pp. 3941,982 passagespart 30 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But to utter the matter plainly without fallax or cavillation, I teach that no man can eat Christs flesh and drink his blood but spiritually, which forasmuch as evil men do not, although they eat the sacramental bread until their bellies be full, and drink the wine until they be drunken, yet eat they neither Christs flesh, nor drink his blood, neither in the sacrament nor without the sacrament, because they cannot be eaten and drunken but by spirit and faith, whereof ungodly men be destitute, being nothing but world and flesh.
But to vtter the matter playnly without fallax or cauilation, I teach that no man can eat Christes flesh and drincke his bloud but spiritually, which forasmuch as euill men do not, although they eat the sacramentall bread vntill theyr bellyes be full, and drincke the wine vntill they be dronken, yet eat they neither Christes flesh, nor drincke his bloud, neither in the sacrament nor without the sacrament, because they cannot be eaten and dronken but by spirite and fayth, wherof vngodly men be destitute, being nothing but world and flesh.
This therefore is the sum of my teaching in this fourth book, that in the true ministration of the Sacrament Christ is present spiritually, and so spiritually eaten of them that be godly and spiritual. And as for the ungodly and carnal, they may eat the bread, and drink the wine, but with Christ him self they have no communion or company,1 and therefore they neither eat his flesh nor drink his blood, which who soever eateth,2 hath (as Christ saith him self) life by him, as Christ hath life by his father. And to eat Christs body or drink his blood (saith S. Augustine) ⟨p. 213⟩is to have life.3 For whether Christ be in the Sacrament corporally (as you say) or spiritually in them that rightly believe in him, and duly receive the Sacrament (as I say) yet certain it is, that there he is not eaten corporally but spiritually. For corporal eating with the mouth, is to chaw & tear in pieces with the teeth, after which manner Christs body is of no man eaten: although Nicholas the second,4 made such an article of the faith, and compelled Berengatius so to profess. And therefore although Christ were corporally in the Sacrament, yet seeing that he cannot be corporally eaten, this book cometh in good place and is very necessary, to know that Christs body can not be eaten but spiritually, by believing and remembering Christs benefits, and revolving them in our mind, believing that as the bread and wine feed and nourish our bodies, so Christ feedeth and nourisheth our souls.
This therfore is the summe of my teaching in this fourth booke, that in the true ministration of the Sacrament Christ is present spiritually, and so spiritually eaten of them that be godly and spirituall. And as for the vngodly and carnall, they may eate the bread, and drincke the wine, but with Christ him selfe they haue no communion or company,1 and therfore they neyther eate his flesh nor drincke his bloud, which who soeuer eateth,2 hath (as Christ sayth him selfe) life by him, as Christ hath life by his father. And to eate Christes body or drincke his bloud (sayth S. Augustine) ⟨p. 213⟩is to haue life.3 For whether Christ be in the Sacrament corporally (as you say) or spiritually in them that rightly beleue in him, and duely receaue the Sacrament (as I say) yet certayne it is, that there he is not eaten corporally but spiritually. For corporal eating with ye mouth, is to chaw & teare in peces with ye teeth, after which maner Christes body is of no man eaten: although Nicholas the second,4 made such an article of the fayth, and compelled Berengatius so to professe. And therfore although Christ were corporally in the Sacrament, yet seeing that he cannot be corporally eaten, this booke commeth in good place and is very necessary, to know that Christes body can not be eaten but spiritually, by beleuing and remembring Christes benefites, and reuoluing them in our mynd, beleeuing that as the bread and wine feed and nourish our bodyes, so Christ feedeth and nourisheth our soules.
And ought this to come out of a christian mans mouth, That these be good words, but such as the words of christs supper do not learn us? Do not the words of Christs supper learn us to eat the bread and drink the wine in the remembrance of his death?1 Is not the breaking and eating of the bread, after such sort as Christ ordained, a communication of Christs body unto us? Is not the cup likewise a communication of his blood unto us? Should not then christian people according hereunto, in faith feed upon Christ spiritually, believing that as the bread & wine feed and nourish their bodies, so both Christ their souls with his own flesh and blood? And shall any Christian man now say, that these be good words, but such as the words in Christs supper do not learn us?
And ought this to come out of a christian mannes mouth, That these be good wordes, but such as the wordes of christes supper do not learne vs? Do not the wordes of Christes supper learne vs to eate the breade and drinke the wine in the remembraunce of his death?1 Is not the breakyng and eating of the bread, after such sort as Christ ordayned, a communication of Christes body vnto vs? Is not the cuppe likewise a communication of his bloud vnto vs? Should not then christian people according hereunto, in fayth feed vpon Christ spiritually, beleuing that as the bread & wine feed and nourish theyr bodyes, so both Christ their soules with his owne flesh and bloud? And shall any Christian man now say, that these be good wordes, but such as the wordes in Christes supper do not learne vs?
And yet these said words limit not the mystery of the supper: for as much as that mystery of eating Christs flesh and drinking his blood extendeth further then the supper, and continueth so long as we be lively members of Christs body. For none feed nor be nourished by him, but that be lively members of his body, and so long and no longer feed they of him, then they be his true members, and receive life from him. For feeding of him, is to receive life.
