pp. 3941,982 passagespart 5 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
First, in the sixth of John, when Christ had taught of the eating of him, being the bread §6descended from heaven, and declaring that eating to signify believing, whereat was no §7murmuring, that then he should enter to speak of giving of his flesh to be eaten, and his blood to be drunken, and to say that he would give a bread, that is, his flesh which he would give for the life of the world. In which words Christ maketh mention of two gifts. and therefore as he is truth, must needs intend to fulfil them both. And therefore as we believe the gift of his flesh to the Jews to be crucified: so we must believe the gift of his flesh to be eaten, and of that gift, livery, and seisin (as we say) to be made of him, that is in his promises faithful (as Christ is) to be made in both. And therefore when he said in §8his Supper: Take, eat, this is my body, he must needs intend plainly as his words of promise required: And these words in his Supper purport to give as really then his body to be eaten of us, as he gave his body in deed to be crucified for us, aptly nevertheless, and conveniently for each effect, and therefore in manner of giving diversly, but in the substance of the same given, to be as his words bear witness, the same, and therefore said: this is my body that shall be betrayed for you, expressing also the use, when he said: take, eat, which words, in delivering of material bread, had been superfluous: for what should men do with bread when they take it, but eat it, specially when it is broken.
First, in the sixt of Iohn, when Christ had taught of the eating of him, being the bread §6descended from heauen, and declaring that eating to signifie beleeuing, whereat was no §7murmuring, that then he should enter to speak of geuing of his flesh to be eaten, and his bloud to be dronken, and to say yt he would geue a bread, that is, his flesh which he would geue for the life of the world. In which wordes Christ maketh mention of two giftes. and therfore as he is truth, must needes intend to fulfill them both. And therefore as we beleeue the gift of his flesh to the Iewes to be crucified: so we must beléeue the gift of his flesh to be eaten, and of that gifte, liuery, and seisme (as we say) to be made of him, that is in his promises faithfull (as Christ is) to be made in both. And therefore when he sayd in §8his Supper: Take, eate, this is my body, he must néedes intend plainly as his words of promise required: And these wordes in his Supper purporte to geue as really then his body to be eaten of vs, as he gaue his body in deede to be crucified for vs, aptly neuerthelesse, and conueniently for ech effect, and therefore in maner of geuing diuersly, but in the substance of the same geuen, to be as his wordes beare witnes, the same, and therefore sayd: this is my body yt shalbe betraied for you, expressing also the vse, when he said: take, eate, which words, in deliuering of material bread, had béen superfluous: for what should men doe with bread when they take it, but eate it, specially when it is broaken.
But as Cyril saith: Christ opened there unto them the practise of that doctrine he spake of in the sixth of S. John, and because he said he would give his flesh for food, which he would give for the life of the world, he for fulfilling of his promise, said: Take, eat, this is my body, which words have been taught and believed to be of effect, and operatory, and Christ under the form of bread to have been his very body. According whereunto S. Paul noteth the receiver to be guilty, when he doth not esteem it our Lords body, wherewith it pleaseth Christ to feed such as be in him regenerate, to the intent that as man was redeemed by Christ, suffering in the nature of his humanity: so to purchase for man the kingdom of heaven, lost by Adams fall. Even likewise in the nature of the same humanity, giving it to be eaten, he ordained it to nourish man, and make him strong to walk, and continue his journey, to enjoy that kingdom. And therefore to set forth lively unto us the communication of the substance of Christs most precious body in the Sacrament, and the same to be in deed delivered, Christ used plain words, testified by the Evangelists. Saint Paul also rehearsed the same words in the same plain terms in the eleventh to the Corinthians, and in the tenth, giving (as it were) an exposition of the effect, useth the same proper words, declaring the effect to be the communication of Christs body and blood. And one thing is notable touching the Scripture, that §01in such notable speeches uttered by Christ, as might have an ambiguity, the Evangelists by some circumstance declared it, or sometime opened it by plain interpretation: as when Christ said he would dissolve the temple, and within three days build it again. The Evangelist by and by addeth for interpretation: This he said of the temple of his body. And when Christ said, he is Elijah, and I am the true vine: The circumstance of the text openeth the ambiguity.
But as Cyrill sayth: Christ opened there vnto them the practise of that doctrine hée spake of in the sixt of S. Iohn, and because he sayd he would geue his flesh for food, which he would geue for the life of the world, he for fulfilling of his promise, sayd: Take, eate, this is my body, which wordes haue béen taught and beléeued to be of effect, and operatory, and Christ vnder the forme of bread to haue béen his very body. According whereunto S. Paule noteth the receauer to be gilty, when he doth not estéeme it our Lordes body, wherewith it pleaseth Christ to féede such as be in him regenerate, to the intent that as man was redéemed by Christ, suffering in the nature of his humanitie: so to purchase for man the kingdome of heauen, lost by Adams fall. Euen likewise in the nature of the same humanitye, geuing it to be eaten, he ordayned it to nourish man, and make him strong to walke, and continue his iorney, to enioy that kingdome. And therefore to set forth liuely vnto vs the communication of the substance of Christes most precious body in the Sacrament, and the same to be in déede deliuered, Christ vsed playn wordes, testified by the Euangelistes. Saint Paule also rehearsed the same wordes in the same plain termes in the eleuenth to the Corinthians, and in the tenth, geuing (as it were) an exposition of the effect, vseth the same proper wordes, declaring the effect to be the communication of Christes body and bloud. And one thing is notable touching the Scripture, that
But to show that Christ should not mean of his very body when he so spake.1 Neither S. Paul after, ne the Evangelists in the place, add any words or circumstances, whereby to take away the proper signification of the words (body) and (blood) so as the same might seem not in deed given (as the catholic faith teacheth) but in signification as the author would have it. For as for the words of Christ (the Spirit giveth life, the flesh profiteth nothing) be to declare the two natures in Christ, each in their property a part considered, but not as they be in Christs person united, the mystery of which union, such as believed not Christ to be God, could not consider, and yet to insinuate that unto them, Christ made mention of his descension from heaven, and after of his ascension thither ⟨p. 28⟩again, whereby they might understand him very God, whose flesh taken in the virgins womb, and so given spiritually to be eaten of us, is (as I have before opened) vivific, and giveth life.
