pp. 3941,982 passagespart 47 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And the final end of all this Antichrists doctrine is none other, but by subtlety and craft, to bring christen people from the true honouring of Christ, unto the greatest idolatry, that ever was in this world devise: as by Gods grace shall be plainly set forth hereafter.
And the final end of al this Antichristes doctrine is none other, but by subtilty and craft, to bring christen people from the true honoring of Christ, vnto the greatest idolatry, that euer was in this world deuise: as by Gods grace shal be plainly set forth hereafter.
It hath vene heard without fables of certain men that have lived and been nourished with savours only. And in gold and certain precious stones, that they give a kind of nurture to an other substance, without diminution of their substance, experience hath showed it so, and therefore the principle or maxim that this author gathereth hath no such absurdity in it, as he noteth, to say that substance is nourished without substance. But when vermin by chance happen to devour any host, as I am sure they cannot violate Christs most precious body, so what effect followeth of the rest, what needeth it to be discussed? If it nourisheth, then doth that effect remain, although the substance be not there. If every nurture must needs be of substance, then would those that discuss those chances say the substance to return, but hell gates shall not make me speak against my faith. And if I be asked the question, whether the visible matter of the sacrament nourish. I will answer, yea Ergo saith he, there is substance, I deny it. He shall now from the effect to the cause argue by physic, I shall disprove the conclusion by the §2authority of faith, who is it most meet should yield to other? And if in nature many things be in experience contrary to the general rules, why may not one singular condition be in this visible matter of the sacrament, that the only substance being changed, all other parts, properties and effects may remain? Is it an absurdity for a maid to have a child, because it is against the rules of nature? Is it an absurdity the world to be made of nothing, because the philosopher saith: Of nothing cometh nothing? The principle of nature is that whatsoever hath a beginning, hath an end, and yet it is no absurdity to believe our souls to have a beginning without end, and to be immortal. Wherefore to conclude this matter, it is a great absurdity in this author, to note that for an absurdity in our faith, which repugneth only to the principles of philosophy, or reason, when that is only to be accounted for an absurdity, that should repugn to the scripture and gods will, which is the standard to try the rule of our faith.
It hath vene heard without fables of certaine men that haue liued and bene norished with sauors onely. And in gold and certayne precious stones, that they geue a kinde of nurriture to an other substance, without diminution of their substance, experience hath shewed it so, and therefore the principle or maxime that this author gathereth hath no such absurdity in it, as he noteth, to say that substaunce is nourished without substance. But when vermin by chaunce happen to deuour any host, as I am sure they cannot violate Christes most precious body, so what effect foloweth of the rest, what néedeth it to be discussed? If it nourisheth, then doth that effect remaine, although the substaunce be not there. If euery nurriture must néedes bee of substaunce, then would those that discusse those chances say the substaunce to returne, but hell gates shall not make me speake agaynst my fayth. And if I be asked the question, whether the visible matter of the sacrament nourish. I will answere, yea Ergo sayth he, there is substaunce, I deny it. He shall now from the effect to the cause argue by physicke, I shall disproue the conclusion by the §2authority of faith, who is it most méet should yeld to other? And if in nature many things be in experience contrary to the generall rules, why may not one singular condition be in this visible matter of the sacrament, that the onely substaunce being chaunged, all other partes, properties and effectes may remayne? Is it an absurdity for a mayde to haue a child, because it is against the rules of nature? Is it an absurdity the world to be made of nothing, because the philosopher sayth: Of nothing commeth nothing? The principle of nature is that whatsoeuer hath a beginning, hath an end, and yet it is no absurditye to beléeue our soules to haue a beginning without end, and to be immortall. Wherefore to conclude this matter, it is a great absurdity in this author, to note that for an absurdity in our fayth, which repugneth onely to the principles of phylosophy, or reasō, when that is onely to be accounted for an absurdity, that should repugne to the scripture and gods will, which is the standerd to try the rule of our fayth.
Howsoever reason or Philosophy be offended it forceth not, so gods teaching be embraced and persuaded in faith, which needeth no such plasters and salves as this author hath devised, to make a sore where none is, and to corrupt that is whole.
Howsoeuer reason or Phylosophy be offended it forceth not, so gods teaching be embraced and persuaded in fayth, which néedeth no such plaisters and salues as this author hath deuised, to make a sore where none is, and to corrupt that is whole.
Men may here see, what feigned fables be sought out, to defend your errors and ignorance, which is how so manifest, that it appeareth you never read, or else have forgotten, the very principles, and definitions ⟨p. 358⟩of Philosophy. Of which this is one, that nutrition is a conversion of substance into substance, that is to say, of the meat into the substance of the thing that is fed. An other is thus Ex eisdem sunt & nutriuntur omnia. All thinges be nourished of things like themselves. And so I grant you, that a man made of savours, and a man made of the virtue of gold and precious stones, may be nourished by the same, because he is made of the same. And yet it may be, that some certain savour or the virtue of some precious stone, may increase or continue some humour, whereof a man may be nourished, as we read of some men or certain people that have lived no small time by the savour of apples.
MEn may here see, what fayned fables be sought out, to defend your errors and ignorance, which is how so manifest, that it appeareth you neuer read, or els haue forgotten, the very principles, and diffinitions ⟨p. 358⟩of Philosophy. Of which this is one, that nutrition is a conuertion of substance into substance, that is to say, of the meate into the substance of the thing that is fedde. An other is thus Ex eisdem sunt & nutriuntur omnia. All thinges be nourished of thinges like themselues. And so I graunt you, that a man made of sauoures, and a man made of the vertue of gold and precious stones, may be nourished by the same, bicause he is made of the same. And yet it may be, that some certayne sauor or the vertue of some precious stone, may increase or continue some humor, wherof a man may be nourished, as we read of some men or certayne people that haue liued no small time by the sauonr of apples.
But still in your book you cry faith, faith, and catholic faith, when §2you teach but your own inventions, clean contrary to the true catholic faith and express word of God. And in all your arguments here you commit the greatest vice that can be in reasoning, called Petitio principij, taking that thing which is chiefly in controversy, to be a principle to induce your conclusion: Faith, faith say you: where is no faith, but your bare feigning. I have disproved your faith by gods word, by the universal consent of all Christendom a M. years together, and you cry out still, faith faith, which is not the faith of Christ, but of Antichrist. Let christen men now judge, who should yield to other. If you had proved your doctrine by faith, founded upon Gods word, I would condescend unto you that it is no absurdity that accidents remain when the substance is gone. But gods word is clearly against you, not only in your doctrine of transubstantiation, but also in the doctrine of the real presence, of the eating and drinking, and of the sacrifices of Christs flesh and blood.
