pp. 3941,982 passagespart 46 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1And where you speak of the soberness and devotion of the school authors (whom before you noted for boasters) what soberness and devotion was in them (being all in manner monks and fryers) they that be exercised in them do know, whereof you be none. For the devotion that they had, was to their God that created them (which was their Pope) by contention, sophistication, and all subtle means they could devise by their wit or learning, to confirm and establish whatsoever oracle came out of their Gods mouth. They set up their Antichrist directly against Christ, and yet under pretence of Christ, made him his vicar general, giving him power in heaven, earth and in hell. And is not then the doctrine of Transubstantiation, and of the real and sensual presence of Christ in the sacrament, to be believed (trow you) seeing that it came out of such a gods mouth, & was set abroad by so many of his Angels?
1And where you speake of the sobernesse and deuotion of the schoole authors (whom before you noted for boasters) what sobernesse and deuotion was in them (being all in manner monkes and fryers) they that be exercised in them do know, wherof you be none. For the deuotion that they had, was to their God that created them (which was their Pope) by contention, sophistication, and all subtle meanes they could deuise by their witte or learning, to confirme and establish whatsoeuer oracle came out of theyr Gods mouth. They set vp their Antichrist directly agaynst Christ, and yet vnder pretence of Christ, made him his vicar generall, giuing him power in heauen, earth and in hell. And is not then the doctrine of Transubstantiation, and of the reall and sensuall presence of Christ in the sacrament, to be beleued (trow you) seing that it came out of such a gods mouth, & was set abroad by so many of his Aungels?
And is not this a simple and plain doctrine (I pray you) that visible forms and substances be transubstantiated,1 and yet accidents remain? A plain doctrine (be you assured) which you confess your self, that the simple and plain people understand not, nor your self, with the help of all the Papists is not able to defend it, where the true doctrine of the first catholic christian faith is most plain, clear and comfortable, without any difficulty, scruple or doubt, that is to say, that our Saviour Christ, although he be sitting in heaven in equality with his father, is our life, strength• food, and sustenance, who by his death delivered us from death, and daily nourisheth and increaseth us to eternal life. And in token hereof he hath prepared bread to be eaten and wine to be drunken of us in his holy supper to put us in remembrance of his said death, and of the celestial feeding, nourishing, increasing, and of all the benefits, which we have thereby, which benefits through faith and the holy ghost are exhibited and given unto all that worthily receive the said holy supper. This the husbandman at his plough, the weaver at his loom, and the wife at her rock can remember and give thanks unto God for the same. This is the very doctrine of the Gospel, with the consent wholly of all the old ecclesiastical doctors ⟨p. 352⟩howsoever the Papists for their pastime put visors upon the said doctors, and disguise them in other coats, making a play and mocking of them. Now followeth the second absurdity.
And is not this a simple and playne doctrine (I pray you) that visible formes and substances be transubstantiated,1 and yet accidents remayn? A playne doctrine (be you assured) which you confesse your selfe, that the simple and playne people vnderstand not, nor your selfe, with the helpe of all the Papistes is not able to defend it, where the true doctrine of the first catholick christian fayth is most playne, cleare and comfortable, without any difficulty, scruple or doubt, that is to say, that our Sauiour Christ, although he be sitting in heauē in equality with his father, is our life, strēgth• food, and sustenaunce, who by his death deliuered vs from death, and daily nourisheth and increaseth vs to eternall life. And in tokē hereof he hath prepared bread to be eaten and wine to be drunken of vs in his holy supper to put vs in remembrance of his sayd death, and of the celestiall feeding, nourishing, increasing, and of all the benefites, which wee haue thereby, which benefites through fayth and the holy ghost are exhibited and geuen vnto all that worthely receiue the sayd holy supper. This the husbandman at his plough, the weauer at his loume, and the wife at her rocke can remember and geue thankes vnto God for the same. This is the very doctrine of the Gospel, with the consent wholly of al ye old ecclesiastial doctors ⟨p. 352⟩howsoeuer the Papistes for their pastime put vysers vpon the sayd doctors, and disguise them in other coates, making a play and mocking of them. Now followeth the second absurdity.