But to shew that Christ should not mean of his very body when he so spake.1 Neither S. Paule after, ne the Euangelistes in the place, adde any wordes or circumstaunces, whereby to take away the proper signification of the wordes (body) and (bloud) so as the same might seeme not in déede geuen (as the catholicke faith teacheth) but in signification as the author would haue it. For as for the wordes of Christ (the Spirite geueth life, the flesh profiteth nothing) be to declare the two natures in Christ, ech in their property a part considered, but not as they be in Christs person vnited, the mistery of which vniō, such as beléeued not Christ to be God, could not consider, and yet to insinuate that vnto them, Christ made mention of his descention from heauen, and after of his ascension thether ⟨p. 28⟩agayn, whereby they might vnderstand him very God, whose flesh taken in the virgins wombe, and so geuen spiritually to be eaten of vs, is (as I haue before opened) viuifike, and geueth life.
And this shall suffice here to show how Christs intent was to give verily (as he did in deed) his precious body and blood to be eaten and drunken, according as he taught them §11to be verily meat and drink, and yet gave and giveth them so under form of visible creatures to us, as we may conveniently and without horror of our nature receive them, Christ therein condescending to our infirmity. As for such other wrangling as is made in understanding of the words of Christ, shall after he spoken of by further occasion.
And this shall suffice here to shew how Christes intent was to geue verely (as he did in déede) his precious body and bloud to be eaten and dronken, according as he taught thē §11to be verely meate and drinke, and yet gaue and geueth them so vnder forme of visible creatures to vs, as we may conueniētly and without horror of our nature receaue them, Christ therein condescending to our infirmity. As for such other wrangling as is made in vnderstanding of the words of Christ, shall after he spoaken of by further occasion.
1Now we be come to the very pith of the matter, and the chief point whereupon the whole controversy hangeth, whether in these words, this is my body: Christ called bread his body, wherein you and Smith agree like a man and a woman that dwelled in Lincolnshire (as I have heard reported) that what pleased the one misliked the other, saving that they both agreed in wilfulness.2 So do Smith and you agree both in this point, that Christ made bread his body, but that it was bread which he called his body when he said. This is my body, this you grant, but Smith denieth it. And because all Smiths buildings clearly fall down, if this his chief foundation be overthrown, therefore must I first prove against Smith,3 that Christ called the material bread his body, & the wine which was the fruit of the vine,4 his blood. For why did you not prove this my Lord (saith Smith) would you that men should take you for a prophet, or for one that could not err in his sayings?
1NOw we be come to the very pith of the matter, and the chiefe pointe wherupon the wholl controuersie hangeth, whether in these words, this is my body: Christ called bread his body, wherin you and Smith agree like a man and a woman that dwelled in Lincolnshere (as I haue heard reported) that what pleased the one misliked the other, sauing that they both agreed in wilfulness.2 So do Smith and you agree both in this point, that Christ made bread his body, but yt it was bread which he called his body when he sayd. This is my body, this you graunt, but Smith denieth it. And because all Smithes buildinges cleerely fall downe, if this his chiefe foundation be ouerthrowen, therfore must I first proue against Smith,3 that Christ called the materiall bread his body, & the wine which was the fruite of the vine,4 his bloud. For why did you not prooue this my Lord (sayth Smith) would you that men should take you for a prophet, or for one that could not erre in his sayinges?
First I allege against Smiths negation, your affirmation, which, as it is more true in this point then his negation, so for your estimation it is able to countervail his saying, if there were nothing else: & yet if Smith had well pondered what I have written in the second chap. of my second book, and in the 7. and 8. chapters of my third book, he should have found this matter so fully proved, that he neither is, nor never shall be able to answer thereto. For I have alleged the scripture, I have alleged the consent of the old writers, holy fathers, and martyrs, to prove that Christ called bread his body, and wine his blood. For the Evangelists speaking of the Lords supper,1 say, that he took bread, blessed it, brake it, & gave it to his disciples, saying: This is my body: and of the wine he said: Take this, divide it among you, & drink it: this is my blood. I have alleged Irene,2 saying that Christ confessed bread to be his body, and the cup to be his blood I have cited Tertullian who saith in many places,3 that Christ called bread his body. I have brought in for the same purpose Cyprian,4 who saith that Christ called such bread as is made of many corns joined together, his body: and such wine he named his blood, as is pressed out of many grapes. I have written the words of Epiphanius,5 which be these, that Christ speaking of a loaf which is round in fashion, and can neither see, hear, nor feel, said of it: This is my body. And S. Hierom writing ad Hedibiam, 6sayth that Christ called the bread which he brake, his body. And S. Augustine saith,7 that Jesus called meat, his body, and drink his blood. And Cyril saith more plainly,8 that Christ called the pieces of bread his body. And last of all I brought forth Theodorete,9
Which because they speak the thing so plainly as nothing can be more, and Smith seeth that he can devise nothing to answer these Authors, like a wily fox, he stealeth away by them softly, as he had a flea in his ear saying nothing to all these authors, but that they prove not my purpose. If this be a sufficient answer let the Reader be judge, for in such sort I could make a short answer to Smiths whole book in this one sentence that nothing that he saith proveth his purpose. And as for proofs of his saying, Smith hath utterly none but only this fond reason: That if Christ had called bread his body, then should bread have been crucified for us, because Christ added these words: this is my body, which shall be given to death for you. If such wise reason shall take place, a man may not take a loaf in his hand made of wheat that came out of Danske, and say this is wheat that grew in Danske, but it must follow, that the loaf grew in Danske. And if the wife shall say: this is butter of my own cow, Smith shall prove by this speech that her maid milked butter. But to this fantastical or rather frantic reason, I have spoken more in mine answer to Smiths preface.
