pp. 3941,982 passagespart 49 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And as he there corporally eateth the very bread and drinketh the very wine, so spiritually he may feed of the very flesh and blood of Jesus Christ his Saviour and redeemer, remembering his death, thanking him for his benefits, and looking for none other sacrifice at no priests hands for remission of his sins, but only trusting to his sacrifice, which being both the high priest, and also the Lamb of God (prepared from the beginning to take away the sins of the world) offered up him self once for ever, in a sacrifice of sweet smell unto his Father, and by the same paid the ransom for the sins of the whole world. Who is before us entered into heaven, and sitteth at the right hand of his Father, as a patron, mediator and intercessor for us. And there hath prepared places for all them that be lively members of his body, to reign with him for ever, in the glory of his father, to whom with him, and the holy Ghost, be glory, honour, and praise for ever and ever. Amen.
And as he there corporally eateth the very bread and drinketh the very wine, so spiritually he may feede of the very fleshe and bloud of Iesu Christ his Sauiour and redeemer, remembryng his death, thankyng him for his benefites, and lookyng for none other sacrifice at no priestes handes for remission of his sinnes, but onely trustyng to his sacrifice, which beyng both the high priest, and also the Lambe of God (prepared from the begynnyng to take away the sinnes of the world) offered vp him selfe once for euer, in a sacrifice of sweete smell vnto his Father, and by the same payd the raunsome for the sinnes of the whole worlde. Who is before vs entred into heauen, and sitteth at the right hand of his Father, as a patron, mediatour and intercessour for vs. And there hath prepared places for all them that be lyuely members of his body, to reigne with him for euer, in the glory of his father, to whom with him, and the holy Ghost, be glory, honour, and prayse for euer and euer. Amen.
Thus having rehearsed the whole words of my last book, I shall return to your issue,1 and make a joinder or demur with you therein. And if you can not prove your propitiatory Sacrifice of the Priests by Petrus Lombardus and Nicene Council, then must you confess by your own Issue, that the Verdict must justly pass against you, and that you have a fall in your own suite. As for the sacrifice of lauds and thanksgiving, I have set it forth plainly in my book, but the sacrifice propitiatory (devised to be made by the priest in the Mass only) is a great abomination before ⟨p. 381⟩God, how glorious soever it appear before men. And it is set up only by Antichrist, and therefore worthy to be abhorred of all that truly profess Christ.
Thus hauing rehearsed the whole wordes of my last booke, I shall returne to your issue,1 and make a ioynder or demurre with you therein. And if you can not proue your propitiatory Sacrifice of the Priestes by Petrus Lombardus and Nicene Councell, then must you confesse by your owne Issue, that the Uerdite must iustly passe agaynst you, and that you haue a fall in your own suite. As for the sacrifice of laudes and thakesgeuyng, I haue set it forth playnly in my booke, but the sacrifice propitiatory (deuised to be made by the priest in the Masse onely) is a great abhominatiō before ⟨p. 381⟩God, how glorious soeuer it appeare befor• men. And it is set vp onely by Antichrist, and therefore worthy to be abhorred of all that truely professe Christ.
First to begin with the council of Nice, the same hath opened the mystery of the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ in this wise, that christen men believe the Lamb §2that taketh away the sins of the world to be situate upon Gods word, and to be sacrificed of the priests, not after the manner of other sacrifices. This is the doctrine of the §1council of Nice, and must then be called an holy doctrine, and thereby a true doctrine, consonant to the scriptures, the foundation of all trueth. If the author will deny this to have been the teaching of the council of Nice, I shall allege therefore the allegation of the same by Decolampadius, who being an adversary to the truth, was yet by Gods providence ordered to bear testimony to the truth in this point, and by his mean is published to the world in greek as followeth, which nevertheless may otherwise appear to be true. [Greek or Hebrew] Iterum etiam hic in divina mensa, ne humiliter intenti simus ad propositum pannem & poculum, sed mente exaltata fide intilligamus, situm esse in sacra illa mensa, illum Dei agnum, qui tollit peccata mundi, sacrificatum à sacerdotibus, non victimarum more & mos preciosum illius corpus, & sanguinem verè sumentes, credere haec esse resurrectionis nostrae Symbola. Ideo enim non multum accipimus, sed parum, ut cognoscamus quoniam non in satietatem, sed sanctificationem. These words may be englished thus: Again in this godly table, we should not in base and low consideration direct our understanding to the bread and cup set forth, but having our mind exalted, we should understand by faith to be situate in that table the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sins of the world sacrificed of the priests not after the manner of other Sacrifices, and we receiving truly the precious body and blood of the same Lamb, to believe these to be §2the tokens of our resurrection: And for that we receive not much but a little, because we should know that not for saturity and filling, but for sanctification.
Fyrst to begin with the counsell of Nice, the same hath opened the mistery of the sacrament of the body and bloud of Christ in this wise, that christen men beleue the Lamb §2that taketh away the sinnes of the world to be situate vpon Gods woorde, and to be sacrificed of the priestes, not after the manner of other sacrifices. This is the doctrine of the §1
This holy counsel of Niece, hath been believed universally in declaration of the mystery of the Trinity and the Sacraments also. And to them that confess that council to be holy, as the author here doth, and to such as proofs to believe the determination of that council in the opening of the mystery of the Trinity with other words then Scripture useth, although they express such sense as in the scriptures is contained: Why should not all such like wise believe the same counsel in explication of the Sacraments, which to do, the author hath bound himself, granting that council holy. And then we must believe the very presence of Christs body and blood on gods board,1 and that Priests do there sacrifice, and be therefore called and named sacrificers. So as those names & terms be to be honoured, and religiously spoken of, being in an holy council uttered and confessed because it was so seen to them and the holy ghost, without whose present assistance and suggestion believed to be there, the council could not or ought not to be called holy. §3Now if we confer with that council of Nice the testimony of the Church beginning at S. Dionyse, who was in the time of the Apostles, and after him coming to Irene, who was near the apostles, and then Tertullian, and so S. Cyprian, S. Chrysostom, S. Cyril, S. Hierome, S. Augustine, and from that age to the time of Petrus Lombardus, all spake of the sacrament to the same effect, and termed it for the word sacrifice and oblation, to be frequented in the church of the body and blood of Christ,2 as may be in particularity showed, whereof I make also an issue with the author.