Secondly, these Transubstantiators do say (contrary to all learning) that the accidents of bread and wine do hang alone in the air without any substance, wherein they may be stayed. And what can be said more foolishly?.
Secondly, these Transubstantiatours do say (contrary to all learning) that the accidentes of bread and wine doe hang alone in the ayre without any substance, wherin they may be stayed. And what can be sayd more foolishly?.
The Master of the sentences showing divers mens sayings in discussion (as they §1can) of this mystery, telleth what some say, that had rather say somewhat, then nothing, which this author rehearseth as a determination of the church, that indeed maketh no doctrine of that point so, but acknowledgeth the mystery to exceed our capacity. And as for the accidents to be staid, that is to say, to remain without their natural substance is without difficulty believed of men that have faith, considering the almighty power of §2Christ, whose divine body is there present. And shall that be accounted for an inconvenience in the mystery, that any one man saith, whose saying is not as a full determination approved? If that man should encounter with this author if he were alive, so to do, I think he would say it were more tolerable in him of a zeal to agree with the true doctrine, to utter his conceit fondly, then of a malice to dissent from the true doctrine this author so fondly to improve his saying. But if he should appose this author in learning,§3 and ask him how he will understand (Fiat lux) in creation of the world, where the light §4stayed that was then create? But I will proceed to peruse the other differences.
The Mayster of the sentences shewing diuers mens sayings in discussion (as they §1can) of this mistery, telleth what some say, that had rather say somewhat, then nothing, which this author rehearseth as a determination of the church, that indéede maketh no doctrine of that poynt so, but acknowledgeth the mistery to exéede our capacity. And as for the accidentes to be stayd, that is to say, to remayne without their naturall substaūce is without difficulty beleued of men that haue fayth, considering the almighty power of §2Christ, whose diuine body is there present. And shall that be accounted for an inconuenience in the mistery, that any one man saith, whose saying is not as a full determination approued? If that man should encounter with this author if he were aliue, so to do, I think he would say it were more tolerable in him of a zeale to agrée with the true doctrine, to vtter his conceit fondly, then of a malice to dissent from the true doctrine this author so fondly to improue his saying. But if he should appose this author in learning,
The doctrine that even now was so simple and plain is now again §1waxed so full of ambiguities and doubts, that learned men in discussing thereof, as they can, be fain to say rather some thing than nothing, and yet were they better to say nothing at all, then to say that is not true, or nothing to purpose. And if the master of the sentences saying in this point, vary from the common doctrine of the other Papists, why is not this his error rejected among other, wherein he is not commonly held? And why do your self after approve the same saying of the Master, as a thing believed without difficulty, that the accidents be stayed without their §2natural substance? And then I would know of you wherein they be stayed? seeing they be not stayed in the air, as in their substance, nor in the bread and wine, nor in the body of Christ? For either you must appoint some other stay for them or else grant (as I say) that they hang alone in the air, without any substance wherein they may be stayed. And either I understand you not in this place (you speak so diffusely) or else that thing §3which the Master spake, and your self have here affirmed, you call it a tolerable conceit fondly uttered. And where as to answer the matter of the staying of the accidents, you ask wherein the light was stayed as the creation §4of the world: this is a very easy opposall, and soon answered unto. For first God created heaven and earth and after made light, which was stayed in them as it is now, although not divided from the darkness in such sort as it was after. Now followeth the third absurdity.