Which because they speak the thinge so plainly as nothing can be more, and Smith seeth that he can deuise nothinge to answere these Authors, like a wily fox, he stealeth away by them softly, as he had a flea in his eare saying nothing to all these authors, but that they proue not my purpose. If this be a sufficient answere let the Reader be iudge, for in such sort I could make a short answere to Smithes whol booke in this one sentence that nothing that he sayth proueth his purpose. And as for proofes of his saying, Smith hath vtterly none but onely this fond reason: That if Christ had called bread his body, then should bread haue been crucified for vs, because Christ added these words: this is my body, which shalbe geuē to death for you. If such wise reason shall take place, a man may not take a loafe in his hand made of wheate that came out of Danske, and say this is wheate that grew in Danske, but it must follow, that the loafe grew in Danske. And if the wife shall say: this is butter of my own cow, Smith shall proue by this speach that her mayd milked butter. But to this fantasticall or rather frantike reason, I haue spoaken more in mine aunswere to Smithes preface.
How be it, you have taken a wiser way then this, granting that Christ called bread his body, and wine his blood: but adding thereto, that Christs calling was making. Yet here may they that be wise, learn by the way how evil favouredly you and Smith agree among your selves.
How be it, you haue taken a wiser way then this, graunting that Christ called bread his body, and wine his bloud: but adding thereto, that Christs calling was making. Yet here may they that be wise, learn by ye way how euil fauoredly you and Smith agree among your selues.
And forasmuch as Smith hath not made answer unto the Authors by me alleged in this part, I may justly require that for lack of answer in time and place where he ought to have answered, he may be condemned as one that standeth mute. And being condemned in this his chief demur, he hath after nothing to answer at all. For this foundation being overthrown all the rest falleth down withal.
And forasmuch as Smith hath not made answere vnto the Authors by me alleadged in this parte, I may iustly require that for lacke of answere in time and place where he ought to haue answered, he may be condemned as one that standeth mute. And being condemned in this his chiefe demur, he hath after nothing to answere at al. For this foundation being ouerthrown all the rest falleth down withall.
Wherefore now will I return to answer you in this matter, which is the last of the evident, and manifest untruths, whereof you appeach me.
Wherefore now will I returne to aunswere you in this matter, which is the last of the euident, and manyfest vntruthes, wherof you appeach me.
I perceive here how untoward you be to learn the truth, being brought up all your life in Papistical errors. If you could forget your law, which hath been your chief profession and study from your youth, and specially the Canon law which purposely corrupteth the truth of Gods word you should be much more apt to understand and receive the secretes of holy scripture. But before those scales fall from your sawlish eyes, you neither can, nor will perceive the true doctrine of this holy sacrament of Christs body & blood. But yet I shall do as much as lieth in me, to teach and instruct you, as occasion shall serve, so that the fault shall be either in your evil bringing up altogether in popery, or in your dullness, or frowardness, if you attain not true understanding of this matter.
I perceaue here how vntoward you be to learn the truth, being brought vp all your life in Papisticall errors. If you could forget your law, which hath been your chief profession and study from your youth, and specially the Canon law which purposely corrupteth the truth of Gods word you should be much more apte to vnderstand and receaue the secretes of holy scripture. But before those scales fall from your sawlish eyes, you neither can, nor will perceaue the true doctrine of this holy sacrament of Christes body & bloud. But yet I shall doe as much as lyeth in me, to teach and instruct you, as occasion shall serue, so that the fault shall be either in your euill bringing vp altogether in popery, or in your dulnes, or frowardnes, if you attaine not true vnderstanding of this matter.
Where you speak of the miraculous working of Christ,1 to make bread his body, you must first learn that the bread is not made really Christs body, nor the wine his blood, but sacramentally: And the miraculous working is not in the bread, but in them that duly eat the bread, and drink that drink. For the marvellous work of God is in the feeding, and it is Christen people that be fed, and not the bread.
Where you speake of the miraculous workinge of Christ,1 to make bread his body, you must first learne that the bread is not made really Christes body, nor the wine his bloud, but sacramētally: And the miraculous working is not in the bread, but in them that duely eate the bread, and drink yt drink. For the marueylous worke of God is in the feeding, and it is Christen people that be fed, and not the bread.
And so the true confession and belief of the universal Church, from the ⟨p. 30⟩beginning, is not such as you many times affirm,1 but never can prove: for the Catholic church acknowledgeth no such division between Christs §3holy flesh and his spirit, that life is renewed in us by his holy spirit, and increased by his holy flesh, but the true faith confesseth that both be done by his holy spirit and flesh jointly together, as well the renovation, as the increase of our life. Wherefore you diminish here the effect of baptism, wherein is not given only Christs spirit, but whole Christ. And herein I will join an issue with you.2 And you shall find, that although you think I lack law where with to follow my plea, yet I doubt not but I shall have help of Gods word enough, to make all men perceive that you be but a simple divine, so that for lack of your proofs, I doubt not but the sentence shall be given upon my side by all learned and indifferent judges that understand the matter which is in controversy between us.
And so the true confession and beleefe of the vniuersall Church, from the ⟨p. 30⟩beginning, is not such as you many times affirme,1 but neuer can proue: for the Catholicke church acknowledgeth no such diuision betweene Christes §3holy flesh and his spirite, that life is renued in vs by his holy spirite, and increased by his holy flesh, but the true fayth confesseth that both be done by his holy spirite and flesh iointly together, as well the renouation, as the increace of our life. Wherfore you diminish here the effect of baptisme, wherin is not geuen only Christes spirite, but wholl Christ. And herein I will ioyne an issue with you.2 And you shall finde, that although you thinke I lacke law where with to follow my plea, yet I doubt not but I shall haue helpe of Gods word inough, to make al men perceiue that you be but a simple diuine, so that for lacke of your proofes, I doubt not but the sentence shall be geuen vpon my side by all learned and indifferent iudges that vnderstand the matter which is in controuersy betweene vs.
And where you say that we must repress our thoughts and imaginations,§4 and by reason of Christs omnipotency,1 judge his intent by his will, it is a most certain truth that Gods absolute and determinate will is the chief governor of all things, and the rule whereby all things must be ordered, and thereto obey. But where (I pray you) have you any such will of Christ, that he is really, carnally, corporally, & naturally, under the forms of bread and wine: There is no such will of Christ set forth in the scripture as you pretend by a false understanding of these words, this is my body. Why take you then so boldly upon you, to say that this is Christs will and intent, when you have no warrant in scripture to bear you?