This holy counsel of Niece, hath bene beleued vniuersally in declaration of the mistery of the Trinity and the Sacramentes also. And to them that confesse that counsell to be holy, as the author here doth, and to such as profes to beleue the determination of that counsell in the opening of the mistery of the Trinity with other words then Scripture vseth, although they expres such sence as in the scriptures is contained: Why should not all such like wise beleue the same counsel in explication of the Sacraments, which to do, the author hath bound himselfe, graunting that counsell holy. And then we must bebeleue the very presence of Christes body and bloud on gods bord,1
For answer to Nicene council, it speaketh of a sacrifice of lauds and §1thanks giving (which is made by the Priest in the name of the whole church, and is the sacrifice as well of the people as of the priest) this sacrifice I say, the council of Nice speaketh of, but it speaketh not one word of the sacrifice propitiatory, which never none made but only Christ, nor he never made it any more then once, which was by his death, And where so ever Christ shall be hereafter in heaven or in earth, he shall never be sacrificed again, but the church continually in remembrance of that sacrifice, maketh a sacrifice of laud and praise, giving evermore thanks unto him, for that propitiatory sacrifice. And in the third chapter of my book here recited, the difference of these ii. sacrifices is plainly set out.
FOr aunswere to Nicene councell, it speaketh of a sacrifice of laudes and §1thankes giuing (which is made by the Priest in the name of the whole church, and is the sacrifice as well of the people as of the priest) this sacrifice I say, the counsell of Nice speaketh of, but it speaketh not one word of the sacrifice propitiatory, which neuer none made but onely Christ, nor he neuer made it any more then once, which was by his death, And where so euer Christ shal be herafter in heauē or in earth, he shal neuer be sacrificed agayne, but the church continually in remembraunce of that sacrifice, maketh a sacrifice of laud and prayse, geuing euermore thanks vnto him, for that propitiatory sacrifice. And in the third chapter of my booke here recited, the difference of these ii. sacrifices is playnely set out.
1And although Nicene council call Christ the lamb that taketh away §2the sins of the world, yet doth it not mean that by the sacrifice of the priest in the Mass, but by the sacrifice of himself upon the cross. But here (according to your accustomed manner) you alter some words of the council, and add also some of your own, For the council said not that the Lamb of God is sacrificed of the priests, not after the manner of other sacrifices: but that he is sacrificed not after the manner of a sacrifice.2 And in saying, that Christ is sacrificed of the priest, not like a sacrifice, or after the manner of a sacrifice, the council in these words signified a difference between the sacrifice of the priest, and the sacrifice of Christ, which upon the Cross offered himself to be sacrificed after the manner of a very sacrifice (that is to say unto death) for the sins of the world. Christ made the bloody sacrifice, which took away sin, the priest with the church make a commemoration thereof with lauds and thanksgiving, offering also themselves obedient to God unto death. And yet this our sacrifice taketh not away our sins, nor is not accepted but by his sacrifice. The bleeding of him took away our sins, not the eating of him.
1And although Nicene counsell call Christ the lambe that taketh away §2the sins of the world, yet doth it not mean that by the sacrifice of the priest in the Masse, but by the sacrifice of himselfe vpon the crosse. But here (according to your accustomed maner) you alter some wordes of the counsell, and adde also some of your owne, For the councell sayd not that the Lamb of God is sacrificed of the priests, not after the manner of other sacrifices: but that he is sacrificed not after the manner of a sacrifice.2 And in saying, that Christ is sacrificed of the priest, not like a sacrifice, or after the maner of a sacrifice, the counsell in these wordes signified a difference betweene the sacrifice of the priest, and the sacrifice of Christ, which vpon the Crosse offered himselfe to be sacrificed after the manner of a very sacrifice (that is to say vnto death) for the sinnes of the world. Christ made the bloudy sacrifice, which tooke away sinne, the priest with the church make a commemoration thereof with laudes and thanksgeuing, offering also themselues obedient to God vnto death. And yet this our sacrifice taketh not away our sinnes, nor is not accepted but by his sacrifice. The bleeding of him took away our sinnes, not the eating of him.
And although that Council say, that Christ is situate in that table, yet §3it saith not that he is really and corporally in the bread and wine. For them that council would not have forbid us to direct our minds to the bread and cup, if they had believed that Christ had been really there. But forasmuch as the council commandeth, that we shall not direct our minds downward to the bread and cup, but lift them up to Christ by faith, they give us to understand by those words, that Christ is really and corporally ascended up into heaven, unto which place we must lift up our minds, and reach him there by our faith, and not look down to find him in the bread. And yet he is in the bread sacramentally, as the same counsel saith, that the holy ghost is in the water of baptism. And as Christ is in his supper present to feed us, so is he in baptism present to clothe and apparel us with his own self, as the same council declareth, whose words be these: He that is baptised, goeth down into the water, being subject to sin, and held in the bands of corruption, but he riseth up free from bondage and sin, being made by the grace of God his son and heir, and coinheritor with Christ, and apparelled with Christ himself as it is written: As many of you as be baptised unto Christ, you have put Christ upon you. These words of the council I rehearse only in english,1 because I will not let nor ⟨p. 383⟩encumber the reader with the greek or latin (as you do) which is nothing else but to rehearse one thing thrice, without need or profit. If I had list, I could have rehearsed all the greek authors in greek, and the latin writers in latin, but unto english men (unto whom only I write) it were a vain labour or glory, without fruit or profit, or any other cause, except I intended to make my book long for gain of the printer, rather then for profit to the reader.
And although that Counsell say, that Christ is situate in that table, yet §3it sayth not that he is really and corporally in the bread and wine. For thē that counsell would not haue forbid vs to direct our mindes to the breade and cup, if they had beleued that Christ had bene really there. But forasmuch as the counsell commaundeth, that we shall not direct our mindes downeward to the bread and cup, but lift them vp to Christ by fayth, they geue vs to vnderstand by those wordes, that Christ is really and corporally ascended vp into heauen, vnto which place we must lift vp our mindes, and reach him there by our fayth, and not looke downe to find him in the bread. And yet he is in the bread sacramentally, as the same counsel sayth, that the holy ghost is in the water of baptisme. And as Christ is in his supper present to feed vs, so is he in baptisme present to clothe and apparell vs with his owne selfe, as the same counsell declareth, whose words be these: He that is baptised, goeth downe into the water, being subiect to sinne, and held in the bands of corruption, but he riseth vp free from bōdage and sinne, being made by the grace of God his sonne and heir, and coinheritor with Christ, and apparelled with Christ himself as it is written: As many of you as be baptised vnto Christ, you haue put Christ vpon you. These wordes of the counsell I reherse onely in english,
But to return to the matter, Christ is present in his holy supper (as that holy Council saith) even as he is present in Baptism, but not really, carnally, corporally, and naturally, as you without ground imagine.