And yet these sayd wordes limit not the mistery of the supper: for as much as that mistery of eating Christes flesh and drinking his bloud extendeth further then the supper, and continueth so long as we be liuely membres of Christes body. For none feede nor be nourished by him, but that be liuely members of his body, and so long and no longer feede they of him, then they be his true membres, and receaue life from him. For feeding of him, is to receaue life.
But this is not that invisible sacrament which you say S. Augustin speaketh of in sermone Domini in monte, 1the iij book. For he calleth there the daily bread, which we continually pray for, either corporal bread and meat which is our daily sustenance for the body, or else the visible sacrament of bread and wine, or the invisible sacrament of gods word and commandments, of the which sacraments gods word is daily heard, and the other is daily seen. And if by the invisible sacrament of God's word S. Augustine meant our nourishment by Christs flesh and blood, than be we nourished with them as well by gods word, as by the sacrament of the lords supper.
But this is not that inuisible sacrament which you say S. Augustin speaketh of in sermone Domini in monte, 1the iij booke. For he calleth there the dayly bread, which we continually pray for, eyther corporall bread and meate which is our dayly sustenaunce for the body, or els the visible sacrament of bread and wine, or the inuisible sacrament of gods word and cōmaundementes, of the which sacramentes gods word is dayly heard, and the other is dayly seene. And if by the inuisible sacrament of goddes word S. Augustine ment our norishment by Christes flesh and bloud, than be we nourished with them as well by gods word, as by the sacrament of the lordes supper.
But yet who so ever told you that S. Augustine wrote this in the iij. book de sermone Domini in monte, trust him not much hereafter, for he did utterly deceive you. For S. Augustine wrote no more but .ij. books de sermone Domine in monte, and if you can make iij. of ij. (as you do here) and one of iiij. as you did before in the substances of Christ, you be a marvellous auditor, and then had all men need to beware of your accounts, least you deceive them. And you cannot lay the fault ⟨p. 214⟩here in the Printer, for I have seen it written so both by your own hand, and by the hand of your secretary.
But yet who so euer tolde you that S. Augustine wrote this in the iij. booke de sermone Domini in monte, trust him not much hereafter, for he dyd vtterly deceaue you. For S. Augustine wrote no more but .ij. bookes de sermone Domine in monte, and if you can make iij. of ij. (as you do here) and one of iiij. as you dyd before in the substances of Christ, you be a meruailouse auditour, and then had all men neede to beware of your accomptes, least you deceaue them. And you cannot lay the fault ⟨p. 214⟩here in the Printer, for I haue seen it written so both by your own hand, and by the hand of your secretary.
Now when you have wrangled in this matter as much as you can, at length you confess the truth, that who so feedeth upon Christ spiritually, must needs be a good man, (for only good men be members of Christs mystical body) which spiritual eating is so good a fruit, as it declareth the tree necessarily to be good. And therefore it must be and is a certain conclusion, that only good men do eat and drink the body and blood of Christ spiritually, that is to say, effectually to life. This you write in conclusion, and this is the very doctrine that I teach, and in the same terms: marry, I add thereto, that the eating of Christs body is a spiritual eating, and the drinking of his blood is a spiritual drinking, and therefore no evil man can eat his flesh, nor drink his blood, as this my forth book teacheth, and is necessary to be written. For although neither good nor evil men eat Christs body in the sacrament, under the visible signs, in the which he is not but sacramentally: yet the good feed of him spiritually, being inhabiting spiritually within them, although corporally he be absent and in heaven: but the evil men neither feed upon him corporally, nor spiritually (from whom he is both the said ways absent) although corporally, they eat and drink with their mouths, the sacraments of his body and blood.
Now when you haue wrangled in this matter as much as you can, at length you confesse the truth, that who so feedeth vpon Christ spiritually, must needes be a good man, (for only good men be membres of Christes misticall body) which spirituall eating is so good a frute, as it declareth the tree necessarelye to be good. And therfore it must be and is a certaine conclusion, that onely good menne doe eate and drinke the bodye and bloude of Christ spiritually, that is to say, effectually to lyfe. This you write in conclusion, and this is ye very doctrine that I teache, and in the same tearmes: marry, I adde therto, yt the eating of Christes body is a spirituall eating, and the drinking of his bloud is a spirituall drinkyng, and therfore no euill man can eate his flesh, nor drinke his bloud, as this my forth booke teacheth, and is necessary to be writen. For although neither good nor euell men eate Christes body in the sacrament, vnder the visible signes, in the which he is not but sacramentally: yet the good feede of him spiritually, being inhabiting spiritually within them, although corporally he be absent and in heauen: but the euell men neither feede vpon him corporally, nor spiritually (from whom he is both the sayd wayes absent) although corporally, they eate and drinke with theyr mouthes, the sacramentes of his body and bloud.