And where you say that we must represse our thoughtes and imaginations,§4 and by reason of Christes omnipotency,1 iudge his intent by his wil, it is a most certayne truth that Gods absolute and determinate wil is the chiefe gouernour of all thinges, and the rule wherby all things must be ordered, and therto obey. But where (I pray you) haue you any such will of Christ, that he is really, carnally, corporally, & naturally, vnder the formes of bread and wine: There is no such will of Christ set forth in the scripture as you pretend by a false vnderstanding of these wordes, this is my body. Why take you then so boldly vpon you, to say that this is Christs will and intent, when you haue no warrant in scripture to beare you?
It is not a sufficient proof in Scripture, to say, God doth it, because he can do it.1 For he can do many things which he neither doth, nor will do. He could have sent moe then twelve Legions of Angels to deliver Christ from the wicked Jews,2 and yet he would not do it. He could have created the world and all things therein, in one moment of time, and yet his pleasure was to do it in six days.
It is not a sufficient proofe in Scripture, to say, God doth it, because he can doe it.1 For hee can doe many thinges which hee neither doth, nor will doe. He could haue sent moe then twelue Legions of Angels to deliuer Christ from the wicked Iewes,2 and yet he would not doe it. He could haue created the world and all thinges therin, in one moment of time, and yet his pleasure was to doe it in sixe dayes.
In all matters of our christen faith, written in holy Scripture, for our instruction and doctrine, how far so ever they seem discrepant from reason, we must repress our imaginations, and consider Gods pleasure and will, and yield thereto, believing him to be omnipotent: And that by his omnipotent power, such things are verily so as holy scripture teacheth. Like as we believe that Christ was borne of the blessed virgin Mary, without company of man: that our Saviour Christ the third day rose again from death: that he in his humanity ascended into heaven: that our bodies at the day of judgement shall rise again, and many other such like things, which we all that be true christen men, do believe firmly, because we find these things written in Scripture. And therefore we (knowing Gods omnipotency) do believe that he hath brought some of the said things to pass already, and those things that are yet to come, he will by the same omnipotency without doubt likewise bring to pass.
In all matters of our christen faith, written in holy Scripture, for our instruction and doctrin, how farre so euer they seeme discrepant from reason, we must represse our imaginations, and consider Gods pleasure and will, and yeald therto, beleeuing him to be omnipotent: And that by his omnipotent power, such thinges are verelye so as holy scripture teacheth. Like as we beleeue that Christ was borne of ye blessed virgin Mary, without company of man: that our Sauyour Christ the third day rose agayn from death: that he in his humanity ascended into heauen: that our bodyes at the day of iudgement shall rise agayne, and many other such like thinges, which we all that be true christē men, do beleeue firmely, because we finde these thinges written iu Scripture. And therfore we (knowing Gods omnipotency) doe beleue that he hath brought some of ye said things to passe already, and those things that are yet to come, he will by the same omnipotency without doubt likewise bring to passe.
Now if you can prove that your transubstantiation, your fleshly presence of Christs body and blood, your carnal eating and drinking of the same, your propitiatory sacrifice of the mass, are taught us as plainly in the scripture, as the said articles of our faith be, then I will believe that it is so in deed. Otherwise, neither I nor any man that is in his right wits, will believe your said articles, because God is omnipotent, and can make it so. ⟨p. 31⟩For you might so under pretence of Gods omnipotency, make as many articles of our faith as you list if such arguments might take place, that God by his omnipotent power, can convert the substance of bread and wine, in to the substance of his flesh and blood: ergo he doth so in deed.
Now if you can proue that your transubstantiatiō, your fleshly presence of Christes body and bloud, your carnall eating and drinking of the same, your propitiatory sacrifice of the masse, are taught vs as plainly in ye scripture, as the sayd articles of our faith be, then I will beleeue that it is so in deede. Otherwise, neither I nor any man that is in his right wittes, will beleeue your said articles, because God is omnipotent, and can make it so. ⟨p. 31⟩For you might so vnder pretence of Gods omnipotency, make as many articles of our faith as you list if such arguments might take place, that God by his omnipotent power, can conuert the substance of bread and wine, in to the substance of his flesh and bloud: ergo he doth so in deede.
And although Christ be not corporally in the bread and wine, yet Christ used not so many words in the mystery of his holy supper, without effectual signification. For he is effectually present, and effectually worketh not in the bread and wine, but in the godly receivers of them, to whom he giveth his own flesh spiritually to feed upon, and his own blood to quench their great inward thirst.
And although Christ be not corporally in the bread and wine, yet Christ vsed not so many wordes in the mistery of his holy supper, without effectual signification. For he is effectually present, and effectually worketh not in the bread and wine, but in the godly receauers of them, to whom he geeueth his own flesh spiritually to feede vpon, and his own bloud to quench their great inward thirst.
And here I would wish you to mark very well one true sentence which you have uttered by the way, which is: That Christ declared, that eating of him signifieth believing,1 and start not from it an other time. And mark the same I pray thee (gentle Reader.) For this one sentence assoyleth almost all the arguments that be brought by this Lawyer in his whole book against the truth.
And here I would wishe you to marke very wel one true sentence which you haue vttered by the way, which is: That Christ declared, that eating of him signifieth beleeuing,1 and start not from it an other time. And marke the same I pray thee (gentle Reader.) For this one sentence assoyleth almost all the argumentes that be brought by this Lawyer in his wholl booke against the truth.
And yet to the said true saying, you have joined an other untruth, & have yoked them both together in one sentence.3 For when Christ had taught of the eating of him, being the bread descended from heaven there was no murmuring thereat, (say you.) Which your saying I can not but wonder at, to see you so far deceived in a matter so plain and manifest.2 And if I had spoken such an evident and manifest untruth, I doubt not but it should have been spoken of to Rome gates. For the text saith there plainly, Murmur abant Judaei de illo, qoud dixisset: Ego sum panis vinus, qui de coelo descendi: 3The Jews murmured at him because he said, I am the bread of life that came from heaven. But when you wrote this, it seemeth you looked a little to low and should have looked higher.