But still in your booke you crye fayth, fayth, and catholike fayth, when §2you teach but your owne inuentions, cleane contrary to the true catholike fayth and expresse worde of God. And in all your arguments here you commit the greatest vice that can be in reasoning, called Petitio principij, taking that thing which is chiefly in controuersy, to be a principle to induce your conclusion: Fayth, fayth say you: where is no fayth, but your bare faining. I haue disproued your fayth by gods word, by the vniuersall consent of all Christendome a M. yeares togither, and you crye out still, fayth fayth, which is not the fayth of Christ, but of Antichrist. Let christen men now iudge, who should yeld to other. If you had proued your doctrine by fayth, founded vpon Gods word, I would condescend vnto you that it is no absurdity that accidents remayne when the substance is gone. But gods word is clearly agaynst you, not onely in your doctrine of transubstantiation, but also in the doctrine of the reall presence, of the eating and drinking, and of the sacrifices of Christes flesh and bloud.
The best plaster and medicine that could now be devised, were to leave a part questions §1and idle talk, and meekly to submit our capacities to the true faith, and not to overwhelm our understandings with search and inquiry, whereof we shall never find an end, entering the bottomless secrecy of Gods mysteries. Let us not seek that is above our reach, but that God hath commanded us let us do. Each man impugneth an others learning with words, none controleth in others living with better deeds. Let all endeavour themselves to do that God commandeth, and the good occupation thereof shall exclude all such idleness as is cause and occasion of this vain and noisome curiosity. And now to return to this author, whiles he seeth a mate in an other mans eye, he feeleth not a beam in his own. Who recommendeth unto us specially Theodoret, whom he calleth an holy Bishop, and with him doth bring forth a piece of an Epistle of S. Chrysostom. The doctrine of which two joined with the doctrine of this author, in such sense as this author would have all understanded to be called catholic, touching the faith of the sacrament, hath such an absurdity in it, as was never hard of in religion.§2 For this author teacheth for his part that the body of Christ is only really in heaven and not indeed in the sacrament, according whereunto this author teacheth also the bread to be very bread still, which doctrine if it be true as this author will needs have it, then join unto it the doctrine of the secret Epistle of Chrysostom and Theodoret,§3 whose doctrine is that after the consecration, that is consecrate, shall be called no more bread, but the body of Christ. By these two doctrines joined together it shall appear that we must call that is consecrate, by a name that we be learned by, this author it is not, and may not by the doctrine of Theodoret call it by the name of the which this author teacheth us in deed it is. And thus: It is in deed bread quoth this author, but call it not so quoth this Theodoret: It is not in deed the body of Christ quoth this author, but yet in any wise call it so quoth Theodoret. Here is plain simulation and dissimulation ⟨p. 359⟩both together.
The best plaster and medicine that could now be deuised, were to leaue a part questions §1and idle talke, and meekly to submit our capacities to the true fayth, and not to ouerwhelme our vnderstandinges with search and inquiry, wherof we shall neuer finde an ende, entring the bottomles secresy of Gods misteries. Let vs not seeke that is aboue our reach, but that God hath commaunded vs let vs do. Each man impugneth an others learning with wordes, none controleth in others liuing with better dedes. Let all endeuour themselues to do that God commaundeth, and the good occupation therof shall exclude al such idlenes as is cause and occasion of this vayne and noysome curiosity. And now to returne to this author, whiles he seeth a mate in an other mans iye, he feeleth not a beame in his owne. Who recommendeth vnto vs specially Theodoret, whome he calleth an holy Bishop, and with him doth bring forth a pece of an Epistle of S. Chrisostome. The doctrine of which two ioyned with the doctrine of this author, in such sence as this author would haue all vnderstanded to be called catholike, touching the fayth of the sacrament, hath such an absurdity in it, as was neuer hard of in religion.
For by forbidding of the name of bread, according to Theodorets teaching we dissemble and hide that it is by this authors teaching, and by using the name of our Lords body, according to Theodorets teaching, we feign it to be that it is not by this authors teaching, which saith, there is only a figure, and by this means in so high a mystery we should use untruths on both sides, in simulation and dissimulation, which is a marvellous teaching.
For by forbidding of the name of bread, according to Theodorets teaching we dissemble and hide that it is by this authors teaching, and by vsing the name of our Lordes body, according to Theodorets teaching, we fayne it to be that it is not by this authors teaching, which sayth, there is onely a figure, and by this meanes in so high a mistery we should vse vntruthes on both sides, in simulation and dissimulation, which is a meruaylous teaching.
I deny not but things signifying may have the name of that they signify by a figure §4of speech, but we read not in any doctrine given that the thing signifying should have the name by figure, and be delivered from the name of that it is in deed. And yet this is now the teaching of this author in defence of his new Catholic faith joined with the teaching of Theodoret, and the secret Epistle of S. Chrysostom, as this author would have them understanded. But those men Theodoret and Chrysostom in the sense they §5meant, as I understand them, taught a true doctrine. For they take the name of the body of Christ in the sacrament to be a real naming of the body of Christ there present in deed, and therefore a true perfect name, which as S. Chrysostoms secret Epistle saith, the thing is worthy to have declaring, by that worthiness the thing named to be there in deed. And likewise I understand the other name of bread worthily done away, because the substance whereupon in reason the name was grounded, is changed, according to the true doctrine of Transubstantiation, therefore that name of bread in their doctrine is truly laid away although Theodoret writeth the visible matter of bread §6and wine to be seen and felt as they were before, and therefore saith their substance which there signifieth the outward nature is seen and felt to remain, which terms with convenient understanding may thus agree with the catholic teaching of transubstantiation, §7and so in the sacrament on every part, but in the heavenly and earthly part to be a full, whole and perfect truth, as the high mystery being the sacrament of our perfect unity in body and soul with Christ, doth require. Whereby in my judgement as this author hath against his own determination in this enterprise uttered that confirmeth the truth of the real presence of Christs most precious body in the sacrament, which he doth in special entreating the words of S Augustine in the xxvii. leaf of his book besides that in divers other places he doth the like: so bringing us forth this Theodoret and his secret epistle of S. Chrysostom, he hath brought forth that may serve to convince him in transubstantiation. Howbeit as for transubstantiation Zuinglius taketh it truly for a necessary consequence of the trueth, if there be in the sacrament the real presence of Christs body, as there is in deed.