1Now where you note here three manner of eatings, and yet but two §6manner of eatings of Christ, this your noting is very true, if it be truly understand. For there be in deed three manner of eatings, one spiritual only an other spiritual and sacramental both together, & the third sacramental only: and yet Christ him self is eaten but in the first two manner of ways, as you truly teach. And for to set out this distinction somewhat more plainly, that plain men may understand it, it may thus be termed, That there is a spiritual eating only, when Christ by a true faith is eaten without the sacrament: Also there is an other eating both spiritual and sacramental, when the visible sacrament is eaten with the mouth, and Christ him self is eaten with a true faith: The third eating is sacramental only, when the sacrament is eaten and not Christ himself. So that in the first is Christ eaten without the sacrament: in the second he is eaten with the sacrament: and in the third the sacrament is eaten without him: and therefore it is called sacramental eating only, because only the sacrament is eaten, and not Christ himself. After the two first manner of ways, godly men do eat (who feed and live by Christ) the third manner of ways the wicked do eat, and therefore (as S. Augustine saith) they neither eat Christs flesh nor drink his blood although every day they eat the sacrament thereof,2 to the condemnation of their presumption. And for this cause also S. Paul saith not, He that eateth Christs body, and drinketh his blood unworthily, shall have condemnation, and be guilty of the Lords body: but he saith, he that eateth this bread,3 and drinketh the cup of the Lord unworthily, shall be guilty of the Lords body, and eateth and drinketh his own damnation, because he esteemeth not the Lords body.
1Now where you note here three manner of eatinges, and yet but two §6manner of eatinges of Christ, this your noting is very true, if it be truly vnderstand. For there be in dede three maner of eatinges, one spirituall onely an other spiritual and sacramentall both together, & the third sacramentall only: and yet Christ him selfe is eaten but in the first two manner of waies, as you truely teache. And for to set out this distinctiō somewhat more playnly, that playne menne may vnderstand it, it may thus be tearmed, That there is a spirituall eating only, when Christ by a true fayth is eaten without the sacrament: Also there is an other eating both spirituall and sacramental, when the visible sacrament is eaten with the mouth, and Christ him selfe is eaten with a true fayth: The third eating is sacramentall only, when the sacrament is eaten and not Christ himselfe. So that in the fyrst is Christ eaten without the sacrament: in the seconde he is eaten with the sacrament: and in the thirde the sacrament is eaten without him: and therfore it is called sacramentall eating onely, bycause onely the sacramente is eaten, and not Christ himselfe. After the two first maner of wayes, godly men do eate (who feede and liue by Christ) the thirde manner of wayes the wicked do eate, and therfore (as S. Augustine sayth) they neither eate Christes flesh nor drinke his bloud although euery day they eat the sacrament therof,
And here you commit two foul faults. One is, that you declare S. Paul to speak of the body and blood of Christ, when he spake of ⟨p. 215⟩the bread and wine. The other fault is, that you add to S. Pauls words this word (there) and so build your work upon a foundation made by your own self.
And here you committe two fowle faultes. One is, that you declare S. Paule to speake of the body and bloud of Christ, when he spake of ⟨p. 215⟩the bread and wine. The other fault is, that you adde to S. Paules wordes this word (there) and so buylde your worke vpon a foundation made by your owne selfe.
And where you say, that if my doctrine be true, neither good men nor evil eat but the sacramental bread, it can be none other but very frowardness and mere wilfulness, that you will not understand that thing which I have spoken so plainly, & repeated so many times. For I say, that good men eat the Lords body spiritually to their eternal nourishment, where as evil men eat but the bread carnally to their eternal punishment. And as you note of S. Augustine, that baptism is very well called health,1 and the sacrament of Christs body called life, as in which God giveth health and life, if we worthily use them: so is the sacramental bread very well called Christs body, and the wine his blood, as in the ministration whereof, Christ giveth us his flesh and blood, if we worthily receive them.
And where you say, that if my doctrine be true, neyther good men nor euill eate but the sacramentall bread, it can be none other but very frowardnes and mere wilfulnes, that you will not vnderstand that thinge which I haue spoken so playnly, & repeted so many tymes. For I say, that good men eat the Lordes body spiritually to theyr eternall nourishment, where as euyl men eat but the bread carnally to their eternall punishment. And as you note of S. Augustine, that baptisme is very well called health,1 and the sacrament of Christes body called lyfe, as in which God gyueth health and lyfe, if we worthely vse them: so is the sacramentall bread very well called Christes body, and ye wine his bloud, as in the ministration wherof, Christ geueth vs his flesh and bloude, if we worthely receaue them.
And where you teach how the works of God in them selves be alway true and uniform in all men without diversity in good and evil,1 in worthy and unworthy, you bring in this mystical matter here clearly without purpose or reason, far passing the capacity of simple readers, only to blind their eyes withal. By which kind of teaching it is all one work of God to save and to damn, to kill and to give life, to hate and to love, to elect and to reject, and to be short, by this kind of doctrine God and all his works be one, without diversity either of one work from an other, or of his works from his substance. And by this means it is all one work of God in baptism and in the Lords supper. But all this is spoken quite besides the matter, and serveth for nothing but to cast a mist before mens eyes, as it seemeth you seek nothing else through your whole book.
