The Jesuits maintain, that if a man do but believe in their Pope and Church as infallible, he may (not only as some say, be ignorant of some Article of the Creed it self, and yet be a true Catholic, yea and be saved, but also) believe a false Article as from God and the Church: The former is commonly taught not only by such as Suarez, that say the Article of Christs Descent into Hell is not to all of Necessity to Salvation, but by many others in the Doctrine of Implicit faith. The later clause you may see among others in Franc. Albertinus the Jesuit, Corollar. pag. 250. where his objectors put this case [Suppose twenty Bishops preach to a country man a false Article, as if it were spoken by God and the Church: that proposal of the twenty Bishops is so sufficient, that the Country man prudently formeth an evident practical judgement, and morally certain, ⟨p. 156⟩to believe with a speculative assent the Article proposed by the twenty Bishops, for the Authority of God as the formal reason. Three absurdities seem hence to follow. 1. That the Country man should be obliged under mortal sin, to believe the twenty Bishops, and so the precept of faith should bind to believe a falsehood. 2. The Country man should be in Gods Grace without faith. In Grace, because he commits no mortal sin, yea he obeys the command of believing: Yet without faith, because he believes a falsehood opposite to faith, and so loseth faith. 3. God should concur to deceive—To the first Albertinus answereth that its no Absurdity that the command of faith do oblige to believe a falsehood, it being not per se, but per accidens. To the second he saith, that the Country man doth not lose his grace or faith, because the falsehood believed is not formally opposite to the true faith (but materially)—Here you see that a man may hold an Article opposite to the faith materially, and yet not only be a true Christian in grace and faith, but also in so doing obey by accident the command of believing, so be it he believe in their Church. And if that be so, with what face can these men say, that our Church or Religion is new, or not the same with the Greeks, &c. when we have the same formal Object of faith, and differ in no Essential Material point? See here their lubricity and partiality.
The Jesuits maintain, that if a man do but believe in their Pope and Church as infallible, he may (not only as some say, be ignorant of some Article of the Creed it self, and yet be a true Catholick, yea and be saved, but also) believe a false Article as from God and the Church: The former is commonly taught not only by such as Suarez, that say the Article of Christs Descent into Hell is not to all of Necessity to Salvation, but by many others in the Doctrine of Implicite faith. The later clause you may see among others in Franc. Albertinus the Jesuite, Corollar. pag. 250. where his objectors put this case [Suppose twenty Bishops preach to a countrey man a false Article, as if it were spoken by God and the Church: that proposal of the twenty Bishops is so sufficient, that the Countrey man prudently formeth an evident practical judgement, and morally certain, ⟨p. 156⟩to believe with a speculative assent the Article proposed by the twenty Bishops, for the Authority of God as the formal reason. Three absurdities seem hence to follow. 1. That the Countrey man should be obliged under mortall sin, to believe the twenty Bishops, and so the precept of faith should bind to believe a falshood. 2. The Countrey man should be in Gods Grace without faith. In Grace, because he commits no mortal sin, yea he obeys the command of believing: Yet without faith, because he believes a falshood opposite to faith, and so loseth faith. 3. God should concur to deceive—To the first Albertinus answereth that its no Absurdity that the command of faith do oblige to believe a falshood, it being not per se, but per accidens. To the second he saith, that the Countrey man doth not lose his grace or faith, because the falshood believed is not formally opposite to the true faith (but materially)—Here you see that a man may hold an Article opposite to the faith materially, and yet not only be a true Christian in grace and faith, but also in so doing obey by accident the command of believing, so be it he believe in their Church. And if that be so, with what face can these men say, that our Church or Religion is new, or not the same with the Greeks, &c. when we have the same formal Object of faith, and differ in no Essential Material point? See here their lubricity and partiality.