And yet to the sayd true saying, you haue ioyned an other vntruth, & haue yoaked them both together in one sentence.3 For when Christ had taught of the eating of him, being the bread descended frō heauen there was no murmuring thereat, (say you.) Which your saying I can not but wonder at, to see you so farre deceaued in a matter so plaine and manifest.2 And if I had spoaken such an euident and manifeste vntruth, I doubt not but it should haue beene spoaken of to Rome gates. For the text sayth there plainly, Murmur abant Iudaei de illo, qoud dixisset: Ego sum panis vinus, qui de coelo descendi: 3The Iewes murmured at him because he sayd, I am the bread of life that came from heauen. But when you wrote this, it seemeth you looked a litle to low and should haue looked higher.
And here by this one place the Reader may gather of your own words, your intent and meaning in this your book, if that be true which you said before, that ever where contention is, on what part the Reader seeth in any one point an open manifest lye, there he may consider (whatsoever excuse be made of truth) yet the victory of truth not to be there intended.
And here by this one place the Reader may gather of your own wordes, your intent and meaning in this your booke, if that be true which you sayd before, that euer where contention is, on what parte the Reader seeth in any one point an open manifest lye, there he may consider (whatsoeuer excuse be made of truth) yet the victory of truth not to be there intended.
An other untruth also followeth incontinently, that when Christ said: The bread which I will give you,1 is my flesh, which I will give for the life of the world.2 In these words (say you) Christ maketh mention of two gifts But what be those two gifts I pray you? And by what words is the diversity of those two gifts expressed? If the giving (as Smith saith) be giving to death, then those two gifts declare that Christ dyed for us twice. And if one of Christs gifts have livery and seisin, why hath not the other likewise? And when was then that livery and seisin given? And if eating of Christ be believing (as you said even now) then livery and seisin is given when we first believe, whether it be in baptism, or at any other time.
An other vntruth also followeth incontinently, that when Christ sayd: The bread which I will geue you,1 is my flesh, which I will geue for the life of the world.2 In these wordes (say you) Christ maketh mention of two gifts But what be those two giftes I pray you? And by what wordes is the diuersitie of those two giftes expressed? If the geuing (as Smith sayth) be geuing to death, then those two giftes declare that Christ dyed for vs twise. And if one of Christes giftes haue liuery and seisyn, why hath not the other likewise? And when was then that liuery and seisyn geuen? And if eating of Christ be beleeuing (as you sayd euen now) then liuerey and seisyn is geuen when we first beleeue, whether it be in baptisme, or at any other time.
But what you mean by these words, that Christ gave in his supper, his body as really to be eaten of us, as he did to be crucified for us, I understand not, except you would have Christ so really eaten of his Apostles at his supper with their teeth, as he was after crucified, whipped, and thrust to the §8hart with a spear. But was he not then so really and corporally crucified, that his body was rent and torn in pieces? And was not he so crucified then, that he never was crucified after? Was he not so slain then, that he never ⟨p. 32⟩dyed any more? And if he were so eaten at his supper, then did his Apostles tear his flesh at the supper, as the Jews did the day following. And then how could he now be eaten again? Or how could he be crucified the day following, if the night before he were after that sort eaten all up? But aptly (say you) and conveniently: Mary Sir, I thank you: but what is the aptly and conveniently, but spiritually, and by faith (as you said before) not grossly with the teeth as he was crucified. And so the manner was divers (I grant) and the substance all one.
But what you mean by these wordes, that Christ gaue in his supper, his body as really to be eatē of vs, as he did to be crucified for vs, I vnderstand not, except you would haue Christ so really eaten of his Apostles at his supper with their teeth, as he was after crucified, whipped, and thrust to the §8hart with a speare. But was he not then so really and corporally crucified, that his body was rent and torne in peeces? And was not he so crucified then, that he neuer was crucified after? Was he not so slayn then, that he neuer ⟨p. 32⟩dyed any more? And if he were so eaten at his supper, then did his Apostles teare his flesh at the supper, as the Iewes did the day following. And then how could he now be eaten agayn? Or how could he be crucified the day following, if the night before he were after that sort eaten all vp? But aptly (say you) and conueniently: Mary Sir, I thanke you: but what is ye aptly and conueniently, but spiritually, and by faith (as you said before) not grosly with the teeth as he was crucified. And so the manner was diuers (I graunt) and the substance all one.
1But when Christ said, the bread which I will give is my flesh, which I will give for the life of the world,2 if he had fulfilled this promise at his supper (as you say he did) then what needed he after to dye that we might live, if he fulfilled his promise of life at his supper? Why said the Prophets, that he should be wounded for our iniquities, and that by his wounds we should be healed if we had life, and were healed before he was wounded?3 Why doth the catholic faith teach us to believe that we be redeemed by his blood shedding, if he gave us life (which is our redemption) the night before he shed his blood? And why saith S. Paul that there is no remission without blood shedding? Yea why did he say: Absit mihi gloriari, nisi in cruce, God forbid that I should rejoice, but in the cross only. Why did he not rather say? Absit mihi gloriari, nisi in caena Domini. God forbid that I should rejoice, but in the Lords supper: whereat as you say, the promise of life was fulfilled. This is godly doctrine for such men to make, as being ignorant in Gods word, wander in fantasies of their own devises,4 and putantes se esse sapientes, stulti facti sunt. But the true faithful believing man professeth, that Christ by his death, overcame him that was the Author of death, and hath reconciled us to his Father,5 making us his children, and heirs of his kingdom: that as many as believe in him, should not perish, but have life everlasting. Thus saith the true christian man, putting his hope of life and eternal salvation, neither in Christs supper, (although the same be to him a great confirmation of his faith) nor in any thing else, but with S. Paul faith: Mihi absit gloriari, nisi in cruce Domini nostri Jesus Christi: 6God save me that I rejoice in nothing, but in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ.
