pp. 3941,982 passagespart 31 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
These sentences of S. Ambrose be so plain in this matter, that there needeth no more, but only the rehearsal of them.
These sentences of S. Ambrose be so playne in this matter, that there nedeth no more, but onely the rehersall of them.
But S. Augustine in many places plainly discussing this matter, saith: He that agreeth not with Christ, doth neither eat his body, nor drink his blood, 1although to the condemnation of his presumption, he receive every day the sacrament of so high a matter.
But S. Augustine in many places playnly discussing this matter, sayth: He that agreeth not with Christ, doth neither eate his body, nor drinke his bloud, 1although to the condemnation of his presumption, he receaue euery day the sacramēt of so hygh a matter.
And moreover S. Augustine most plainly resolveth this matter in his ⟨p. 220⟩book De civitate Dei, 1disputing agaynst two kinds of heretics: Whereof the one said, that as many as were Christened, and received the sacrament of Christs body and blood, should be saved, how so ever they lived or believed, because that Christ said: This is the bread that came from heaven, that who so ever shall eat thereof, shall not dye. I am the bread of life, which came from heaven, who so ever shall eat of this bread, shall live for ever.
And moreouer S. Augustine most playnly resolueth this matter in his ⟨p. 220⟩booke De ciuitate Dei, 1disputing agaynst two kindes of heretikes: Wherof the one sayd, that as many as were Christned, and receaued the sacramēt of Christes body and bloud, should be saued, how so euer they liued or beleeued, bycause that Christ sayd: This is the bread that came from heauen, that who so euer shall eate therof, shall not dye. I am the bread of lyfe, which came from heauen, who so euer shall eate of this bread, shall liue for euer.
Therefore (said these heretics) all such men must needs be delivered from eternal death, and at length be brought to eternal life. The other said, that heretics and schismatics might eat the sacrament of Christs body, but not his very body, because they be no members of his body.
Therfore (sayd these heretikes) all such men must nedes be deliuered from eternall death, and at length be brought to eternall life. The other sayd, that heretikes and scismatikes myght eate the sacrament of Christes body, but not his very body, bycause they be no members of his body.
And therefore they promised not everlasting life to all that received Christs baptism and the sacrament of his body, but to all such as professed a true faith, although they lived never so ungodly. For such (said they) do eat the body of Christ, not only in a sacrament, but also in deed, because they be members of Christs body.
And therfore they promised not euerlasting life to all that receaued Christes baptisme and the sacrament of his body, but to all such as professed a true fayth, although they liued neuer so vngodly. For such (sayd they) do eate the body of Christ, not onely in a sacrament, but also in deede, bycause they be members of Christes body.
But S. Augustine answering to both these heresies, saith: That neither heretics, nor such as profess a true faith in their mouths, and in their living show the contrary, have either a true faith (which worketh by charity, and doth none evil) or are to be counted among the members of Christ. For they can not be both members of Christ and members of the devil. Therefore (saith he) it may not be said, that any of them eat the body of Christ. For when Christ saith, he that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me, and I in him: He showeth what it is (not sacramentally, but indeed) to eat his body and drink his blood: which is, when a man dwelleth so in Christ, that Christ dwelleth in him. For Christ spake those words as if he should say, He that dwelleth not in me, and in whom I dwell not let him not say or think, that he eateth my body, or drinketh my blood.
But S. Augustine answering to both these heresies, sayth: That neither heretikes, nor such as professe a true fayth in theyr mouthes, and in theyr liuing shew the contrary, haue eyther a true fayth (which worketh by charitie, and doth none euil) or are to be counted among the members of Christ. For they can not be both members of Christ and members of the deuill. Therfore (sayth he) it may not be sayd, that any of them eate the body of Christ. For when Christ sayth, he that eateth my flesh and drincketh my bloud, dwelleth in me, and I in him: He sheweth what it is (not sacramentally, but indeed) to eate his body and drincke his bloud: which is, when a man dwelleth so in Christ, that Christ dwelleth in him. For Christ spake those wordes as if he should say, He that dwelleth not in me, and in whom I dwell not let him not say or thincke, that he eateth my body, or drincketh my bloud.