But to returne to the matter, Christ is present in his holy supper (as that holy Councell sayth) euen as he is present in Baptisme, but not really, carnally, corporally, and naturally, as you without ground imagine.
And if he were to present, yet is he not there sacrificed again for sin. For then were his first sacrifice upon the Cross in vain, if it sufficed not therefore.
And if he were to present, yet is he not there sacrificed agayne for sinne. For then were his first sacrifice vpon the Crosse in vayne, if it sufficed not therefore.
And as for Dionyse, Irenee, Tertullian, with all your other authors, I have answered them in the thirteenth chapter of this my last book. And what need you make an issue in this thing which is not in controversy, and which I affirm in my whole last book? The matter in question, is of the sacrifice propitiatory, and you make your issue of the sacrifice generally. Now let us see how you entreat Petrus Lombardus.1
And as for Dionyse, Irenee, Tertullian, with all your other authors, I haue aunswered them in the thirtenth chapiter of this my laste booke. And what need you make an issue in this thing which is not in controuersy, and which I affirme in my whole last booke? The matter in question, is of the sacrifice propitiatory, and you make your issue of the sacrifyce generally. Now let vs see how you intreat Petrus Lombardus.1
For the other point in that the author approveth the judgement of Petrus Lombardus in the matter, what should I more do, but write in the words of Petrus Lombardus as he hath them which he these in the fourth book the xii. chapter alleged by the author Post haec quaeritur, si quod gerit sacerdos, proprie dicatur sacrisiciū, vel immolatio, & si Christus quotidie, vel immoletur semel tantum immolatus sit? Ad hoc breviter dici potest, illud quod offertur & consecratur a sacerdote, vocari sacrificium & oblationem quia memoria est & representatio veri sacrificy & sanctae immolationis factae in ara crucis & semel Christus mortuus in cruce est, ibique immolatus est in semetipso, quotidie autē immolatur in sacramento, quia in sacramento recordatio fit illius, quod factum est semel unde Augustin. Certum habemus, quia Christus resurgens ex mortus jam non moritur. &c. tamen ne obliniscamur, quod semel factum est, in memoria nostra omn […] fit, sclicet quando pascha celebratur. Nunquid totiens Christus occiditur? sed tantū aniu• […] •ecordatio representat quod olim factū est, & sic nos facit moveri tanquā videamus Domin• […] juice: Item semel immolatus est Christus in semetipso,1 & tamē quotidie immolatur in sacram••••. Quod sic intilligendū est: quia in manifestatione corporis & distinction membrorū, semel tanti in cruce pependit, offerens se Deo patri hostiā redemptionis efficacem, eorū scilicet, quos praedestinavit. Item Ambrosius. In Christo semel oblata est hostia ad salutē potes, quid ergo nos? Nonne per singulos dies offerimus? Fae si quotidie offeramus, ad recordationem eius mortis fit, & una est hostia, non multae: quomodo una & nō multae, quia semel immolatus est Christus. Hoc autē sacrificium exemplum est illius, idipsum, & semper idipsum offertur, proinde hoc idem est sacrificium, alioquin dicetur quoniam in multis locis offertur, multi sunt Christi, non sed unus ubique, est Christus, & hic plenus existens, & illic plenus, sicut quod ubique offertur unum est corpus, ita & unum sacrificium. Christus hostiam obtulit, ipsam offerimus & nunc, sed quod nos agimus recordatio est sacrificij: Nec causa suae infirmitatis reperitur, quia per ficit hominem, sed nostrae, quia quotidie peccamus.
For the other poynt in that the author approueth the iudgemēt of Petrus Lombardus in the matter, what should I more doe, but write in the wordes of Petrus Lombardus as he hath them which he these in the fourth booke the xii. chapter alleadged by the author Post haec quaeritur, si quod gerit sacerdos, proprie dicatur sacrisiciū, vel immolatio, & si Christus quotidie, vel immoletur semel tantum immolatus sit? Ad hoc breuiter dici potest, illud quod offertur & consecratur a sacerdote, vocari sacrificium & oblationem quia memoria est & representatio veri sacrificy & sanctae immolationis factae in ara crucis & semel Christus mortuus in cruce est, ibique immolatus est in semetipso, quotidie autē immolatur in sacramēto, quia in sacramento recordatio fit illius, quod factum est semel vnde Augustin. Certum habemus, quia Christus resurgens ex mortus iam non moritur. &c. tamen ne obliniscamur, quod semel factum est, in memoria nostra omn fit, sclicet quādo pascha celebratur. Nunquid totiens Christus occiditur? sed tantū aniu ecordatio representat quod olim factū est, & sic nos facit moueri tāquā videamus Domin uce: Itē semel immolatus est Christus in semetipso,
Ex his colligitur esse sacrificium & dici quod agitur in altari, & Christum semel oblatū & quotidie offerri, sed aliter tunc, aliter munc•et etiam quae sit virtus huius sacramenti ostenditur: remissio scilicet peccatorum venalium, & perfectio virtutis. The English hereof is this. After this it is asked whether that the Priest doth, may be said properly a sacrifice or immolation: and whether Christ be daily immolate or only once? Whereunto it may be shortly answered, that which is offered and consecrate of the priest, is called a sacrifice and oblation, because it is a memory and representation of the true sacrifice and holy immolation done in the altar of the cross. And Christ was once dead on the cross, and there was ⟨p. 384⟩offered in himself, but he is daily immolate in the sacrament, because in the sacrament there is made a memory of that is once done. Whereupon S. Augustine. We are assured that christ rising from death dieth not now, &c. Yet least we should forget that is once done, in our memory every year is done, videl, as often as the pascha, is celebrate, is Christ as often killed? only a yearly remembrance, representeth that was §3once done, and so causeth us to be moved as though we saw our Lord on the cross. Also Christ was once offered in himself, and is offered daily in the sacrament, which is thus to be understanded, that in open showing of his body and distinction of his men bers he did hang only once upon the cross, offering himself to God the father an host of redemption effectual for them whom he hath predestinate. Also S. Ambrose: In Christ the host was once offered being of power to health, what do we then? do we not offer every day? and if we offer every day, it is done to the remembrance of the death of him, and the host is one, not many. How one and not many? because Christ is once offered, this sacrifice is the example of that, the same, and always the same is offered, therefore this is the same sacrifice. Or else it may be said, because offering is in many places, there be many Christs, which is not so, but one Christ is each where, and here full, and there full, so as that which is offered every where, is one body, and so also one sacrifice: Christ hath offered the host, we do offer the same also now: But what we do, is a remembrance of the sacrifice.
