Now hearken our sad and discrete judges, how shameful a sentence they have put in the ⟨image 203⟩confutation:1 Thus they say, It is expressed in the holy scriptures, that the religious life duly observed & kept, which through God's grace all religious persons may observe and keep, doth merit eternal life / and that Christ hath promised it more largely to them, which shall forsake house or brethren. &c. These be the words of our adversaries, in which this is first a very shameless lye, to say that it is expressed in holy scripture, that Monastical life doth merit eternal life. For where do the holy scriptures in any place speak of Monastical life? Thus our adversaries defend their cause / thus the wretched men allege the scriptures, when every man knoweth, that Monastical life is a thing newly devised: and yet they allege y• authority of scripture, and say, that this their decree is expressed in the scriptures. Besides this, they do injury and dishonour to Christ, in saying, that men by Monastical life do merit eternal life. God doth not give this honour no not to his own law, that it should merit eternal life, as he him self saith plainly in the .xx. chapter of Ezekiel,2 I gave unto them precepts, that were not good, and judgements, in which they shall not live. First this is undoubted, that monkish life doth not merit remission of since, but that we freely receive it by faith, as it hath ben said before. Secondly this also is written, that for Christs sake, through mercy is given eternal life to them, which by faith receive remission, and plead not their own merits against the judgement of god, as Bernard most gravely and wisely doth say,3 It is necessary saith ⟨image 203⟩he, first of all to believe, that remission of since can not be obtained nor had, but by God's indulgence and pardon. Secondarily, that thou cannest have no good work, onles he giveth it unto thee. Finally, that thou can nest not by no manner works merit eternal life, oneles it also be freely given. Other things that follow, concerning the same sentence, we have heretofore recited. And Bernard addeth in the end these words, Let no man deceive him self. For if he consider well, he shall find without any doubt, that he is not able, no not with ten thousands to mete him, which cometh against him with twenty thousands.
Nowe herken oure sadde and discrete iudges, howe shameful a sentēce they haue put in the ⟨image 203⟩confutation:1 Thus they say, It is expressed in the holy scriptures, that the religious lyfe duely obserued & kepte, which through goddꝭ grace all religious persones may obserue and kepe, dothe merite eternall lyfe / and yt Christe hath promysed it more largely to them, which shal forsake house or bretherne. &c. These be the wordes of our aduersaries, in whiche this is fyrste a very shameles lye, to saye that it is expressed in holy scripture, that Monasticall lyfe dothe merite eternall lyfe. For where do the holy scripturꝭ in any place speake of Monasticall lyfe? Thus our aduersaries defende theyr cause / thus the wretched men alledge the scriptures, whan euery man knoweth, that Monasticall lyfe is a thynge newly deuised: and yet they alledge y• auctoritie of scripture, and say, that this theyr decree is expressed in the scriptures. Besydes this, they do iniurie and dishonour to Christe, in sayenge, that mē by Monastical lyfe do merite eternal lyfe. God dothe not gyue this honoure no not to his owne lawe, that it shulde merite eternall lyfe, as he hym selfe sayth playnly in the .xx. chapitre of Ezechiel,2 I gaue vnto them preceptes, that were not good, and iudgementes, in whiche they shall not lyue. Fyrste this is vndoubted, that monkyshe lyfe dothe not merite remission of synnes, but that we freely rece•ue it by fayth, as it hath ben said before. Secōdly this also is wryten, that for Christꝭ sake, thrughe mercye is gyuen eternall lyfe to them, whiche by fayth receyue remission, and pleade not theyr owne merites agaynste the iudgement of god, as Barnarde most grauely and wysely dothe say,3 It is necessarye saythe ⟨image 203⟩he, fyrst of all to beleue, that remission of synnes can not be obteyned nor had, but by goddes indulgence and pardone. Secundarilye, that thou cannest haue no good worke, onles he gyueth it vnto the. Finally, that thou can nest not by no maner workes merite eternall lyfe, oneles it also be freelye gyuen. Other thynges that folowe, concernynge the same sentēce, we haue heretofore recited. And Barnarde addeth in the ende these wordꝭ, Let no man deceyue hym selfe. For if he cōsidre wel, he shall fynde without any doubte, that he is not able, no not with tenne thousandꝭ to mete hym, which cometh agaynst hym with twenty thousandes.
- 1The shem tense of thaduersaries.The sē tence of thaduersaries.
- 2Eze. 20
- 3Barn.