (ad Bonifacium) the author shall perceive his fault at Martin Bucers hand, who in his epistle dedicatory of his enarrations of the gospels, rehearseth his mind of Saint Augustine in this wise.1 Est (scribit divus Augustinus) secundum quendam modum sacramentum corporis Christi, Corpus Christi: sacramentum sanguinis Christi, sanguis Christi. At secundum quem modum? Ut significet tantum corpus & sanguinem Domini absenta? Absit, Honorari enim & percipi in simbolis visibilibus corpus & sanguinem ⟨p. 127⟩Domini, idem passim scribit. These words of Bucer may be thus englished. Saint Augustine writeth the sacrament of the body of Christ is after a certain manner, the body of christ, the sacrament of the blood of christ, the blood of christ, but after what manner? that it should signify only the body and blood absent? Absit, In no wise: for the same Saint §2Augustine writeth in many places, the body and blood of Christ to be honoured, and to be received in those visible tokens. Thus saith Bucer, who understandeth not saint Augustine to say the sacrament of Christs body, to be Christs body after a certain manner §3of speech, as this author doth: nor S. Augustine hath no such words, but onely (secundum quendam modum) after a certain manner, whereunto to put (of speech) is an addition more then truth required of necessity. In these words of Bucer may appear his whole judgement concerning S. Augustine, who affirmeth the very true presence of the thing signified in the sacrament, which truth established in the matter, the calling it a sign, or a token, a figure, a similitude, or a showing, maketh no matter when we understand the thing really present that is signified. Which and it were not in deed in §4the Sacrament, why should it after Bucers true understanding of S. Augustine be honoured there? Arguing upon mens speeches, may be without end: & the authors upon divers respects speak of one thing diversly. Therefore we should resort to the pith and knot of the matter,2 and see what they say in expounding the special place, without contention, §5and not what they utter in the heat of their disputation, ne to search their dark and ambiguous places, wherewith to confound that they speak openly and plainly.
As for saynt Agustine (ad Bonifacium) the author shall perceiue his fault at Martyne Bucers hand, who in his epistle dedicatory of his enarations of the gospels, reherseth his mind of Saynt Augustine in this wise.1 Est (scribit diuus Augustinus) secundum quendam modum sacramentum corporis Christi, Corpus Christi: sacramentum sanguinis Christi, sanguis Christi. At secundum quem modum? Vt significet tantum corpus & sanguinem Domini absenta? Absit, Honorari enim & percipi in simbolis visibilibus corpus & sanguinem ⟨p. 127⟩Domini, idem passim scribit. These wordes of Bucer may be thus englished. Saynt Augustine writeth the sacrament of the body of Christ is after a certayn maner, ye body of christ, ye sacramēt of ye bloud of christ, ye bloud of christ, but after what maner? yt it should signifie onely the body and bloud absent? Absit, In no wise: for the same Saynt §2Augustine writeth in many places, the body and bloud of Christ to be honored, and to be receiued in those visible tokens. Thus sayth Bucer, who vnderstandeth not saynt Augustine to say the sacrament of Christes body, to be Christes body after a certayn maner §3of speach, as this author doth: nor S. Augustine hath no such wordes, but onely (secundum quendam modum) after a certayne maner, wherunto to put (of speach) is an addition more then truth required of necessitie. In these wordes of Bucer may apeare his whole indgement concerning S. Augustine, who affirmeth the very true presence of the thing signified in the sacrament, which truth established in the matter, the calling it a signe, or a token, a figure, a similitude, or a shewing, maketh no matter when we vnderstand the thing really present that is signified. Which and it were not in dede in §4the Sacrament, why should it after Bucers true vnderstanding of S. Augustine be honored there? Arguing vpon mens speaches, may be without end: & the authors vpon diuers repsectes speake of one thing diuersly. Therfore we should resort to the pith and knot of the matter,2 and see what they say in expounding the speciall place, without contention, §5and not what they vtter in the heat of their disputation, ne to search their dark and ambiguous places, wherwith to confound that they speake openly and playnly.