These be the plain words of S. Augustine, that such as live ungodly, although they may seem to eat Christs body (because they eat the sacrament of his body) yet in deed they neither be members of his body, nor do eat his body.
These be the playne wordes of S. Augustine, that such as liue vngodly, although they may seme to eate Christes body (bicause they eate the sacrament of his body) yet in deed they neyther be members of his body, nor do eate his body.
Also upon the gospel of S. John he saith, that he that doth not eat his flesh and drink his blood, hath not in him everlasting life. And he that eateth his flesh and drinketh his blood,1 hath everlasting life. But it is not so in those meats, which we take to sustain our bodies. For although without them we cannot live, yet it is not necessary, that who so ever receiveth them, shall live, for they may dye by age, sickness or other chances.
Also vpon the gospell of S. Iohn he sayth, that he that doth not eate his flesh and drincke his bloud, hath not in him euerlasting lyfe. And he that eateth his flesh and drincketh his bloud,1 hath euerlasting lyfe. But it is not so in those meates, which we take to sustayne our bodyes. For although without them we cannot liue, yet it is not necessary, that who so euer receaueth them, shall liue, for they may dye by age, sicknes or other chaunces.
But in this meat and drink of the body and blood of our Lord, it is otherwise. For both they that eat and drink them not, have not everlasting life: And contrariwise who so ever eat and drink them, have everlasting life.
But in this meat and drincke of the body and bloud of our Lord, it is otherwise. For both they that eate and drincke them not, haue not euerlasting lyfe: And contrariwyse who so euer eate and drincke them, haue euerlasting life.
Note and ponder well these words of S. Augustine, that the bread and wine and other meats & drinks (which nourish the body) a man may eat, and nevertheless dye: but the very body and blood of Christ no man eateth, but that hath everlasting life. So that wicked men can not eat nor drink them, for then they must needs have by them everlasting life.
Note and ponder well these wordes of S. Augustine, that the bread and wine and other meates & drinckes (which nourish the body) a man may eate, and neuerthelesse dye: but the very body and bloud of Christ no man eateth, but that hath euerlasting life. So that wicked men can not eate nor drincke them, for then they must nedes haue by them euerlasting life.
And in the same place S. Augustine saith further. The sacrament of the unity of Christs body & blood is taken in the Lords table, of some men to life: & of some men to death, but the thing it self (whereof it is a sacrament) is taken of all men to life, & of no man to death. And more over he saith: This is to eat that meat ⟨p. 221⟩and drink that drink, to dwell in Christ, and to have Christ dwelling in him. And for that cause he that dwelleth not in Christ, & in whom Christ dwelleth not, without doubt he eateth not spiritually his flesh nor drinketh his blood, although carnally and visibly with his teeth, he byte the Sacrament of his body and blood.
And in the same place S. Augustine sayth further. The sacramēt of the vnitie of Christes body & bloud is takē in the Lordes table, of some men to lyfe: & of some mē to death, but the thing it selfe (wherof it is a sacramēt) is takē of all men to lyfe, & of no man to death. And more ouer he sayth: This is to eate that meate ⟨p. 221⟩and drincke that drincke, to dwell in Christ, and to haue Christ dwelling in him. And for that cause he that dwelleth not in Christ, & in whome Christ dwelleth not, without doubt he eateth not spiritually his flesh nor drincketh his bloud, although carnally and visibly with his teeth, he byte the Sacrament of his body and bloud.