I deny not but thinges signifying may haue the name of that they signify by a figure
For as a carnal man not instruct by faith §9aswell after consecration as before as he is of the earth, speaketh and calleth it bread and asking him what it is, will never answer otherwise, and if one asked him whether it were the body of Christ, would think the questioner mocked him, so the faithful spiritual man answering to that question what it is, would after consecration according to faith, answer the body of Christ, and think himself mocked if he were asked is it not bread? unless he had been taught Christ to have said it had been both his body and bread. As for calling it by the name of bread which it was, he would not greatly stick, and one thing may have many names, but one thing is but one substance, whereby to answer to the question what it is, saving only in the person of Christ, wherein we know united the two substances of god and man. And this matter I repeat and summarily touch again to leave in the readers breast the principal point of our belief of this mystery to be of the real presence, that is to say, unfeigned substantial presence, and therefore the true presence of Christs most precious body in the Sacrament, which hath been in all ages taught, and been as it is the Catholic faith of Christendom, as appeareth by the testimony of the old authors in all ages.
For as a carnall man not instruct by fayth §9aswell after consecration as before as he is of the earth, speaketh and calleth it bread and asking him what it is, will neuer aunswere otherwise, and if one asked him whether it were the body of Christ, would thinke the questioner mocked him, so the faythfull spirituall man answering to that question what it is, would after consecration according to fayth, aunswere the body of Christ, and thinke himself mocked if he were asked is it not bread? vnles he had bene taught Christ to haue sayd it had bene both his body and bread. As for calling it by the name of bread which it was, he would not greatly stick, and one thing may haue many names, but one thing is but one substance, whereby to aunswere to the question what it is, sauing onely in the person of Christ, wherein we know vnited the two substances of god and man. And this matter I repeate and summarily touch agayne to leaue in the readers brest the principall poynt of our beliefe of this mistery to be of the reall presence, that is to say, vnfayned substantiall presence, and therefore the true presence of Christes most precious body in the Sacrament, which hath bene in al ages taught, and bene as it is the Catholick fayth of Christendome, as appeareth by the testimony of the old authors in all ages.
For the conclusion of all these questions, when you see that you can make no answer, but that you be driven to so many absurdities, and that I have answered so plainly unto every one, that there is left neither absurdity nor difficulty at all, then you devise the best way and most easy for your ⟨p. 360⟩self, to lay apart all questions and idle talk, when all these questions and idle talk needed not, if the papists of their idle brains had not devised their transubstantiation, and thereupon moved this idle talk themselves, which hath been occasion not only of much dissension in all Christian realms, but of the effusion also of much innocent blood.
FOr the conclusion of al these questions, when you see that you can make no aunswere, but that you be driuen to so many absurdities, and that I haue answered so playnely vnto euery one, that there is left neither absurdity nor difficulty at al, then you deuise the best way and most easy for your ⟨p. 360⟩selfe, to lay apart all questions and idle talke, when all these questions and idle talke needed not, if the papistes of their idle braines had not deuised their transubstantiation, and thereupon moued this idle talke themselues, which hath bene occasion not onely of much dissention in all Christian realmes, but of the effusion also of much innocent bloud.
But when the Papists, like unto Lucifer, have ascended into heaven,§2 and searched by vain and arrogant questions the bowels and secrets of gods majesty and his wisdom. Yea even whether God have made the world so well as he might have done, then they command other to keep silence, and not to enter into the bottomless secrecy of Gods mysteries, nor to seek that is above their reach, but to endeavour themselves to do that God commandeth, which counsel as it is most godly and wholesome, so if the Papists themselves had observed in the beginning, no man should have needed to have troubled his brains with such frivolous questions, and idle talk. But the Papists do like boys in the school, that make rods to beat other, and when they should be beaten with the rods which they made themselves, then they wish that all rods were in the fire. So the Papists when they see themselves overthrown in their own questions which they first devised themselves, & to be beaten with their own rods, then they cry peace, hold hands, and question no more.
But when the Papistes, like vnto Lucifer, haue ascended into heauen,§2 and searched by vayne and arrogant questions the bowels and secrets of gods maiesty and his wisedome. Yea euen whether God haue made the world so well as he might haue done, theu they commaund other to keepe silence, and not to enter into the bottomles secrecy of Gods misteries, nor to seeke that is aboue their reach, but to eudeuour themselues to doe that God commanndeth, which counsaile as it is most godly and holesome, so if the Papistes themselues had obserued in the beginning, no man should haue needed to haue troubled his braynes with such fryuolous questions, and idle talke. But the Papists do like boyes in the schole, that make rods to beat other, aud when they should be beaten with the roddes which they made themselues, then they wish that al rods were in the fier. So the Papistes when they see themselues ouerthrowne in their owne questions which they first deuised themselues, & to be beaten with their owne rods, then they cry peace, hold hands, and question no more.
But to answer the absurdities laid unto the Papists charge, you recompense me again with •• great huge absurdities. One is that Christ is really but in heaven only, the other is that bread is still bread. Here thou mayst judge (gentle reader) what errors I defend, that am by force driven to such two absurdities, that I am fain to say as I have written in my book, and as the Apostles and Evangelists said. But beware I would advise thee, that thou say not as Gods word teacheth, for if thou dost, thou mayst be sure to be taken of the Papists for an heretic.
But to aunswere the absurdityes layed vnto the Papistes charge, you recompence me agayne with •• great huge absurdities. One is that Christ is really but in heauen onely, the other is that bread is stil bread. Here thou mayst iudge (gentle reader) what errours I defend, that am by force driuen to such two absurdities, that I am fayne to say as I haue written in my booke, and as the Apostles and Euangelistes sayd. But beware I would aduise thee, that thou say not as Gods word teacheth, for if thou doost, thou mayst be sure to be taken of the Papistes for an hereticke.