What need you to bring Martin Bucer to make me answer,1 if you could answer your self? but because you be ashamed of the matter, you would thrust Martin Bucer in your place, to receive rebuke for you. But in this place he easeth you nothing at all, for he saith no more but that the body and blood of Christ be exhibited unto the worthy receivers of the sacrament, which is true, but yet spiritually, not corporally.
WHat nede you to bring Martine Bucer to make me answer,1 if you could answer your selfe? but bicause you be ashamed of the matter, you would thrust Martine Bucer in your place, to receaue rebuke for you. But in this place he easeth you nothing at all, for he sayth no more but that the body and bloud of Christ be exhibited vnto the worthy receiuers of the sacrament, which is true, but yet spiritually, not corporally.
And I never said, that Christ is utterly absent, but I ever affirmed,1 that he is truly and spiritually present, and truly and spiritually exhibited unto the godly receivers: but corporally is he neither in the receivers, nor in or under the forms of bread or wine, as you do teach, clearly with out the consent of master Bucer, who writeth no such thing.
And I neuer sayd, that Christ is vtterly absent, but I euer affirmed,1 that he is truly and spiritually present, and truly and spiritually exhibited vnto the godly receiuours: but corporally is he neither in the receiuors, nor in or vnder the fourmes of bread or wine, as you do teach, clearly with out the consent of master Bucer, who writeth no such thing.
And where I allege of Saint Augustine, that the sacrament of Christs body is called Christs body, after a certain manner of speech, and you deny that saint Augustine meant of a certain manner of speech, but saith only, after a certain manner: Read the place of saint Augustin who will, and he shall find, that he speaketh of the manner of speech, and that of such a manner of speech, as calleth one thing by the name of an other, where it is not the very thing in deed. For of the manner of speech is all the process there, as appeareth by these his words: a day or two before good Friday, we use in common speech to say: to morrow, or this day two days, Christ suffered. &c. Likewise upon Easter day we say: this day Christ rose. And why do no men reprove us as liars, when we speak in this sort? And we call those days so by a similitude. &c. And so it is called that day which is not that day in deed. And sacraments commonly have the name of the things whereof they be sacraments. Therefore as after a certain manner the sacrament of Christs body, is Christs body: so likewise the sacrament of faith is faith. And likewise saith Saint Paul, that in baptism we be buried, he saith not, that we signify burial, but he saith plainly, that we be buried: So that the ⟨p. 124⟩sacrament of so great a thing, is called by the name of the thing. All these be S. Augustine's words, showing how in the common use of speech, one thing may have the name of another. Wherefore when Doctor Gardiner saith, that S. Augustine spake not of that manner of speech, thou mayst believe him hereafter as thou shalt see cause, but if thou trust his words to much, thou shalt soon be deceived.
And where I alleadge of Saynt Augustine, that the sacrament of Christes body is called Christes body, after a certayn maner of speach, and you deny that saynt Augustine ment of a certayne maner of speach, but sayth onely, after a certayne maner: Read the place of saynt Augustin who will, and he shall find, that he speaketh of the maner of speach, and that of such a maner of speach, as calleth one thing by the name of an other, where it is not the very thing in dede. For of the maner of speach is all the processe there, as apeareth by these his wordes: a day or two before good Friday, we vse in common speach to say: to morowe, or this day two dayes, Christ suffered. &c. Likewise vppon Easter day we say: this day Christ rose. And why do no men reproue vs as lyars, whan we speake in this sort? And we call those dayes so by a similitude. &c. And so it is called that day which is not that day in dede. And sacramentes commonly haue the name of the thinges wherof they be sacramentes. Therfore as after a certayne manner the sacrament of Christes body, is Christes body: so likewise the sacramēt of fayth is fayth. And likewise sayth Saynt Paule, that in baptisme we be buried, he sayth not, that we signifie buriall, but he sayth playnly, that we be buried: So that the
As for the real presence of Christ in the sacrament, I grant that he §4is really present,1 after such sort as you expound really in this place, that is to say, indeed, and yet but spiritually. For you say your self, that he is but after a spiritual manner there, and so is he spiritually honoured, as S Augustine saith.