1But when Christ sayd, the bread which I will geue is my flesh, which I will geue for the life of the worlde,
And when this true believing man cometh to the Lords Supper, & (according to Christs commandment) receiveth the bread broken, in remembrance that Christs body was broken for him upon the cross, and drinketh the wine in remembrance of the effusion of Christs blood for his sins, and unfeignedly believeth the same, to him the words of our Saviour Christ be effectuous and operatory.1 Take, eat, this is my body, which is given for thee: And drink of this, for this is my blood which is shed for thee, to the remission of thy sins. And as S. Paul saith, the bread unto him is the communion of Christs body,2 and the wine the communion of his blood. For the effect of his godly eating (as you truly herein gather of S. Pauls words) is the communication of Christs body and blood, but to the faithful receiver, and not to the dumb creatures of bread and wine, under whose forms the catholic faith teacheth not the body and blood of Christ invisibly to be hidden. And as to the godly eater, (who duly esteemeth Christs body, and hath it in such price and estimation as he ought to have) the effect is the communication of Christs body: so to the wicked eater, the effect is damnation, and everlasting woe.
And when this true beleeuing man commeth to the Lordes Supper, & (according to Christes commaundement) receaueth the bread broaken, in remembrance that Christes body was broaken for him vpon the crosse, and drinketh the wine in remembrance of the effusion of Christes bloud for his sinnes, and vnfaynedly beleeueth the same, to him the words of our Sauyour Christ be effectuous and operatory.1 Take, eate, this is my body, which is geuen for thee: And drinke of this, for this is my bloud which is shed for thee, to the remission of thy sinnes. And as S. Paul saith, the bread vnto him is the communion of Christes body,2 and the wine the communiō of his bloud. For the effect of his godly eating (as you truely herein gather of S. Paules wordes) is the communication of Christes body and bloud, but to the faithfull receauer, and not to the dumme creatures of bread and wine, vnder whose formes the catholick faith teacheth not the body and bloud of Christ inuisibly to be hidden. And as to the godly eater, (who duely esteemeth Christes body, and hath it in such price and estimation as he ought to haue) the effect is the communication of Christes body: so to the wicked eater, the effect is damnation, and euerlasting woe.
And now I am glad that here your self have found out a warrant for the apparel of bread and wine,1 that they shall not go altogether naked, & be nude and bare tokens, but have promises of effectual signification, which now you have spied out both in the words of Christ, and S. Paul.
And now I am glad that here your selfe haue found out a warrante for the apparrell of bread and wine,1 that they shall not goe altogether naked, & be nude and bare tokens, but haue promyses of effectuall significatiō, which now you haue spyed out both in the wordes of Christ, and S. Paule.
Now for the ambiguity of Christs speeches, it is not always true,1 that such speeches of Christ as might have ambiguity, the Evangelists either plainly or by circumstances open them. For Christ speaking so many things in parables, similes, allegories, metaphors, and other tropes and figures, although sometime Christ himself, and sometime the Evangelists open the meaning, yet for the most part the meaning is left to the judgement of the hearers, without any declaration. As when Christ said:2 gird your loins, and take light candles in your hands. And when he said: No man that setteth his hand to the plough,3 and looketh behind him, is meet for the kingdom of God. And when he said: Except the grain of wheat falling upon the ground, dye, it remaineth sole. And as S. Matthew sayeth:4 Christ spake not to the people without parables, that the Scriptures might be fulfilled, which prophesied of Christ,5 that he should open his mouth in parables.
Now for the ambiguity of Christes speeches, it is not alwayes true,1 that such speaches of Christ as might haue ambiguity, the Euangelistes either plainly or by circumstāces open them. For Christ speaking so many things in parables, similies, allegories, metaphores, and other tropes and figures, although sometime Christ himselfe, and sometime the Euangelistes open ye meaning, yet for the most parte the meaning is left to the iudgement of the hearers, without any declaration. As when Christ sayd:2 gird your loines, and take light candles in your handes. And when he sayde: No man that setteth his hand to the plough,3 and looketh behind him, is meet for the kingdome of God. And when he sayd: Except the grayne of wheate falling vpon the ground, dye, it remayneth sole. And as S. Mathew sayeth:
And although some of his parables,1 Christ opened to the people, some to his Apostles only, yet some he opened to neither of both, as can appear, but left them to be considered by the discretion of the hearers. And when Christ called Herod a Fox, Judas a Devil, himself a Door, a way, a Vine, a well: Neither he nor the Evangelists expounded these words, nor gave warning to the hearers that he spake in figures: For every man that had any manner of sense or reason, might well perceive, that these sentences could not be true in plain form of words as they were spoken. For who is so ignorant, but he knoweth that a man is not a Fox a Devil, A Door, a Way, a Vine, a Well.
And although some of his parables,1 Christ opened to the people, some to his Apostles onely, yet some he opened to neither of both, as can appeare, but lefte them to be considered by the discretion of the hearers. And when Christ called Herod a Foxe, Iudas a Deuill, himself a Dore, a way, a Uine, a well: Neither he nor the Euangelistes expounded these wordes, nor gaue warning to the hearers that he spake in figures: For euery man that had any manner of sence or reason, might wel perceaue, that these sentences could not be true in playn forme of wordes as they were spoaken. For who is so ignorant, but he knoweth that a mā is not a Foxe a Deuil, A Dore, a Way, a Uine, a Well.
And so likewise when Christ brake the bread, and commanded his disciples to eat it, and said: This is my body: and of the wine he said: Divide it among you, drink it, this is my blood. No man that was there present was so fond, but he knew well that the bread was not Christs body, nor the wine his blood. And therefore they might well know that Christ called the bread his body, and the wine his blood for some figure, similitude, and property of the bread and wine unto his flesh and blood: For as bread and wine be foods to nourish our bodies, so is the flesh and blood of our Saviour Christ, (being annexed unto his Deity,) the everlasting food of our souls.