Thus writeth S. Augustine in the xxvj. homely of S. John. And in the next homely following, he saith thus.1 This day our sermon is of the body of the Lord, which he said he would give to eat for eternal life. And he declared the manner of his gift and distribution, how he would give his flesh to eat, saying: He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me and I in him. This therefore is a token or knowledge, that a man hath eaten and drunken, that is to say, if he dwell in Christ, and have Christ dwelling in him. If he cleave so to Christ, that he is not severed from him. This therefore Christ taught and admonished by these mystical or figurative words, that we should be in his body under him our head among his members, eating his flesh, nor forsaking his unity.
Thus writeth S. Augustine in the xxvj. homely of S. Iohn. And in the next homely following, he sayth thus.1 This day our sermon is of the body of the Lord, which he sayd he would geue to eat for eternall life. And he declared the maner of his gift and distribution, how he would geue his flesh to eate, saying: He that eateth my flesh and drincketh my bloud, dwelleth in me and I in him. This therfore is a token or knowledge, that a man hath eaten and drunken, that is to say, if he dwell in Christ, and haue Christ dwelling in him. If he cleaue so to Christ, that he is not seuered from him. This therfore Christ taught and admonished by these misticall or figuratiue wordes, that we should be in his body vnder him our head among his members, eating his flesh, nor forsaking his vnitie.
And in his book De doctrina Christiana. S. Augustine saith,1 (as before is at length declared) that to eat Christs flesh, and to drink his blood, is a figurative speech signifying the participation of his passion, and the delectable remembrance to our benefit and profit, that his flesh was crucified and wounded for us.
And in his booke De doctrina Christiana. S. Augustine sayth,1 (as before is at length declared) that to eate Christes flesh, and to drincke his bloud, is a figuratiue speach signifying the participation of his passion, and the delectable remembraunce to our benefite and profite, that his flesh was crucified and wounded for vs.
And in an other sermon also De verbis Apostoli he expoundeth what is the eating of Christs body and the drinking of his blood,1 saying, The eating is to be refreshed, and the drinking what is but to live? Eat life, drink life: And that shall be, when that which is taken visibly in the sacrament, is in very deed eaten spiritually and drunken spiritually.
And in an other sermon also De verbis Apostoli he expoundeth what is the eating of Christes body and the drincking of his bloud,1 saying, The eating is to be refreshed, and the drincking what is but to liue? Eate life, drincke life: And that shall be, when that which is taken visibly in the sacrament, is in very deed eaten spiritually and dronken spiritually.
By all these sentences of S. Augustine it is evident and manifest, that all men, good and evil, may with their mouths visibly and sensibly eat the sacrament of Christs body and blood, but the very body & blood them selves be not eaten but spiritually, & that of the spiritual members of Christ, which dwell in Christ, & have Christ dwelling in them, by whom they be refreshed and have everlasting life.
By all these sentences of S. Augustine it is euident and manifest, that all men, good and euill, may with theyr mouthes visibly and sensibly eate the sacrament of Christes body and bloud, but the very body & bloud them selues be not eaten but spiritually, & that of the spiritual members of Christ, which dwell in Christ, & haue Christ dwelling in them, by whome they be refreshed and haue euerlasting lyfe.
And therefore saith S. Augustine,1 that when the other Apostles did eat bread that was the Lord, yet Judas did eat but the bread of the Lord, and not the bread that was the Lord. So that the other Apostles with the sacramental bread did eat also Christ him self, whom Judas did not eat. And a great number of places moe hath S. Augustine for this purpose, which for eschewing of tediousness, I let pas for this time, and will speak some thing of S. Cyril. ¶ Cyril upon S. John in his Gospel saith, that those which eat Manna, dyed,2 because they received thereby no strength to live ever: (for it gave no life, but only put away bodily hunger) but they that receive the bread of life, shall be made immortal, and shall eschew all the evils that pertain to death, living with Christ for ever. And in an other place he saith 3For as much as the flesh of Christ doth naturally give life, therefore it maketh them to live that be partakers of it. For it putteth death away from them, & utterly driveth destruction out of them.