THe doctrine that euen now was so simple and playne is now agayne §1waxed so full of ambiguities and doubtes, that learned men in discussing therof, as they can, be fayne to say rather some thing than nothing, and yet were they better to say nothing at all, then to say that is not true, or nothing to purpose. And if the master of the sentences saying in this poynt, vary from the cōmon doctrine of the other Papists, why is not this his errour reiected among other, wherin he is not commonly helde? And why do your selfe after approue the same saying of the Master, as a thing beleeued without difficultie, that the accidents be stayed without their §2naturall substāce? And then I would know of you wherin they be stayed? seeing they be not stayed in the ayre, as in their substance, nor in the bread and wine, nor in the body of Christ? For eyther you must appoynt some other stay for them or els graunt (as I say) that they hange alone in the ayre, without any substance wherin they may be stayed. And eyther I vnderstand you not in this place (you speake so diffusely) or els that thing
Thirdly, that the substance of Christs body is there really, corporally, and naturally present, without any accidents of the same. And so the Papists make accidents to be without substances, and substances to be without accidents.
Thirdly, that the substance of Christes body is there really, corporally, and naturally present, without any accidents of the same. And so the Papistes make accidents to be without substances, and substances to be without accidents.
How Christs body is in circumstance present, no man can define, but that it is truly present, and therefore really present, corporally also, and naturally,1 with relation to the truth of the body present, and not to the manner of presence which is spiritual, §1exceeding our capacity, and therefore therein without drawing away accidents or §3adding, we believe simply the trueth howsoever it liketh this author without the book to term it at his pleasure, and to speak of substance without accidents and accidents without substance, which perplexity in words can not jest out the truth of §2the catholic belief. And this is on the authors part nothing but jesting with a wrong §4surmise and supposal, as though men had invented and imagined that which by force and truth of the scripture all good men have and must believe, that is to say, the true presence of the substance of the body and blood of Christ in the Sacrament, according to the words of Christ: This is my body, which exclude the substance of bread, declaring the substance of the body of Christ to be acknowledged and professed in the Sacrament by the true faith of a christen man. Compare with this what this author writeth in his ninth difference in the 47. leaf of his book, and so consider the truth of this report, §5and how this author agreeth with himself.
How Christes body is in circumstance present, no man can define, but that it is truly present, and therfore really present, corporally also, and naturally,1 with relation to the truth of the body present, and not to the maner of presence which is spirituall, §1exceeding our capacitye, and therefore therein without drawing away accidentes or §3adding, wee beleeue simplye the trueth howesoeuer it liketh this author without the booke to terme it at his pleasure, and to speake of substaunce without accidentes and accidents without substance, which perplexity in wordes can not iest out the truth of
I Suspect not the judgement of the indifferent reader so much, but that he can perceive how undirectly you answer to this third absurdity, and be loth as it seemeth to answer any thing at all.
I Suspect not the iudgement of the indifferent reader so much, but that he can perceaue how vndirectly you answere to this third absurdity, and be loth as it seemeth to answere any thing at all.
But it is no little confirmation of the catholic faith, to see you Papists vary so much among your selves, and you alone to devise so many things contrary to all the rest, and yet you be uncertain your self what you may say. They say also with one accord (saving only Smith & you) that in the sacrament be not the qualities and quantities of Christs body. (For he is not there visible and sensible with his voice to be heard, his colours to be seen, his softness to be felt, his quantities to be extended, and to be local in place, with his other accidents) so that they take away his accidents from the sacrament. Smith saith that he is there (not naturally, as you say, but against nature) with all his qualities and accidents.1 You dare neither add them, nor draw them away, being uncertain whether they be there or no, and being also uncertain whether in the §2sacrament he have distinction of members or no. But telling the truth is but jesting and railing to you, which for lack of answer be glad to shift of the truth as a matter of jesting.