And where you teach how the workes of God in them selues be alway true and vniforme in all men without diuersitie in good and euill,1 in worthy and vnworthy, you bring in this misticall matter here clearly without purpose or reason, farre passyng the capacitie of simple readers, onely to blinde their eyes withall. By which kynde of teaching it is all one worke of God to saue and to damne, to kill and to gyue lyfe, to hate and to loue, to elect and to reiect, and to be short, by this kinde of doctrine God and all his workes be one, without diuersite eyther of one worke from an other, or of his workes from his substaunce. And by this meanes it is all one worke of God in baptisme and in the Lordes supper. But all this is spoken quite besides the matter, and serueth for nothing but to cast a myst before mens eyes, as it semeth you seeke nothing els thorow your whole booke.
And this your doctrine hath a very evil smack, that spirit and life should fall upon naughty men, although for their malice it tarry not. For by this doctrine you join together in one man, Christ and Belial, the spirit of God and the spirit of the devil, life and death, and all at one time:1 which doctrine I will not name what it is, for all faithful men know the name right well and detest the same.2 And what ignorance can be showed more in him that accounteth himself learned, then to gather of Christs words (where her saith, his words be spirit and life) that spirit and life should be in evil men because they hear his words.3 For the words which you recite by and by of S. Augustin, show how vain your argument is,4 when he saith, The words be spirit and life, but not to thee, that doest carnally understand them. What estimation of learning or of truth would you have men to conceive of you, that bring such unlearned arguments whereof the invalidity appeareth within six lines after? Which must needs declare in you either, much untruth and unsincere proceeding, or much ignorance, or at the least all exceeding forgetfulness, to say anything, reproved again within six lines after. And if the promises of God (as you say) be not disappointed by our infidelity, then if evil men eat the very body of Christ and drink his blood, they must needs dwell in Christ, and have Christ dwelling in them, and by him have everlasting life: because of these promises of Christ, Qui manducat ⟨p. 216⟩meam carnem, & bibit meum sanguinem, in memanet et ego in eo. Et quimanducat meam carnem & bibit meum sanguinem, habet vitam aeternam, 5He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, hath everlasting life. And he that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me and I in him. And yet the third promise. Qui manducat me, & ipse vives propter me, 6He that eateth me, he shall also live by me. These be .iij. promises of God, which if they can not be disappointed by our infidelity, then if evil men eat the very body of Christ and drink his blood (as you say they do in the sacrament) then must it needs follow, that they shall have everlasting life, and that they dwell in Christ and Christ in them, because our infidelity (say you) can not disappoint God's promises.
1And how agreeth this your saying with that doctrine which you were wont earnestly to teach both by mouth and pen, that all the promises of God to us be made under condition, if our infidelity can not disappoint Gods promises? For then the promises of God must needs have place, whether we observe the condition or not.
1And how agreeth this your saying with that doctrine which you were wont earnestly to teach both by mouth and penne, that all the promises of God to vs be made vnder condition, if our infidilitie can not disappoynt Gods promises? For then the promises of God must nedes haue place, whether we obserue the condition or not.
But here you have fetched a great compass & circuit utterly in vain,§10 to reprove that thing which I never denied,1 but ever affirmed, which is, That the substance of the visible sacrament of the body and blood of Christ, (which I say is bread and wine in the sacrament, as water is in baptism) is all one substance to good and to bad, and to both a figure. But that under the form of bread and wine, is corporally present by Christs ordinance his very body and blood, either to good or to ill, that you neither have nor can prove, & yet thereupon would you bring in your conclusion here, wherein you commit that folly in reasoning, which is called Petitio principij.
But here you haue fetched a great compasse & circuit vtterly in vayne,§10 to reproue that thing which I neuer denied,1 but euer affirmed, which is, That the substaunce of the visible sacrament of the body and bloud of Christ, (which I say is bread and wine in the sacrament, as water is in baptisme) is all one substance to good and to badde, and to both a figure. But that vnder the fourme of bread and wine, is corporally present by Christes ordinaūce his very body and bloud, eyther to good or to ill, that you neyther haue nor can proue, & yet thereupō would you bring in your conclusion here, wherin you commit that folly in reasoning, which is caled Petitio principij.
1What need you to make herein any issue, when we agree in the matter? For in the substance I make no diversity, but I say that the substance of Christs body and blood is corporally present, neither in the good eater, nor in the evil. And as for the substance of bread and wine, I say they be all one, whether the good or evil eat and drink them. As the water of Baptism is all one,2 whether Simon Peter, or Simon Magus, be christened therein, and it is one word that to the evil is a savour of death and to the good is a savour of life. And as it is one Sun that shineth upon the good and the bad,3 that melteth butter, and maketh the earth hard: one flower whereof the bee sucketh honey, and the spider poison, and one ointment, (as Decumenius saith) that killeth the beetle,4 and strengtheneth the dove. Nevertheless as all that be washed in the water be not washed with the holy spirit, so all that eat the sacramental bread, eat not the very body of Christ. And thus you see that your issue is to no purpose, except you would fight with your own shadow.