And therfore sayth S. Augustine,1 that when the other Apostles did eate bread that was the Lord, yet Iudas did eate but the bread of the Lord, and not the bread that was the Lord. So that the other Apostles with the sacramentall bread did eate also Christ him selfe, whome Iudas did not eate. And a great number of places moe hath S. Augustine for this purpose, which for eschewing of tediousnes, I let pas for this tyme, and will speake some thing of S. Cirill. ¶ Cyrill vpon S. Iohn in his Gospell sayth, that those which eate Manna, dyed,2 bycause they receaued therby no strength to liue euer: (for it gaue no lyfe, but onely put away bodily hunger) but they that receaue the bread of life, shall be made immortall, and shall eschewe all the euils that pertayne to death, liuing with Christ for euer. And in an other place he sayth• 3For as much as the flesh of Christ doth naturally geue life, therfore it maketh them to liue that be partakers of it. For it putteth death away from them, & vtterly driueth destructiō out of them.
And he concludeth the matter shortly in an other place in few words,1 saying, that when we eat the flesh of our saviour, than have we life in us. For if things that were corrupt, were restored by only touching of his clothes, how can it be, that we shall not live that eat his flesh? And further he saith, that as ⟨p. 222⟩two waxes that be molten together, do run every part into other:2 so he that receiveth Christs flesh and blood, must needs be joined so with him, that Christ must be in him, and he in Christ.
And he concludeth the matter shortly in an other place in fewe wordes,1 saying, that when we eate the flesh of our sauiour, than haue we life in vs. For if thinges that were corrupt, were restored by onely touching of his clothes, how can it be, that we shall not liue that eate his flesh? And further he sayth, that as ⟨p. 222⟩two waxes that be molten together, do run euery part into other:2 so he that receaueth Christes flesh and bloud, must nedes be ioyned so with him, that Christ must be in him, and he in Christ.
Here S. Cyril declareth the dignity of Christs flesh, being inseparably annexed unto his divinity, saying, that it is of such force and power, that it giveth everlasting life. And what soever occasion of death it findeth, or let of eternal life, it putteth out and driveth clean away all the same, from them that eat that meat and receive that medicine. Other medicines or plasters sometime heal, and sometime heal not, but this medicine is of that effect and strength, that it eateth away all rotten and dead flesh and perfectly healeth all wounds and sores that it is laid unto.
Here S. Cyrill declareth the dignitie of Christes flesh, being inseparably annexed vnto his diuinitie, saying, that it is of such force and power, that it geueth euerlasting life. And what soeuer occasion of death it findeth, or let of eternall life, it putteth out and driueth cleane away all the same, from them that eate that meate and receaue that medicine. Other medicins or playsters sometyme heale, and sometyme heale not, but this medicine is of that effect and strength, that it eateth away all rotten and dead flesh and perfectly healeth all woundes and sores that it is layd vnto.
This is the dignity and excellency of Christs flesh and blood, joined to his divinity, of the which dignity, Christs adversaries the Papists, deprive and rob him, when they affirm, that such men do eat his flesh and receive this plaster, as remain still sick and sore, and be not holpen thereby.
This is the dignitie and excellēcy of Christes flesh and bloud, ioyned to his diuinite, of the which dignite, Christes aduersaries the Papistes, depriue and robbe him, when they affirme, that such men do eate his flesh and receaue this playster, as remayne still sicke and sore, and be not holpen therby.
Thus hast thou heard (gentle reader) the grounds and proofs which moved me to write the matter of this iiii. book, that good men only eat Christs flesh and drink his blood. Now shalt thou here the late bishops confutation of the same.
Thus hast thou heard (gentle reader) the groundes and profes which moued me to write the mater of this iiii. booke, that good men onely eate Christes flesh and drincke his bloud. Now shalt thou here ye late byshopes confutation of the same.