But it is no little confirmation of the catholike fayth, to see you Papists vary so much among your selues, and you alone to diuise so many thinges contrary to all the rest, and yet you be vncertayne your selfe what you may say. They say also with one accord (sauing onely Smith & you) that in the sacrament be not the qualities and quantities of Christes body. (For he is not there visible and sensible with his voyce to be heard, his colours to be seene, his softnes to be felt, his quantities to be extended, and to be locall in place, with his other accidents) so that they take away his accidents from the sacrament. Smith sayth that he is there (not naturally, as you say, but against nature) with all his qualities and accidents.1 You dare neither adde them, nor drawe them away, being vncertayue whether they be there or no, and being also vncertayne whether in the §2sacrament he haue distinction of members or no. But telling the truth is but iesting and rayling to you, which for lacke of answer be glad to shift of the truth as a matter of iesting.
And it is not my terming without the book and at my pleasure, to §3speak of substances without accidents, and accidents without substances, (For I speak none otherwise therein, then as it hath pleased the Papists before to term the same in all their books of that matter) but I termed this matter so upon the papistical books, as they at their pleasure devised or dreamed without all manner of books written before their time. And the force of scripture constraineth no man to the belief §5of Transubstantiation, although the body of Christ were really, corporally, and carnally present, who by his omnipotent power can be present as well with the substances, as with the accidents of bread and wine, as fully is declared before.
And it is not my terming without the booke and at my pleasure, to §3speake of substances without accidents, and accidents without substances, (For I speake none otherwise therein, then as it hath pleased the Papistes before to terme the same in all their bookes of that matter) but I termed this matter so vppon the papisticall bookes, as they at their pleasure deuised or dreamed without all manner of bookes written before their tyme. And the force of scripture constrayneth no man to the beleefe §5of Transubstantiation, although the body of Christ were really, corporally, and carnally present, who by his omnipotent power can be present as well with the substances, as with the accidents of bread and wine, as fully is declared before.
And where you allege the disagreeing of me with my self, if you ⟨p. 354⟩would have taken the pain to read some of the school authors, you should have learned, that there is no disagreement in my sayings at all. For they say, that the body of Christ that is in the sacrament hath his proper forms and quantities (as I said in the 47. leaf) But yet those accidents (say they) be in heaven, and not in the sacrament, as I say in this place, not varying one mite from mine other saying. But ignorance in you, thinketh a difference where none is at all.
And where you alleadge the disagreing of me with my selfe, if you ⟨p. 354⟩would haue taken the payne to reade some of ye schole authors, you should haue learned, that there is no disagrement in my sayings at all. For they say, that the body of Christ that is in the sacrament hath his proper formes and quantities (as I sayd in the 47. leafe) But yet those accidents (say they) be in heauen, and not in the sacrament, as I say in this place, not varying one mite from myne other saying. But ignorance in you, thinketh a difference where none is at all.
Now followeth the fourth absurdity.
Fourthly, they say, that the place where the accidents of bread and wine be, hath no substance there to fill that place, and so must they needs grant vacuum, which nature utterly abhorreth.
Fourthly, they say, that the place where the accidents of bread and wine be, hath no substance there to fill that place, and so must they needes graunt vacuum, which nature vtterly abhorreth.
This author goeth about to find so many absurdities, that he speaketh he wotteth not what, and where he seeth and feeleth quantity, accounteth the place void for want of substance, as though in consideration of common natural things severally as they be in nature, it were the substance that filled the place and not rather quantity, although in the natural order of things there is no quantity without substance, and is in this Sacrament only by miracle. There wanted a substance in consideration of this absurdity, and was such a vacuum, as nature plainly endureth.
This author goeth about to finde so many absurdities, that he speaketh he wotteth not what, and where he seeth and feeleth quantity, accompteth the place voyd for want of substance, as though in consideration of common naturall thinges seuerally as they be in nature, it were the substance that filled the place and not rather quantity, although in the naturall order of thinges there is no quantity without substance, and is in this Sacrament onely by miracle. There wanted a substance in consideration of this absurdity, and was such a vacuum, as nature playnly endureth.