1Finally you come to your contradictions of bread and no bread, the body and not the body, simulation and dissimulation, wherein when you have well practised your self in all your book through, at the last you make as it were a play in a dialogue between Chrysostom, Theodoret and me. But Chrysostom, Theodoret and I shall agree well enough,2 for they tell §3not what in no wise may be, but what was commonly used, that is to say not to call the bread by his proper name after consecration, but by the name of the body of Christ. And if you had well considered, what I wrote in my §4book concerning figurative speeches, and negatives by comparison (which you also have allowed) you should have well perceived your labour here spent all in vain. For in all figures and sacraments, the signs remaining in their own proper natures, change nevertheless their names,3 and be called by the names of the more high and excellent things which they signify. And both Chrysostom and Theodoret show a cause thereof which is this, that we should not rest in the sight of the sacraments and figures, but lift up our minds to the things that be thereby represented. And yet in the sacraments is neither simulation nor dissimulation, except you will call all figurative speeches, simulation, and say that Christ simuled, when he said, he was a vine, a door, a herdsman, the light of the world, and such like speeches. But it pleaseth you for refreshing of your wit (being now so sore travailed with impugning of the truth) to devise a pretty merry dialog ⟨p. 361⟩of Quoth he and quoth he. And if I were disposed to dally and trifle, I could make a like dialogue of simulation or dissimulation, of quoth he and quoth you, even between you and Christ.
1Fynally you come to your contradictions of bread and no bread, the body and not the body, simulation and dissimulation, wherin when you haue well practised your selfe in all your booke thorow, at the last you make as it were a play in a dialogue betweene Chrysostome, Theodoret and me. But Chrysostome, Theodoret and I shall agree well enough,
But (as I have declared before,) all things which be exalted to an higher dignity, be called by the names of their dignity (So much the many times their former names be forgotten,) and yet nevertheless they be the same things that they were before, although they be not usually so called, As the surnames of Kings and Emperors, to how many be they known? or how many do call them thereby? but every man calleth them by their royal and imperial dignities. And in like manner is it of figures and sacraments, saving that their exaltation is in a figure, and the dignities royal and imperial be real and indeed. And yet he should not offend that should call the princes by their original names, so that he did it not in contempt of their estates. And no more should he offend that did call a figure by the name of the thing that it is indeed, so that he did it not in contempt of the thing that is signified. And therefore Theodoret saith not, that the bread in the sacrament may not be called bread, and that he offendeth that so calleth it, for he calleth it bread himself, but with this addition of dignity, calling it the bread of life, which it signifieth. As the cap of maintenance is not called barely and simply a cap, but with addition of maintenance. And in like manner we use not in common speech to call bread, wine and water in the sacraments, simple and common water, bread and wine: but according to that they represent unto us, we call them the water of baptism, the water of life, sacramental water, sacramental and celestial bread and wine, the bread of life, the drink that quencheth our thirst for ever. And the cause Theodoret showeth, why they be so called, that we hearing those names should lift up our minds unto the things that they be called, and comfort our selves therewithal. And yet neither in the sacraments, in the cap of maintenance, nor in the imperial or royal majesties is any simulation or dissimulation, but all be plain speeches in common usage, which every man understandeth.
But (as I haue declared before,) all thinges which be exalted to an hier dignity, be called by the names of their dignity (So muche the many times their former names be forgotten,) and yet neuertheles they be the same thinges that they were before, although they be not vsually so called, As the surnames of Kinges and Emperours, to how many be they knowen? or how many doe call them thereby? but euery man calleth them by their royall and imperiall dignities. And in like maner is it of fygures and sacramentes, sauing that their exaltation is in a figure, and the dignities royall and imperiall be reall and indeed. And yet he should not offend that should call the princes by their original names, so that he did it not in contempt of their estates. And no more should he offend that did call a figure by the name of the thing that it is indeed, so that he did it not in contempt of the thing that is signified. And therefore Theodoret sayth not, that the bread in the sacrament may not be called bread, and that he offendeth that so calleth it, for he calleth it bread himselfe, but with this addition of dignity, calling it the bread of life, which it signifieth. As the cap of maintenāce is not called barely and simply a cap, but with addition of maintenaunce. And in like manner we vse not in common speach to call bread, wine and water in the sacraments, simple and common water, bread and wine: but according to that they represent vnto vs, we call them the water of baptisme, the water of life, sacramentall water, sacramentall and celestiall bread and wine, the bread of lyfe, the drinke that quencheth our thirst for euer. And the cause Theodoret sheweth, why they be so called, that we hearing those names should lift vp our mindes vnto the thinges that they bee called, and comfort our selues therewithall. And yet neither in the sacraments, iu the cap of maintenaunce, nor in the imperiall or royall maiesties is any simulation or dissimulation, but all be playn speaches in common vsage, which euery man vnderstandeth.
But there was never man that understood any author further from his meaning, then you do Theodoret and Chrysostom in this place. For they meant not of any real calling, by changing of substances, but of a sacramental change of the names remaining the substances. For Theodoret saith in plain words, that as Christ called bread his body, so he called his body corn, and called himself a vine. Was therefore the substance of his body transubstantiated and turned into corn, or he into a vine? And yet this must needs follow of your saying, if Christs calling were a putting away of the former substance, according to the doctrine of Transubstantiation. But that Theodoret meant not of any such changing of substances, but of changing of names, he declareth so plainly, that no man can doubt of his meaning. These be Theodorets own words. Our Saviour without doubt changed the names and gave to his body the name of the sign, and to the sign the name of his body, and yet (saith he) they kept their former substance, fashion, and figure. And the cause wherefore Christ doth vouchsafe to call the sacramental bread by the name of his body, & to dignify so earthly a thing by so heavenly a name, Theodoret showeth to be this, that the godly receivers of the Sacrament, when they hear ⟨p. 362⟩the heavenly names, should lift up their minds from earth unto heaven, and not to have respect unto the bread outwardly only, but principally to look upon Christ, who with his heavenly grace and omnipotent power feedeth them inwardly.
But there was neuer man that vnderstood any author further from his meaning, then you do Theodoret and Chrysostome in this place. For they ment not of any reall calling, by chaungyng of substances, but of a sacramentall chaunge of the names remaining the substaunces. For Theodoret sayth in playne wordes, that as Christ called bread his body, so he called his body corne, and called himselfe a vine. Was therefore the substance of his body transubstantiated and turned into corne, or he into a vine? And yet this must needes follow of your saying, if Christes calling were a putting away of the former substance, according to the doctrine of Transubstantiation. But that Theodoret ment not of any such chaunging of substances, but of chaunging of names, he declareth so playnely, that no man can doubt of his meaning. These be Theodorets owne wordes. Our Sauiour without doubt chaunged the names and gaue to his body the name of the signe, and to the signe the name of his body, and yet (sayth he) they kept their former substaunce, fashion, and figure. And the cause wherfore Christ doth vouchsafe to call the sacramental bread by the name of hys body, & to dignify so earthly a thing by so heauenly a name, Theodoret sheweth to be this, that the godly receiuers of the Sacrament, when they heare
But there was never such untruth used, as you use in this author, to §6hide the trueth, and to set forth your untruth. For you alter Theodoretes words, and yet that sufficeth not, but you give such new and strange significations to words, as before was never invented. For where Theodoret saith, that the sacraments remain, you turn that into the visible matter, and then that visible matter (as you take it) must signify accidents. And where Theodoret saith in plain terms, that the substance remaineth, there must substance also by your saying signify accidents, which you call here outward nature, contrary to your own doctrine, which have taught hitherto, that substance is an inward nature, invisible and insensible. And thus your saying here neither agreeth with the trueth nor with your self in other places.