Ex his colligitur esse sacrificium & dici quod agitur in altari, & Christum semel oblatū & quotidie offerri, sed aliter tunc, aliter munc•et etiam quae sit virtus huius sacramenti ostenditur: remissio scilicet peccatorum venalium, & perfectio virtutis. The English hereof is this. After this it is asked whether that the Priest doth, may be sayd properly a sacrifice or immolation: and whether Christ be dayly immolate or onely once? Whereunto it may be shortlye aunswered, that which is offered and consecrate of the priest, is called a sacrifice and oblation, because it is a memory and representation of the true sacrifice and holye immolation done in the aultar of the crosse. And Christ was once dead on the crosse, and there was
Nor there is no cause found of the own invalidity, because it profiteth the man, but of us, because we daily sin: Hereof it is gathered that to be a sacrifice and to be so called that is done in the alter, and Christ to be once offered and daily offered, but otherwise then, and otherwise now, and also it is showed what is the virtue of this Sacrament, that is to say, remission of venial §4sin and perfection of virtue.
Nor there is no cause found of the owne inualidity, because it perfiteth the man, but of vs, because we dayly sinne: Hereof it is gathered that to be a sacrifice and to be so called that is done in the alter, and Christ to be once offered and dayly offered, but otherwise then, and otherwise now, and also it is shewed what is the vertue of this Sacrament, that is to say, remission of veniall §4sinne and perfection of vertue.
Thus writeth Petrus Lombardus, whose judgement because this author alloweth, he must grant that the visible church hath Priests in ministry, that offer daily Christs most precious body and blood in mystery, and then must it be granted, that Christ §1so offered himself in his supper. For otherwise then he did cannot now be done. And by the judgement of Petrus Lombardus, the same most precious body and blood is offered §3daily, that once suffered and was once shed. And also by the same Petrus judgement, which he confirmeth with the saying of other, this daily offering by the priest is daily offered for sin, not for any imperfection in the first offering, but because we daily fall. And by Petrus judgement appeareth also how the priest hath a special function to make §3this offering, by whose mouth god is prayed unto (as Hesychius saith) to make this sacrifice, which Emissene noteth to be wrought by the great power of the invisible priest. By Petrus Lombardus also, if his judgement be true (as it is in deed, and the author confesseth it so to be) that is done in the altar is not only called a sacrifice, but also is so, & the same that is offered once and daily to be the same but otherwise then and otherwise now. But to the purpose, if the author will stand to the judgement of Petrus Lombardus, all his fifth book of this treaty is clearly defaced. And if he will now call back that again, he might more compendiously do the same in the whole treatise, being so far overseen as he is therein.
Thus writeth Petrus Lombardus, whose iudgement because this author alloweth, he must graunt that the visible church hath Priestes in ministery, that offer dayly Christes most precious body and bloud in mistery, and then must it be graunted, that Christ §1so offered himselfe in his supper. For otherwise then he did cannot now be done. And by the iudgement of Petrus Lombardus, the same most precious body and bloud is offered §3dayly, that once suffered and was once shed. And also by the same Petrus iudgement, which he confirmeth with the saying of other, this dayly offering by the priest is daylye offered for sin, not for any imperfection in the first offering, but because wee daylye fall. And by Petrus iudgement appeareth also how the priest hath a speciall functiō to make §3
How is it possible, to set out more plainly the diversity of the true sacrifice of Christ made upon the altar of the cross (which was the propitiation of sin) from the sacrifice made in the sacrament, then Lombardus hath done in this place? For the one he calleth the true sacrifice,§1 the other he calleth but a memorial or representation thereof, likening the sacrifice made in the lords supper to a years mind or anniversary, whereat is made a memorial of the death of a person, and yet it is not his death indeed. So in the Lords supper according to his commandment we remember his death, preaching and commending the same until his return again at the last day.
HOw is it possible, to set out more playnely the diuersity of the true sacrifice of Christ made vpon the aulter of the crosse (which was the propitiation of sinne) from the sacrifice made in the sacrament, then Lombardus hath done in this place? For the one he calleth the true sacrifice,§1 the other he calleth but a memoriall or representation thereof, likening the sacrifice made in the lordes supper to a yeares mind or anniuersary, wherat is made a memoriall of the death of a person, and yet it is not his death indeed. So in the Lords supper according to his commaundement we remember his death, preaching and commending the same vntill his return agayne at the last day.
And although it be one Christ,1 that died for us, and whose death we remember, yet it is not one sacrifice that he made of himself upon the cross §2and that we make of him upon the alter or table. For his sacrifice was the redemption of the world, ours is not so: his was death, ours is but a remembrance thereof. His was the taking away the shines of the world, ours is a praising and thanking for the same, and therefore his was satisfactory, ours is gratulatory. It is but one christ that was offered then & that is offered now, yet the offerings be divers, his was the thing, and ours is the figure. His was the original and ours is as it were a pattern. Therefore concludeth Lombardus, that Christ was otherwise offered then and otherwise now. And seeing then that the offerings and sacrifices be divers, if the first was propitiatory and satisfactory, ours cannot be so, except we shall make many sacrifices propitiatory. And then as S. Paul reasoneth, either the first must be insufficient, or the other in vain.2 And as Christ only made this propitiatory sacrifice, so he made but one, and but once. For the making of any other, or of the same again, should have been (as S. Paul reasoneth) a reproving of the first, as unperfect and insufficient.3 And therefore at his last supper although Christ made unto his father sacrifices of lauds and thanksgiving (as these words [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew] do declare) yet he made there no sacrifice propitiatory, for then either the sacrifice upon the cross had been void, or the sacrifice at the supper unperfect, and unsufficient. And although he had at his supper made sacrifices propitiatory, yet the priests do not so, who do not the same that Christ did at his supper. For he ministered not the sacrament in remembrance of his death (which was not then brought to pass) but he ordained it to be ministered of us in remembrance thereof. And therefore our offering after Lombardus judgement, is but & remembrance of that true offering wherein Christ offered himself upon the cross. And so did Christ institute it to be.