A Lithe authors that write what vacuum is, account a place that is not filled with a substance which hath quantity in it, to be void and empty. So that my saying is not grounded upon ignorance; but upon the mind of all that write in that matter. Where as your saying, that quantity alone filleth place, without substance, hath no ground at all, but the Papists bare imagination. And if quantity in the sacrament be without substance by miracle, it is marvel that no ancient writer in no place of their books made any mention of such a miracle. But your self grant enough for my purpose in this place, that it is an absurdity in nature, and wrought only by miracle that quantity occupieth a place alone without substance. Which absurdity followeth not of the true and right faith, but only of your error of transubstantiation. Now to the fifth absurdity.
A Lithe authors that write what vacuum is, account a place that is not filled with a substaunce which hath quantity in it, to be void and emty. So that my saying is not grounded vpon ignoraunce; but vpon the mind of all that write in that matter. Where as your saying, that quantity alone filleth place, without substaunce, hath no ground at all, but the Papistes bare imagination. And if quantity in the sacrament be without substaunce by miracle, it is maruaile that no auncient writer in no place of their bookes made any mention of such a miracle. But your selfe graunt inough for my purpose in this place, that it is an absurdity in nature, and wrought onely by miracle that quantity occupieth a place alone without substaunce. Which absurdity followeth not of the true and right fayth, but onely of your errour of transubstantiation. Now to the fift absurdity.
Fifthly, they are not ashamed to say, that substance is made of accidents, when the bread moleth or is turned into worms, or when the wine soureth.
Fiftly, they are not ashamed to say, that substaunce is made of accidentes, when the bread mouleth or is turned into wormes, or when the wine sowreth.
True believing men are not ashamed to confess the trueth of their faith, whatsoever arguments might be brought of experience in nature to the contrary. For Christs works we know to be true by a most certain faith, what mouldeth in bread, or soureth in wine, we be not so assured, or whereon worms engender, it is not so fully agreed on among men. The learned lawyer Ulpian writeth (as I have before alleged) that wine and vinegar have in manner one substance, so as when wine soureth and is vinegar, in manner the same substance remaineth, in whom it is thought no absurdity to say by that means that the accidents only sower. And if we agree with the Philosophers that there is Materia prima, which in all things is one and altereth not, but as a new form cometh, taketh a new name, fancying that as one wave in the water thrusteth away an other, so doth one form an other. It should seem by this conclusion all alteration to be in accidents, and the corruption of accidents to be the generation of new accidents, the same Materia prima, being as it were substantia, that altereth not. And this I write that may be said as it were to make a title to this authors certainty, which is ⟨p. 355⟩not so sure as he maketh it. Amongst men have been marvellous fancies in consideration of natural things, and it is to me a very great absurdity of that secret, and therefore to our certain faith. But to come nearer to the purpose, it is wrong borne in hand, that we affirm worms to be engendered of accidents, but when the worms be engendered, we grant the worms to be, and will rather say, whereof they be we cannot tell, then to say that substance is made of accidents, and that doctrine is not annexed to the faith of transubstantiation, and such as entreat those chances and accidents do not induce that conclusion, but do reasonably avoid it. And yet by the way in moulding and souring it should me seemeth be properly said that the accidents mould, and the accidents sower, because we call mould bread, bread: sower wine, wine, and in wine as I said before, §3made vinegar, the former substance hath been in learning accounted in manner to remain, so as this author overshooteth himself, when he matcheth generation of worms with moulding and souring, which differ so far in the speculation.