But there was neuer such vntrueth vsed, as you vse in this author, to §6hide the trueth, and to set forth your vntrueth. For you alter Theodoretes wordes, and yet that suffiseth not, but you geue such new and straunge significations to wordes, as before was neuer inuented. For where Theodoret sayth, that the sacramentes remayne, you turne that into the visible matter, and then that visible matter (as you take it) must signify accidents. And where Theodoret sayth in playne termes, that the substaunce remayneth, there must substaunce also by your saying signify accidentes, which you call here outward nature, cōtrary to your own doctrine, which haue taught hetherto, that substaunce is an inward nature, inuisible and insensible. And thus your saying here neither agreeth with the trueth nor with your selfe in other places.
And all these cantelless and false interpretations, altering of the words, and corrupting of the sense both of all authors and also of scripture, is nothing else but shameless shifts to deceive simple people, and to draw them from the old Catholic faith of Christs Church, unto your new Romish errors, devised by Antichrist, not above four or five hundred years passed.
And all these cantelless and false interpretations, altering of the words, and corrupting of the sence both of all authors and also of scripture, is nothing els but shameles shiftes to deceiue simple people, and to draw them from the olde Catholicke fayth of Christes Churche, vnto your newe Romish errors, deuised by Antichrist, not aboue foure or fiue hundred yeares passed.
And where you say, that in the sacrament, in every part both in the heavenly §7& earthly part, is an whole & perfect truth. Now is perfect truth in the earthly part of the sacrament, if there be no bread there at all, but the colour and accidents of bread? For if there be none other truth in the heavenly part of the sacrament, then is not Christ there at all, but only his qualities and accidents.
And where you say, that in the sacrament, in euery part both in the heauenly §7& earthly part, is an whole & perfect truth. Now is perfect truth in the earthly part of the sacrament, if there be no bread there at all, but the color and accidents of bread? For if there be none other truth in the heauē ly part of the sacrament, then is not Christ there at all, but onely his qualities and accidentes.
And as concerning your unjust gathering of mine own words upon §8S. Augustine, I have answered thereunto in the same place.
And as concerning your vniust gathering of mine owne wordes vpon §8S. Augustine, I haue aunswered thereunto in the same place.
And where you have set out the answer of the carnal and spiritual §9man, after your own imagination, you have so well devised the matter, that you have made ii. extremities without any mean. For the true faithful man would answer, not as you have devised, but he would say (according to the old catholic faith and teaching of the Apostles, Evangelists, Martyrs and confessors of Christs Church) that in the Sacrament or true ministration thereof be two parts, the earthly and the heavenly. The earthly is the bread and wine, the other is Christ himself: The earthly is without us, the heavenly is within us: The earthly is eaten with our mouths, and carnally feedeth our bodies, the heavenly is eaten with our inward man, and spiritually feedeth the same: The earthly feedeth us but for a time, the heavenly feedeth us for ever. Thus would the true faithful man answer, without leaning unto any extremity, either to deny the bread or inclosing Christ really in the accidences of bread, but professing & believing Christ really and corporally to be ascended into heaven, and yet spiritually to dwell in his faithful people, and they in him unto the worlds end. This is the true catholic faith of Christ, taught from the first beginning, and never corrupted but by Antichrist and his ministers.
And where you haue set out the aunswere of the carnall and spirituall §9man, after your owne imagination, you haue so well deuised the matter, that you haue made ii. extremities without any meane. For the true faythfull man would answere, not as you haue deuised, but he would say (according to the old catholick fayth and teaching of the Apostles, Euangelists, Martyrs and confessours of Christes Churche) that in the Sacrament or true ministration thereof be two parts, the earthly and the heauenly. The earthly is the bread and wine, the other is Christ himselfe: The earthly is without vs, the heauenlye is within vs: The earthlye is eaten with our mouthes, and carnally feedeth our bodies, the heauenly is eaten with our inward man, and spiritually feedeth the same: The earthly feedeth vs but for a tyme, the heauenly feedeth vs for euer. Thus would the true faythfull man answere, without leaning vnto any extremity, either to deny ye bread or inclosing Christ really in ye accidēces of bread, but professing & beleuing Christ really and corporally to be ascended into heauen, and yet spiritually to dwell in his faythfull people, and they in him vnto the worldes ende. This is the true catholicke fayth of Christ, taught from the first beginning, and neuer corrupted but by Antichrist and his ministers.
1And where you say, that one thing is but one substance, saving only ⟨p. 363⟩in the person of Christ, your teaching is untrue, not only in the person of Christ, but also in every man, who is made of ij. substances, the body and soul. And if you had been learned in philosophy, you would have found your saying false also in every corporal thing, which consisteth of ij. substances, of the matter, and of the form. And Gelasius showeth the same likewise in this matter of the sacrament. So untrue it is that you most vainly boast here, that your doctrine hath been taught in all ages, and been the catholic faith, which was never the catholic, but only the Papistical faith, as I have evidently proved by holy scripture and the old catholic authors, wherein truly and directly you have not answered to one.
1And where you say, that one thing is but one substaunce, sauing onelye ⟨p. 363⟩in the person of Christ, your teaching is vntrue, not onely in the person of Christ, but also in euery man, who is made of ij. substaunces, the body and soule. And if you had beene learned in philosophy, you would haue founde your saying false also in euery corporall thing, which consisteth of ij. substaunces, of the matter, and of the forme. And Gelasius sheweth the same likewise in this matter of the sacrament. So vntrue it is that you moste vainely boast here, that your doctrine hath bene taught in all ages, and bene the catholicke faith, which was neuer the catholique, but onely the Papisticall fayth, as I haue euidentlye proued by holy scripture and the old catholick authors, wherein truely and directly you haue not aunswered to one.