And although it be one Christ,1
And Lombardus saith not that Christ is daily offered for proportion of our sins,1 but because we daily sin, we daily be put in the remembrance §3of Christs death, which is the perfect proportion for sin. And the priest (as Lombardus saith) maketh a memorial of that oblation of Christ, and (as Hesechius saith) he doth in the name of the people, so that the sacrifice is no more the priests then the peoples. For the priests speak the words, and the people should answer (amen) as Justinus saith. The priest should declare the death and passion of Christ, and all the people should look upon the cross in the mount of Calvary, & see Christ there hanging, and the blood flowing out of his side into their wounds to heal all their sores, and the priest and people altogether should laud and thank instantly the Chirurgeon and Physician of their souls. And this is the priests and peoples sacrifice, not to be propitiators for sin, (but as Emissene saith) to worship continually in mystery, that was but once offered for the price of sin: and this shortly is the mind of Lombardus, that the thing which is done at gods board is a sacrifice, & so is that also which was made upon the cross, but not after one manner of understanding. For this was the thing in deed, and that is the anniversary or commemoration of the thing.
And Lombardus sayth not that Christ is dayly offered for proportion of our sinnes,1 but because we dayly sinne, wee dayly bee put in the remembraunce §3of Christes death, which is the perfect proportion for sinne. And the priest (as Lombardus sayth) maketh a memoriall of that oblation of Christ, and (as Hesechius sayth) he doth in the name of the people, so that the sacrifice is no more the priestes then the peoples. For the priestes speak the wordes, and the people should aunswere (amen) as Iustinus sayth. The priest should declare the death and passion of Christ, and all the people should looke vpon the crosse in the mount of Caluary, & see Christ there hanging, and the bloud flowing out of his side into theyr wounds to heale all their sores, and the priest and people altogether should laud and thanke instantly the Chyrurgion and Phiscycion of their soules. And this is the priestes and peoples sacrifice, not to be propitiators for sinne, (but as Emissene sayth) to worship continually in mistery, that was but once offered for the price of sinne: and this shortly is the mind of Lombardus, that the thing which is done at gods boord is a sacrifice, & so is that also which was made vpon the crosse, but not after one manner of vnderstanding. For this was the thing in deed, and that is the anniuersary or commemoration of the thing.
And now have I made it evident, that Petrus Lombardus defaceth in no point my saying of the sacrifice, but confirmeth fully my doctrine, aswell ⟨p. 386⟩of the sacrifice propitiatory made by Christ himself only, as of the sacrifice commemorative and gratulatory made by the priests and people. So that in your issue taken upon Lombard, the verdict cannot but pass with me, by the testimony of Lombard himself. And yet I do not fully allow Lombards judgement in all matters (who with Gratian his brother as it is said) were ij. chief champions of the Romish sea, to spread abroad their errors and usurped authority) but I speak of Lombard only to declare that yet in his time they had not cited so far, to make of their was a sacrifice propitiatory. But in the end of this process Lombard speaketh with §4out the book, when he concludeth this matter thus: that the virtue of this sacrament is the remission of venial sin, and perfection of virtue, which if Lombard understand of the sacrifice of Christ, it is to little, to make his sacrifice the remission but of venial sin: And if he understand it of the sacrifice of the priest, it is to much to make the priests sacrifice, either the perfection of virtue, or the remission of venial sin, which be the effects only of the sacrifice of Christ. Now let us consider the rest of your confutation.
And now haue I made it euident, that Petrus Lombardus defaceth in no poynt my saying of the sacrifice, but confirmeth fully my doctrine, aswell ⟨p. 386⟩of the sacrifice propitiatory made by Christ himselfe onely, as of the sacrifice cōmemoratiue and gratulatory made by the preists and people. So that in your issue taken vpon Lombard, the verdit cannot but passe wyth me, by the testimony of Lombard himselfe. And yet I do not fully allow Lombardes iudgement in all matters (who with Gratian his brother as it is sayd) were ij. chiefe champiōs of the Romish sea, to spread abroad their errours and vsurped authority) but I speake of Lombard onely to declare that yet in his tyme they had not cited so farre, to make of theyr was a sacrifice propitiatory. But in the end of this processe Lōbard speaketh with §4out the booke, when he concludeth this matter thus: that the virtue of this sacrament is the remission of veniall sin, and perfection of vertue, which if Lombard vnderstand of the sacrifice of Christ, it is to little, to make hys sacrifice the remission but of veniall sin: And if he vnderstand it of the sacrifice of the priest, it is to much to make the priests sacrifice, either the perfection of vertue, or the remission of veniall sinne, which be the effects onely of the sacrifice of Christ. Now let vs consider the rest of your confutation.
The catholic doctrine teacheth not the daily sacrifice of Christs most precious body §2and blood to be an iteration of the once perfected sacrifice on the cross, but a sacrifice that representeth that sacrifice, and showeth it also before the faithful eyes and refresheth the effectual memory of it, so as in the daily sacrifice without shedding of blood, we may see with the eye of faith the very body and blood of Christ by Gods mighty power,§3 without division distinctly exhibits, the same body and blood that suffered and was §4shed for us, which is a timely memorial to stir up our faith and to consider therein briefly the great charity of God towards us declared in Christ. The catholic doctrine teacheth the daily sacrifice to be in the same in essence that was offered on the cross once, assured §1thereof by Christs words when he said: This is my body that shall be betrayed for you. The offering on the cross was and is propitiatory and satisfactory for our redemption and remission of sin whereby to destroy the tyranny of sin, the effect whereof is given and dispensed in the sacrament of baptism, once likewise ministered and never to be iterate, no more then Christ can be crucified again and yet by virtue of the same offering §5such as fall be relieved in the sacrament of penance.
The catholicke doctrine teacheth not the daily sacrifice of Christes most precious body §2and bloud to be an iteration of the once perfited sacrifice on the crosse, but a sacrifice that representeth that sacrifice, and sheweth it also before the faythfull eyes and refresheth the effectuall memory of it, so as in the dayly sacrifice without shedding of bloud, we may sée with the eye of fayth the very body and bloud of Christ by Gods mighty power,§3 without diuision distinctly exhibits, the same body and bloud that suffered and was §4shed for vs, which is a timely memoriall to stir vp our fayth and to consider therin briefly the great charity of God towardes vs declared in Christ. The catholick doctrine teacheth the dayly sacrifice to be in the same in essence that was offered on the crosse once, assured
After you wilful wrangling without any cause at the last of your own swing you come to the truth (purely and sincerely professing and setting forth the same) except in few words here and there cast in, as it were cockle among clean corn. The offering on the cross (say you) was §1and is propitiatory and satisfactory for our redemption and remission of sin, the effect whereof is given and dispensed in the sacrament of baptism once likewise ministered and never to be iterate, but the catholic doctrine teacheth not that the daily sacrifice is an iteration of the once perfected sacrifice §2on the cross, but a representation thereof, showing it before the faith full eyes, and refreshing our memory therewith, so that we may see with the eye of faith the very body and blood of Christ, by gods mighty power exhibit unto us, the same body and blood that suffered and was shed for us, This is a godly and catholic doctrine, but of the cockle (which you cast in by the way) of distinction without division, I cannot tell what you mean, except you speak out your dreams more plainly. And that it is §3the same body in substance, that is daily (as it were) offered by remembrance,§4 ⟨p. 387⟩which was once offered in the Cross for sin, we learn not so plainly by these words, This is my body, Hoc. est corpus meum, 1as we do by these: Hic Jesus assumptus est in coelum, and Qui descendit, ipse est & qui ascendit suprae omnes coelos: 2This Jesus was taken up into heaven, and he that descended was the same Jesus that ascended above all the heavens.