And so likewise when Christ brake the bread, and commaunded his disciples to eate it, and sayd: This is my body: and of the wine he said: Deuide it among you, drinke it, this is my bloud. No man that was there present was so fond, but he knew well that the bread was not Christes body, nor the wine his bloud. And therfore they might well know that Christ called the bread his body, and the wine his bloud for some figure, similitude, and property of the bread and wine vnto his flesh and bloud: For as bread and wine be foodes to nourish our bodies, so is the flesh and bloud of our Sauyour Christ, (being annexed vnto his Deity,) the euerlasting food of our soules.
And although the Evangelists in that place do not fully express the words in this sense, yet adjoining the sixth chapter of John (speaking of the spiritual manducation of Christ) to the circumstances of the text in the three Evangelists, (reciting Christs last Supper) the whole matter is fully gathered as old authors of the Church have declared. For do not the circū stances of the text, both before and after the eating and drinking, declare that there is very bread and wine? Is not that which is broken and eaten, bread? And that which is divided, drunken? And the fruit of the vine, is it not very wine? And doth not the nature of Sacraments require that the sensible elements should remain in their proper nature, to signify an higher mystery, and secret working of God inwardly, as the sensible elements ⟨p. 34⟩be ministered outwardly? And is not the visible and corporal feeding upon bread and wine, a convenient and apt figure and similitude to put us in remembrance, and to admonish us how we be fed invisibly and spiritually, by the flesh and blood of Christ, God, and man? And is not the Sacrament taken away, when the element is taken away? Or can the accidents of the element be the Sacrament of substantial feeding? Or did ever any old author say, that the accidents were the Sacramental signs without the substances?
And although the Euangelistes in that place doe not fully expresse the words in this sence, yet adioyning the sixt chapter of Iohn (speaking of the spirituall manduratiō of Christ) to the circumstances of the text in the three Euangelistes, (reciting Christs last Supper) the wholl matter is fully gathered as olde authors of the Church haue declared. For doe not the circū stances of the texte, both before and after the eating and drinking, declare that there is very bread and wine? Is not that which is broken and eaten, bread? And that which is deuided, dronken? And the fruit of the vine, is it not very wine? And doth not the nature of Sacramentes require that the sensible elements should remain in their proper nature, to signifie an higher mistery, and secret working of God inwardly, as the sensible elementes ⟨p. 34⟩be ministred outwardly? And is not the visible and corporall feeding vpō bread and wine, a conuenient and apte figure and similitude to put vs in remembraunce, and to admonish vs how we be fedde inuisibly and spiritually, by the flesh and bloud of Christ, God, and man? And is not the Sacrament taken away, when the element is taken away? Or can the accidents of the element be the Sacrament of substanciall feeding? Or did euer any olde author say, that the accidentes were the Sacramentall signes without the substances?
But for the conclusion of your matter, here I would wish that you would once truly understand me. For I do not say that Christs body & blood be given to us in signification, and not in deed. But I do as plainly speak as I can, that Christs body and blood, be given to us in deed, yet not corporally, and carnally, but spiritually, and effectually, as you confess your self within twelve lines after.
But for the conclusion of your matter, here I would wish that you would once truely vnderstand me. For I doe not say that Christes body & bloud be geuen to vs in signification, and not in deed. But I doe as plainly speake as I can, that Christes body and bloud, be geuen to vs in deede, yet not corporally, and carnally, but spiritually, and effectually, as you confesse your selfe within twelue lines after.
The Author uttereth a great many words, from the eight to the seventeenth chapter of the first book, declaring spiritual hunger and thirst, and the relieving of the same by spiritual feeding in Christ, and of Christ, as we constantly believe in him, to the confirmation of which belief, the author would have the Sacraments of Baptism, and of the body and blood of Christ, to be adminicles as it were, & that we by them be preached unto, as in water, bread and wine, and by them all our sins (as it were) spoken unto, or properly touched, which matter in the gross, although there be some words by the way not tolerable, yet if those words set apart, the same were in the sum granted, to be good teaching and wholesome exhortation, it containeth so no more but good matter, not well applied. For the Catholic church that professeth the truth of the presence of Christs body in the Sacrament, would therewith use that declaration of hunger of Christ, and that spiritual refreshing in Christ, with the effect of Christs passion and death, and the same to be the only mean of mans regeneratio, and feeding also, with the differences of that feeding, from bodily feeding, for continuing this earthly life. But this toucheth not the principal point that should be entreated. Whether Christ so ordered to feed such as be regenerate in him, to give to them in the Sacrament the same his body, that he gave to be crucified for us. The good man is fed by faith, and by merits of Christs passion, being the mean of the gift of that faith, and other gifts also, and by the suffering of the body of Christ, and shedding of his most precious blood on the altar of the Cross: which work and passion of Christ is preached unto us, by words and Sacraments, and the same doctrine received of us by faith, and the effect of it also. And thus far goeth the doctrine of this author.
The Author vttereth a great many wordes, from the eyght to the seuententh chapiter of the fyrst booke, declaryng spirituall hunger and thirst, and the releuing of the same by spyrituall feeding in Christe, and of Christe, as we constantly beleue in him, to the confirmation of whiche beliefe, the author would haue the Sacramentes of Baptisme, and of the body and bloud of Christ, to be adminicles as it were, & that we by them be preached vnto, as in water, breade and wyne, and by them all our sinnes (as it were) spoken vnto, or properly touched, which matter in the grosse, although there be some wordes by the way not tollerable, yet if those wordes set apart, the same were in the summe graunted, to be good teachyng and holsome exhortation, it contayneth so no more but good matter, not well applyed. For the Catholicke churche that professeth the truth of the presence of Christes body in the Sacramēt, would therewith vse that declaratiō of hunger of Christ, and that spirituall refreshing in Christ, with theffect of Christes passion and death, and the same to be the onely meane of mans regeneratio, and feeding also, with the differēces of that feeding, from bodilye feeding, for continuing thys earthly lyfe. But thys toucheth not the principal poynt that should be intreated. Whether Christ so ordered to feede such as be regenerate in him, to geue to them in the Sacramēt the same his body, that he gaue to be crucified for vs. The good man is fed by fayth, and by merites of Christes passion, being the mean of the gift of that fayth, and other giftes also, and by the suffering of the body of Christ, and shedding of his most precious bloud on the altar of the Crosse: which worke and passion of Christ is preached vnto vs, by wordes aud Sacramentes, and the same doctrine receaued of vs by fayth, and theffect of it also. And thus farre goeth the doctrine of this author.