In whose particular words although there may be sometime cavillations, yet I will note to the reader, four marks and tokens imprinted rather in those old authors deeds then words, which be certain testimonies to the truth of their faith of the real presence of Christs most precious body in the Sacrament. The first mark is in the process of arguing used by them to the conviction of heretics by the truth of this Sacrament, wherein I note not the particular sentences, which sometime be dangerous speeches, §2but their whole doings. As Irene who was in the beginning of the church, argueth against the Ualentinians that denied the resurrection of our flesh, whom Irene reproveth by the feeding of our souls and bodies with the divine glorified flesh of Christ in the Sacrament, which flesh and •t be there but in a figure, then it should have proved the resurrection of our flesh slenderly as it were but figuratively. And if the Catholic faith had not been then certainly taught, and constantly believed without variance, Christs very flesh to be indeed eaten in that mystery, it would have been answered of the heretics, if had been but a figure, but that appeareth not, and the other appeareth, which is a testimony to the truth of matter indeed.
In whose particular words although there may be sometime cauillations, yet I will note to the reader, foure marks and tokens imprinted rather in those olde authors deeds then wordes, which be certayne testimonies to the truth of their fayth of the reall presence of Christes most precious body in the Sacrament. The first marke is in the processe of arguing vsed by them to the conuiction of heretiques by the truth of this Sacrament, wherein I note not the particuler sentences, which sometime be daungerous speches, §2but their whole doinges. As Irene who was in the beginning of the church, argueth agaynst the Ualentinians that denied the resurrection of our flesh, whome Irene reproueth by the féeding of our soules and bodies with the diuine glorified fleshe of Christ in the Sacrament, which flesh and •t be there but in a figure, then it should haue proued the resurrection of our flesh slenderly as it were but figuratiuely. And if the Catholicke fayth had not bene then certainely taught, and constantly beleued without varience, Christes very flesh to be indeede eaten in that mistery, it would haue beene aunswered of the heretickes, if had bene but a figure, but that appeareth not, and the other appeareth, which is a testimony to the truth of matter indéed.
Hilary reasoning of the natural conjunction between us and Christ by mean of this Sacrament, expresseth the same to come to pass by the receiving truly the very flesh of our Lord in our Lords meat, and thereupon argueth against the Arians, which Arians if it had not been so really in deed, would have answered, but all was spiritually, so as there was no such natural and corporal Communion in deed as Hilary supposed, but (as this author teacheth) a figure; and it had been the Catholic doctrine: so that argument of Hilary had been of no force. Saint Chrysostom, Gelasius and §3Theodorete argue of the truth of this mystery to convince the Appolinaristes and Eutychians, which were none argument if Christs very body were not as really present in the Sacrament for the truth of presence, as the Godhead is in the person of Christ, being §4the effect of the argument this: that as the presence of Christs body in this mystery doth not alter the property of the visible natures, no more doth the Godhead in the person of Christ extinguish his humanity, which against those heretics served for an argument to exclude confusion of natures in Christ, and had been a dangerous arguing to be embraced of the Nestorians, who would hereby have furthered their heresy, to prove the distinction of natures in Christ without any union, for they would have said: As the earthly and heavenly natures be so distinct in the Sacrament, as the one is not spoken of the other: so be the natures of the humanity and Godhead not united in Christ, which is false, and in the comparynges we may not look that all should answer in equality, but only for the point that it is made for, that is, as in the Sacrament the visible element is not extinguished by the presence of Christs most precious body, no more is Christs humanity by his Godhead: and yet we may not say, that as in the Sacrament be but only accidents of the visible earthly matter, that therefore in the person of Christ be only accidents of the humanity. For that mystery requireth the whole truth of mans §5nature, and therefore Christ took upon him the whole man, body and soul. The mystery of the Sacrament requireth the truth of the accidents only, being the substance of ⟨p. 376⟩the visible creatures converted into the body and blood of Christ. And this I write to prevent such cavillations as some would search for.
But to return to our matter, all these arguments were vain, if there were not in the Sacrament the true presence of Christs very body, as the celestial part of the Sacrament, being the visible forms the earthly thing. Which earthly thing remaineth in the former propriety with the very presence of the celestial thing. And this sufficeth concerning the first mark.
But to returne to our matter, all these argumentes were vayne, if there were not in the Sacrament the true presence of Christes very body, as the celestiall part of the Sacrament, beyng the visible formes therthly thyng. Which earthly thyng remayneth in the former proprietie with the very presence of the celestiall thyng. And this suffiseth concernyng the first marke.
AS for your four marks & tokens (if you mark them well) you shall §1perceive most manifestly your ignorance and error, how they note and appoint (as it were with their fingers) your doctrine to be erroneous, as well of Transubstantiation, as of the real presence.
AS for your foure markes & tokens (if you marke them well) you shall §1perceaue most manifestly your ignoraūce and errour, how they note and appoint (as it were with their fingers) your doctrine to be erronious, as well of Transubstantiation, as of the reall presence.
1And to begin with your first mark, Irenee in deed proved the resurrection §2of our bodies unto eternal life, because our bodies be nourished with the everlasting food of Christs body. And therefore as that food is everlasting, so it being joined unto his eternal deity, giveth to our bodies everlasting life. And if the being of Christs body in any creature should give the same life, then it might peradventure be thought of some fools, that if it were in the bread, it should give life to the bread. But neither reason, learning nor faith beareth, that Christs body being only in bread, should give life unto a man. So that if it were an Article of our faith, to believe that Christ is present in the forms of bread and wine, it were an unprofitable Article, seeing that his being in the bread, should profit no man.
1And to begyn with your first marke, Irenee in deede proued the resurrection §2of our bodyes vnto eternall lyfe, bycause our bodyes be nourished with the euerlastyng foode of Christes body. And therfore as that foode is euerlastyng, so it beyng ioyned vnto his eternall deitie, giueth to our bodies euerlastyng lyfe. And if the beyng of Christes body in any creature should geue the same lyfe, then it might peraduenture be thought of some fooles, that if it were in the bread, it should giue life to the bread. But neither reason, learnyng nor fayth beareth, that Christes body beyng onely in bread, should gyue life vnto a man. So yt if it were an Article of our faith, to beleue that Christ is present in the formes of bread and wine, it were an vnprofitable Article, seyng that his being in ye bread, should profit no man.