As for the reall presence of Christ in the sacrament, I graunt that he §4is really present,1 after such sort as you expound really in this place, that is to say, indede, and yet but spiritually. For you say your selfe, that he is but after a spirituall maner there, and so is he spiritually honored, as S Augustine sayth.
But as concerning heat of disputation, mark well the words of S. Augustine, good reader, cited in my book, and thou shalt see clearly, that §5all this multiplication of words is rather a juggling, then a direct answer. For saint Augustine writeth not in heat of disputation, but temperately and gravely, to a learned Bishop his dear friend, who demanded a question of him. And if Saint Augustine had answered in heat of disputation, or for any other respect, otherwise then the truth, he had not done the part of a friend, nor of a learned and godly Bishop. And who so ever judgeth so of Saint Augustine, hath small estimation of him, and showeth him self to have little knowledge of Saint Augustine.
But as concerning heat of disputation, marke well the wordes of S. Augustine, good reader, cited in my booke, and thou shalt see clerely, that §5all this multiplication of wordes is rather a iugling, then a direct answer. For saynt Augustine writeth not in heate of disputation, but temperatly and grauely, to a learned Bishop his deare frend, who demanded a question of him. And if Saynt Augustine had aunswered in heate of disputation, or for any other respect, otherwise then the truth, he had not done the part of a friend, nor of a learned and godly Bishop. And who so euer iudgeth so of Saynt Augustine, hath small estimation of him, and sheweth him selfe to haue litle knowledge of Saynt Augustine.
But in this your answer to saint Augustine, you utter where you learned a good part of your divinity, that is, of Albertus Pighius,1 who is the father of this shift, and with this sleight eludeth Saint Augustin when he could no otherwise answer. As you do now shake of the same Saint Augustine, resembling as it were in that point the lively countenance of your father Pighius. Next in my book followeth Theodoret
But in this your answer to saynt Augustine, you vtter where you learned a good part of your diuinitie, that is, of Albertus Pighius,1 who is the father of this shift, and with this fleight eludeth Saynt Augustin when he could no otherwise answer. As you do now shake of the same Saynt Augustine, resembling as it were in that poynt the liuely countenaūce of your father Pighius. Next in my booke foloweth Theodoret
And to this purpose it is both pleasant, comfortable, and profitable to read Theodoretus in his Dialogues,1 where he disputeth and showeth at length, how the names of things be changed in scripture, and yet things remain still. And for example he proveth that the flesh of Christ is in the scripture sometime called a veil or covering, sometime a cloth, sometime a vestment, and sometime a stole: & the blood of the grape is called Christs blood, and the names of bread and wine, and of his flesh and blood, Christ doth so change, that sometime he calleth his body, corn or bread, and sometime contrary, he calleth bread his body. And likewise his blood sometime he calleth wine, and sometime contrary he calleth wine his blood.
And to this purpose it is both pleasaunt, comfortable, and profitable to read Theodoretus in his Dialogs,1 where he disputeth and sheweth at length, how the names of things be chaunged in scripture, and yet thinges remayne still. And for example he proueth that the flesh of Christ is in the scripture sometime called a vayle or coueryng, sometime a cloth, sometyme a vestment, and sometyme a stole: & the bloud of the grape is called Christes bloud, and the names of bread and wine, and of his flesh and bloud, Christ doth so chaunge, that sometyme he calleth his body, corne or bread, and sometime contrary, he calleth bread his body. And likewise his bloud sometime he calleth wine, and sometime contrary he calleth wine his bloud.
For the more plain understanding whereof, it shall not be amiss to recite his own sayings in his foresaid dialogues, touching this matter of the holy sacrament of Christs flesh and blood. The speakers in these dialogues be Orthodoxus, the right believer, and Eranistes his companion, but not understanding the right faith.
For the more playne vnderstanding wherof, it shall not be amisse to recite his owne sayings in his foresayd dialogs, touching this matter of the holy sacrament of Christes flesh and bloud. The speakers in these dialogs be Orthodoxus, the right beleuer, and Eranistes his companyon, but not vnderstanding the right fayth.