1What neede you to make herein any issue, when we agree in ye matter? For in the substance I make no diuersitie, but I say that the substance of Christes body and bloud is corporally present, neyther in the good eater, nor in the euill. And as for the substance of bread and wine, I say they be all one, whether the good or euill eate and drincke them. As the water of Baptisme is all one,2 whether Symon Peter, or Symon Magus, be christned therin, and it is one word that to the euill is a sauoure of death and to the good is a sauoure of lyfe. And as it is one Sonne that shineth vppon the good and the badde,3 that melteth butter, and maketh the earth harde: one flower wherof the bee sucketh hony, and the spyder poyson, and one oyntment, (as Decumenius sayth) that kylleth the bettyll,4
Now forasmuch as after all this vain and frivolous consuming of words you begin to make answer unto my proofs, I shall here rehearse my proofs and arguments, to the intent that the reader seeing both my proofs and your confutations before his eyes, may the better consider and give his judgement therein. My forth book beginneth thus.1
Now forasmuch as after all this vayne and friuolous consuming of wordes you begin to make answere vnto my profes, I shall here reherse my profes and argumentes, to the intent that the reader seyng both my profes and your confutations before his eyes, may the better consider and geue his iudgement therein. My forth booke begynneth thus.1
1The gross error of the Papists is, Of the carnal eating and drinking of Christs flesh and blood with our mouths.
1THe grosse errour of the Papistes is, Of the carnall eating and drinking of Christes flesh and bloud with our mouthes.
For they say, that whosoever eat and drink the sacraments ⟨p. 217⟩of bread and wine, do eat and drink also with their mouths Christs very flesh and blood, be they never so ungodly and wicked persons. But Christ him self taught clean contrary in the sixth of John, that we eat not him carnally with our mouths, but spiritually with our faith, saying:1 Verily verily I say unto you: he that believeth in me, hath everlasting life. I am the bread of life. Your fathers did eat Manna in the wilderness, and dyed. This is the bread that cam from heaven,2 that who so ever shall eat thereof, shall not dye. I am the lively bread that cam from heaven. If any man eat of this bread, he shall live for ever. And the bread which I will give is my flesh, which I will give for the life of the world.
For they say, that whosoeuer eate and drincke the sacramentes ⟨p. 217⟩of bread and wine, do eat and drincke also with theyr mouthes Christes very flesh and bloud, be they neuer so vngodly and wicked persons. But Christ him selfe taught cleane contrary in the sixt of Iohn, that we eate not him carnally with our mouthes, but spiritually with our fayth, saying:1 Verily verily I say vnto you: he that beleueth in me, hath euerlasting lyfe. I am the bread of life. Your fathers did eat Manna in the wildernes, and dyed. This is the bread that cam from heauen,2 that who so euer shall eate therof, shall not dye. I am the liuely bread that cam from heauen. If any man eat of this bread, he shall liue for euer. And the bread which I will geue is my flesh, which I will geue for the lyfe of the world.
This is the most true doctrine of our saviour Christ, that whosoever eateth him, shall have everlasting life. And by and by it followeth in the same place of S. John more clearly. Verily verily I say unto you, except you eat the flesh of the son of man, and drink his blood, you shall not have life in you. He that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, hath life everlasting, 1and I will raise him again at the last day: For my flesh is very meat, and my blood is very drink. He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me and I in him. As the living father hath sent me, and I live by the father, even so he that eateth me, shall live by me. This is the bread which came down from heaven, not as your fathers did eat Manna, and are dead. He that eateth this bread shall live for ever.
This is the most true doctrine of our sauiour Christ, that whosoeuer eateth him, shall haue euerlasting lyfe. And by and by it followeth in the same place of S. Iohn more clearly. Verely verely I say vnto you, except you eat the flesh of the sonne of man, and drincke his bloud, you shall not haue life in you. He that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my bloud, hath life euerlasting, 1and I will rayse him agayne at the last day: For my flesh is very meate, and my bloud is very drincke. He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my bloud, dwelleth in me and I in him. As the liuing father hath sent me, and I liue by the father, euen so he that eateth me, shall liue by me. This is the bread which came downe from heauen, not as your fathers did eate Manna, and are dead. He that eateth this bread shall liue for euer.
This taught our saviour Christ as well his disciples as the Jews at Capernaum, that the eating of his flesh and drinking of his blood was not like to the eating of Manna. For both good and bad did eat Manna, but none do eat his flesh and drink his blood, but they have everlasting life. For as his father dwelleth in him, and he in his father, and so hath life by his father: so he that eateth Christs flesh and drinketh his blood, dwelleth in Christ and, Christ in him, and by Christ he hath eternal life.
This taught our sauiour Christ as well his disciples as the Iewes at Capernaum, that the eating of his flesh and drincking of his bloud was not like to the eating of Manna. For both good and bad did eate Manna, but none do eate his flesh and drincke his bloud, but they haue euerlasting lyfe. For as his father dwelleth in him, and he in his father, and so hath life by his father: so he that eateth Christes flesh and drinketh his bloud, dwelleth in Christ and, Christ in him, and by Christ he hath eternall life.