And as for the Scriptures and doctors which this author allegeth to prove that only good men receive the body and blood of Christ, I grant it without contention §1speaking of spiritual manducation and with lively faith without the Sacrament. But in the visible sacrament evil men receive the same that good men do, for the substance of the sacrament is by God's ordinance all one. And if this author would use for a proof §2that in the sacrament Christs very body is not present, because evil men receive it, that shall be no argument, for the good seed when it was sown did fall in the evil ground and although Christ dwelleth not in the evil man, yet he may be received of the evil §3man to his condemnation, because he receiveth him not to glorify him as God, as S. Paule sayth (Non dijudicans corpus domini) not esteming our Lords body. And to all §4that ever this author bringeth to prove, that evil men eat not the body of Christ, may be said shortly, that spiritually they eat it not, besides the sacrament, and in the sacrament they eat it not effectually to life, but condemnation. And that is and may be called a not eating. As they be said not to hear the word of God, that here it not profitably. And because the body of Christ of it self is ordained to be eaten for life, those that unworthily eat to condemnation, although they eat in deed, may be said not to eat, because they eat unworthily, as a thing not well done, may be in speech called not done, in respect of the good effect wherefore it was chiefly ordered to be done. And by this rule, thou reader mayst discuss all that this author bringeth forth for this purpose, either out of Scriptures or doctors. For evil men eat not the body of Christ to have any fruit by it, as evil men be said not to hear gods word to have any fruit by it, and yet as they hear the word of spirit & life and nevertheless perish, so evil men eat in the visible sacrament the body of Christ and yet perish. And as I said, this answereth the Scripture §5with the particular sayings of Cyprian, Athanase, Basil, Hierome, and Ambrose.
And as for the Scriptures and doctours which this author alleadgeth to proue that only good men receaue the body and bloud of Christ, I graunt it without contention §1speaking of spirituall manducation and with liuely fayth without the Sacrament. But in the visible sacrament euell men receaue the same that good men do, for the substance of the sacrament is by godes ordinauce all one. And if this author would vse for a profe
As for S. Augustine which this author alleageth De civitate dei, the same S. Augustine §6doth plainly say there in this place alleged, how the good and evil receive the same sacrament, and addeth, but not with like profit, which words this author suppresseth, and therefore dealeth not sincerely. As for S. Augustine shall be hereafter more plainly declared. Finally, he that receiveth worthily the body & blood of Christ, hath everlasting life, dwelleth in Christ and Christ in him, he that receiveth unworthily, which can be only in the sacrament, receiveth not life, but condemnation.
As for S. Augustine which this author alleageth De ciuitate dei, the same S. Augustine §6doth playnly say there in this place alledged, how the good and euill receaue the same sacrament, and addeth, but not with like profite, which wordes this author suppresseth, and therfore dealeth not sincerely. As for S. Augustine shall be hereafter more playnly declared. Finally, he that receaueth worthely the body & bloud of Christ, hath euerlasting life, dwelleth in Christ and Christ in him, he that receaueth vnworthely, which can be onely in the sacrament, receaueth not lyfe, but condemnation.
IF you grant without contention that which I do prove, then you §1must grant absolutely and frankly without any addition, that only good men eat and drink the body and blood of Christ. For so say all the scriptures and authors plainly, which I have alleged, without your addition of spiritual manducation: and not one of them all say as you do, that in the visible Sacrament evil men receive the same that good men do.
IF you graunt without contention that which I do proue, then you §1must graunt absolutely and franckly without any addition, that onely good men eate and drincke the body and bloud of Christ. For so say all the scriptures and authors playnly, which I haue alleadged, without your addition of spirituall manducation: and not one of them all say as you do, that in the visible Sacrament euell men receaue the same that good men do.
But I make no such vain proofs as you feign in my name, that in the sacrament Christs very body is not present, because evil men receive it. But this argument were good (although I make no such.) Evil men eat and drink the sacrament, and yet they eat and drink not Christs flesh and blood: Ergo his flesh and blood be not really and corporally in the sacrament.