True beleuing men are not ashamed to confes the trueth of theyr fayth, whatsoeuer arguments might be brought of experience in nature to the contrary. For Christes workes we know to be true by a most certayne fayth, what mouldeth in bread, or sowreth in wine, we be not so assured, or wheron worms ingēder, it is not so fully agréed on amōg men. The learned lawyer Vlpian writeth (as I haue before alleadged) that wine and vineger haue in manner one substaunce, so as when wine sowreth and is vineger, in manner the same substaunce remayneth, in whom it is thought no absurdity to say by that meanes that the accidents onely sower. And if we agrée with the Phylosophers that there is Materia prima, which in all thinges is one and altereth not, but as a newe forme commeth, taketh a new name, fansying that as one waue in the water thrusteth away an other, so doth one forme an other. It should séeme by this conclusion all alteration to be in accidents, and the corruption of accidentes to be the generation of new accidentes, the same Materia prima, being as it were substantia, that altereth not. And this I write that may be sayd as it were to make a title to this authors certainety, which is
But even as this authors wit is overturned in consideration of the true faith, so doth it appear perverted, in consideration of natural things.
But euen as this authors wit is ouerturned in consideration of the true fayth, so doth it appeare peruerted, in consideration of naturall thinges.
I know not to what purpose you have written all this fond matter, except it be, that you would the world should know how ignorant you be in §1philosophy, which have not learned so much, as to know the diversity between the vi. kinds of mornings, generation, corruption, augmentation, diminution, alteration, and moving from place to place. Whereof the iiii. last be from accidents to accidents, and the two first from substance to substance. So that all mutation is not in accidents, and the corruption of accidents to be the generation of new accidents, as you unlearnedly imagine, both of that, and of materia prima, which never was no such thing in deed, but by imagination.
I know not to what purpose you haue written all this fond matter, except it be, that you would the world should know how ignorant you be in §1philosophy, which haue not learned so much, as to know the diuersity betwene the vi. kindes of mornings, generation, corruption, augmentation, diminution, alteration, and mouing from place to place. Wherof the iiii. last be from accidents to accidents, and the two first from substance to substance. So that all mutation is not in accidents, and the corruption of accidents to be the generation of new accidents, as you vnlearnedly imagine, both of that, and of materia prima, which neuer was no such thing in deede, but by imagination.
But because you bear me in hand, that I bear the papists wrong in hand, that they affirm worms to be engendered of accidents, I shall §2rehearse their own words, that the readers may know your ignorance herein, or else how loud a lye you make willingly. Ex speciebus sacramentalibus (say they) generantur vermes, siputre fiant. Of the sacramental forms, if they be rotten, be gendered worms. But it is no point of true meaning men, now to deny that ever they said any such things, as they have taught in their schools these four or five hundred years, as their own books do plainly testify. And be these Papists to be credited, which have taught untruly so many years, and now when they be pressed with all, go clean from it, and say they never said so, but he wrong borne in hand.
But bicause you beare me in hand, that I beare the papistes wrong in hand, that they affirme wormes to be ingendred of accidents, I shall §2reherse their owne wordes, that the readers may know your ignorance herein, or els how loud a lye you make willingly. Ex speciebus sacramentalibus (say they) generantur vermes, siputre fiant. Of the sacramentall formes, if they be rotten, be gendred wormes. But it is no poynt of true meaning men, now to deny that euer they sayd any such things, as they haue taught in their scholes these foure or fiue hundred yeares, as their owne books do playnly testefy. And be these Papistes to be credited, which haue taught vntruely so many yeares, and now when they be pressed with all, goe cleane from it, and say they neuer sayd so, but he wrong borne in hand.
And because Smith denieth here the same that you do, that worms be engendered of the accidents in the sacrament, let him help you to answer this matter. And for as much as he saith that when the host reserved beginneth to mole and to putrefy,1 and should engender worms, then an other substance succeedeth it, of which such things are made, let him tell what substance that is which succeedeth, and whereof that substance is made.
And bicause Smith denieth here the same that you doe, that wormes be ingendred of the accidents in the sacrament, let him helpe you to aunswere this matter. And for as much as he sayth that when the host reserued beginneth to moule and to putrify,1 and should ingender wormes, then an other substance succeedeth it, of which such thinges are made, let him tell what substaunce that is which succedeth, and whereof that substance is made.