1Irenee therefore meaneth not of the being of Christ in the bread and wine, but of the eating of him. And yet he meaneth not of corporal eating (for so Christ saith him self,2 that his flesh availeth nothing) but spiritual eating by faith. Nor he speaketh not of spiritual eating in receiving of the Sacrament only, for then our life should not be eternal, nor endure no longer then we be eating of the sacrament: for our spiritual life continueth no longer than our spiritual feeding. And then could none have life, but that receive the Sacrament, and all should have perished that dyed before Christs Supper and institution of the Sacrament, or that dye under age before they receive the Sacrament.
1Irenee therefore meaneth not of the beyng of Christ in the bread and wyne, but of the eatyng of him. And yet he meaneth not of corporall eating (for so Christ sayth him selfe,2 that his flesh auayleth nothing) but spirituall eatyng by fayth. Nor he speaketh not of spirituall eatyng in receauyng of the Sacrament onely, for then our lyfe should not be eternall, nor endure no longer then we be eating of the sacrament: for our spirituall life cōtinueth no lōger thē our spirituall feedyng. And then could none haue lyfe, but that receaue the Sacramēt, and all should haue perished that dyed before Christes Supper and institutiō of the Sacrament, or that dye vnder age before they receiue the Sacrament.
But the true meaning of Irenee, Hilary, Cyprian, Cyril, and other that treated of this matter was this, that as Christ was truly made man and crucified for us, and shed his blood upon the Cross for our redemption, & now reigneth for ever in heaven, so as many as have a true faith and belief in him, chawing their cuds, and perfectly remembering the same death and passion (which is the spiritual eating of his flesh and drinking of his blood) they shall reign in everlasting life with him. For they spiritually and truly by faith eat his flesh and drink his blood, whether they were before the institution of the Sacrament or after. And the being or not being of Christs body and blood really and corporally in the Sacrament under the forms of bread and wine, neither maketh nor marreth, nor is to no purpose in this matter. But for confirmation of this our faith in Christs death and passion, & for a perpetual memory of the same, hath Christ ordained this holy Sacrament, not to be kept, but to be ministered among us, to our singular comfort, that as outwardly and corporally we eat the very bread and drink the very wine, and call them the body and blood of Christ, so inwardly and spiritually we eat & drink the very body ⟨p. 365⟩and blood of Christ. And yet carnally and corporally he is in heaven, and shall be until the last Judgement, when he shall come to Judge both the quick and the dead. And in the Sacrament, (that is to say, in the due ministration of the Sacrament) Christ is not only figuratively, but effectually unto everlasting life.
But the true meaning of Irenee, Hilary, Cyprian, Cyrill, and other that treated of this matter was this, that as Christ was truely made man and crucified for vs, and shed his bloud vpon the Crosse for our redemption, & now reigneth for euer in heauen, so as many as haue a true fayth and belefe in him, chawyng their cuddes, and perfectly remembryng the same death and passion (which is the spirituall eatyng of his flesh and drinkyng of his bloud) they shall reigne in euerlastyng lyfe with him. For they spiritually and truely by faith eate his flesh and drinke his bloud, whether they were before the institution of the Sacrament or after. And the beyng or not beyng of Christes body and bloud really and corporally in the Sacrament vnder the formes of bread and wine, neither maketh nor marreth, nor is to no purpose in this matter. But for confirmation of this our fayth in Christes death and passion, & for a perpetuall memory of the same, hath Christ ordeined this holy Sacrament, not to be kept, but to be ministred among vs, to our singular comfort, that as outwardly and corporally we eate the very bread and drinke the very wine, and call them the body and bloud of Christ, so inwardly and spiritually we eate & drinke the very body
And this teaching impugneth the heresies of the Ualentinians, Arians, and other heretics, and so doth not your feigned doctrine of Transubstantiation, of the real presence of Christs flesh and blood in the Sacrament, under the forms of bread and wine: and that ungodly and wicked men eat and drink the same, which shall be cast away from the eternal life, and perish for ever. And for further answer to Hilary, I refer the Reader to mine other answer made to him before.
And this teachyng impugneth the heresies of the Ualentinians, Arrians, and other heretickes, and so doth not your fayned doctrine of Transubstantiation, of the reall presence of Christes flesh and bloud in the Sacrament, vnder the formes of bread and wine: and that vngodly and wicked men eate and drinke the same, which shall be cast away from the eternall lyfe, and perish for euer. And for further aunswere to Hilary, I referre the Reader to myne other aunswere made to him before.
And for S. Chrysostom, Gelasius, and Theodorete, if there be no bread and wine in the Sacrament, their Arguments serve for the heretics purpose, and clean directly against them selves. For their intent against the heretics, is to prove that to the full perfection of Christ is required a perfect soul, and a perfect body, and to be perfect God and perfect man. As to the full perfection of the Sacrament is required pure and perfect bread and wine, and the perfect body and blood of Christ. So that now turning the Argument, if there be no perfect bread and wine (as the Papists falsely surmise) then may the heretics conclude against the Catholic faith, and convince Chrysostom, Gelasius & Theodorete with their own weapon, that is to say, with their own similitude, that as in the Sacrament lacketh the earthly part, so doth in Christ lack his humanity. And as to all our senses seemeth to be bread and wine, and yet is none in deed, so shall they argue by this similitude, that in Christ seemed to all our senses flesh and blood, and yet was there none in very deed. And thus by your devilish Transubstantiation of bread and wine, do you transubstantiate also the body and blood of Christ, not convincing but confirming most heinous heresies. And this is the conclusion of your ungodly feigned doctrine of transubstantiation.
And for S. Chrisostome, Gelasius, and Theodorete, if there be no bread and wine in the Sacrament, their Argumentes serue for the heretickes purpose, and cleane directly agaynst them selues. For their entent agaynst the heretickes, is to proue that to the full perfection of Christ is required a perfect soule, and a perfect body, and to be perfect God and perfect man. As to the full perfection of the Sacrament is required pure and perfect bread and wine, and the perfect body and bloud of Christ. So that now turnyng the Argument, if there be no perfect bread and wine (as the Papistes falsely surmise) then may the heretickes cōclude agaynst the Catholicke fayth, and conuince Chrisostome, Gelasius & Theodorete with their own weapon, that is to say, with their own similitude, that as in the Sacramēt lacketh the earthly part, so doth in Christ lacke his humanitie. And as to all our senses seemeth to be bread and wine, and yet is none in deede, so shall they argue by this similitude, that in Christ seemed to all our senses flesh and bloud, and yet was there none in very deede. And thus by your deuilish Trāsubstantiation of bread and wine, do you trāsubstantiate also the body and bloud of Christ, not conuincyng but confirmyng most haynous heresies. And this is the conclusion of your vngodly fayned doctrine of transubstantiation.