But I make no such vayne proofes as you fayne in my name, that in the sacrament Christes very body is not present, bycause euil men receaue it. But this argument were good (although I make no such.) Euell men eate and drincke the sacrament, and yet they eate and drincke not Christes flesh and bloud: Ergo his flesh and bloud be not really and corporally in the sacrament.
And when you say that Christ may be received of the evil man to his condemnation, is this the glory that you give unto Christ, that his whole presence in a man, both with flesh, blood, soul and spirit, shall make him never the better? and that Christ shall be in him, that is a member of the devil? And if an evil man have Christ in him for a time, why may he not then have him still dwelling in him? For if he may be in him a quarter of an hour, he may be also an whole hour, and so a whole day, and an whole year, and so shall God and the devil dwell together in one house. And this is the crop that groweth of your sowing, if Christ fall in evil men, as good seed falleth in evil ground.
And when you say that Christ may be receaued of the euel man to his condemnation, is this the glory that you geue vnto Christ, that his whole presence in a man, both with flesh, bloud, soule and spirite, shall make him neuer the better? and that Christ shalbe in him, that is a member of the deuell? And if an euill man haue Christ in him for a tyme, why may he not then haue him still dwelling in him? For if he may be in him a quarter of an houre, he may be also an whole houre, and so a whole day, and an whole yeare, and so shall God and the diuell dwell together in one house. And this is the croppe that groweth of your sowing, if Christ fall in euell men, as good seed falleth in euell ground.
And where you say, that all that ever I bring, to prove that evil men eat not the body of Christ, may be shortly answered, truth it is (as you said in one place of me) that all that I have brought may be shortly answered, if a man care not what he answer: as it seemeth you pas not much what you answer, so that you may lay on lode of words. For where as I have fully proved as well by authority of scripture, as by the testimony of many old writers, that although evil men eat the sacramental bread, and drink the wine (which have the names of his flesh and blood) yet they eat not Christs very flesh nor drink his blood: Your short and whole answer is this,1 that evil men may be said not to eat Christs flesh and drink his blood, because they do it not fruitfully, as they ought to do. And that may be called a not eating, as they may be said not to hear God's word, that hear it not profitably: and a thing not well done, may be in speech called not done, in the respect of the good effect. I grant such speeches be sometime used, but very rarely and when the very truth cometh in discussion, then such Paradoxes are not to be used. As if it come in question whether a house be builded, that is not well builded, then the definition of the matter must not be, that it is not builded, although the carpenters and other workmen have failed in their covenant and bargain, and not builded the house in such sort as they ought to have done. So our saviour Christ teacheth that all heard the word,2 whether the seed fell in the high way, or upon the stones, or among the thorns, or in the good ground. Wherefore when this matter cometh in discussion among the old writers, whether evil men eat Christs body or no, if the truth had been that evil men eat it, the ⟨p. 224⟩old writers would not so precisely have defined the contrary, that they eat not, but would have said they eat it, but not effectually, not fruitfully, not profitably. But now the authors which I have alleged, define plainly and absolutely, that evil men eat not Christs body, without any other addition. But after this sort that you do use, it shall be an easy matter for every man to say what liketh him, and to defend it well enough, if he may add to the scriptures and doctors words at his pleasure, and make the sense after his own fantasy.
The scriptures and Doctors which I allege, do say in plain words (as I do say) that evil men do not eat the body of Christ nor drink his blood, but only they that have life thereby.
The scriptures and Doctoures which I alleadge, do say in playne wordes (as I do say) that euell menne do not eate the body of Christ nor drincke his bloud, but onely they that haue life therby.
Now come you in with your addition and gloss, made of your own head, putting thereto this word (effectually.) If I should say that Christ was never conceived nor borne, could not I avoid all the scriptures that you can bring to the contrary, by adding this word (apparently) and defend my saying stoutly? And might not the Ualentinians, Marcionists and other that said that Christ dyed not for us, defend their error with addition (as they did,) of this word (putative) to all the scriptures that were brought against them? And wat heresy can be reproved, if the heretics may have the liberty that you do use, to add of their own heads to the words of scripture?1 contrary unto God's word directly, who commandeth us to add nothing to his word, nor to take any thing away.