But the Catholic teaching, by the scriptures, goeth further, confessing Christ to feed such as be regenerate in him, not only by his body and blood, but also with his body and blood, delivered in this Sacrament, by him in deed to us which the faithful, by his institution and commandment, receive with their faith and with their mouth also, and with those special dainties, be fed specially at Christs table: And so God doth not only preach in his Sacraments, but also worketh in them, and with them, and in sensible things giveth celestial gifts, after the doctrine of each Sacrament, as in baptism the spirit of Christ, and in the Sacrament of the altar, the very body and blood of Christ, according to the plain sense of his words which he spake: This is my body. &c. And this is the Catholic faith, against which, how the Author will fortify, that he would have called Catholic, and confute that he improveth, I intend hereafter more particularly to touch in discussion of that is said.
But the Catholicke teaching, by the scriptures, goeth further, cōfessing Christ to feed such as be regenerate in him, not onely by his body and bloud, but also with his body and bloud, deliuered in this Sacrament, by hym in deede to vs which the faythfull, by his institution and commaūdement, receaue with their faith and with their mouth also, and wt those special deinties, be fed specially at Christs table: And so God doth not onely preach in his Sacraments, but also worketh in them, and wt them, and in sensible thinges geueth celestiall giftes, after the doctrine of eche Sacramēt, as in baptisme the spirite of Christ, and in the Sacrament of the altar, the very body and bloud of Christ, accordinge to the playne sence of his wordes whiche he spake: This is my body. &c. And this is the Catholicke fayth, agaynst which, how the Author will fortifye, that he woulde haue called Catholick, and confute that he improueth, I intend hereafter more particularly to touche in discussion of that is sayd.
I Mistrust not the indifferency of the reader so much, but he can well perceive how simple & slender a rehearsal you have made here of my eight ⟨p. 35⟩annotations, and how little matter you have here to say against them, and how little your sayings require any answer.
I Mystrust not the indifferency of the reader so much, but he can well perceiue how simple & slender a rehearsall you haue made here of my eight ⟨p. 35⟩annotations, and how little matter you haue here to say agaynst them, and how little your sayinges require any aunswere.
And because this may the more evidently appear to the reader, I shall rehearse my words hear again.
And because this may the more euidently appeare to the reader, I shall rehearse my wordes heare agayne.
Although in this treaty of the Sacrament of the body & blood of our saviour Christ,1 I have already sufficiently declared the institution & meaning of the same, according to the very words of the Gospel and of saint Paul, yet it shall not be in vain somewhat more at large to declare the same, according to the mind, as well of holy scripture, as of old ancient authors, and that so sincerely & plainly, without doubts, ambiguities, or vain questions, that the very simple and unlearned people, may easily understand the same, and be edified thereby.
Although in this treatie of the Sacrament of the body & bloud of our sauiour Christ,1 I haue already sufficiētly declared the institution & meaning of the same, according to the very wordes of the Gospell and of saint Paule, yet it shall not be in vayne somwhat more at large to declare the same, according to the minde, as well of holy scripture, as of olde auncient authours, and that so sincerely & plainly, without doubts, ambiguities, or vain questions, that the very simple and vnlearned people, may easily vnderstand the same, and be edified thereby.
And this by Gods grace is mine only intent and desire, that the flock of Christ dispersed in this Realm (among whom I am appointed a special pastor) may no longer lack the commodity and fruit, which springeth of this heavenly knowledge. For the more clearly it is understood the more sweetness, fruit, comfort, and edification it bringeth to the godly receivers thereof. And to the clear understanding of this Sacrament, divers things must be considered.
And this by Gods grace is myne only intent and desire, that the flocke of Christ dispersed in this Realme (among whome I am appointed a speciall pastour) may no longer lacke the commodite and fruite, whiche springeth of this heauenly knowledge. For the more clerely it is vnderstood the more swetnes, fruite, comfort, and edification it bringeth to the godly receauers therof. And to the clere vnderstandyng of this Sacrament, diuers thinges must be cō sidered.
First I alleadge against Smithes negation, your affirmation, which, as it is more true in this point then his negation, so for your estimation it is able to counteruail his saying, if there were nothing els: & yet if Smith had well pondered what I haue written in the second chap. of my second booke, and in the 7. and 8. chapters of my third book, he should haue foūd this matter so fully prooued, that he neither is, nor neuer shalbe able to answere thereto. For I haue alleadged the scripture, I haue alleadged the consent of the old writers, holy fathers, and martirs, to prooue that Christ called bread his body, and wine his bloud. For the Euangelistes speaking of the Lords supper,1 say, yt he took bread, blessed it, brake it, & gaue it to his disciples, saying: This is my body: and of the wine he sayd: Take this, deuide it among you, & drinke it: this is my bloud. I haue alleadged Irene,2 saying that Christ confessed bread to be his body, and the cup to be his bloud I haue cyted Tertulliā who sayth in many places,3 that Christ called bread his body. I haue brought in for the same purpose Cyprian,4 who sayth that Christ called such bread as is made of many cornes ioyned together, his body: and such wine he named his bloud, as is pressed out of many grapes. I haue written the wordes of Epiphanius,5 which be these, that Christ speakinge of a loafe which is round in fashion, and can neither see, heare, nor feele, said of it: This is my body. And S. Hierom writing ad Hedibiam, 6sayth that Christ called the bread which he brake, his body. And S. Augustine sayth,7 that Iesus called meate, his body, and drinke his bloud. And Cyrill sayth more plainly,8 that Christ called the peeces of bread his body. And last of all I brought forth Theodorete,9 whose saying is this, that when Christe gaue the holy mysteries, he called bread his body, and the cuppe mixt with wine and water, ⟨p. 29⟩he called his bloud. All these Authors I alleadged, to prooue that Christ called bread his body, and wine his bloud.