First, partial, in declaring the state of the question, which was not as he intimateth, but thus. After an historical narration made by him of a difference between the Classis and Mr. Hook; about a custom, which the Ministers of the Dutch Church in Amsterdam have, of baptizing all that are brought by whomsoever, he asked me what I thought of it. I desired (for my satisfaction) to know wh•t their custom was, being then, in part, ignorant thereof. He told me, that they baptized all, refusing none. I replied, that I would baptize all their infants, who were members of his Church, refusing none. He said, that is not sufficient. I, desiring to carry matters with all possible peaceableness, told him that I would not refuse to baptize others also, which were no members of his Church, if I were satisfied concerning the Parents, and instanced in such as might occasionally be there from England, & were sufficiently known to me. But yet the case might be such, in some others, as I should not adventure to do it. He answered. But here they except none, but baptize all that are brought, though the parents be not known, or the infant be presented, in the f•thers absence, by persons unknown. I told him, that, I hoped, such cases were seldom, especially in the English Church. He said, it must be expected to fall out often. I told him, I should desire to be satisfied concerning the parents, before the child were presented. He said. They would often bring them, in sermon time, without giving any notice before, and, in such a case, to refuse any, would give offence, if the child should be unbaptized. I replied, that offence may be prevented, seeing those, whom I dare not admit, may repair to the Dutch Church, where none are refused. He added, that it would give offence to the Classis, if our Church •hould not do as they did, in this. I answered, the difference between the small English Church, & the vast Dutch Church in the same town being considered, that might easily be answered.
First, partiall, in declaring the state of the question, which was not as he intimateth, but thus. After an hystoricall narration made by him of a difference betweene the Classis and Mr. Hook; about a custom, which the Ministers of the Dutch Church in Amsterdam have, of baptizing all that are brought by whomsoever, he asked me what I thought of it. I desired (for my satisfaction) to know wh•t their custom was, being then, in part, ignorant thereof. He told me, that they baptized all, refusing none. I replyed, that I would baptize all their infants, who were members of his Church, refusing none. He sayd, that is not sufficient. I, desiring to carry matters with all possible peaceablenes, told him that I would not refuse to baptize others also, which were no members of his Church, if I were satisfyed cōcerning the Parents, and instanced in such as might occasionally be there from England, & were sufficiently knowne to me. But yet the case might be such, in some others, as I should not adventure to doe it. He answered. But here they except none, but baptize all that are brought, though the parents be not knowne, or the infant be presented, in the f•thers absence, by persons unknowne. I told him, that, I hoped, such cases were seldom, especially in the English Church. He said, it must be expected to fall out often. I told him, I should desire to be satisfyed concerning the parents, before the child were presented. He sayd. They would often bring them, in sermon time, without giving any notice before, and, in such a case, to refuse any, would give offence, if the child should be unbaptized. I replyed, that offence may be prevented, seing those, whom I dare not admit, may repayre to the Dutch Church, where none are refused. He added, that it would give offence to the Classis, if our Church •hould not doe as they did, in this. I answered, the difference betweene the small English Church, & the vast Dutch Church in the same towne being considered, that might easily be answered.