Now come you in with your addition and glose, made of your owne head, putting therto this word (effectually.) Yf I should say that Christ was neuer conceaued nor borne, could not I auoyd all the scriptures that you can bring to the contrary, by adding this word (apparantly) and defend my saying stoutly? And might not the Ualentinians, Marcianistes and other that sayd that Christ dyed not for vs, defend their errour with addition (as they did,) of this word (putatiue) to all the scriptures that were brought agaynst them? And wat herisie can be reproued, if the heretikes may haue ye liberty that you do vse, to adde of their owne heades to the wordes of scripture?1 contrary vnto Godes word directly, who cō maundeth vs to adde nothing to his word, nor to take any thing away.
And yet more over, the authorities which I have brought to approve my doctrine, do clearly cast away your addition, adding the cause why evil men can not eat Christs flesh nor drink his blood. And you have taught almost in the beginning of your book, that Christs body is but a spiritual body, and after a spiritual manner eaten by faith. And now you have confessed, that who so fedeth upon Christ spiritually, must needs be a good man. How can you than defend now, that evil men eat the body of Christ? except you will now deny that which you granted in the beginning (and now have forgotten it) that Christs body cannot be eaten but after a spiritual manner by faith? Wherein it is marvel, that you having so good a memory, should forget the common proverb, Mendacem memorem esse oportet.
And yet more ouer, the authorities which I haue brought to approue my doctrine, do clerely cast away your addition, adding the cause why euell men can not eate Christes flesh nor drincke his bloud. And you haue taught almost in the beginning of your booke, that Christes body is but a spirituall body, and after a spirituall manner eaten by fayth. And now you haue confessed, that who so fedeth vpon Christ spiritually, must nedes be a good man. How can you than defend now, that euell men eat the body of Christ? except you will now deny that which you graunted in the beginning (and now haue forgotten it) that Christes body cannot be eaten but after a spirituall maner by fayth? Wherin it is meruayle, that you hauing so good a memory, should forgette the common prouerbe, Mendacem memorem esse oportet.
And it had ben more convenient for you to have answered fully to Cyprian, Athanasius, Basil, Hierom and Ambrose, then when you cannot answer, to wipe your hands of them with this slender answer, saying that you have answered. And whether you have or no, I refer to the judgement of the reader.
And it had ben more conuenient for you to haue answered fully to Cyprian, Athanasius, Basyll, Hierom and Ambrose, then when you cannot answer, to wipe your handes of them with this slender answer, saying that you haue answered. And whether you haue or no, I refer to the iudgement of the reader.
1And as concerning S. Augustine De civitate Dei, he sayth, that evil men receive the sacrament of Christs body, although it availeth them not. But yet he saith in plain words, that we ought not to say, that any man eateth the body of Christ that is not in the body. And if the reader ever saw any mere cavillation in all his life time, let him read the chapter of S. Augustine and compare it to your answer, and I dare say he never saw the like.
1And as concerning S. Augustine De ciuitate Dei, he sayth, that euell men receaue the sacrament of Christes body, although it auayleth them not. But yet he sayth in playne wordes, that we ought not to say, that any man eateth the body of Christ that is not in the body. And if the reader euer saw any meare cauilation in all his lyfe tyme, let him read the chapter of S. Augustine and compare it to your answer, and I dare say he neuer sawe the like.
And as for the other places of S. Augustine by me alleged, with Origen and Cyril, for the more ease you pass them over with silence, and dare eat no such meat it is so hard for you to digest. And thus have you ⟨p. 225⟩with post hast run over all my scriptures and doctors, as it were playing at the post, with still passing and giving over every game. And yet shall you never be able for your part to bring any scripture that serveth for your purpose, except you may be suffered to add thereto such words as you please. Than come you to my questions wherein I write thus.