But to return to you again, such philosophy as you make here, learned I never in Aristotle, Plato, nor Pliny, nor I trow none such to be found in any that ever wrote. But as you delight all in singularity, and have made strange divinity, so must you invent as strange philosophy. For who ever heard the Terminus a quo is changed, or Terminus ad quem? And whatsoever seemeth to you (as commonly it seemeth to you that seemeth to ⟨p. 356⟩no man else) yet it seemeth to no man else that ever was learned, that accidents be properly changed, but that the substances or subjects be changed from accidence to accidence.
But to returne to you agayne, such philosophy as you make here, learned I neuer in Aristotle, Plato, nor Pliny, nor I trow none such to bee found in any that euer wrote. But as you delight all in singularity, and haue made strange diuinity, so must you inuēt as strange philosophy. For who euer heard the Terminus a quo is chaunged, or Terminus ad quem? And whatsoeuer semeth to you (as commonly it seemeth to you that seemeth to ⟨p. 356⟩no man els) yet it seemeth to no man els that euer was learned, that accidēts be properly changed, but that the substaunces or subiectes be chaunged from accidence to accidence.
And it is the simplest reason that ever was made, that the accidents §3mole and sower, because the substance remaineth, so as moulded bread is called bread, and sower wine is called wine. For so is cold water and hot water both, called water. And yet it is the water that is now hot now cold, and not the accidents. For neither can hot be cold nor cold be hot, nor heat go into coldness, nor coldness into heat, but the subject that receiveth them, is now hot, now cold by alteration, as iron that is now cold, is soon made hot, but coldness can never be hotness by no art nor science, forasmuch as they be contrary qualities. And likewise pureness can not moll, nor sweetness cannot be sower, but wine that is sweet may turn into sower wine, & bread that is pure may be changed into mouldy bread. But the more you strive in the matters of philosophy, the more appeareth your ignorance therein, even as it did before in the matters of our faith. And who can condemn your doctrine more clearly then your own Ulpian §4doth, as you do here allege him? that in vinegar remaineth in manner the same substance that was in the wine, whereof it must follow, that when the sacramental wine is turned into vinegar, there must be a substance remaining, which is in manner the same with the substance of the vinegar. The sixth absurdity.
And it is the simplest reason that euer was made, that the accidentes §3moule and sower, because the substaunce remayneth, so as mouled bread is called bread, and sower wine is called wine. For so is colde water and hoat water both, called water. And yet it is the water that is now hoate now colde, and not the accidentes. For neyther can hote be colde nor colde be hoat, nor heat go into coldnes, nor coldnes into heat, but the subiect that receiueth them, is now hoat, now cold by alteration, as yron that is now colde, is soone made hoat, but coldnes can neuer be hotenes by no arte nor science, forasmuch as they be contrary qualities. And likewise purenes cā not moul, nor sweetnes cannot be sower, but wine that is sweet may turn into sower wine, & bread that is pure may be chaunged into mouly bread. But the more you striue in the matters of philosophy, the more appeareth your ignoraunce therein, euen as it did before in the matters of our fayth. And who can condemne your doctrine more clearely then your owne Vlpian §4doth, as you do here alleadge him? that in vineger remayneth in manner the same substaunce that was in the wine, wherof it must folow, that when the sacramentall wine is turned into vineger, there must be a substaunce remaining, which is in manner the same with the substaunce of the vineger. The sixt absurdity.
Sixthly, that substance is nourished without substance, by accidents only, if it chance any Cat, Mouse, Dog, or other thing, to eat the Sacramental bread.
Sixtly, that substaunce is norished without substance, by accidents onely, if it chaunce any Catte, Mouse, Dogge, or other thing, to eate the Sacramentall bread.
These inconveniences and absurdities do follow of the fond papistical transubstantiation, with a number of other errors, as evil or worse then these, whereunto they be never able to answer, as many of them have confessed themselves.