What need we any other witness? when Christ himself doth testify the matter so plainly, that who so ever eateth his flesh and drinketh his blood, hath everlasting life? and that to eat his flesh and to drink his blood, is to believe in him? And who so ever believeth in him, hath everlasting life, whereof it followeth necessarily, that ungodly persons (being limbs of the devil) do not eat Christs flesh nor drink his blood, except the Papists would say, that such have everlasting life.
What neede we any other witnes? when Christ himselfe doth testifie the mater so playnly, that who so euer eateth his flesh and drinketh his bloud, hath euerlasting life? and that to eate his flesh and to drincke his bloud, is to beleue in him? And who so euer beleueth in him, hath euerlasting lyfe, wherof it followeth necessarily, that vngodly persons (being limmes of the deuill) do not eate Christes flesh nor drinke his bloud, except the Papistes would say, that such haue euerlasting life.
But as the devil is the food of the wicked, which he nourisheth in all iniquity, and bringeth up into everlasting damnation: so is Christ the very food of all them that be the lively members of his body, and them he nourisheth, fedeth, bringeth up and cherisheth unto everlasting life.
But as the diuell is the food of the wicked, which he nourisheth in all iniquitie, and bringeth vp into euerlasting damnatiō: so is Christ the very foode of all them that be the liuely members of his body, and them he nourisheth, fedeth, bringeth vp and cherisheth vnto euerlasting life.
And every good and faithful Christian man selleth in himself,1 how he fedeth of Christ, eating his flesh and drinking of his blood. For he putteth the whole hope and trust of his redemption and salvation in that only sacrifice,2 which Christ made upon the Cross, having his body there broken, and his blood there shed for the remission of his sins. And this great benefit of Christ, the faithful man earnestly considereth in his mind, cheweth and digesteth it with the stomach of his hart, spiritually receiving Christ wholly into him, and giving again him self wholly unto Christ.
And euery good and faythfull Christian man seleth in himselfe,1 how he fedeth of Christ, eating his flesh and drincking of his bloud. For he putteth the whole hope and trust of his redemption and saluation in that onely sacrifice,2 which Christ made vpon the Crosse, hauing his body there broken, and his bloud there shedde for the remission of his sinnes. And this great benefite of Christ, the faythfull man earnestly considereth in his mynd, chaweth and digesteth it with the stomake of his hart, spiritually receauing Christ wholy into him, and giuing agayne him selfe wholy vnto Christ.
And this is the eating of Christs flesh and drinking of his blood, the feeling whereof is to every man, the feeling how he eateth and drinketh Christ, ⟨p. 218⟩which none evil man nor member of the devil can do.
And this is the eating of Christes flesh and drinking of his bloud, the feeling wherof is to euery man, the feling how he eateth and drincketh Christ, ⟨p. 218⟩which none euill man nor member of the deuill can do.
1For as Christ is a spiritual meat, so is he spiritually eaten and digested with the spiritual part of us, and giveth us spiritual and eternal life, and is not eaten,2 swallowed & digested with our teeth, tongues, throats & bellies.
1For as Christ is a spirituall meate, so is he spiritually eaten and digested with the spirituall part of vs, and giueth vs spirituall and eternall lyfe, and is not eaten,2 swallowed & digested with our teeth, tongues, throtes & bellies.
Therefore saith S. Cyprian, he that drinketh of the holy cup, remembering this benefit of God, is more thirsty then he was before. And lifting up his hart unto the living God, is taken with such a singular hunger and appetite, that he abhorreth all gally and bitter drinks of sin, and all savour of carnal pleasure is to him as it were sharp and sour vinegar. And the sinner being converted, receiving the holy mysteries of the Lords supper, giveth thanks unto God, and boweth down his head, knowing that his sins be forgiven, and that he is made clean and perfect, and his soul (which God hath sanctified) he rendereth to God again as a faithful pledge, and then he glorieth with Paul, and rejoiceth saying: Now it is not I that live, but it is Christ that liveth within me. These things be practised and used among faithful people and to pure minds, the eating of his flesh is no horror but honour, and the spirit delighteth in the drinking of the holy and sanctifying blood. And doing this, we whet not our teeth to bite, but with pure faith we break the holy bread. These be the words of Cyprian.
Therfore sayth S. Ciprian, he that drincketh of the holy cup, remembring this benefite of God, is more thirsty then he was before. And lifting vp his hart vnto the liuing God, is taken with such a singular hunger and apetite, that he abhorreth all gally and bitter drinkes of sinne, and all sauor of carnall pleasure is to him as it were sharp and sowre viniger. And the sinner being conuerted, receauing the holy misteries of the Lordes supper, geueth thankes vnto God, and boweth downe his head, knowing that his sinnes be forgeuen, and that he is made clean and perfect, and his soule (which God hath sanctified) he rendreth to God agayne as a faythfull pledge, and then he glorieth with Paule, and reioyseth saying: Now it is not I that liue, but it is Christ that liueth within me. These thinges be practised and vsed among faythful people and to pure myndes, the eating of his flesh is no horror but honor, and the spirit deliteth in the drinking of the holy and sanctifiing bloud. And doing this, we whet not our teeth to bite, but with pure fayth we breake the holy bread. These be the wordes of Ciprian.