And as for the other places of S. Augustine by me alleadged, with Origen and Cirill, for the more ease you passe them ouer with silence, and dare eate no such meate it is so hard for you to digest. And thus haue you ⟨p. 225⟩with post hast runne ouer all my scriptures and doctours, as it were playing at the post, with still passing and geuing ouer euery game. And yet shal you neuer be able for your part to bring any scripture that serueth for your purpose, except you may be suffered to adde therto such wordes as you please. Than come you to my questions wherin I write thus.
And now for corroboration of Cyril's saying,1 I would thus reason with the Papists, and demand of them: When an unrepentant sinner receiveth the sacrament, whether he have Christs body within him or no?
And now for corroboration of Cyrils saying,1 I would thus reason with the Papistes, and demaund of them: Whan an vnrepentant sinner receaueth the sacrament, whether he haue Christes body within him or no?
If they say no, than have I my purpose, that evil men although they receive the sacrament of Christs body, yet receive they not his very body. If they say yea, Than I would ask them further, Whether they have Christs spirit within them or no?
If they say no, than haue I my purpose, that euell men although they receaue the sacrament of Christes body, yet receaue they not his very body. If they say yea, Than I would aske them further, Whether they haue Christes spirite within them or no?
If they say nay, than do they separate Christs body from his spirit, and his humanity from his divinity, and be condemned by the Scripture as very Antichrists, that divide Christ.
If they say nay, than do they separate Christes body from his spirite, and his humanitie from his diuinitie, and be condemned by the Scripture as very Antichristes, that diuide Christ.
And if they say yea, that a wicked man hath Christs spirit in him, then the scripture also condemneth them,1 saying: that as he which hath not the spirit of Christ, is none of his, so he that hath Christ in him, liveth because he is justified: And if his spirit that raised Jesus from death, dwell in you, he that raised Jesus from death, shall give life to your mortal bodies, for his spirits sake, which dwelleth in you.
And if they say yea, that a wicked man hath Christes spirit in him, then the scripture also condemneth them,1 saying: that as he which hath not the spirite of Christ, is none of his, so he that hath Christ in him, lyueth bycause he is iustified: And if his spirite that raysed Iesus from death, dwell in you, he that raysed Iesus from death, shall geue life to your mortall bodies, for his spirites sake, which dwelleth in you.
Thus on every side the scripture condemneth the adversaries of gods word.
Thus on euery side the scripture condemneth the aduersaries of gods word.
And this wickedness of the Papists is to be wondered at, that they affirm Christs flesh, blood, soul, holy spirit, and his deity to be in a man, that is subject to sin and a lim of the devil, They be wonderful jugglers and conjurers, that with certain words can make God and the devil to dwell together in one man, and make him both the temple of God, and the temple of the Devil. It appeareth that they be so blind that they cannot see the light from darkness: Belial from Christ, nor the table of the Lord from the table of devils. Thus is confuted this third intolerable error & heresy of the Papists, That they which be the limbs of the devil, do eat the very body of Christ, and drink his blood, manifestly and directly contrary to the words of Christ him self, who saith: Who soever eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, hath everlasting life.
And this wickednes of the Papistes is to be wondred at, that they affirme Christes flesh, bloud, soule, holy spirite, and his deitie to be in a man, that is subiect to sinne and a lim of the deuill, They be wonderful iuglers and coniurers, that with certayne wordes can make God and the diuell to dwell together in one man, and make him both the temple of God, and the temple of the Deuill. It appeareth that they be so blind that they cānot see the light from darknes: Beliall from Christ, nor the table of the Lord from the table of diuels. Thus is cōfuted this third intolerable error & heresie of the Papists, That they which be the limmes of the dyuell, do eate the very body of Christ, and drinke his bloud, manifestly and directly contrary to the wordes of Christ him selfe, who sayth: Who soeuer eateth my flesh and drincketh my bloud, hath euerlasting lyfe.