These inconueniences and absurdities do follow of the fond papistical transubstantiation, with a number of other errours, as euill or worsse then these, whereunto they be neuer able to aunswere, as many of them haue confessed themselues.
And it is wonder to see, how in many of the foresaid things, they vary among themselves. Where as the other doctrine of the scripture and of the old catholic church, but not of the lately corrupted Romish church is plain and easy, as well to be understanded, as to answer to all the aforesaid questions, without any absurdity or inconvenience following thereof, so that every answer shall agree with gods word, with the old church, and also with all reason and true philosophy.
And it is wonder to see, how in many of the foresayd thinges, they vary among themselues. Where as the other doctrine of the scripture and of the old catholick church, but not of the lately corrupted Romish church is plaine and easy, as well to be vnderstanded, as to aunswere to all the aforesayd questions, without any absurdity or inconuenience folowing thereof, so that euerye aunswere shall agree with gods word, with the olde church, and also with all reason and true philosophy.
For as touching the first point, what is broken, what is eaten, what drunken and what chawen in this sacrament, it is easy to answer. The bread and wine, as S. Paul saith: The bread which we break.
For as touching the first poynt, what is broken, what is eaten, what drunkē and what chawen in this sacrament, it is easy to aunswere. The bread and wine, as S. Paule sayth: The bread which we breake.
And as concerning the second and third points, neither is the substance of bread and wine without their proper accidents, nor their accidents hang alone in the air without any substance, but according to all learning, the substance of the bread and wine reserve their own accidents and the accidents do rest in their own substances.
And as concerning the second and third poyntes, neither is the substaunce of bread and wine without their proper accidents, nor their accidentes hange alone in the ayre without any substance, but according to all learning, the substaunce of the bread and wine reserue their owne accidents and the accidents do rest in their owne substaunces.
And also as concerning the fourth point, there is no place left void after consecration (as the Papists dream) but bread and wine fulfil their place as they did before.
And also as concerning the fourth poynt, there is no place left voyd after consecration (as the Papistes dreame) but bread and wine fulfill their place as they did before.
And as touching the fifth point (whereof the worms or moulding is engendered, and whereof the vinegar cometh) the answer is easy to make (according ⟨p. 358⟩to all learning and experience) that they come according to the course of nature, of the substance of the bread and wine, to long kept, and not of the accidents alone, as the Papists do fondly fantasy.
And as touching the fift poynt (whereof the wormes or mouling is ingendred, and wherof the vineger commeth) the aunswere is easy to make (according ⟨p. 358⟩to all learning and experience) that they come according to the course of nature, of the substance of the bread and wine, to long kept, and not of the accidentes alone, as the Papistes do fondly phantasy.
And likewise the substances of bread and wine, do feed and nourish the body of them that eat the same, and not only the accidents.
And likewise the substances of bread and wine, do feed and nourish the body of them that eat the same, and not onely the accidents.
In these answers is no absurdity nor inconvenience, nothing spoken either contrary to holy scripture, or to natural reason, Philosophy, or experience, or against any old ancient author, or the primitive or catholic church, but only against the malignant and Papistical church of Rome. Where as on the other side, that cursed synagogue of Antichrist, hath defined and determined in this matter, many things contrary to Christs words, contrary to the old catholic church, and the holy martyrs and doctors of the same, and contrary to all natural reason, learning, and philosophy.
In these answeres is no absurdity nor inconuenience, nothing spoken either contrary to holy scripture, or to naturall reason, Philosophy, or experience, or agaynst any old auncient author, or the primitiue or catholicke church, but onely agaynst the malignant and Papisticall church of Rome. Where as on the other side, that cursed synagog of Antichrist, hath defyned and determined in this matter, many thinges contrary to Christes words, contrary to the old catholick church, and the holy martirs and doctors of the same, and contrary to all naturall reason, learning, and philosophy.