After you wilfull wrangling without any cause at the last of your own swing you come to the truth (purely and sincerely professing and setting forth the same) except in few wordes here and there cast in, as it were cockle among cleane corne. The offering on the crosse (say you) was §1and is propitiatory and satisfactory for our redemption and remission of sin, the effect whereof is geuen and dispensed in the sacrament of baptisme once likewise ministred and neuer to be iterate, but the catholick doctrine teacheth not that the dayly sacrifice is an iteration of the once perfited sacrifice
And where you say that by virtue of Christs sacrifice such as fall be relieved in the Sacrament of penance,1 the truth is, that such as do fall be relieved by Christ, when so ever they return to him unfeignedly with hart and mind. And as for your words concerning the Sacrament of penance, may have a Popish understanding in it. But at length you return to your former error, and go about to revoke, or at the least, evil favouredly to expound, that which you have before well spoken. Your words be these.
And where you say that by vertue of Christes sacrifice such as fal be releued in the Sacrament of penaunce,1 the truth is, that such as do fall be releued by Christ, when so euer they returne to him vnfaynedly with hart and mynde. And as for your wordes concernyng the Sacrament of penaunce, may haue a Popishe vnderstandyng in it. But at length you returne to your former errour, and goe about to reuoke, or at the least, euill fauoredly to expounde, that which you haue before well spoken. Your wordes be these.
The daily offering is propitiatory also,1 but not in that degree of propitiation: As for redemption, regeneration or remission of deadly sin, which was once purchased, & by force thereof is in the Sacraments ministered, but for the increase of Gods favour the mitigation of Gods displeasure provoked by our infirmities, the subduing of temptations and the perfection of virtue in us. All good works, good thoughts and good meditations may be called sacrifices,2 and the same be called sacrifices propitiatory also, for so much as in their degree God accepteth and taketh them through the effect and strength of the very sacrifice of Christs death, which is the reconciliation between God and man, ministered & dispensed particularly as God hath appointed, in such measure as he knoweth. §2But S. Paul to the Hebrews exhorting men to charitable deeds saith: with such sacrifices God is made favourable, or God is propitiate, if we shall make new English. Whereupon it followeth, because the Priest in the daily sacrifice doth as Christ hath ordered to be done for she wing forth and remembrance of Christs death, that act of the Priest done according to Gods commandment, must needs be propitiatory and provoke Gods favour, and ought to be trusted on to have a propitiatory effect with God to the members of Christs body particularly, being the same done for the whole body, in such wise as God knoweth the dispensation to be meet & convenient, according to which measure, God worketh most justly and most mercifully, otherwise then man can by his §3judgement discuss & determine.3 To call the daily offering a sacrifice satisfactory, must have an understanding that signifieth not the action of the Priest, but the presence of Christs most precious body and blood the very sacrifice of the world once perfectly offered being propitiatory and satisfactory for all the world, or else the word satisfactory must have a signification and meaning, as it hath sometime that declareth the acceptation of the thing done, and not the proper countervail of the action, after which sort man may satisfy God that is so merciful as he will take in good worth for Christs sake mans imperfect endeavour, and so the daily offering may be called a sacrifice satisfactory, because God is pleased with it, being a manner of worshipping of Christs passion according to his institution.
But otherwise the daily sacrifice in respect of the action of the Priest called satisfactory, and it is a word in deed that soundeth not well so placed, although it might be saved by a signification, and therefore think that word rather to be well expounded, then by captious understanding brought in slander when it is used, and this speech to be frequented that the only immolation of Christ in him self upon the altar of the Cross is the very satisfactory Sacrifice for reconciliation of mankind to the favour §4of God. And I have read the daily sacrifice of Christs most precious body to be called a Sacrifice satisfactory, but this speech hath in deed been used, that the Priest §5should sing satisfactory, which they understood in the satisfaction of the Priests duty, to attend he prayer the was required to make, and for a distinction thereof they had prayer sometime required without special limitation, and that was called to pray not satisfactory. ⟨p. 388⟩Finally in man by any his action to presume to satisfy God by way of countervail, is a very mad and furious blasphemy.
But otherwise the dayly sacrifice in respect of the action of the Priest called satisfactorie, and it is a word in déede that soundeth not well so placed, although it might be saued by a signification, and therfore thinke that word rather to be well expounded, then by captious vnderstandyng brought in slaunder when it is vsed, and this speach to be frequented that the onely immolat•on of Christ in him selfe vpon the aultar of the Crosse is the very satisfactorie Sacrifice for reconciliation of mankynde to the fauour §4of God. And I haue read the dayly sacrifice of Christes most precious body to be called a Sacrifice satisfactorie, but this speach hath in déede bene vsed, that the Priest §5should sing satisfactorie, which they vnderstode in the satisfaction of the Priestes duety, to attend he prayer the was required to make, and for a distinction therof they had prayer sometyme required without speciall limitation, and that was called to pray not satisfactorie. ⟨p. 388⟩
TO defend the Papistical error, that the daily offering of the Priest §1in the Mass is propitiatory, you extend the word Propitiation other wise then the Apostles do, speaking of that matter. I speak plainly (according to S. Paul and S. John) that only Christ is the propitiation for our sins by his death.1 You speak according to the Papists, that the Priests in their Masses make a sacrifice propitiatory. I call a sacrifice propitiatory (according to the Scripture) such a sacrifice as pacifieth Gods indignation against us, obtaineth mercy and forgiveness of all our sins, and is our ransom and redemption from everlasting damnation. And on the other side I call a sacrifice gratificatory of the sacrifice of the Church, such a sacrifice as doth not reconcile us to God, but is made of them that be reconciled to testify their duties, and to show them selves thankful unto him. And these sacrifices in Scripture be not called propitiatory, but sacrifices of Justice, of laud, praise and thanks giving. But you confound the words,2 and call one by an others name, calling that propitiatory which the Scripture calleth but of Justice, laud and thanking. And all is nothing else but to defend your propitiatory sacrifice of the Priests in their Masses, whereby they may remit sin, and redeem souls out of Purgatory.