Eran. I know that.
Orth. And in an other place he calleth his body corn.
Orth. And in an other place he calleth his body corne.
Eran. I know that also, for I have heard him say: The hour is come, that the son of man shall be glorified. &c.1 Except the grain of come, that falleth in the ground dye, it remaineth sole, but if it dye, then it bringeth forth much fruit.
Eran. I know that also, for I haue heard him say: The houre is come, that the sonne of man shalbe glorified. &c.1 Except the grayne of come, that falleth in the ground dye, it remayneth sole, but if it dye, then it bringeth forth much fruite.
Eran. So he called them.
Orth. But that also which was his natural body, may well be called his body and his very blood also, may be called his blood.
Orth. But that also which was his naturall body, may well be called his body and his very bloud also, may be called his bloud.
Eran. It is plain.
Eran. It is playne.
Orth. But our saviour without doubt changed the names, and gave to the body the name of the sign or token, and to the token he gave the name of the body. And so when he called himself a vine, he called blood that, which was the token of blood.1
Orth. But our sauiour without doubt chaunged the names, and gaue to the body the name of the signe or token, and to the token he gaue the name of the body. And so whē he called himself a vyne, he called bloud that, which was the token of bloud.1
Eran. Surely thou hast spoken the truth. But I would know the cause wherefore the names were changed.
Eran. Surely thou hast spokē the truth. But I would know the cause wherfore the names were changed.
Orth. The cause is manifest to them that be expert in true religion. For he would that they which be partakers of the godly sacraments, 1should not set their minds upon the nature of the things which they see, but by the changing of the names, should believe the things which be wrought in them by grace. For he that called that, which is his natural body, corn and bred, and also called himself a vine, he did honour the visible tokens and signs, with the names of his body and blood, not changing the nature, but adding grace to nature.
Orth. The cause is manifest to them that be expert in true religion. For he would that they which be partakers of the godly sacraments, 1should not set their mindes vpon the nature of the things which they see, but by the changing of the names, should beleue the things which be wrought in them by grace. For he that called that, which is his naturall body, corne and bred, and also called himselfe a vyne, he did honor the visible tokēs and signes, with the names of his body and bloud, not changing the nature, but adding grace to nature.
Eran. Sacraments be spoken of sacramentally, and also by them be manifestly declared things, which all men know not.
Ortho. Seeing then that it is certain, that the Patriarch called the lords body a vestiment and apparel,1 and that now we be entered to speak of godly sacraments, tell me truly of what thing thinkest thou this holy meat to be a token and figure of Christs divinity, or of his body and blood?
Ortho. Seyng then that it is certayne, that the Patriarch called the lords body a vestiment and apparell,1 and that now we be entred to speak of godly sacraments, tell me truely of what thing thinkest thou this holy meat to be a tokē and figure of Christes diuinity, or of his body and bloud?
Eran. It is clear that it is the figure of those things, whereof it beareth the name.
Eran. It is cleare that it is the figure of those thinges, whereof it beareth the name.
Orth. Meanest thou of his body and blood?
Orth. Meanest thou of his body and bloud?
Eran. Even so I mean
Eran. Euen so I meane
Orth. Thou hast spoken as one that loveth the truth, for the Lord when he took the token or sign, he said not. This is my divinity, but This is my body, & this is my blood. And in an other place.1 The bread which I will give is my flesh, which I will give for the life of the world.
Orth. Thou hast spoken as one that loueth the truth, for the Lord when he tooke the token or signe, he sayd not. This is my diuinity, but This is my body, & this is my bloud. And in an other place.1 The bread which I wil giue is my flesh, whiche I will geue for the life of the world.
Eran. These things be true, for they be Gods words. All these writeth Theodoretus in hi first Dialogue.'1 And in the second he writeth the same in effect (& yet in some thing more plainly) against such heretics, as affirmed that after Christs resurrection & ascension, his humanity was changed from the very nature of man & turned into his divinity. Against whom thus he writeth.