And where you would gather the same conclusion, if Christs flesh and blood be not really present, it seemeth that you understand not the purpose and intent of these Authors. For they bring not this similitude of the Sacrament for the real presence, but for the real being. That as the Sacrament consisteth in two parts, one earthly & an other heavenly, (the earthly part being the bread and wine, and the heavenly the body and blood of Christ) and these parts be all truly and really in deed, without colour, or simulation (that is to say very true bread and wine, in deed, the very true body and blood of Christ in deed:) even likewise in Christ be two natures, his humanity and earthly substance, and his divinity and heavenly substance, and both these be true natures and substances, without colour or dissembling. And thus is this similitude of the Sacrament brought in, for the truth of the natures, not for the presence of the natures. For Christ was perfect God and perfect man, when his soul went down to hell, and his body lay in the grave (because the body and soul were both still united unto his divinity) and yet it was not required that his soul should be present with the body in the sepulture, no more is it now required that his body should be really present in the Sacrament, but as the soul was then ⟨p. 366⟩in hell, so is his body now in heaven. And as it is not required, that where so ever Christs divinity is, there should be really and corporally his manhood: so it is not required, that where the bread and wine be, there should be corporally his flesh and blood.
And where you would gather the same cōclusion, if Christes flesh and bloud be not really present, it seemeth that you vnderstand not the purpose and intent of these Authors. For they bring not this similitude of the Sacrament for the reall presence, but for the reall beyng. That as the Sacrament consisteth in two partes, one earthly & an other heauenly, (the earthly part beyng the bread and wine, and the heauenly the body and bloud of Christ) and these partes be all truely and really in deede, without colour, or simulation (that is to say very true bread and wine, in deede, the very true body and bloud of Christ in deede:) euē likewise in Christ be two natures, his humanitie and earthly substaunce, and his diuinitie and heauēly substaunce, and both these be true natures and substaunces, without colour or dissemblyng. And thus is this similitude of the Sacrament brought in, for the truth of the natures, not for the presence of the natures. For Christ was perfect God and perfect man, whē his soule went downe to hell, and his body lay in the graue (bycause the body and soule were both still vnited vnto his diuinitie) and yet it was not required that his soule should be present with the body in the sepulture, no more is it now required that his body should be really present in the Sacrament, but as the soule was then
But as you frame the Argument against the heretics, it serveth so little against them, that they may with the same frame and engine, overthrow the whole Catholic Church. For thus you frame the Argument: As the presence of Christs body in this mystery doth not alter the propriety of the visible natures, no more doth the Godhead in the person of Christ extinguish his humanity. Mark well now good Reader what followeth hereof. As the presence of Christs body in this mystery, doth not alter (say you) the propriety of the visible natures, no more doth the Godhead in the person of Christ extinguish his humanity. But the presence of Christs body in this mystery doth so alter the visible natures (as the Papists say) that the substances of bread and wine be extinguished, and there remaineth no substance but of the body of Christ, Ergo likewise in the mystery of Christs incarnation the humanity is extinguished by the presence of his Godhead, and so there remaineth no more but the substance of his divinity, as the Eutychians said.
But as you frame the Argument agaynst the heretickes, it serueth so litle agaynst them, that they may with the same frame and engine, ouerthrow the whole Catholicke Church. For thus you frame the Argument: As the presence of Christes body in this mystery doth not alter the proprietie of the visible natures, no more doth the Godhead in the person of Christ extinguish his humanitie. Marke well now good Reader what foloweth hereof. As the presence of Christes body in this mysterie, doth not alter (say you) the proprietie of ye visible natures, no more doth the Godhead in the person of Christ extinguish his humanitie. But the presence of Christes body in this mystery doth so alter the visible natures (as the Papistes say) that the substaunces of bread and wyne be extinguished, and there remayneth no substaūce but of the body of Christ, Ergo likewise in the mysterie of Christes incarnation the humanitie is extinguished by the presence of his Godhead, and so there remayneth no more but the substaunce of his diuinitie, as the Eutichians sayd.
And thus the similitude of Chrysostom, Gelasius, and Theodorete joined to the saying of the Papists, frameth a good Argument for the heretics. But those Authors framed their Argument clean contrary, on this wise: that the bread and wine be not transubstantiate or extinguished, but continue still in their own substances, figures, fashion, and all natural proprieties, and therefore doth the humanity of Christ likewise endure and remain in proper substance with his natural proprieties, without extinction or transubstantiation. For those Authors take no bread and wine for the visible proprieties only of bread and wine, but for very true bread and wine, with all their natural qualities and conditions.
And thus the similitude of Chrisostome, Gelasius, and Theodorete ioyned to the saying of the Papistes, frameth a good Argument for the heretickes. But those Authours framed their Argumēt cleane cōtrary, on this wise: that the bread and wyne be not transubstantiate or extinguished, but continue still in their owne substaunces, figures, fashion, and all naturall proprieties, and therfore doth the humanitie of Christ likewise endure and remayne in proper substaunce with his naturall proprieties, without extinction or transubstantiation. For those Authours take no bread and wyne for the visible proprieties onely of bread and wyne, but for very true bread and wyne, with all their naturall qualities and conditions.
And the heretics shall soon find out your cavillation, where (to avoid §7the matter) you say that the mystery of the Sacrament requireth not the truth of the substance. For why should the Authors bring them forth, to prove the truth of the substance in Christ, if there were no true substance in them? Thus all your shifts and Sophistications be but wind, or colours cast over the truth to blear mens eyes, which colours rubbed of, the truth appeareth clear and plain. And your first mark is not clearly put out, but turned to a mark & spectacle for your self, wherein you may clearly see your own error, and how foul you have been deceived in this matter, and open your eyes, (if God will give you grace to put away your indurate hart) to see the clear truth.
And the heretickes shall soone finde out your cauillation, where (to auoyde §7the matter) you say that the mysterie of the Sacrament requireth not the truth of the substaunce. For why should the Authours bryng them forth, to proue the truth of the substaunce in Christ, if there were no true substaunce in them? Thus all your shiftes and Sophistications be but wynde, or colours cast ouer the truth to bleare mens eyes, which colours rubbed of, the truth appeareth cleare and playne. And your first marke is not clearely put out, but turned to a marke & spectacle for your selfe, wherin you may clearely see your owne errour, and how foule you haue bene deceaued in this matter, and open your eyes, (if God will geue you grace to put away your inducate hart) to see the cleare truth.