TO defend the Papisticall errour, that the dayly offering of the Priest §1in the Masse is propitiatory, you extend the word Propitiation other wise then the Apostles do, speakyng of that matter. I speake playnly (accordyng to S. Paule and S. Iohn) that onely Christ is the propitiation for our sinnes by his death.1 You speake accordyng to the Papistes, that the Priestes in their Masses make a sacrifice propitiatory. I call a sacrifice propitiatory (accordyng to the Scripture) such a sacrifice as pacifieth Gods indignation agaynst vs, obteineth mercy and forgiuenes of all our sinnes, and is our raunsome and redemption from euerlastyng damnation. And on the other side I call a sacrifice gratificatory of the sacrifice of the Church, such a sacrifice as doth not reconcile vs to God, but is made of them that be reconciled to testifie their dueties, and to shewe them selues thankefull vnto him. And these sacrifices in Scripture be not called propitiatory, but sacrifices of Iustice, of laude, prayse and thankes geuyng. But you confounde the wordes,
And yet all your wiles and shifts will not serve you, for by extending the name of a propitiatory sacrifice unto so large a signification as you do, you make all manner of Sacrifices propitiatory, leaving no place for any other sacrifice. For (say you) all good deeds and good thoughts be Sacrifices propitiatory, and then be the good works of the lay people Sacrifices propitiatory, as well as those of the Priest. And to what purpose then made you in the beginning of this book a distinction between sacrifices propitiatory and other? Thus for desire you have to defend the Papistical errors, you have not fallen only into imaginations contrary to the truth of Gods word, but also contrary to your self.
And yet all your wyles and shiftes will not serue you, for by extendyng the name of a propitiatory sacrifice vnto so large a signification as you do, you make all maner of Sacrifices propitiatory, leauyng no place for any other sacrifice. For (say you) all good deedes and good thoughtes be Sacrifices propitiatorie, and then be the good workes of the lay people Sacrifices propitiatorie, as well as those of the Priest. And to what purpose then made you in the begynnyng of this booke a distinction betwene sacrifices propitiatorie and other? Thus for desire you haue to defend the Papisticall errours, you haue not fallen onely into imaginations contrary to the truth of Gods word, but also contrary to your selfe.
But let pass away these Papistical inventions, and let us humbly profess ourselves with all our Sacrifices, not worthy to approach unto God, nor to have any access unto him, but by that only propitiatory sacrifice, which Christ only made upon the Cross. And yet let us with all devotion, with whole hart and mind, and with all obedience to Gods will, come unto the heavenly Supper of Christ, thanking him only for propitiation of our sins. In which holy Communion the act of the Minister and other be all of one sort, none propitiatory, but all of lauds and thanks giving. And such sacrifices be pleasant and acceptable to God (as S. Paul saith) done of them that be good,1 but they win not his §2favour, and put away his indignation from them that be evil. For such reconciliation can no creature make but Christ alone.
But let passe away these Papisticall inuentions, and let vs humbly professe ourselues with all our Sacrifices, not worthy to approche vnto God, nor to haue any accesse vnto him, but by that onely propitiatorie sacrifice, which Christ onely made vpon the Crosse. And yet let vs with all deuotion, with whole hart and mynde, and with all obedience to Gods will, come vnto the heauenly Supper of Christ, thankyng him onely for propitiation of our sinnes. In which holy Communion the act of the Minister and other be all of one sort, none propitiatorie, but all of laudes and thankes geuyng. And such sacrifices be pleasaunt and acceptable to God (as S. Paule sayth) done of them that be good,1 but they winne not his §2fauour, and put away his indignation from them that be euill. For such reconciliation can no creature make but Christ alone.
And where you say, that to call the daily offering a sacrifice satisfactory,§3 must have an understanding that signifieth not the action of the priest: here you may see what a business and hard work it is, to patch the Papists rags together, and what absurdities you fall into thereby. Even ⟨p. 392⟩now you said, that the act of the Priests must needs be a Sacrifice propitiatory, and now to have an understanding for the same; you be driven to so shameful a shift, that you say either clean contrary that it is not the action of the Priest but the presence of Christ, or else that the action of the Priest is none otherwise satisfactory then all other Christen mens works be. For otherwise (say you) the daily Sacrifice in respect of the action of the Priest, can not be called satisfactory. Wherefore at length, knowledgyng your Popish doctrine to sound evil favouredly, you confess again the true Catholic teaching, that this speech is to be frequented and used, that the only immolation of Christ in him self upon the altar of the Cross, is the very satisfactory Sacrifice for reconciliation of mankind to the favour of God.
And where you say, that to call the dayly offeryng a sacrifice satisfactorie,§3 must haue an vnderstādyng that signifieth not the action of the priest: here you may see what a businesse and hard worke it is, to patch the Papistes ragges together, and what absurdities you fall into thereby. Euen ⟨p. 392⟩now you sayd, that the acte of the Priestes must needes bee a Sacrifice propitiatorie, and now to haue an vnderstandyng for the same; you bee driuen to so shamefull a shift, that you say either cleane contrary that it is not the action of the Priest but the presence of Christ, or els that the action of the Priest is none otherwise satisfactorie then all other Christen mens workes be. For otherwise (say you) the dayly Sacrifice in respect of the action of the Priest, can not be called satisfactorie. Wherefore at length, knowledgyng your Popish doctrine to sound euill fauoredly, you confesse agayne the true Catholicke teachyng, that this speach is to be frequented and vsed, that the onely immolation of Christ in him selfe vpon the aultar of the Crosse, is the very satisfactorie Sacrifice for reconciliation of mankynde to the fauour of God.
And where you say, that you have not read the daily sacrifice of Christs most precious body to be called a sacrifice satisfactory: if you have not read of satisfactory Masses, it appeareth that you have read but very little of the School Authors. And yet not many years ago, you might have heard them preached in every pardon. But because you have not read thereof, read Doctor Smiths book of the sacrifice of the Mass, and both your ears and eyes shall be full of it. Whose furious blasphemies you have with one sentence here most truly rejected, wherefore yet remaineth in you some good sparks of the spirit, that you so much detest such abomination.