Eran. These things be true, for they be Gods words. All these writeth Theodoretus in hi first Dialogue.'1 And in the second he writeth the same in effect (& yet in some thing more playnly) agaynst such heretiques, as affirmed that after Christes resurrection & ascention, his humanity was changed from the very nature of man & turned into his diuinity. Agaynst whom thus he writeth.
Orth. Corruption, healeth sickness, and death, be accidents, for they go & come.
Orth. Corruption, healeth sicknes, and death, be accedents, for they goe & come.
Era. It is meet they be so called.
Orth. Mens bodies after their resurrection be delivered from corruption, death, & mortality, and yet they lose not their proper nature.
Orth. Mens bodies after their resurrection be delyuered from corruption, death, & mortalitie, and yet they lose not theyr proper nature.
Eran. Truth it is.'
Orth. The body of Christ therefore did rise quite clean from all corruption & death,1 and is impassible, immortal, glorified with the glory of God, & is honoured of the powers of heaven, and it is a body, & hath the same bigness that it had before.
Orth. The body of Christ therfore did rise quite cleane from all corruption & death,1 and is impassible, immortall, glorified with the glory of God, & is honored of the powers of heauen, and it is a body, & hath the same bignes that it had before.
Era. Thy saying seem true & according to reason, but after he was ascended ⟨p. 130⟩up into heaven, I think thou wilt not say, that his body was not turned into the nature of his godhead.
Era. Thy saying seeme true & according to reason, but after he was ascended ⟨p. 130⟩vp into heauen, I thinke thou wilt not say, that his body was not tourned into the nature of his godhead.
Orth. I would not so say for the persuasion of mans reason: nor I am not so arrogant and presumptuous, to affirm any thing which scripture passeth over in silence. But I have heard S. Paul cry,1 that God hath ordained a day when he will judge all the world in justice, by that man which he appointed before, performing his promise to all men, and raising him from death. I have learned also of the holy angels,2 that he will come a•ter that fashion, as his disciples saw him go to heaven. But they saw a nature of a certain bigness, not a nature which had no bigness. I heard furthermore the lord say, You shall see the son of man come in the clouds of heaven.3 And I know that every thing that men see, hath a certain bigness. For that nature that hath no bigness, can not be seen. Moreover to sit in the throne of glory, and to set the Lambs upon his right hand, and the goats upon his left hand, signifieth a thing that hath quantity and bigness. Hitherto have I rehearsed Theodoretus words, and shortly after Eranistes saith.
Orth. I would not so say for the persuation of mans reason: nor I am not so arrogant and presumptious, to affirme any thing which scripture passeth ouer in silence. But I haue heard S. Paule cry,1 that God hath ordayned a day when he will iudge all the world in iustice, by that man which he appoynted before, performing his promise to all men, and raysing him from death. I haue learned also of the holy angels,2 that he will come a•ter that fashion, as his disciples saw him goe to heauen. But they saw a nature of a certayn bignesse, not a nature which had no bignes. I heard furthermore the lord say, You shall see the sonne of man come in the cloudes of heauen.3 And I know that euery thing that men see, hath a certayne bignes. For that nature that hath no bignes, can not be seene. Moreouer to sit in the throne of glory, and to sette the Lambes vpon his right hand, and the goates vpon his left hand, signifieth a thing that hath quantitie and bygnes. Hitherto haue I rehersed Theodoretus wordes, and shortly after Eranistes sayth.
Eran. We must turn every stone (as the proverb saith) to seek out the truth, but specially when godly matters be propounded.
Eran. We must tourne euery stone (as the prouerb sayth) to seeke out the truth, but specially when godly matters be propounded.
Orth. Tell me than the sacramental signs which be offered to God by his priests, whereof be they signs, sayest thou?
Orth. Tell me than the sacramentall signes which be offered to God by his priestes, wherof be they signes, sayst thou?
Eran. Of the Lords body and blood.
Eran. Of the Lordes body and bloud.
Orth. Of a very body? or not of a very body?
Eran. Of a very body.