1And according unto the same, S. Augustine saith: Prepare not thy jaws, but thy hart. And in an other place he saith, why doest thou prepare thy belly and thy teeth? Believe, and thou hast eaten. But of this matter is sufficiently spoken before,2 where it is proved, that to eat Christs flesh and drink his blood, be figurative speeches.
1And according vnto the same, S. Augustine sayth: Prepare not thy iawes, but thy hart. And in an other place he sayth, why doest thou prepare thy belly and thy teeth? Beleue, and thou hast eaten. But of this matter is sufficiently spoken before,2 where it is proued, that to eate Christes flesh and drincke his bloud, be figuratiue speaches.
1And now to return to our purpose, that only the lively members of Christ do eat his flesh and drink his blood, I shall bring forth many other places of ancient authors before not mentioned.
1And now to returne to our purpose, that onely the liuely members of Christ do eate his flesh and drincke his bloud, I shall bring forth many other places of auncient authors before not mentioned.
1First Origen writeth plainly after this manner. The word was made flesh and very meat, which who so eateth, shall surly live for ever, which no evil man can eat. For if it could be, that he that continueth evil might eat the word made flesh, seeing that he is the word and bread of life, it should not have been written: Who so ever eateth this bread, shall live for ever. These words be so plain, that I need say nothing for the more clear declaration of them. Wherefore you shall hear how Cyprian agreeth with him.
1Fyrst Origen writeth playnly after this maner. The word was made flesh and very meat, which who so eateth, shall surly liue for euer, which no euill man can eate. For if it could be, that he that continueth euill might eat the word made flesh, seing that he is the word and bread of life, it should not haue bene written: Who so euer eateth this bread, shall liue for euer. These wordes be so playne, that I need say nothing for the more clere declaration of them. Wherfore you shall heare how Ciprian agreeth with him.
1Cyprian in his sermon, ascribed unto him, of the Lords supper, saith: The author of this tradition said, that except we eat his flesh & drink his blood, we should have no life in us, instructing us with a spiritual lesson, & opening to us a way to understand so privy a thing, that we should know, that the eating is our dwelling in him, and our drinking is as it were an incorporation in him, being subject unto him in obedience, joined unto him in our wills, and united in our affections. The eating therefore of this flesh, is a certain hunger and desire to dwell in him.
1Cyprian in his sermon, ascribed vnto him, of the Lordes supper, sayth: The author of this tradition sayd, that except we eat his flesh & drincke his bloud, we should haue no life in vs, instructing vs with a spirituall lesson, & opening to vs a way to vnderstand so priuy a thing, that we should know, that the eating is our dwelling in him, and our drincking is as it were an incorporation in him, being subiect vnto him in obedience, ioyned vnto him in our willes, and vnited in our affections. The eating therfore of this flesh, is a certayne hunger and desire to dwell in him.
Thus writeth Cyprian of the eating and drinking of Christ'. And a little after he saith, that none do eat of this lamb, but such as be true Israelites, that is to say, pure christian men without colour or dissimulation.
Thus writeth Cyprian of the eating and drinking of Christ'. And a litle after he sayth, that none do eate of this lambe, but such as be true Israelites, that is to say, pure christian men without colour or dissimulation.
1And Athanasius speaking of the eating of Christs flesh and drinking of his blood, saith that for this cause he made mention of his ascension into heaven, to pluck them from corporal fantasy, that they might learn hereafter that his flesh was called the celestial meat that came from above, and a spiritual ⟨p. 219⟩food, which he would give. For those things that I speak to you (saith he) be spirit and life. Which is as much to say, as that thing which you see, shall be slain and given for the nourishment of the world, that it may be distributed to every body spiritually, and be to all men a conservation unto the resurrection of eternal life.
1And Athanasius speaking of the eating of Christes flesh and drincking of his bloud, sayth that for this cause he made mention of his ascentiō into heauen, to plucke them from corporall phantasy, that they might lerne hereafter that his flesh was called the celestiall meate that came from aboue, and a spirituall ⟨p. 219⟩food, which he would geue. For those thinges that I speake to you (sayth he) be spirit and life. Which is as much to say, as that thing which you se, shalbe slayne and giuen for the nourishment of the world, that it may be distributed to euery body spiritually, and be to all men a conseruation vnto the resurrectiō of eternall life.
In these words Athanasius declareth the cause why Christ made mention of his ascension into heaven, when he spake of the eating and drinking of his flesh and blood. The cause after Athanasius mind was this, that his hearers should not think of any carnal eating of his body with their mouths (for as concerning the presence of his body) he should be taken from them, and ascend into heaven, but that they should understand him to be a spiritual meat, & spiritually to be eaten, and by that refreshing to give eternal life, which he doth to none, but to such as be his lively members.
In these wordes Athanasius declareth the cause why Christ made mention of his ascension into heauen, when he spake of the eating and drincking of his flesh and bloud. The cause after Athanasius mynd was this, that his hearers should not thinke of any carnal eating of his body with their mouthes (for as concerning the presence of his body) he should be taken from them, and ascend into heauen, but that they should vnderstād him to be a spirituall meate, & spiritually to be eaten, and by that refreshing to giue eternall life, which he doth to none, but to such as be his liuely members.