And where you say, that you haue not read the dayly sacrifice of Christs most precious body to be called a sacrifice satisfactory: if you haue not read of satisfactory Masses, it appeareth that you haue read but very little of the Schoole Authours. And yet not many yeares agoe, you might haue heard them preached in euery pardon. But because you haue not read therof, read Doctour Smithes booke of the sacrifice of the Masse, and both your eares and eyes shalbe full of it. Whose furious blasphemies you haue with one sentēce here most truely reiected, wherfore yet remaineth in you some good sparkes of the spirit, that you so much detest such abhominatiō.
And yet such blasphemies you go about to salve and plaster,1 as much as you may, by subtle and crafty interpretations. For by such exposition as you make of the satisfactory singing of the Priest, in doing his duty in that he was required to do, by this exposition he singeth aswell satisfactory in saying of Matins as in saying of Mass (for in both he doth his duty that he required unto) and so might it be defended that the Player upon the Organs playeth satisfactory, when he doth his duty, in playing as he is required. And all the singing men in the Church that have wages thereto, sing satisfactory aswell as the Priests, when they sing according to that they be hired unto. And then as one singing man or player on the Organs, receiving a stipend of many men to play or sing at a certain time if he do his duty, satisfieth them all at once, so might a priest sing satisfactory for many persons at one time, which the teachers of satisfactory Masses utterly condemn. But if you had read Duns, you would have written more Clerkly in these matters, then you now do. Now let us hear what you say further.
And yet such blasphemies you go about to salue and playster,1 as much as you may, by subtle and crafty interpretations. For by such exposition as you make of the satisfactory singyng of the Priest, in doyng his duetie in that he was required to do, by this exposition he singeth aswell satisfactory in saying of Mattens as in saying of Masse (for in both he doth his duetie that he required vnto) and so might it be defended that the Player vpon the Orgaines playeth satisfactory, when he doth his duety, in playing as he is required. And all the singyng men in the Church that haue wages thereto, sing satisfactory aswell as the Priestes, when they sing accordyng to that they be hyered vnto. And then as one singyng man or player on the Orgaines, receauyng a stipende of many men to play or sing at a certaine tyme if he do his duety, satisfieth them all at once, so might a priest sing satisfactory for many persons at one tyme, which the teachers of satisfactory Masses vtterly condemne. But if you had read Duns, you would haue written more Clerkely in these matters, then you now do. Now let vs heare what you say further.
Where the Author citing S. Paul Englisheth him thus, that Christs Priesthood can not pass from him to an other. These words thus framed be not the simple and sincere expression of the truth of the text. Which saith, that Christ hath a perpetual Priesthood, and the Greek hath a word ([Greek or Hebrew]) which the Greek Schools express and expound by the word ([Greek or Hebrew]) signifying the Priesthood of Christ endeth not in him to go to an other by succession as in the tribe of Levi, where was among mortal men succession in the office of Priesthood, but Christ liveth ever, and therefore is a perpetual everlasting Priest, by whose authority Priesthood is now in this visible Church as S. Paul ordered to Timothy and Tite, and other places also confirm, which Priests visible Ministers to our invisible Priest offer the daily Sacrifice in Christs Church,1 that is to say, with the very presence by Gods omnipotency wrought of the most precious ⟨p. 390⟩body and blood of our Saviour Christ, showing forth Christs death, and celebrating the memory of his Supper and death according to Christs institution, so with daily oblation and sacrifice of the self same Sacrifice, to kindle in us a thankful remembrance §2of all Christs benefits unto us.
Where the Authour cityng S. Paul Englisheth him thus, that Christes Priesthode can not passe from him to an other. These wordes thus framed be not the simple and sincere expression of the truth of the text. Whiche sayth, that Christ hath a perpetuall Priesthode, and the Gréeke hath a word (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) which the Gréek Schooles expresse and expounde by the word (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) signifiyng the Priesthode of Christ endeth not in him to go to an other by succession as in the tribe of Leui, wher was amōg mortal men succession in the office of Priesthode, but Christ liueth euer, and therfore is a perpetuall euerlastyng Priest, by whose authoritie Priesthode is now in this visible Church as S. Paule ordered to Timothe and Tite, and other places also confirme, which Priestes visible Ministers to our inuisible Priest offer the dayly Sacrifice in Christes Churche,1
The dayly offeryng is propitiatory also,1 but not in that degrée of propitiation: As for redemption, regeneration or remission of deadly sinne, which was once purchased, & by force therof is in the Sacramentes ministred, but for the increase of Gods fauour the mitigation of Gods displeasure prouoked by our infirmities, the subduyng of temptations and the perfection of vertue in vs. All good workes, good thoughtes and good meditations may be called sacrifices,2 and the same be called sacrifices propitiatorie also, for so much as in their degrée God accepteth and taketh them through the effect and strength of the very sacrifice of Christes death, which is the reconciliation betwene God and mā, ministred & dispensed particularly as God hath appointed, in such measure as he knoweth. §2But S. Paule to the Hebrues exhortyng men to charitable déedes sayth: with such sacrifices God is made fauorable, or God is propitiate, if we shall make new Englishe. Whereupon it foloweth, bycause the Priest in the dayly sacrifice doth as Christ hath ordered to be done for she wyng forth and remembraunce of Christes death, that act of the Priest done accordyng to Gods commaundement, must néedes be propitiatory and prouoke Gods fauour, and ought to be trusted on to haue a propitiatory effect with God to the members of Christes body particularly, beyng the same done for the whole body, in such wise as God knoweth the dispēsation to be méete & conuenient, accordyng to which measure, God worketh most iustly and most mercyfully, otherwise then man can by his §3iudgement discusse & determine.3 To call the dayly offeryng a sacrifice satisfactory, must haue an vnderstandyng that signifieth not the action of the Priest, but the presence of Christes most precious body and bloud the very sacrifice of the world once perfectly offered beyng propitiatorie and satisfactorie for all the world, or els the worde satisfactorie must haue a signification and meanyng, as it hath sometyme that declareth the acceptation of the thyng done, and not the propre contreuaile of the action, after which sort man may satisfie God that is so mercyfull as he will take in good worth for Christes sake mās imperfect endeuour, and so the dayly offering may be called a sacrifice satisfactory, bicause God is pleased with it, beyng a maner of worshyppyng of Christes passion accordyng to his institution.