And of this eating speaketh also Basilius,1 that we eat Christs flesh and drink his blood, being made by his incarnation and sensible life, partakers of his word and wisdom. For his flesh and blood he calleth all his mystical conversation here in his flesh and his doctrine, consisting of his whole life, pertaining both to his humanity and divinity, whereby the soul is nourished and brought to the contemplation of things eternal.
And of this eating speaketh also Basilius,1 that we eate Christes flesh and drincke his bloud, being made by his incarnation and sensible lyfe, partakers of his word and wisedome. For his flesh and bloud he calleth all his misticall conuersation here in his flesh and his doctrine, consisting of his whole life, pertayning both to his humanitie and diuinitie, wherby the soule is nourished and brought to the contemplation of thinges eternall.
Thus teacheth Basilius how we eat Christs flesh and drink his blood" which pertaineth only to the true and faithful members of Christ.
Thus teacheth Basilius how we eate Christes flesh and drincke his bloud" which pertayneth only to the true and faythfull members of Christ.
S. Hierom also saith: All that love pleasure more then God, eat not the flesh of Jesus, nor drink his blood. 1Of the which himself saith: He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, hath everlasting life."
S. Hierom also sayth: All that love pleasure more then God, eate not the flesh of Iesu, nor drincke his bloud. 1Of the which himselfe sayth: He that eateth my flesh and drincketh my bloud, hath euerlasting lyfe."
Thus agreeth S. Hierom with the other before rehearsed, that heretics and such as follow worldly pleasures eat not Christs flesh nor drink his blood, because that Christ said, He that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, hath everlasting life.
Thus agreeth S. Hierom with the other before rehersed, that heretikes and such as follow worldly pleasures eate not Christes flesh nor drincke his bloud, bicause that Christ sayd, He that eateth my flesh, and drincketh my bloud, hath euerlasting life.
And S. Ambrose saith, that Jesus is the bread which is the meat of saints and that he that taketh this bread, dyeth not a sinners death. For this bread is the remission of sins. 1And in other book to him entitled, he writeth thus. This bread of life which came down from heaven, doth minister everlasting life, and who soever eateth this bread, shall not dye for ever, and is the body of Christ. And yet in an other book set forth in his name, he saith on this wise: He that did eat Man dyed, but he that eateth this body, shall have remission of his sins, and shall not dye for ever. 2And again he saith: As often as thou drinkest thou hast remission of thy sins.
And S. Ambrose sayth, that Iesus is the bread which is the meat of sainctes and that he that taketh this bread, dyeth not a sinners death. For this bread is the remission of sinnes. 1And in other booke to him intituled, he writeth thus. This bread of life which came downe from heauen, doth minister euerlasting life, and who soeuer eateth this bread, shall not dye for euer, and is the body of Christ. And yet in an other booke set forth in his name, he sayth on this wise: He that did eate Manne dyed, but he that eateth this body, shall haue remission of his sinnes, and shall not dye for euer. 2And agayne he sayth: As often as thou drinckest thou hast remission of thy sinnes.
And this your doctrine hath a very euill smacke, that spirite and life should fall vppon naughty men, although for theyr malice it tary not. For by this doctrine you ioyne togither in one man, Christ and Beliall, the spirite of God and the spirite of the diuell, lyfe and death, and all at one tyme:1 which doctrine I will not name what it is, for all faythfull men know the name right well and detest the same.2 And what ignoraunce can be shewed more in him that accoumpteth himselfe learned, then to gather of Christes wordes (where her sayth, his wordes be spirit and life) that spirit and lyfe should be in euill men because they heare his wordes.3 For the wordes which you recyte by and by of S. Augustin, shew how vayne your argument is,4 when he sayth, The wordes be spirite and life, but not to thee, that doest carnally vnderstand them. What estimation of learning or of truth would you haue men to conceaue of you, that bring such vnlearned argumentes wherof the inuadilitie appeareth within six lynes after? Which must nedes declare in you either, much vntruth and vnsincere proceding, or much ignoraunce, or at the least all exceding forgetfulnes, to say anythyng, reproued agayn within six lynes after. And if the promises of God (as you say) be not disapoynted by our infidelitie, then if euyll men eate the very body of Christ and drink his bloud, they must nedes dwell in Christ, and haue Christ dwelling in them, and by him haue euerlasting lyfe: bycause of these promises of Christ, Qui manducat ⟨p. 216⟩meam carnem, & bibit meum sanguinem, in memanet et ego in eo. Et quimanducat meam carnem & bibit meum sanguinem, habet vitam aeternam, 5He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my bloud, hath euerlasting lyfe. And he that eateth my flesh and drincketh my bloud, dwelleth in me and I in him. And yet the third promise. Qui manducat me, & ipse viues propter me, 6He that eateth me, he shall also lyue by me. These be .iij. promises of God, which if they can not be disapoynted by our infidilitie, then if euyll men eat the very body of Christ and drinke his bloud (as you say they doe in the sacrament) then must it nedes follow, that they shall haue euerlasting life, and that they dwell in Christ and Christ in them, bicause our infidilitie (say you) can not disappoynt Goddes promises.